Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005)

71 reports from pages 12–15 · 62 Best Buys21 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Removall

Jim Deardorff, Chillicothe, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

Deardorff is manufacturer of “Classic Blast”, an aluminum oxide and walnut shell mixture used for sandblasting in place of tradition media. He does a lot of restoration work on tractors and older cars. He recently called to tell us about a new product that he has been using to strip paint called “Removall”. It’s made in Canada by Napier Environmental (www.biowash.com; ph 800 663-9274). Deardorff also sells it (www.classicblast.com; ph 660 646-6355).

“I’ve always had trouble with extra thick, tough paints and this product works better than any other paint stripper I’ve ever tried. It will remove virtually any kind of paint. Removall is based on a hydrogen peroxide formulation which makes it environmeltally safe with no disposal problems.

“I just spray this material on with an airless sprayer with a big nozzle tip, wait four to six hours, and then power wash it off. A medium-sized car or tractor usually takes about a gallon, which costs $35. To strip paint off a tractor, I mask off the hydraulic hoses. Takes only about 20 min. to treat a tractor.

“In addition to stripping off paint, I also use it to clean paint out of paint sprayers. I just run a little through after I’m done spraying and it keeps nozzles free and clean. This is a great product.”

Best Buy

Mantis garden tiller

Keith Fravel, Cresco, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

“I bought a 20-lb. Mantis garden tiller a few years ago. At first it did a good job and started easy. But last spring it quit working, and I discovered the engine wasn’t producing a spark. This machine doesn’t have any points, just a coil next to the flywheel. I installed a new coil but it didn’t help. Then I checked the kill switch to see if I could find a short in the wire, with no luck. I got no help when I called the company. In fact, I can’t remember ever talking to someone who thought they knew so much but had so little common sense. I’ve been working on small engines all my life so I know what I’m doing.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup

Ray Combe, Paradise, Utah · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

“In the last issue of FARM SHOW Bonetz Zeimetz of Mondovi, Wis., got my attention with his worst buy, a 2000 Ford F-150 pickup. I and two of my sons have similar vehicles with defective engines. My pickup has leaking head gaskets, and the engine in one of my son’s Ford Expedition blew two spark plugs.

“The problem isn’t exclusive to the engines manufactured in 1999 and 2000. It covers engines built all the way from 1997 to 2003.

“The warranty on my F-150 had just expired when I discovered the head gaskets were leaking. After talking to several Ford dealers I found that leaking head gaskets and blown spark plugs are a common problem with Ford engines. Also, Ford was well aware of the problem but kept installing the defective engines in their vehicles.

“In addition to Ford, I filed a complaint with the NHTSA, the FTC, the Center for Auto Safety, the Michigan Better Business Bureau, and the Utah Attorney General. After spending a year and a half without getting help I decided to just let the head gaskets leak. There are other trucks to buy.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 1 more

Dave Nicholas, Martinsville, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

“My 1987 Ford F-150 pickup has more than 207,000 miles on it and is my best buy. It’s powered by a 6-cyl., 300 cu. in. engine which has never required any major engine work except for the replacement of an oil pump. I bought it used about ten years ago with about 100,000 miles on it. I think Ford’s 6-cyl., 300 cu. in. engine is the best gas engine Ford has ever built, especially the fuel-injected models. I wouldn’t hesitate to make a long trip to California or anywhere else with it. My neighbor has a vehicle with one of these engines and it has more than 340,000 miles on it and has never had the head off.

