Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007)

83 reports from pages 12–15 · 73 Best Buys29 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Wood Mizer

Lewis Legge, Valley City, N. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1995 Wood Mizer is one of the best pieces of equipment I’ve ever seen. It does what it says it will and never breaks down. I do about 15,000 board feet a year as a sideline. On a good day, I can saw up to 1,000 board feet.

“The tensioning system is simpler and easier than competitive saws, and it is quick and easy to set up. I can pull into a yard and be sawing wood 15 minutes later. I can fold up and leave even faster, in five minutes or less.”

Legge says the Wood Mizer has helped make possible several sideline businesses in addition to custom sawing.

“I saw primarily cottonwood for windbreak fence, trailer deck and for mini-storage buildings I set up and rent out. I also saw up ash trees and market to local woodworkers. I quarter saw it, and it makes wonderful furniture.

“Milling is a customer-driven business. You have to give them what they want with some exceptions. One is cottonwood. It has a very bad name, only because mills cut it up for people who take it home and nail it up. You have to cure it first. I won’t even give them green wood. I educate my customers on how to use the stuff.

“Most of my wood comes from tree trimmers and guys in town who cut down a tree. It makes me feel good to use up trees that would otherwise be burned.”

Worst Buy

American Steel Span

Robert Horne, Rural Retreat, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My worst buy is a steel building kit manufactured by Powerbuilt Steel Buildings and sold by American Steel Span. The kit consists of overlapping metal arches that bolt together. The supplier recommended a contractor, who suggested I have the county inspectors waive the progress inspections which I was able to do because it was a farm building. Followup investigations revealed the man was a Class C contractor doing Class A work. As work progressed, the building was leaning severely. He abandoned the project without waiting for his final 25 percent fee. I had to hire another contractor but the building still leans and required internal supports. It also leaks in several places. The original contractor was arrested and paid a fine. My advice: Don’t bypass the building inspectors.”

Best Buy

John Deere AMT 600 utility vehicle + 1 more

Ron Gardner, Grand Valley, Ontario · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1988 Deere AMT 600 utility vehicle is my best buy. It’s almost 20 years old but still works good for hauling deer, moose and firewood.

Roger Kahler, Kahler Kustom Iron, used it a lot on our farm and for hunting. In heavy brush it’ll go anywhere a regular ATV can go. It’ll also easily outclimb a 4-wheeler. The new machine now has about 5,500 trouble-free miles on it and has never let us down. Over the years we’ve had good luck with Polaris ATV’s, too. We bought our first one in 1989.”

Best Buy

Unihydro 42-ton metal worker

Dunnell, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My best buy is my Unihydro 42-ton metal worker (www.unihydro.com). I bought it to replace another 35-ton Unihydro metal worker that was lost in a fire. I’ve used Unihydro products for more than 20 years and really like them. They’re built with quality and come with a vertical no-distortion shearing plate.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 2500 diesel pickup + 1 more

Allen Condon, Chesapeake, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“It has more than 247,000 miles on it but is still going strong,” reports Allen about his 1994 Dodge 2500 diesel pickup. “The transmission was overhauled at about 150,000 miles. I use it to haul my antique tractors to shows.

“My Maytag refrigerator equipped with a bottom freezer is my worst buy. I bought it at Lowes. The first unit lasted only three days and was replaced. The second unit had forklift marks on top from the factory and lasted only 13 months. The company sent us a new compressor, but we had to pay for the $150 labor charge to install it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 1 more

Daniel Rioux, Layton, Utah · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“I’m well pleased with my 1998 Ford F-150 pickup. It has more than 130,000 miles on it but just keeps going strong.

“My Ryobi 4-cycle weedeater is my worst buy. It has been a piece of junk since the day I bought it. After only two months of light use it started leaking oil, and the company wouldn’t do anything about it. I’ve had it rebuilt twice but the same problem keeps happening.”

Best Buy

White Field Boss 37 tractor equipped + 1 more

Jack Kovars, Mountainburg, Ark. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1992 White Field Boss 37 tractor equipped with a front-end loader is my best buy. I bought it used 11 years ago. This tractor has a 4-cyl. Isuzu diesel engine, an 18-speed transmission with a creeper gear, and a fully synchronized main gearbox. The engine runs quiet and is fuel efficient.

