Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Sears Craftsman

Sears Craftsman: what farmers say

142 reports in FARM SHOW · 96 Best Buys46 Worst Buys

Sears Craftsman chainsaw equipped

11 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Steve Landgrebe, Albia, Iowa · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 14

Steve’s 1991 Dodge pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine has more than 300,000 miles on it but is still going strong. “I replaced the transmission at about 200,000 miles. Otherwise this pickup has required only routine maintenance.

“My 2017 AGCO LT90 tractor equipped with a Cummins diesel engine just turned over 10,000 hrs. I’ve spent little money on this tractor, mainly for oil and tires.”

He’s had problems with his 2017 Sears Craftsman chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar. “The engine won’t idle whenever I set it down. The store where I bought the saw finally gave me a voucher card, but I used it to buy tools instead of another saw.”

Best Buy
Duane Spencer, DeFuniak Springs, Fla. · Vol. 39, No. 3 (2015), p. 14

Duane’s satisfied with his 2006 Ford F-350 4-WD crew cab pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine and an 8-ft. bed, which he bought used with about 99,500 miles.

“I had to replace the oil cooler and the turbocharger needed work, but overall I love this pickup’s power and ride. It’s fun to drive as long as I don’t have to park in tight spaces. The crew cab is wonderful and has plenty of room for my hand tools and parts. And as a contractor, I have a lot of tools and parts to carry.

“My wife and I bought a Sears Craftsman 42-in. riding mower equipped with a 19 1/2 hp engine and hydrostatic transmission. I like not having to stand on a foot pedal to keep moving. Instead, I just put my feet on the floorboard and use the clutch only as a panic button.

“All I’ve done is change the oil, blades, drive belt, battery and recently the starter solenoid. I think ethanol is bad for small engines, but that’s almost all I’ve used in this mower yet it always starts right up. The only problem is that its ground-driven belt seems to wear out and slip prematurely. If the company had used the same hydraulic drive transmission that IH uses in its Cub Cadet tractor, this would be a fantastic machine.”

Best Buy
Jack Willis, Lind, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Jack’s impressed with his 2007 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck and 18 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. “I’ve worked the heck out of this mower but it just keeps on running. We live on 1 1/2 acres in dryland wheat country and mow everything on it, even going right over gopher mounds. I change the blades twice a year and all is good. It was a great buy at $999.”

Best Buy
Darrell Moffett, South Bend, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 2 (2012), p. 13

“I use it to mow 4 acres on my property, along with neighbors’ lawns. It has required only routine maintenance,” says Darrel about his 2009 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with a 20 hp engine and 46-in. deck.

In 2011, Don bought an Italian-built Harvester BCS-718 rear tine garden tiller. “It runs okay but it’s hard to keep the machine where I want it. The tines are only as wide as the drive wheels, which make it hard to keep it from sliding off into the soil I’ve already tilled. The tines should extend 3 to 4 in. beyond the wheels, which would make the machine easier to handle. Also, the handles should be higher so my back wouldn’t ache from having to bend over so far.”

Best Buy
Jack B. Elliott, Florence, Ontario · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 1999 Sears Craftsman lawn tractor equipped with a 20.5 hp, 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton engine and 42-in. mower deck came with an extended warranty. The company replaced blades and belts as required, changed the oil, replaced a faulty carburetor, and replaced the batteries at no charge during warranty. I use it to cut at least one acre of lawn around farm buildings and to mow down tall weeds and small brush in the surrounding area. Over the years I’ve used about six different riding mowers, but this is by far the best one.”

Best Buy
Jerry Mankowski, Wild Rose, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“I haven’t spent one penny on repairs,” says Jerry about his 2001 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with a 22 hp, V-twin, Kohler Pro engine, automatic transmission, and 50-in. deck. “I use it to cut four acres every week. It still has the original blades and belts.”

Best Buy
Larry King, Maryville, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“My 1968 Chevrolet WT 1500 pickup equipped with a Vortec V-6 engine and automatic transmission is my best buy. I bought it used with a lot of miles on it and replaced the brake rotors, pads, drums and shoes. Now it has more than 170,000 miles on it but still doesn’t use any oil. It has a smooth ride.

“My 2000 Sears Craftsman lawn tractor equipped with a 23 1/2 hp Kohler engine and 60-in. deck has had a lot of problems. Fortunately, I purchased a maintenance contract when I bought the mower. The deck had to be replaced, as well as the rear end, transmission, battery, fuse, and blades. A blade shaft snapped off at the bearing. Now the juncture of the fender assembly is splitting under the seat where it joins the frame. It’s impossible to mow evenly. Also, the entire front axle and steering rod had to be replaced.”

Worst Buy
Royal Hohl, Salina, Kansas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

A 2002 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with an automatic transmission and 48-in. deck rates as Royal’s “worst buy.” “The day I brought it home I was setting it up when the spring to the neutral shift rod came off and wouldn’t stay on. Also, the electric clutch that controls the blade engagement locks and won’t engage the blade. It happens every time I use the mower. The deck has to be cleaned often so I can keep it running. The transmission is so weak that in reverse gear the mower will barely back up on level ground. However, the engine does have a lot of power and starts and runs good.

“The deck is mounted too low. I’ve adjusted it according to the owner’s manual, but even with the adjustment lever at its highest level, the bottom of the deck is only about three inches above the ground. If the deck didn’t have four anti-scalping wheels I think it could be lowered all the way to below-ground level. Another problem is that the magnet holding the hood down came off within the first couple of hours of use.

“I’ve owned Sears Craftsman equipment for many years, but lately I’ve found their products to be weak and poorly made. My Craftsman rototiller had such flimsy handles that the tubing around the welds broke during the first season of use.”

Best Buy
John Blanque, Franklinton, La. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

A 2002 Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 23 hp engine and 48-in. deck rates as John’s “best buy.” “I use it to cut 15 acres and it never causes any problems. I also use it to pull up to 1,000 lbs. of firewood on an old airport luggage cart. I bought it with an extended warranty, which was cheaper and better than what Home Depot and Lowe’s were offering with their garden tractors.”

Best Buy
Bill Reeks, Cromwell, Ky. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 13

“My 2001 Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 17 1/2 hp engine and a 42-in. mower deck has performed well, except for problems with the front axle and the spindle on the left front wheel. The axle literally broke in half due to metal that was too thin, and the left front spindle housing split due to poor factory welds. The spindle had worn 1/8 in. at the bottom. I was told the company’s replacement axles were built heavier so I ordered a complete new axle. To my dismay, I discovered that it was an identical replacement and didn’t use it. Instead, I rebuilt the broken axle by clamping it back together and welding it properly. At the same time, I welded two 3/8-in. lengths of rebar onto the bottom side of the axle to make it stronger than new.

“The tractor’s front wheels have what are called friction bearings, although I don’t consider them bearings because even with regular greasing, the left front spindle wore excessively on the lower side. I welded and built up the worn area, then machined it so the wheel would fit on properly. After six months of use I’m now satisfied with this machine. The front axle and spindle were the only problems I’ve experienced with it. I told Sears I now know why they call their machines ‘Craftsman’. It’s because the customer has to be a craftsman just to keep them going.

“Would I buy another Sears Craftsman garden tractor? Since I know how to repair their weak points, I probably would, if I could buy the machine at a discount. We have a 1996 Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 13 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and a 42-in. deck that has been trouble-free. It has a better built front axle, but that axle won’t fit the 2001 model.”

Worst Buy
Franklin H. Knapp, Milton, Fla. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 16

“My worst buy ever was a 1998 Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 42-in. mower deck and powered by a 15 1/2 hp Briggs & Stratton single cylinder gas engine. Two weeks after I bought it all the tires started losing air. Rather than traveling 45 miles one way to take the mower back to Sears, I installed tubes in all the tires. Then three weeks later the bracket that holds the bagger started to bend backward, which caused the bags to fall off the rear. I had to weld on a triangulated brace to fix it.

“The carburetor slowly leaked gas past the float valve and into the combustion chamber, which caused a hydrostatic lock. I had to remove the spark plug to drain the gas out so I could start it again. I also had to change the oil often because it was diluted with gas. I solved this problem by installing a fuel shutoff valve in the line.

“As for Briggs & Stratton engines, they’re among my worst buys, too. They used to be pretty good but not any more. I have a pressure washer equipped with an 11 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and a generator with an 8 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. On both machines, after the engines run for a few minutes the recoil starters lock up and rip the ropes right out of the housings.”

Best Buy
Douglas G. Cramb, Beloit, Kan. · Vol. 24, No. 4 (2000), p. 14

Douglas likes his Drill Doctor drill bit sharpener. “It’s user friendly and works just like the company said it would.

“I like my Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 42-in. mower. The deck is nice and level, the automatic transmission works great, all the controls are within reach, and it steers easy. The Briggs & Stratton 19 1/2 hp Twin-Turbo gas engine is smooth and vibrates very little compared to a single cylinder engine. All these features are a definite plus to someone who has arthritis. It’s built a lot like a ‘real’ tractor.

“All my Ford vehicles have been best buys, including ten cars, six pickups, four grain trucks, two full-size conversion vans, an Explorer, a Windstar van, and three tractors. I’ve used other brands, but in the end I’ve been much more satisfied with the performance of Ford products. The only real problem is that when I want to buy a used Ford, it’s hard to find one for sale.”

Best Buy
Johnie W. Oglesby, Ewing, Va. · Vol. 23, No. 4 (1999), p. 17

“It’s a great performer,” says Johnie about his Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with an 18 1/2 hp twin cylinder Kohler Magnum gas engine. “It makes a 46-in. wide cut. I also like my Sears air compressor.

“My 1997 Ford F-150 pickup equipped with a 4.6-liter V-8 engine and automatic transmission is a best buy.”