“My 1999 Dodge Durango SUV equipped with a 318 cu. in. engine is a best buy. Hands down it’s the best mid-size SUV on the market. It has the same running gear as a full-size Dodge 1/2-ton pickup, bigger than any other 1/2-ton or full-size SUV or pickup except another Dodge. It has the same rear axle housing as my 1977 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup and 1984 Ram Charger.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Polaris 4-wheeler 400 2-WD atv + 1 more

Norm Batson, Clay Springs, Arizona · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

Norm’s impressed with his 1994 Polaris 4-wheeler 400 2-WD ATV. “We’ve used this machine hard, both for play and for work. My grandsons use it almost every day. I put new rings on the pistons and installed new rear tires, but otherwise it has required only routine maintenance. The only problem is that it takes at least a week to get parts, and they’re quite expensive.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2000 Ace scroll saw. “The problem is that the blade keeps breaking, no matter what tension I set it at. I can’t cut any material thicker than 1/8 in., and even then the blade still breaks no matter how careful I am. The company says I don’t have the blade tension set right. I chalk it up to experience - no more Ace products for me.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 6410 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Donald Parker, Apple Springs, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 12

A Deere 6410 4-WD tractor equipped with a self-leveling front-end loader rates as Donald’s “best buy.” “I haven’t had one problem with this tractor. I’ve been using Deere tractors for well more than 50 years and have tried other brands, but in my opinion Deere tractors are the best.

“My Krone 283 10-ft. disc mower is my worst buy. This mower cost me more than $3,000 in broken glass on the cab of my tractor. It wouldn’t cut with the cover in the low position. It did cut with the cover in the high position but then it would throw rocks. The dealer wouldn’t do anything about it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

MTD riding mower equipped + 1 more

James McGowan, Russell Springs, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

An MTD riding mower equipped with an 18 1/2 hp engine and 46-in. deck rates as James’s “best buy.” “I traded for it two years ago and have used it since then to mow roadside lawns. It has a deep deck so it does a good job of discharging grass. It can cut anything I can drive on. The only repair it needed was to the deck wheels, and they had good reason to break off because I drove over a lot of rough ground.

“Mad Dog drill bits are my worst buy. I had to return them to the company twice. They sent more bits but they all had the same problem. My wife bought a set of drill bits for $20 from another company that work better than this set, which cost me $80.”

Best Buy

Jesse Ma-chine Works + 1 more

Larry Moranda, Eureka, Calif. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“The quick-tach bracket I bought from Jesse Ma-chine Works for my Deere 145 front-end loader is my best buy (Jesse Machine Works, Chico, Calif. ph 530 342-4379). The hitch converts your loader into a quick-tach. It attaches to your loader permanently.

“My Saginaw Tractor 3-pt. hitch for my Deere B tractor is also a best buy (ph 810 638-5787; www.saginawcounty tractor.com). It comes preassembled and is raised and lowered by the tractor’s internal hydraulic lift.”

Best Buy

John Deere 8200 tractor + 3 more

Bill Fuller, Kinder, La. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 1999 Deere 8200 tractor has a lot of power. Also, it drives and handles nice.

“My 2004 Deere 6615 tractor has a much-improved transmission over the company’s 6605 model.

“My 2003 GM 2500 pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter engine is an excellent work truck with a lot of towing capacity. My 2004 GM 3500 pickup has a lot of power and towing capacity, and it accelerates well. It has a fairly nice ride.

“My 1999 Polaris Sportsman 500 has been trouble-free.”

Best Buy

Harman PC 45 corn stove

Philip Coblentz, Country Comfort, 396 Gordon Rd., Aua, Ill. 62907 ph 888 561-8232 · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

Philip uses a Harman PC 45 corn stove and has also become a dealer. “Harman has addressed all the issues that have plagued other corn burning stoves. It’s the first to have a practical self-ignition system that really works well, even with 15 percent moisture corn. It uses a 400-watt element, which means that no special wiring is required. Takes about five minutes to ignite.

“The cleaning interval has been greatly reduced and electronics are advanced, allowing more consistent room temperature. Conventional thermostatic controls provide a three degree plus or minus swing in room temperature.

“In addition, the stove has advanced safety features. It’s easy to use, efficient, and well designed.”

Best Buy

Ram 1-ton Laramie SLT dually truck

Roy Cude, Trinity, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

Roy’s happy with his 1998 Dodge 1-ton Laramie SLT dually truck. “It gets the job done. We use it to pull a 35-ft. trailer through Colorado, New Mexico, and a lot around Texas. We change the oil and do a maintenance check every 3,000 miles. I’ve spent a total of less than $5,000 over the years, counting oil and filters.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Yanmar 1700 tractor + 1 more

Ed Gorham, Gladewater, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 2002 Yanmar 1700 tractor was hard to get on and off. I sold it with only 22 hours on it and bought a 1949 8N, which works great.”