“We’ve used this tractor to clear five wooded acres, to erect a 30 by 40-ft. metal shop, to build roads, and to help build a new home. It has required only routine maintenance. I recently mounted a Bush Hog 750 backhoe on it which I’ve used to dig many tree stumps, and so far the tractor handles it well. I wouldn’t trade it for any other tractor.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota 4-WD pickup + 1 more

Wayne Heiserman, Bloomfield, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1990 Dodge Dakota 4-WD pickup has more than 195,000 miles on it and is my best buy. It has a V-6 engine that doesn’t use any oil and gets 22 mpg. This is the fourth Dodge pickup I’ve owned since 1973, and I’ve put more than 100,000 trouble-free miles on all of them.

“My 1995 Troy-Bilt 5 hp rototiller is a best buy. It’ll grind up just about anything in my 5,000 sq. ft. garden. All it has ever needed was a new belt.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 pickups

Kyle Sodoma, Bayboro, N.C. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1997 and 2001 Dodge Ram 1500 pickups were both best buys, but my 2001 Dodge Ram 1500 equipped with a Hemi is an even better vehicle. It accelerates like a race car, rides like a Rolls Royce, and gets about 20 mpg. I absolutely love it.”

Best Buy

Subaru 4-WD mini truck

Mike Miller, Spencer, Neb. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“My 1994 Subaru 4-WD mini truck that I use like an ATV is both my best buy and my worst buy. This truck is very versatile with a short turning radius, the ability to haul heavy loads, and a good heater. I installed bigger wheels and tires on it to soften the ride. The downside is that the importer gave me an air filter that didn’t properly fit, and as a result the engine got ruined with only 3,000 miles on the vehicle. In less than one year, the importer’s used engines went up in price from $550 for a transaxle/engine assembly to $800 for just the engine. A local dealer of this importer said that ‘no American-made air filters fit these trucks’, contary to what the importer said, and that he had heard of several incidences just like mine.

“I hope someone will start a class action lawsuit so that we can get reimbursed. So far, I’ve been able to locate used engines but no rebuilt engines or rebuild kits. Otherwise, I think this mini truck works great.”

Worst Buy

DR power wagon

Arthur J. Gleason, Walpole, Ma. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“My DR power wagon is my worst buy. The Briggs & Stratton engine that powers it is the worst running engine I’ve ever seen. Another problem is that this rig won’t climb steep grades as advertised. These newer engines have no carburetor adjustments so there’s no way to make them start and run better.”

Best Buy

Hydra-Bed

Ken Scharabok, Waverly, Tenn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“Ten years and many hundreds of round hay bales after I bought it, my Hydra-Bed still keeps on humming along (HydraLine Products, Sabetha, Kansas ph 785 284-3674). I’ve had to replace some hydraulic lines on it but that’s expected with any hydraulic equipment. It’s nice to be able to feed out hay from a heated cab rather than from a cold tractor seat. I’ve also used this unit’s loading arms for many other jobs on our farm. And unlike a hired hand, this machine always shows up on a Monday.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere tractors ranging + 1 more

Galen Garber, Conneautville, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“Over the years we’ve owned more than a dozen Deere tractors, ranging from a 1949 ‘A’ to a 2005 6603 and they’ve all been best buys, although some have been better than others. These tractors are operator-friendly, considering when they were built, and they hold their resale value. At present, I have two models that have more than 12,000 hours on them, with no sign of quitting.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists the Zimmerman water bowls in his tie-stall barn. “For 10 years I bought and installed the company’s updates, but they still flood the barn at regular but unpredictable intervals. I took all the bowls out and put them in the trash where they belong. I wouldn’t recommend these water bowls to anyone.”

Best Buy

Satoh 650 G 4-WD tractor equipped

Rodney Luttrell, Nebo, W. Va. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

Rodney nominates his 1978 Satoh 650 G 4-WD tractor equipped with a 15 hp diesel engine as his “best buy”. “I’ve used it to mow my yard, work my garden, and haul wood. It’s really fuel efficient. I’ve overworked it and abused it and even used it to push cars, and to haul motors around. I didn’t change the oil for a long time, and as a result the oil got so thick that it wouldn’t even run down out of the drain hole. Yet this tractor just keeps on running. It’s a great machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Huskee self-propelled mulching mower + 1 more

Harley Willett, Dallas, Texas · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“The 2005 Huskee self-propelled 21-in. mulching mower I bought at Tractor Supply Company is my best buy. It’s equipped with a Briggs & Stratton Intek 6 1/2 hp engine that has plenty of power and always starts on the first pull. This machine does a beautiful job of mulching, and it’s sturdy and well-built.”

