Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005)

64 reports from pages 12–15 · 51 Best Buys20 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Gentle Leader head collar

Jim Ruen, Lanesboro, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My Gentle Leader head collar works like a charm on my 70-lb. German Shepherd cross (www.gentleleader.com; ph 888 640-8840). With any other lead, let him see a deer, and he’s gone like a ton of bricks over the side of the road, and you’re along for the ride. With the Gentle Leader, I think a deer could walk past his nose, and he wouldn’t move. The head collar isn’t a muzzle, but rather applies pressure to the back of the head and around the muzzle. It restrains him without hurting him in any way.”

Best Buy

Kubota BX1500 tractor equipped + 1 more

R. Kennedy Davis, Imperial, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My 2003 Kubota BX1500 tractor equipped with a 48-in. mower and Meg-Mo mower blades is my best buy (www.meg-mo.com; ph 815 625-0125). I’ve owned a lot of small tractors over the years, but this one is the best yet. I use it to cut my two acres of lawn and also to mow for two of my sons next door, cutting a total of six acres. It uses only 1 1/2 gal. of fuel each week and, because of the Meg-Mo blades, I don’t have to sweep the lawn any more. They mulch everything up. The tractor has a comfortable ride and is easy to get on and off. I have bad legs but have no problem getting on and off this tractor. My doctor told me I would never be able to operate a tractor again but I fooled him with my Kubota.” it.

Best Buy

Troybilt rototiller

Brian D. Gardiner, Mallorytown, Ontario · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My Troybilt rototiller is the best rototiller I’ve ever owned. It can break up sod in only three passes, leaving a seedbed that’s ready to plant. It takes only one hand to operate this unit with ease. I haven’t had any problems with the body of this machine. However, it’s powered by a 6 hp Tecumseh engine and every time I use it I have to adjust the carburetor just to keep it running. Another problem is that the governor keeps blowing out, causing the engine to run wide open. The new TroyBilt tillers use Briggs and Stratton or Honda engines, and I wish this one did, too. This will be the last Tecumseh engine I’ll ever own. I operate mainly Briggs & Stratton and some Honda engines in my other equipment with no problems.”

Best Buy

Bombardier Traxter XT ATV

James Symynyshen, Arborg, Manitoba · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My 2002 Bombardier Traxter XT ATV is my best buy. It’s easy to get on and off, has a lot of power, and the 4-wheel drive is terrific. It has a big 22-liter gas tank and is a fuel efficient machine. I use it on my farm like a small tractor.”

Best Buy

New Holland TR 86 combine + 1 more

David Richburg, Manning, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“I bought a 1991 New Holland TR 86 combine used three years ago and it’s my best buy. This combine now has more than 3,000 hours on it and has many more to go. It’s easy to service and repair and also easy to operate. My dealer said it’s painted yellow to be seen and be proud of.

“My Sleep Number mattress lives up to its claims. I sleep good on it all night long, waking up able to get out of bed with little stiffness. It’s much more comfortable than our old mattress because it’s filled with air and can easily be adjusted. My wife agrees with me. We really like it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 2210 4-WD compact tractor equipped + 1 more

Dennis Eft, Secor, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My 2004 Deere 2210 4-WD compact tractor equipped with a 23 hp, 3-cyl. diesel engine is a real workhorse. I bought it equipped with a quick-tach front-end loader and a quick-tach bucket, which comes as standard equipment. All the control levers for it are well placed. This tractor turns as sharp as a garden tractor and will go almost anywhere that a garden tractor will go.”

He says his 1999 Ford F-250 4-WD 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a Power Stroke diesel engine and automatic transmission is his “worst buy”. “It has more than 112,000 miles on it but is a poor excuse for a 3/4-ton truck. I previously owned 1995 and 1996 models equipped with Power Stroke engines and they were built much better. This model has far less power and less load carrying capacity. The only improvement it offers is in ride quality, but it comes at the expense of load capacity.”