“My 1996 Dodge 2500 pickup is my worst buy. The dealer put the wrong size tires on it and there were problems with the rear axle seals. The pickup was in the shop about 40 times during its first 60,000 miles. I finally got the problems fixed and it now has more than 126,000 miles on it.”

Best Buy

John Deere 330 riding mower equipped

Jim Schilling, Graf, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 1986 Deere 330 riding mower equipped with a 16 hp Yanmar diesel engine is my best buy. The engine has a lot of power and can pull our large homemade wood splitter up some good-sized hills with no problems. It has a lever-action hydrostatic drive that gives us infinite speeds and doubles as a cruise control when we find the speed we want. Hydraulic lift makes it easy to raise the deck. The machine has a 4 1/2-gal. fuel tank so we can cut our large yard three to four times before we have to refill the tank.”

Best Buy

Woods 1190 post hole auger

Pete Schilling, Gaylord, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“I don’t like my 2003 Woods 1190 post hole auger. When I bought it the salesman told me it had an internal slip clutch. But it turned out to be a shear bolt machine and the first time the bolts sheared it destroyed the auger extension which was built too light for an 18-in. auger. I wanted to return it but the dealer refused to take it back. No more Woods products for me. I use this machine to make a living putting up Silverstream hoop buildings, and I can’t wait until I can afford to trade it off.”

Best Buy

Ram Grand Caravan LE 4-wd mini van + 1 more

Bruce Moorhead, Susquehanna, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 1994 Dodge Grand Caravan LE 4-WD mini van is my best buy. It works great in snow - one time I was able to drive it up a steep hill with 10 inches of new snow on the ground. It has more than 148,000 miles on it but has required only routine maintenance.

“I like my Mantis tiller and Mantis sprayer. Both machines are more than 10 years old. They’re well-built.”

Best Buy

Troy-Bilt high wheel string

Darian Sullivan, McBee, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

Darian’s impressed with his Troy-Bilt high wheel string trimmer equipped with a 6 1/2 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. “It has performed flawlessly and really cuts well. It starts easy and is well balanced, making it easy to push and a pleasure to operate. The trimmer strings are easy to replace.”

Best Buy

Ram D-50 2-WD shortbed pickup equipped

Jerry Jenkinsa, Omak, Wash. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

Jerry’s happy with his 1978 Dodge D-50 2-WD shortbed pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine. “I bought it from an irrigation company. Their shop maintenance records showed it had a little more than 200,000 miles on it. I’ve put another 130,000 miles on it with only minor repairs. The really good part was that I paid only $550 for it. It’s also fairly economical to operate.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD Z-71 pickup equipped

Dwight Shiels, Stoughton, Sask. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 2003 Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD Z-71 pickup equipped with an off-road package is my worst buy. It has had a lot of problems. The cruise control has quit working three times, the 4-WD switch quit working, and the air conditioner failed. After the air conditioner was repaired, the blower motor quit working. One time the brake pedal stuck to the floor and I had to be towed. The rear brakes wore out quickly. I was told that rocks got in the brakes and that I needed to install stone guards. Sounds like they’re telling me that I can’t drive an off-road truck off the highway?”

Best Buy

Schulte XH1500 brush cutter

Kevin Lys, Fort Smith, N.T. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My Schulte XH1500 brush cutter is an excellent value. I’m a contractor in the Northwest Territories of Canada and in the past 12 years I’ve owned several of these machines, cutting about 3,000 miles of right-of-way. They greatly outperform the competition. If a company ever built a pickup with this quality, I’d own a whole fleet of them.”

