Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009)

81 reports from pages 12–15 · 68 Best Buys30 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Edenpure quartz heaters

Thomas C. Jones, Williamstown, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“I recently read reports in FARM SHOW from readers unhappy with Edenpure quartz heaters. I wanted to tell readers that I have two Edenpure heaters bought in 2008 that I like a lot. I use them to heat three rooms and a bath, and last winter my furnace didn’t come on until the temperature got down to 7 degrees above zero. The friend who talked me into buying them has four of units. The company promptly answers any questions. I have numerous friends who have seen my heaters and then bought their own. The older models had trouble with the bulbs burning out, but the company stood behind them all the way. Their new models have 20,000-hour bulbs. I’d recommend this heater to anyone.”

Worst Buy

Univer-sal corn burner

Jay Strayer, Degraff, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“My Univer-sal corn burner is my worst buy. The first year I had to replace three or four auger motors, and the second year the water pump went bad and the machine ran only for about six weeks the entire winter. I couldn’t keep the auger motors running, even though I use corn that’s dried to 13 1/2 percent moisture and is cleaned through a screen.

“All the company says is that I’m doing something wrong. I’ve used this corn burner for only three winters but already I’ve had to totally rebuild it, adding a new firepot, new augers, new timers, new auger motors, and a new blower.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 4-WD equipped

Kelly Shelton, River View, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“This pickup runs great,” says Kelly, pleased with his 1995 Dodge 2500 4-WD equipped with a diesel engine. “It’s fuel efficient, pulls anything, and is dependable. I run it on a fuel mixture of 50 percent diesel and 50 percent used oil, and I can’t tell any difference between them other than the color of the exhaust smoke.”

A 1,500-lb. 12-volt winch that he bought from Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy”. “The cable came off the pulley and wrapped around the motor housing which caused it to lock up.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Staber top load washing + 1 more

Sue Seefeldt, Coloma, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“We’re well pleased with our Staber top load washing machine (Staber Industries, Groveport, Ohio ph 800 848-6200; www.staber.com). It’s very efficient, using only a fraction as much water as other machines. My clothes are always clean and there’s no agitator to cause wear and tear on them. I use only one ounce of detergent per load. The extra cost of this machine has paid off in savings to our pocket book and to the environment. Best of all, it’s made in the U.S.

“My 2006 Jeep Commander is my worst buy. At first we were mostly pleased with it, except the V-6 engine wasn’t as fuel efficient as we had expected. Then we had problems with the electronics and there were noises, fluid leaks, and safety control issues. All this with well under 36,000 miles.”

Best Buy

Titan loader tractors

Art Hertz, Fairfax, S. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

Art’s son is a dealer for Titan loader tractors (ph 605 638-0897; www.titanloadersales.com). “I bought a 4-yard 958G model and like it real well. I’ve operated it for 60 hours and it uses less than 4 gal. of fuel per hour. These tractors are made in China using American-made parts.”

Best Buy

Stihl 460 chainsaw equipped + 2 more

Jim Peake, Leask, Sask. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“I like my Stihl 460 chainsaw equipped with a 20-in. bar.

“My 2001 Husky 359 saw has never been touched and the carburetor is still on original factory settings. I use it every other day all winter, cutting about 14 cords per winter.

“I use my Stihl FS85 trimmer equipped with an 8-in. saw blade to cut willow trees. It does a wonderful job.”

Best Buy

Gravely 12 hp lawn tractor + 2 more

Richard Quik, Vandreuil-Dorion, Que-bec · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“I use my 1980 Gravely 12 hp lawn tractor to cut grass and clear snow. It’s still going great and always starts right up.

“I use my 1990 Stihl 034 chainsaw to cut 20 cords of wood every year. I just bought a 24-in. blade for it from Cutters Choice to make cutting large trees an easier job (ph 814 898-1738; www.cutterschoice.com).”

Best Buy

Reese Maxi twin drum mower + 1 more

Stephen Carpenter, Somerset, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“My Reese Maxi twin drum mower, which I bought used, mows as fast as I can stay on the tractor seat without plugging up. It’ll mow grass from 6 in. high to 4 ft. high with ease.

