Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006)

55 reports from pages 12–15 · 42 Best Buys23 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Pine Tree Garden Seeds

Elliott Ertman, Roanoke, Va. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My best buy came from a seed company called Pine Tree Garden Seeds (ph 207 926-3400; www.superseeds.com). This company offers great service and a wide variety of seeds including vegetables, herbs, flowers, gourds, ornamental grasses, grains, etc. They offer a number of unusual fruits and vegetables including heirloom tomatoes, mushroom growing kits, Middle Eastern vegetables, and much more. And, they sell interesting gardening books and implements; bird feeders, hummingbird feeders, natural skin care products, etc.

“The company has an experienced, knowledgeable work force and treats its customers the way most companies did 50 years ago. They’re not a big company, but for service they can’t be beat. To show you the kind of service they provide, I had a problem with a packet that had the wrong kind of seed. I called the company to let them know what happened, and by the next day the replacement seed package was in my mailbox. We’re talking here about a $1 package of seed! I really appreciate this kind of service.”

Worst Buy

Horizon Products grease buster

Jayson Williams, Mulvane, Kansas · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My worst buy is my Horizon Products grease buster, which is supposed to free up dirt and hardened grease in grease zerks. It consists of a metal housing with a piston inside it that you pound on to inject fluid into the zerk. I bought it about a year ago but could never get it to work right. I’ve tried using it many times with different kinds of oils and lubricants, but without success. Finally I just gave up on it.”

Best Buy

FMB Triton bandsaw

Raymond E. Miller, Paris, Tenn. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“I operate a small welding shop and am well pleased with my 11-in. FMB Triton bandsaw (ph 800 323-7503; www.patmooneysaws .com). No other saw in its class can compete with this one. It’s powered by a 2 hp electric motor and has a recirculating fluid cooling system that allows me to cut through 4-in. solid metal in only 2 1/2 to 3 minutes. It has a 37-in. working height and can cut at up to a 60 degree angle, which makes it a pleasure to operate.”

Best Buy

DR electric-over-hydraulic bench top

Rick Garner, Winnemucca, Nevada · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

Rick likes his DR electric-over-hydraulic bench top wood splitter. “Having heated with wood for most of my life, I prefer it to gas. When I retired in 1995 and moved to the high desert area of northern Nevada, I found that most people heat with propane. I wanted to stick with wood, but I soon found that I couldn’t split enough wood using a maul, the way I did when I was younger. After shopping around for a splitter that would fit my needs, I settled on the DR unit. The company provided an excellent packet describing the product. When I got the splitter I found it to be well designed and well built, and it performed even better than advertised. It has definitely made my best buy list.”

Best Buy

New Holland TC35A 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Lynn Lucius, Vardaman, Miss. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My 2003 New Holland TC35A 4-WD tractor equipped with a Bush Hog front-end loader is my best buy. It has almost 500 hours on it and has been a pleasure to operate. The loader is great for feeding cows and loading mulch. We also use the tractor to mow and to haul logs. It has only 35 hp, but with 4-WD it can do a lot of jobs that would normally take a bigger machine.

“This tractor has had a couple of problems including an electrical short and a burned-out clutch, but the clutch problem was probably due more to an inexperienced driver than to equipment failure. The dealer was more than helpful with the warranty and got the tractor going again. I had been a loyal Deere customer but I switched to the blue New Holland color for price, and I couldn’t be happier.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 990 4-WD utility tractor

John C. Reckart, Bruceton Mills, W. Va. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“Our 2005 Deere 990 4-WD utility tractor is our worst buy. As soon as we start it up the engine puts out a lot of foul smelling smoke. Exhaust exits against the front axle and bounces back into the radiator and operator’s station. I can’t put this tractor in gear without braking unless I pause for at least 10 seconds, which makes it unhandy for loader work. Both fenders are rusting at the seams. All these problems were brought to the attention of our dealer, but all we got was lip service. We solved the exhaust problem by installing a vertical exhaust pipe. It cost $38 for materials and an hour of labor.”

Best Buy

Ford F-100 pickup + 1 more

Bobby E. Lucas, Jefferson, S.C. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My best buy is my 1966 Ford F-100 pickup. It has almost 400,000 miles on it but still gets me wherever I need to go with almost no problems. It still runs great.