Best Buy
Matthew Friesen, Winkler, Manitoba · Vol. 21, No. 2 (1997), p. 15

“It’s a fantastic machine,” says Matthew about his 1987 Sears Craftsman 38-in. riding mower equipped with a 14 hp Briggs & Stratton gas engine and 5-speed transmission. “It has a lot of torque and is easy on fuel. I installed a bucket seat from a Datsun car which greatly improved the ride. I built my own trailer and sled for it, as well as an aerator, drag, and clippings collector. I pull a 40-in. harrow behind it to seed grass.”

Sears Craftsman shop tools

5 Best Buys4 Worst Buys
Best Buy
David Roth, Cheney, Kansas · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 13

“I use my 2016 Husqvarna zero-turn riding mower equipped with a 61-in. deck to mow about 2 1/2 acres of grass. It’s built heavy.

“I’ve found the quality of Sears Craftsman shop tools has declined. Their wrenches just don’t hold up under punishment like they did in the past.”

Best Buy
Dean Potts, Woodsfield, Ohio · Vol. 41, No. 5 (2017), p. 13

“My 1990 Kubota L&G tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine, hydrostatic transmission, and 48-in. mower deck has about 1,300 hrs. on it but still works great. We use it to mow about 2 1/2 acres of hilly, rough lawn and it’s now on its third set of blades. I’ve had to replace only a universal joint and the tires. I’d be hard pressed to replace this tractor with any other brand, or maybe even with a Kubota because their new models have too much plastic and fiberglass.

“For more than 35 years I’ve used only Sears Craftsman shop tools including saws, planers, drill presses, sanders, and routers. I can’t say enough good things about these tools. It’s a shame the company sold this brand.”

Best Buy
Loren Konda, Sherman, S. Dak. · Vol. 41, No. 2 (2017), p. 15

“My Stihl MS 290 chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar is my best buy. I’ve run 44 gal. of gas through it over the years, but it has only been back to the dealer once for a checkup. It’s an unbelievable saw.

“I own a lot of Sears Craftsman tools that used to be made in the U.S., including allen wrenches and ratchets, and they work great. But the company’s newer tools are made in China and the quality has gone down. I’m very disappointed in them.”

Worst Buy
John Teder, Jackson, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 6 (2014), p. 15

“I’ve been buying Sears Craftsman tools for 45 years. However, the last set of 1/4 to 9/16-in. combination open-box end wrenches I bought are poor quality. They’re thicker and wider than the company’s previous wrenches, which makes them useless in confined areas. Also, these tools are no longer stamped ‘Made in the U.S.A’.

“Here’s a question: why can Ace Hardware sell Craftsman tools, but not honor the warranty if you don’t buy from them?”

Worst Buy
Rupert Theuerer, Spring Valley, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I had good luck with a 1981 White 2-135 tractor I bought used in 2000, so when a neighbor sold his farm 3 years ago I bought his White 2-155 with about 8,000 hrs. on it. I use this tractor mostly to pull a 1,500-gal., 120-ft. field sprayer up and down our hilly fields at speeds up to 9 mph. I can easily spray 100 acres per hour. Both tractors have required only routine maintenance.

“My Sears Craftsman tools are worst buys. This company used to build fair value tools, but not any more. For example, their punches break easily. I no longer buy from them and instead buy professional tools. They cost more up front, but they last.”

Best Buy
A. Earl Cheal, Ellerslie, Ga. · Vol. 34, No. 3 (2010), p. 14

“I’ve had good success with Sears Craftsman tools since the 1950’s. However, last year I bought a top-of-the-line Craftsman rototiller equipped with reversing tines. It worked good except when the engine surged. Under warranty the service rep replaced 7 different carburetors, but even that didn’t solve the problem. The company refunded my money. The service rep said the EPA’s requirements for carburetors don’t allow for power and idle adjustments like on older models; therefore, the fuel/air mixture couldn’t be regulated.”

Worst Buy
Shannon Nowak, Glyndon, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 5 (2008), p. 15

“My worst buy is any Sears Craftsman motorized tool. I bought three different products equipped with an ‘easy start’ system: a 2000 push mower, a 2002 16-in. chain saw, and a 2006 Craftsman riding mower. Unfortunately, the easy start system isn’t easy to start. The first time I went to use the riding mower it wouldn’t start and spent two weeks in the shop. When we finally picked it up and brought it home, it still didn’t work. Sears had to come out two more times to get it running. No more Craftsmans for us.

“My husband loves our 2007 Hyundai Elantra. It has 100 percent bumper-to-bumper warranty coverage up to 5-year/60,000 miles, and a 10-year/100,000 mile power train warranty. It averages 34 mpg.”

Best Buy
Patrick McGoldrick, Oxford, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 3 (2003), p. 14

Patrick’s impressed with his 1998 Troy Bilt wide body lawn mower. “We use it to mow our 1-acre lawn which is very steep. We had been using a Cub Cadet riding mower, but even when it was equipped with wheel weights it didn’t do a very good job. The Troy Bilt does a great job and has been trouble-free.”

“I don’t like Sears Craftsman power tools and lawn and garden equipment. My most recent negative experience was with a gas-powered leaf blower. If I tilted the blower the least bit to the left or right it stalled. The company says that’s normal, but I don’t think so.”

Worst Buy
Bill Griffin, North Garden, Va. · Vol. 26, No. 3 (2002), p. 15

“I’m impressed with my Deere AMT 600 utility vehicle which I bought used. It’s one of the company’s earliest models and has a motorcycle front end. This machine has performed beyond my expectations in every way and has required no major repairs. I use it for hauling hay, wood, dirt, manure, rocks, and to tow my log splitter and a small trailer. It goes through mud and climbs hills with no problems. I like that it fits in the back of my pickup.

On the “worst buy” side, he lists Sears Craftsman tools. “They break easily. Here’s what happened to the tools I own. Open end wrenches spread open, rounding off the bolt head. The ends broke off screwdrivers. Sockets split. The end broke off my breaker bar. The pliers are too sloppy to get a good grip. I plan to buy Snap-On tools from now on.”

Best Buy
Darwin Schrader, San Antonio, Texas · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 13

“My Dremel chainsaw sharpening attachment works fast and is highly effective (www.dremel.com). I like it because I can sharpen individual teeth. The chain lasts much longer this way than grinding every tooth.

“My Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt cordless chainsaw can cut a 5-in. dia. mesquite tree in less than 5 sec. However, it doesn’t oil the chain as much as it should. I carry oil and a short 1-in. wide brush in a jar and swab the chain with oil frequently so it’ll last longer.”

Worst Buy
Carol Ann McNeese, Eddyville, Iowa · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 14

“Our Honda 2000 generator always starts on the first pull, runs quiet, and will go for a long time on a tank of gas. We like it so much that we bought another one.

“We’ve found that Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt batteries last less than a year before they die and can’t be recharged. The company won’t replace them.”

Best Buy
Henry L. Hitechew, Sr., New Paris, Penn. · Vol. 41, No. 4 (2017), p. 13

“I like my 2016 Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt, 1/2-in. drive impact wrench. Works great for changing tires and for service work on riding mowers.”

Best Buy
James Dirks, Alva, Wyo. · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 12

“My Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt, 1/2-in. impact wrench puts out 200 ft. lbs. of torque and is really handy to use. My Sears Craftsman Nextec 12-volt right angle impact driver also works hard. I can drive a 4-in. screw with a Phillips head without slipping once.

“I’m disappointed with my 2005 Sterling truck equipped with a 12-liter, 60 series Detroit diesel engine. The engine lacks power when pulling uphill and sometimes smokes, even when going downhill. I’ve taken the truck to the dealer several times, but they can’t find any fault codes in the computer and told me the vehicle is running as good as it ever will. When I told them the truck smokes going downhill, they just shrugged and told me they had no idea what would cause that. This truck struggles to get 4 mpg.”

Best Buy
Larry Owen, Pocahontas, Ark. · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 15

“I’m satisfied with my 2009 Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt cordless 3/8-in. drill-driver. I’ve used this tool in numerous situations, using most of the torque settings and speed variations, and it performs well at every setting. I especially like the balance and grip of this tool. The company increased the power and adjustability of this tool but it didn’t result in a larger drill – in fact, it’s smaller than some previous models.”

Best Buy
Joe Germuga, Rochester, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 1 (2012), p. 12

“My Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt cordless drill has a lot of power and the battery lasts a long time, even with continuous use. I like it better than my Ryobi, Makita and Harbor Freight cordless drills.

“In my experience Harbor Freight metal drill bits don’t hold an edge, and they break too easily.”

Best Buy
Stan F. Gruver, Hutchinson, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Stan’s the owner of a Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt cordless drill. “I’m satisfied with the drill but not the friction chuck on it. The only way I can keep the drill bit from slipping is to put a band wrench on the chuck. The next time I get one of these drills I’m taking the chuck off and replacing it with a Jacobs chuck with key.”

Best Buy
Ted Boice, Great Falls, Montana · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“Several years ago I bought a Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt driver drill set for about $100. I really liked its performance and used it almost every day. However, a year or so ago both batteries quit charging so I headed down to Sears to get a couple of new ones. I was told they don’t handle batteries for ‘older’ drills, and that I’d have to go to a service center across town. They wanted $74 for a pair of batteries, which I wasn’t willing to pay.

“Then I went to Sam’s Club and bought two Kawasaki 19.2-volt drills, four batteries, and two chargers for less than $80. I love them and use them all the time. I’ll never buy another electric tool with the Craftsman name on it.”

Best Buy
Howard Birr, Albany, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 4 (2006), p. 12

“I like my Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless tool set. It’s a 4-piece set with two batteries, and it didn’t cost much more than what I paid for a Skil reciprocating saw that came with only one battery. The Sears batteries hold their charge much longer, too.”