Worst Buy

Haier America chest freezer

Dan Sabo, Mount Sterling, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“Last November I bought a Haier America chest freezer with a 1-year warranty. I was only able to use it for four months before it broke down. I called the company six different times during a three week period, and every time they promised that a repairman would come out within 48 hours. However, no one ever showed up. I was finally told there isn’t a repairman in my area because it’s too remote. They said that if I could produce a sales receipt they’d give me a full refund. I sent them the sales receipt but never got a refund. Finally I took them to small claims court and won a judgement, but I still haven’t been paid. My recommendation is that if you don’t live in New York City where the company is headquartered, then don’t buy their products because they won’t honor the warranty. I’d appreciate hearing from anyone who thinks they can help me.”

Best Buy

Tree Lounge Co

T.E. Kirk, Edgerton, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“I think tree lounge deer stands are dangerous in general, particularly when climbing up tree trunks. I bought a stand from the Tree Lounge Co. and they wouldn’t refund my money, as they advertised they would.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4400 compact utility tractor

Dean Sharp, Rexburg, Idaho · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“It’s just an all-around handy little tractor,” says Dean, pleased with his 2000 Deere 4400 compact utility tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission, front-end loader, and backhoe. “I was reluctant to get the hydrostatic transmission, but my two sons talked me into it and I’m sure glad they did. I can move dirt or snow so fast that passersby often stop just to watch. My only complaint is the loader’s control lever isn’t well located. I think this problem has been taken care of on the company’s newer models.”

Best Buy

Hesston 4590 center-feed baler

Jim Schroeder, Bend, Oregon · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 2004 Hesston 4590 center-feed baler is a great machine. It makes nice bales, turns short, and it’s small enough to fit through small gates. It handles well on the road since it trails right behind my tractor. We use it on small farms. This baler saves a lot of time compared to side-feed models. I can’t imagine using anything else.”

Best Buy

Pest Chaser electronic rodent repellers

Raymond Baillargeon, North Battleford, Sask. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“I’ve been using Pest Chaser electronic rodent repellers for about 30 years and they’ve kept my buildings mouse and rat-free for all that time (Comfort House, Newark, N.J. ph 800 359-7701; www.comforthouse.com). They’re very reliable and are designed to last for five to seven years, but I’ve had them last for up to ten years. I recently paid $19.95 for a new model. It’s maintenance-free and I like not having to deal with poisons or dead animals. The ultrasonic sound waves can’t penetrate solid objects so the company recommends putting one Pest Chaser in each room where you have a problem.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere LT 133 lawn tractor + 1 more

Shannon Rupnow, Reeseville, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“My 1999 Deere LT 133 lawn tractor always starts and has been trouble-free. The blades hold a sharp edge so well I only have to sharpen them once a year.”

On the negative side, “I love Matco tools because they never let me down, but I always had problems with slow delivery of their products. I complained to the company and they told me the problem was with my distributor. So I changed distributors, and now the stuff I order is delivered to my door the same day it arrives at the distributor’s place.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere + 1 more

R. Engel, Phoenix, Arizona · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

“I bought a 1950 Deere A tractor that needed repair work. It was a fun project to work on, and plenty of used and new parts were available. Now it’s a great running tractor.

“My 1997 Lincoln Town Car equipped with a 4.6-liter engine is my worst buy. The engine has a plastic intake manifold that started leaking at 60,000 miles. The company offers a kit with a new intake with metal inserts in the water jacket. There’s also a replacement mount for the alternator. It cost me $1,800. Why didn’t Ford recall this problem? Do all Ford 4.6-liter engines leak behind the alternator?”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toyota Prius + 1 more

Wayne W. Urffer, Moorestown, N.J. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My wife and I are well pleased with our hybrid 2002 Toyota Prius. It comfortably seats four big adults, has a generous-sized trunk, and a lot of power. It’s very fuel efficient, getting anywhere from 45 to 53 mpg. Our best mileage was on a 660-mile round trip from southern New Jersey to western Massachusetts, when we got almost 56 mpg. We’ve had only one problem, a faulty computer module that was fixed under warranty. We’re already looking at ordering another Prius, as Toyota has improved the power, lowered the emissions, and increased luggage space.