“My 2006 Deere 6603 and 2007 Deere 6403 MFWD tractors are both easy on fuel. They let me plant beans with a 15-ft. 1560 drill on one quart of diesel per acre. These are ‘value’ tractors - no electronics means no trouble.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hardee Navigator sprayer equipped + 1 more

Vince Manhart, Palestine, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“My Hardee Navigator sprayer, equipped with a 1,000-gal. tank and 60-ft. boom, is easier to operate than any other sprayer I’ve owned. At first I had trouble with the computer, but the district rep got it working. He actually took it to the field and ran it himself to be sure it worked okay. Not many companies provide service like that any more.

“My White 5100 splitter planter is my worst buy. I was never so proud of Case IH machinery until after we bought this planter. It was a nightmare - we seemed to be working on it all the time. We planted 30 percent less per day with it than we did with the same size Case IH planter.”

Worst Buy

Wallenstein BX42 pto-powered wood chipper

Ellis S. Kinney, Louisville, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 12

“I’m disappointed with my Wallenstein BX42 pto-powered wood chipper. The top rotor housing tapers from 5.25 in. sq. to 4 in. round to accommodate the discharge chute, and this taper causes a tremendous plugging problem. The machine plugs up as often as six or seven times per hour.

“A factory rep told me an increase in rpm’s should solve the problem, but it didn’t. Another factory rep told me to adjust the stationary knife. No luck.

“I solved the problem by sawing off the top rotor housing taper and replacing it with a straight square piece that’s welded to the top housing. Now it works perfect. I have to reposition the tractor in order to change discharge directions, but that’s a minor inconvenience.

“Also, while working on this machine I noticed the welds that hold the hopper bracket to the base frame have cracked. The problem isn’t faulty welds but an over exuberance in grinding to dress up the welds.”

Best Buy

Bloom Buildings

Dennis Kaltenheuser, Elkhart, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“I’m impressed with the machinery storage shed I bought from Bloom Buildings (Oskaloosa, Iowa ph 641 673-8338). The company was good to work with and took their time and did things right.”

Best Buy

Mazda B2000 pickup + 1 more

Thomas E. Farris, Sr., Winchester, Kan-sas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“My 1989 Mazda B2000 pickup has more than 700,000 miles and is still going strong. I drive it every day.

“My 1991 Mazda B2600i pickup is a best buy. I drove it for 10 years and put about 530,000 miles on it.

“The 1993 Mazda B2600i pickup I bought used three years ago just turned 300,000 miles and is still running strong. Mazda makes good pickups that require only routine maintenance.”

Best Buy

Stihl 290XXS chainsaw

Neal Galloway, Lynch, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

Neal’s the proud owner of a 2007 Stihl 290XXS chainsaw. “After owning a Stihl Woodboss model for 25 years I bought this saw and found it has the same great quality. We use it to cut firewood and to cut cedar fence posts for sale. This company makes a fantastic saw.”

Best Buy

Verm-X

Chris Dohogne, Lebanon, Mo. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

Chris likes Verm-X, an internal parasite control for animals (www.verm-x.com). “It’s advertised as a natural solution made up of herbs for repelling internal parasites. Formulations are available for horses, a range of poultry, dogs, cats, rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, sheep, goats, alpacas, llamas, pigs and cows. The product is available in different forms - liquid, powder, daily treats, different-sized pellets, and nuggets.”

Best Buy

Murray riding mower

Jerome Cooper, Jamestown, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“It runs great,” says Jerome about his 2003 Murray riding mower. “I had to replace a mandrel on the deck, but otherwise it has held up well. Even the factory battery held out for four years. This mower still has the original tires and still climbs embankments easily. I had one small problem with the carburetor due to some gas that I allowed to go bad. I drained the bad gas and in a few minutes it ran fine again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Staber washing machine + 1 more

Eric J. Wise, Omar, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

Eric says his Staber washing machine is his “worst buy”. “We were really impressed with the Staber design so we bought the machine. However, from day one it wouldn’t balance correctly. Whenever it went into the spin cycle it sounded like there were elves with rubber mallets trapped inside.

