Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002)

33 reports from pages 14–16 · 23 Best Buys19 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Toro personal pace recycle

Jeff Lang, Newport News, Va. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

“I recently bought a Toro 22-in. personal pace recycle mower, which I now regard as my all-time best buy. A friend of mine recommended this mower to me and I can’t thank him enough. I’ve used it for about 12 hours and am completely satisfied with it. The personal pace is a fantastic option for a self-propelled mower. If the grass is tall I just go a little slower - the mower does the work. I think the personal pace feature would be especially valuable for anyone with a physical handicap and also for the elderly. It really takes the work out of cutting your lawn and makes working with a self-propelled mower seem almost like exercise.

“The mower does a good job of picking up all leaves, grass, grass clippings and even small twigs, and bagging them. The “atomic” blade minces grass into fine particles. The grass particles and leaves get chopped very fine. For anyone who bags their grass or leaves, this is an important option because you get a lot more in the bag.”

Best Buy

Keho Windreel

Paul Storey, Seaforth, Ontario · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

“I’ve used my Keho Windreel for more than 12 years to bring beans into combines. It’s an outstanding product (Keho Products Ltd., Barons, Alberta, Canada (ph 800 661-9419 or 403 757-2444). The Windreel uses individual fingers’ to blow crop into the header.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman socket organizer

Nathan Rand, Marshalltown, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman socket organizer is my worst buy. It came with 12 more sockets than pins, so I ordered 12 pins over the phone. When I found out how much the pins cost, I tried to cancel my order. However, the company said that it was impossible to cancel the order due to the way its computers were set up. I could have purchased another complete socket organizer and still had plenty of money left over for what they charged just for a few measley plastic pins. The company told me I could return the product to a local Sears for store credit. Now I have to use the credit to buy something that I don’t really need, or else keep these grossly over-priced pins.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Houle underground manure pump + 2 more

Ray Alexander, Fredericton Junction, New Brunswick · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

“My 1986 Houle underground manure pump has been a reliable, trouble-free product.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Tubeline bale wrapper. “Without a doubt it was the worst piece of equipment I’ve ever owned. It hardly ever worked right and was totally undependable. I finally got rid of it and bought an Anderson wrapper, which is a real pleasure to own and operate. It works like a dream.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hesston 530 round baler + 1 more

David C. Moore, West Grove, Penn. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

David nominates his 1996 Hesston 530 round baler as his “worst buy”. “The main drive chain broke and had to be replaced. Sometimes the baler couldn’t keep the bale rolling. It would stop turning, and then I would have to eject it and start over. Neither the dealer nor the service rep could solve the problem. I finally sold it and bought a used Deere 335 baler. It works good.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 1500 4-WD pickup

Curt Kallal, Des Moines, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

Curt’s unhappy with his 2002 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 4-WD pickup. “The paint was too light in the corners of the bed and on the tailgate. I got the run-around from my dealer and also from the company’s customer assistance center so I paid for a spray-on bedliner. I had to repair some spots on the bottom of the tailgate myself.

“Six months after I bought the pickup the transfer case started making noises. I had to return the pickup to the dealer twice for this problem. The first time the dealer couldn’t find anything wrong. The second time he kept the pickup for 10 days but still couldn’t find the problem so he said it was just a normal noise. Now they won’t do anything about it. I took the time to test drive two other pickups that were similar to mine, but I couldn’t get either of them to make the same noise. I asked both the dealer and the company’s customer assistance people if they could tell me what was causing this noise, since it’s so ‘normal’, but neither of them offered a response. They both pretty much told me tough luck.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 4600 4-WD tractor equipped

Curtis B. Reeves, Gainesboro, Tenn. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 14

Curtis nominates his 1999 Deere 4600 4-WD tractor, equipped with a front-end loader, as his “best buy”. “This tractor is unbelievably easy to operate. The transmission has low, medium and high range, with four gears in each range. To shift from forward to reverse in the low and medium gears, all I have to do is move a lever on the steering column, right where the turn signal would be on a car. I don’t even have to use the brake or clutch. It really works great when I’m mowing, or doing anything that requires a lot of forward and backward shifting.

