Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005)

64 reports from pages 12–15 · 53 Best Buys20 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

At about 90,000 miles the transmission on my 1994 Dodge Ram pickup equ

Arco Rosenow, Chillicothe, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“At about 90,000 miles the transmission on my 1994 Dodge Ram pickup equipped with a V-6 engine started acting up. Three different dealers looked at it and said it needed to be rebuilt, at a cost of about $1,500. I took it to a local mechanic and for $75 he did a full transmission flush and it has shifted perfectly ever since and now has more than 146,000 miles on it with no other shop time other than oil changes. Flushing differs from an oil change in that all components, including the torque converter, are cleaned by flushing a cleaner throughwhile the truck is running and going through shift cycles while on the rack. You can actually watch the oil become cleaner.”

Worst Buy

Orthman 1tRIPer preplant tillage tool

Bill Moore, Cambridge, Neb. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

A 2005 Orthman “1tRIPer” preplant tillage tool rates as Bill’s “best buy” (Orthman Mfg., Inc., Lexington, Neb. Ph 308 324-7555). The tool combines strip-till soil management, precision nutrient placement, and seedbed preparation in a single field pass. It can be used as a stand-alone machine or with the Orthman combo caddy or a planter attachment package to combine multiple operations in one pass. It’s available in 4 to 16-row configurations.

“It does a superb job of making a seedbed in high residue,” says Moore. “It never plugs up, even in 240 bu. per acre corn residue. But on the negative side, the company uses really poor bearings in all the coulters on this machine. The ripper shank is made of mild steel and bends in hard ground without hitting any kind of an obstacle. In planting 5,000 acres we broke one shear bolt and bent 30 shanks. And we had to replace 30 bearings. The hydraulics used on the caddy machine are so poor it doesn’t lift evenly. This uneven lift eventually wore out the clevis on the lift cylinders.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 9320 tractor equipped

Marc Rasmussen, Cambridge, Neb. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

Marc’s disappointed with his 2005 Deere 9320 tractor equipped with a powershift transmission and a 3-pt. hitch. “We had barely put 30 hours on the machine, when the tractor would no longer move because a microswitch on the clutch pedal started to stick. After we installed a set of saddle tanks, the company said they would void the warranty unless we took the tanks off and installed a set of frame stiffeners.

“But our real trouble began when we started to plant using an Orthman 1tRIPer strip-till rig tied to our planter. The tractor has a Cat. I 3-pt. hitch with poor capacity. Any time the nose of the tractor goes over a hump it won’t pick up the Orthman rig. At 151 hours the frame of the tractor gave out causing the tractor to buckle in half. The company blamed the problem on soft metal, but about 10 bolts is all that holds the front and back halves of the tractor together. At 200 hours the top link on the 3-pt. hitch broke while we were raising the machine at the end of the field, dropping the planter. The bolts that hold the pins in on the quick hitch broke and the pins worked themselves out of the hitch.

“The powershift transmission has a protection mechanism built into it so that when shifting from forward to reverse, sometimes it pauses and sometimes it doesn’t, making it hard to tell whether to set the planter down or wait for the tractor to decide which way it’s going. Any time the tractor is under load, when I’m shifting from eighth to ninth gear, it jerks really hard. I can’t believe Deere can get away with rating this tractor at 375 hp because it has no reserve power. It can’t pull on a really long grade under load without giving up. Our dealer has been great to work with, but the company apparently does not care if we ever buy any more of its equipment.”

Best Buy

Ram 4-WD dually pickup equipped

Eugene Sellers, Trout Run, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“My 2003 Dodge 4-WD dually pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and 6-speed transmission is my best buy. It has more than 68,000 miles on it but has been totally trouble-free. I had a complete Banks power system installed and the truck now does everything I ask, almost effortlessly. Since I bought this pickup, its fuel efficiency has improved almost 2 mpg. I replaced the Goodyear Wrangler tires on the rear at 62,000 miles. The front tires still had almost 3/4 tread.”