Best Buy
Richard Fryzek, Estes Park, Colo. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My 2001 Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless drill driver has power and is a tough tool. I’ve used it to build several decks. It’s durable, and the battery charge lasts a long time.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2004 FlowTron leaf eater. “It wouldn’t do anything the manufacturer said it would. The cutter string lasted about seven minutes. It was supposed to mulch pine needles but it wouldn’t touch them. I’m disappointed with it.”

Best Buy
Joshua Abernathy, Covington, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“My best buy is my Sears Craftsman 18-volt circular saw, drill, and flashlight set. It has more than enough power - the batteries on it stay charged longer than any other brand I’ve used. As a result, the saw cuts tough, treated hardwood lumber with ease.

“My Mantis rototiller is a best buy. My only complaint is that the dealer I purchased it from doesn’t stock many spare parts such as special grease for the gearbox, air filters, or accessories. However, the rototiller itself works great. I’m really impressed with it.”

Best Buy
Howard Cigelske, Beaver Dam, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“My Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless 3/8-in. drill-driver is my best buy. It has a lot more power than the 9-volt model I had previously owned. The chuck works good, and the reverse button doesn’t get in the way of the trigger grip.

‘My 1946 Miller 150-amp welder is a best buy. It has worked well all these years with no problems. I replaced the cables only once.”

Worst Buy
Daniel D. Cripps, Brush Creek, Tenn. · Vol. 27, No. 2 (2003), p. 12

“It lets me haul heavy loads with ease,” says Daniel, pleased with his 2001 Deere 6 by 4 Gator. “It tows loads well and is almost unstoppable in all weather conditions. This vehicle is almost maintenance-free.”

On the negative side, he lists his Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless drill. “After about six months the chuckless mechanism locked up so I couldn’t even change bits. The dealer broke a screwdriver trying to replace the chuck.”

Best Buy
Gary Sampson, Freedom, N.Y. · Vol. 27, No. 1 (2003), p. 12

A Sears Craftsman 18-volt Hi/Lo variable speed drill rates as Gary’s “best buy”. “My wife and son bought it as a Father’s Day gift. I was skeptical when I saw that it was made in China, but I really like it. It drives a 3-in. screw into a 2 by 4 like nothing, and the variable speed drive works great. Recently I used this drill outdoors on a building project. The temperature was only 20 degrees but the battery lasted for four hours of hard use. When the battery ran out I had a spare battery all ready to go. The quick charger that comes with the drill charges the battery in only one hour. This drill is also built tough. It slid off a tin roof that we were working on but the battery didn’t even come off and the drill kept right on working.”

Sears Craftsman cordless drills

3 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Carter Edgar, Three Brooks, N.B. · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 14

“Some of your readers have complained that the batteries quit working on their Sears Craftsman cordless drills. I own six of the company’s 19.2-volt models, and the batteries quit working on them, too. However, I find that if you take the battery apart usually you’ll find a heater bar has burned off. To solve the problem, I just solder these back together with a flameless solder gun. By using this technique I’ve been able to keep my drills working for at least two more years.”

Best Buy
Greg Perry, Casper, Wyo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I bought a used 2007 Ford F-150 4-WD crewcab pickup with about 48,000 miles. It rides smooth and quiet and the stereo has an incredible sound. It can haul a cord of wood in the bed while pulling a car trailer with an 11,000-lb. load.

“In 2010 I got a Sears Craftsman cordless drill as a Christmas gift. The batteries don’t hold a charge and the drill chuck won’t tighten up enough to keep from slipping. New batteries are as expensive as the drill and don’t keep a charge for more than 15 min. The loss of power gets frustrating when I’m working on a job away from an electrical outlet. I bought a new charger thinking that would solve the problem, but it didn’t.”

Best Buy
Larry Hecht, Poulsbo, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“I’ve used my 2008 Kubota B3030 loader tractor to maintain about 5 acres of blackberries and alder saplings. I used the loader to dig everything down to the roots, then burned the material and planted pasture grass and fir trees. I couldn’t have done it without my Kubota. It was up to every task without missing a beat.

“I’ve gone through 3 different Sears Craftsman cordless drills because the batteries keep failing. Unfortunately, the replacement batteries cost more than the original drill with batteries. I’ve learned my lesson – no more Craftsman drills.”

Best Buy
Randy Cowart, The Dalles, Ore. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 13

“I bought my Kubota B7300 tractor used with 210 hours on it. It came equipped with frontend loader, 4-ft. rear blade, and 4-ft. finish mower. At first I thought this tractor was a bit on the small side, but it does a good job.

“I stopped buying Sears Craftsman cordless drills. The batteries wouldn’t stay charged. I’ve switched to Ridgid cordless drills, which work much better.”

Worst Buy
H.G. Duncan, Aurora, Oregon · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 13

“My Stihl gas-powered string trimmer has never let me down. It always starts after a couple of pulls, even when I forget to drain gas from the carburetor over the winter. It cuts great with either string line or blades.

“My Sears Craftsman rechargeable drill is my worst buy. The problem is the batteries won’t hold a charge. I’ve always liked Craftsman non-powered tools such as wrenches, sockets, and ratchets, etc. But every time I buy a powered item I seem to have problems. I’ve finally learned my lesson with this drill set-up - no more electric or gas-powered products with the Craftsman name on them.”

Worst Buy
Clint Smith, Sr., Junction, Texas · Vol. 28, No. 5 (2004), p. 15

“Clint’s the satisfied owner of a 2003 Echo extendable chain saw. “With this extendable saw I can trim trees from the ground as high as I could if I stood in a Caterpillar loader bucket - and it’s much safer this way.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2002 Sears Craftsman cordless drill. “I hadn’t used it much when the battery charger quit working. Unfortunately, the company wouldn’t honor the warranty. I bought another charger for about $65 but it, too, quit working within a month. The company refused to either replace or repair it.”

Best Buy
Clay Engel, Hays, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 4 (2008), p. 15

“My Sears Craftsman industrial reciprocating saw is the best tool in my toolbox.

“My worst buy was a Pagsta 49 cc motorcycle made in China. What a piece of junk.”

Best Buy
Barry Fennig, Celina, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 15

“My Sears Craftsman 10-in. portable table saw is my best buy. I used it to help build a 2,000-sq. ft. log home and it worked great, cutting and ripping all the trim and lumber.

“My 2001 Hyundai Sonata car equipped with a V-6 engine is my worst buy. The problem was the unibody frame that supports the front wheels and the engine was defective. The frame cracked, and at 108,000 miles a tire almost broke off it. The part that was needed to solve the problem cost $1,500 and labor was another $500. However, the dealer charged me only for labor as the car is covered by a 100,000-mile bumper-to-bumper warranty. Otherwise this car has been trouble-free. It runs great and is fuel efficient.”

Worst Buy
Malcolm McEachern, Harwood, Texas · Vol. 31, No. 5 (2007), p. 15

“My 2006 Massey Ferguson 1552 tractor equipped with a front-end loader is my best buy. It always starts right up. It has plenty of deck room and plenty of power. I use it to mow acreage for my cows and to move lumber and other loads, and also to do landscaping work.

“My 2006 Sears Craftsman radial arm saw equipped with a 10-in. laser track is my worst buy. I can’t stabilize the motor on the arm, or adjust it accurately to square and perpendicular cuts. It’s built too flimsy for the $600 I paid for it.”

Worst Buy
John E. Cissell, Bardstown, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“I bought my best buy Echo weed eater more than 15 years ago. It always starts on the second or third pull. I’ve changed the spark plug only twice. I use this weed eater not only at home but also to keep all the fence rows clean on a farm that I own. It’s a great tool.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 1995 Sears Craftsman chain saw is the worst chain saw on the market. I have to pull the starter rope at least 20 times before it’ll start. Three different repair shops have tried to fix it with no luck. The only good thing is that my elbows stay in good shape from all the cranking I have to do. I’m glad I don’t have to use this saw very much.”

Best Buy
William G. Hurd, Meriden, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

A Stihl 029 18-in. chain saw rates as William’s “worst buy.” “It always started hard, and then one day it wouldn’t start at all. I took it to the dealer who said it would cost $300 to repair. I brought it back home and then bought a Sears Craftsman 18-in. chain saw that cost about half as much as it would have cost to repair the Stihl. The Sears model has already cut more wood than the Stihl ever did, and it starts a lot easier. It has been trouble-free.

“My General Motors cars, trucks, and pickups, as well as my Massey Ferguson tractors and implements, have all been best buys.”

Best Buy
C. Todd Russell, Conyers, Ga. · Vol. 37, No. 6 (2013), p. 14

“My Deere 5105 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader is an awesome machine. I’ve used it to clear land, plow, do grading work, spread gravel on driveways, and plant wildlife food plots. I also use it to haul logs and firewood. This tractor will go anywhere.

“My 2013 Sears Craftsman zero-turn riding mower equipped with a 54-in. deck doesn’t turn like a zero-turn mower. It keeps going straight even when the lever is moved which leaves drag marks on my lawn. It mows great but isn’t really a zero-turn mower.”

Best Buy
Mike Shy, New Carlisle, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 12

Mike likes his Simplicity Legacy riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck. “This is our second Simplicity mower. We bought our first one in 1990 and had very few problems with it on our five acres. We just used it until it wore out. These mowers are easy to work on and seem to last forever.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2005 Sears Craftsman riding mower. “The company offered a ‘no interest for six months’ financing deal so I took the bait. What they didn’t tell me was how bad their mowers are. It doesn’t cut level and stalls easily, and it’s hard to work on. Finally I just gave it away and bought another Simplicity.”

Best Buy
Sid Miller, Sparta, N.C. · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 15

“I’ve used my 1977 Massey Ferguson 1105 tractor to do everything from plowing to pulling a 5-yard scraper. I’ve never had to spend much money on it other than for routine maintenance.

“My Sears Craftsman 42-in. riding mower has been loud and uncomfortable to operate. Last summer the 17 hp Briggs & Stratton engine on it blew up for no apparent reason. I’ll never buy another Craftsman.”

