Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004)

65 reports from pages 12–15 · 60 Best Buys12 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Barricade Fire Fighting Foam

Lloyd Schade, Homer, Alaska · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

Lloyd says Barricade Fire Fighting Foam is his “best buy” (www.barricadegel.com; ph 800 201-3927). It’s a water-based gel that’s added to water to fight fire. It’s used in wildland forest and grass fire protection. The product can also be used on houses, log piles, shrubbery, haystacks, cars, propane tanks, and anything else. It can be applied using standard hoses and nozzles. A home fire defense kit that includes a nozzle is available. The company recommends that you coat the object until it’s white, which usually means a coating of about 1/4 in. thick. When the danger has passed, the product can be rinsed off with plain water and a pressure nozzle.

“We have a real fire danger here on our 600-acre ranch, which has 23 buildings on it,” says Lloyd. “There are beetle-killed trees all around us and a lot of open grass land. Our 500-gal. water tank trailer doesn’t go very far with just water. However, with Barricade Foam added to the water, it’s the same as having 5,000 gallons. The product will last for 24 hours or more.

“We’ve used it twice in the past two years - once on a grass fire that a neighbor started, and the other time on a fire started by lightning. Both times Barricade saved the day.”

Worst Buy

John Fuqua

Stedman Twiss, Camden, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“Several years ago in FARM SHOW John Fuqua of Waynoka, Okla., showed a wire stretcher his father had made (Vol. 15, No. 6). He said it made quicker and tighter splices than any power puller or conventional wire stretcher. I made one using his directions and it’s the handiest fencing tool I have. It’s made from two 1-in. pieces of pipe connected by a 90 degree elbow. The handle, is 16 in. long and the other is 8 in. long. A 5/16-in. dia. hole is drilled through the 8-in. piece, 2 in. out from the elbow.

“When I have a broken fence wire, I simply make a loop in each broken end. Insert a length of smooth wire into one loop and tie it. Slip the other end of the smooth wire through the second loop and then through the drilled hole in the stretcher. Just turn the handle until the fence wire is as tight as needed, then back off and tie it.

“I made this stretcher 10 years ago and mentally thank Mr. Fuqua every time I use it.”

Best Buy

New Holland 688 round baler

Gary Stern, Halliday, N. Dak. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“I’m well satisfied with my 2002 New Holland 688 round baler. It’s a well-built, large capacity baler. The grease zerks on it are well marked and easy to find. I like the way the pickup attachment floats and also the way it picks up hay. It has a hydraulic lift that makes nice, even, tight bales. Overall, it’s an enjoyable machine to operate.”

Worst Buy

Case IH MX110 Maxxum

Mike Colclough, Clinton, Ontario · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

Mike likes his 1998 Case IH MX110 Maxxum but says it could use a few improvements. “My main complaint is with parts availability. I broke the screen mesh on front of my grille while lifting something with the front-end loader. I took the broken mesh to my local Case IH dealer, but they told me I couldn’t buy the mesh separate. Instead, I would have to buy the entire grille for $460. So, I fixed it with duct tape for $2.50.

“Another thing I don’t like is the in-dash acre meter. You have to turn the tractor off just so you can adjust the meter for working width and for most other adjustments. Deere’s corner post monitor works much better. I bought a Deere power strip so I can plug in monitors, CB radios, etc. It gives me six outlets instead of two.”

Best Buy

Walker tilt deck mower

Roger Cogdal, LaMoille, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“I love my side discharge Walker tilt deck mower. (Walker Mowers ph 970 221-5614; www.walkermowers.com). First of all, the tilt deck allows me to really keep it clean underneath. Being clean underneath means there is never any buildup to keep freshly cut grass from moving through at maximum capacity. And, being kept clean means longer life because grass buildup underneath contributes to rotting out of mower decks. As far as I’m concerned, the Walker is the Cadillac of mowers. I have been using one for four years and I’ve had very little upkeep.”