“I’m not impressed with my Wagner electric power painter. The commercials make using it sound so easy. But this paint gun was so noisy the neighbors complained and the dog howled. And to get the paint to flow properly, I had to thin it down and as a result it looked like stain when it was applied. It took four to five coats to get decent coverage and no matter how I fiddled with it, it dripped paint all over the place. I paid $45 for the deluxe model, and I was happy to see it go at a yard sale for $5.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped

Scott Engleka, Fairhope, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“This truck is awesome. It’s the best I’ve ever owned,” says Scott, impressed with his 1999 Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped with a Powerstroke diesel engine. “My pickup had some aftermarket work done to it so it really runs good. Whenever I pass people on the road they always look, because my truck is really loud and sounds like a jet plane. It’s an excellent truck.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4020 tractor

Henry Groeckel, Hanover, Kansas · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“I own an outstanding 1966 Deere 4020 tractor that runs on LP gas. It has more than 13,000 hours on it but the transmission has never been repaired nor have I ever had to do anything to the hydraulics. The engine has been overhauled three times. The only problem is the main bearings are a little weak. They’re the same bearings used in the gas engine that comes with this tractor. The bearings should have been bigger, because LP gas results in higher compression.”

Best Buy

Rhino FM100 finish mower

Joseph Stauffer, Leonardtown, Md. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

Joseph bought a Rhino FM100 finish mower slightly that’s his best buy. “We remodeled this 100-in. mower by adding a 25 hp Kohler Command engine to the deck. We changed the drive ratio by reversing the position of the gearbox, and we replaced the 3-pt. hitch with a simple pin hitch. We also welded blocks to convert the rear two caster wheels into fixed wheels. The machine trails nicely behind my two-horse hitch.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram Dakota pickup equipped + 2 more

Richard Durham, Salford, Ontario · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My worst buy is my 1998 Dodge Dakota pickup equipped with a 3.9-liter, V-6 engine. The bumpers rusted under the paint and bubbled out during the first year. That problem was repaired under warranty, but then the same problem happened again. The bolts snapped off on the exhaust manifold and also on both sides of the engine, and the upper ball joints wore out at about 30,000 miles. When I tried to change the spark plugs for the first time, the threads broke off in the engine. Now I’m just waiting for something else to go wrong. I never had any problems with the 1990 GM S15 pickup I owned previously. It was a much better vehicle.

“My Case 220 lawn tractor is my best buy. It’s probably more than 20 years old, but I’ve never had a problem with it. No other lawn tractor, including Deere models, compares to the quality of the old Case tractors.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ten-nessee walking horse never breaks down + 1 more

David Foster, Lillington, N.C. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My Ten-nessee walking horse never breaks down and is well tempered but spirited. It doesn’t affect the ozone or contribute to bad air. It’s always dependable, and always goes the distance. It has good brakes, starts easy, and accelerates fast.

“My 1994 GM 2500 Sierra extended cab pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter turbo diesel engine is a worst buy.

“This truck has a history of problems but the most recent was last November. I was driving home on a four-lane road at about 45 mph. As a stoplight went from green to yellow, I applied the brakes only to feel the brake pedal go rapidly to the floor. The brakes were gone, with no warning at all. I rolled through the red light still pressing the pedal hard to the floor and downshifting the automatic transmission.

“Lucky for me, the intersection wasn’t busy. I found out the brakes failed due to rapid fluid leakage. After getting the truck home, I discovered a hole in a metal brake line behind the fuel tank. There was no kind of backup braking at all.

“I called GM to let them know and hopefully prevent someone else from having the same problem, but I really don’t expect to hear back from them.”

Best Buy

My 1954 Ford 800 tractor is my best buy

Gary Alford, Edwardsburg, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My 1954 Ford 800 tractor is my best buy. I rebuilt it 20 years ago for my father-in-law. We use it in our truck garden and it performs flawlessly. Years ago I changed the electrical system over to 12-volts and adapted a Dodge truck plow with a 7 1/2-ft. Western blade. With chains on the pickup’s tires and a blade on front and back, it plows snow like a tank. Now that I’m getting older, a power steering retro kit would be nice.”