Best Buy

Easley yearling

Chris Mathison, Grand Cherries, La. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My Easley ‘yearling model’ livestock trailer is the best built livestock trailer I’ve ever been around, and I’ve been around quite a few. Whoever designed it must have had a lot of experience working with cattle on horseback. All the parts that may need to be replaced through the years are designed so that the entire trailer doesn’t have to be taken apart in order to change them out. The handy features of this trailer are too many to mention.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 1500 2-WD pickup equipped + 1 more

Mark S. Yax, Solon, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“I like my 2004 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 2-WD pickup equipped with a 5.3-liter V-8 engine with 295 hp. It’s equipped with a towing package with a 3:73 rear end and has an 8,400-lb. tow rating. It gets 18 mpg on average and rides like a full-size luxury car. Even when it’s loaded up it can pull my trailer and ATV effortlessly. I couldn’t be happier with

“I’m a little disappointed with my 2003 Saturn Vue all-wheel-drive SUV equipped with an automatic transmission. It has only about 17,000 miles on it but already the front rotors have had to be turned. The ignition switch binds up and has been repaired three times. The transmission occasionally misses when shifting between second and third gear. The dealer tried to solve the problem but couldn’t. I was planning on buying this car after the lease is up. Now that decision will depend on whether the car has any more problems.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4020 tractor

Russ Markley, Wheeler, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“In 1965 I bought a new Deere 4020 tractor and it’s my best buy. I replaced the engine 20 years ago, but the rear end, transmission, and hydraulic pump have never been touched. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance and replacement of belts, alternators, tires and batteries. Nowadays I use it mainly for loader work.”

Worst Buy

Polaris 700 Sportsman ATV

Lonny Collins, Osakis, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 12

“My 2003 Polaris 700 Sportsman ATV is my worst buy. The base gasket went out, allowing antifreeze to leak into the crankcase. This problem happened on my son’s ATV and also on units owned by two of my neighbors. All of them are 2003 models. The company won’t admit the machines have this problem. Now I know why they come with only a 6-month warranty.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 pickup equipped

Cornie Van Lant, Chandler, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My 2004 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my best buy. It has a lot of power and handles nice, and it’s fuel efficient. I had a 1996 Dodge 1500 which was great, too, but this one works even better. It’s a great pickup.”

Best Buy

SM Iron

Don Prohaska, Kasson, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My best buy is a 7-ft. wide skid loader bucket made by SM Iron. We installed a 1 1/4-in. rod along the edge of the cutting blade. This way I can clean manure off our cement pad and when the blade hits cracks it just goes over them instead of jamming into them. It also works great for moving snow, because I can tip the bucket down to the grass and clean the snow off without doing any harm. Works great.”

Worst Buy

Kuhn mower

Robert W. Nielsen, Council Bluffs, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My Kuhn mower is my worst buy. It cuts good and is a low maintenance machine. It’s supposed to be easy to hook up but it’s not. After the dealer brought it out I spent about three hours trying to hook it up. Then I called the dealer, who sent out a salesman. The two of us used a pair of tractor jacks and finally got it on, only to find out that the pto shaft was too long. So at my expense, a repair man came out and cut the shaft off. The mower’s 3-pt. hook-up is about 2 ft. off when the mower is unhooked on one side.”

Worst Buy

Billy Goat self-propelled walk-behind lawn

Zack Evans, Somerville, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My 2004 Billy Goat self-propelled walk-behind lawn mower is my worst buy. It has a three-chambered mower deck that clogs almost immediately, even in medium length dry grass and when traveling at the slowest speed. Any conditions more challenging than that, don’t even bother. The mounting bolts for the blade carriers protrude into the deck chambers, which obstructs the discharge and makes cleaning it out a real hassle. The hand-operated controls are configured so that you have to keep both hands on the machine in order to keep mowing. As a result, if you want to swat a fly or wipe sweat out of your eyes you have to come to a complete stop. I can’t imagine what the designers of this machine were thinking. Do they ever try these things out in real conditions? This machine might possibly make a good boat anchor, but as a lawn mower, it’s worthless.”

Worst Buy

Husqvarna riding mower

William D. Strock, Bland, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My Husqvarna riding mower is my worst buy. The mower collects cut grass on the deck and drops it out in clumps or collects it until it will no longer cut. I continually have to stop and clean the grass from under the deck. Having to stop and clean grass out from under the deck is bad enough, but this mower is also a safety hazard. I’ve broken four blades, and when a blade breaks it gets thrown out about 20 ft. I no longer allow anyone in my yard while I’m mowing due to this hazard. When I broke the first blade I asked the dealer if this was a common problem, and he answered yes. I contacted the manufacturer but they showed no interest. They told me to take the mower to my dealer, but they wouldn’t pay for the dealer to look at it.”