“The company reluctantly sent new struts to solve the problem but it didn’t help. The drum drive motor went bad when the welds in the tub leaked water. After talking to the sales manager, I learned the drum had a lifelong warranty and they sent a replacement. But the new drum’s drive motor went bad after only three days. The company sent a new one but it didn’t last any longer.

“Finally I emailed the company and also left a phone message stating we planned to buy a new washer within five days and to please contact me. They emailed me two weeks later detailing how busy they were with warranty issues. My wife and I really like our new Whirlpool washer, and I happily cut up the Staber model for scrap.”

Best Buy

Winkler Canvas Hoop Buildings

David Koopmans, Maurice, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“I like the 38 by 80-ft. canvas hoop building I bought from Winkler Canvas Hoop Buildings (ph 800 852-2638; www.winklercanvas bldg.com). It makes a cheap storage area for our hay. I put the building on 8-ft. sidewalls with tin on them and erected poles at the end to put hay against. I stack small square bales in it, using a New Holland 1002-55 self-loading and unloading bale wagon.”

Worst Buy

I’m disappointed with the new compact fluorescent light bulbs

Tom Neuberger, Canistota, S. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“I’m disappointed with the new compact fluorescent light bulbs. I fell for the pitch by my electric co-op regarding how much electricity these bulbs save. The electricity savings that’s advertised is probably true, but I’m not so sure about the bottom line regarding dollar savings. I have a box full of burned-out bulbs, none of which lasted for even one year, much less the five years they’re supposed to. One bulb didn’t even last an hour.”

Best Buy

Ryobi 18-volt combo kit

Lowell LaFave, Middletown, Mo. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“It’s one of the most versatile cordless tools I’ve ever seen,” says Lowell about his Ryobi 18-volt combo kit. “This kit comes with 11 tools and I purchased other tools to go with it. The lithion battery I bought for it makes the tool work that much better. I highly recommend it.

“My Sears drill press, table saw, bandsaw, and shop vac are all worst buys. I couldn’t use the drill press because the chuck failed. With the bandsaw, the blade would either jump off the wheels or break. The table saw had a throat plate big enough to drop a stick of wood through, and it didn’t have much power. I was a machinist for 40 years and these are the worst pieces of machinery I’ve ever seen.”

Best Buy

Gorilla adjustable step ladder

Brian O’ Shea, Wellsboro, Penn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“My Gorilla adjustable step ladder is an excellent tool (ph 800 867-6763; www.gorilla ladders.net). It’s easy to adjust and extend, and works much better than a stepladder. I can stand on either side of it and use it on steps or on uneven terrain. I like this step ladder so much I plan to buy a second one.”

Best Buy

Lucky Buck mineral supplement

Bill Burrell, Jr., San Angelo, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“I own and operate a 500-acre trophy hunting operation. I bought 10 buckets, or $250 worth, of Lucky Buck mineral supplement which is supposed to produce bigger antlers. However, the deer wouldn’t touch it and it did no good at all. Maybe the empty 3-gal. plastic buckets will come in handy.”

Best Buy

John Deere 3520 tractor equipped

Nikki Roman, Howell, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

Nikki’s the satisfied owner of a Deere 3520 tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “I’m 76 years old and the loader has saved me and my 39-year-old daughter a lot of back aches. The tractor is powered by a diesel engine that always starts, even during the winter. The post hole attachment we use makes putting in fence posts an easy job.”

Best Buy

Sea-Crop saltwater fertilizer

Brad Miller, Ridgeville Corners, Ohio ph 419 267-5679 · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“I like Sea-Crop saltwater fertilizer (www.thefuelman.com). It has worked great on all the crops I’ve used it on. It’s designed to remineralize the soil with a perfect balance of all the missing nutrients. I like it so much that I became a distributor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Domino garage door opener + 1 more

Jeff Weller, Dunnellon, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

Jeff’s impressed with his Domino garage door opener keypad entry system (ph 800 736-6466; www.dominoengineering.com). “We use the door opener keypads on four roll-up doors on our farm and they work great. The keypads are easy to program and are backlit for night use. It’s an awesome product. Ever since we installed them we don’t bother using the factory door buttons or switches. The company’s customer service is outstanding. They trouble shoot the problem with you on the phone and will promptly send a replacement if it’s needed.”