On the negative side, he isn’t happy with the Husky 1750 psi electric power washer he bought at Home Depot. “The model I bought had to be replaced three times before I finally gave up and asked for a refund. Customer service went through India, and replacement parts were still arriving three months after I got my refund.”

Worst Buy

Kubota M8200 + 1 more

Roger Simmons, Falkville, Ala. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“My 2004 Kubota M8200 does everything a tractor is supposed to do.

“My 1986 Deere 4030 tractor is my worst buy. The hydro pump keeps blowing O-rings in the belly of the tractor, and in order to make the repair the tractor has to be broken in half. The fuel filter is located right above the starter, so if it leaks it drips down onto the starter and could cause a fire. I think that’s poor engineering. I’d rather own a four-legged mule than a Deere.”

Worst Buy

Behler electric livestock waterer

Don Payne, Niles, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“My Behler electric livestock waterer is my worst buy. To replace the heating unit and thermostat, you have to take it all off and turn it upside down. It took a week for parts to arrive, and they cost $82. My advice when buying electric livestock waterers is to buy from a local dealer who carries parts, and make sure the heating elements are easy to install.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester 454 diesel tractor + 1 more

Tom E. Weekley, Guysville, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

Tom says his 1971 International Harvester 454 diesel tractor, which he bought used, is his “best buy”. “It’s just the right size for small jobs and is powerful and agile. Easy to use and dependable.

“My 2006 Mantis rototiller is my worst buy. It runs and looks good but has very flimsy digging tines - if I hit the least little rock or root the tines will bend. Because of this problem I’m disappointed in the machine’s overall usefulness.”

Best Buy

Phillips rotary harrow

Duane Lange, Ord, Neb. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“I’m a longtime no-tiller, so I raised some neighbors’ eyebrows when I bought a Phillips 42-ft. rotary harrow. It’s definitely my best buy,” says Duane. “I bought this aggressive harrow because corn stalks were damaging my tractor tires and also pulling off fertilizer hoses and seed tubes on my planter. It does an excellent job of laying down corn and sunflower stalks. It’s a well-built machine.”

Best Buy

Great Plains 3000

Joe Eilert, Jewell, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

Joe’s impressed with his 2005 Great Plains 3000 series, 30-ft., 3-section grain drill. “This drill replaced our IH hoe drills, which worked well but were slow, tedious and unhandy to transport. I’ve used this new drill on 2,800 acres and it works great. It folds easily for transport and works great on rough cropland with high residue. The company is very customer-minded and will be around for the long haul..”

Best Buy

Bombardier Traxter 500 ATV

Gerald W. McKeel, Noname, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“It has a step-through design and is built like a tank,” reports Gerald, pleased with his 1999 Bombardier Traxter 500 ATV. “The engine on this unit is truly bullet-proof, although it’s somewhat hard on spark plugs. The seat lifts up for easy engine maintenance. I like the rear-mounted radiator because it doesn’t plug up with debris.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland 575 baler + 2 more

Ray Tuchscherer, Langley, B.C. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“I’m happy with my New Holland 575 baler, which I bought used. The previous owner had used it hard and it needed some tender loving care, but after making some minor repairs it has worked great. It has a lot of capacity and has required only routine maintenance.

“I also like my 1999 Dodge 3500 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine.”

On the minus side, he isn’t pleased with his Zweegers Fanex 780 hay tedder, which he bought used. “The wheel axle shafts are too light. I broke three out of a total of six. Also, the gearbox is too small and heats up badly.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 pickup equipped + 1 more

Don W. Thomas, Eureka River, Alberta · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“My 2001 Dodge 3500 pickup equipped with an in-line diesel engine and Hydra-Dec bale hauler-unroller is my best buy. I bought it used with the Hydra-Dec installed. This pickup now has about 151,000 miles on it. I use it to unroll bales while feeding cattle, which is hard on the clutch. It had to be replaced recently. I also use it to pull 20 and 24-ft. livestock trailers and a seven-bale wagon. I’m well pleased with it. I like the inline diesel engine much better than a V-8 diesel.”