Best Buy

Whitfield Quest pellet stove + 1 more

Kevin West, Covington, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“I converted my Whitfield Quest pellet stove to burn shelled corn simply by fabricating a burn bucket out of stainless perforated metal (Climate Control Systems, Oakhurst, Calif.; www.hearthtools.com). By turning air flow up a bit and setting the heat setting to medium, we’ve had excellent results. We manually remove the clinkers every day. The fire can be restarted with a handful of wood pellets and a propane torch. I can make a full-scale shop drawing available.

“My Tri-Star 4 1/2-in. flex-wheel grinding wheel is a best buy (Cronatron Welding Systems, ph 800 843-0763). These wheels cut quickly and leave a smooth finish. They also seem to last longer than some other grinding wheels on the market.”

Best Buy

Fieldstar yield sensor + 1 more

Duane Dietz, Owatonna, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

He’s sold on the new Fieldstar yield sensor from Agco. It replaced a sensor that was only a year old.

“Calibration was simple and easy. I compared the sensor data with a weigh wagon after one pass, made an adjustment, and on the next pass the two were within 0.8 of a pound. When I had an Ag Leader system from Case-IH, we considered ourselves lucky if we were within 3 to 5 percent. My co-op agronomist rode along and was amazed. He calibrates all kinds of yield monitors and told me this is the most accurate monitor he’s ever seen.”

Dietz likes his R65 Gleaner, too. Usually he trades combines every two years because of the Gleaner warranty and the great service his dealer (Isaacson Implement, Nerstrand, Minn.) gives him. “Steve from Isaacson’s comes out and fixes things that I don’t even know need fixing because they are under warranty.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 410 baler

Tom Lamont, Maidstone, Sask. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“I must hold the world record for breaking gearbox input shafts on a Deere 410 baler. I’ve owned this baler since it was new and have broken three shafts. After installing a steady bearing as close as possible to the clutch assembly, I discovered the problem had been caused by the improper machining of the clutch assembly. It had a wobble that caused it to wear.

“I found another clutch setup at a salvage yard which is closer to true, but not perfect. It was interesting to see that the original clutch friction plate had less wear than the one on my salvage part so I didn’t abuse it.

“Other complaints: the chain drive to the upper belt rollers was too light. I’ve replaced the single row no. 60 chain with a double row chain which has worked well. The upper belts have never tracked well. Why isn’t there an adjustment similar to a combine pickup? The 12-in. belts wore too quickly so I bought a set of four 8-in. belts, which should get away from the short lacing life caused by chaff build-ups behind the wider belts.

“Why isn’t there a rotating belt guide on the upper belts just above the compression roll, similar to the one on the lower belts? Forage gets between the side plates, pushing the outer belts into the center.

“When one lays out the extra money for green paint, one expects the engineering to be done already. If I could afford it, this baler would be treated to a paint job to match the color of the rims.

“Why do I keep this embarrassment to the engineering profession? Well, I’m scared to buy something else in case it’s worse. And to be truthful, this baler has made a lot of good bales over the years.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5400 4-WD tractor

Michael J. Young, Clinton, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“I thought my Deere 5400 4-WD tractor was a best buy, but now I’m not so sure. This tractor does a good job cutting, baling hay, bush hogging, and doing some light loader work. It also can pull my offset harrow easier than the larger Ford 7700 tractor it replaced. I bought the tractor new, and it now has 850 hours on it. Recently the clutch seems not to disengage completely. When the clutch is depressed, the tractor’s forward motion stops but when changing gears it grinds into the next gear. The longer the clutch stays in neutral the harder it is to get into gear again. I’ve been told the splined shaft that the clutch disk rides on my be dirty or rusty, causing the disk to stick on one side and drag. This tractor is used only by my dad and me and it hasn’t been abused. I don’t think the clutch should be worn out this soon. It’s adjusted with the proper free play, and has adjustment left. I’d like to hear from anyone who has had similar problems with this model tractor, or about a way to lubricate the clutch shaft.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tundra Xtra cab pickup + 1 more

Edwin W. Ruff, Moses Lake, Wash. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My 2000 Toyota Tundra Xtra cab pickup is my best buy. It drives nice, especially on long drives. The 4.7-liter engine has adequate power and I can expect 19 mpg. It’s comfortable to drive and rides nice. It has about 70,000 miles on it with no problems. I’ve always been a Ford man but this pickup makes me think different.

