Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003)

51 reports from pages 12–15 · 45 Best Buys19 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Megli Lawn Care

Harold Rehrauer, Central City, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“My worst buy is the set of Meg-Mo lawn mower cutting discs that I purchased from Megli Lawn Care. I use them on my Dixon 42-in. riding mower. Each disc is fitted with four swivel-mounted blades. They bolt on in place of conventional blades. I met the owner, Roy Megli, at a farm show last year in Madison, Wis. He assured me that his product would surpass the performance of the mower’s original blades so I bought a set for $149.85 plus S&H.

“After two months of use I found these blades couldn’t keep either the shroud or themselves clean, and they vibrated so badly that I had to replace them with the original blades. I faxed Mr. Megli and told him about my problem and suggested that he might want to refund my money. There was no response. I met him again at the National Farm Machinery Show in Louisville, Ky., and again explained my problem with his product. He said that I must have the wrong blades, and that I needed to use the company’s high rise blades. He said that if I sent him the number that was stamped on my blades, he would send me replacement blades. So I optimistically sent him the information but again there was no response. I don’t recommend this product or manufacturer to anyone. They have a badly designed product and no service.”

Best Buy

PB Blaster penetrating oil

Kent Cartwright, Genoa, Nevada · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

Kent nominates PB Blaster penetrating oil as his “best buy” (ph 800 826-8563 or email: [email protected]). It’s a concentrated penetrant that frees rusted or frozen parts by releasing the surface tension that causes parts to stick. It also lubricates to protect against future rust and corrosion. “Over the years I’ve tried most of the other penetrating oil products on the market, as I’m always bringing home some very rusted machine that needs a little repair.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford 1210 tractor equipped + 1 more

Ray L. Combe, Paradise, Utah · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“My Ford 1210 tractor equipped with a front-end loader and backhoe is a best buy. I bought it used 10 years ago and it has saved me a lot of work. I use it around our yard to plant trees and do other small jobs. It still runs good and has a lot of power for its size. It’s also easy on fuel and small enough to get in tight places. I also use this tractor to do some work for my neighbors.

“My 1999 Ford F-150 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5.4-liter engine is my worst buy. At about 45,000 miles the right cylinder head gasket started leaking oil at the rear of the engine. I talked to six service managers at Ford dealers in northern Utah and southern Idaho and learned that this leakage is a common problem in the 4.6 and 5.4-liter engines. It’s caused by shoddy work in the manufacturing process. Metal chips left on the block or head aren’t cleaned off and when the head gasket is installed, the chips keep the gasket from sealing and in some cases damage the head. The oil leak is usually at the right rear, left front or both heads on the engine. How hard is it to clean the head and block before the engine is assembled? Ford hasn’t been able to do it in six years. I let my neighbor, a fan of Dodge, read Ford’s service bulletin 02-22-7 and his question is, if the chips are on the block and head why wouldn’t they be inside the engine also?

“Ford’s recommendation is to pull the engine before removing the heads so the heads won’t get damaged during removal from the engine. Two dealers I talked to won’t replace the gaskets unless new heads are installed. Labor, two new heads, the gaskets, recharging the air conditioner, etc., put the cost at about $3,000.

“When I called Ford and filed a complaint, I asked why they sent pickups out knowing they had defects in them. Their reply was that it doesn’t make any difference if the pickups leave the factory with defects because if they fail during the warranty (three years or 36,000 miles) they’ll fix it - after that it’s the owner’s problem. This is how Ford expects to reach their goal of 100 percent customer satisfaction. My position is if the truck leaves the factory with defects, Ford should fix it, under warranty or not under warranty.

“The people at Ford think they can send their pickups out with defects in them and after the owners get stuck with a huge repair bill they’ll buy another one of their junkers. Not me, I’ve been driving Ford trucks since May 1967 but I wouldn’t buy another one if they were having a two-for-one sale. Besides, if you pay $30,000 for a pickup and it can’t run more than 45,000 miles, why would you want another one?”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 pickup equipped

Robert C. Hudson, Halifax, Va. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“I’m well pleased with my 1997 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a Power Stroke engine. It has more than 124,000 miles on it with no problems. It spent 75 percent of those miles towing loads, yet it has needed only one frontend alignment.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet S10 pickup + 1 more

Ken and Phyllis Groves, Ireland, W. Va. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“My 1991 Chevrolet S10 pickup has more than 270,000 miles on it but is still going strong. No problems.