“In 1978 I bought a used 1967 Ford Falcon station wagon with 95,000 miles on it. Over the years I’ve put about 70,000 miles on it, yet my total cost for repairs during all that time has been only $98. That money went toward a battery, a wheel bearing, and a $15 carburetor.”

Best Buy

MTD 18 1/2 hp riding mower + 1 more

Jim Franklin, Jonesville, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My best buy is my 1987 MTD 18 1/2 hp riding mower equipped with a 46-in. deck. Over the years it has needed only new belts and blades, a couple of new batteries, and a new deck shaft. This mower is still in great working condition. We use it to cut two to three acres a week.

“My 1994 Ford 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 300 cu. in., in-line 6-cylinder engine and a 5-speed manual transmission is a best buy. It has about 140,000 trouble-free miles on it. It’s a great pickup.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Echo 602VL chain saw + 3 more

R.W. Allen, Clare, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My best buy is my Echo 602VL chain saw which I bought as a discontinued model in 1980. We used wood to heat our home for 14 years, and this saw cut almost all of it.

“My Global Hydronics outdoor wood burning furnace is a best buy (www.globalhydronics.com). It keeps us real warm, and eliminates the need to use gas to heat our home or hot water. I got a tune-up on my old Echo chain saw and went back to working in the woods. It’s so nice not to have a huge heating bill any more. Over the years my Echo chain saw has paid for itself many times over. At today’s fuel prices, my Global Hydronics furnace will save enough money to pay for itself in four years.

“My Gateway computer system is my worst buy. It has required five new hard drives, two new mother boards, two new power supply systems, and only the company knows what else. The computer came with a 3-year in-home service warranty, which I think is a joke. The toll-free help line was a nightmare. I had to go through four or five operators until I got one who agreed to service the computer, only to have a supervisor then refuse the order. The company finally agreed to repair the computer just days before the warranty expired, after I told them I was making a sign for my semi truck which I drive nationwide. Even though the computer was repaired, it now runs slower than it did when it was new.”

Best Buy

Husky Rotator 3/8-in drive ratchet

Ralph A. Orsi, Silvis, Ill. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My Husky Rotator 3/8-in. drive ratchet, which I bought at Home Depot, is my best buy. It works like a normal ratchet, but when you twist the handle the socket rotates. A little wheel on top changes the direction of the ratchet, and pressing a button on top releases the socket.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5420 4-WD tractor equipped

Jim Weppler, Lebanon, N.J. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

Jim likes his Deere 5420 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “This is a solid, mid-size tractor and I’ve had no problems with mine. We use it for cleaning out our pole barn, handling round bales, and operating our 7-ft. snow blower. If the rest of the Deere equipment line works as good as this tractor, we’ll be switching from red machinery to green.”

Best Buy

Hobart Handler 125 welder

Ross Allen, Poteau, Okla. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My 2002 Hobart Handler 125 welder is my best buy (www.northerntool.com). This welder has saved me a lot of money by allowing me to fix all sorts of equipment by myself. The only negative is the welding wire costs too much.”

Worst Buy

Homelite gas leaf blower

Steve Lucas, Westmont, Ill. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

Steve’s disappointed with his Homelite gas leaf blower which he purchased from Home Depot for $89 plus tax. “This machine wouldn’t start unless I took the spark plug out and poured a gas/oil mixture into the cylinder. I returned it for another one and it started okay, but then developed a rod knock. I exchanged it for a third machine but it wouldn’t start, either. The Home Depot store manager tried starting the first and third machines with no luck. I thought I’d have to call 911 for an ambulance, as he was totally exhausted and finally had to sit down after pulling on the cord for three to five minutes. I got a refund and then went to Ace Hardware and bought a Ryobi leaf blower for $30 more. It works fine.”