“My Yardman leaf vacuum and mulcher is a best buy. It works great with no problems. I converted it to a self-propelled model. I had been using a Toro leaf vacuum which was absolutely worthless. I had it one month and the company told me it’s my rig. No warranty at all. I sent it back to them and never heard any more about it. I was stuck with the whole price of it. No more Toros for me.”

Worst Buy

Howse 3-pt mounted rotary

Larry Hopkins, Hurley, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

Larry’s disappointed with his Howse 3-pt. mounted, 6-ft. rotary cutter. “First the pto shaft twisted so bad that I couldn’t slide it in or out. Then the U-joints on the pto shaft broke, and I ended up having to replace the entire pto shaft with a heavy duty shaft. Then the stump jumper warped. Next, one of the blades flew off. The transmission continually loosens up from the frame. Finally, the transmission gears stripped.”

Best Buy

Bixby corn burning stove + 1 more

Kevin Holst, Eldridge, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My Bixby corn burning stove is my best buy. It’s clean, trouble-free, nice looking, and requires very little maintenance. It dumps clinkers from the fire pot into the ash pan automatically so I only have to empty the ash pan once a week. It starts the corn on fire automatically with the touch of a button. It can’t quite heat our huge 150-year-old farm house on the coldest days, but it has saved me a lot of money on propane for my house furnace. I think every farmer should have one.

“My 1994 White 6215 with FWA is my best buy. I bought it used and really love it. It’s quiet, has a lot of power and traction, great lights, a roomy cab, and a Cummins engine that starts right up even in cold weather. The 18-speed powershift transmission is easy to use, and I don’t even need the clutch to start up.”

Worst Buy

Country Home Products 18 hp wood chipper

Elias Burr Nyberg, Stow, Ma. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 13

“My Country Home Products 18 hp wood chipper is my worst buy. The company says this chipper can take up to a 4-in. dia. piece of wood. However, the first time I used the machine it bunged up so tight that I had to totally dismantle it in order to get it un-clogged. I thought maybe I had used branches that were too big or too wet so I was real careful the next time I used the machine. I fed in 1-in. dia. branches that were very dry. However, the branches wound around the sprocket and nothing came out. I tried feeding in one more piece but the branch went in and never came out, leaving another solid mass of compacted branches.

“This time I called the company and they tried telling me I had used branches that were too wet or too big. I told them I was going to crate up the entire feeder assembly for them to correct and then return to me. They agreed and did clean out the feeder assembly and returned it to me without charge. However, I still had the same problem.

“I don’t understand why anyone would buy this machine, nor do I understand how the company can keep it on the market. There’s no inspection cover to remove if branches or twigs clog up the blades, which means several hours of work to dismantle the machine every time it jams up. Although the company tried to help, and they agreed the design could have been better, this is one machine I’d never recommend to anyone. I’d like to buy their wood splitter, but I’m reluctant to after the design faults I’ve seen in this machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester + 2 more

Matthew Platt, Roxbury, Ct. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“All of our six International Harvester and 23 Case tractors have worked well over the years with no major problems. Three of them have more than 8,000 hours and are still used regularly on our dairy farm.

“Our 1992 Agco Allis 6680 2-WD tractor equipped with a cab is our worst buy. We purchased this tractor through a local dealer intending to use it mostly as a chore tractor. It had been factory reworked with low hours and some remaining warranty. It was the first tractor with a cab we had ever owned. It came with an electric heater which never worked more than one month at a time. The warranty covered two repairs to it, then we were on our own. The tractor wouldn’t start if the temperature got below 20 degrees. The dealer installed an ether assist, but it didn’t work because there wasn’t enough battery to turn it over. So I added a second one.

“This tractor had radial tires on it, and when pulling a manure spreader in snow it shook so bad, when the tires would spin that it broke a cab mount and also took out a brake line. The drawbar mounts would loosen or break off every couple of months. The front wheel bearings were insert-type ball bearings that would last only 300 to 400 hours before they broke, and then the wheel would fall off.