Best Buy

Grassator extra heavy duty

Michael Johnson, Marengo, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My Grassator extra heavy duty blade-type replacement head for string trimmers is my best buy (CMD Products, Lincoln, Calif. ph 800 210-9949; www.grassgator.com). It requires no tools for installation and features three 3-in. long high impact nylon blades that’ll last the average homeowner an entire season under normal use. It fits 99 percent of all gas-powered trimmers. Works great on heavy weeds. It even survived severe beatings from rocks.”

Worst Buy

United States Stove Co plate steel coal

Joel T. Cowher, Philipsburg, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My worst buy is a United States Stove Co. plate steel coal stove. When I set the stove up, I discovered it was missing two fire bricks which could have created a fire hazard. The grates are so sloppy, they hang up and dump live and raw coal into the ash pan. It’s not very efficient, with coal at $164 per ton.

“I drove 60 miles to the dealer, hoping he could solve the grate problem. He said he would contact the company and call me the next day. However, that ‘next day’ has never come. Apparently the quality of the dealer and the company are the same as the stove. If you want a stove with a Cadillac price and Dollar Store quality, this is the stove for you.”

Best Buy

Yamaha 2000 Big Bear

George Schneider, Pioneer, Calif. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“I’ve come to the conclusion that the only thing an ATV is good for is getting from point A to point B. None of the ATV implements I’ve tried have been satisfactory, including a trailer, sprayer, trailer seeder, feeder, snowplow, and rake, My Yamaha 2000 Big Bear just can’t handle any of them. Of course, I’ve had other troubles with this ATV. It leaked oil, which cost $400 to fix. And it takes up to six weeks for Yamaha to ship parts from a warehouse just 250 miles away.

Worst Buy

Country Clipper zero turn mower

David Weese, Cameron, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

“My Country Clipper zero turn mower equipped with a 17 hp Kohler engine and 48-in. deck is my worst buy. The problem is that it leaves a skip between the blades. The dealer corrected a problem we had with flying belts, but it still does a lousy job of mowing. The company won’t refund my money. Apparently, once the mower leaves the shop it becomes a used machine.”

Worst Buy

Hardy outside woodburning furnace

Robert L. Jefferson, Freeman, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

A 1988 20,000 btu Hardy outside woodburning furnace rates as Robert’s “worst buy.” “This is a stainless steel unit. A leak occurred where the manufacturer bent the steel at a 90 degree angle. They sent me what they called a repair kit, which turned out to be just a tube of cement. This lasted until spring when the problem got much worse. The unit was returned to the company, which said the problem was that we had salty water. I consulted the local water district that supplies our water, and their tests have never shown a presence of salt. We lost $2,000.”

Best Buy

Peltor hearing protector ear

Truman Ross, Comins, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

Truman’s impressed with Peltor hearing protector ear muffs equipped with a radio, which he bought from Gemplers. “I’ve farmed for 40 years and these hearing protectors are the best investment I’ve ever made - bar none. They make driving a tractor or combine, etc., much less monotonous.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Little Giant ladder + 1 more

Denise Solt, Ashfield, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 14

Denise nominates her Little Giant ladder as her “best buy.” “It’s very strong and can be configured in a variety of ways. It has a wide base that’s very stable. We paid more than $300 for it so it isn’t cheap, but we use it several times a week. We haven’t had to take our other extension ladders off the wall in more than a year.

“Our 2002 Honda 4-WD 350 electric shift ATV is our worst buy. It stopped shifting after we had only put 140 miles on it. The dealer said someone at the factory had cross-threaded or stripped a bolt on the transmission. The company said they would replace the transmission case and provide parts, but they wanted $450 for labor. Fortunately, our dealer solved the problem by installing Helicoil inserts for new bolts. However, I still had to pay $30 for the gaskets. The dealer was great, but the company and warranty were not.”