He’s unhappy with his Priefert Wire D gates. “We have more than 50 of these gates on our property. All of them are less than 2 1/2 years old and many are less than 1 1/2 years old. Yet all of them are rusting, some so bad the wire is actually spalling and flying off in pieces.

“I sent some photos to the company, but instead of stepping up and replacing the gates, they sent me some touch-up paint. I refused the shipment and will be filing online complaints to make others aware of my experience with this company. We’ll have to take the gates down and try to sandblast them and paint them with a proper rust inhibitor like Rust Bullet - or we’ll just donate the gates to our local horse rescue organization. This is the kind of experience I’d expect from some made-in-China junk, not an American-made product. Where is the pride?”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Multiton walkie/stacker unit + 1 more

Rick Mabeus, Winfield, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My best buy is my 2003 Multiton walkie/stacker unit - a walk-behind, battery-powered forklift that I bought used three years ago (ph 804 737-7400; www.jungheinrich-us.com). It’s surprising how much it’ll lift. We use it every day to assemble new equipment in my shop. It’ll go 28 days on a single charge and is balanced and very stable when it lifts. I’ve made several attachments for it.

“I’m disappointed with my Berlon skid steer loader attachment called the Forkster. It’s a forklift attachment to help carry more weight without putting the skid loader on its nose. However, when you try to lift with it, the dolly tires flatten and I can’t even move the unit. It might work with a larger skid loader. The stands that it sets on when it’s self-standing also drag whenever I try to use the unit. To me it’s just a high-priced boat anchor. But I’ve used other attachments built by this company with no problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram diesel pickup + 1 more

Keith Gerweck, Falls City, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My 1996 Dodge diesel pickup is the best pickup I’ve ever owned. It has more than 166,000 miles on it, and I expect a lot more as long as I take good care of it.

“My 1990 IH Magnum 7110 tractor is my worst buy. The differential went out twice. A tractor salvage company says that if I install the differential out of a Case IH Magnum 8910 I can still use the tractor’s original ring gear and pinion. The differential out of the Magnum 8910 is heavier built, but it costs $300 more than the standard differential.”

Worst Buy

Northern Tool

Bill Mobley, Hubbard, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“The 10-ton manually-operated log splitter I bought from Northern Tool is my worst buy. It has a 2-speed pump that builds up to 10 tons of pressure and operates by using two steel handles. However, it won’t split logs.”

Worst Buy

Onan Marquis generator set

John Dickinson, Port Orange, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My 1994 Onan Marquis generator set, which I bought used 2 1/2 years ago, is my worst buy. I’ve taken it to two different repair shops and spent more than $4,000 on parts and labor, but they can’t find the problem. It won’t deliver the correct voltage. It seems that dampness may affect it because on hot, sunny days it works better, but not all the time. Both the stator and voltage regulator were replaced but it didn’t help.”

Best Buy

Woodmizer sawmill equipped

Billy M. Gilmore, III, Poplarville, Miss. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

A 2007 Woodmizer 21-ft. sawmill equipped with a 25 hp Kohler engine rates as Billy’s “best buy”. “It performs fantastic and is the best piece of equipment I’ve ever bought. I used it last September while building a house to cut 16,000 board feet and saved thousands of dollars. It’s manually operated but that’s okay because it’s fun to use.”

Best Buy

Thermal Engine Corp wood stove fan

Andy Gheen, Athol, N.Y. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My Thermal Engine Corp. wood stove fan is powered by a Sterling engine, which means the heat of the stove itself powers it (ph 256 772-8781. This fan is American-made and does an outstanding job. Whenever I call the company, real people answer the phone and actually listen to my comments or questions. This fan has increased my wood stove’s effiency by at least 30 percent with its quiet and reliable air circulation.”