“The last straw was when an employee caught the front wheel on an obstacle 2 ft. in front of the parked tractor. It broke the bolster and the front part of the engine block. When we priced parts, we found that a bare block would have cost about $4,000 and complete engine $7,500, and neither was in the country. The dealer said he could weld it back together, but it ended up costing as much as a new engine and still leaked oil. We put it in an auction and walked away. It was the sor-riest excuse for a real tractor I’ve ever seen. It was cheaply built, noisy, and it couldn’t pull a hen off a nest.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 19-volt drill/driver

Brian C. Harp, Blossvale, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman 19-volt drill/driver is my best buy. In the spring I found myself needing a new cordless drill for around the farm. One of its first jobs was to operate a fertilizer spreader. I used it to unload 3,000 lbs. of leftover fertilizer by hooking it to the spreader’s ground drive shift. It did it all on one battery. I was impressed. In the fall we used it while putting together a friend’s 12 by 24-ft. steel building. We installed about 2,500 bolts yet went through only two batteries. I use it every day and have been happy with it. It’s an excellent tool at an affordable price.”

Best Buy

Allis-Chalmers 6070 2-WD tractor + 1 more

R. Costello, Rome, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My 1985 Allis Chalmers 6070 2-WD tractor starts every time and is fuel efficient. It has about 2,000 hours on it.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2002 Chevrolet Trail Blazer. “It has only about 60,000 miles on it, but already I’ve replaced an air conditioner, alternator, power steering pump, rear brakes, and a 4-WD selector switch. Also, the rear window leaks.”

Worst Buy

Ram 2500 heavy duty 4-wd

Shawn Mangham, Mullin, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

Shawn’s had problems with his 2005 Dodge 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. “I couldn’t get the air conditioner to work so I took the vehicle back to the dealer. However, they said they wouldn’t fix it because there was a hole in the condensor and it wasn’t covered by the warranty. It would have cost more than $600 to repair. Since I couldn’t prove the hole was already there when I bought the vehicle, they wouldn’t fix it. I felt the vehicle’s bumper to bumper warranty should have covered the repair cost. The company didn’t seem to care, either. I wouldn’t recommend the company to anyone.”

Best Buy

Subaru Forester

Gary Alfoud, Edwardsburg, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“A friend asked me to service his 2002 Subaru Forester. I was amazed how easy it is to service this vehicle and how well it’s made. It even has a spin-on oil filter for the automatic transmission and a drain plug on the transmission. Also, one large plug at the bottom of the motor drains the whole cooling system. And at 27 mpg it’s fuel efficient, too.”

Best Buy

Future Forestry Products

Derek Suursoo, Chester, Vt. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

Derek nominates a log hand cart manufactured by Future Forestry Products of Willamina, Ore., as his “best buy” (ph 888 258-1445; www.futureforestry.com). “This logging arch is capable of being towed by a tractor, let down a steep slope on a winch line, or being pulled by hand. It does all these things very well. It’ll handle 24-in. logs with ease and is extremely well built. I definitely got my money’s worth. This is one of very few products I’ve ever bought that works better than advertised.”

Best Buy

Kroil industrial strength penetrating

R. W. Ellis, Seymour, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

He likes to use Kroil industrial strength penetrating oil to loosen frozen metal parts (Kano Laboratories, Nashville, Tenn. ph 615 833-5790; www.kanolabs.com). “It penetrates into 1 millionth inch spaces to dissolve rust and lubricate quickly. According to the company, as long as the surface is wet with Kroil it won’t corrode. It’s available in aerosol cans that squirt a stream 3 ft. The company also offers a wide variety of other lubrication products.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram D250 pickup equipped + 3 more

Don Wheeler, Columbiaville, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

A 1989 Dodge D250 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine rates as Don’s “best buy”. “I bought my first model in 1990 and drove it about 475,000 trouble-free miles. The body was starting to wear out so I bought another one in 2003 which now has about 150,000 miles on it. It’s a good truck.

“I like Gibbs penetrating oil. It will loosen rust and oxidation better than anything else on the market.

“My Lanair waste oil burner is by far my worst buy. I was never able to use it for a full day without a problem. The company would do nothing but charge 10 times the value of replacement parts. We offered to sell the machine back to them, but they didn’t want it, either. We finally replaced it with a Clean Burn model, which is an excellent machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Speedrite SP 580 electric fencer + 1 more

Henry Worrall, Newcastle, Ontario · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“One of my best buys is a Speedrite SP 580 electric fencer. We’ve used it for more than 20 years and it has had only one problem, which happened when lightning hit it.