“My 2000 DR push trimmer equipped with a 6 hp engine is my worst buy. It doesn’t work nearly as well as advertised. Parts on it continually break, including string heads and height spacers, etc. My wife wanted the trimmer because it’s supposed to be easy to use, but she can’t even use it at all. Even I have trouble keeping it running straight. It sure wasn’t worth the $900 I spent on it.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless 3/8-in drill-driver + 1 more

Howard Cigelske, Beaver Dam, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“My Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless 3/8-in. drill-driver is my best buy. It has a lot more power than the 9-volt model I had previously owned. The chuck works good, and the reverse button doesn’t get in the way of the trigger grip.

‘My 1946 Miller 150-amp welder is a best buy. It has worked well all these years with no problems. I replaced the cables only once.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 9600 combine + 1 more

William Clark, Isabella, Manitoba · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“I’m happy with my 1992 Deere 9600 combine which I use on our 2,300 acres. This machine has a lot of capacity and is well built. Very little downtime. It’s a pleasure to operate.

“I was disappointed with my 1996 New Idea 4865 round baler. The company used splined bearings on all the rollers, which caused nothing but trouble and usually ruined the rollers as well. I finally traded the baler in for a New Holland 688.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6 + 1 more

Jarret Pine, Paris, Ill. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

“My 2000 Deere 6 by 4 Gator is my best buy. It’s big enough to seat two large men, yet small enough to maneuver through the woods. It has a large cargo box and enough power to pull just about anything. It’s equipped with a V-twin 614cc gas engine and has high flotation tires, so it has enough power and traction to go anywhere. It works much like a small truck. I’m well pleased with it.

“My 1997 Chevrolet 1/2-ton Z71 pickup equipped with a Vortec 350 engine and an off-road package is a best buy. It has a lot of power and the cab has a lot of room. I love it and will probably never get rid of it. It’s a great work truck and can pull and haul a lot. It’s equipped with a third door which I really like.”

Best Buy

Magnum cutting torch + 1 more

Chad Travis, Drasco, Ark. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

“In the last issue of FARM SHOW a Texas man said that based on his experience, he wouldn’t recommend the Magnum cutting torch for the average farmer. He said it burns very hot but is difficult to control and expensive to run. As a certified welder and diesel technician, I’ve had a similar experience with my Magnum torch. It has a lot of power, but it has some drawbacks. I don’t recommend that anyone get rid of their oxygen, acetylene, or plasma cutter before buying a Magnum. However, it burns hot and works good for penetrating thick material beyond conventional means. I’ve actually used it to cut holes in rocks up to 6 in. thick and to cut cast iron. One time I used it to cut a notch in a 27-in. dia., 4-in. thick flywheel. It also works good for washing out large welds. However, the rods for it are expensive and don’t last long enough. It throws a lot of fire and sparks.”

He’s “generally satisfied” with his 1996 Deere 5300 4-WD tractor but says it could use a few improvements. “It has adequate power and hydraulics. However, I think this tractor is too light on back to be used with a front-end loader. The grill and fenders are made of plastic, and the seat is poor quality. I built a bumper and grill guard and added a pair of 3 by 5-in. lights on the fenders. I added a 6-hole trailer plug so I can hook up implement lights. I built a skid plate that goes from the bumper to the drawbar. I also made hose protectors to cover the hydraulic hoses on the loader.”

Best Buy

Ford Ranger pickup equipped

Cliff Grulke, Minneapolis, Minn. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

Cliff likes his Menards garden cultivator. “The cast metal on it isn’t very durable, but it works good for working grass seed into thin turf. This cultivator is a ‘knock-off’ of another commercial model.

“My 1996 Ford Ranger pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and manual transmission is a best buy. It had more than 350,000 miles on it, and if I hadn’t forgot to replace the timing belt I’d still be driving it.”

Best Buy

John Beery

Vaughn Borchers, Gilman, Ill. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

Vaughn’s impressed with the service provided by John Beery of Bement, Ill., who specializes in servicing Steiger tractors (ph 217 763-6616). Beery salvages, reconditions, overhauls, re-powers, and also leases out Steiger tractors. “Beery is a very nice man and has saved me thousands of dollars on my Steiger.”