Best Buy
H.J. Trahan, Jennings, La. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My Ford 3000 tractor has been the most reliable machine I’ve ever had. Neither the engine nor the diesel pump has ever been repaired. I’ve always changed the fuel filters and been careful about using clean fuel.

“I had a problem with the front axle on my Sears Craftsman riding mower. The axle was made by the Roper Co. I replaced the original axle with one made by Sears Craftsman, which I modified a little, and now I have a heavy duty axle.”

Worst Buy
Bill Armstrong, Hermleigh, Texas · Vol. 20, No. 5 (1996), p. 16

“I haven’t had any problems with my two 1987 Kawasaki 300 Bayou 4-wheeler ATV’s. I use them on our ranch to build fence, do chores, herd cattle, go hunting, etc. I wish everything I owned performed as well as these ATV’s.” On the minus side, Bill nominates his 1987 Sears Craftsman riding mower as “worst buy”. “The engine and deck work okay but the gears in the transaxle went out twice and it took over a year to get repair parts. After the first repair I was able to use it only twice before the gears broke again. I’ll never buy a Sears again. My next mower will have hydrostatic drive - no more transaxles for me.”

Sears Craftsman weed trimmer

2 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Best Buy
James L. Hughes, Orange City, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 5 (2009), p. 13

“My 2008 Sears Craftsman 22-in. weed trimmer has large rear wheels and .155 ready-to-cut strings that are easy to replace. I use it to cut under 3,300 ft. of board fence.

“My 2006 Wagner ‘Paint Crew’ airless paint sprayer is my worst buy. It won’t spray Latex fence stain no matter how much it’s thinned. Just about everything on the machine clogs up including the nozzle, line, pump, and filter. I spend more time and wasted more paint trying to make this unit work than it would have taken to paint with brushes and rollers.”

Worst Buy
Bob Cully, Chanute, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My worst buy was my 2006 Sears Craftsman wheeled weed trimmer. I was able to use it only three times before it quit working, even though I had only owned it for 30 days. I took it back for repair work but didn’t get it back until five weeks later. Then when I started it up it would only idle. I’d never buy another one.”

Best Buy
Marie Ellis, Dexter, New Mexico · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“My Sears Craftsman weed trimmer works great on fences. However, the ball that holds the trimmer line is made of plastic and gets hot and breaks. I’ve had it fixed three times. It should be made of metal.”

Worst Buy
Charles T. Koenig, Cuero, Texas · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My 2000 Deere 425 garden tractor is my best buy. I owned a smaller Deere garden tractor for 10 years before I bought this model. It still has the same great quality.”

“My 1993 Ford 5610 II tractor equipped with wide rear tires and an extra flow hydraulic pump is a best buy.

“My Sears Craftsman high wheel trimmer is my worst buy. The problem is that it leaks oil. I should’ve known better because I had previously owned a Sears riding mower which needed repairs almost every week. However, when my DR trimmer finally wore out I decided to try Sears one more time, which was a mistake.”

Best Buy
Leonard Seltzer, Manhattan, Ill. · Vol. 40, No. 1 (2016), p. 14

“I like my 2015 Sears Craftsman 3/8-in., 19.2-volt cordless impact driver. I use it with a variety of sockets, nut drivers and screwdrivers. I bought it with a 3/8-in. drill and flashlight that use the same battery pack. I paid only about $100. It’s not meant for real heavy duty work, but it’s handy for in-between jobs. It’s relatively lightweight and works fast.”

Best Buy
Jon Williams, Pueblo West, Colo. · Vol. 39, No. 2 (2015), p. 15

“I really like my Sears Craftsman 3/8-in. drive flex head ratchet. It has a curved handle so I can use it where there isn’t room for a straight-handled ratchet, and the flex head helps, too.”

He’s happy with his Phillips DVD player. “One of the best things we’ve done is to cancel our cable TV subscription. When we have time my wife and I can watch what we want, when we want thanks to our DVD player. Also, there’s no monthly fee, no commercials, no political ads, and no program interruptions.”

Best Buy
Chuck Peckham, Gardiner, Maine · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 16

Chuck likes his 1996 Sears Craftsman 3/8-in. portable drill-driver. “This 9.6-volt model is lightweight, well balanced, and easy to handle. It has adjustable torque that’s more than adequate even for driving lag screws. It also has enough power to reverse screws that can’t be started by hand. Makes driving wood and sheet metal screws a snap. This drill is one of the handiest things since pockets in a night gown. I’ve never been dissatisfied with anything bearing the Sears Craftsman label.”

Sears Craftsman ratchet wrenches

2 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Tom Borchers, Williamsburg, Ohio · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 13

“My 2016 Milwaukee 18-volt lithium ion 1/2-in. impact wrench has more power than my air impact wrench. It can easily change all 4 tires on my pickup and do a brake job on one battery charge.

“My Milwaukee grease gun can go through 4 or 5 tubes of grease on one battery charge.

“Rust Bomb is the best penetrating oil I’ve ever used (www.conklin.com). It just eats up rust and makes PB Blaster look like it’s made of water.

“I think the quality of Harbor Freight tools has improved.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Sears Craftsman ratchet wrenches and screwdrivers. “The ratchet wrenches have big-toothed gearing that doesn’t hold up to heavy use, and their screwdriver tips break even if you’re turning the screwdriver by hand.”

Best Buy
Michael Mayer, Smithshire, Ill. · Vol. 39, No. 3 (2015), p. 14

“The last set of Sears Craftsman wrenches I bought were made in China and now claim to have a ‘lifetime guarantee’ instead of ‘guaranteed forever’. What exactly does ‘lifetime guarantee’ mean anyway?”

Best Buy
Gary Noblit, Jonesville, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 6 (2005), p. 12

“I like my Sears Craftsman ratchet wrenches with directional levers. They’re not cheap, but the narrow width lets me use these tools in hard-to-get-at areas. It takes only a small degree of movement to operate the ratchets, and they have a high polish for easy cleanup. It’s easier than chasing after sockets.”

Sears Craftsman (general)

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Ernie Tweedy, Oxford, Ark. · Vol. 36, No. 1 (2012), p. 12

He’s had problems with his Sears Craftsman 48-in. GT 5000 riding mower equipped with a 26 hp, 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton engine. “The first year the engine failed when the push rods fell out and got bent up. Neither Briggs and Stratton nor Sears would help so I paid the Sears service shop to fix it. The machine ran for only about three more hours before the same problem happened again. The local rep confirmed the problem and made the repair.

“The second year the transmission went out. A local repair shop found the transmission input shaft was rounded off, so a new shaft was installed. The third year the transmission’s top gear went out, making the machine unusable as a mower.”

Best Buy
John D. Dewell, Scio, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“I really like my 1993 Hardy outside wood burning furnace. I had a few problems with it which the dealer promptly corrected. We use it to heat our house and it does a wonderful job. We use it to burn everything, including old tires and tubes, old round bale bags, and garbage. It burns so clean we don’t even have to pay for a garbage service. We even use it to heat our drinking water. It works for us 365 days a year. “ sockets! From now on we’ll stick with Snap-On, Sears Craftsman, or Kobalt tools.”

Best Buy
Rick Boyd, Lexington, Ohio · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“I like my 2001 Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt drill/driver kit. It’s equipped with a light, charger, and two batteries. I’ve used it to remodel many rooms and projects, and it always works flawlessly. It has performed beyond my expectations.

“My Mantis tiller with dethatcher and sidewalk trimmer edger is also a best buy. I bought it used in 1991. This little tiller does a fantastic job in small gardens and flower beds and works great for cultivating. My neighbors use it and they keep wanting to buy it from me. However, it will never be for sale but will be handed down to our kids.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman line trimmer powered by a 32 cc gas engine is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and vibrates bad. I wish I would have spent extra money and bought an Echo or a Stihl.”

Best Buy
Haskell W. Carr, Twin Falls, Idaho · Vol. 27, No. 1 (2003), p. 12

“My Kawasaki Bayou 220 ATV is one of the most useful tools on our irrigated farm. It has been trouble-free.

“My Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt cordless drill is indispensable around our shop and is a best buy.”

Best Buy
Chester W. Claycomb, Imler, Penn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Chester likes his Sears Craftsman 19-volt rechargeable drill. “It has a lot of power and lasts a long time because of the two power packs that come with it. Also, it stores in a nice case. I’d recommend this drill to anyone.”

The pickup bed-mounted crane lift he bought from Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy”. “This crane is rated at 1,000 lbs. but the mounting system leaves a lot to be desired. It pulled the bolts right out of the pickup bed. I had to put a 3/4-in. thick steel plate under the lift, bolted and welded in place. Pickup beds are too thin to support a crane lifting that much weight.”

Best Buy
Brian C. Harp, Blossvale, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman 19-volt drill/driver is my best buy. In the spring I found myself needing a new cordless drill for around the farm. One of its first jobs was to operate a fertilizer spreader. I used it to unload 3,000 lbs. of leftover fertilizer by hooking it to the spreader’s ground drive shift. It did it all on one battery. I was impressed. In the fall we used it while putting together a friend’s 12 by 24-ft. steel building. We installed about 2,500 bolts yet went through only two batteries. I use it every day and have been happy with it. It’s an excellent tool at an affordable price.”

Worst Buy
Robert Erickson, Williamstown, Vt. · Vol. 38, No. 6 (2014), p. 14

He’s had problems with his 2011 Sears Craftsman 20 hp riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck. “Right from the start the choke didn’t work properly, and the throttle cable broke at the handle. Also, every time I start the engine I have to use starter fluid.”

Best Buy
Marvin W. Dechant, Ness City, Kansas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“Three years ago I bought a Sears Craftsman 20 hp lawn tractor equipped with electric start and an automatic transmission. The engine would often flood, and I had to keep buying spark plugs and blowing gas out the spark plug hole. A pair of wires at the bottom of the carburetor are supposed to automatically adjust the gas flow, but it wasn’t working. I bought a new carburetor but it didn’t help. I finally installed a shutoff valve in the fuel line between the fuel tank and the carburetor, which lets me adjust the gas flow by hand.”

