Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010)

86 reports from pages 12–15 · 75 Best Buys26 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Kelly Products

Norman Blowers, Chambersburg, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

“I ordered a loader for my Deere LA115 on June 16, 2009 from Robert Labonte of Kelly Products, Friendship, Tenn. (featured in Vol. 33, No. 3). I paid in advance, since that was required, and Mr. Labonte cashed the $1,650 check immediately. In July he shipped the arms that attach to the tractor frame. Since that time, there have been 28 emails back and forth but the rest of the loader never shipped. We even talked several times by telephone. He sounded cooperative until April 1, 2010 but has been totally silent since then. The post office just returned an unclaimed registered letter I sent to him. This was definitely the worst buy I’ve ever made.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kinze planter + 1 more

Keith Carfield, Rushville, Ind. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Keith had problems with his 2010 3660 Kinze planter. “Poor engineering, drive chains hitting the frame, and nobody – dealership or Kinze – would help set up the cobalt monitor which caused me to plant double the population I wanted. Information in the owner’s manual was very minimal. The local dealer only had one person who knew anything about the machine and it took Kinze three days to return my calls during planting season.”

One the plus side, Keith likes his 850 Rogator. “It’s a pleasure to operate. The controls are very user friendly. No problems.”

Best Buy

Ford Jubilee tractor + 1 more

James Kennedy, Troutville, Va. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

“Two years ago I bought a worn-out 1954 Ford Jubilee tractor for $3,500. It came with 7 pieces of equipment in very good condition that were worth more than I paid for the whole works. I disassembled the entire tractor, rebuilding and restoring it at a cost of $1,600. It’s now a fine machine that gets a lot of use.

“Another best buy is my 1986 Chevy 1/2 ton pickup. I’ve owned it 21 years and it has 196,000 miles on it without any engine work. I have changed oil every 3,000 miles and the filter every 6,000 miles and it’s still going strong. Me and that truck are growing old together.”

Best Buy

Honda 4-wheelers

Kevin Fulton, Litchfield, Neb. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

“We’re well-satisfied with our four Honda 4-wheelers, but especially like the Rancher models. We find them to be durable and dependable. One Rancher model has 25,000 miles on it but still runs like new. These vehicles get ridden hard on our ranch under all types of adverse conditions.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bobcat CT225 4-WD compact tractor + 1 more

Martin Michalec, White Sulphur Springs, Mont. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

“I’ve used my Bobcat CT225 4-WD compact tractor to do jobs you’d think would require a much bigger tractor, such as lifting big poles and hauling gravel. It’s fuel-efficient and has well-placed controls. No problems.

“My 2008 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 4-WD pickup is my worst buy. The rear bumper rusted through within 2 years, but the company wouldn’t replace it because the 36,000-mile warranty had expired. The pickup has about 42,000 miles on it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Lincoln Idealarc 250 stick welders + 2 more

Mark LaSalle, Sumter, S.C. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Mark uses Lincoln Idealarc 250 stick welders at a welding school, where he maintains equipment. “These welders are tough and powerful. We use them to do stick and scratch-start TIG welding, and they’ve survived student and commercial use for decades. They’re a classic transformer machine with no delicate PC boards. They’re extremely reliable.”

He’s disappointed with his Metabo 6 and 9-in. angle grinders. “The problem is that the company changed the design. The old ‘all green’ 6-in. grinder was a great grinder, but the new ‘black and green’ 9-in. grinders don’t hold up nearly as well. They have poor guards that stretch and come loose.

“Our DeWalt 28494 series 9-in. grinders are cheaper, more reliable, and equipped with much better guards.”

Best Buy

Hustler Fastrak zero turn riding

Joe Park, Carrollton, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Joe nominates his 2006 Hustler Fastrak 52-in. zero turn riding mower as his “best buy”. “We use this machine to mow 5 acres. With a week to go on the 4-year warranty, one of the hydro transmission pumps malfunctioned, which would have been an expensive repair. When I called the company to order a part, I was told the machine was still under warranty and that I should contact a local dealer to have it repaired. They fixed it and the machine works like new. Hustler really stood behind this product.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tacoma pickup

Eugene Hartenstein, Abilene, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Eugene’s happy with his 1991 Toyota Tacoma pickup. “I bought this pickup used for a grandson. It had 118,000 miles on it and had been used on a rural mail route. My grandson drove it for a few years with no problems. Then he wanted a bigger pickup, so I bought it back, and a granddaughter drove it. Then she passed the pickup on to her younger brother. In a few years, he went to a bigger pickup so I bought it back for the third time. It has been used as a knock-around farm truck, and now my second grandson is using it again to save miles on his newer, bigger pickup. The Tacoma has more than 240,000 miles on it but is still going strong. It has required only routine maintenance.”