Best Buy

Troy-Bilt rototiller

Douglas V. Spencer, Fenwick, W. Va. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

Douglas is impressed with his Troy-Bilt rototiller. “I had been using Gravley tillers for 25 years until I bought this one. It has no trouble working my rocky ground, and I immediately fell in love with the machine. It’s much easier to operate, less tiring, and more economical than anything else I’ve ever used.”

Best Buy

John Deere 9650 STS combines

Mark Doudlah, Evansville, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

“We bought one of the first Deere 9650 STS combines in our area in 1999. We were very disappointed to discover that the combine was putting anywhere from 1 1/2 to 3 1/2 bushels of corn on the ground, and 3/4 of a bushel of beans.

“Until we bought the new Deere we had been using a 1979 model IH1460 and we didn’t realize what a great combine it was. There was virtually no grain loss behind that machine.

“To find the problem with the STS we must have rolled the chopper away more than 100 times. We would make adjustments in air flow, sieve setting, concave clearance, and ground speed. We got pretty good at correlating what was what, but it was a maddening time.

“In our opinion, when you pull the chopper away, you can really tell what’s going on. The chopper hides a lot of losses and spreads them out to such an extent that you say, ‘Well, that doesn’t look so bad.’

“In some places we were counting 56 seeds per square foot behind the separation section of the combine. And I’m not talking about head loss - I’m talking about material that was in the combine that’s now laying on the ground.

“We had three different company reps out but nobody could really make it work much better. We finally ended up installing a Kuchar concave threshing assembly from Kuchar Combine Performance in Carlinville, Ill. (ph 217 854-9838). It was very easy to see the improvement. We had a six-row head on that machine and we could tell what was going on without even rolling the chopper out of the way.

“To my knowledge, Deere has not made changes on their STS models to fix the problem. However, they do have three different concaves: the round pipe and a more traditional concave (small wire and large wire). When you buy a new combine model that hasn’t been in the field, you take what the dealer recommends.

“As far as I know most of the machines that have come into our area have the round bar concave. Once we changed out of that concave to the Kuchar concave, our field losses disappeared.

“I heard for years people saying that Deere couldn’t make a rotary combine,” and then when they finally launched their rotary combine, they confirmed that the doubters were right —they weren’t, in fact, capable of making a rotary combine that worked as well as others.”

Worst Buy

DR Trimmer

Charles Willingham, Chipley, Fla. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

“My DR Trimmer is a worst buy. It was in the shop more than it was on my farm where I needed it. The problem is that the manufacturer doesn’t have any repair shop to send you to, so they just pick one for you which can lead to problems. My machine was in one repair shop for 4 1/2 weeks.”

Best Buy

Ram 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped

Randy Eilerts, Mulvane, Kansas · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

“My 1993 Dodge Ram 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and manual transmission is my best buy. It has more than 230,000 miles on it. All I’ve done is change the oil and replace the tires. It averages 21 to 22 mpg. We use it to haul hay, firewood, and steel fencing pipe. It does all these jobs with ease. I’d recommend heavy duty Dodge pickups to anyone.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Farmall M tractor + 2 more

Leland Brendle, Dickens, Texas · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

A 1950 Farmall M tractor that runs on propane gas rates as Leland’s “best buy”. “I bought it used 17 years ago and it’s the most dependable tractor I’ve ever owned. Over the years I’ve used it for plowing, shredding and baling hay. It has covered a lot of ground. It’s equipped with a 3-pt. hitch which is very handy. It’s also easy on fuel.”

On the negative side, he lists his Dodge Dakota pickup equipped with a V-6 engine and automatic transmission with overdrive. “It ran good and was a pleasure to drive. However, it was really hard on fuel and got only 16 1/2 mpg. When gas prices reached $1.75 per gallon we decided to trade it for a 2000 Chevrolet Lumina car, which gets more than 30 mpg.”

Best Buy

Case-IH CX90 tractor equipped + 2 more

Wade Hancock, Cullman, Ala. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 13

Wade’s the satisfied owner of a Case-IH CX90 tractor equipped with a cab. “This is the first tractor I’ve had that was equipped with a cab and I’m well pleased with it. The cab is roomy and quiet. The tractor had a couple small ‘bugs’ when it was new but the dealer took care of them. I like the electric-hydraulic system. This tractor is also easy to service.”