Best Buy

Charmaster wood burning furnace + 1 more

Bill Kobiskie, Milton, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“I like my Charmaster wood burning furnace (Charmaster Products, Grand Rapids, Minn. ph 218 326-6786; www.charmaster.com). My home is totally electric so this furnace keeps my utility bill way down in winter. One good firing of this furnace will keep our house comfortable for up to 24 hours or more.”

The Charmaster is a fully automatic forced air heating system. According to the company, it’s the only wood burning furnace that will convert wood into a glowing bed of charcoal. The airtight design also creates a secondary burn of gases, consuming far less wood than other wood furnaces, says the company.

“My Staber washing machine is a best buy (Staber Industries, Inc., Groveport, Ohio ph 800 848-6200). It’s a real soap and water saver, and is easy on clothes.”

Best Buy

Deines OHV 1860 ZTR riding mower equipped

Don Wooley, Lawton, Okla. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“It just keeps on mowing and mowing with no problems at all,” says Don about his 2002 Deines OHV 1860 ZTR riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck. “This machine is fun to use and has required only routine maintenance. With the big deck I can mow in about three hours what used to take seven hours on my old riding mower.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 pickup

Ronald Dietsche, Colfax, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“It’s the best vehicle I’ve ever owned,” reports Ronald, pleased with his 1997 Ford F-150 pickup. “It has about 110,000 miles on it and has done everything a farm truck can do. No maintenance other than replacing front brake pads, spark plugs and oil.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester 5088 tractor + 2 more

Dennis Weier, Columbus, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“It has plenty of power, is easy to drive, and starts good in cold weather,” says Dennis about his “best buy” 1984 International 5088 tractor. “It has about 4,600 hours on it.

“My 1975 Allis Chalmers 7000 tractor has plenty of power and is a best buy.

“My 2001 Deere 4400 tractor, equipped with a model 430 front-end loader, is my worst buy. It has about 1,200 hours on it. I’ve had trouble with the sync reverser and transmission slipping out of gear ever since it was new. It has been back to the dealer three times. The last time it was back they told me the linkage was worn out. I expected a better product from Deere and will be looking at other brands when it’s time to trade.”

Best Buy

Stanley Fat Max hammer

Autumn Bagley, Mt. Morris, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 13

“My Stanley Fat Max hammer works great. It’s easy to hold, has a lot of power without being heavy, with a magnetic nail setter and textured head. It makes hammer work easy.

“My Harbor Freight router is my worst buy. It’s cheaply made. The plastic gears stripped the first time I used it, making it impossible to adjust the depth. On the plus side, there were no hassles when I returned it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Poulan 330 Pro model + 1 more

Mike Kirik, Union City, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“I replaced my Husqvarna Rancher chain saw with a Poulan 330 Pro 22-in. model. This saw came with a 3-year unlimited warranty. After using it a few times I noticed the bar wasn’t getting any oil. I took it back and immediately received a new saw with no questions asked and no charge. I’ve cut at least 12 cords of wood with it with no problems.

“My 2002 Husqvarna 55 Rancher 20-in. chain saw is my worst buy. After retiring in 2002 I bought what I thought was a top-ofthe-line chain saw. I hoped it would last the rest of my wood-cutting days. After reading the instructions, I mixed oil with gas at the recommended ratio and then proceeded to cut down a 42-in. soft maple tree. However, the saw kept losing power so I returned it to the dealer. They sent it to the manufacturer, who wouldn’t honor the warranty. The company said the oil hadn’t been mixed correctly - yet I’ve been using chain saws for more than 50 years.

“The manufacturer charged me $145 to replace the piston, ring and cylinder. When it came back I had the same result - no power. This saw is now sitting under my work bench gathering dust.”

Best Buy

Echo 3000 chain saw

Jim W. Harkness, Laingsburg, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“I bought an Echo 3000 12-in. chain saw to use in my tree trimming business. I thought if it lasted two seasons I’d be lucky. However, I’ve used this saw for six years now and it still runs great. It also starts easy. It’s an amazing little saw and is my best buy.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

MacDon 9200 swather + 1 more

Judd Rodman, Paonia, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Judd nominates his 2000 MacDon 9200 swather as his “best buy”. “This machine has cut about 3,000 acres of hay per year without any major problems.

“My Deere 4430 tractor is my worst buy. The engine blew up, the transmission has gone out three times, and the hydraulics don’t work right. Also, it uses four times more fuel than my International Harvester tractors do.”