“My Staffix M3 electric fencer is my worst buy. I bought it as a backup and put it into use while the Speedrite was being repaired. However, it lasted just five months and then failed. Since I had bought the unit three years before I needed to use it, the warranty had already expired. I took it to a local repairman, but after a month he still couldn’t fix the problem. He had another one there with the same symptoms that he had been trying to repair.”

Best Buy

Stickler log splitter

David Downey, Jonesboro, Ga. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My Stickler log splitter is more than a best buy (CDK Quality Products, Enumclaw, Wa. Ph 360 802-4366 or 206 387-5084; www.thestickler.com). I bought it at a flea market for $25 about 10 years ago, and I’ve modified the wheel mount for several trucks. It can be dangerous to work with, as any moving thing is, but with proper use and a kill switch I’ve used it to split numerous cords of wood without a single accident.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller

Chris Kornkven, Helenville, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“I noticed in the Vol. 29, No. 1 issue of FARM SHOW that a reader had a problem with his Mantis rototiller. I bought one and had used it extensively for about 18 months and thought it was an incredible machine. It chews through dirt easily and quickly. I also bought the dethatcher and it works great for power raking gravel from the lawn back onto the driveway.

“However, after about 18 months it started lagging, and then it wouldn’t stay running. I took it apart several times and even cleaned the carburetor, but nothing I did would solve the problem. Eventually I got through to the company and was quickly given the correct settings for the carburetor, then was told about the spark arrestor screen in the muffler. I was told if it was plugged, the tiller wouldn’t run.

“Sure enough, I took the muffler apart again, cleaned the spark arrestor screen, and the machine has been running great since then. I think the spark arrestor is some requirement for California, so it’s a newer addition to small engines, and worth looking at for other small engine problems.”

Best Buy

Dodges come

Robert G. Wright, Mansfield, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“We’ve owned many trucks of all makes, new and used, and all were good buys, but for reliability and service the Dodges come out on top. They have style and performance and require fewer repairs. Our 2004 Hemi is the best yet.”

Best Buy

Farmall 460 tractor keeps

Wayne Swartz, Uniontown, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“Our old Farmall 460 tractor keeps on going just like the Energizer Bunny. I used the tractor hard for 30 years. It’s smooth, quiet, and vibration-free. It’s not a powerhouse but it runs great and is quite economical for a gas tractor.”

Best Buy

Notch Mfg

Ron L. Kettler, Sauk Centre, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My Notch Mfg. (Paynesville, Minn.) fifth wheel hay trailer is a best buy. It has a battery-operated hydraulic system and the ‘floor’ is made of 6-in. steel rollers so when the bed is raised the bales slide off. It pulls down the road real well and saves a lot of time.”

Worst Buy

Outback S

K. Wayne Williams, Souris, Manitoba · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My Outback S and 360 guidance system is my worst buy. We installed this unit on our tractor and air seeder in the spring of 2004. The unit would hold its accuracy for a short period of time and then suddenly be off course, sometimes by several feet. The company changed just about every component, but we were left with embarrassing misses in the field.

“The most frustrating part is that the company won’t take the unit back, but instead has put pressure on the salesman to buy it back. I made a deal with the salesman in the fall of 2004 to resell the unit, but as of last spring he was trying to back out of the deal and convince us to keep the unit, which is now gathering dust in a closet.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5205 MFWD tractor equipped

Bruce Johnson, Osage, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 14

“My 2004 Deere 5205 MFWD tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine and a 521 front-end loader is my best buy. It has almost 90 hours on it. I use a high volume 84-in. bucket that I’ve loaded full with stones but it still has enough hydraulic power to handle it. This tractor always starts and has excellent fuel efficiency. I can easily go 20 to 30 hours on a thankful of gas under moderate work loads. I live in a hilly region with slopes of 45 degrees and steeper where 4-WD is a must. This tractor’s controls are conveniently located and it has a good top end speed of 17 mph depending on tire size.

“However, this tractor could use a few improvements. The brake lock is difficult to disengage, and the gear shift transmission is difficult to shift while moving in high range without grinding the gears. The loader cylinders retract at different speeds whenever I try to hook up the quick-tach bucket. I contacted the dealer and he said this was normal, but I disagree. I think a seal is leaking on the rod but I haven’t looked into it yet.