John (last name and address unknown): He’s impressed with R.E.A.M. spark plug adaptors (R.E.A.M. Corp., Box 311, New Lothrop, Mich. 48460 ph 517 743-9148). They’re designed to let you use ordinary automotive spark plugs in old engines. An automotive spark plug screws into the adapter, which then screws into the engine. “They’re a really high quality product. I bought some to use in the grist mill engine on a 1921 McCormick Deering. They really stopped my plug fouling problems. I had been paying $10 apiece for 7/8-in. plugs. The R.E.A.M. adaptors sell for only $5 apiece plus $3 S&H. I’m thinking about buying a set for my old Ford pickup.”

Worst Buy

New Holland 6635 tractor equipped

Tony Smith, Martin, Ga. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

Tony says his 1997 New Holland 6635 tractor equipped with a cab is his “worst buy”. “I bought it used in December 2000 from a dealer who was the only previous owner and had used it on his own farm. At the time, the air conditioning appeared to work okay. Of course, it doesn’t take a lot of air conditioning in December to be comfortable. When hot weather came around I realized that the air conditioner wasn’t adequate for any temperature above 70 degrees. I took the tractor back but they couldn’t find anything wrong with it. They performed some normal maintenance work which cost $200 to $300. Since then I’ve had several other people look at it but they couldn’t find anything wrong with it, either, except that it won’t cool the cab adequately. All together I’ve spent almost $1,000 on it, but the air conditioner still isn’t working right. The air temperature seems to be cool enough but there just aren’t enough cfm’s coming out of the blower. All the filters and ductwork, etc., have either been replaced or cleaned out.

“Regardless of the temperature, if the sun’s shining you almost always need air conditioning. I guess I can plan on sweating it out again this summer unless someone can come up with a solution. If you’ve experienced this same problem, please email me ([email protected]).”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 9500 combine + 1 more

Paul Wielfaert, Britton, Mich. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“It’s well built and has a lot of capacity,” reports Paul, pleased with his 1997 Deere 9500 combine. “It has required only scheduled maintenance service. We use it equipped with a 25-ft. platform and 6-row head which it handles with relative ease and with very little grain loss. This machine replaced our Deere 7720 Titan II. The dealer said I would be amazed at the difference between the two machines, and he was right. Overall, I’ve had good luck with anything green.

“My 2001 Dewalt 14-volt cordless drill is my worst buy. It works good, but the batteries don’t stay charged very long so you have to buy new ones frequently, especially if you use the drill hard. We keep a couple extra batteries on hand at all times.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford New Holland 1720 tractor equipped + 1 more

Vic Smith, Parkville, Mo. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

Vic’s happy with his Ford New Holland 1720 tractor equipped with a diesel engine. “This is the first new tractor on our farm. I think diesel fuel is the way to go because it’s so economical. No problems. I use the tractor every day to do mowing work and to grow produce for our local farmer’s market.

“My Black & Decker Versapack 7.2-volt cordless saw is my worst buy. It’s equipped with a 3 3/8-in. blade. This tool barely has enough power to cut through thin wood and often quits working due to lack of power. It looks like new, but it just doesn’t work well.”

Best Buy

International Harvester tractors + 1 more

Roger Veigel, Dutton, Montana · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“All my International Harvester tractors have been best buys. They seem to have more power than advertised, which I think is due to their high torque rise engineering. But they use only enough fuel to do the job at hand, whether it’s turning windrows or primary tillage. This allows me to mix and match different power units at different locations, rather than move a specific tractor to do a specific job. The 1086 model, for example, has more than 130 pto hp but because of its 105-in. long wheelbase, positive camber angle, and mid-mount cab, it handles like a tractor half its size.

“These tractors also have ample hitch and hydraulic capacity. Like anything mechanical, they have their own unique problems such as with the steering, brakes and shift linkage, but these things are manageable because they don’t cost a lot to repair and result in no down time. I bought all these tractors used, and most if not all the problems they’ve had are due to the previous owner’s neglect or lack of knowledge of the product.

“I’m well pleased with my New Holland hay equipment. When it comes to commercial haying equipment I think New Holland is the best on the market.”