Best Buy

Polaris Magnum 4-WD ATV

Don Sharow, Camp Point, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“My 2001 Polaris Magnum 4-WD ATV is my best buy. Cold or hot weather, it always starts right up. And if I let the battery run down, I can use a pull start that stays out of the way when not needed. It has an automatic transmission so I don’t have to worry about shifting, and also has a high-low range. I’m totally amazed at its pulling power and great traction in low range. I use it to pull home-built 4 by 6-ft., 2-wheeled carts with 32 cu. ft. capacity each. I can load four of them with firewood, and use my Polaris to haul this ‘train’ of carts with ease. In high range I can out-maneuver and outrun any of my hard-headed cows. I use this machine to check fences, haul firewood, and to get rid of frustrations and just go zooming along on some trails I carved out of our woods. I have a handicap, and this ATV allows me to access places on our farm that I otherwise couldn’t reach if I had to walk there. Work or play, it’s the most FUNctional machine on our farm.”

Best Buy

Gravely Promaster 300 riding mower

Steve Corbin, Fort Pierce, Fla. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“It’s a very reliable machine,” says Steve, happy with his 1994 Gravely Promaster 300 riding mower - a hydrostatic drive, front-mounted mower with rear steering and a zero turning radius. “Other than normal maintenance on items such as belts, blades, and filters, the only thing I’ve ever had to replace was the coil. It’s a blast to use and so maneuverable that it cut my mowing time in half compared to the previous machine I had been using. It cuts so close that I don’t have to use my string trimmer very often.”

Best Buy

Dixon mowers

E. J. Tippen, Kennett, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“After using Dixon mowers for 26 years I became a dealer. The company is downsizing and cutting back, but their mowers are upsizing and getting heavier so after getting a heavy Dixie Chopper I designed and built a lift to help me. I got one and liked it so well I built another so I can lift both front and back.”

Best Buy

DR 15 hp brush trimmer

Frank S. Fowler, Gatlinburg, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

“It works as good as advertised,” says Frank, pleased with his DR 15 hp brush trimmer. “It’ll cut right through 1-in. tree saplings with no problem at all. This machine won’t lug down even in the heaviest grass or brush. It’s the best off-the-shelf machine I’ve had in more than 50 years of farming.”

Best Buy

Uniroyal Tiger Paw AWP tires + 2 more

Robert VonKamp, Collins, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 12

Robert’s pleased with the Uniroyal Tiger Paw AWP tires on his Chevrolet S10 pickup. “These tires were brand new on the pickup when I bought it used in 1998. Now they have more than 97,000 miles on them and could still go another 30,000 to 40,000 miles. All I do is keep them properly inflated and rotate them maybe once a year if I happen to think of it. I’m putting them on all my vehicles.”

Mike Brandner, Brandner Dairy, been a trouble-free workhorse since I bought it.”

On the “worst buy” side, “I bought a Gate-way computer in 2001. It was returned to the factory twice because it would ‘lock up’. They never did fix it so I bought a Dell 2400 and it works great.”

Worst Buy

Agco 9745 tractor

Medford, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“We nominate our Agco 9745 tractor as our worst buy. We had a set hourly lease on this tractor, but in three years it was in the dealer’s shop for warranty work three months out of the year. Finally, when it was in the shop for the entire spring planting season, we let it go back and didn’t pay the final lease payment. We tried to trade it off, but the dealer wouldn’t take it in trade since he ‘didn’t want two angry customers’.

“Now Agco Finance says they’re not part of Agco Allis (contrary to dealer comments when the initial purchase was made) and wants financial compensation. What a joke -this tractor was useless. We were forced to rent tractors to do our fieldwork because the tractor never worked. We have a stack of warranty work orders totaling about $24,000 - from computer problems to air conditioning problems. The list was endless. The way in which the company treated us left much to be desired. I can say for certain that we’ll never purchase another piece of Agco Allis equipment.”

Best Buy

Last year we had irrigated corn that was knocked down across the row,

Laverne Hoefer, Petersburg, Neb. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“Last year we had irrigated corn that was knocked down across the row, 100 percent flat. It was 6 to 7 ft. tall and thickly planted. We used our Deere 9500 combine equipped with a 6-row head to try to harvest it. However, we would go in only about 150 ft. before the corn head would be covered 2 ft. deep, totally plugged up.