Best Buy

Troy-Bilt GTX20 riding mower equipped

Richard Ross, Shelbyville, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“My 2000 Troy-Bilt GTX20 riding mower equipped with a 20 hp Kohler engine is built heavy. It has hydraulic lift and hydraulic outlets and has required only routine maintenance. It still runs and looks as good as new. A few years ago MTD purchased Troy-Bilt and dropped this tractor model, as well as a couple of others. Now they make lighter, poorer quality tractors.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

SealLube seal expander + 1 more

Karla Tschoepe, Paonia, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Karla likes SealLube seal expander (New Tech International, Fraser, Mich. ph 800 434-9192; www.seallube.com). This product is said to stop rubber oil seal leaks in engines, transmissions, power steering and hydraulic systems. “I used it to stop a leak in the power steering on my backhoe. I put a SealLube in last year and the power steering is still working just fine with no leaks,” says Karla.

“My 2005 Chicago variable speed reciprocating saw is my worst buy. I was able to use it for only about five minutes when the part that holds the blade broke, rendering the saw useless.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears Craftsman 26 hp riding mower + 1 more

Hal D. Stephens, Solomon, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

A 2004 Sears Craftsman 26 hp riding mower rates as Hal’s “best buy”. “We have a hilly yard but this unit has power to spare and has required only routine maintenance. It cuts even and doesn’t miss any grass between the blades.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2005 McCulloch EZ Pull weedeater. “We used it only twice and then it wouldn’t start. The company gave us another one which worked better, but at times it doesn’t want to run, either. Most of the problem seems to be in the carburetor and the choke system. However, when this weedeater is running it does do a good job of cutting.”

Best Buy

Geo-Thermal heating

Justin Schafer, Portland, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“My Geo-Thermal heating and cooling system, which pulls heat from ground water, is about 35 percent more efficient than an air-to-air heat pump. We know because we’ve been keeping records for about 20 years. We’re well pleased with it. The only negative is that it wastes good well water.”

Worst Buy

Motorola

Wayne R. Wangsness, Decorah, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Wayne nominates his 2006 Motorola ‘Razor’ cell phone as his “worst buy”. “As soon as I started using this phone I noticed that the reception was worse than it was on the cheap Nokia that I had been using. What good is a cell phone if you can’t hear your calls?”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota L3400 equipped + 1 more

Grant England, Gales Creek, Oregon · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“This is a small tractor, but it doesn’t seem to know it,” says Grant, pleased with his Kubota L3400 equipped with a front-end loader and detachable backhoe. “I use this tractor to haul timber off a thinned-out hillside. Some of the logs are 3 ft. in diameter and 60 ft. long and are laying on slopes as steep as 45 degrees. The tractor may grunt a little, but it pulls these trees right out of there. It’s set up with Hydra-steer which I really like.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Warn winch. “I use it with my 2005 Kubota RTV utility vehicle to pull smaller logs. The winch itself works fine. It’s rated at 2,500 lbs. and has plenty of power, but the design of the guide rollers needs improvement. Even on a straight pull the wire doesn’t track evenly across the spool. Instead, it piles up in one area and gets frayed.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet riding mower + 1 more

B. Glenn Wells, Bostic, N.C. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

He’s enthusiastic about his 2004 Cub Cadet riding mower. “This riding mower is a Bush Hog wanna-be - I love it. It’s equipped with a 24 hp Briggs & Stratton engine, a 50-in. deck, a smooth hydrostatic transmission, cruise control, and even a cup holder. I use it to keep four to six acres of grass looking like a golf course. No problems at all. I paid less than $2,000 for it. My only complaint is that the dealer wanted $30 to bring it to my place, which ticked me off. So I went to Tractor Supply Co. and bought a new utility trailer for $620. “I’ll show him,” I thought, and I used the trailer to bring my new mower home.

“The trailer has turned out to be a best buy, too. I use it all the time. It’s equipped with a rear fold-down ramp and bigger wheels than other trailers I looked at. And, I saved the $30 delivery fee!”

Best Buy

EasySet Mole Eliminator mole trap

Warren Black, Owosso, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“My best buy is the EasySet Mole Eliminator mole trap (Bob Bruno, Nuisance Wildlife Control Products, Winona, Minn. ph 888 778-7988; www.easysetmoletrap.com). Whoever designed this trap did their homework. I bought 21 of them. The trap is set by stepping on it until the trigger pushes down onto the tunnel.”