Worst Buy

Caterpillar 246 Turbo

Alan M. Tierney, Capron, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“In 2000 my brother Daryl and I bought a Caterpillar 246 Turbo A Series skid loader. It’s equipped with a cab and heater but the heater has never worked. At 238 hours the right side hydraulic motor went out. At 1,555 hours the oil pump housing broke off, ruining the motor. The company wanted $20,000 to repair it, but after three months of fighting we ended up paying $4,753 for the repairs.

“My brother and I are the only ones who operate this machine so it’s not abused. It’s powered by a poorly designed Perkins/Caterpillar diesel engine. After 8 years of use and with only a little more than 3,000 hours on it, I’m not impressed. Not with an industrial piece of equipment doing hobby farm work. So much for Caterpillar dependability and resale.”

Best Buy

Elec-Trac electric mower

Alan Auerbach, Waterloo, Ontario · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“I use an Elec-Trac electric mower and snow-blower that just keeps humming along (as long as I install new batteries every 6 to 8 years). I bought the tractor in 1972, the year GE discontinued making them.”

Best Buy

Segway

Elmer Pinkerton, Elmwood, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“I’m fascinated with the Segway, which is an innovative two-wheeled electric standup scooter. I bought one from a dealer in Omaha and was supposed to get it in two weeks.

“Two weeks passed with nothing to show so I called the dealer. He had no idea what was going on. I told him I’m 83 years old and don’t even buy green bananas any more. He returned my money.

“I wrote to the factory but got no response. It may be a fine machine but the company is too disorganized. What if you needed service?”

Best Buy

Vink Cow Lift

Victor Daniels, Arenac County, Mich. ph 989 654-2425 · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

Victor likes his Vink Cow Lift, which allows dairymen to get downed cows back on their feet. However, he saw the need for something that would allow a cow to turn around once she has been lifted. So he modified it by adding a swivel.

“Once she’s on her feet the cow can turn around. Also, the swivel helps the cow to walk with a natural rotating action to another location where she can have time to recover. “This lift has worked well every time I’ve used it,” says Daniels.

The device won the 2008 Michigan Farm Bureau invention award.

Best Buy

Kubota B2910 compact tractor

Brad Cole, Skaneateks, N.Y. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My Kubota B2910 compact tractor has a lot of around 360 degrees to slosh rinse water around.

“The barrel stand costs $442. I installed a brass valve in the bottom bung so I can shut off the flow quickly. On the top bung, I devised a system to pressurize the container. I drilled a 5/8-in. hole in the center of the top bung cover to accept a tire valve stem. I’ve used this idea in barrel bungs for over 30 years, and have never had any problems. You do have to be a little careful not to over-pressurize the barrel, especially if it’s made of plastic, or it could burst, and then you would have a big mess.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

HU-LIFT Mobile Drum Carrier + 1 more

Roger Gutschmidt, Gackle, N. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“I really love the barrel stand I bought for emptying 55 and 30-gal. barrels. It makes it easy to handle heavy barrels of herbicide or oil in the shop. I’ve used it on barrels weighing as much as 1,000 lbs. and it was effortless. It’s called a HU-LIFT Mobile Drum Carrier and I bought it from Fastenal (www.Fastenal.com; 507-454-5379). You just wheel it up against a barrel and ratchet a belt tightly around it. Then you use the handle to lift the barrel about 6 in. off the floor so you can tip it horizontally. When it’s empty and you want to clean it, you can even swing the barrel power and is economical to operate. It’s extremely reliable and always starts, even in cold weather.

“My Husqvarna 18-in. chainsaw is my worst buy. After using it for less than two years and cutting no more than 40 face cords of firewood, the saw wouldn’t run at full rpm’s. It would just lose power and stall. I took the saw back to the dealer who rebuilt the carburetor, but it didn’t help. Another dealer told me the problem was spun bearings and that the saw wasn’t worth repairing.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota 4-WD pickup equipped

Lewis Klejeski, Cloquet, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“It has more than 138,000 miles on it but still runs like a clock,” reports Lewis about his 1992 Dodge Dakota 4-WD pickup equipped with a V-6 engine. “I’ve never had any problems with the 4-WD even though I’ve often driven in 4-WD at freeway speeds. I drive on gravel and salted roads every winter but it has no rust.”