“It was half an hour before dark when I remembered something that I had read in FARM SHOW. I had my son go home and cut some sickle sections off the blade, saving the part with rivet holes in them. The rectangular pieces are 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 in. wide. He attached these pieces to the auger flighting on our grain head with two self-tapping screws. The pieces extend about 1/4 in. to 3/8 in. out from the edge of the flighting. Fifteen minutes later we had them on. We made one round in a field that was a half mile long and we never had to stop. We picked two semi truck loads in the dark after that at 3 to 3 1/2 miles per hour. The crop flowed through like a carpet. There was some shelling of the ears, but the kernels fell in the pan under the auger with no loss of grain. It was unbelievable. Total modification cost: less than $5.”

Worst Buy

Crestline factory-built home

Eugene Ostman, Mackinaw City, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

Eugene’s not happy with his Crestline factory-built home. “I purchased a brand new factory-built home from Crestline that cost more than $100,000. At the time of the purchase I upgraded the windows to get the best they offered. Recently, one of the windows fell out. When I investigated I found the wood on that window, and on all the windows, had completely rotted. The dealer that I purchased the home from won’t stand behind it. After checking into the matter I found there are many other people who have had the same experience.”

Best Buy

Miracle Truss 24 + 1 more

Dale Hazelton, New Hampton, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

Dale nominates his Miracle Truss 24 by 48-ft. steel frame building as his “best buy”. “The truss system allowed me to assemble the entire building by myself. The only help I needed was to hire someone to hoist the large trusses overhead with a boom. The rest of the work I did by myself, basically with a saw and a cordless drill/driver. It’s a clear span building that has already withstood a 24-in. deep snow load. It was a bit more expensive than a wood outbuilding, but it was worth the extra cost.”

A 2003 Snapper self-propelled riding mower rates as his “worst buy”. “The drive system slips on rough terrain or hills. Also, to change the mulcher/bag/side discharge attachments you need wrenches, which is a pain on a modern mower.

“I’ve purchased several products in the last year or two because they came with cash rebates. However, the rebate companies refuse to mail checks to my post office box. They have no problem notifying me by mail, but refuse to issue the checks. It’s frustrating, and some companies have lost my business because of this.”

Best Buy

Ram W-250 pickup equipped

Tim Jorn, Ames, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

Tim’s pleased with his 1991 Dodge W-250 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. “I bought it used with about 193,000 miles on it and now it has more than 235,000 miles. I’ve replaced a water pump, alternator, and block heater. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance. I use a 5 percent soy diesel blend in the engine and have all the power I need. Fuel efficiency averages in the high teens to lower 20s.”

Best Buy

Rhino International 65 hp tractor lacks

Nancy Wells, Shade, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“Our Rhino International 65 hp tractor lacks power and, when driving it in one of the higher gears, the clutch always slips. It can’t be adjusted. Another problem is that whenever we drive up a steep grade it loses all hydraulics, so we have to turn around and head it down hill so it’ll prime the exterior hydraulic pump. As a result, the only way to go up a hill is to back up.”

Best Buy

Hesston 1340 discbine + 1 more

Terry Coulas, Cobden, Ontario · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

Terry likes his 2002 Hesston 1340 discbine. “We do custom hay cutting and also cut our own hay, for a total of about 2,500 acres per year. With this machine we can cut any type of hay at any speed, any time. We trade every five years and only have to replace the knives. Drying time is one day quicker than for our neighbor who uses a New Idea model. This machine is a pleasure to use, and because it’s a hydro-swing model it works excellent in odd-shaped fields.”

He nominates his 2000 Case-IH 8312 discbine as his “worst buy”. “The conditioner rolls wore out after one season and had to be replaced. No warranty coverage.”

Worst Buy

Lincoln town car

Vernon Boettcher, Stacy, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“The worst riding car I ever bought is my 2004 Lincoln town car. My previous 1999 Town Car rode wonderful, but on this one they changed the steering, rear shocks, and tires and it rides terrible. It rides like my 2-ton Ford truck. My advice is to take a ride before you buy.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller + 1 more

Arco Rosenow, Chillicothe, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“I thought I made a mistake last year when I bought my Mantis rototiller, but it turned out to be my best buy (ph 215 355-9700; www.mantisgardentools.com). The rototiller came in a small box that weighed only about 20 lbs., and it looked like a toy compared to other tillers on the market. When I started the motor, it sounded like a big bee. However, I quickly found out this machine really tears up the ground. And the drier the ground is, the better it works. It pulverizes soil to the size of corn kernels and works great to weed the garden. I’ve also used it to cut away and terrace a 6-ft. high by 8-ft. wide hard clay bank - a job that took about two hours. One time I even used it to cut an 8-in. deep trench for burying a cable to an outbuilding, and to cut a 36-in. deep trench for a building foundation. I was able to make the trench so straight I didn’t even have to use forms below ground.