Worst Buy

Bush Hog 287 rotary cutter

Benton Hester, Florala, Ala. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

Benton says his Bush Hog 287 rotary cutter is his “worst buy”. “My 14-year-old Brown 7-ft. rotary cutter was worn out so I replaced it with this model, which was supposedly a premium brand. However, it has caused nothing but trouble. First, the 3-pt. lift points are engineered so that you can’t pick the arms up high enough to drive the tractor onto a trailer or even to clear terraces. A company engineer said it was designed this way because of liability problems from roll-overs. The wheel bearings are an unusual straight roller design, vulnerable to hay twine and available only from Bush Hog. The ‘stump-jumper’ nut and cotter are always working loose, the nut being an old metric pitch that again is available only from Bush Hog. The machine was delivered with water in the gearbox, which the dealer removed. However, water infiltration remains a problem unless I cover the gearbox with a bucket.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toro 3-blade mower + 1 more

Robert Szabo, Westland, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“I bought my Toro 20-in. Snow Master snow-blower 10 years ago for $20 from a lady who was moving to Florida, and it has been trouble-free and has saved my back and heart.

“I like my Toro 21-in., 3-blade mower. The grass catcher is easy to take off and empty, and I can fill the crankcase with Slick 50 oil straight from the bottle. I use this mower every spring, summer and fall. It doesn’t burn any oil and always starts on the second pull. It still has the original spark plug.”

On the negative side, “We bought a Maytag Neptune automatic front load washing machine in 1999 for $1,096. It’s a complete piece of junk. The control boards shorted out, and the tub bearing burned out after six years so I’m scrapping it. It does have a good motor and good control boards. I’m willing to sell parts from it.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet 3205 tractor equipped

Mel Thompson, Armstrong, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My Cub Cadet 3205 tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck is my worst buy. I have no complaints about the tractor, as it has good power steering, a tilt steering wheel, cruise control, a water-cooled Kawasaki engine, and a deck that’s easy to remove and replace. But the left front corner of the deck plugs up with grass after only about 10 minutes of mowing. Another problem is there’s way too much clearance between the end of the blades and the deck. I’d like to hear from anyone who has solutions to any of these problems.”

Worst Buy

TSR chopper

Bill Brandt, Concordia, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

Bill says the TSR chopper he mounted on his Case 2188 combine is his “worst buy”. “It’s built too light, and the knives come out on a daily basis. The splines on the drive pulley stripped on the second day of use. The knives broke and damaged the chaffer.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

NAPA Workaholic batteries + 1 more

James Brooks, Homer, Ga. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

James is impressed with the NAPA Workaholic batteries he bought in 2004. “I’ve tried all types of batteries in both farm and heavy construction equipment. These batteries last longer than their warranty, outlasting even Exide batteries.

“My 2004 Weed Eater weed trimmer is my worst buy. The string trimmer head doesn’t last very long, and a replacement head cost more than $40. I bought it at Home Depot which doesn’t sell Weed Eater products any more, not even the trimmer string. However, the machine itself runs great. We’re still using a hand held Weed Eater trimmer that we bought more than 25 years ago, and we’ve used it hard.”

Worst Buy

Hesston round baler

George Hodges, Westfield, N.C. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My 2003 Hesston round baler is my worst buy. The unit was delivered with everything out of adjustment and with no hitch bolt assembly, so I made my own even though it’s supposed to be standard equipment. After three seasons of use it almost works okay now. But recently I discovered that the dipstick for the gearbox fell into the gearbox.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Case IH Magnum front wheel assist + 3 more

Art Mangels, Dillon, Mont. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My two Case IH Magnum front wheel assist tractors, one a 1989 model 7120 and the other a 1990 model 7140, are both best buys. They start easy and have a lot of pulling power. The 7140 has about 8,500 hours on it but is still going strong. The cabs on these tractors are the best on the market for when they were made. Deere finally copied their design five or six years later.

My 1992 Case IH Maxxim 5250 tractor equipped with a reverser gear is a very handy loader tractor.

“My Great Bend 770 front-end loader is well built and comes with a good manual that covers both installation and maintenance.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists ColorBack paint renewer from Apollo Sales. “The instruction manual is very poorly written. The company said ColorBack would work on Case IH tractors, but it didn’t for us. In fact, it even ruined the good paint on our tractor. They said I used the product wrong and wouldn’t refund my money, even though I followed all the instructions.”