Best Buy

RCO

Jack Kaschmitter, Paynesville, Minn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“I purchased an underground rodent blaster and the first time I used it, the blast was so large I decided to never use this piece of equipment on my farm again. My ears were ringing for a long time after the one use.

“I found an alternative that works well. It is a gopher poison that is made of hulled oats and strychnine. It works so well I’ve eliminated all gophers from my farm. The product is from RCO and I bought it from Fedick Distribution, North Branch, Minn. (ph 651 674-2100).

“You can learn more at RCO’s website: www.rodent-baits.com.”

Best Buy

Phoenix Rotary Harrow

Ted and TJ Shambaugh, Oakley, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

This father/son team loves their Phoenix Rotary Harrow because the rolling harrow makes an ideal seed bed (www.phoenixrotary.com; ph 888 891-9929).

Ted prepares the ground using the 36-ft. long harrow set at a 45 degree angle. He pulls it at 10 to 11 mph. Then, T.J. follows behind with a 24-row planter.

“By pulling at that speed, it sets up a great profile for planting. The fine soil settles down with smaller clods on top. It is ideal for planting in.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 diesel pickup + 1 more

Charles Sassmen, Reedsport, Oregon · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 12

“My 2000 Dodge 2500 diesel pickup is by far the best pickup I’ve ever owned. I installed a BD power chip on it which provided a 100 hp boost (BD Power, www.bd-power.com; ph 800 887-5030). After more than 60,000 miles with no problems, I think it’s still just getting broken in. I use it to pull 24-ft. livestock trailers and hay trailers. It pulls a fully-loaded trailer like it was empty.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman 22 hp garden tractor is always breaking down. The mower deck bearings keep going out, and the deck plugs up with grass. I’ll never buy another Craftsman garden tractor.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 335 XPT chain saw

Wayne Whittaker, Horton, Mich. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

Wayne likes his Husqvarna 335 XPT chain saw, a professional model equipped with a 14-in. bar. “This compact, light saw starts easy and cuts faster than any other saw I’ve ever used. I can use it all day without getting too tired. It works perfect for keeping fence rows cut back. It replaced both a small and a medium sized saw that I had been using in the past.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

M.D. Products Humboldt, Iowa + 1 more

Terry Charles, Mt. Carroll, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

Terry’s impressed with front fenders for tractors made by M.D. Products (Humboldt, Iowa; ph 515 332-3550). “These fenders are designed for chore tractors and work great during the rainy season. They keep the tractor clean, the driver stays dry, and if the tractor has a cab the windshield remains free of salt and road debris. These fenders are made tough, and the company is great to work with.

“My 2002 Polaris 325 Magnum 4-wheeler is my worst buy. The Mossy Oak finish flaked off, and the air box connected to the carburetor was made wrong for where it’s installed, which causes the machine to function improperly on damp days. The company wouldn’t fix it even though the machine was still under warranty. They knew about the problem because they changed the design on their new machines, but they wouldn’t fix the machines that were already sold even though they were still under warranty.“ “We’re in the fertilizer business and have a total of nine pickups ranging from 1/2-ton to 1-ton models. They’re used to spray and deliver and service our accounts. In the past we always bought only Dodge pickups. Then we decided to try a GM model, and it convinced us to convert our entire fleet to Chevy and GM gas and diesel-powered pickups. By doing so, we were able to lower our operating costs by about one third. We didn’t compare just one pickup - we compared nine pickups. We plan to stay with GM from now on.”

Best Buy

REM 2100 corn

Dan and Tim Thissell, Centerville, S. Dak. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

They like their 2002 REM 2100 “corn and soybean special” grain vac. “This grain vac is relatively inexpensive to buy and is simple to repair. It’s very user friendly, with no expensive air pumps or air locks on it. It uses an auger to fill our truck and will load it at a rate of 90 bushels per minute under the best conditions. I think you can buy a new fan for about $500, so you don’t have to worry about the possibility of a catastrophic breakdown.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Deutz GP 250 round baler + 1 more

Kevin Dibble, Smethport, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

“My 1996 Deutz GP 250 round baler has been relatively trouble-free and is virtually impossible to plug up. It makes a firm bale in either wet or dry hay, no matter what ground speed it’s working at.