“Gibbs Oil is the best penetrating oil I’ve ever found (ph 800 555-3167; www.gibbsoil.us). It’s expensive at about $20 per can, but it takes very little oil to do the job. This oil contains no silicone, water, kerosene, acids or cheap fillers. It can be used to spray into door locks to prevent freeze-ups, to wipe a door jam to keep doors from freezing shut, and to eliminate corrosion on battery terminals. It takes about 20 minutes of soak time for a badly rusted bolt and nut, or about two days to free a stuck engine.”

Worst Buy

Maytag dishwasher

Catherine Dibenedetto, Oscar, La. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“Our 2004 Maytag dishwasher is our worst buy. The water failed to drain out of it and then leaked out and ruined our pine floors. The company replaced the pump but then the hose broke. They replaced the hose, but now the door won’t close properly.”

Best Buy

Excalibur food de-hydrator

R.W. Ellis, Sr., Seymour, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“One of my best buys ever is an Excalibur food de-hydrator (www.excaliburdehydrator.com or ph 800 875-4254). I can dry just about anything with it - all kinds of fruits and vegetables. One good treat is tomatoes sliced 1/8 thick, which I eat like potato chips after they’re dried. I slice the tomatoes with a slicer that I bought at a hardware store. My most popular treat, though, is a dried banana with a pecan on top. People just love them. I slice the bananas with a plastic curved cutter that I found at a yard sale. I give these out as treats wherever I go. I’m the favorite customer at the bank.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Echo weed eater + 1 more

John E. Cissell, Bardstown, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“I bought my best buy Echo weed eater more than 15 years ago. It always starts on the second or third pull. I’ve changed the spark plug only twice. I use this weed eater not only at home but also to keep all the fence rows clean on a farm that I own. It’s a great tool.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 1995 Sears Craftsman chain saw is the worst chain saw on the market. I have to pull the starter rope at least 20 times before it’ll start. Three different repair shops have tried to fix it with no luck. The only good thing is that my elbows stay in good shape from all the cranking I have to do. I’m glad I don’t have to use this saw very much.”

Best Buy

New Holland TC-33 tractor

Andrew R. Holko, Bristolville, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“I use my 2003 New Holland TC-33 tractor on my tree farm, along with five other tractors. It’s reliable, well balanced, and well engineered. The problem is that on rough ground the plastic parts break, such as light assemblies, grill parts, instrument panels, etc. My dealer has been helpful. However, I question the design and testing of these Boomer series tractors.”

Best Buy

Grasshopper zero turn riding

John K. Reed, Charleston, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“I’ve had good luck with my Grasshopper zero turn riding mower equipped with a 28 hp diesel Kubota engine and a 61-in. power fold, front mount deck. Last fall I had the pleasure of touring the company’s factory in Moundridge, Kansas. When I got home I decided I had to have one of their mowers so I bought a 2005 928D model and am well pleased with it. My grass can’t grow fast enough.”

Best Buy

John Deere 466 round baler

Michael Shull, Leitchfield, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“It has performed beyond my expectations,” says Michael about his Deere 466 round baler. “I’ve used it to make almost 10,000 bales. The only repair it has needed was to a drive chain. The 4-ft. bale width allows us to move hay up narrow roads without posing a danger to oncoming traffic.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Orthman hydraulic drive + 1 more

Thomas Stejskal, Lewis, Kansas · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“I like the Orthman hydraulic drive on my Deere 7300 stackfold 12-row planter. The hydraulic drive is very accurate with no slippage, and it’s easy to change the seed population. Virtually no problems.

“My 2003 Dodge Ram 1/2-ton pickup has been nothing but trouble. The front end won’t hold together, the engine runs hot, and it’s terribly fuel inefficient. For repairs, I have to take it to a Dodge dealer. It’s the last Dodge pickup I’ll ever buy.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mirafount hog waterers + 1 more

John Jacobs, Hamler, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

John’s impressed with his Mirafount hog waterers. “We’ve had Mirafount waterers on our farm for almost 10 years and recently bought four more. They hold up well and work in all weather. My only complaint is with the underground shut-off valves, which are built cheap.