Best Buy

Cummins diesel engine

Kirk Dahl, Ruby Valley, Nevada · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“We installed a 5.9-liter Cummins diesel engine in our 1992 Ford F-250 4-WD Supercab pickup and it really worked out great. This repower job was such a success that we put the same engine in a 1988 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup. Both vehicles have performed great since the conversions, both in fuel economy and power.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 360 Pro chain saw + 2 more

Aaron Barneson, Chippewa Falls, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“My Stihl 360 Pro chain saw is lightweight, works fast and smooth, and is powerful. It lets me cut two to three times as much wood in the same amount of time as I could with any other brand.

“My 2002 Sears Craftsman 42 cc string trimmer is my worst buy. It wouldn’t even run when I got it home. I exchanged it for another model, but that model wouldn’t stay running either except at full throttle - it randomly stalled out. I took it to the service department seven different times during the first year - and then the warranty expired. Finally I got rid of it and bought a Stihl FS 200, which has been trouble-free.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 1-ton pickup

R. Himmerich Y Valencia, Pena Blanca, N. Mex. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“My 2002 Dodge 3500 1-ton pickup is my best buy. I bought it to replace a 1989 Dodge W-350 model. Both pickups have manual transmissions. The 1989 model had 480,000 miles on it when my son bought it. The 2002 model already has more than 54,000 miles on it with no problems. The 1989 model averages more than 20 mpg; the 2002 model, 18 1/2 mpg. The 2002 model really should have locking hubs, though.”

Best Buy

Stihl chain saw equipped

Joe Price, Somerset, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

Joe’s the satisfied owner of a Stihl chain saw equipped with a telescoping extension. “The extension really comes in handy for trimming branches off trees. I can stand on the ground and reach up a long ways without having to climb up in the tree, which I appreciate as I’m 65 years old. My wife and I are really pleased with this chain saw.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6500 L tractor

Clark E. Martin, Harrisonburg, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“Our 1995 Deere 6500 L tractor has a lot of power, good hydraulics, and adeqauate traction. Best of all, the engine has amazing torque and power. It’s the most fuel efficient tractor we own. My only complaint is that the operator station could be improved in design and layout.

Best Buy

Long 3-pt backhoe

James F. Friesen, Lake Charles, La. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

James likes his 1971 Long 3-pt. backhoe. “This machine can’t match the power or capabilities of an industrial model backhoe. But for general, light duty work it’s great. Over the years it has required some repairs, of course, but nothing out of the ordinary. It works great for rice field work, burying dead animals, conservation practices, and for many miscellaneous jobs.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 1/2-ton pickup equipped + 1 more

Cullen Loveless, Booneville, Miss. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

A 1969 Chevrolet 1/2-ton pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine and manual transmission rates as Cullen’s “best buy.” “I bought it used in 1971. It has performed beautifully with hardly any breakdowns and is still going strong. I use it to haul seed, fertilizer, firewood, etc. It’s a cheap form of transportation in these days of high gas prices.

“My 1952 Ford 8N tractor is still going strong. I use it almost every day, especially for gardening work.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

GMLS Golden Fox steel building + 1 more

Mont Blackburn, Thermopolis, Wyo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“We’re happy with our 2004 GMLS Golden Fox steel building. We were on our way to pick up the building in Peabody, Kansas, when our pickup quit working 20 miles from town. The company’s head man came out and personally diagnosed the problem with the pickup. He drove to Wichita, bought the part and then - most amazingly - installed it for us right there on the side of the road. How’s that for customer service? My wife and I, who are 75 and 72 years old, were able to put the building up ourselves without any help. This is our second Golden Fox building and we wouldn’t buy anything else.