Best Buy

Bri-Mar dump trailer

Arthur Timmel, Collins, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“My 12-ft. Bri-Mar dump trailer is my best buy (Bri-Mar Mfg., Chambersburg, Penn. ph 800-732-5845 or 717 263-6116; www.bri-mar.com). “I pull this trailer behind my pickup. It’s easy to pull and dump and requires very little maintenance. I like not having to buy insurance. It replaces an expensive dump truck.”

Best Buy

Subaru Robin engines + 1 more

Sam Peachey, McAlisterville, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“Subaru Robin engines are the easiest starting, quietiest running, and most fuel efficient gas engines I’ve ever seen (Subaru Robin, Wood Dale, Ill. ph 800 277 6246 or 630 350-8200; www.robinamerica.com). However, the engines come with a cheap spark plug so if you buy them new be sure to also buy a good spark plug. If you do, these engines will run and run and run.

“My Husqvarna 395 chain saw works great.”

Best Buy

GM Duramax 3500 pickup equipped

Mike Foppe, Silex, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Mike bought a used 2004 GM Duramax 3500 pickup equipped with an Allison transmission. After three months and about 30,000 miles, he says it’s his “best buy”. “It’s a nice truck with a lot of power for big trailers and on hills. My only complaint is that I wish it was more fuel efficient. It gets only about 13 mpg.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Speedtech In-struments handheld digital thermometer + 1 more

Garry Lentz, Dunmore, Alberta · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Garry’s the satisfied owner of a 2006 Speedtech In-struments handheld digital thermometer and wind speed indicator. “It’s lightweight, compact, and extremely accurate. The battery is still going strong after a full season of use.

“My 2005 Thermor home weather station is my worst buy. The receiver display unit was faulty from the start. A replacement unit came with a large black spot inside the screen that looked like a fungus. By the time the second replacement unit came, the wind had broken the outside wind sensor off. The batteries in the remote transmitter last only for a few days. The distributor promptly delivered replacement parts but they were also of inferior quality.”

Best Buy

Kubota B2410 tractor

Sheila Martin, Hepworth, Ontario · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“We’re happy with our 2002 Kubota B2410 tractor. We’re semi retired and use this tractor at a local cemetery. It maneuver great around headstones. We also use it to landscape around cottages. On the farm this tractor is used in the fields and woods and for moving snow during the winter. No problems.”

Best Buy

Dixon zero turn riding

Emery F. Olsen, Turtle Lake, N. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Emery’s the satisfied owner of a 2004 Dixon 42-in. zero turn riding mower. “I bought it in 2005 as a hold-over mower. It replaced a 48-in. garden tractor-type mower. With this machine I can mow my lawn in half the time and do a nicer job of mowing. If anything happened to this mower, I’d definitely buy another one.”

Best Buy

Polaris 700 ATV + 2 more

Pete Dickinson, Park Rapids, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“I use it hard, but it never lets me down,” says Pete about his 2003 Polaris 700 ATV. “I use tire chains with it for winter snow plowing and for pulling a fish house. It always starts right up and just keeps on going.

“My Stihl 044 chain saw is a best buy. I’ve used it for many years. It requires very little maintenance, always starts right up and runs strong. It comes with hand warmers which I really like.

“I install NAPA alternators, window motors, starters, etc. for customers of our shop and almost always have to warranty them, or swap them for a different brand.”

Worst Buy

John Deere Sabre lawn tractor

Belding F. Clearwater, Cornwall, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“My Deere Sabre lawn tractor is my worst buy. I bought it for mowing my lawn and for towing a small 2-wheel cart. The transaxle broke and the replacement cost was only partly covered by the warranty, after much ‘discussion’ with the dealer. Also the frame broke just ahead of the drive wheels, and the deck is hard to remove. What a piece of junk.”