Best Buy

John Deere 318 garden tractor

John C. Reckart, Bruceton Mills, W. Va. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“Our 1986 Deere 318 garden tractor is our best buy. We’ve used it every summer to mow two acres a week for 17 years and to push snow during the winter. It has also taught five grandsons how to drive. I had to replace a starter at about 2,000 hours. It’s equipped with an Onan engine and hydrostatic transmission. The feature I like best is the individual rear wheel brakes. We also own a Deere 870 4-WD equipped with a front-end loader and backhoe. It has been trouble-free for 1,500 hours.”

Best Buy

John Deere equipment

Walter Fifelski, Wayland, Mich. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“I can’t quite believe all these farmers have as much good luck with their Deere equipment as they say they do. My son, who is in the excavating business, bought a new Deere 650 dozer for $80,000. It’s his worst buy. The machine is unusable about 50 percent of the time. The dealer he works with must be factory trained at making up excuses as to why the dozer can’t be fixed. My son has lost a lot of money on account of machine downtime. Bulldozers have had hydraulic blades that go up and down for more than 50 years, but not this Deere.

“The dealer finally told my son that nothing can be done as all these models are like that and it will take two years before the company can develop a new valve. They didn’t offer him a replacement machine while his was down, either. He finally got sick of this piece of junk and traded it for a Cat.”

Best Buy

Kuhn disc mower

Stan Bleszinski, Oregon City, Oregon · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“My Kuhn disc mower cuts heavy, wet, down hay with ease and almost never plugs up. Disc mowers have turned conventional sicklebar mowers into dinosaurs.

‘My Kuhn tedder rake does a good job, both in the tedding position and the raking position. I think Kuhn builds quality products.”

Best Buy

John Deere Gator 4 + 1 more

Mary Suttinger, Chatfield, Minn. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

Mary says her Deere Gator 4 by 6 utility vehicle is her “best buy”. “Ever since it arrived at our house, we keep asking ourselves how we ever did without it. As a woman, however, I must insist that it’s not just for guys. It’s second nature for us now to put our equipment and tools in the Gator’s bed and zip off to remote areas on our place. Also, this vehicle is so comfortable to ride in that I often take my 89-year-old mother on rides to see the sights. It handles easily even though it’s a rugged, powerful piece of equipment. Of course, as a woman I accessorize my Gator with a Deere cap appropriate for the season.” By Mark Newhall, Editor & Publisher do for free at sites like

Best BuyWorst Buy

Echo chain saws + 1 more

James Barton, Bath, Ontario · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 14

“My two Echo chain saws - one and three years old -have performed flawlessly and are my best buys. They start easy and just keep on running. My Echo weed eater is a best buy. It’s five years old but has required only one tuneup.

“My 2000 Polaris Expedition 425 ATV equipped with a standard transmission is my worst buy. The transmission never worked right from day one. I made repeated visits to the dealer and was told the transmission needed time to break in. However, once the warranty period was up the dealer told me it needed a new shifter and heavier springs - at my cost. My 1981 Honda ATV shifted better than this one. I put up with the poor transmission, but then at 1,200 miles the engine failed even though the ATV had been serviced regularly. The dealer and company told me the problem was that I hadn’t warmed up the engine 30 minutes prior to operation. However, the owner’s manual doesn’t even mention this. After owning seven ATV’s over a 22-year period, I’ve never been more disappointed with a product, a dealer, or a company.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 8520 tractor + 2 more

Alex Vanhervaben, Hamilton, Ontario · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“My 2002 Deere 8520 tractor is my best buy. We had been farming only Case tractors until we decided to try Deere. I like it so much that I’d never go back to Case.

“My 2003 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with a V-8 turbocharged diesel engine is my worst buy. After two months the engine blew up. We have a 1986 Chevrolet 1-ton pickup and haven’t had any problems with it. It goes to show you which brand is on top.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Steiner 4-WD turf tractor equipped + 1 more

Dale Kallenbach, Girard, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“This has to be one of the best engineered tractors on the market,” says Dale about his Steiner 4-WD turf tractor equipped with a front-mount mower deck. “It’s available with more than 30 attachments, which can be changed without tools in only a few minutes. The mower is in front where it’s easy to see. And with 4-WD this tractor has fantastic traction. If I were 30 years younger, I’d probably become a dealer.”

“My Hudson backpack 4-gal. sprayer is my worst buy. It won’t build up pressure and needs continual pumping. Rubber pump parts wore out fast.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Woods 6200 + 1 more

Dan Gordon, Convoy, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“Our best buy is our 1999 Woods 6200 Mow’n Machine equipped with a 20 hp Kohler engine and 52-in. deck on front. We bought it used with more than 1,000 hours on it and it now has more than 1,300 hours. It’s the most impressive machine I’ve ever used.