“My worst buy is a 2000 commercial hot water heater made by Rheem Mfg. Co. The tank had to be professionally installed in order for the warranty to be valid. The tank was delivered and installed with the wrong regulator so the water wouldn’t get hot enough to meet dairy regulations. It took three tries before the company finally sent me the right regulator. Then I found out they wouldn’t last. Three regulators have gone bad, and the warranty had just expired on all of them. I paid $1,800 for the tank, and the regulators cost more than $200 apiece , including installation.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Gehl 3510 skid steer loader + 3 more

Al Kuck, Smithfield, Neb. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

“My 1996 Gehl 3510 skid steer loader is my best buy. It’s just like having another right hand for doing pivot irrigation work, moving snow, pulling posts, and so on.

“My 1994 Dodge 1500 4-WD pickup equipped with a 360 cu. in. engine has more than 154,000 miles on it. All I’ve had to replace is the fuel pump and the water pump.

“My Ryobi weed trimmer, which I bought at Wal-Mart, is my worst buy. It wouldn’t start so I took it to Wal-Mart’s service people. They got it started once. After arguing with them for four months they finally refunded my money. Since then I’ve purchased an Echo weed trimmer, which works great.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 3500 heavy duty 4-wd + 2 more

Winston D. Rhodes, Sr., Weyers Cave, Va. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

“My 2001 Chevrolet 3500 heavy duty 4-WD dually pickup equipped with a diesel engine and an Allison automatic transmission is my best buy. This pickup is quiet and has a lot of power. I use it to pull a 30-ft. trailer with heavy loads of 25,000 to 30,000 lbs.”

He rates Dodge trucks as his “worst buys.” to your vacuum cleaner,

“I like Greased Lightning spray spot remover (A&M Cleaning Products, Inc., P.O. Box 1731, Clemson, S.C. 29633 ph 864 646-7730; website: www.greased-lightning.com). It gets greasy mechanics pants almost clean enough to wear to church.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4

Tom McCracken, Vanderbilt, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

Tom’s happy with his 2000 Deere 4 by 2 Gator. “My wife and son bought our Gator over my objections. Boy, was I wrong. We all love it. We use it for everything - feeding livestock, fencing work, checking cattle and hogs, and so on. All of us, including our sheep dog Duke, love taking it on Sunday afternoon rides.”

Best Buy

Kubota L4300 tractor equipped

Larry Ingram, Lincoln, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

A 2002 Kubota L4300 tractor equipped with a frontend loader heads up Larry’s “best buy” list. “It’s handy for doing garden and farm work, and I like being able to hang deer from the loader during hunting season. I get a lot of things done with it that I never thought I could do.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 1500 Quad cab pickup equipped

Billy C. Nance, Cedar Hill, Tenn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

A 2003 Dodge Ram 1500 Quad Cab pickup equipped with a 4.7-liter, V-8 engine is Billy’s “best buy.” “This pickup has great room and a lot of power. It has no problem pulling trailers with heavy loads.

“On the other hand, my 2001 Dodge Ram 1500 Quad Cab pickup with a 318 cu. in., V-8 engine was a worst buy. It went through three engine replacements in only 500 miles. The door and rear window seals leaked. The pickup wouldn’t go faster than 65 mph, and whenever I went between 35 and 45 mph the entire pickup would shudder. Another problem is that the automatic transmission shifts hard when going uphill with the cruise control on.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Prairie 300 4-WD atv

Paul A. Krumenauer, Chippewa Falls, Wis. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

A 1999 Kawasaki Prairie 300 4-WD ATV rates as Paul’s “best buy.” “This machine has been used and abused, but it can handle it. I use it to plow snow on my 600-ft. driveway. It works much faster than my tractor, and it has good traction on ice. I’ve used this machine successfully to pull logs and loads weighing as much as 10 times the machine’s own weight.”