“I use this tractor really hard, probably a lot harder than it was designed for. One time I was rebuilding a berm alongside a creek and working in the water. I accidentally ran into a hole in the creek, which caused the front end of the tractor to go under water, and the engine died as I was trying to back out of the hole. The nose of the tractor was out of sight and water was right up to the seat, but I was still able to restart the engine right away, which really surprised me. After I got the tractor back on dry ground and checked it out, I couldn’t find any water in the hydraulics, oil, or fuel. I was able to keep on using the tractor as if nothing had happened.

“The front-end loader is so handy and easy to use that I’d be lost without it. This tractor can outwork a lot of bigger tractors. It’s well worth the money I put into it. I added a holder on the right fender where I can put a small cooler for sodas and water. It’s nice to be able to get something cold to drink while mowing or doing other work with the tractor. There’s plenty of room to put toolboxes. I added electrical outlets on the front and rear of the tractor so I can plug in a 12-volt air compressor or a chain saw sharpener for use when I’m cutting logs.”

On the negative side, “I bought a new Sears circular saw for $39 and started using it to cut 2 by 4’s. The clutch burned out after only about one hour. I took the saw back to the dealer but he said I had to leave a $32 deposit in order to have the saw repaired, even though I used it for only one hour. He said that since the saw was an electrical item, it wasn’t covered by the warranty and that if the repairs cost more than the deposit, I would have to pay the difference. I threw the saw away.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husqvarna 44 Rancher chain saw + 1 more

Rob Grant, Harlem, Ga. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“My 1982 Husqvarna 44 Rancher 16-in. chain saw has never let me down and is still going strong. I use it to cut several loads of firewood and fence posts every year. The engine still has so much compression that I have to replace the cord every two or three years.

“My 1996 S&H two-horse trailer is my worst buy. Paint started peeling immediately after I bought it and all the joints had to be caulked. Now rust is forming under every piece of caulking, and since the floor isn’t treated I’ll probably have to replace it soon. I may have to sandblast the entire trailer in order to keep it from rusting away.”

Best Buy

Kinze Mfg

Lee Kissinger, Jackson, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

Lee hired Kinze Mfg. to repower his Deere 8640 tractor with a Cummins 855 diesel engine. “This tractor is put together very well and is built strong. However, it started developing engine problems at about 2,600 hours and I had to have the original engine overhauled twice. The last overhaul lasted less than 250 hours. The third time I went to Kinze to repower it. It eliminated all the problems I had before. The Cummins 855 engine is excellent and has unbelievable power and torque. I can pull a load with the tractor almost at idle. When I move the throttle ahead the tractor just takes off. Repowering wasn’t cheap, but it cost less than the two engine overhauls and only about one third the cost of a brand new engine of the same size. The tractor now has about 8,000 hours on it.

“It would be a good move to buy a tractor with engine problems and then have Kinze repower it. I had my tractor repainted so now it looks new.

“When Deere designed this tractor they should never have designed the engine to be part of the tractor frame. The engine never ran right. The service rep said we had too much power one time, and then the next time said that the water pump ran too fast. I wrote to Deere a couple times but didn’t get much of a response. Poor design and inferior parts caused this problem, but the company won’t admit it because they know that if they did it would cost them millions of dollars.”

Worst Buy

Plast-aid

Terry Corman, Fort Collins, Colo. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“You can’t go wrong with this product,” says Terry, impressed with Plast-aid, a two-part repair compound that consists of a liquid and powder. You mix the two together to form a hard, durable, waterproof plastic that sets up in only about 15 minutes (Plast-aid Corporation, Box 2156, Estes Park, Colo. 80517 ph 970 577-1000; Website: www.plast-aid.com/).