“My mother’s Husqvarna 2448 lawn mower is a worst buy. At 30 hours the welds on the deck broke and ruined the belt. Fortunately, the mower was still under warranty. However, we had to make a number of phone calls and wait about a month before a service man finally came out with a new deck.”

Worst Buy

Ram 2500 pickup

John Chestnut, Wernersville, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“FARM SHOW is my best buy. It’s pleasing to know there are so many people out there who are doers and thinkers. Many, many ideas in your magazine have helped me with my own tinkering. Bless everyone who contributes.

“My 1999 Dodge 2500 pickup is my worst buy. I bought this pickup new and have kept up a routine maintenance schedule. At about 35,000 miles this pickup started having problems with the ball joints, transmission, rust, etc. I wanted a good, strong truck that I could count on for a long time. Obviously, I bought the wrong model.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 770 utility tractor + 1 more

John Vincent, Albany, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My best buy Deere 770 utility tractor has more than 1,000 hours of trouble-free service. I use it for pushing snow and also to pull a 5-ft. Bush Hog mower, which it handles with ease. It uses about one gallon of fuel per hour at full throttle.

“My Simplicity ZT-16 ZTR riding mower is my worst buy. It has an excellent Kohler engine but is hard on drive belts, going through up to six belts in a single season. And, it takes me up to two hours to replace a belt. The dealer can’t seem to solve the problem so this mower spends a great deal of time either in my barn or at the dealers.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 1500 pickup + 1 more

Stuart Childers, Fredricktown, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

Stuart’s the proud owner of a 2002 Chevrolet 1500 pickup. “Before I changed jobs I drove 165 miles round trip to work so I put a lot of miles on it, but all I’ve had to do is change oil and put on new tires. It now has more than 70,000 miles on it.

“Our 2004 Deere 5420 is a great utility tractor. It has a really nice balance between power and size.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda Odyssey EXL minivan + 2 more

Dave Winkle, Granville, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My 2005 Honda Odyssey EXL minivan is our best buy. When we bought it my wife talked me into getting a car-based navigation system. This is our first experience with a navigation system, and we love it. It’s very user friendly and has kept us from getting lost on numerous occasions. The van rides and handles like a car and is fuel efficient, as the engine switches from six cylinders to three cylinders during steady driving.

“My Generac generator is a best buy. We have a lot of power outages in our rural area, and after being without electricity for five days during the 2004 Christmas holidays, we knew we had to buy a larger generator with 240-volt capacity so we could at least operate our well pump. So far have been well pleased with it. It has electric start and a low oil sensor, and it will idle down whenever it’s not under load. It generates 7,500 watts and has a surge capacity of 13,500 watts. Several weeks ago our power was off for 21 hours but we were still able to power the well pump, a freezer, two refrigerators, TV, lights, and barn fans with no problem.”

On the negative side, “By far the worst buy we’ve ever made is our Water Furnace geothermal heating and cooling system (www.WaterFurnace.com). We built our house in 1987 and installed a York heat pump with a propane furnace for backup. The system was set to turn the heat pump off and the propane furnace on whenever the outside temperature dropped below 30 degrees. This system operated flawlessly for 15 years, with only one minor service call for the heat pump.

“During the summer of 2002 we decided the heat pump was probably nearing the end of its life cycle and, with propane costs rising each year, we wanted a lower cost system. We did a lot of research and decided to purchase this company’s premier 3-ton geothermal heating and cooling system. We kept our propane furnace for emergency backup and were assured by the dealer that it would rarely if ever be needed. During the first winter, the new geothermal system couldn’t heat the house and we used over 200 gallons of propane. The company said the underground loop just needed time to settle in. But the next winter the problem got even worse. I contacted the company again, was given the runaround, and finally told to work with the dealer to solve the problem. Not very good customer support.

“This summer has been warmer than the previous two, and the system runs in A/C mode all day long just to keep the house at 73 degrees. To add insult to injury, this system has required three service calls (due to a defective loop pump, defective capacitor, and defective circuit board) since it was installed. In hindsight we would have saved a lot of money by replacing our old heat pump with a new, high efficiency model that I’m told would operate without propane back-up down to 10 degrees above zero or lower.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Mule 2510 4-WD utility vehicle equipped

James A. Smith, Kaysville, Vt. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My Kawasaki Mule 2510 4-WD utility vehicle equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. This is a great machine for general farm use. I use it to carry everything I need for fencing and chores. With 4-WD it lets me go anywhere I need to. I’m an amputee so this machine serves as my off-road wheelchair. I can’t take it to the grocery store, though.”