Best Buy
Charles Sassmen, Reedsport, Oregon · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“My 2000 Dodge 2500 diesel pickup is by far the best pickup I’ve ever owned. I installed a BD power chip on it which provided a 100 hp boost (BD Power, www.bd-power.com; ph 800 887-5030). After more than 60,000 miles with no problems, I think it’s still just getting broken in. I use it to pull 24-ft. livestock trailers and hay trailers. It pulls a fully-loaded trailer like it was empty.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman 22 hp garden tractor is always breaking down. The mower deck bearings keep going out, and the deck plugs up with grass. I’ll never buy another Craftsman garden tractor.”

Best Buy
Richard E. Adams, Winnebago, Minn. · Vol. 26, No. 1 (2002), p. 14

“We’re impressed with our Sears Craftsman 2.2 chain saw. In three years we’ve used it to cut 150 pickup loads of firewood. All we have to do is sharpen the chain.”

Best Buy
Joe E. Miller, Fredericksburg, Ohio · Vol. 41, No. 3 (2017), p. 15

“I’m well satisfied with my Massey Ferguson 240 4-WD loader tractor which I bought used with 880 hrs. on it. It always starts right up and is ready to go.

“My Sears Craftsman 4 1/2-in. right angle grinder was only about 6 mo. old when the motor burned up. I was able to use it only 4 or 5 times. Next time I’ll go with a different brand.”

Worst Buy
Ben F. Reeves, Fountain, Colo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“My worst buy was a Sears Craftsman 4 1/2-in. industrial grinder. The first wheel wasn’t even worn out before sparks started blowing out of the motor, so I took it back to the dealer. However, they said they couldn’t pay to have the motor repaired because I didn’t have an extended warranty. That was never mentioned when I bought the machine.”

Sears Craftsman 5 hp wall-mount

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John T. Conway, Wilmore, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 3 (2005), p. 15

“My Sears Craftsman 5 hp, wall-mount vacuum is handy to store and has plenty of power to pick up dirt. All the Sears products I’ve used over the years have worked great, and the company stands behind its warranty, too.”

Best Buy
Brent Griggs, Piedmont, Mo. · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 17

Brent likes his Sears Craftsman 12-volt cordless drill. “It’s unbelievable how handy it is. It saves a lot of trips to the garage. It has enough power that I can use it for a long time.

“My Sears Craftsman 30-gal. 5 hp compressor does a fine job of supplying air without having to work very hard.

“MyDeWalt chop saw can cut through any kind of steel. It’s built tough.”

Worst Buy
Ken Abbott, Big Timber, Montana · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Ken nominates his Sears Craftsman 75-piece combination tap and die carbon steel set as his “worst buy”. “The 3/8 by 16-in. die chipped. I took it back to the store but they just told me to contact the warranty center, which I did. I sent 2 letters but never got an answer. It’s frustrating to buy a tap and die set made in the U.S. for Sears and then be unable to get a replacement part for it. I’m disappointed in Sears. I’ve trusted them my entire life.”

Worst Buy
Ken Abbott, Big Timber, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 2 (2012), p. 14

Ken’s disappointed with his Sears Craftsman 75-piece carbon steel tap and die set. “It chipped on the finishing side so I took it back, but they said it wasn’t guaranteed like most Craftsman tools. This isn’t the same Sears company that I grew up with.”

Best Buy
Terry Heckman, South Bend, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 5 (2014), p. 12

“I like my 2013 Kubota L4600 HST 4-WD tractor equipped with an LA764 front-end loader. I use it to pull a haybine, baler, 2-bottom plow, and bush hog. I also use it to power a post hole digger, 3-pt. mounted spreader, hay rake and rear blade. It has power to spare for any job. Last winter it started right up at temperatures down to 16 degrees below zero and went right through 4-ft. deep snowdrifts. I used the loader to pile snow 20 ft. high. One time I buried the tractor in a swamp and used the bucket, 4-WD and rear wheel lock to get myself out. This tractor is unstoppable.”

On the “worst buy” side, “Three months after I bought my 2013 Sears Craftsman LT2000 riding mower, fuel leaked into the crankcase and I had to order a new carburetor for $196. The mechanic said the problem is that ethanol eats the seals out of the carburetor. I asked him to install a fuel shutoff valve, but the company wouldn’t allow him to do it so I installed one myself.”

Worst Buy
Bill Medlin, Shingletown, Calif. · Vol. 37, No. 6 (2013), p. 14

“I’ve owned tractors for more than 30 years, but this one is the best yet,” says Bill about his 2006 Deere 110 loader tractor.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2010 Sears Craftsman LT2000 riding mower. “Sears technicians have made 7 visits trying to understand why the engine shuts off without warning. The company extended the warranty 3 times. Finally, after 1 1/2 years it’s fixed for the time being. I wanted to return the mower for an upgrade, but the company refused.”

Worst Buy
Bill Welfley, Sr., New Philadelphia, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman gas-powered leaf blower is my worst buy. The head bolts and carburetor bolts kept working loose, causing it to quit running. It cost $109 new, and the company wanted $85 just to look at it. So we put LocTite on the threads, but the bolts still kept vibrating loose. This leaf blower is a piece of junk. Next time I’ll buy a quality product from Stihl.”

Worst Buy
W.M. Goolsby, Auburn, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

He likes Royal Purple synthetic oil (Royal Purple, Ltd., ph 888 382-6300 or 281 354-8600; www.royalpurple.com). “I started using this oil on a trial basis eight years ago in such machines as my truck, tractor, and lawn mower. It has proven itself in lowering friction in both gas and diesel engines. I get better mileage on gas engines and more hours on my tractor cutting brush. Plus, I don’t have to change oil as often.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman leaf blower is my worst buy. It worked okay the first couple of times I used it, but then it started having problems. I always run the gas out of 2-cycle engines before I put them in storage. When I got the blower out to use it last spring, it wouldn’t crank. It has only about two hours of running time on it.”

Best Buy
Jeff Lang, Newport News, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 2 (2009), p. 13

“My Sears Craftsman electric cultivator/tiller is my best buy. I use it in my raised bed vegetable garden. I’ve also used it to work up a 20 by 30-ft. section of lawn and it worked well for that, too.”

Best Buy
Jeff Lang, Newport News, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“My all-time best buy is a nut and bolt loosener and rust penetrant called Open & Shut made by Drummond American and sold by Lawson Products (ph 804 241-9541; www.Lawson products.com). I work in a tractor trailer repair shop where there’s a need for such a product every day. I’m really impressed with it. P.B. Blaster is a good penetrant, but Open & Shut works five times better at penetrating rust.

“For a good demonstration of how fast this product works, fill two Styrofoam coffee cups half full of water, then spray a little Open & Shut in one cup and P.B. Blaster in the other. Open & Shut will penetrate the water and go through the cup before P.B. Blaster does every time. It’s not at all corrosive to metals or to your hands should you accidentally get any on your skin. I’d recommend this product to anyone.

“My Sears Craftsman electric cultivator/tiller works great. I bought it to use in my raised bed vegetable garden but I’ve also used it to work up a 20 by 30-ft. section of lawn. It worked well for that, too.”

Sears Craftsman socket set

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
William Miller, West Springfield, Penn. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“I work for American Eagle Windmills, and the Makita 18-volt cordless tools we use on the job work great. We tried using a couple other brands but these tools have more power and are compact, which makes them easy to use in tight spots. It takes only 10 to 12 min. to charge the batteries.

“My Sears Craftsman socket set doesn’t stay organized in its case, and the first time I used it I broke some of the sockets. I have to keep running to the store to replace sockets. These sockets are built with about the same quality as Harbor Freight tools.”

Best Buy
Wilbert Goering, Moundridge, Kan. · Vol. 24, No. 4 (2000), p. 14

“My best buy is my Sears Craftsman Speed-Lok set for drill bits, screwdrivers, and nut drivers. It lets me change heads in only a few seconds and is a real time-saver.

“I like my 1994 Chevrolet S-10 pickup, except for one problem. The automatic transmission doesn’t always shift up like it should without racing the engine. I’ve taken it to two different shops and changed the transmission oil and even flushed the transmission, but this problem still occasionally happens. It doesn’t make any difference what the outside temperature is. If anyone has a solution I’d like to hear from them (P.O. Box 175, Moundridge, Kan. 67107 ph 316 345-8674).”

Sears Craftsman snowblower

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Levi Jefferies, Ludington, Mich. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I bought my 1998 Deere LT155 riding mower to resell and make a profit. I cleaned it up and changed the oil and blades, then sold it. The next year the buyer called and said he had mowed his 3-acre lawn once a week without a single problem. This machine was built to last.

“Our 2006 Sears Craftsman 33-in. snowblower has yet to provide one week of reliable service. It snaps shear pins in the drive and auger even when the snowblower doesn’t hit anything, and it also eats up belts. Another problem was that bolts rattled loose because they weren’t properly tightened at the factory. We replaced the shear pins with grade 8 bolts, but they still break.”

Best Buy
Arnold Hollingsworth, Strasburg, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 13

Arnold’s the satisfied owner of a Sears Craftsman 28-in. snowblower. “Last winter Colorado had record snowfalls. We were without adequate snow removal equipment on a country road with no help from the county, so we bought this snowblower. It worked like a champ, going right through 4 and 5-ft. high snowdrifts without plugging or faltering. I’m very happy with this machine.”

Sears Craftsman 1 hp 120-volt air

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Terry Morgel, Avon, Minn. · Vol. 38, No. 5 (2014), p. 14

“I had problems with my 2012 Stihl 026 Pro chainsaw. The carburetor had to be rebuilt twice and the clutch also seized up twice. The bar turned blue for lack of chain oil, and I couldn’t adjust the oil flow. After making several trips to different dealers, I traded it in on a Husqvarna 353 Pro. We now have 3 Husqvarnas. They’re great saws.