Worst Buy

EZ Hoe tiller/cultivator

William Thompson, Williston, N. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“My 2007 EZ Hoe tiller/cultivator is my worst buy. It worked alright for one year but the next year I couldn’t get it started. I ended up having to replace the carburetor. We’re garden growers for a local farmer’s market, and this problem put us about two weeks behind schedule.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight

Jim Rymut, North Royalton, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

Jim likes the 2007 electric chainsaw sharpener he bought from Harbor Freight. “I already had a much better chainsaw sharpener that I bought 20 years ago for hundreds of dollars. However, I would have to sharpen a mountain of chains in order to justify buying one of those machines again. This sharpener is lightweight and easy to use, and I paid only $29 for it. It paid for itself after sharpening only a few chains.

“I’m not happy with the 2,000-lb. Chicago electric utility winch I bought from Harbor Freight. I needed help getting my riding mower up the ramps to my pickup. I mounted the winch in the pickup bed and mounted the remote control at the rear bumper, so I could watch as the mower was pulled up. However, the winch couldn’t pull it up even though it’s rated at 2,000 lbs. So I’m still pushing the mower up the ramps by hand.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Dell 8250 computer + 2 more

M. Lien, Gonvick, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My 2007 Dell 8250 computer has been trouble-free.

“My 2008 Ryobi 18-volt cordless tool set works well. The lithion batteries hold a charge and also recharge quickly, and the controls are user friendly.

“My 2007 Suzuki King Quad 700 4-wheeler has been nothing but trouble. At 100 miles the ring gear broke, locking up the rear tires at 60 mph. The front differential has broken twice, leaving the machine without 4-WD, and now a rear seal is leaking. This machine won’t start if the temperature goes below zero or if it sits for more than two or three days. The rig’s side panels make it difficult to check the oil or change it. It now has about 1,500 miles on it, and I figure it has cost me about a dollar per mile to keep this machine on the road. That’s not very impressive for a $7,500 machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Deutz Allis 6265 + 1 more

Clayton Borntrager, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“It’s a fuel efficient tractor that’s easy to maintain, and parts for it are relatively inexpensive,” says Clayton, impressed with his 1985 Deutz Allis 6265. “It has a lot of lugging power and starts easy in cold weather. We’ve tried six other tractor brands in the past, but this one is the best yet.

“We’ve had trouble with the hydraulics on our mid 1960’s Deere 4010 diesel tractor, which we bought used. The tractor was taken to a couple of different mechanics where it racked up big bills, but it seems those repairs didn’t fix the problem.

“This tractor was supposed to be rebuilt when we bought it, but in cold weather it takes a big can of ether to start it. Or, we have to pull it 3/4 of a mile down the road before it’ll start. It seems there’s just not a big enough battery available on the market for what it needs to start. Also, parts for this tractor are expensive and complicated.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda 420 Rancher ATV equipped + 2 more

Raymond J. Gingerich, Mylo, N. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My 2009 Honda 420 Rancher ATV equipped with an automatic transmission and independent suspension is my best buy. Over the years I’ve had a lot of ATV’s, but I can’t seem to wear this one out. It just goes and goes. It handles nice and rides great.

“My Ruger pistol is accurate, jam-proof, and fun to shoot.

“My Mosquito Motel mosquito trap is my worst buy. Flying insects are attracted to the unit by its ultraviolet lights and the carbon dioxide produced by light hitting titanium oxide-coated panels. When insects enter the unit, a quiet fan pushes them down into a capture net at the bottom where they dehydrate and die. However, I was able to use the trap less than a month before both of the light bulbs on it burned out. They’re expensive to replace.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 2500 pickup equipped + 3 more

Russell S. Smith, Waco, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My 1991 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine just keeps going and going, as does my 1952 Ford 8N tractor. I also like my Drill Doctor drill bit sharpener. It works great and saves money, too.