Best Buy

Turner Mills bandsaw

Daryl Oakes, Cattaraugus, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My Turner bandsaw is my best buy (Turner Mills; ph 607 843-7318; www.turner mills.com). I had a Norwood sawmill for five years and, as good as that little sawmill was, I wanted a fully hydraulic mill offering easier operation and higher production. I looked at Woodmizer, along with others, then saw an ad for Turner Mills and ordered a video. This sawmill is well built, and most parts for it can be bought at local Napa and Honda dealerships. The sawmill’s main shaft did break after only about six months of use, but one call is all it took to get it fixed. Bill Turner not only took care of the problem immediately, he also made the shaft, gave me new bearings, and delivered them to my house for free. Try getting that kind of service from a big company.

“This sawmill is comparable to the Woodmizer LT 40 model, which costs about $40,000. I spent less than $15,000, and I think this sawmill will outperform the Woodmizer. If you’re looking for a great sawmill at a good price, with a company that will stand 100 percent behind its product, call them.”

Worst Buy

Case 8930 front wheel assist

Mike Allen, Skippers, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My worst buy is a 1998 Case 8930 front wheel assist tractor that I bought with only 1,200 hours on it. It now has 3,100 hours and I’ve had to replace two head gaskets, two fuel injectors, a water pump, two vacuum valves for the turbocharger, both brake pedal switches, a rear wheel bearing and seal, rocker shaft bushings and seals for the upper lift arm. Also, both rear tires separated at the wheel rim and had to be replaced, and I had to replace both hood shocks, a door shock, shifter accumulator, throttle cable, shifter cable, fan belt tensioner, and both lift arm connector blocks.

“On the plus side, my dealer fixed every problem.”

Worst Buy

Ram 3500 4-WD pickup equipped

Billie Hearsman, Carlisle, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

Billie’s had problems with his 1994 Dodge Ram 3500 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. “The fit and finish of this vehicle is poor, and it has a poor front axle design. The 4-WD won’t stay engaged because the vehicle has vacuum problems. Also, the door panels are falling apart and the radio doesn’t work right. I realize this pickup is more than 10 years old, but the manufacturer won’t stand behind anything. We have 30-year-old pickups that are in better shape. The only thing worth saving on it is the Cummins engine.”

Best Buy

DR 12 1/2 hp walk-behind brush

Jack Kaspari, Bovey, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My DR 12 1/2 hp walk-behind brush mower has lived up to my expectations and is my best buy. It clears 1 to 1 1/2-in. dia. brush with ease. I added a 42-in. mower deck that works equally as well. The unit is well built, and the attachments for it can be installed in only about five minutes.”

Best Buy

New Holland 615 3-pt mounted disc mower

Jim Heyboer, Nashville, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My New Holland 615 3-pt. mounted disc mower is my best buy. Over the years we’ve had four different New Holland mowers and have mowed close to 20,000 miles of roadsides in our county. We’ve put on more than 8,000 miles on this model in just two summers. Some parts on it have worn out, but that’s to be expected because we mow in road gear. Overall, they’ve been good units.”

Best Buy

American Auto Club better known

Arnold L. Madsen, Bovey, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

Arnold nominates the American Auto Club, better known as “Triple A”, road atlas as his “best buy”. “I’m retired so my wife and I travel a lot. This atlas always gets us where we want to go. All roads, big and small, are included and even most of the little roads are properly numbered or lettered. In comparison, the Rand McNally road atlas leaves out most of that information. I’m not a member of AAA but I buy their road atlas at book stores .”

Best Buy

New Holland TC240 4-WD compact tractor equipped

Terry Sauer, Cambria, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My New Holland TC240 4-WD compact tractor equipped with a front-end loader and 60-in. belly mower is my best buy. I use this tractor all year long to mow our lawn, plow snow, and do other chores. The 4-WD has gotten me out of a lot of trouble, and it also helps whenever I have a full bucket of gravel and need more weight on back. My only complaint is that you can’t get this tractor equipped with a hard cab. Also, the pins that hold the mower on kept falling out. However, I was able to fix that problem.”