“The tractor had a coolant leak at 75 hours, but the cause turned out to be a hose clamp that had been super tightened, deforming the hose a little. The noise from the diesel engine is so loud that I have to use hearing protection. The telescoping drawbar is difficult to move in and out. The bucket tilt cylinders seem slow, but this could also be due to a leaking cylinder seal.”

Worst Buy

Dove Tec corn stove

Jim Johnston, Flesherton, Ontario · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My 2004 Dove Tec corn stove is my worst buy. The stove plugged up. I had to dismantle it to get the auger out. The door wouldn’t shut tight due to poor manufacturing. The house filled with corn soot. I had to have the house and carpets cleaned. The company said I should see my salesman, but the distributor said they don’t sell them any more. I ended up selling this year-old stove for scrap.”

Best Buy

Bobcat lawn mower

Joel Pominville, Middlebury, Vt. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My best buy is a 2002 zero-turn Bobcat lawn mower. It lets me mow our lawn in half the time we previously spent. I rigged up a weed whipper and mounted it on the side of the machine. I use it to clear grass under miles of high tensile fences. It’s almost indestructible.”

Best Buy

Vicon rotary mower

Jack Wilson, Eldridge, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My 2004 Vicon rotary mower is my best buy. It cuts good at lower rpm’s than most rotary mowers and only requires a 42 hp tractor to power it. It has three cutter blades per disc compared to two blades per disc on most mowers. This lessens the cutting amount per blade, which lessens the power needed to turn the blades.

“This mower’s only problem is that it’s hard to maintain an even cutting height above ground. I solved this problem by making an outer cutterbar shoe from a tandem disc. I turned the cupped area up toward the cutterbar with a makeshift bracket on the disc to mount on the regular cutterbar bolts. The reason I used a disc was to provide a sled runner surface in every direction.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 1 more

Robert Anderson, Newell, Ala. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“I like my 2001 Ford F-150 pickup. I use it for heavy hauling, dragging trailers through mud, etc. No problems after 125,000 miles. It has required only routine maintenance.

“My 1998 Toyota pickup, which I bought used, is my worst buy. The original owner told me he had problems but thought they were all fixed. They were, but I got a lot of new ones from the transmission to the water pump, all before the pickup reached 100,000 miles.”

Worst Buy

Polaris 700 4-wheeler ATV

Richard Pickar, Sebeka, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My 2002 Polaris 700 4-wheeler ATV is my worst buy. I bought it in October 2002 and parked it in the garage for the winter. In the spring of 2004, with about 800 miles on it, the water pump seal went out and last spring it went out again. The company wouldn’t help at all.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mac Don 4000 windrower + 2 more

Wayne Manthey, Big Bend, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My most recent best buys have been used machinery. My Mac Don 4000 windrower runs smooth, is easy to adjust and maintain. It also does a superior job of conditioning hay.

“My Westendorf WL-42 front-end loader is built heavy and goes on and off the tractor easily. The quick-tach bucket allows for many different attachments like a bale fork or pallet fork to be used easily.

“My 1999 Corn Pro 25 plus 5 tandem dually gooseneck flatbed trailer is my worst buy. After about 1 1/2 years I noticed that it leaned to one side. Further inspection revealed that a bent I beam was used in the main frame. I could tell it was bent because the horizontal channels weren’t even touching the I beam when it was welded together. The assemblers at the factory had to have seen this, also. The fact that they still put it together and rolled it out the door shows me they have virtually no quality control. They did a nice job of painting this trailer, but I think a high school shop class could have done a better job of selecting materials and welding them together.

“I complained to the company but it didn’t help. They seem to have a policy of not talking to their customers or their dealers. That’s a convenient policy to have when you build substandard equipment.”

Best Buy

He says he’s happy with the 4M trimmer he mounted on the Dixie Chopper

Mike Johnson of Clarkton, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

He says he’s happy with the 4M trimmer he mounted on the Dixie Chopper riding mower he uses to mow a local cemetery. He first read about it in FARM SHOW (Vol. 29, No. 2). “It saves me so much time. I know a good quality product when I see one, and this one is designed perfectly. I would definitely recommend it to anyone.”