Best Buy

Nissan 4-WD pickup equipped

Ralph Farnsworth, New Haven, Vt. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 13

“One of my best buys ever is a used 1992 Nissan 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5-speed transmission and an electric lift snow plow. It has about 142,000 miles on it with very few problems. The tires on it last about 60,000 miles, and it doesn’t use oil. I change the oil every 2,000 miles. This pickup is fuel efficient, always starts, and has a lot of power.”

Best Buy

International Harvester 4300 dually truck equipped

Gary Parker, Ft. Shaw, Montana · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

Gary’s the proud owner of a 2002 International 4300 dually truck equipped with a DT 466 engine, 7-speed transmission, jake brakes, and air seats. “I use it to pull a 24-ft. aluminum trailer and put on about 20,000 miles every year delivering cattle. This truck has a lot of power and an excellent split on gears, and the jake saves on brakes. With a full load and hauling big cattle, the duallies on the rear axle are all overloaded yet the jake brakes can handle it. Pickup brakes don’t compare. This truck keeps me road legal and is great to drive.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5300 MFWD tractor equipped

Larry Hershberger, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“I like my Deere 5300 MFWD tractor equipped with a 540 front-end loader. I bought it used a year ago, and several weeks later the pto clutch gave out. However, the dealer replaced it at no cost. This tractor is small enough to get in and around buildings, yet it’s strong enough to handle round bales and grind feed. And, with front wheel assist, it works great in mud and snow.”

Best Buy

Melroe Spray Coupe

Aaron Warner, LaMonte, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“We’re well satisfied with our 1995 Melroe Spray Coupe which we bought used two years ago. The controls and monitor are user friendly and within easy reach. Everything on this machine can be easily serviced. It has worked flawlessly and we’re well satisfied with it.”

Best Buy

Struck mini dozer heads

Douglas Ripka, Rebersburg, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

A 2004 Struck mini dozer heads his “best buy” list (www.struckcorp.com; ph 262 377-3300). It’s a compact tracked machine for digging, dozing, hauling, and earthmoving that’s available in five models ranging from 10 to 28 hp. The 10 hp model is small enough to fit in the back of a pickup. More than 30 different attachments are available including a loader, front and rear hitch, six-way blade, backhoe, auxiliary hydraulic circuit, pto-operated auger, scarifier/ripper, log splitter, log fork, post-hole auger, plow, etc.

“I bought it last March and there were a few problems at first which the factory promptly worked out. This little workhorse has helped me move a lot of dirt and manure. The transmission system consists of Kevlar cord belts, with a sprocket and chain final drive, which is very simple to work on.”

Best Buy

DR trimmer-mower

Cathy Stapleton, Atascadero, Calif. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

Cathy likes her DR trimmer-mower. “It works like a weed whacker on wheels and is able to power through 3-ft high wet weeds and 1-in. dia. brush with ease. It starts right up every time and has low maintenance requirements. It’s worth every penny I paid for it.”

Best Buy

Lincoln power-luber

Kurt Freitag, Ashvelot, N.H. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

Kurt’s pleased with his 2002 Lincoln Power-Luber. “It requires only one hand to operate and comes with a 36-in. long hose to reach hard-to-get-at fittings. The battery lasts a long time between charges.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4100 compact tractor equipped + 1 more

Fred E. Foster, Brandywine, Md. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My 2001 Deere 4100 compact tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower has been used all over southern Maryland for landscaping and plowing snow. It’ll lift anything imaginable with no problems at all. All I have to do is grease it, fill it with fuel, and go.