Best Buy

Farmi logging winch

Lonny Gervais, Cromwell, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My 3-pt. mounted, pto-driven Farmi logging winch is my best buy. We use it to log 50 to 60 cords of wood each year. No problems. It has a 160-ft. cable so I don’t need to make a road to every tree I cut. This product has made our firewood gathering much easier and also helps provide some additional farm income.”

Best Buy

Case IH 8920 tractor + 1 more

Danny Hege, Olar, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“I’m well pleased with my Case IH 8920 tractor. I bought it four years ago as a lease return with 800 hours on it. No problems. It has a lot of power and is reliable. I’m also pleased with my Gruett silage wagons (Gruett’s Inc., Potter, Wis.; ph 920 853-3516; www.gruetts.com). These wagons have been trouble-free. They’re well built and should last a long time.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mantis rototiller equipped + 1 more

Paul Grisso, Roanoke, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My Mantis rototiller equipped with a Honda engine is handy to use. On rocky ground I pull it backward to keep from jamming rocks in the tines. It works great in small areas.

“My Harbor Freight 1/2-in., 18-volt cordless drill is my worst buy. The problem is the chuck won’t stay in the body of the drill. This tool was cheap so I guess you get what you pay for.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Allis-Chalmers WD tractor + 2 more

Monte Blue, Troy, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“I bought my Allis Chalmers WD tractor from my brother-in-law for $400. I’ve used it to pull logs for firewood, plant crops, do road work, etc.

“I’ve had my Ferguson T-20 tractor for only a year but it has never failed to start, even during the winter.

“My Struck tracked tractor powered by a 15 hp Kohler engine and equipped with both a blade and bucket is a worst buy. One problem is the gas tank is too small. Another is that the engine doesn’t have as much power as advertised and it’s hard to get at. This tractor has a Japanese-made carburetor which is hard to get parts for. A new carburetor sells for well more than $100.”

Best Buy

Dr. Chipper 3-pt mounted wood chipper

Leon L. Bailey, Elkton, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“It’s the best wood chipper I’ve ever used,” says Leon, pleased with his 2005 Dr. Chipper 3-pt. mounted wood chipper (Country Home Products, Vergennes, Vt.; ph 800 687-6575; www.countryhomeproducts.com). It’s easy to hook up to my tractor and works great with brush up to 4 1/2 in. in dia. It’ll take any type of wood and reduce it to chips. I’ve used it for 500 hours with no problems.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 Lariat pickup

John H. Markham, Newport, N.C. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

A 2000 Ford F-150 Lariat pickup rates as John’s “best buy”. “It’s reliable and fuel efficient, getting 22 mpg on the open road. We’ve had only one problem with it, and the dealer replaced the part under warranty. I didn’t know it even had a warranty because I bought this pickup used with about 36,000 miles on it. The repair was made at 67,000 miles.”

Best Buy

New Williams corn grist mill

Wayne A. Beggs, Lincolnton, Ga. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“In 1984 my dad traded his Allis Chalmers B tractor for a 1924 New Williams 18-in. corn grist mill. It still works great and I haven’t had to buy any corn meal since 1985. I think he made a good deal. I give away some of my corn meal as Christmas gifts. Grist mills were common in the South at one time.”

Best Buy

John Deere Gator

Marion E. Carter, Frenchburg, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My Deere Gator is by far the handiest machine I’ve ever owned. I can’t see how anyone could get along without it. It serves as both a small pickup and also as a general all-around utility vehicle. It always starts right up and seems to run forever on a tank of gas. It’ll go about anywhere on our farm. If I want I can even ride it to church on Sunday.”

Best Buy

Taylor wood-fired outdoor furnace

Ronald Morgan, Dunlap, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My Taylor wood-fired outdoor furnace is my best buy (Taylor Mfg., Elizabethtown, N.C. ph 800 545-2293; www.taylormfg.com). I use it to heat our home and all our hot water. It’s designed with enough capacity to heat two residences and provide hot water for both, or to heat a house and garage as well as a swimming pool. There are many options available.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson TO-35 tractor

Greg Nenni, Middletown, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My 1956 Massey Ferguson TO-35 tractor is my best buy. I bought it used five years ago when we moved to a new 20-acre home. It has a lot of power. I use it to bush hog six acres of pasture and to pull an 8-ft. harrow. It has excellent traction, power, and strength. I also use it to plow snow, drive posts, level the driveway, etc. I can change the points and plugs myself because everything is accessible and easy to work on. This tractor always starts, even in the coldest weather, and is a 6-volt positive ground. It’s a pretty cool old tractor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl power equipment + 1 more

Gary Alford, Edwardsburg, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“We have a lot of different Stihl power equipment, with a lot of different people operating them, and they all perform well. Some are more than 20 years old but still work fine.