“I bought a new Sears Craftsman 1 hp 120-volt air compressor in 1973, and I can’t imagine how many hours are on it now. I use this compressor in my shop and have also sprayed many gallons of paint with it. It still has the original V-belt. I’ve replaced the pressure switch twice and made a minor motor repair once. I change the oil and clean or replace the air filter once a year.”

Sears Craftsman 1000 20 hp riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Willard Meyer, Newton, Wis. · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 14

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman 1000 20 hp riding mower equipped with a 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton engine is my best buy. It has required only routine maintenance. I change the oil twice a year and grease the wheels. It really runs smooth.”

Sears Craftsman 12-volt cordless drill

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Brent Griggs, Piedmont, Mo. · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 17

Brent likes his Sears Craftsman 12-volt cordless drill. “It’s unbelievable how handy it is. It saves a lot of trips to the garage. It has enough power that I can use it for a long time.

“My Sears Craftsman 30-gal. 5 hp compressor does a fine job of supplying air without having to work very hard.

“MyDeWalt chop saw can cut through any kind of steel. It’s built tough.”

Sears Craftsman 15 hp riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Edgar R. Rutledge, Oakland City, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 3 (2002), p. 15

“My Sears Craftsman 15 hp riding mower is a hydrostatic drive model equipped with a 42-in. deck. After two years of use the lifter that engages the blades caused me some trouble and was repaired by the company. Apparently there was a design fault.”

Sears Craftsman 17 1/2 hp garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Al Schollenberger, Egg Harbor, N.J. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Al’s had good luck with his 2008 Sears Craftsman 17 1/2 hp garden tractor. “I had used it for only 1 1/2 hours before the blade hit something and a mandrel broke. A company technician came right out and repaired it for free under warranty.”

Sears Craftsman 180-amp welder

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Charles Jennings, Seligman, Mo. · Vol. 42, No. 3 (2018), p. 15

“My 1969 Sears Craftsman 180-amp welder still works like new. All I’ve done to it is to replace the welder’s original electrode cable with one that’s 30 ft. long. They don’t make welders like this any more.”

Sears Craftsman 2 hp 7 1/4-in

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Sam C. Parsons, Sugar Grove, Va. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

Sam says his Sears Craftsman 2 hp 7 1/4-in. Skil saw is his “worst buy”. “I’m a building contractor so I use many different brands of tools. This one didn’t last even one day on the job. I sent it back to the factory for repairs and had to wait about three months to get it back. Then I was able to make only about 10 cuts with it before it blew up again. Again, I had to wait three months to get it back, and this time I got a $45 bill for repairs. That’s when I decided to throw the saw in the trash. I currently use Makita, DeWalt, and Milwaukee tools. No more Sears Craftsman power tools for me.”

Sears Craftsman 2000 LT lawn tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bill Medlin, Shingletown, Calif. · Vol. 38, No. 3 (2014), p. 14

“My 2006 Deere 110 backhoe works exceptionally well and does everything I want it to.

“Six months after I bought my Sears Craftsman 2000 LT lawn tractor it started shutting off for no reason. A Sears rep came out to look at it 6 different times, and finally 1 1/2 years later it was repaired.”

Sears Craftsman 24 hp riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bob Williams, Lebam, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I use my 2005 Sears Craftsman 24 hp riding mower to mow lawns for local disabled vets. I go over 5 to 6 acres every 3 weeks on land that has everything from blackberry briars to mole hills on it. In 7 years I’ve replaced just the battery and a belt and used 2 cans of Fix-A-Flat on the front tires. I think this mower will keep going for at least another 7 years.”

Sears Craftsman 26 hp riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Hal D. Stephens, Solomon, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

A 2004 Sears Craftsman 26 hp riding mower rates as Hal’s “best buy”. “We have a hilly yard but this unit has power to spare and has required only routine maintenance. It cuts even and doesn’t miss any grass between the blades.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2005 McCulloch EZ Pull weedeater. “We used it only twice and then it wouldn’t start. The company gave us another one which worked better, but at times it doesn’t want to run, either. Most of the problem seems to be in the carburetor and the choke system. However, when this weedeater is running it does do a good job of cutting.”

Sears Craftsman 29 cc 4-cycle

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Dustin Jarshaw, Newfolden, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 3 (2010), p. 15

“I bought a used Massey Ferguson Ski Whiz snowmobile last year. This old snowmobile was able to keep up with my friends’ much newer models, and it has plenty of power for pulling my wood sled.

“My Sears Craftsman 29 cc, 4-cycle, gas-powered weed trimmer is my worst buy. After less than an hour of use the pull rope on it broke. Later the muffler screen partially plugged up, causing the piston to seize. I’ll never buy a Craftsman trimmer again.”

Sears Craftsman 2-piece lithium-ion

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bruce G. Hartman, Dansville, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 6 (2012), p. 12

“I like my Sears Craftsman 2-piece lithium-ion C3 drill and impact driver kit. The lithium batteries are much improved over the Ni-Cad batteries. They charge faster, have a battery level indicator, and they provide full power right up until they need to be recharged. I find that buying online at www.ebates.com and then picking up the product at my local Sears store is always much cheaper than buying at the store itself.”

Sears Craftsman 300 amp

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Warren Lathe, Brattleboro, Vt. · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 17

Warren likes his 1996 Morton 54-ft. by 75-ft. building. “It’s attractive and well-constructed with no obstructions or pillars inside which makes it easy to move equipment. I have a sawmill inside that’s opposite a large set of double doors. With the doors open it’s like the sawmill is out in the open - there are no dark areas. The building is equipped with large skylites which add more light.

“My best buy of all time is my Sears Craftsman 300 amp AC welder which I bought in 1950. It was expensive at that time. However, I’ve used it to weld large trailers and all sorts of things over the years and it’s still purring away like new. I wanted to be able to weld out in the field so in 1975 I bought a Lincoln AC-DC unit with 6,000-watt auxillary power. Both welders are best buys. They’re ready for action any time.”

Sears Craftsman 30 LED wand-type rechargeable flashlight

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gale Goff, Chandler Heights, Arizona · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Gale likes his 2008 Sears Craftsman 30 LED wand-type rechargeable flashlight. “It’s very bright and long lasting for its small size. It provides instant emergency light for power failures and for night trips - it’s 500 ft. to our mailbox - and for irrigation inspection and inspection of car and machine problems. It has a hook on one end so it can be used as an under-hood worklight.”

Sears Craftsman 3 1/2 hp direct-drive

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
William Richardson, Hemingway, S.C. · Vol. 37, No. 6 (2013), p. 14

“In 1973 I bought a Sears Craftsman 3 1/2 hp, 12-in. direct-drive table saw. It has always worked well and we still use it constantly. My friends tell me I should have a belt-driven model, but a belt-driven model couldn’t handle what this saw can. It’s built heavy and is a pleasure to operate.

“My 2013 Deere Gator XUV 550 utility vehicle saves a lot of steps. We use it to check our fence lines and our cows. Our grandchildren really like it, too.”

Sears Craftsman 4 hp electric

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Carl from Avon, Conn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“I really like my 2011 Sears Craftsman 4 hp, 18-in. electric chainsaw, which I bought just 6 months ago. It weighs 14 lbs. and is the most powerful electric chainsaw sold by Sears. I replaced the original chain with a PowerSharp self-sharpening chain (ph 800 223-5168; www.powersharp.com), which I bought at a local Sears hardware store.

“The biggest advantage for an electric chainsaw compared to gas models is you don’t have to restart the saw time after time when working on a big project. There are no cold or warm engine problems to deal with. Just pull the trigger and away you go. The saw has a 15-amp power draw so it does draw quite a bit of current.

“I highly recommend this saw for small to medium projects near the house. I use it to cut firewood. It’ll slice up 3-ft. dia. trees with no problems. I’ve had electric chainsaws before, but most were 2 hp models. My 4 hp model has a lot more power, and not much can stop

“The saw is equipped with a tool-less chain adjustment that makes it easy to change the tension or re-attach the chain if it comes off, which doesn’t happen often. There are no tightening screws at all.

“I paid $100 for my chainsaw and liked it so much that I bought a second unit.”

Sears Craftsman 42 cc string trimmer

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Aaron Barneson, Chippewa Falls, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“My Stihl 360 Pro chain saw is lightweight, works fast and smooth, and is powerful. It lets me cut two to three times as much wood in the same amount of time as I could with any other brand.

“My 2002 Sears Craftsman 42 cc string trimmer is my worst buy. It wouldn’t even run when I got it home. I exchanged it for another model, but that model wouldn’t stay running either except at full throttle - it randomly stalled out. I took it to the service department seven different times during the first year - and then the warranty expired. Finally I got rid of it and bought a Stihl FS 200, which has been trouble-free.”

Sears Craftsman 46 cc chainsaw equipped

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
John Hartford, Vienna, W. Va. · Vol. 34, No. 1 (2010), p. 14

“I’m well pleased with my Porter Cable 18-volt multi-pack tool kit. It hasn’t let me down yet. It comes with two batteries so I never run out of power.

“My 2007 Sears Craftsman 46 cc chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar is my worst buy. The first hour a rod broke in the engine. It would’ve cost too much to repair so I junked it. I was very disappointed, to say the least.”

Sears Craftsman 4-piece cordless tool set

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Tracy Howard, Lancing, Tenn. · Vol. 31, No. 3 (2007), p. 13

“It’s a real workhorse,” says Tracy about his 2004 Sears Craftsman 4-piece cordless tool set which includes a flashlight, jigsaw, receptical saw, and sander. “I’ve used these tools to build two porches, a barn, and various other projects. I’ve also helped other people with their projects. These tools work good and stay charged for a long while.