“My 2003 Dodge Ram 3500 4-WD crew cab pickup equipped with a 24-valve Cummins diesel engine is also a best buy. It has a lot of power and is fuel efficient.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Echo line trimmer + 1 more

Greg Dennis, Ranburne, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My 2002 Echo line trimmer is my best buy. I’m well into my third growing season of using and abusing this jewel of a trimmer. I use it to trim grass around our house, cut weeds around our chicken houses, and for cutting weeds and light brush along fence lines and road frontages. I haven’t spent a dime on it other than routine maintenance.

“Goodyear Wrangler radial tires are my worst buys. I bought these tires for my GM pickup and had nothing but problems with them from the start, including tread separations, sidewall failure, and punctures by objects that couldn’t be found in the tire. I went through nine different tires on the pickup over a 20,000-mile period. Finally I decided to replace them with another brand.”

Best Buy

A twine tensioner for round balers that he bought from Don Parker, Sco

Jason Onago, Milan, Mich. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

A twine tensioner for round balers that he bought from Don Parker, Scottville, Mich., rates as Jason’s “best buy” (Vol. 28, No. 2). Powered by the tractor battery, the unit bolts onto the baler between the twine box and twine applicator tubes and is connected to a remote switch in the cab. Flipping the switch for one or two seconds actuates a solenoid that causes the brake to lift off the twine, thus freeing the twine for an easy start.

One reason he wanted tighter bales was so he could bale straw left by his Case IH rotary combine.

“It lets me get the twine tight enough so bales don’t break. One time I accidentally dropped a tightly wrapped big bale 12 ft. and I was surprised to see it bounce. Without the tensioner, the bale would have exploded. But with the twine so tight it bounced like a small square bale might bounce.”

While Onago adjusted his Parker tensioner to work with the baler manufacturer’s original tensioner, you can also back off completely from the manufacturer’s tensioner and use Parker’s unit in place of it. Fits most bal-ers (Donald Parker, Scottville, Mich. ph 231 757-2804).

Best Buy

Bradley likes the pair of support stands he bought from Gray Professio

Bradley Stroll, Ozone Park, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

Bradley likes the pair of support stands he bought from Gray Professional Service Equipment (St. Joseph, Mo., www.grayusa.com/support_stand.asp or 800 821-7320). The stands have an adjustment range of 12 to 20 in. A pair of stands can support up to 30,870 lbs.

“I farm and also have a wholesale bakery company so I have a lot of trucks, and I do most of my own service work on them. I bought the stands last summer after the ones I was using wore out. Shopping around, I quickly discovered that it’s hard to find support stands not made in China and, in my opinion, most of them are junk. It doesn’t pay to take chances when you’re working underneath a vehicle.

“These stands are well made and lock in place with metal pins. I use a jack to lift the vehicle and then place the two support stands underneath, one on each side. When I remove the jack from the vehicle, I know that it won’t budge. The stands sell for $225 plus S&H.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt drill/driver kit + 2 more

Rick Boyd, Lexington, Ohio · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“I like my 2001 Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt drill/driver kit. It’s equipped with a light, charger, and two batteries. I’ve used it to remodel many rooms and projects, and it always works flawlessly. It has performed beyond my expectations.

“My Mantis tiller with dethatcher and sidewalk trimmer edger is also a best buy. I bought it used in 1991. This little tiller does a fantastic job in small gardens and flower beds and works great for cultivating. My neighbors use it and they keep wanting to buy it from me. However, it will never be for sale but will be handed down to our kids.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman line trimmer powered by a 32 cc gas engine is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and vibrates bad. I wish I would have spent extra money and bought an Echo or a Stihl.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki 2-WD 4-wheeler

H.M. Black, Sudan, Texas · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

A 2002 Kawasaki 2-WD 4-wheeler rates as his “best buy.” “It starts well in both cold and hot weather. I like the excellent gear ratios because it works well for slow travel on rough ground to check fences and to deliver cotton seed to our cows. It also works good for checking crops and is fast enough for road travel. It loads and hauls easily in the back of a pickup.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Venture

Paul Lammers, Kalamazoo, Mich. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

Paul’s disappointed with his 1998 Chevrolet Venture. “I bought it used with 60,000 miles on it. It wasn’t long before I discovered that third gear was gone. The transmission shop said the other gears looked brand new, but for some reason third gear was gone.