A self-contained hydraulic pump powers the attachment that mounts on one side of the deck of all types of riding mowers. (4M Inc., Martinsville, Va. ph 866 623-8264: www.4mtrimmers.com).

Best Buy

I’m a longtime subscriber to FARM SHOW and keep a lot of the more rece

Gary Resch, St. Cloud, Minn · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

I’m a longtime subscriber to FARM SHOW and keep a lot of the more recent issues on hand. Not only do I think FARM SHOW is a best buy, but so do my three grand children, ages 11 to 16. Every time they come over to our home, right away they all tear into the magazines. Sometimes they even fight over who gets to read the latest issue. Just like me, they enjoy reading about all the different ideas and inventions.”

Worst Buy

Some of my worst buys include: ATV’s that don’t have spin-on oil filte

George Schneider, Pioneer, Calif. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“Some of my worst buys include: ATV’s that don’t have spin-on oil filters; equipment that engineer/designers never even tried to use; high gas prices and presidential candidates that ignore the problem; judges that make decisions based on politics rather than law; underpowered trucks with a long turning radius; and faucets that freeze in 20 degree temperatures.”

Best Buy

Kendall Roetman

Jack Kaschmitter, Paynesville, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My best buy is the ‘full fingered’ auger modification kit offered by Kendall Roetman for IH 1020 series bean platforms and featured in FARM SHOW’s Vol. 28, No. 1 issue (Hospers, Iowa ph 712 230-1831). The addition of the fingers helps feed the crop in much better, and it lets me slow the reel speed down and also raise the reel above the sickle. I do some custom harvesting of soybeans with two combines and had both heads modified right before harvest. Kendall offers a 3-minute video on CD that shows the working of a bean head.”

Best Buy

International Harvester 1450 Cub Cadet tractor equipped

Leon Rasbeck, Wolcott, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My 1978 International 1450 Cub Cadet tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission is my best buy. I bought it used at an auction in 1991. It came equipped with a snow blower, a lawn mower, and a cab. I made a blade for it and also a wheelbarrow tray that dumps on back. The 1450 was starting to show wear so in 2001 I bought an 1864 model. I thought I would sell the 1450 but then, on second thought, I figured I wouldn’t get much for it. I’m glad I kept it because it has more than paid for itself.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 1155 tractor + 1 more

Bob Simpson, Gallivan, Sask. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My 1976 Massey Ferguson 1155 tractor is my best buy. It always starts right up, even in cold weather. I use it for just about everything on my farm including combining, cultivating, spraying, and swathing. The only thing I don’t like about this tractor is the tilting cab.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 1979 Massey Ferguson 2745 is a terrible tractor. The engine doesn’t match the transmission, and the transmission doesn’t match the rear end. The only good thing about this tractor is the cab. It offers a good view.”

Best Buy

Echo 1100 Weed Eater + 1 more

Norman Ellis, Maypearl, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“I like my 1993 Echo 1100 Weed Eater . It’s 12 years old but I just put my first spark plug in it and also replaced the primer bulb. It always starts right up. It does an excellent job.

“My Kubota BX 2200 tractor equipped with a front-end loader is a best buy. It has had a couple of problems but the dealer promptly corrected them. It’s equipped with a 60-in. mower deck, a tiller, and a box blade. It does a great job for a small tractor. It’s now 5 years old and has 300 hours on it.”

Worst Buy

Caterpillar 242 skid steer loader

Bruce Stumlin, Holmen, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My worst buy is my 2003 Caterpillar 242 skid steer loader which I bought from Fabco Industries, LaCrosse, Wis. They can’t fix it and refuse to replace it with a working machine. The first year I used it I had to return it to the dealer several times, as the hydraulics didn’t work properly. I can’t control the movement of the bucket. As a result it will drop, not holding the position required. Also, whenever I release the joystick I never know if the wheels will stop right away or continue to turn some.”

Best Buy

Baker Mfg

James G. Jarmes, Postville, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“Forty years ago we bought the farm we live on now. The well was bad so we dug a new one and hit good water at 200 ft. Then we dropped in a submersible pump made by Baker Mfg., Evansville, Wis. This pump is still providing water to this day. We had to pull the pump once when a hole rusted through the galvanized steel pipe. We replaced the steel pipe with plastic and haven’t had any trouble since. My old grand pappy always said that when you start bragging on something it will soon break down. I hope not; it’s been a good pump.”