According to the company, the product can be used to make a wide variety of repairs and works great for everyday broken items at home, work and in the shop. For example, at home it can be used to fix cracks in dropped cell phones, remote controls, and hair dryers; to repair stripped-out hinges, broken toys, computer housings, and refrigerator shelves; to repair handles on pots and pans; and to fix stripped-out screw holes in wood. It works great for PVC plumbing repairs, because instead of having to cut out the damaged PVC you can just patch it. On cars and recreational vehicles you can use it to fix cracked panels and fenders, stripped knobs, broken light lenses, and even to plug radiator leaks. The product can even be colored and made into parts.

“It’s like having your own liquid plastic,” says Corman. “I learned about Plast-aid from my brother, who works at an auto body shop and uses the product to make repairs. It’s crazy looking stuff and has a terrible smell, but once the product sets the smell goes away. My brother mixes it into a thick paste that’s almost like a putty, which he uses to build up studs on the back side of car parts. Once it sets up Plast-aid becomes very tough - almost as hard as a rock.

“I used Plast-aid to repair trim work inside my 1986 Buick Somerset car. I had to pull the trim loose so I could fix some stuff behind it. I used Plast-aid to repair cracks that developed in the trim. I also used it to repair my son’s broken action figure toys. You can pour this stuff into a hole that’s all stripped out and let it set up, then drill it and tap it to take screws.”

Plast-aid is available in 0.75-oz., 1.5-oz., and 6-oz. kits. They sell for $7.95 to $19.95 plus S&H.

Worst Buy

Ryobi high wheel

Emory Spiegelberg, Larsen, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“The worst product I bought recently was a Ryobi high wheel, 18-in. string trimmer mower powered by a 5 hp gas engine. The problem is that the rewind starter wouldn’t work right, and as a result the trimmer string won’t go around”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kawasaki 400 4-wheeler + 1 more

Curtis Holmes, Graham, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“We really like our 2002 Kawasaki 400 4-wheeler. We use it for spraying crops and for checking cows. This is the second one we’ve owned. It has a smooth-running, reliable belt drive system - in 7,000 miles we’ve had only one belt break.

“Our Campbell Hausfield 3/8-in. air ratchet is a worst buy. My dad says it pinches his hand whenever he uses it.”

Worst Buy

Case-IH

Tony and Mary Wortmann, Stanton, Neb. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“Recently we needed to do some engine work on a 1950’s vintage International 300 tractor and found that we could still purchase most parts for it at our Case-IH dealer. We thought that was great. In contrast, we recently bought a new computer for $2,000. Six months later we couldn’t even get parts for it. The software is buggy, and after two years this computer is almost worthless.

“What’s wrong with this picture? One company is still supporting its products 50 some years after introducing them, while the other one won’t support its products for even a year.

“Another worst buy is all the money we’ve invested in the Pork and Beef Check-off programs. What a total waste of money for small farmers. These check-off programs are great for the retailers, the media, and the packers. However, they’re very destructive for small pork and beef producers and are putting them out of business left and right. Nebraska pork production has dropped more than 50 percent since the ‘pork tax’ was put into effect. It’s a total waste of money for us.”

Worst Buy

Honda walk-behind hydrostatic

George H. Baker, Sr., Dunlap, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“My Honda walk-behind, 21-in. hydrostatic lawn mower is my worst buy. I paid $980 for it but was able to use it for only about 45 minutes before the blade clutch seized and the mower quit working. The dealer came out to look at the machine but refused to give me a full refund. He took it back to the shop for repairs.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller

Jack D. Loveless, White Cloud, Mich. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

Jack says his 1984 Mantis rototiller rates as his “best buy”. “Over the years I’ve spent a total of only about $80 for repairs. It works great in raised garden beds. I use it to make rows and to make compost. I also use it during the winter to chop snow and ice off my sidewalk. I’m 75 years old, but both me and my Mantis are still going strong.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford 39-30 tractor + 1 more

Alan Eberly, Port Clinton, Ohio · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“My Ford 39-30 tractor is my best buy. It replaced a Ford 1900 model, which was a good tractor but was underpowered. The 39-30 has more power.

“My Water Hog pond pump is my worst buy. The problem is that the pump shuts down after running for only about 20 minutes, and I have to keep turning it back on all the time.”