“My 2001 Troy-Bilt garden tractor equipped with a 42-in. deck is my worst buy. I was able to put less than 100 hours on it before the deck mounts broke. The spindle bearings also wore out, and the blades were as soft as butter and new ones weren’t available. The next year bushings on the transmission went out. I’ve never seen such a pile of junk in my life.”

Best Buy

Sears David Bradley walk-behind garden tractor

Wayne A. Beggs, Lincolnton, Ga. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“In 1952 my dad bought a Sears David Bradley walk-behind garden tractor. It’s still going strong and is our best buy. The tractor’s 5 hp Briggs & Stratton engine has been replaced a few times as well as the clutch facing, bearing and seals, and tires. However, I won’t get rid of this machine any time soon. It’s like plowing with a mule. Last year I repainted the tractor and all the attachments that I use with it.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet pickup equipped

Tom King, Winn, Nevada · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“In 1989 I bought a 1985 Chevrolet pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine, and it’s my best buy. It had about 43,000 miles on it when I bought it. Over the years I’ve put more than 400,000 miles on it with no major problems. The clutch was replaced at 325,000 miles. I drove this pickup every day in my horseshoeing business. It still gets 18 mpg.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 750 no-till drill + 1 more

Harm Spangenberg, St. Thomas, Ontario · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“My 1997 Deere 750 no-till drill does a good job in moist soil types and requires very little maintenance.”

On the negative side, “My 1997 Chevrolet Sonoma 4-WD pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter V-6 engine got only 15 mpg and didn’t have enough power to do anything. The cab is way too small for more than two people.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 4620 + 2 more

William Johnson, Holdrege, Neb. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“My 1994 Deere 4620 is an excellent tractor. It has had a few electrical problems but they weren’t too hard to fix.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1992 Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine. He bought it used in 1996. “It’s a poorly built pickup. The 4-WD should be made to shift like 1971-1976 models. Also, it had many electrical problems. For example, the lights would go out while I was driving at night. New switches for it weren’t cheap. I finally sold it 3 years ago at a loss and bought an older 1976 GM 4-WD pickup. At least it’s not loaded with computers and cheap electrical components.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 425 riding mower equipped

Elmer Pinkerton, Elmwood, Neb. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“My Deere 425 riding mower equipped with a 54-in. deck is my worst buy. I wish I could get my money back. The deck works well when it’s clean, but it takes only a short time for grass to begin sticking to the entire inside part of the deck. It’s too much work to remove the deck so I bought a small electric winch and mounted it on front of the mower. Now when I’m done mowing I hitch the mower to a heavy tree branch and raise the front end of the mower to a vertical position so that I can easily hose it off. To power the winch I replaced the rig’s original small battery with a larger car battery. Now I don’t swear at the mower nearly as often.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Fielder’s Choice

Bob Stewart, Fishers, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“My worst buy was not really a buy at all. I ordered six bags of Intellicoat-treated seed corn from Fielder’s Choice last winter so that I could do a comparison trial. However, when I got the seed I discovered that it wasn’t the treated seed that I had ordered so I asked to return it. In fact, the seed hadn’t been treated at all. After making many phone calls I finally got my refund but it was for $136 less what I had paid. And the money doesn’t take into account the 80-mile trip I had made to pick up the seed at the company’s drop-off point or the 180-mile trip I made to return the seed to their seed plant. Not a bad profit for them considering they still have the product. I’ll never buy from this company again.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight tool

Ken Scharabok, Waverly, Tenn. · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 15

“In our area, when you go to a small engine repair shop to have a chain saw’s teeth sharpened, they take off so much of the teeth that after three sharpenings the chains are about useless. So I bought a ‘Nick the Grinder’ over eBay (www.eBay.com), which turned out to be a Harbor Freight tool (www.harbor freighttools.com). It’s my best buy. While it may look like a toy, it’s a serious piece of equipment that’s simple to set up and use. I can take off as little of the teeth as required, meaning I can get several times the number of uses out of a chain compared to ‘professional’ sharpening. I estimate this machine will pay for itself in only one season of woodlot management and firewood cutting.”