Best Buy

Geringhoff corn head

Harold Barton, Silver Lake, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

Harold ran a 12-row 22-in. Geringhoff corn head over 1,000 acres last fall and says he couldn’t have been more impressed. “I’ve been running self-propelled combines since 1961 and this is the most impressive header I’ve ever seen,” says the 91-year-old Barton. “It’s got built-in stalk choppers so it eliminates a separate trip across the field to chop. It doesn’t chop the stalks quite as close to the ground but it’s pretty good.

“We mounted the header on our Case IH 2388 with rear wheel assist and harvested at speeds of 3.6 to 4 mph. It’s a very aggressive header that does a great job bringing in the ears, although we put Corn Shields (which Barton invented) at each end of the header. With the shields in place, you can go with the row or across the rows and still do a good job. They also make it possible to plant 15-in. rows and harvest with this header.”

Barton says rear wheel assist is a must-have on today’s combines. “If you can’t afford rear wheel assist, you can’t afford to farm,” he notes.

Best Buy

Morton pole barn

David Fox, Edon, Ohio · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My 60 by 98-ft. Morton pole barn is my best buy. The building started leaking a little around a skylight, but the company came out and fixed it. No one was home when they came out, and they left me a message saying the south side of the roof was peeling slightly. They also listed a phone number for me to call. I thought maybe the problem was because I have 400 hogs in an outdoor feedlot that runs parallel to the building, but I guess the problem was due to some bad paint. Regardless, they replaced the entire roof at no charge. I’m really happy with the warranty this company offers.”

Best Buy

Paslode cordless angled finish

Louis Kocon, Jr., Woodstock, Va. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“My Paslode cordless angled finish nailer is my best buy. I used it recently to do trim work on a new house that we built. It worked as advertised, without leaving even one ‘hammer blossom’ anywhere in the entire house. No problems of any kind. It’s an excellent tool.”

Best Buy

Ford pickups burning

Dan Hill, Dixmont, Maine · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“In FARM SHOW’s Vol. 29, No. 1 issue you published a story about Ford pickups burning up. Two years ago I bought a 1996 Ford F-150 pickup from my son, who bought a new GM after testing and rejecting several Ford models. He had put about 100,000 miles on the Ford with few problems.

“From what I can determine, the pickups that have burned have an aluminum master cylinder with a plastic fluid reservoir. The faulty switch is at the top front of the master cylinder. It supplies power to the cruise control. The switch is closed until hydraulic pressure opens it and removes 12 volts from the cruise control whenever you step on the brake. The green wire that plugs into the switch is hot at all times even when the pickup isn’t running. There is supposed to be a fuse in the line but I can’t find one. The pickup’s brake light switch is a mechanical type under the dash. You can unplug the switch on the master cylinder, tape up the connector, and tie the wire back with some plastic tie wraps. This is what Ford dealers did until they could get replacement switches from the company.

“This problem only affects vehicles with cruise control. On my pickup I don’t use the cruise control at all so I disconnected the switch and taped it. If you want to use the cruise control you can cut into the green wire and add an in-line fuse holder, then solder and tape the connection. Use a small fuse, 5 amps or smaller.

“I’ve checked my pickup for recalls but haven’t found any. The offending switch was a small square unit made by Texas Instruments. The switch would catch fire and burned through the plastic brake fluid reservoir.

“If you search the internet you’ll find more information on Ford pickups that have burned up.”

Worst Buy

Pio-neer Steel Mfg. Ltd

Leonard Stanek, Baring, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

“My worst buy is the steel building I bought from Pio-neer Steel Mfg. Ltd., Mississauga, Ontario. The first clue that I made a mistake should have been when I had to pay a down payment before the company would even send me an information packet.

“I had the understanding that the building was to sit on a flat slab. However, when I received the instructions I learned it sets in a trough. When I questioned the sales person, I was told that if I wanted a base plate it would cost $1,700 extra for a 24 by 40-ft. building such as mine.

“The plans weren’t clear on some measurements. About 25 percent of the drawings are for a sliding door and track, which my building doesn’t even have. Another problem is that the arch panels aren’t bent to the right angles. The plans say the panels may ‘grow’ a little, but that two men could push them down. However, I couldn’t find two men big enough to push that much since they were off 1 1/2 to 2 inches per panel.