Best Buy

Oldsmobile Silhouette minivan

Darin Miller, Wamego, Kansas · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“My 1993 Oldsmobile Silhouette minivan just keeps on running. I bought it used with about 140,000 miles and have put another 80,000 miles on it. It’s equipped with a 3,800 cc V-6 engine that has plenty of power. It has plastic body panels that are easy to clean and are dent and rust resistant.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Porter Cable 19.2-volt cordless drill + 1 more

Dan Maciosek, Westfield, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

Dan’s impressed with his Porter Cable 19.2-volt cordless drill and saw. “I’m a general contractor and have used a lot of cordless tools over the years. However, these are the best. Long lasting batteries and durable on the job site.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Campbell Hausfeld “contractor’s model” airless sprayer. “It lasted for only a very short time after I bought it. The company won’t repair it so now I’m forced to throw it away. This machine is hard to clean, overheats, and doesn’t spray consistently. I wasted my money on it.”

Best Buy

Honda Civic

Morris Beckman, Junction City, Kansas · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“It gets more than 40 mpg and still runs like a sewing machine,” says Morris about his 1990 Honda Civic. “It has required only routine maintenance, including new tires and a new battery.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Greasemaster electric grease pump + 2 more

Steve Wilkerson, Dahlgren, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 15

“I like my Greasemaster electric grease pump. I bought it about five years ago from an industrial salvage dealer. It’s one of the finest tools I’ve come across in a long time. It consists of a 5-gal. pail of grease with an electric motor mounted on top of the cover plate. The motor drives a shaft that goes down inside the bucket and is connected to a small can and pump, which pumps the grease out.

“I carry it in the back of my pickup and power it off the truck’s 12-volt battery. The original model was designed to operate on six volts. It pumped too fast and drew too much current. I converted it to run on 12 volts by modifying the motor’s field coils. I do heavy equipment excavating so I have to pump a lot of grease. I had been pumping grease by hand, which about wore me out. The Greasemaster is a lot more convenient than an air-operated pump because you don’t need to haul an air compressor around to run it.

“The only thing I know about the manufacturer is that the words ‘G and T Industries, Inc., Wichita, Kansas’ are inscribed on the tool. (Editor’s Note: We

“I’m not happy with my Deere 317 garden tractor. “I bought it used a few years ago and it’s now on its third Kohler 17 hp engine. The company should never have allowed such a power plant to be used in its products.”

Best Buy

Schlagel power chip

Bob Olson, Amboy, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“We couldn’t believe how well it worked,” says Bob about the Schlagel power chip he put into his 2001 Deere 8310 4-WD to boost horsepower. “We pull a 24-row corn planter and a 31-ft. bean planter but didn’t quite have enough horsepower. The chip boosted the tractor about 65 hp., which made all the difference in the world. Works like a charm. My son borrowed the tractor and didn’t want to give it back. So we’re ordering another one for our other 4-WD.

“It took only a couple minutes to install. It simply plugs into the wiring harness that leads out of the injector pump. Essentially, it’s like turning up the fuel pump on an older model tractor. The chip we bought will work on any 8.1 Deere engine.

“The Schlagel people told me they’ve never had a complaint. A lot of guys are putting them into new tractors. You can save a lot of money. For example, the 8410 has 25 more horsepower than the 8310 with exactly the same engine. But it costs $8,000 more. You can just buy the 8310 and install this chip and you’ll have even more horsepower. We’re sold on the idea.”

Best Buy

Kubota 3410 4-WD diesel tractor + 2 more

Sylvio Bourgeois, Yucaipa, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“My 2000 Kubota 3410 4-WD diesel tractor is a best buy. It’s easy on fuel, handles well, and has all the power I need.

“My 2002 Chevrolet Duramax 3/4-ton diesel pickup is also a best buy. It gets about 22 mpg and the ride is great. I use it to pull my 24-ft. flatbed trailer loaded with a tractor and disk. I’ve had no problems at all with it. The diesel engine runs a lot quieter than the diesels in Ford and Dodge pickups.