“My remanufactured Yanmar loader tractor is my worst buy. Right before the 4-month warranty expired, the loader hydraulics went out. I was using a box blade when the hitch broke. A ring in the fuel injector system failed which resulted in a loss of compression, and now the hydraulic cylinders on the loader are leaking again.”

Sears Craftsman 6 hp oil-free air

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Ken Gilbertson, Ada, Minn. · Vol. 27, No. 3 (2003), p. 13

“My 1995 Hoelscher small square bale accumulator is my best buy. The design of the machine and the quality of the material it’s built out of, as well as the workmanship that went into it, are all outstanding. No problems.

“My Sears Craftsman 6 hp oil-free air compressor is my worst buy. It was a lot louder than an oil-type compressor, and after the warranty expired a connecting rod in the compressor broke. I took the compressor apart and found that it wasn’t even worth repairing.”

Sears Craftsman 6 1/8-in jointer-planer

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Charles Schilling, Frazee, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 4 (2006), p. 13

“My worst buy is a Sears Craftsman 6 1/8-in. jointer-planer. The motor will operate only if the temperature is 30 degrees F or above -otherwise it just sits there and smokes. I took the unit back to the company but they said there’s nothing wrong with it. They plugged it into an outlet at room temperature and of course everything worked fine. However, it still won’t operate when the temperature is less than 30 degrees. Now I’m stuck with a piece of junk.”

Sears Craftsman 675E wheeled string trimmer

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mark Vroman, Buffalo, S. Dak. · Vol. 38, No. 1 (2014), p. 13

“I like my Sears Craftsman 675E 22-in. wheeled string trimmer. It uses 1/4-in. string that lasts a long time. I use this trimmer to cut 2 to 3-ft. tall weeds around corrals and my barns. It also works well along roadside culverts where I can’t mow with my tractor.

“My 2011 Deere 6115 90 hp loader tractor was underpowered, and tipsy with a loaded bucket. The stick shift transmission, with 3 ranges and 3 gears, was awkward to use. It seemed like I had to shift all the time to match my speed to the job. Also, there was no remote button on the fender to operate the 3-pt. hitch. On the plus side, the tractor was easy on fuel and the loader worked fast. I could use a lever to hook or unhook all 6 loader hoses at once, which I really liked, and the reverser on the steering column also worked well. Now I own a Deere 6430 tractor, which I like.”

Sears Craftsman 7 1/2 hp chipper-shredder

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Edmund Weninger, Billings, Mont. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

Edmund nominates his Sears Craftsman 7 1/2 hp chipper-shredder as his “worst buy”. “This machine works well on small tree limbs, but it won’t handle 3 1/2-in. dia. limbs

Sears Craftsman DT6000 riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Ora Weston, Estherville, Iowa · Vol. 41, No. 4 (2017), p. 13

“The tie rods on my 2015 Sears Craftsman DT6000 riding mower are too weak, which causes the front wheels to toe out and the mower to steer hard. Another problem is the mower deck doesn’t float, so when I’m mowing in ditches it can easily get hung up.”

Sears Craftsman GT garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bill Clark, Caldwell, Ohio · Vol. 42, No. 2 (2018), p. 14

“My 1995 Sears Craftsman GT garden tractor, equipped with a 22 1/2 hp. Kohler engine and 50-in. deck, has been virtually flawless. I built a hitch out of a Mack clutch assembly so I could pull some Wheelhorse attachments that I already had. As a result, I can use the tractor to plow, mow and do grading work. I replaced the engine coils 3 years ago and the deck last year, and now my GT is ready for another 20 years.”

Sears Craftsman GT5000 equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Fred Welton, Grove City, Penn. · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 13

“Best lawn tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Fred about his 2005 Sears Craftsman GT5000 equipped with a 22 hp., 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton engine. “We use it hard to mow light brush and tall grass, and to haul hay on a trailer. We have chains on the tires and a brush bar on front. The battery, blades, and drive belt have been replaced once.”

Sears Craftsman II lawn tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Cameron Messinger, Hummelstown, Penn. · Vol. 38, No. 3 (2014), p. 14

Cameron likes Star Brite Star Tron enzyme gasoline fuel treatment (ph 954 587-6280; www.mystarbrite.com/startron/). “This product is unbelievable. My grandpa had a 1990’s Ford pickup that wouldn’t start due to fuel problems. He put Star Tron in it, and the next day it fired right up. Our neighbor had a practically brand new sidewalk edger that wouldn’t start until I put some Star Tron in it. It’s an awesome product that really works.”

He also likes his 1986 Sears Craftsman II lawn tractor equipped with an 11 hp. Briggs & Stratton engine and a 40-in. deck. “I was given this tractor about 2 years ago and removed the deck so I can use it to pull a home-built, heavy-duty trailer. It can pull a 200-lb. load with no problem. I recently wired the tractor with a 4-way trailer light coupler and also installed a custom exhaust stack. Three of the 4 tires are original; I put some slime in them to prevent any leaks that might happen due to dry rot. It’s a great all-around tractor.”

Sears Craftsman Industrial 13.2-volt 3/8-in cordless

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Joseph Rayna, Stewartsville, N.J. · Vol. 22, No. 4 (1998), p. 14

“My best buy is my 1997 Sears Craftsman Industrial 13.2-volt, 3/8-in. cordless drill/driver. I actually got it as a Christmas present from my wife. It’s one of the most useful and handiest tools in my shop. It has a lot of power and is cordless so I don’t have to drag an extension cord around.”

Sears Craftsman LED flashlight

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Dick Combs, Worth, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman LED flashlight is my best buy. It’s made from stainless steel and rubber and has five bulbs. The ‘on’ button has three settings - bright, brighter, and brightest. It uses four AA batteries, and the first ones I put in months ago are still going strong. It’s a handy, durable flashlight.

“My Cub Cadet 7254 lawn tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower deck is my worst buy. I first time I started it, the belt came off after I went only about 100 ft. I put the belt back on but the same thing happened again. There have also been other problems.”

Sears Craftsman LT1000 17 hp riding mower

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Doug Fedderke, Defiance, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 1975 BCS 10 hp rototiller is my best buy. I bought it used from my brother’s father-in-law. It sat outside for years. All I did was change the oil, spark plug, and filters and it always fires right up. I like being able to change implements on it. I’d definitely buy another one.

“My Sears Craftsman LT1000 17 hp riding mower is my worst buy. It’s on its third transmission and has been a pain from the start. When I let off the clutch I can pop a wheelie in sixth gear. I wouldn’t recommend this mower to anyone.”

Sears Craftsman LT2500 riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bob Ruehling, New Prague, Minn. · Vol. 40, No. 1 (2016), p. 13

“I bought a new Sears Craftsman LT2500 riding mower after my old Craftsman LT2000 caught fire and the wiring burned up. Nothing happened when I started up the new mower because someone had forgot to put the drive belt on. As we cut grass the mower deck swings from side to side as if there’s a part missing. So last winter I rewired the old mower and am now using it again, while the new one sits in a corner of my garage.”

Sears Craftsman Nextec 12-volt lithium ion right

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gary Thomsen, Arion, Iowa · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 15

Gary’s the satisfied owner of a Sears Craftsman Nextec 12-volt lithium ion right angle impact driver. “The lithium battery lasts a long time and works great for drilling holes, driving screws and any job that can be done with a tool equipped with a 1/4-in. hex shank. This is my ‘go to’ tool. With a couple of spare batteries that charge quickly, it can go all day long with no down time.”

Sears Craftsman Nextec 3/8-in drill/driver equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Marrel Bush, Windom, Minn. · Vol. 41, No. 2 (2017), p. 14

“Last summer I bought a used Sears Craftsman Nextec 3/8-in. drill/driver equipped with a lithium ion battery. I’m surprised at how much torque it has and how long the battery lasts on a charge. The drill comes with an integrated LED work light that illuminates your work surface, and I’ve used it a lot more than I expected. I use a Ryobi 1/2-in., 18-volt drill for bigger jobs. Both are good drills.”

Sears Craftsman Robo Grip pliers

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Clifford Burke, Homestead, Fla. · Vol. 27, No. 3 (2003), p. 13

“My 2002 New Holland 29D tractor is well built, easy to service, and comfortable to operate.

“My 2002 Sears Craftsman Robo Grip pliers is my worst buy. It’s a great idea but is poorly made. It twists and bends if any pressure is applied.”

Sears Craftsman VT3000 model

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Bill Wood, Giddings, Texas · Vol. 39, No. 4 (2015), p. 15

“I’m 74 years old and have owned many riding mowers over the years, but my 2013 Sears Craftsman VT3000 42-in. model is the worst. The first time I used this mower the belts came off, and the company repairman said they weren’t assembled properly. The next time I drove it the belts came off again. I called the company and tried to return the machine, but they said since it had been bought more than 30 days ago they wouldn’t take it back. I’ve never been able to finish a mowing job with this mower without a problem. Now it’s broken down again, and we’ve been waiting 3 weeks for a repairman to show up.

“Not long ago I noticed this mower was made by Husqvarna, and if I had known that I wouldn’t have bought it. Sears used to have good products and great customer service. Now they seem to have neither.”

Sears Craftsman YTS 400 riding mower

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Bill Pittman, Bakersville, N.C. · Vol. 37, No. 6 (2013), p. 13

“No problems with my 2009 Sears Craftsman YTS 400 riding mower. I use it a lot to mow about 2 acres of grass, but the V-belts have never been replaced and are still in good condition.

“My 1995 Honda 5013 4-WD garden tractor was equipped with 3 expensive V-belts, and 2 of them had to be replaced 3 times during just one season.”