“My 2002 Deere L100 42-in. riding mower equipped with a 17 1/2 hp engine quit starting without help after one season of use. The dealer said the compression release had broken so they replaced the engine at no charge, but they also billed me $80 for cleaning, greasing, and leveling the mower deck. The engine started okay for a couple of years but now it’s having problems again. I won’t buy another Deere riding mower.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 026 chainsaw wore + 1 more

John Ebel, Custer, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My Stihl .026 chainsaw wore out after 25 years of use, so I bought a Stihl Farm Boss and couldn’t be happier with it. This saw always starts right up and has plenty of power. If it lasts as long as my other model, it’ll probably be the last saw I’ll ever buy.”

He’s disappointed with his Grizzly 18-volt cordless drill equipped with a 1/2-in. chuck. “After about four months of light use the clutch started slipping, and then about two months later it quit working entirely. I guess you get what you pay for.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4320 tractor

Brent Arthur John Priest, Grenfell, Sask. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“Our 1971 Deere 4320 tractor has almost 9,400 hours but still works great. We use it to pull 50 ft. of harrows in the spring, a job that it handles with ease. It’s also easy on fuel. This tractor was rolled once but we straightened out the cab and it has worked fine ever since. It’s the best tractor on our farm.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 heavy duty 4-wd

Don Jensen, Mankato, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

A 2004 Dodge 2500 heavy duty 4-WD Quad Cab pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine rates as Don’s “best buy”. “It has more than 95,000 miles on it and we couldn’t be happier with it. We bought a new set of tires at about 72,000 miles, but even including that cost we haven’t spent $800 on this pickup. It averages 18 to 25 mpg. I think this is Dodge’s best pickup.”

Worst Buy

Sears Whenever

Dexter Brahm, Ionia, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Dexter isn’t happy with the 117-piece tool set he bought from Sears. “Whenever I pick up the case, half the tools fall to the bottom tray. I tried to return it but was told the case wasn’t covered under the company’s ‘return or replace’ policy. It’s probably the last product I’ll buy from Sears.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 19-volt rechargeable drill

Chester W. Claycomb, Imler, Penn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Chester likes his Sears Craftsman 19-volt rechargeable drill. “It has a lot of power and lasts a long time because of the two power packs that come with it. Also, it stores in a nice case. I’d recommend this drill to anyone.”

The pickup bed-mounted crane lift he bought from Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy”. “This crane is rated at 1,000 lbs. but the mounting system leaves a lot to be desired. It pulled the bolts right out of the pickup bed. I had to put a 3/4-in. thick steel plate under the lift, bolted and welded in place. Pickup beds are too thin to support a crane lifting that much weight.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Landini 4-WD + 1 more

Bill Smith, Moulton, Ala. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“This tractor is comfortable and easy to operate,” says Bill about his 2003 Landini 4-WD. “It’s rated at 85 pto hp but tested at 96 hp on our dealer’s dynamometer. We use this tractor mostly to make hay, but it performs equally well for tillage and other operations. It uses less fuel than other tractors with half as much power. I’ve bought several new tractors over the past 20 years, but this one is special.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his large 2006 Husqvarna backpack leaf blower. “A connecting rod broke within the first hour of use so the dealer gave us a replacement unit. However, we were able to use it for only about two weeks before the same problem happened again even though we were using the correct gas/oil mix. Normally this is a reliable brand of equipment - I just got a couple of units that somehow got by the quality controls.”

Best Buy

Hardy 120 000 btu

Mark A. Miller, Belvidere, Tenn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“I like my Hardy 120,000 btu outdoor boiler. I’ve had to replace a few things but I still like this outdoor boiler. The nice thing is the mess stays outside instead of inside the house.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bobcat 773 skid loader equipped + 1 more

Kathy Edelman, Solway, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Kathy nominates her 2001 Bobcat 773 skid loader equipped with a Kubota diesel engine as her “best buy”. “I use it every day all winter long. I plug it in at night and it never fails to start. I use it every day for feeding hay and regularly for plowing snow, cleaning the barn and other odd jobs.

“My 2000 Chevy Silverado ‘cab and a half’ 3/4-ton pickup is my worst buy. It has never been as fuel efficient as we were told it would be, and it lacks power.”