Best Buy

Ford pickups equipped

Don Hartley, Murphy, Idaho · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Don’s the satisfied owner of a pair of Ford pickups equipped with Powerstroke diesel engines, one a 1997 model and the other a 2001. “I’ve replaced the transmission twice on the 1997 model but the engine is still solid. This pickup has about 250,000 miles on it but still doesn’t use a drop of oil. The 2001 model has 85,000 miles. The only problem I ever had was a driveline vibration, which the dealer promptly took care of.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 5103 tractor

Harry Hamilton, Henderson, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 12

Harry nominates his 2007 Deere 5103 tractor as his “worst buy”. “Six months after I bought this tractor the control levers for the rear lift froze up which caused the lift to quit working. The dealer said this problem commonly happens when the lift isn’t used enough. He said an internal valve would have to be replaced at a cost of $800, not including labor. I always store this tractor inside out of the weather. It has about 160 hrs. on it.”

Best Buy

Stihl MS260 chainsaw

Doug Martens, Teslin, Yukon · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“My Stihl MS260 chainsaw is my best buy. I’ve used it to cut hundreds of cords of firewood and to build a large log home, with no problems. It’s a professional grade model that uses bearings instead of bushings and is designed for long, continuous usage. After years of steady use I bought another one and experienced similar amazing results. I mix the gas and oil at a 30:1 ratio, which works perfect.”

Best Buy

Arthro-IonX

Tom Albers, Grinnell, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Tom’s had good luck with Arthro-IonX, a liquid medicine for pets (Vetionx, ph 866 977-0888; www.vetionx.com). “I have a dog that had hip dysplasia and arthritis so bad that he couldn’t even get up for three months. I gave him the recommended dosage of Arthro-IonX for one month and he started walking and running again. The vet said he had good range of motion in his body and that I should keep doing whatever I was doing. I had brought the dog in earlier to the vet on a stretcher, but now his lifestyle is the same as when he was younger.”

Best Buy

Ram 4-WD pickup equipped

Zach Shaw, Fremont, Neb. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Zach’s the satisfied owner of a 2003 Dodge 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. “This pickup has about 140,000 miles on it with no problems. It has awesome power and can easily pull a 24,000-lb. load. We use it to haul cattle and hay. This pickup is easy to maintain and starts even in the coldest weather. Also, the 4-WD is smooth and trouble-free.”

Worst Buy

ITP Mud Lite 6-ply tires

Charles Henkel, Norfolk, Neb. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Charles is disappointed with the ITP Mud Lite 6-ply tires on his ATV. “Three of the tires failed in the same way after lasting only about one third as long as they should have. They rapidly developed tears in many of the hollow cleats on the tread pattern. The ATV dealer said I was at fault for keeping the tire air pressure too low, and wouldn’t compensate me.

“I have other ITP tires that have served well, two of which are now bald. As an experiment, I deliberately ran them with low air pressure for a few hundred miles, and I even drove one of the tires for another 50 miles completely flat and they didn’t show any pattern of failure like my bad tires. I suspect there wasn’t enough real rubber in some batches of material that were used to make the tires.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 heavy duty 4-wd

Bob Palmer, Grove, Okla. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

A 1999 Ford F-250 heavy duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine rates as Bob’s “best buy”. “I bought this pickup slightly used in 2000. Now it has about 213,000 miles and all I’ve replaced was an alternator at 210,000 miles, tires at 50,000 to 60,000-mile intervals, and several headlights. This pickup is still running strong and works great pulling a 5th wheel trailer.”

Worst Buy

New Holland TC55DA tractors

Robert Spiker, Warren, Ind. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Robert’s had a lot of problems with two different New Holland TC55DA tractors, one a 2007 model and the other a 2008. “I farm 30 acres of hay, which I cut with a 7-ft. sickle mower and rake with an old 4-bar Deere steel-wheeled model. The 2007 model was a lemon so the dealer took it back and replaced it with the 2008 model. However, last June I was working in the field when the tractor’s drawbar fell off. The tractor had only about 400 hrs. on it. Then in August the hydraulics failed. By that time the tractor was out of warranty, despite having only 540 hrs. on it. It cost $1,263.79 to repair.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2350 MFWD model equipped

Tom Kussow, Little Suamico, Wis. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“It’s the most reliable tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Tom about his Deere 2350 MFWD model equipped with a front-end loader. “It has about 10,500 hrs. on it, but the engine still doesn’t use any oil unless it’s working very hard. I use the loader for doing logging work and for general chores. The clutch was replaced and the pto was rebuilt at about 9,000 hrs., and the hydraulic pump was rebuilt at about 9,500 hrs.”

Worst Buy

CertainTeed organic asphalt shingles

Stan McCarty, Promise City, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Stan nominates CertainTeed organic asphalt shingles as his “worst buy”. “During the fall of 2003, I built a new home and installed these 25-year organic shingles. However, by the spring of 2009 the shingles were already going bad. Now I have a metal roof on my home, and I don’t plan to buy anything from this company again.”

Best Buy

Ford Ranger pickup equipped + 1 more

Marshall Orcutt, Siloam Springs, Ark. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Marshall’s pleased with his 2006 Ford Ranger pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine, 5-speed transmission, air conditioning, and power steering. “This pickup cost about $11,000 new. It averaged 32 mpg on a recent trip to California and averages 25 mpg around town. No problems.

“The choke has never worked right on my 2005 Yamaha 9.9 hp, 4-stroke outboard boat motor. Three dealers and $400 haven’t solved the problem.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-550 pickup

Troy Dean, Rapid City, S. Dak. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“It’s probably the best pickup I’ve ever owned, but definitely has the worst engine,” says Troy about his 2006 Ford F-550 pickup. “It gets terrible mileage and lacks power. and now it has started leaking anti-freeze, probably into the engine. I took the pickup back while it was still under warranty, but they couldn’t find the leak. They checked the EGR cooler and compression. It also developed a high pressure oil leak so the fuel injectors wouldn’t fire. Next time I buy a pickup it’ll definitely be equipped with a Cummins diesel engine.”

Worst Buy

Volkswagen Jetta TDI

Ron Carey, West Chester, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“My 2006 Volkswagen Jetta TDI is my worst buy. This was our second new TDI. The first one was a 2004 model which worked great until we traded it in at about 75,000 miles for this top-of-the-line model, which cost about $30,000. About 400 miles after the warranty expired, the fuel pump went out and cost $600 to replace. The dealer installed the pump wrong and as a result we got stranded in Des Moines, Iowa. Then the glow plugs started failing, one by one, about a month apart. About the time we had to change the fourth glow plug, one of the ones we’d already replaced burned out. The glow plugs cost $150 apiece.

“Next, a vacuum/whistling noise developed. The dealer said there was a problem with the EGR valve which was replaced at a cost of $400, but that didn’t solve the problem. Next, some type of flapper valve in the exhaust failed which caused the engine light to go on. The repair cost for new parts and labor was about $400. The car also needed new rear shocks, front-end alignment, and new tires because they were getting chopped up so bad. One of the front outer CV joints had to be replaced at a cost of about $700. The car did average 45 mpg. Finally at 114,000 miles we traded it for a Kia Sorento.”

Worst Buy

Harley Davidson ElectraGlide motorcycle

Clark Carns, Fontanelle, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

Clark’s had problems with his 2009 Harley Davidson ElectraGlide motorcycle. “The same day I bought it I was on the way home when the rear brake pedal came loose from the master cylinder. The front tire ‘cupped’ and had to be replaced. The muffler on one side of the motorcycle has had to be replaced three different times. The rear turn signals fell off and scratched the paint, and the license plate bracket vibrated so bad that it broke in half. The rear wheel bearing went bad, and the gas tank mounting bolt shook out and is missing completely.

“The fuel economy on this motorcycle is terrible. The front wheel weight came off while I was driving in Nebraska, but the dealer told me not to worry about it. Sometimes the cruise control disengages when I hit a bump in the road, and now the front end has started to shake. I’d like to hear from anyone else who has had similar problems with this motorcycle.”

Worst Buy

Stihl MS210 chainsaw

Ronald Miller, Bonner Springs, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“My Stihl MS210 chainsaw is hard to start. I took the saw back to the dealer three different times, but after spending more than $200 it doesn’t work any better. Thank goodness I still have my old Homelite Super XL.”

Best Buy

Sears Professional cordless drill

Brian Talbott, Maryville, Mo. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“I like my Sears Professional cordless drill, which is powered by a 20-volt Lithion battery. This drill has more power than any other drill I’ve owned, including electric drills. I left the battery three fourths charged in an unheated garage for a long time, but it didn’t lose its charge at all.”

Best Buy

John Deere 345 riding mower equipped + 1 more

Wayne K. Johnson, Madison, Mo. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“My 1998 Deere 345 riding mower equipped with a 50-in. deck is dependable and trouble-free. It has about 900 hrs. on it.

“My best buy Troy-Bilt garden tiller, equipped with an 8 hp Kohler electric start motor, is on its third set of blades. The tines on this machine are nearly worn out but it still does a good job.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet garden tiller

Charles Ewton, Chattanooga, Tenn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 13

“I bought my Cub Cadet garden tiller in 2009 but, due to health problems, I didn’t use it until this year. It was stored in the barn kast winter. When I tried to use the tiller last spring the gearshift lever wouldn’t move, and even though the machine was still under warranty the company refused to repair it free of charge. They said the problem was due to moisture in the gearbox. They wanted more money for a new gearbox than what I paid for the tiller itself. Now I have a tiller that I can’t even use.”

Best Buy

DR 6 1/2 hp

Jeffrey Gresch, Marietta, Ga. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

Jeffrey’s impressed with his 2004 DR 6 1/2 hp Powerwagon. “This is my second Powerwagon - the first one was a 4 hp model. I used that machine for 12 years with no problems and then sold it for almost as much as I paid for it. I use the new model almost every day with the sulky. It works even better than advertised, and the customer service is outstanding. No problems.”

Best Buy

Oxy multi-purpose cleaner

John G. Ruff, Logan, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“I like Oxy multi-purpose cleaner. This stuff cleans anything. Just spray it on and wipe with a paper towel. It works better than any cleaner I’ve ever used. I paid only $1 for it, but I suspect this is an introductory price that won’t last long.”

Best Buy

Kubota RTV 900 utility vehicle equipped

Robert C. Petersen, Summerdale, Ala. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“It’s the handiest machine I’ve ever owned,” says Robert about his 2006 Kubota RTV 900 utility vehicle equipped with a winch and dump body. “It has plenty of power and the winch is handy. The only problem I had was with the machine’s plastic radiator, when two pins on the bottom broke off. A new radiator would have cost about $400, so I had a local radiator shop plastic weld it back together.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grasshopper 729 zero turn riding + 1 more

Tom Gibbs, Dauphin, Man. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“My Grasshopper 729 zero turn riding mower performs as well as advertised. It cuts at high ground speeds and does a good job. It’s also easy to service.”

He’s disappointed with the fuel economy on his 2010 Ford Ranger pickup. “This pickup doesn’t even come close to advertised fuel economy. It’s lucky to average 22 mpg, whereas the company advertises 29 mpg.”

Best Buy

Toro Personal Pace lawn mower

Kenneth Carr, Greenville, S.C. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

A Toro Personal Pace lawn mower rates as Kenneth’s “best buy”. “Pushing on the handle regulates the speed of the mower. It always starts and has required very little maintenance. I can walk as fast or slow as the need requires, depending on whether I’m going up or down slopes or working in light or heavy grass.”

Best Buy

Gorilla Lift trailer tailgate lift

Gary K. Gladin, Oakley, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“The 5 by 7-ft. ramp-gate on the 7 by 12-ft. trailer that hauls my riding mower got too heavy, so two years ago I bought a Gorilla Lift trailer tailgate lift assist system (ph 877 388-8895; www.GorillaLift.com). It takes almost all the weight off the trailer’s tailgate and lets me lower it with virtually no effort. It works on tailgates from 4 to 6 ft. high.

“The unit attaches to both sides of the tailgate and fully encloses the lifting system inside a housing. The lifting system consists of 5-ft. long sq. tubes with concentric garage door-like springs inside them and rollers on the ends that guide a cable, which bolts about 3 ft. up on the ramp gate. The housings sit on top of the trailer’s side rails. The instructions that came with the unit were great. Now just a gentle push or pull in either direction is all it takes for the tailgate to float up and down. The entire system is built tough and holding up well.”

Best Buy

Honda Rancher 4-wheeler goes anywhere + 1 more

Jo Nylander, Fulks Run, Va. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“My 2002 Honda Rancher 4-wheeler goes anywhere and has never gotten stuck. It’s a reliable machine.

“My Ryobi weedeater equipped with a brush blade can’t handle anything bigger than a thistle, and that’s provided I can get the machine started. After pulling on the cord for 10 minutes, I’m often too tired to work anyway. I’ve taken this machine in numerous times for repairs.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Tecumseh 8 hp horizontal shaft + 1 more

Joseph Syczylo, North Fork, Idaho · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“My Tecumseh 8 hp horizontal shaft gas engine is my worst buy. It starts hard and needs starting fluid whenever the temperature drops to 30 degrees or below. The carburetor adjusting screw fell out and got lost while I was using the engine to operate a log splitter. I noticed oil coming out of the governor, due to a fitting on the crankcase vent that had frozen with condensation. Finally I replaced the engine with a Honda GX 340 model. It always starts on the first or second pull.”

Best Buy

Ingersoll 4223 lawn tractor

Robert Menard, Portland, Maine · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

Robert’s impressed with his 2008 Ingersoll 4223 lawn tractor. “I bought this tractor directly from the factory in Portland, Maine. It’s a great lawn tractor, with superior craftsmanship and quality construction. It’s powered by a 2-cyl. Briggs Vangard engine, which is tremendously powerful. Multiple attachments are available for this tractor, with the same quality construction. I can mow my 2-acre lawn in half the time it used to take with my old mower. Also, the tractor’s big 16-in. rear tires let it ride smooth on rough ground.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Skil 4 1/2-in angle grinder + 1 more

Charles Plushanski, Kutztown, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

A Skil 4 1/2-in. angle grinder rates as Charles’s “best buy”. “I bought this grinder after my Makita 4 1/2-in. angle grinder broke and use it all the time.

“The Makita grinder lasted only about three weeks and was my worst buy. I was using it to grind down a part on my manure spreader when the gearing inside the unit broke. I found out later that it was made in China.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husqvarna 575 XP chainsaw + 1 more

Adam Nation, Crawford, Ga. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

A 2010 Husqvarna 575 XP chainsaw rates as Adam’s “best buy”. “I use this saw to cut trees every day, and it has plenty of power to go through large hardwoods and pines. It’s a strong, durable saw.

“My Stihl 390 MS chainsaw is my worst buy. One week after I bought it the chain tensioner broke, and recently I had to replace the handle which is made of plastic. Also, I had to replace rubber bushings three times in two years.”

Best Buy

Kuhn 12-wheel SpeedRake

Gregory Innerst, Red Lion, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“My Kuhn 12-wheel SpeedRake is my best buy. My past experience with wheel rakes was terrible, but this V-rake is amazing. It’ll rake anything including wet alfalfa, sudan grass, and even corn stalks. I sold my other rakes, and now this rake is the only one on our farm. My neighbor rented it once and was so impressed that he bought his own. It’s an excellent piece of equipment.”

Best Buy

New Holland TC-40 4-WD tractor

Edward Weber, Cincinnati, Ohio · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“I have almost 1,000 hrs. on my 2003 New Holland TC-40 4-WD tractor with no problems, except for a pin in the forward-reverse shift lever that came out a couple times. I use this tractor with a 6-ft., 3-pt. mounted finish mower and to plow snow with a 7-ft., rear-mount blade. I also use it with a 3-pt. mounted log splitter, a fertilizer and salt spreader, a rear carryall, a rotary tiller and many other pieces of equipment. I mounted a quick hitch on the 3-pt., which makes changing equipment an easier job.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grasshopper 322D riding mower equipped + 1 more

Charles D. Ewton, Chattanooga, Tenn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“My Grasshopper 322D riding mower equipped with a diesel engine is easy to use and has a comfortable seat. It has reduced my mowing time by half.

“My 2009 Cub Cadet RT 65 rototiller is my worst buy. I used it one time last year and then stored it in the barn. When I used it for the first time last spring, the gearshift lever froze up so I couldn’t shift gears. I took the rototiller to a repair shop where I was told the machine had a 2-year warranty. However, the shop called 30 days later and said the gearbox had moisture in it so they wouldn’t repair it under warranty. I have no idea how moisture got into the gearbox.

“I was told a new gearbox would cost almost as much as what I paid for the rototiller. Now I have a new Cub Cadet rototiller that I can’t use because I can’t afford to repair it.”

Best Buy

DR Powerwagon equipped + 1 more

Paul A. Badger, Lecompton, Kan. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

“I’ve used my 2002 DR Powerwagon, equipped with a 6 3/4 hp engine, to haul many loads of firewood with no problems. I bought this little rig with the sulky. The machine came with an interchangeable ABS plastic cargo box, which I’ve used to mix and haul wet concrete. I’m well pleased with my Powerwagon.

“I like my Grasshopper 618 riding mower equipped with an 18 hp Kohler engine, but have had problems with sizing on the drive pulley idler. Otherwise this machine is easy to operate. The deck tilts up, which is really handy for servicing the blades.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Winkler hoop building + 1 more

John & Dave Hebert, Owaneco, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

After feeding cattle on an open concrete slab for several years, John & Dave decided to make the jump to a Winkler hoop building that gives them optimum feeding and environmental conditions and would allow for a deep-bedded manure buildup. The building is 42 by 182 ft. long and houses 80 head at one end. The Heberts are able to let manure build up for about 6 months, using cornstalk bedding. One thing the men say they really like about the building is that it’s about 15 degrees cooler in summer and 15 degrees warmer in winter, even with the open ends. There’s also a ridge vent for summer ventilation. At the center of the building they set up a work and storage area. Simplicity riding mower. “Two days after the warranty expired the brake rod broke. The company paid for the part, but I had to pay for labor and for a new choke cable that the ‘authorized’ dealer broke. Now this mower is sitting out in my barn with a blown as advertised. Because of the heavy use that I give this rig I have to resharpen the blades regularly. However, to do that the blades have to be unscrewed from the flywheel using tools that I made myself. It’s a 2-hour job from start to finish.”

Best Buy

New Holland CR9000

Travis Buhe, Rib Lake, Wis. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

Travis likes his 2010 New Holland CR9000 series Twin Rotor combine. “The twin rotor design results in faster threshing and separating, and the combine has a roomy, quiet cab. The new IntelliView Plus II color touch-screen display on my combine has a 10.4-in. diagonal screen. It allows me to monitor the combine’s rotor speed, header height, engine rpm’s, percent of engine load, sieve performance, grain loss, returns, and self-leveling cleaning system.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Amsoil motor oil + 1 more

Richard Miller, Bloomfield, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

Richard likes Amsoil motor oil. “We ran a new stationary engine on break-in oil for about 85 hrs., then installed a bypass oil filter system and switched to using Amsoil 15W40 diesel and marine oil. Since then we’ve put more than 2,500 hrs. on the engine without an oil change, but every 300 hrs. we do change two filters and add some replacement oil. Every 600 to 900 hrs. we have the oil analyzed, and it always shows very little wear. The use of Amsoil also resulted in a cooler running engine and easier starting in cold weather. We also use Amsoil in our small motors with good success. I’m not a dealer, just a satisfied customer.

“We tried using a Hydro Fuel Maximizer made by Advanced Hydrogen Technology, but it didn’t work for us. It’s an electrolysis unit that uses 15 to 40 amps to break water down into oxygen and hydrogen and slowly releases the gases into the combustion air intake. It’s supposed to enhance combustion of petroleum fuel.

“We bought it to save diesel fuel on our stationary engine and installed it following the company’s directions. We saw no decrease in fuel consumption. If anyone has had more success with this unit we’d like to hear from them.”

Best Buy

Jeep Patriot

Kevin R. Pfautsch, Dunkerton, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“Our 2008 Jeep Patriot has exceeded our expectations. The fit and finish on it are excellent. We bought this vehicle mainly for its fuel efficiency and it has performed as well as the salesman said it would.

“The only problem with the Jeep is the limb saw. “I’ve already had to replace the trim head on this machine twice.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 pickup equipped

Steven Scheer, Lowden, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“Five years ago we paid $850 for a used 1984 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with an 11-ft. flatbed. We used the pickup for two years to haul four tons of sand for our sandblasting outfit across a 3-state area. Since then, this pickup has made countless trips out of our woods, loaded with firewood. The pickup is equipped with an-line, 6-cyl. engine and 4-speed transmission. It has required only routine maintenance and doesn’t use any oil.

“It’s old enough to vote and is really ugly. But I figure that for every four loads of wood that it hauls, it pays for itself one more time. I’ve put almost 30,000 miles on it.”

Best Buy

Skag Turf Tiger zero turn riding + 2 more

Scott Werling, Decatur, Ind. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My 2003 Skag Turf Tiger zero turn riding mower, equipped with a 27 hp Kawasaki engine, is a best buy. It’s comparable in quality to Exmark mowers, which I’ve also owned. I did have one problem with the Skag a couple weeks after I bought it. I was mowing next to a heavy rubber mat, which accidentally got sucked up into the deck. The machine stopped dead in its tracks. The engine was running at top speed, and I was sure I had broken the crankshaft. But luckily all that broke was a lower pulley on the mower deck, and it was covered by the warranty. The dealer sent a replacement pulley to my house so I could fix it myself. I love this machine.

“Last December I bought a Hobart 210 wire welder. I haven’t yet tapped into the full potential of this machine, even though I’ve already used it to weld thick metals. It’s a good welder.”

Best Buy

Rubbermaid

William J. Rappe, Ipswich, S. Dak. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“I’ve purchased a number of products from Rubbermaid, including sawhorses and garbage cans, and have always been impressed by the quality and durability of their products. The company stands behind everything they make and offers great customer service.”

Best Buy

Grizzly wood working equipment

Ted Luckenbaugh, Abbottstown, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“I’m impressed with Grizzly wood working equipment (ph 800 523-4777 or 360 647-0801; www.grizzly.com). I own a Grizzly table saw, band saw, and jointer and they all work well. These products are built to last a long time. Great company service.”

Best Buy

Polaris 550 4-WD ATV

Don Bulechek, Iowa City, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My 2010 Polaris 550 4-WD ATV has electronic power steering and works great. We raise beef cattle on rough pasture and artificially inseminate the cows, so we do a lot of slow speed driving. We put about 1,000 miles per year on this ATV just for farm work. We’ve owned seven Polaris ATV’s since 1988.”

Best Buy

Case 430 skid loader

Lyndon Dunbar, Brighton, Iowa · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My 2008 Case 430 skid loader has a low profile that lets me get into low clearance buildings. The operator’s compartment is roomy for my long legs and arms. I use it to stack large round bales on end 3-high in my barn, and it’s very stable doing this. I bought it with the high-speed transport option, which reduces my travel time between farmsteads by half. I also use the foot throttle option a lot.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 4710 tractor + 1 more

David A. Lizotte, Sprucehead, Maine · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My 2006 Deere 4710 48-hp tractor is the perfect size for my needs. I actually bought this tractor in 2008 with 123 hours on it. It had been loaned by Deere to the Kansas City Chiefs as a field tractor, and then sold to a local dealer here in Maine. This tractor works well in confined wooded areas. It’s low to the ground and is equipped with turf tires which provide excellent traction. No problems. I also own another 4710 model that I bought in 2005. Both tractors are powered by excellent Yanmar 4-cyl. diesel engines that run smooth and quiet.”

On the negative side, “My 2007 Deere 4320 tractor was noisy and leaked diesel fuel. Sometimes the turbocharger caused the tractor to accelerate by surprise and if I hit a bump loads of firewood would spill out. I traded it in favor of the 4710.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota L5240 tractor + 2 more

Ken Wasserzieher, Aitkin, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“In 2007 I bought a new Kubota L5240 tractor which is my worst buy. A pin on the 3-pt. lift arm broke. If the arm ends were a yoke I feel it wouldn’t have been a problem. Also, the 3-pt. lift doesn’t operate smoothly. From start to shutdown the tractor squeaks and squeals constantly. After about 250 hours of use the fuel gauge quit working and the dealer couldn’t fix it. It’s also hard on fuel. This tractor must have been cobbled together on a Monday or a Friday. I plan to trade it off.

“In 2005 my son and I bought a Valtra 6350HT tractor equipped with a Quickie Q1060 front-end loader. It’s economical and has a lot of power and traction. It’s a great tractor.

“We use all three of these tractors to harvest firewood and gather maple sap and to do other chores, so we don’t put a lot of hours on any of them.”

Best Buy

Ultra-Cut Gold Stick

Chuck Smith, Dunkirk, N.Y. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My best buy is Ultra-Cut Gold Stick which is a drill and cutting lubricant (Kimball Midwest, ph 800 233-1294). If you start out with a sharp drill bit and use this product according to the company’s directions, the bits stay sharp and cut easily.”

Worst Buy

Bombardier 330 Outlander 4-wheeler atv

Perry Eide, International Falls, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My Bombardier 330 Outlander 4-wheeler ATV is my worst buy. I used it very little the first year. The next year the high temperature alarm went on, even though the motor wasn’t hot. I took it to the dealer who knew right away that the problem was a bad temperature sensor. But the warranty had expired, and neither he nor the company would help.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hesston 1120 haybine + 2 more

Lawrence Bannerman, Holly, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

Lawrence is disappointed with his 2008 Hesston 1120 haybine. “When the haybine was delivered it wasn’t completely put together and the dealer wouldn’t do anything about it. I used the machine to cut about five acres of hay and it shook so bad the knife broke. The dealer took it back and said he fixed it, but the next year it didn’t work any better. I took the haybine back to the dealer for repair and when I went to pick it up the dealer said the warranty had expired and I had to pay $500 to get the machine back. Since then I’ve cut only about 50 acres with it and have spent $1,000 on repairs.

“My 1979 New Holland 489 haybine was able to cut about 5,000 acres of hay before it broke down and I had to spend $900 on a new gearbox. But since I bought the Hesston model I’ve cut 600 acres of hay with the old New Holland model and only about 50 acres with the Hesston.” Goodyear Conquest TSI series tires on it. After only about 29,000 miles we’ve already had to replace three of the tires. The tires start separating in the center of the tread, and then the steel belting starts to protrude. We’ve gone to two local Goodyear dealers with no satisfaction. No more Goodyear products for us.”

Best Buy

Toyota Sienna van + 1 more

James C. Walker, Pinewood, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“In 2003 we bought a used 2002 Toyota Sienna van with about 20,000 miles on it. Now it has more than 230,000 miles. Everything on the van is original except for parts that were replaced on a scheduled maintenance program. The battery is still going strong. I can’t find anything negative to say about this van.

“I have a problem with using modern gas in older engines. For example, I have a 1946 Allis Chalmers WD tractor that I’ve used for 25 years. It wouldn’t pull or idle well on the new gas until I started adding a quart of automatic transmission fluid to each 5 gal. of gas. I also installed electronic ignition and one-step-hotter spark plugs. Now the tractor runs great.”

Best Buy

Bobcat skid loader equipped

Ken Barlau, Delano, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

A used 1999 Bobcat skid loader equipped with a Kubota diesel engine rates as Ken’s “best buy”. “This is a powerful machine that has made cattle farming much easier for us. I use it to load manure, push snow, and dig trenches with a backhoe that we made for tiling cropland. This skid loader has been trouble-free, and I’ll buy another if this one ever wears out.”

Best Buy

My Earthquake dirt auger is a handy ATV attachment

Jim Ruen, Lanesboro, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

“My Earthquake dirt auger is a handy ATV attachment. It’ll never replace a full-size auger, but mounted on the hydraulic loader on my 500cc Honda, it does a good job for its size. The 8-in. auger is just the right size for smaller posts and creates a good pilot hole for larger posts. I’ve even used it for planting raspberries. I just went down the row, digging 1-ft. deep holes every 3 ft. It only took a few minutes dropping the starters in, and I had 180 ft. of raspberries ready to grow.

The 2-hp Tecumseh engine that powers it is a little lightweight, but does a decent job in most soils. Mounted on the hydraulic Groundhog loader, it self-centers, and I have down pressure. If I am on a slope, I do need to either be directly up hill or down from the hole site for a straight hole. It’s not perfect, but mounted on the ATV, it gets in a lot of spots where a larger rig couldn’t go. Even if I have to enlarge the hole some by hand, the Earthquake makes a good start.”