Sears Craftsman professional model angle

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Wayne W. Harley, New Brighton, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 5 (2008), p. 14

Wayne’s the proud owner of a 2007 Deere 6 by 4 Gator equipped with a gas engine. “Deere finally seems to have the problems resolved with the gas engine they use on their Gators. We had two older Gators that had constant problems with fouled plugs. Our only complaint is the windshield mounting brackets need to be stiffened so the windshield won’t wobble as much.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2007 Sears Craftsman 7-in. professional model angle grinder. “After less than a year of limited use the armature and brushes went bad. Repair parts cost $50. It’s a real disappointment. Craftsman power tools used to be dependable before they started making them in China. This will be my last new Craftsman power tool purchase.”

Sears Craftsman hand tools any

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Don Lasee, Krakow, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 2 (2001), p. 17

“A product called Astro Seal is my best buy. I used it to seal a weeping pto gasket on my semi tractor without having to do any draining or disassembly work. It seals through water or oil and doesn’t harden or crack. It works in temperatures ranging from 50 degrees below zero to 220 above. It’ll seal lead, asphalt, glass, wood, sheet metal, concrete, and all solid surfaces. Whatever you seal is paintable immediately. I liked it so much that I became a dealer.

“My Snap-On hand tools are my worst buy. I’v found Snap-On dealers to be extremely arrogant and they refuse to warrant their tools. Also, their polished wrenches may look impressive but they’re difficult to hang onto when you have oily hands. The company’s screwdrivers twist and their cotter pin puller bends. I’d rather have Sears Craftsman hand tools any day.”

Sears Craftsman bench top belt

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Douglas Brown, Alleman, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“Our 2000 Sophtec water conditioner softens our water magnetically without requiring any salt or electricity. It almost completely eliminates hydrogen sulfide odors. It’s a great product.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Sears Craftsman bench top belt and disc sander. “We didn’t use it for more than a year after we bought it. The first time we used it the motor started smoking. Since the product was more than a year old, the company wouldn’t honor the warranty. I think this sander was defective the day it was made.”

Sears Craftsman titanium-coated drill bits

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Otto Maas, Potter, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 3 (2007), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman titanium-coated drill bits are my worst buy. They come in a metal index box. I paid $100 for the set, but they’re no good at all. After drilling one hole the bits are already dull. The entire set is a piece of junk.”

Sears Craftsman wheeled tool chest

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Eli Yoder, Turbotville, Penn. · Vol. 39, No. 2 (2015), p. 15

“I like my Sears Craftsman wheeled tool chest. Now I can put each tool in its own drawer and push the tool chest to wherever I’m working, instead of hanging the tools on nails. Not many wrenches get mislaid any more.”

Sears Craftsman compressor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Fred Davis, Bigfoot, Texas · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 14

“The 2016 Porter Cable air compressor I bought from Tractor Supply Company came with a one-year warranty, but when the motor failed at 14 mos. the company wouldn’t help. I previously owned a Sears Craftsman compressor that lasted for 30 years with the same level of use.”

Sears Craftsman customer

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Rick Byrne, Tunas, Mo. · Vol. 41, No. 2 (2017), p. 14

“I’ve been a loyal Sears Craftsman customer over the years, but the quality of their products has gone way down. My Sears riding mower has had problems ever since I brought it home. I have 3 different Sears chainsaws but I’ve been told it’s not worth fixing them. I also own a lot of Sears cordless power tools, but the batteries seem to last only about a year. I will no longer shop at Sears.”

Sears Craftsman twin cutter electric

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Garry Janney, Manhattan, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 13

Garry’s impressed with his DR road grader. “I can’t believe how great this grader works on gravel driveways. It does exactly what the company says. They told me to use the grader for six months and that if I didn’t like it, they’d come and pick it up. You can’t beat that for service.”

On the negative side, he lists his Sears Craftsman twin cutter electric saw with double blades. “I used this saw only twice. One of those times, I used it to cut the bottom off an old wood garage door, and the motor up. It’s a great concept, but it’s just not built right. The reviews on the internet agree with me.”

Sears Craftsman riding mower should

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
D.J. Tournillon, Carriere, Miss. · Vol. 38, No. 6 (2014), p. 14

“The deck on my 2013 Sears Craftsman 46-in. riding mower should be built stronger.

“My 2012 Deere 46-in. riding mower started hard and needed numerous repairs.”

Sears Craftsman socket organizer

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Nathan Rand, Marshalltown, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman socket organizer is my worst buy. It came with 12 more sockets than pins, so I ordered 12 pins over the phone. When I found out how much the pins cost, I tried to cancel my order. However, the company said that it was impossible to cancel the order due to the way its computers were set up. I could have purchased another complete socket organizer and still had plenty of money left over for what they charged just for a few measley plastic pins. The company told me I could return the product to a local Sears for store credit. Now I have to use the credit to buy something that I don’t really need, or else keep these grossly over-priced pins.”

Sears Craftsman line trimmer powered

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Rick Boyd, Lexington, Ohio · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“I like my 2001 Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt drill/driver kit. It’s equipped with a light, charger, and two batteries. I’ve used it to remodel many rooms and projects, and it always works flawlessly. It has performed beyond my expectations.

“My Mantis tiller with dethatcher and sidewalk trimmer edger is also a best buy. I bought it used in 1991. This little tiller does a fantastic job in small gardens and flower beds and works great for cultivating. My neighbors use it and they keep wanting to buy it from me. However, it will never be for sale but will be handed down to our kids.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman line trimmer powered by a 32 cc gas engine is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and vibrates bad. I wish I would have spent extra money and bought an Echo or a Stihl.”

Sears Craftsman ratchet

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John L. Kennedy, Seligman, Ariz. · Vol. 34, No. 4 (2010), p. 15

“I like my 2009 Arizona Mfg. 12,000-lb. dump trailer. It’s 12 ft. long with 3-ft. high sides. I don’t haul a lot of stuff any more, but I still need to transport some material in order to maintain my rental properties. My dump truck needed a lot of tender loving care and cost about $1,000 a year just to put it on the road. By pulling the dump trailer behind my pickup, I’m saving about $1,000 in license and insurance and can still haul all I need to.

“My 2007 Sears Craftsman ratchet had to be returned several times for repairs. I like Craftsman tools, but their little cheap ratchet sets come with a round headed ratchet that fails about every third use. When I took the ratchet back I found they had a drawer full of them. They gave me a refurbished one but I got only about three uses out of it, and then I had to go back to the store again. I tried to trade up and pay the difference, but they refused.”

Sears Craftsman rototiller

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Jerry Byrn, Brashear, Mo. · Vol. 43, No. 3 (2019), p. 15

“The second year I used my Sears Craftsman rototiller, a bearing in the gearbox failed. The gearbox is made so that there’s no way to lubricate it. Unfortunately, the company wanted almost as much for a new gearbox as what I paid for the rototiller.”

Sears Craftsman self-powered key start

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Barry Williams, Humboldt, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 2 (2010), p. 14

“My 2008 Kubota B7800 loader tractor is my best buy. I use it with a belly mower to mow about a half acre of woods and also to blade snow and move dirt. It always starts, even below zero.

“We had to do a lot of re-landscaping work last year and this tractor saved me a lot of back problems. We also use it when we cut firewood.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2007 Sears Craftsman self-powered key start riding mower.

“It’s too heavy and doesn’t do a good job of lifting and cutting the grass. Also, the bag isn’t big enough. I ended up repairing our old Ahrens push mower. It cuts better and holds more clippings and is generally a much better mower.”

Sears Craftsman garden tractor

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Fred Cailey, Batavia, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

“In your last issue, Bill Reeks of Cromwell, Ky., said he had problems with the front axle and spindle on his 2001 Sears Craftsman garden tractor. He ended up rebuilding the broken axle by clamping it back together and welding it properly. So when the front axle failed on our 1998 Sears Craftsman garden tractor, I was disappointed but not surprised.

“Following Reeks’ experience, I can confirm that Sears does not make a heavy duty axle to replace their standard production front axle. The standard axle is part number 154427 and costs $32.99. This axle is made of two pressed steel halves that are about 0.100 in. thick and are joined together with intermittent welds along the seams where the two halves mate. It appears that the axle on our garden tractor failed in about the same location as did the axle on Reeks’ tractor - at a high stress point at the end of one of the intermittent welds on the lower left side of the axle.

“After making several phone calls to the company, I ended up talking to a gentleman in the ‘research department.’ He said there was no history of failed axles except on tractors that had been abused, and that some of the newer Sears tractors did have cast front axles. At a local Sears store I found that the larger Sears tractors do have cast front axles, but the tractor on display that was similar to our tractor had a front axle like ours. I don’t believe our tractor was ever abused, but perhaps Sears wants to equate failure to abuse -‘If the axle fails, it means the tractor has been abused.’

“Like Mr. Reeks, I repaired the axle by welding the failed area and adding some dou-blers. If I end up having to buy a Sears replacement axle, I will completely weld the full length of the seam between the two axle halves. I believe this simple step will greatly improve the integrity of the axle.”

Sears Craftsman power washer

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Heide, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“After 19 years, our Morton buildings still look like new. Also, our 1991 MacDon 7000 swather cuts and works well in our tough Montana wild hay, but the paint and decals are in terrible shape. Our Deere 468 baler is an excellent baler that makes good bales and never misses tying.”

On the other hand, he doesn’t like his Sears Craftsman power washer. “If we’d known there is no way to drain it, we wouldn’t have bought it. They say you have to store it in a warm place to prevent damage form freezing.”

Sears Craftsman 2-wheeled weed

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Stanley W. Wisnloski, Jr., Cottondale, Fla. · Vol. 39, No. 5 (2015), p. 13

“I used my 2003 Kubota LA 211 frontend loader almost every day to haul hay and feed bags and do other chores. I’m 82 years old and couldn’t do without this loader. It saves me a mountain of work.

“I own a 2012 Sears Craftsman 22-in., 2-wheeled weed trimmer but don’t use it much because the plastic cutters on it continually break off. It’s not worth the trouble to replace them.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW