Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012)

82 reports from pages 12–15 · 69 Best Buys21 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

John Deere 825i Gator 4-WD utility vehicle

Stanley Johnson, Wyandotte, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

Stanley’s had a lot of trouble with his 2010 Deere 825i Gator 4-WD utility vehicle. “We owned a Gator before so when they came out with the new design, we decided to try it. However, we found the new Gator to be poorly designed and cheaply made. We bought it with a cab and heater for about $20,000. Many of the parts on this vehicle are made in China, including the engine,” says Stanley.

“This rig has had one problem after another. The engine’s drive belt slips all the time and makes a screaming sound. The air intake valve fell off one day when my son was driving down the road, and we ended up using my wife’s nylon stocking for a filter. The doors won’t stay closed and the tires were way too thin and already had to be replaced. The treads are hardly worn at all, but the tires are made from thin material that punctures way too easily. And when you do get a flat tire, you have to use a high lift jack to lift the bed 2 ft. up in the air just to change the tire.

“The gear shifter is made from lightweight material and had to be replaced under warranty. Every time I shifted gears, it felt like I was going to bend it. Another problem is the shifter has to be in exactly the right position or the vehicle won’t even start. A buzzer sounds every time the emergency brake is set, which is about the only thing we can count on working.

“The frame of the cab is made from poly with a glass windshield. The dump bed has a metal floor but plastic on the sides and back. One time I tried to pull my kids on a sled behind the vehicle and hooked a chain up to the front of the bed, so it bent back. The hydraulic cylinders on the dump bed are too small and bent right away.

“We were told by the dealer to keep the heater on during the summer just so the vehicle won’t overheat. If we turn the lights on at night, the battery soon runs down. The fuel gauge is located on top of the gas tank, so the driver has to get out of the cab and look under the vehicle just to see how much gas is in the tank.

“The cab was installed several months after we bought the vehicle. When they came out to our farm to install it they only sent one guy, even though the cab is too heavy for one person to lift. He didn’t even bring any tools with him and had to use mine.

“All together we’ve had the vehicle in to the dealer 3 times, and the dealer has come out to our place 3 times. All we use it for is to check on our cows on pasture, to haul 5-gal. buckets of feed with milk bottles for our calves, along with an occasional bale of straw. In my opinion this Gator is made for hobby farmers who just want to cruise around; it isn’t made for hard use. We could have bought a Jeep Wrangler for the money we’ve spent on this machine.

“We’re still making payments on the Gator, and if we weren’t ‘upside down’ on this vehicle we’d sell it in a heartbeat. I think Deere is riding the shirt tails of their reputation and selling disposable green plastic. After this experience we’ll never buy another Deere of any kind.”

Best Buy

All Bikes salvage yard

James R. Allen, Columbia, Tenn. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“After reading the article in FARM SHOW’s Vol. 36, No. 1 last January, about All Bikes salvage yard in Arizona, I ordered a used rear master cylinder for a 1980 900 Honda CB custom cycle for $357.48. The check was cashed but after that, nothing. I have been unable to contact them by phone, and a registered letter went unanswered. I have contacted the Better Business Bureau and will be pursuing other avenues. All I want now is my money back.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 4-WD

Zachary Moss, Hernando, Fla. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“My 2003 Dodge Ram 3500 4-WD with Cummins engine gets 20 mpg if I keep it under 70 mph. I bought it new and have only had two problems so far. The A/C ducts will no longer switch from dash to floor. At 60,000 miles the brake pads started rubbing and heating the rotor. I was told the plastic pistons that are now used in the calipers have to be replaced periodically because they expand from the heat and do not retract far enough to stop the pads from rubbing.”

Best Buy

Cooper Avalanch Extreme tires

Larry Hilliard, Sandy, Oregon · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“I bought a set of Cooper Avalanch Extreme tires for my 4-WD pickup. They are by far the best all-weather tires on the market. You can’t believe how well they work in snow. They are factory-siped and have a deep tread and get good mileage.”

Best Buy

Last Glue

Joni Lund, Carrington, N. Dak. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“The best glue I’ve ever used is Last Glue (ph 905 465-3805; www.thelastglue.com). Just a tiny drop of glue guarantees an excellent hold. Works best on non porous items like wood, steel, aluminum, porcelain, glass, rubber, pvc, plastic, and leather. Great to repair shoes and boots.”

Best Buy

Dixie Chopper Turbinator zero turn mower

Gary Schultz, Janesville, Wis. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“My 2000 Dixie Chopper Turbinator zero turn mower equipped with a 72-in. deck still runs great. It can go through 10-in. tall grass and leave the lawn looking like it was mowed twice.

“This mower is equipped with two 20 hp gas engines. It’s really fun to operate and will go up to 12 mph. I can cut 4 1/2 acres in only 2 hours. It’s so much fun to use that I can hardly wait for the grass to grow.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Makita 18-volt cordless tools + 1 more

William Miller, West Springfield, Penn. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“I work for American Eagle Windmills, and the Makita 18-volt cordless tools we use on the job work great. We tried using a couple other brands but these tools have more power and are compact, which makes them easy to use in tight spots. It takes only 10 to 12 min. to charge the batteries.

“My Sears Craftsman socket set doesn’t stay organized in its case, and the first time I used it I broke some of the sockets. I have to keep running to the store to replace sockets. These sockets are built with about the same quality as Harbor Freight tools.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6405 85 hp

Tom Grilliot, Hutchinson, Kansas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 12

“I’ve had good luck with my 2002 Deere 6405 85 hp MFWD tractor equipped with a 640 front-end loader with bucket and bale spear. This tractor has about 2,300 hours on it and has made about 12,000 round bales with a New Holland 664 baler. No major problems. A small oil leak developed in the oil filter line and there was a problem with the air conditioning compressor, but the dealer promptly fixed everything under warranty. The tractor is equipped with a 3-speed transmission with 4 ranges so it can go from 1/2 mph to 18 1/2 mph.”

Best Buy

Ford tractor + 1 more

Terry Hill, Ceresco, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“The Ford 2000 tractor my grandpa bought new in 1973 still has the original engine, starter and Firestone tires. It has about 3,300 trouble-free hours and we use it almost every day.

“We attend 5 different farmer’s markets from May through October so we bought a couple of canopies from TSC on sale for $50 apiece. I figured we would get at least one year’s use out of them, but they lasted only a month. The frames bent and broke and the canopies weren’t waterproof.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 155 articulated riding mower

Bruce W. Johnson, Wendell, N.C. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“My 2003 Husqvarna 155 articulated riding mower is equipped with a 41-in. front-mount deck that mows just as well as my old Gravely L riding mower. This mower is equipped with a foot pedal-operated hydro transmission which allows either slow or fast forward movement while keeping the blades going at full speed. And it uses a steering wheel instead of levers, which I like. It’ll mow right around trees thanks to a tight turning radius of 4 ft.”

Best Buy

Deutz 06 tractors

Emery Beachy, Hardin, Mo. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“I like my older Deutz 06 tractors. In 35 years of farming with mostly Deutz tractors, only one has ever been back to the dealer for repairs. The other brands I’ve tried are long gone. These tractors are well-built, fuel-efficient, and simple enough for any farmer to maintain. I especially like that they have ‘instant’ cold start. Just hop on the seat, pull the start switch and they’re running. No waiting a long time for the engine to preheat. Also, there are no extra electronics and emission control junk to create problems.”

Best Buy

CBC 40 backhoe

Rosendo Pena, Jr., Three Rivers, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“My 2008 CBC 40 backhoe is easy to operate and also easy to transport (ph 541 582-2583). It does the same work as a bigger backhoe, at less cost.”

Best Buy

Honda CRV car

Bentley Howard, Gouldsboro, Maine · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“My 2000 Honda CRV car has more than 253,000 miles but is still going strong. It doesn’t burn oil and is fuel efficient. I’ve had to replace only normal ‘wear’ parts. I wouldn’t hesitate to buy another one.”

Best Buy

Bobcat S300 skid loader equipped + 1 more

Eugene Miller, Rawling, Wyo. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

Eugene’s the satisfied owner of a 2008 Bobcat S300 skid loader equipped with a Loegering tracked undercarriage system (ph 800 373-5441; www.loegering.com). “We operate a fencing business and work in a lot of rough country. The Loeggering track system adds weight and increases stability. If we want we can switch back to tires in less than 30 min. We make hay during the summer and like to use wheels when stacking hay.”

Best Buy

Poulan riding mower went

Fred L. Homburg, Warsaw, Ind. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“The of tires. The brakes have never been adjusted and it still has the original spark plugs. It always starts right up.

“The Briggs & Stratton 22 hp engine on my Poulan riding mower went bad 6 times in one summer. It bent a push rod 5 times, and the valve guide slipped. I installed another head with valves but then the engine threw a rod and busted the piston and crankcase. I finally replaced the engine with an older Briggs & Stratton which has worked fine.”

Worst Buy

Wolverine boots

William A. Morneault, Humble, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

He’s disappointed with Wolverine boots. “I bought a pair of these boots about 2 years ago and only wore them 4 or 5 times. I went to use them late last year and when I picked them up from the closet floor, heel and sole material had crumbled like yesterday’s corn bread. A call to the company connected me to customer service, and the girl who answered snottily asked, ‘How long do you expect them to last?’ All she offered was a 20 percent discount for a replacement pair. Big deal. I can beat that offer all over town. It’s really sad to see a one-time good company go so wrong.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 pickup

Robert J. Zeimetz, Mondovi, Wis. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“It’s the best truck I’ve ever had,” says Robert about his 2009 Dodge 1500 pickup which has more than 94,000 trouble-free miles on it. “The 5.7-liter Hemi engine has unbelievable power.”

Best Buy

Farmall

Carl Schultheis, Caro, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“Our Farmall A tractor had no starter or lights or pto when dad bought it back in 1941. It was equipped from the factory with 9-24 tires, but dad soon put 10-24 tires on it.

“When I was about 5 years old he installed a starter, lights and pto on the tractor so I could start and drive it. It was the only tractor he used for about 10 years, working 60 acres of hilly, heavy clay ground to support his dairy herd. He used the tractor with a single 16-in. plow, a 5-ft. double cultipacker, a single 6-ft. disk, a 3-section drag, and a 13-hoe grain drill. The same tractor was used to mow hay with a 5-ft. mower. It also did the raking and hauled the wagons with a hay loader behind. He also pulled a 4 1/2-ft. cut combine with it.

“That tractor had a hard life, being used just about every day until I retired from the dairy business in 1995. It never got a break during the winter. We put chains on it and used it to keep snow off our driveway. I’m not sure just how many sets of tires it went through. I think the engine is on its third set of pistons and sleeves and the crankshaft was ground once. The clutch was also replaced once.

“I learned to drive on that tractor, as did my kids, and I know my grandkids will drive it, too. Any time we ask this tractor to do a full day’s work, it gladly tackles the task without complaint.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 250 skid loader + 3 more

Parker Beaupre, Groton, Vt. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“It has been a dependable machine so far,” says Parker about his 1999 Deere 250 skid loader. “This model doesn’t have the best reputation, but my dealer thoroughly serviced it before I bought it. I use it with Loegering steel tracks during the summer and tire chains during the winter, which allows it to perform all the loader work on my 200-acre farm and woodlot. I use a number of attachments with it, which makes my life easier every day.

“My worst buy is the pellet stove I bought from U.S. Stove Co. When it works this furnace does a good job of heating my large old house, but it seems to go out often for no apparent reason. Then I restart the fire and away it goes – but only for a while.” Harbor Freight cargo nets that I bought for my Chevy S-10 pickup and my 6 by 8 by 2 trailer are best buys. The nets with wire hooks work better than the ones with big, flat plastic hooks. As a volunteer I haul large loads of food for food pantries, bags of used clothes for shelters, and cab-high loads of flattened cardboard for recycling. The net stretches over the most irregular loads and keeps everything intact.

“A lot of my friends think Poulan chainsaws are junk, but I use only Poulan Wild Thing saws and really like them. I buy the saws used at auctions and garage sales and throw them away if they cause trouble. They all use the same chains and sprockets so I can interchange parts. The company’s toll-free phone number for parts is printed right on the saw and has been helpful. I always get good service. I currently own five of these saws.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Homelite chainsaw + 1 more

Howard Waller, Webbers Falls, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

Howard’s satisfied with his Homelite 42cc, 14-in. chainsaw. “It’s light and handy, once I take off the safety tip that restricts the cut to about 12 in. Best of all it starts with a couple of pulls, unlike my Poulan and Stihl models.”

On the negative side, he lists his 1999 Ford F-250 Superduty pickup equipped with a Triton 5.4-liter engine. “An oil leak developed between the head and block and cost $1,900 to repair. Also, the heads only have 4 threads in the spark plug ports with aluminum inserts rather than steel inserts, like on a real engine. Ford should have stuck with what they were good at – cast iron and push rods, not aluminum and overhead cams.”

Worst Buy

Volkswagen Jetta diesel

Bill Skipper, Carrollton, Ohio · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 13

“I’ve been buying cars for 45 years, but this one is the worst,” says Bill about his 2000 Volkswagen Jetta diesel. “It’s not as much a car problem as a company problem.

“I bought the car used with about 124,000 miles. The timing belt had been changed at 97,000 miles but at 136,000 miles the belt broke, and because of the engine design it ruined the head. The company wanted to install a new engine at a cost of $7,000. Fortunately, I knew someone who was able to fix the head for $2,200.

“At about 172,000 miles the car’s automatic transmission went out, and because the company doesn’t sell any repair parts the only option is to spend $4,000 for a new transmission. For that expense they’ll give you a whopping 12,000-mile warranty. The company has also been involved in a class action lawsuit for not releasing key codes. You had to go to a dealer to get a replacement key that cost $800. The turbocharger has a faulty wastegate that I can’t get parts for, and a new turbocharger costs $1,100. So at this point I have a car sitting in my driveway with a good running diesel engine that won’t go anywhere.”

Best Buy

Ford Edge

Ernest A. Sjuts, Urbane, Ill. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“This is the quietest and smoothest vehicle we’ve ever owned,” says Ernest about his 2011 Ford Edge. “It turns short, is fuel efficient, and easy to enter and exit. Also, the driver has a great view.”

Best Buy

Ford F-100 pickup

Richard Smith, Piketon, Ohio · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“It takes me back and forth to work in all kinds of weather,” says Richard, pleased with his 1980 Ford F-100 pickup with about 55,000 miles on it. “This pickup provides reliable transportation that shade-tree mechanics can appreciate, and parts for it are cheap. It has required only routine maintenance.”

Best Buy

Super Clean degreasing product

Cora Berg, Yacolt, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“I’ve used Super Clean degreasing product for years to remove thick grease on several restoration projects, including my 1956 Farmall (ph 800 501-1702; www.superclean.com). It comes in a spray bottle. You just squirt it on and the grease dissolves. To get rid of heavier coats of grease I use a brush and make several applications. It leaves everything spotless and is biodegradable. Just rinse with water.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-550 pickup equipped

Brent Strickland, Louisburg, N.C. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Brent’s disappointed with his 2003 Ford F-550 pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine. “The engine goes down often and always costs $1,500 to $2,000 to fix even when the problems are minor. Now it needs a new automatic transmission, even though it has only about 100,000 miles on it. This pickup has been a $30,000 disappointment.”

Best Buy

Edge CS engine tuner

Brad Whitaker, Linneus, Mo. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Brad installed an Edge CS engine tuner on his 2005 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty, 4-WD pickup equipped with a Duramax engine (ph 888 360-3343; www.edgeproducts.com). He also installed a new 4-in. exhaust and cold air intake. The CS tuner consists of an in-cab controller, monitor and digital gauge display with a full-color, high-resolution screen.

“We liked the pickup but were disappointed with the fuel efficiency. Then we talked to a local service manager and he recommended the Edge tuner and to upgrade the exhaust and cold air intake. We experienced a 2 to 4 mpg improvement in fuel efficiency and a lot more power.”

Best Buy

Ram dually pickup equipped

Ron Kraemer, Norfolk, Neb. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“It pulls my 35-ft. fifth wheel camper and 22-ft. gooseneck flatbed trailer with ease,” says Ron about his 1996 Dodge dually pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and 5-speed transmission. It has about 235,000 miles on it. “This pickup is easy to maintain and the fuel efficiency keeps improving the more I drive it. I recently put more than 2,000 miles on it hauling a tractor from Idaho to Nebraska, and it averaged 16 mpg.”

Best Buy

Voltman rebuilt battery pack + 1 more

Vernon Noell, Westlake Village, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Vernon’s impressed with his Voltman rebuilt battery pack (ph 419 526-1570; www.voltmanbatteries.com). The company says that if you have a rechargeable power tool battery pack that’s gone bad, they can rebuild it. “The battery pack they rebuilt for me works better than the original,” says Noell.

He’s happy with the inflatable Air Dancer he uses as a moving scarecrow to keep birds away (ph 866 586-3888; www.lookourway.com). Air Dancers consist of a 20-ft. tall tube made of high strength polyamide nylon silk that flaps back and forth, powered by a 1 hp industrial fan.

Worst Buy

The Tire Rack

Franklin Russell, Speedwell, Tenn. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“The four Kumho Solus KR21 tires I bought for my pickup from an online tire site called The Tire Rack are my worst buy. Before I could put 8,000 miles on them, 3 of the tires were so out of round and wobbly that I couldn’t even use them. The tires were warranted against defects in workmanship and materials for 6 years. They promised free replacement for the first 2/32 in. of tread wear, and then pro-rated from there to the final 2/32 in. of tread. However, the company said that since I had owned the tires for 2 years they were no longer under warranty.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped

Jack Willis, Lind, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Jack’s impressed with his 2007 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck and 18 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. “I’ve worked the heck out of this mower but it just keeps on running. We live on 1 1/2 acres in dryland wheat country and mow everything on it, even going right over gopher mounds. I change the blades twice a year and all is good. It was a great buy at $999.”

Best Buy

Carolina Carports Inc

Bill Johnson, APO, AE · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Bill’s the satisfied owner of a 16 by 20-ft. equipment shed he bought from Carolina Carports Inc. (ph 800 670-4262; www.carolinacarportsinc.com). “Their online custom ordering process is simple and you can see exactly what it will cost as you add or subtract features. The building was delivered on time and erected by a professional crew. It’s built solid and is weathertight. I’m happy with it.”

Worst Buy

Ram 1500 2-WD pickup

Dennis C. Coulter, Chaplin, Ky. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“This is the worst new vehicle I’ve ever owned,” says Dennis about his 2006 Dodge Ram 1500 2-WD pickup. “At about 30,000 miles the rear end started locking up whenever I turned from a stop, and at about 32,000 miles the CD player quit working. Then at about 35,000 miles the right front wheel bearing went out. The dealer wouldn’t fix any of these problems and said they were all due to normal wear and tear. At about 50,000 miles the recirculate door in the heater box broke.”

Worst Buy

Bosch front load clothes

Anthony Indiek, Spearville, Kansas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

Anthony’s disappointed with his Bosch front load clothes washing machine. “The back part of the machine’s center tub deteriorated and broke - it looked like something had eaten the metal. The machine came with a 2-year warranty but was 2 years and 3 months old when this problem happened. It would have cost more than $600 to repair, so instead I bought a new washing machine of a different brand. The company did give me a $250 adjustment.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 20 hp lawn tractor

Marvin W. Dechant, Ness City, Kansas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“Three years ago I bought a Sears Craftsman 20 hp lawn tractor equipped with electric start and an automatic transmission. The engine would often flood, and I had to keep buying spark plugs and blowing gas out the spark plug hole. A pair of wires at the bottom of the carburetor are supposed to automatically adjust the gas flow, but it wasn’t working. I bought a new carburetor but it didn’t help. I finally installed a shutoff valve in the fuel line between the fuel tank and the carburetor, which lets me adjust the gas flow by hand.”

Best Buy

Kubota L2550 30 hp tractor equipped

Chris Scigliano, Leeds, N. Dak. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

A 1987 Kubota L2550 30 hp tractor equipped with a front-end loader and backhoe rates as Chris’s “best buy”. “I bought this tractor used with less than 300 hours, and now after many thousands of hours it still works perfect. It has required only oil and filter changes and 2 sets of new tires. It starts instantly and has plenty of power.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Case IH RXM 340 tandem disk + 2 more

James Konechne, Kimball, S. Dak. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“I’ve used several different disks in my life but this is the best ever,” says James about his Case IH RXM 340 tandem disk. “Depth adjustment is a simple matter of turning a crank. The implement works at the same depth all across the field.

“My Silencer hydraulic chute with overhead scale makes working cattle a much easier job (ph 308 536-2369; www.silencerchutes.com).

“My 2008 Vermeer 605M round baler may be the heaviest baler ever built, but the bearings on it were junk. We could hardly go to the field without a bearing going out. We finally traded it for a different model.”

Best Buy

Boxer 320 mini stand-on skid

Ty Witt, Lamar, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

“I like my Boxer 320 mini stand-on skid loader so much that I might have to put it in my will (ph 800 654-6433; www.boxerequipment.com). I bought this machine for cleaning out horse stalls which have 40-in. wide doors, and it has been far more useful than we ever imagined. I even use it to carry large square bales that we feed to our calves whenever our big skid loader or tractor is down. It has been a real backsaver.

“I like using it to help our neighbors out as well. People are amazed that a stand-on skid loader the size of an ATV can do the job of a full-size payloader. We currently have a set of pallet forks and a bucket for it, but we plan on buying a few more of the 50 available attachments for it such as a tiller and posthole digger. I’d recommend this unit to anyone.”

Best Buy

Toro Wheel Horse 522XI garden tractor equipped

James Snyder, Norton, Ohio · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 14

James is the satisfied owner of a 1999 Toro Wheel Horse 522XI garden tractor equipped with a 48-in. recycler deck. “It still amazes me how well this mower grinds up yard waste. It not only makes cut grass disappear but also grinds up leaves and tree trimming material, and even standing sweet corn stalks.”

Best Buy

Case IH 3320 sprayer

Josh Goehring, Delmont, S. Dak. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“I work for an ag co-op where we use a 2008 Case IH 3320 sprayer that has 1,800 hours on it with no problems. This machine is well balanced and fuel efficient. I’ve driven every sprayer known to man, but nothing compares to this one. After we bought this model we bought 5 more, and all have been trouble-free.”

Best Buy

Ram 3/4-ton pickup equipped

Roger Hyatt, Salome, Ariz. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“It has plenty of power to pull trailers and gets 22 mpg on the highway empty,” says Roger, pleased with his 2004 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a Hemi engine. “It has about 120,000 miles on it, yet all I’ve replaced are the front brakes and power steering pump.”

Best Buy

Hitachi cordless drill

Grady C. Morey, Sylvester, Ga. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Grady’s satisfied with his 2008 Hitachi cordless drill. “It works even better than I expected, but after 4 years of use the tool’s performance declined so I returned it to the service center for repairs. The manufacturer restored it to original specifications at no cost and returned the tool within 5 days. They even paid for the shipping.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman 75-piece combination tap

Ken Abbott, Big Timber, Montana · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Ken nominates his Sears Craftsman 75-piece combination tap and die carbon steel set as his “worst buy”. “The 3/8 by 16-in. die chipped. I took it back to the store but they just told me to contact the warranty center, which I did. I sent 2 letters but never got an answer. It’s frustrating to buy a tap and die set made in the U.S. for Sears and then be unable to get a replacement part for it. I’m disappointed in Sears. I’ve trusted them my entire life.”

Best Buy

Menards

Neal Galloway, Lynch, Neb. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“My best buy is the 30 by 45-ft. post frame building equipped with 16-ft. sidewalls that I bought at Menards. The company provides complete instructions for putting the building up. I was able to complete the building myself, using my Farmall Super M tractor and F-11 front-end loader. I rented some portable scaffolding and hired someone to install the cement floor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 5310 + 1 more

Larry R. Cline, Pine Village, Ind. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“My Deere 5310 and 4720 loader tractors never fail to do the job and always start right up. They work great for doing everything from cleaning snow off driveways to mowing hay, pulling a Deere round baler, and feeding bales to livestock. The 4720 is just the right size for performing smaller jobs around the farm yard.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2012 Ford Escape SUV equipped with a 6-liter engine and 6-speed automatic transmission. “It does a terrible job of shifting gears whenever the temperature is between 35 and 55 degrees. It slips between third and fourth gear and then ‘slam shifts’ between fourth and fifth gear. I’ve been back to the dealer several times and also called the company. They claim they’ll fix the problem but it hasn’t happened yet. They did increase the shift point rpm’s of the engine, but all that did was lower the fuel efficiency.”

Best Buy

Dremel 200 2-speed rotary tool

Wilson Rickenbaker, Lexington, S.C. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Wilson’s pleased with his Dremel 200 2-speed rotary tool. “I use it mostly for sharpening flail mower blades using the lawn mower blade sharpening accessory. When the switch failed, the company repaired the tool free under warranty and returned it quickly.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-250 pickup equipped

Larry Jinnette, Goldsboro, N.C. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Larry’s “worst buy” is his 2006 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine. “The engine blew at about 44,000 miles and the company won’t do anything about it. I’ve bought dozens of Fords over the last 45 years, but this is my last one.”

Best Buy

Troy-Bilt rototiller

Dennis Janowiak, South Bend, Ind. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Back in 1974 Dennis bought a new Troy-Bilt rototiller and is still using it today on his 1/2-acre garden. “It works great not only to till the soil but also to cultivate between rows. I replaced the engine in 1991, but otherwise it has required only routine maintenance.”

Worst Buy

Ram Nitro 4-WD SUV

Jerry Overdorf, Pingree, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Jerry describes his 2010 Dodge Nitro 4-WD SUV as “a big disappointment.” “This vehicle was a gas guzzler and got only 19 mpg. It was hard to see out the rear view mirrors, it was hard to get in, and it rode like a truck. It came equipped with 20-in. tires which are twice as expensive as 15 or 16-in. radial tires. It was a stylish vehicle and did have one redeeming feature – the 4-WD was easy to get in and out of. I finally traded the vehicle at about 8,000 miles.”

Best Buy

Optima batteries

John Ulaminck, Grass Valley, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“I’ve had good luck with Optima batteries. I started using them 15 years ago on all my equipment and still have most of them. I’ve had as many as 33 batteries at a time. I don’t have to worry about adding water or acid. I just install the batteries and forget about them.”

Best Buy

Great Dane Surfer zero turn riding

Clay Spencer, Somerville, Ala. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Clay’s impressed with his Great Dane Surfer zero turn riding mower equipped with a stand-on platform on back (ph 920 756-2141; www.greatdanemowers.com). “I bought this mower used so I don’t know how old it is. I do know it’s the heaviest built mower I’ve ever seen - the 52-in. deck is made from 1/4-in. thick steel. It’ll go up to 5 mph, turns short, and will mow steep slopes in all directions. I’ve used this rig to mow in woods and even to cut 1-in. dia. saplings. It’s fun to use.”

Best Buy

New Holland TM-140 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Donald B. Colvin, Whittemore, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Donald’s the proud owner of a 2006 New Holland TM-140 4-WD tractor equipped with a New Holland 62LB front-end loader. “This tractor has about 3,300 hours of use without a single problem. It always starts, even in the coldest weather.

“My 2006 New Holland LS 170 skid loader has also been trouble-free, other than the replacement of 2 bearings and a couple of hydraulic hoses.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt 1 1/2-in heavy duty die + 2 more

Pat Macha, Marlin, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“My DeWalt 1 1/2-in. heavy duty die grinder is built tough and is dependable.

“Changing the oil on my 2009 Honda Big Red utility vehicle is a pain. The oil filter is hard to replace and the drain plug is hard to access. Another problem is the air filter pulls dirty air from under the passenger seat behind the front right wheel, resulting in excessive dirt on the filter. The filter has to be cleaned every week. This problem finally resulted in the failure of the filter, which ruined the engine. It’s a very poor design. I hope I have better luck with my new Polaris Ranger diesel.”

Best Buy

Chrysler Intrepid full-sized car equipped

Doug White, Unity, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

Doug nominates his son’s 2001 Chrysler Intrepid full-sized car equipped with a 2.7-liter, V-6 engine as his “best buy”. “He bought this car used one year ago with about 100,000 miles on it for only $3,500. Since then he has put another 20,000 miles or so on it with no problems. It gets 35 mpg on the highway, which I think is good for a full-sized vehicle. This is the only Chrysler car we’ve owned in more than 65 years, but it’s by far the best. My son bought it because he drives 32 miles to work and needs economical transportation.”

Best Buy

DR Pro mower trimmer equipped

Boyd Stanley, South Port, N.C. · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“I like my 1998 DR Pro mower trimmer equipped with a Kawasaki FC150 engine. I’ve changed the spark plug, oil and belt and that’s it. It starts on the first pull and mows like crazy. No more back pain like with other weed trimmers. Good product, good company, and good, reliable service.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna commercial-style weed eaters

Andy Larson, Stanton, Iowa · Vol. 36, No. 3 (2012), p. 15

“I’ve had good luck with Husqvarna commercial-style weed eaters. I maintained 7 different parks for 8 years on contract and am still using all 3 of the weed eaters that I bought for this work.

“I work at a local highway department, and our shop foreman ordered Chinese-made brake shoes and drums for a Ford 9000 truck. Unfortunately they lasted less than a year, whereas the old U.S.-made brakes we used before lasted about 250,000 miles. We installed a Chinese-made clutch in a 1-ton sign truck, but it lasted only about a year. We replaced it with a U.S.-made clutch assembly, which is still going strong after 4 years. Tools, roller chains, and bearings made in China are all junk.”