“My Deere pressure washer cost $550 but never worked right from the start. I took it back to the dealer but he couldn’t get it to work either. I finally bought a different model at Home Depot for $350 that works fine.”

Best Buy

Minneapolis Moline G900 LP loader tractor + 2 more

Edward Welters, Verona, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

Edward nominates three old but reliable tractors as “best buys”.

He bought his 1968 Minneapolis Moline G900 LP loader tractor used when it was 12 years old. “It still has the same clutch it had when we bought it. We credit that to the engine, which runs at slow rpm’s. We’ve put more than 5,000 hours on it. It’s an economical tractor to operate.

“We bought our Minneapolis Moline G1350 LP Wheatland about ten years ago and mounted a Vaughn front-end loader on it. The loader has tremendous capacity - it will lift more than 5,000 lbs. The loader’s normal lift height is 12 ft., but by adding a boom it will lift up to 15 ft. high. We prefer tractors that run on LP gas, especially for loader work.

“We bought our White 2-85 torbocharged tractor used. It generates 105 hp on the dynometer. We use this tractor mainly for haying work so we decided to make it our ‘economy’ tractor. We put in some different pto gears that allow us to slow down the engine speed while keeping up the pto speed. As a result, at 1,600 to 1,800 engine rpm’s we can pull a discbine or a baler at 5 to 7 mph and use only about 2 gallons of fuel, when other tractors would use 3 to 4 gallons. This tractor is equipped with a 3-speed shift-on-the-go transmission that really works good in the field.”

Best Buy

Case-IH 8312 disc mower-conditioner + 1 more

Mark Lange, Paullina, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

Mark likes his 2000 Case-IH 8312 disc mower-conditioner. “This is my second 8312 model. I do a lot of custom work and both machines have performed excellent even in the toughest conditions. They cut fast and do a good job of conditioning hay.

“My 1994 Case-IH 5240 Maxxum tractor is a best buy. I’ve put more than 4,000 hours on this tractor, and it hasn’t been in the shop once. It’s fuel efficient and has a lot of power. It has required only routine maintenance.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland 55 hay rake + 1 more

Brent Brueland, Boone, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“My New Holland 55 hay rake is my best buy. I bought it used decades ago from the original owner, yet it’s still as tight as the day it was manufactured. It picks up hay well and does a great job of mowing.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1997 Dynamark 18 hp garden tractor. “The mower deck is built too light, the gauge wheels and cables have broken, and the spindle bearings went out. Also, parts for it are hard to find.”

Worst Buy

Skil cordless drill

Ronald Fenske, Engadine, Mich. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“My Skil cordless drill is my worst buy. The battery charger quit working so I tried to find another charger. I checked out the company’s Website and found that I could order one there, but unfortunately they didn’t provide any price information. I E-mailed the company to find out where I could get a charger and they sent me names of some stores that were supposed to carry them. However, the nearest store was more than 100 miles away. I made the trip only to find out that this store didn’t carry them. I E-mailed the company again and they sent the name of the nearest service center, which again is 100 miles from me and in Canada. I ended up buying another company’s drill. Over the years I’ve owned a lot of Skil tools, but you can be sure I’ll never own another one.”

Worst Buy

Husqvarna 350 chain saw

Bud Sobesne, Bronson, Mich. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“My 2001 Husqvarna 350 chain saw is my worst buy. After I used it for only a few days it wouldn’t start. I took the saw back to the dealer and got it going. However, the next day it wouldn’t start again. This happened six different times. The company finally gave me a new model, but I was able to use it for only about six hours before it refused to start, too. I took the saw back and they found that it had only about 75 lbs. of compression. New parts were ordered six weeks ago, but they’re still not here.”

Best Buy

M & W Dyna Drive

Roy Richters, Utica, Neb. · Vol. 26, No. 4 (2002), p. 16

“My M & W Dyna Drive is the finest tillage tool I’ve ever used. It can be used during the fall for breaking up stalks and leaves enough cover on top of the ground to hold soil. In the spring with one pass it will work the ground into an ideal planting bed that will not wind erode and holds valuable moisture in the soil.”