“About a year later I discovered an antifreeze leak. The problem turned out to be the intake gasket. It seems that GM makes the engine block out of iron and the heads out of aluminum. The gasket in between is made of plastic. Because the different metals expand and contract at different temperatures, the gasket in between can’t handle the changes. I talked to an independent mechanic who said he has seen the intake gaskets fail at only 20,000 miles.

“Finally, this spring we discovered the air conditioning didn’t work. It’s probably the evaporator, which is an $800 job. I now have 92,000 miles on this vehicle and can’t wait to get rid of it.”

Best Buy

GM Sierra longbed pickup equipped

James Baugus, Kemp, Texas · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

James is pleased with his 2002 GM Sierra longbed pickup equipped with a 4.8-liter engine and automatic 4-speed transmission with overdrive. “It’s the right size pickup for what I need. The engine has a lot of power for a small V-8 and gets up to 24 mpg on the highway going with the wind, and 17 mpg loaded with the air conditioning on and going against the wind. On average it gets 21 mpg.”

Best Buy

My 1997 White 6510 tractor has a lot of power but I wish it had a bett

Zachary White, Alamagordo, New Mexico · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My 1997 White 6510 tractor has a lot of power but I wish it had a better seat with more adjustments. It handles better than any other tractor I’ve ever driven although it could be more fuel efficient. With all the improvements in vehicles and weight reduction that comes with using plastic and aluminum, why hasn’t the fuel efficiency improved very much?”

Best Buy

Clear Out

Gerald A. Borders, Sullivan, Ind. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My best buy is Clear Out, which is a generic Roundup product. As far as I can tell it works just as good as Roundup, but costs only $4 per acre. Monsanto gets plenty of my money for tech fees, so I don’t want to give them any more than I have to.

“My 2 1/2-year-old daughter is a best buy. She only cost $2,250 and I’m looking forward to a lifetime of enjoyment out of her. So far she’s top of the line!”

Best Buy

John Deere 750 2-WD tractor

Harry Williams, Warrenton, N.C. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“I like my 1985 Deere 750 2-WD tractor. It’s made by Yanmar. This tractor has a lot of power, a strong lift, and handles good. It’s also easy to trailer. I use it with a 72-in. grooming mower, 4-ft. Bush Hog, 4-ft. box blade, angle blade, scoop, post hole digger, and 3-pt. sprayer to control weeds along fence lines. Fuel economy is excellent.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6400 tractor

John Sparling, St. Marys, Ontario · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

John nominates his 1995 Deere 6400 tractor as his “best buy.” “Visibility is good all the way around, controls are conveniently located, and the swivel seat is comfortable. They should make the hood easier to open and also make it easier to access the batteries and air filter. I also wish there were more outlets available for accessories.”

Best Buy

Ram 150 pickups rate

Armand D. Gravel, Kingman, Maine · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

A pair of Dodge Ram 150 pickups rate as Armand’s “best buys.” “We put 202,700 miles on our 1994 model without any repairs to the engine, and we have 129,600 miles on the 1998 model. We just sold the 1994 model and hope to keep the 1998 model as long as we can. Both pickups are powered by V-6 engines that are small but very reliable.”

Worst Buy

GM Sierra 3/4-ton 4-WD supercab longbed pickup

Guy Norton, Dome Creek, B.C. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My 2000 GM Sierra 3/4-ton 4-WD supercab longbed pickup became a worst buy when cracks developed in the box corners just behind the cab. These cracks developed at about 16,000 miles and eventually cost me $1,600 to have repaired. GM takes no responsibility, blaming poor road conditions, which I think is ridiculous. We’ve lived and farmed in this same location for 30 years and never had this problem with my last four GM pickups. The problem seems to be common, so I recommend other 1999 to 2003 owners check closely with a mirror - your headache rack/canopy may be the only thing holding your box together.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 4253 tractor + 1 more