“The company said that all panels were pre-drilled or punched, but they didn’t say that 15 percent of them were punched at least half to over an entire hole off line. I had to take a punch and try to line the holes up and sometimes drill out holes to make the panels fit. The bolts and nuts were bad, they had nicks and burrs, no threads, just a bunch of reject trash. Buyer beware.”

Best Buy

Unadilla arch rafters

Roger Brainard, Kennedy, N.Y. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

“My best buy is the hoop building I put up a year ago last November, using 50-year-old Unadilla arch rafters from a barn that was being taken down by the Amish. I bought the tarp and ratchets from Custom Canvas in Buffalo, N.Y., and am really happy with them. They had the tarp ready within 30 hours after I called.”

Best Buy

Deep Creep + 1 more

Wendell Newman, Carson City, Nevada · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

Wendell likes an aerosol penetrating solution called “Deep Creep”. “This product is sold at NAPA stores. I like it better than WD-40 or other penetrants because it puts a foam on whatever part you’re trying to loosen, thus penetrating longer. It doesn’t dry up as fast as other products I’ve used.”

Gene Gehlhausen, G & K Windmills, It got rid of the algae and bad odor in our pond and also kept the pond from freezing completely. Now I’ve got the cleanest pond in our area, without using chemicals. I liked the results so well that I became a dealer.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 crew cab pickup

Robert L. Brown, Trenton, Neb. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

“My 2003 Ford F-150 crew cab pickup is my best buy. I use it to pull an 18-ft. trailer loaded with a 5,500-lb. load. We also use this pickup as our vacation vehicle. It’ll burn any type of fuel including E-10 and E-85 ethanol blended fuel. It gets about 14 mpg when pulling a trailer and 19 mpg empty.”

Worst Buy

Sun Brite

Marcus Yoder, Wellman, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

Marcus is disappointed with Sun Brite all purpose professional cleaner. “A salesman came out to show us how this product would clean our dairy equipment, parlor walls, and other miscellaneous items. However, whatever product he used must have been different than the product he left us. I called the company but never got a response. We’re very upset with this product.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 extended cab pickup + 1 more

Sam Poljansek, Mullinville, Kansas · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

“My best buy is my 1998 Dodge 1500 extended cab pickup. It has about 165,000 miles and is on its third set of tires and the ring and pinion gear were rebuilt. That’s it. I’m well pleased with its performance and ride.

“I bought a used ‘gray market’ Kubota 1501 17 hp tractor from Japan and it’s a best buy. It had 936 hours on it when I bought it and now has almost 1,400 hours. The 2-cyl. diesel engine goes about five hours on one gallon of fuel.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grass-hopper front mount mower + 1 more

Elmer Pinkerton, Elmwood, Neb. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

Elmer traded his Deere 425 mower in for a Grass-hopper front mount mower. He says he regrets that decision. “I hated the Deere because it took two hours of hard labor just to convert the machine from mowing to snowblowing, and I had to make the conversion twice a year. It took an 800-lb. box of sand on the machine’s drawbar to keep the drive wheels from spinning on snow. And during the summer, every time I was done mowing I had to hang the mower deck vertically in a tree just so I could clean off the crud.

“I was fascinated with the Grasshopper machine because the deck can automatically be tilted vertically for cleaning. I took delivery the fall of 2004, right before we got our first snow.

“The operator’s manual said tire chains weren’t needed. However, without them this machine drove like a hog on ice when blowing snow. And in order to make room for tire chains I had to throw away the rig’s beautiful, expensive fenders. Another problem was that the machine’s skid shoes hung up on uneven dirt and on low ground. The manual lift on the rig was hard to use. The factory rep came out and modified the skid shoes, which helped. He also brought an electric-operated lift and that worked well but cost $750. The blower worked fine in dry snow, but in wet snow it often clogged up badly.

“The following spring was a wet one and on flat land, the mower’s drive wheels spun badly and destroyed our sod. The drive wheels were useless on slopes and made so many ruts that my small acreage look like a plowed field. I welded metal boxes over the drive wheels and put 600 lbs. of sand in each box, which solved the problem. The machine now weighs about 2,400 lbs. with me on the seat.

“This machine is fun to drive, but it has a two-lever steering system that takes getting used to.