“Our Deere HPX 4-WD Gators equipped with a 20 hp gas engine are worst buys. We bought four Gators and all of them are hard to start - even at temperatures of 90 degrees or higher. All of them have been back to the dealer at least once, and one model has been back twice. They run better now but they’re still tricky to start, even after they’ve been running at operating temperature. I don’t know why Deere didn’t make these Gators fuel-injected like they do on their 20 hp model 445 riding mowers.

“We had extra alternators put on, but it wasn’t long before a fan belt rubbed through the upper radiator hose. The same problem was starting to happen with another Gator before we caught it. To solve the problem we tied the hoses back. Another problem is that if you get the machine equipped with a R.O.P.S., you have to remove the windshield because otherwise it’ll suck in dust real badly. If you’re thinking about purchasing a Gator, I think it would be a real good idea to test one of them for a few days before you buy. A Gator equipped with a diesel engine might work better, but it costs a lot more. In my opinion, there are a lot of other brands on the market worth looking at.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet pickup equipped + 2 more

Gerald Zimmerman, Lititz, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

A 1994 Chevrolet pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter diesel engine rates as Gerald’s “best buy”. “It has required only routine maintenance. We have a K & N air filter on it (K & N Engineering, Riverside, Calif. ph 800 858-3333 or 951 826-4000) and also a Banks computer chip that bumps up horsepower (Banks Power; ph 888 601-8072; www.bankspower.com). This is the most reliable pickup I’ve ever owned.”

Worst Buy

Ford Ranger XLT pickup

Glenn W. Friant, Sr., Morris, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My 1996 Ford Ranger XLT pickup is my worst buy. I bought it used with about 82,000 miles on it. The owner told me he had no problems with this vehicle. But two days later the dome light wouldn’t go off, so I had to pull the fuse. Five days later the ‘check engine’ light came on and it cost $140 to fix. Nine days later the catalytic converter went out and that cost $250. Fourteen days later the windshield wipers went out. Nineteen days later, the heater and temperature control stripped and I couldn’t turn the heat down or turn the air conditioner on. I fixed the problem myself by running a throttle cable to the main control door, allowing me to regulate both heat and air conditioning.

“Twenty five days later the automatic transmission went out without warning. It cost $1,400 to take care of that problem. Now everything is working okay, but I’m just waiting for something else to happen. I think this pickup is possessed. I also think the guy I bought it from was real lucky to sell it when he did, or else he was psychic.”

Best Buy

Power King Economy 1614 lawn tractor

E.W. Shults, Coloma, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My best buy is my 1973 Power King Economy 1614 lawn tractor, which I bought new. I’ve used it to mow our lawn every year since I bought it, and it’s still going strong. These tractors were built the way I would build one. You won’t find any aluminum or pot metal on them. They have an automotive drive system right off the Kohler engine, individual wheel brakes just like on big tractors, a 3-pt. hitch, and hydraulics. In recent years I’ve bought two other Power King tractors - another 1614 and a 2418 - and restored both to like-new condition. I also found an original Power King front-end loader for the 2418.”

Worst Buy

Banks exhaust brake

Rodney C. Smith, Powhatan, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

Rodney bought a Banks exhaust brake for his 2002 Chevrolet Duramax diesel pickup. It’s his “worst buy”. “We use the pickup to tow our trailer in mountainous country. When speed drops to 45 mph, the transmission makes a violent, hard shift from third to second gear. It doesn’t happen if we’re not using the exhaust brake. We’ve made several phone calls and written letters to the company, and every time we call we get a promise that they will take it up with ‘engineering’ and call us back. However, they never call and didn’t even bother to answer our letter. Obviously this company doesn’t provide good customer support. I’m afraid to use this brake and plan to remove it from the truck. I’m sorry I invested the $1,400 for parts and labor.”