Phil Carter, New Era, Mich. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Phil rates his 1999 Massey Ferguson 4253 tractor as “best buy.” “I use it to pull a 500-gal. FMC 350 orchard sprayer, 7-shank mounted chisel plow, a corn planter, and to plow snow. It’s fuel efficient and uses only 2 1/2 to 3 gal. per hour. It doesn’t smoke, uses very little oil, and starts right up even in the coldest weather. The cab is easy to enter, the controls are convenient, and the seat is comfortable. Compared to my old Massey Ferguson 1085, the engine is much quieter - I can actually hear the radio and talk on the cell phone. This tractor has adequate power and is fun to drive. Several of my neighbors have the same model and they all love them.

“Our Morton 54 by 105-ft. building with 16-ft. sidewalls is a well designed, attractive building. The materials are top notch and the building crew was a great group to work with. I’ve received many compliments on it. The building was completed in December 2002.”

Best Buy

Europa 75 corn/pellet stove

Rick Titus, Clarion, Iowa · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Rick liked his Europa 75 corn/pellet stove so much he became a dealer (www.pelletstove.com or 877 331-6212). “This stove has 12-volt motors for augers, fans and all the electronics. It uses only about 65 watts. It automatically speeds up all fans and augers or slows them with the change in heat output. Three ash augers remove ash from the burn pot. It uses a gasification process to burn both the corn and the gases produced by the burning corn. The fire spins like a tornado and has a flame that’s blue, lavender, purple, yellow, and orange. The prettiest fire I’ve ever seen. I’ve been selling wood stoves for 29 years and corn stoves for 20 years, and I’ve seen or tried just about everything on the market. This is the best one out there.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6210 4-WD tractor equipped

Lavon Flaherty, Nashville, Ark. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

“I’m well satisfied with my 2002 Deere 6210 4-WD tractor equipped with a Power Quad transmission and cab. It’s a quiet, stable tractor with powerful hydraulics, and I really like the Power Quad transmission. The cab offers good visibility, and the air ride seat and two-way adjustable steering wheel make it comfortable to operate. In my opinion, it would be difficult to improve this tractor.”

Best Buy

Ford Explorer

Dan Homan, David City, Neb. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Dan’s impressed with his 1998 Ford Explorer and also his 1999 Ford F-250 diesel pickup. “We purchased both vehicles new and have had great luck with both of them. Neither has been back to the dealer except for a Firestone tire recall on the Explorer.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4840 2-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Ed Guran, Rosetown, Sask. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

“It’s the best tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Ed, pleased with his 1980 Deere 4840 2-WD tractor equipped with 23 by 38 dual wheels. “The engine had more than 10,000 hours before it had to be overhauled. We updated it to 4850-style sleeves and pistons in order to get better fuel economy and extra power. The powershift transmission was overhauled at 11,000 hours. I didn’t make even one trip to the dealer before those repairs. It’s an excellent, clean tractor and doesn’t leak oil anywhere. I never bought any accessories for this tractor because it didn’t need any. It has a good lighting setup, and the batteries are well located.

“The view from the cab is good on both sides, but the exhaust pipe and air cleaner do block the front view considerably. The cab is equipped with a hydraulic-operated seat, which I really enjoy. I haven’t modified this tractor in any way. With new tires, a new engine, and a new power shift assembly, this will be my last tractor in my farming career. Because it took 24 years before this tractor needed repairs of any kind, I don’t expect to have to work on it again for a long time.

“My 1969 Allis Chalmers XT190 tractor isn’t green, but it sure stands up to Deere’s long green line as far as quality and durability are concerned. It was my main tractor when I bought it new in 1970. At the time, there wasn’t a better tractor anywhere in its category other than the rugged 4010 and 4020, which cost considerably more. It has a lot of power and still doesn’t leak any oil even though I’ve always worked it hard. It has a large roomy cab with a good view. This tractor has a super high-low dual shift transmission that can be shifted any time on-the-go. It shifts smooth, with no clashing of gears. I haven’t had any problems with the transmission to this day.”