Best Buy

Miller hay mill

Norman Harris, Acampo, Calif. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“I’ve been grinding hay mixed with molasses for more than 40 years using a Miller hay mill made in Turlock, Calif. It’s my best buy. After the first four or five years the company came up with a ‘Bale Buster’ equipped with six sickle blades. The machine’s four paddles have only been changed twice - after grinding 2,500 tons of alfalfa and oats hay. It’s a great machine.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet

Gerald West, Trenton, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“We’ve been a Chevy family for generations and have always been happy with Chevrolet cars and trucks. Many of our trucks have logged more than 200,000 miles without requiring major repairs. The cars have been just as reliable. We’re looking forward to the new-style Silverado pickup.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda Foreman 450 cc 4-wd + 1 more

Joe Baldwin, Glencoe, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

“It’s powerful, yet quiet, and handles nimbly. So far it has been very reliable,” says Joe, pleased with his 2004 Honda Foreman 450 cc 4-WD ATV. “I use it primarily for cutting, splitting and hauling firewood and to pull a 4 by 8-ft. trailer. It’s well designed and easy to maintain. It has a motorcycle-type transmission and electric shift, and it uses thumb-operated buttons instead of belt-type variable clutches like the ones found on snowmobiles, which is much better suited for a work machine. It has low gearing for slow speed, high torque pulling, and there’s no belt to wear out.

“My 2003 Polaris 700cc Sportsman 4-WD ATV is my worst buy. It was actually too powerful and could go dangerously fast -easily up to 55 mph. Also, it was noisy and vibrated excessively. The machine leaked coolant so I returned it to the dealer twice for repairs. However, it still leaked. The battery ‘cooked over’ one day while I was plowing snow, using an electric winch to raise and lower the plow. The frame around the battery area, as well as the rear suspension, became corroded. The Polaris snowplow I used on it was built too light for this machine, and as a result I bent it several times. I had to weld extra supports on it. I never really liked this machine and was glad when my Honda dealer took it on trade.”

Worst Buy

Campbell Hausfeld Husky Pro compressor

Gerald Kandell, Clark Lake, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

Gerald nominates his 2005 Campbell Hausfeld Husky Pro compressor as his “worst buy”. “The tires were low so I put air in them. However, when I went to move the unit it rolled away from me and slipped from my hands, smashing the air controls. We had to replace the parts at a cost of about $60. We bought this unit at Home Depot but they didn’t carry the parts we needed. The machine has no extra leg to help stabilize it. It’s very top heavy and shouldn’t be used as a mobile compressor the way it’s designed.”

Best Buy

GM 1/2-ton extended cab 4-wd + 1 more

Tom Woods, Creston, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“In 2000 I bought a used 1994 GM 1/2-ton extended cab 4-WD pickup with about 125,000 miles on it. It now has more than 240,000 miles on it but still has the original engine. It’s a best buy.

“My 2005 Polaris 400 Sportsman 4-WD ATV actually rides smoother than most cars and performs well. I use it to check on cows and calves and to do other chores. My only complaint is that it has plastic composite racks.”

Best Buy

EZ Boardwalk 24 hp

Billy Joe Owen, Lebanon, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

Billy Joe says his 2004 EZ Boardwalk 16-ft., 24 hp bandsaw mill is his “best buy” (Enden, Mo. ph 573 633-2135). “This bandsaw mill is easy to operate - with the angled design of the blade it pulls itself right through the log. It’s an economical machine and well worth the money.”

Best Buy

Gorilla Glue

Walter Fifelski, Wayland, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“I like Gorilla Glue. It’s superior to other adhesives because it sticks to just about anything. If you get nicks, cuts or split skin on your fingers, just place a drop of this glue on the affected area. It’ll take about an hour for the glue to set, but it will stay on for three to four days. However, you won’t even know you have it on, and by the end of that time the cut will have healed. If you wipe the spout clean on the bottle before replacing the cap, a small bottle will last a long time.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

T-L center pivot hydraulic + 2 more

Steve Parker, Beaver, Okla. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“The T-L center pivot hydraulic drive system I bought in 2003 is my best buy. This system has no driveshafts or U-joints and requires no electricity. I use my well engine to power the hydraulic pump on the system. Again, no electricity. The machine moves continuously without the ‘start and stop’ that you get with electric-operated machines. I have heavy soil so I purchased Agri-tracks to help eliminate deep tracks. I’m now into my second year of using the machine to irrigate permanent grass, and the tracks are no more than 5 to 6 in. deep. My neighbors without Agri-tracks are getting stuck.

“My worst buy is Just For Copper solderless copper bonding adhesive. It’s made by Jaco and is advertised as the easiest, fastest and safest way to permanently install brass and copper fittings onto rigid copper tubing. However, I found that it doesn’t work. In a situation where the ‘glued’ joint won’t be disturbed or moved it might work, but my fear was that I’d come home to find it flooded. Use your torch and solder to be safe.”