“Our 1999 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a Powerstroke diesel engine is our worst buy. The camshaft position sensor went out and left us sitting in the middle of a highway construction zone. We’d been warned that this problem had happened to several other people. What’s really bad is that you don’t get any warning there’s a problem at all.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 261 tractor equipped + 1 more

Martin J. Engelbrecht, Jefferson City, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“It’s big enough for 90 percent of the needs on my small farm,” says Martin about his 1999 Massey Ferguson 261 tractor equipped with a Bush Hog QT front-end loader. “It has the best fuel economy I’ve ever seen in a late model tractor. The loader frame has never been off the tractor. My only complaint is that the remote hydraulics work too slow. Also, gear shifting is slow and clumsy, especially when you try to shift the pto on or off. I put used airplane tires on front. The original tubeless front tires punctured too easily. Airplane tires don’t steer as well with a loader tractor, but they don’t go flat all the time, either.”

Best Buy

John Deere X495 garden tractor equipped

Robert E. Whitehead, Kiowa, Colo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“Our 2003 Deere X495 garden tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. Yanmar diesel engine and 54-in. mower deck is our best buy. It does an excellent job mowing, has a lot of power, and a comfortable ride. I use the mower on two acres around our home and farm buildings. Deere equipment is more expensive, but I think it’s worth the additional cost.” wheels. I’ve had problems with them breaking and can’t get anyone to help. The small lugs on the front wheels make this tractor very unsafe to operate. Because of this dangerous condition I don’t recommend this tractor to anyone. I’d appreciate hearing from anyone else who’s had similar problems with Landini tractors. I can be reached at [email protected]. “

Best Buy

Sears zero turning riding

Reverend Barry Andrews, Williston, Fla. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

Reverend Barry is impressed with his 2002 Sears zero turning riding mower. “Although it has broken down twice, the company repaired it to my satisfaction. It does a great job of cutting our tough Florida grass, reducing the time spent on my 1-acre parsonage yard by about one third. I bought it used as a returned model for less than half its retail price.”

Best Buy

Volkswagen Golf TDI equipped

Mick Corse, St. Louis, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

“My 2002 Volkswagen Golf TDI equipped with a diesel engine and 5-speed transmission is a best buy. No problems. It gets 50 mpg. I installed grease fittings on the rear wheels just so that I could grease the wheel bearings. I don’t like the front end because I can’t grease it at all.”

Worst Buy

Ford 2120 4-WD tractor

Harold Hershey, Harrisonville, Penn. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 15

Harold nominates his 1991 Ford 2120 4-WD tractor as his “worst buy.” “At first I thought I had made a good buy because this tractor performed so much better than my previous Case 885 2-WD loader tractor. With that tractor I was always getting stuck while cleaning out ditches and trying to back out with a loaded bucket, whereas the Ford could handle that kind of work well. But the Ford wasn’t as good as the Case when it came to plowing. The Case could pull a 3-bottom plow with no problems. I only put a 2-bottom plow on the Ford, but if I didn’t have the tractor in 4-WD the wheels would just spin.

“In September of 1992, with just 340 hours on it, the Ford started having problems. The bell housing broke into five pieces. However, the tractor was still under warranty so the company paid for it. The tractor had been sagging down in the middle and, in my opinion, it had to have put pressure on some gears in the transmission. The dealer got paid only for the time the company figured it should take to change a bell housing. So they didn’t want to take the time to see if there was any other damage inside the transmission.

“Then in 1999, with 1,325 hours on the tractor, I heard a noise in the transmission gears. The dealer took the transmission apart and found a gear that was all chipped up. No gears were completely broken, but they ended up changing three gears, the gear slide, and a center shaft. With parts and labor the total repair bill was $1,521.95. They told me it looked as if the transmission had been low on oil at some time or other. But I know that wasn’t true.

“In 2000, with 1,462 hours on the tractor, the front wheel drive locked up due to a piece of metal between two cogs in the gearbox located in front of the transmission.

“At 1,490 hours the transmission started making a terrible growling noise whenever I put it in reverse. The dealer took the tractor apart and changed a bearing. Then they decided to change all the bearings in the transmission just to play it safe. But that still didn’t solve the problem.

“I’m tired of being a guinea pig and paying for all these repairs. I was told I would have to pay to have anyone come to my place and even listen to the noise. Now I can sometimes hear the noise with the transmission in a forward gear. I can also hear the noise by putting the clutch in and out without the transmission in gear.”