“It took me 80 years to learn that if you’re going to spend $14,000 on a mower and snow blower, you should first ask for a demonstration model and test it out for a week on your home turf to be sure your eyes aren’t bigger than your brain. I wish I had my Deere machine back again.”

Worst Buy

Sears Kenmore stainless steel oven

Greg Neymeyer, Northfield, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

On Thanksgiving Day of 2004 Greg bought a new Sears Kenmore stainless steel oven range for $1,500. He says it’s his “worst buy”. “A couple of weeks after we bought the oven my wife noticed that a couple of stainless steel trim pieces on the control panel were bent.

“New panels arrived, but they were dented because there was no packing inside the box. We ordered more panels but the same thing happened again. Finally, on the third shipping attempt the parts were usable. After inspecting the new ones the technician told me the entire oven had been welded together twisted and that making an adjustment was impossible. When a new oven arrived, the door and warming drawer were bent and had to be swapped with the same parts off a display model. Everything went well for a few weeks until one of the touch pads on top of the unit quit working.

“I called the company, and they sent a new panel and made arrangements to send a technician. When he arrived, he inspected the panel and observed a damaged ‘ribbon’ cable. Upon installation, the new panel didn’t work either so another one was ordered. It came with a damaged cable, too, so another one was ordered but it had a damaged cable, too. Another order was made, and when it arrived the entire panel was completely shattered! All the parts were shipped in an over-sized box with no packing, so all the parts were flopping around inside.

“When I saw the shattered panel, I again called on my local retailer for a complete replacement oven, which he said was more than appropriate due to all the problems I’d been having. But when the new oven arrived, again the door and drawer were dented and they had to be swapped, this time with the door and drawer from the oven I already had.

“Following this comedy of errors, I contacted Sears and requested a free 60-month warranty, since it was obvious this appliance was a problem child. However, the company did everything it could to put me off and ignore me.

“I’ve owned Sears products all my life and have a washer/dryer pair that has worked great for more than 20 years, but no Sears Kenmore product will ever cross my door sill again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Yanmar diesel garden tractor + 1 more

Edward DuBois, Monticello, N.Y. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

“My 1987 Yanmar diesel garden tractor is my best buy. I used it commercially for several years with very few problems and still use it today. I bought a 48-in. mower deck for the tractor but found that it scalped my lawn at times. To solve the problem, I bought a 48-in. long rod with rollers from a mower repair shop and bolted them on back of the deck. Now it works great.

“My 2004 Billy Goat 33 self-propelled walk-behind lawn mower isn’t my all-time worst buy, but it ranks right up there. It has a three-chambered deck that clogs up. I have to use a hose and stiff broom after each mowing to clean it out. I installed an in-line fuel shut-off, which allows me to tip the mower all the way up, front to back after using up all the gas in the carburetor. I built a 6-in. high ramp to back the mower up onto. I also built a tag-a-long, ride-on vacuum system and attached it to the machine. It works well.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bosch angle grinder + 1 more

Jim Wicks, Sr., Lewiston, Idaho · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

A Bosch 5-in. angle grinder rates as Jim’s “best buy”. “It has good balance and a lot of power for its size. I like the way it feels in my hands, and I also like the type of switch it has. When you turn the switch on the tool stays on, and when you turn it off it goes off.

“The Coleman cordless drill I bought at Home Depot is my worst buy. From the beginning it lacked power, and the battery wouldn’t hold a charge. I could drive only about three 2-in. screws before the battery gave out. Then I had to put the battery on the charger for an hour just so that I could drive another three screws. It was very frustrating.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller

Max Black, Aurora, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My 2004 Mantis rototiller is my best buy. It’s so light I can pick it up with one hand and throw it in my pickup. It weighs about the same as a Weed Eater. But when it comes time to till, this rototiller is unbelievable. It digs like crazy. I’ve hit rocks with it that were almost as big as the tiller but didn’t break anything. This is one tough machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toro zero turn riding + 1 more

W. Gray Abercrombie, Broad Run, Va. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My Toro zero turn 62-in. riding mower equipped with a Kohler engine is my best buy. It’s stable on steep hills and has a lot of power. It mows large lawns quickly, and it does a good job of spreading grass clippings even in tall grass. It turns in a tight circle around trees and virtually eliminates the need to use a weed trimmer. It’s a fantastic machine.

