Truck & Tractor Parts (TTP
As a mechanic at Strutz Farms, Greg’s responsible for keeping the tractors running, including a 1984 White 2-180 used for tillage work and silage chopping. In January of 1998, the tractor’s original Caterpillar 3208 engine had more than 6,000 hours on it and was on its last legs. That’s when the farmers decided to repower the tractor with a Caterpillar 3208T, upgrading to the turbo to keep up with the demands of the growing operation. They bought a rebuilt engine at Truck & Tractor Parts (TTP) in Warsaw, Ind. which turned out to be their “worst buy”.
“They told us on the phone that they had a 3208T ready to go but they’d need a cashier’s check for $5,700 because we were from out-of-state. So my boss and I loaded up the 3208, which we were trading and drove the 6 1/2 to 7 hours to Indiana. They told us they still had to rebuild us an engine. Even though we’d been told they had an engine in stock, we reluctantly agreed to have them build one for us anyway. So we went home without an engine.
“When it arrived three days later, we were assured the engine had been dynoed and was field ready. We installed it and got the tractor into the field toward the end of April. After 40 hours, it started using a little oil, then a lot of oil. TTP agreed to pay the freight to return the engine. After examining it, they said it had ingested dirt and that it would cost $3,400 to fix it.
“We got the engine back in a couple of days, installed it, and were back in the field the same evening. That night it used 1 gal. of oil in three hours, yet there were no visible external leaks. This time TTP claimed it simply had to be broken in properly. We went round and round with the company for three months, during which time the engine used about a barrel of oil in 300 to 350 hours.
“TTP finally agreed to rebuild the engine a third time for $6,800 so we sent it back to them. We changed our minds right away, however, and decided to rebuild it ourselves. We bought $2,800 worth of parts directly from Caterpillar and sent the engine to Polk Diesel in Green Bay, where they looked at the block and heads and machined them out to exact factory specs. We took the injectors, injection pump and turbo to Diesel Specialists in Green Bay for examination. Between the two companies we learned that the cylinder walls were .003 to .005 in. out of round, the valve guides were bad, six of the eight injectors were bad, and the injection pump was set wrong - for trucks, not ag applications. The governor weights were also worn out and the turbo showed no signs of abrasion in the compressor housing and impeller wheels, which discounted TTP’s earlier claim that dirt in the engine was the root of the problem. Fixing all these problems cost more than $2,600.
“Finally, last January, I reassembled the engine, installed it and broke it in myself. After 22 hours, the tractor used only 2 qts. of oil.
“We figure we’re out about $20,000, including tractor rental while the White was down.”