Best Buy

REM 210 grain vac

Dan Rossmiller, Brady, Montana · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Dan likes his 2003 REM 210 grain vac. “This grain vac is about 10 percent faster than the company’s older 1026 model and has many more convenient features. After one year of use I can’t find any noticeable wear on it.”

Best Buy

Saturn SL1 car + 1 more

Patrick McGoldrick, Oxford, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

“My 1996 Saturn SL1 car has more than 213,000 miles on it and is still going strong. My only expenses have been for routine maintenance. It’s a superb car.”

Saturn also makes his “worst buy” list. “My LW1 has about 113,000 miles on it, and I’ve already spent more on maintenance for it than I have on the SL1 model at 213,000 miles. Something always seems to be going wrong with it.”

Best Buy

John Deere 9120 tractor

Richard Ruggles, Marlette, Mich. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Richard’s impressed with his 2003 Deere 9120 tractor. “It’s equipped with a 496 cu. in. engine that’s rated at 280 horsepower but feels like it has a lot more. The 24-gear transmission has many working speeds so it’s an easy job to find just the right one. This tractor is fuel efficient and has had no problems so far.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bestway Field Pro II sprayer equipped + 1 more

Laif Anderson, Pine Bluffs, Wyo. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

Laif nominates his 1999 Bestway Field Pro II sprayer equipped with X-fold 60-ft. booms as his “best buy.” “This sprayer has covered 50,000 to 60,000 acres with very few problems. It’s durable, well-built, and handy to use. We use it on our farm and also to do custom work. After five seasons of use the booms are starting to get weak, but the rest of the machine is as tight as the day I bought it.

“My 2001 Orthman 8-row one-trip strip till machine is my worst buy. The machine plugged up even in wheat stubble, bending the first row of shanks, which were too light to till deep. The company didn’t want to replace them so I upgraded to their new shanks which were unavailable when I purchased the machine. I still had to buy some of the parts. This year I got some relief from my dealer. He put me in touch with a welding company that modified the machine, lengthening the tool frame by 4 inches, which made it work. Orthman still claims their machine is fine and won’t approve the changes, but the modification fixed the plugging problem in stubble and I haven’t bent a single shank since then. Now the machine works good.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman garden tractor

Fred Cailey, Batavia, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 15

“In your last issue, Bill Reeks of Cromwell, Ky., said he had problems with the front axle and spindle on his 2001 Sears Craftsman garden tractor. He ended up rebuilding the broken axle by clamping it back together and welding it properly. So when the front axle failed on our 1998 Sears Craftsman garden tractor, I was disappointed but not surprised.

“Following Reeks’ experience, I can confirm that Sears does not make a heavy duty axle to replace their standard production front axle. The standard axle is part number 154427 and costs $32.99. This axle is made of two pressed steel halves that are about 0.100 in. thick and are joined together with intermittent welds along the seams where the two halves mate. It appears that the axle on our garden tractor failed in about the same location as did the axle on Reeks’ tractor - at a high stress point at the end of one of the intermittent welds on the lower left side of the axle.

“After making several phone calls to the company, I ended up talking to a gentleman in the ‘research department.’ He said there was no history of failed axles except on tractors that had been abused, and that some of the newer Sears tractors did have cast front axles. At a local Sears store I found that the larger Sears tractors do have cast front axles, but the tractor on display that was similar to our tractor had a front axle like ours. I don’t believe our tractor was ever abused, but perhaps Sears wants to equate failure to abuse -‘If the axle fails, it means the tractor has been abused.’

“Like Mr. Reeks, I repaired the axle by welding the failed area and adding some dou-blers. If I end up having to buy a Sears replacement axle, I will completely weld the full length of the seam between the two axle halves. I believe this simple step will greatly improve the integrity of the axle.”