“My 1994 Dodge Ram 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my worst buy. The engine is outstanding but that’s all. The ball joints were replaced at about 30,000 miles, the front brakes at about 20,000 miles, and the exhaust at about 28,000 miles. It has also had problems with the front wheel bearing, wiper motor, and wiper switch. This pickup still looks great and has only about 40,000 miles on it. It has been well cared for. On the positive side, it’s really powerful on hills and I like the 4-WD.”

Best Buy

Ford 3000 tractor + 1 more

H.J. Trahan, Jennings, La. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My Ford 3000 tractor has been the most reliable machine I’ve ever had. Neither the engine nor the diesel pump has ever been repaired. I’ve always changed the fuel filters and been careful about using clean fuel.

“I had a problem with the front axle on my Sears Craftsman riding mower. The axle was made by the Roper Co. I replaced the original axle with one made by Sears Craftsman, which I modified a little, and now I have a heavy duty axle.”

Best Buy

Ridgid 1/2-in drive cordless drill

James Moldenhauer, Ferndale, Wash. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

James nominates his 12-volt Ridgid 1/2-in. drive cordless drill as his “best buy”. “It charges quickly, has a lot of power, and the carbide chuck does a good job of gripping bits. This drill cost $69, which was less than the cost of replacement batteries for my 9.6-volt Sears drill. Also, it has a better (3-year) warranty.”

Worst Buy

Genamaxx portable diesel 7.5-kilowatt + 1 more

Freeman Wattam, Deseronto, Ontario · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

Freeman is disappointed with his 2004 Genamaxx portable diesel 7.5-kilowatt generator. “I use it to provide backup power for my house and also to provide power at a remote shop on my farm. I’ve had to return the generator for repair work seven times in nine months, with one motor blow-up. The rest of the problems had to do with the generator not producing enough power. At first the company made the repairs or gave me a new generator under warranty, but later I had to deliver my machine to their shop which is a 3-hour drive in one direction.

“Last April the company gave me a new generator part which I had to install myself. I was told there was no more warranty coverage on my machine even though it had less than 110 hours on it. They told me I was overloading the generator with the arc welder I was using so I haven’t used that welder since then, but four months later the power failed again. Now I have a generator that won’t produce enough kilowatts. I gave up on it and recently purchased a new Generac generator from a different supplier.”

Best Buy

Maytag Neptune front load washer

Salon Sheldon, Blissfield, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“Our Maytag Neptune front load washer is easy on clothes and uses only about half as much water as a top load Maytag washer. But we’ve spent more on repairs and parts than for any other washer we’ve owned. We paid $1,100 for the washer and have spent another $127.95 for labor and $202.48 for parts.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Geo Metro equipped

Richard Ellis, Pomona, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

Richard likes his 1996 Chevrolet Geo Metro equipped with a 3-cyl. gas engine and 5-speed transmission. “I bought this car used and paid $12,000 for it. It had a small dent on back and about 40,000 miles on it. Now it has about 90,000 miles. The best thing is that it’s fuel efficient. It gets about 45 mpg in town and 60 mpg on the highway. Also, it doesn’t use any oil and runs good. I’ve spent less than $15 on repairs.”

Worst Buy

Avalon Olympic wood stove equipped

J. Harry Wright, Red Lodge, Mont. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My worst buy is my Avalon Olympic wood stove equipped with an ash pan. This stove smokes every time I open the door to put wood in it. I’ve raised the chimney and done everything the dealer recommended. I wrote to the company and sent a copy to the dealer, but neither has bothered to answer. This was an expensive stove and I’m very dissatisfied with it. The ash pan is a real joke.”

Worst Buy

Balzer

Ernest Amershek, McCune, Kansas · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

Ernest nominates his Balzer 8-ft., V-6 liquid manure pump as his “worst buy”. “The first time we backed the tractor up to it we found we couldn’t use a quick coupler to hook it up. When we put the pump into the pit we found the agitation nozzle was too long and had to be removed. Finally, the clamshell-style discharge valve tried to close on a large piece of gravel and bent the valve and the shaft it was mounted on. Our previous N-Tech pump ran good for years with just a sliding gate valve.”