Worst Buy

Eagle Re-search

Roman M. Kulzer, Sauk Centre, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My worst buy was a hydrogen gas cell called the ER Hyzor that I bought from Eagle Re-search. The idea is to make hydrogen gas with an onboard electrolysis unit to boost mileage. The company’s advertising makes it seem like you can easily expect a reasonable increase in fuel efficiency. However, after using it for several months in my car I have yet to see any improvement. In fact, I feel it has actually decreased fuel efficiency. The $500 I spent on it was a total loss.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3430 tractor equipped

Bob Schelling, Marshalltown, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“Bob’s pleased with his 2006 Kubota L3430 tractor equipped with an LA723 quick-tach loader, and with his 2007 Kubota RTV 900 utility vehicle. “I’ve used the tractor hard yet it has performed amazingly well. There are a couple of things I don’t like about the RTV 900. It doesn’t go fast enough, and it stops too suddenly when I let up on the accelerator. However, it runs super cheap.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland TT45 tractor equipped + 1 more

Gene Exum, Brooksville, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

A 2007 New Holland TT45 tractor equipped with a front-end loader rates as Gene’s “best buy”. “I’m a disabled vet so I appreciate a tractor that’s easy to get on and that has a comfortable work space. All the controls are easy to operate and conveniently located, and fuel efficiency is outstanding. I’m completely satisfied with this tractor.

“My 2003 Bush Hog 4-ft. mower is my worst buy. I used it the first year to cut heavy pasture for about 30 hours. Then I had health problems and the machine sat in the barn until last summer, when I tried to use it to cut some light underbrush that was less than 3/8 in. in diameter. The driveshaft got badly bent. I’m disappointed in this mower. I have a Bush Hog finish mower that I’ve used for more than 20 years.”

Worst Buy

Pellet Pro’s pellet mill

Larry Nolf, Lakeview, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

Larry’s disappointed with his Pellet Pro’s pellet mill. “I bought this farm-sized pellet-making mill last December. I had hoped to start up a pellet-making business and put 8 to 12 machines to work.

“After I bought the mill I waited for the company to send a moisture tester, but I got tired of waiting and started the machine up in January. Apparently the moisture content of the material I used was too high and as a result I was unable to produce anything. Two weeks later four bolts between the gearbox and milling side of the machine failed. Finally, I got the moisture tester and used material with the proper moisture content, but the machine still did’t work well.

“Then in March the motor went bad and blew some capacitors. The company sent new ones. The company says the machine is capable of producing 200 to 400 lbs. of pellets per hour but I get less than 100 lbs.

“I called the company and asked for a refund, but their best offer was to take the machine back and try to sell it for me. And I would have to deliver the machine to them in Illinois - a round trip drive of about 16 hours. I think I should have received a complete refund. This issue still is not resolved.”

Best Buy

Milwaukee impact wrench powered + 1 more

Dan Rhodes, Myerstown, Penn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“I really like my Milwaukee impact wrench powered by a lithium ion battery. It has terrific torque. I keep it with me when on the road in case of a flat tire. I also use it for setting up farm equipment and for general repair work.

“We use our Dodge pickups equipped with Cummins diesel engines to pull heavy loads in our business. These pickups are powerful with excellent fuel efficiency.”

Worst Buy

Edenpure infrared heater

Keith Fravel, Cresco, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

“My worst buy recently was an Edenpure infrared heater. I set it up in my living room, but I didn’t notice a bit of difference. So one afternoon I put the heater in our smallest bedroom, along with a thermometer, and closed the door. The next day I checked to find the temperature hadn’t changed a bit, so I boxed the heater up and sent it back. I had to pay for the shipping and handling. I had to make a number of phone calls before I eventually got my money back.”

Best Buy

All Sports

Steve Derrick of Omaha, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 15

When gas reached $4 a gallon last summer, Steve bought two scooters over the internet from All Sports in Newton, Kansas. “When I bought the scooters I also purchased a lifetime warranty for them. When the scooters were delivered there were some damaged parts, so I was told to mail photos and parts numbers so I could get replacements. More than six months have gone by now but nothing has been replaced.”