Best Buy

Chicago pneumatic 1/2-in drive

Don Holdeman, Elma, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“I like my 2005 Chicago pneumatic 1/2-in. drive air impact wrench. This wrench was advertised to have 625 ft.-lbs. I have a 3/4-in. impact wrench with 700 ft.-lbs. but this small 1/2-in. wrench will do just as much as the 3/4-in. one. I bought an adapter so that I can use my 3/4-in. sockets with the 1/2-in. impact wrench. It also has a handy torque setting on back of the gun with four settings. Small gun, big power.”

A set of gear pullers from Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy”. “The first time I used it a bolt that holds the jaws together sheared off.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram Dakota 2-WD pickup equipped + 1 more

Robert (Fish) Pike, Hollandale, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“I bought my 1992 Dodge Dakota 2-WD pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and 5-speed transmission used for $900. The engine is fuel efficient. I put a utility box on back that I bought from a friend for $160 and use it as a service truck. I work for a local International truck dealer so it comes in handy for service calls. I converted an air conditioning compressor into an engine-driven air compressor so it also has on-board air.”

“My Chicago electric hammer drill is my worst buy. I was able to use it only once before the gears stripped out. Lesson learned. I think we should all stop being so cheap and buy good American-made tools as much as possible. Support your neighbors and you’ll be rewarded with quality.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 2500 pickup equipped + 1 more

Gerald Kropf, Jamesville, N.Y. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“My 1999 Dodge Ram 2500 pickup equipped with a 5.9-liter engine is my worst buy. I use it around our farm and also to tow a two-horse trailer. It gets only 6 to 7 mpg. Just after it was three years old, the entire wiring harness had to be replaced due to corrosion. The vehicle’s warranty had expired one month earlier, even though the vehicle had only about 20,000 miles on it, Fortunately the dealer covered the cost.

“Another problem was the pickup kept slipping out of 4-WD. Also, some vacuum actuators had to be replaced as well as a bent linkage. When the pickup was less than four years old the inside of the doors started showing rust, and then the front end started going. Whenever I used the pickup to pull a trailer, the front end would wander all over the road. After I spent $1,000 to replace the ball joints, tie rods, and a sway bar, the dealer wanted to try replacing the steering box. That’s when we threw in the towel and traded this pickup in on a Ford 250 diesel model, which so far has been outstanding.

“My 2000 Kubota 2500DT 4-WD, 25 hp loader tractor is my best buy. This machine has been impeccable. The only problem was with a short on the block heater which was quickly resolved. This tractor has about 550 hours on it and I’ve done all the maintenance myself. I use it for mowing, blowing and plowing snow, handling manure, dragging a riding arena, and digging fence post holes. Last summer I made a rear-mounted snow blower for it as well as a fixed front-mounted plow. I’m impressed with the power and reliability of this tractor. I’d buy another Kubota in a heartbeat.”

Best Buy

Nuisance Wildlife Control Products

John R. Dorrel, Middletown, Ohio · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“The mole trap I purchased from Bob Bruno of Nuisance Wildlife Control Products is my best buy (ph 888 778-7988; www.easysetmoletrap.com). Bob guaranteed it would catch moles or he would refund my money. I set it when I got home and within an hour or so, I caught the biggest mole I’ve ever seen. Five days later, I saw a new mole run in the yard. I set the trap and caught another huge mole within about three hours. This is an easy trap to set, and it really works. We’ve tried many other solutions to get rid of moles, but this is the only one that works.”

Best Buy

Kubota LA 211 tractor

Robert D. Perice, Hagerstown, Ind. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“Our little 2001 Kubota LA 211 tractor is our best buy. It came equipped with a frontend loader and a belly mower, and we’ve also bought a box blade, Bush Hog mower, and scraper blade for it. We use it for hauling trees, moving large rocks, burying dead animals, putting in drainage pipes, mowing, moving snow and dirt and various other jobs. It has about 800 hours on it. We had a couple of minor problems which the dealer promptly corrected. It’s a fantastic small tractor. My wife enjoys using it almost as much as I do.”