Worst Buy

Bolens riding mower

Charles Fuller, La Grange, Ga. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“My 2005 Bolens 38-in. riding mower is my worst buy. It has cost me $350 in repairs. The transmission locked in reverse gear, the gas tank had a crack in it and had to be replaced, and a belt broke while I was cutting grass. Now it’s on its fourth set of blades. The first set lasted only one week. The headlight bulbs have been replaced twice, and the ignition switch shorted out.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Allis-Chalmers D15 tractor equipped + 1 more

Philip Pippenger, Churubusco, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“This loader tractor is like a hired hand,” says Philip about his Allis Chalmers D15 tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “It’s handy to use and is always there when I need it.”

A Flex-A-Bed adjustable bed rates as his “worst buy”. “I’m paralyzed from the waist down so we needed an adjustable bed. The motors on it went bad three times within a year. It takes six weeks to get the motors repaired. The bed is too high for my wheelchair so we made a ramp that has to be moved every day.”

Best Buy

Buhler Allied 795 front-end loader equipped + 1 more

John C. Haldemann, Chinook, Mon-tana. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“My Buhler Allied 795 front-end loader equipped with ‘true self-leveling’ and ‘cushion ride’ is a best buy. It works well and has quick tach brackets that make hooking up to different attachments a fast and easy job. I’d recommend the cushion ride system for any loader. It’s fantastic when going through rough fields with heavy loads. Visibility is very good, and the bucket and grapple fork are built heavy. We use it mostly with a 2-bale Hydra Grabber from the Hydra-Bed company that stacks two 3 by 3 by 8 bales (Country Trailer Sales, Ludell, Kansas ph 785 626-9200; regan @countrytrailer. com). It greatly speeds up the bale-stacking process.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram pickup equipped + 1 more

Gary D. Waggoner, Deepwater, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“Our 1991 Dodge pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my best buy. It has required only minor repairs and upkeep in more than 300,000 miles.

“My 1991 Ford Explorer is my worst buy. We’ve replaced the motor, transmission, air conditioner, and a lot of other minor parts. In just 120,000 miles, we’ve spent 1 1/2 times as much money to keep it running as we did to buy it.”

Best Buy

GM 3/4-ton 2-door pickup equipped

John Anderson, Grand Coulee, Wash. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“My 2001 GM 3/4-ton 2-door pickup equipped with a Duramax engine is my best buy. It averages 18 mpg in city driving, about 17 mpg on the highway, and about 14 mpg when pulling a trailer. It has more than 97,000 miles on it but has required only routine maintenance. The engine has unbelievable power, and the Allison transmission is the best. The only problem is the high price of diesel fuel.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Massey Ferguson 35 deluxe tractor + 1 more

Simon Gordon, Irvington, Ky. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“My 1963 Massey Ferguson 35 deluxe tractor is my best buy of all time. I bought it used in 1999. The only problem was with a leak in the gas tank, which was promptly fixed. No problems after that.

“My 1995 Troy-Bilt rototiller is my worst buy. It doesn’t dig right and jumps out of the ground whenever I try to use it. It also burns up belts. I talked to the company and tried everything I could to solve these problems, without success. I won’t buy another one.”

Best Buy

John Deere 210 garden tractor

Richard S. Gilbertson, Fulda, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

Richard’s the proud owner of a 1973 Deere 210 garden tractor. “I’ve used this tractor to mow many lawns and also to do thatching work. It has about 3,000 hours on it. I’ve also used it to plow snow for myself and others. It’s a fantastic machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hesston disc mower + 1 more

Art E. Crary, Huddleston, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

A 2004 Hesston disc mower that he bought used in 2005 rates as Art’s “best buy”. “We use it to cut about 60 to 70 acres of hay, two cuttings a year, with no problems. We replaced the cutting blades once. This machine reduces our mowing time almost by half compared to our old hay conditioner.

“Our worst buy is the Industrial Tools suspension seat we bought at Northern Tools and installed on our Ford 5000 tractor. After installing the seat my son-in-law went out to ted hay. He reached down to adjust the seat back a notch and it slid back completely off the tractor. Fortunately, he was able to grab the fender to keep from falling into the tedder. That’s when we realized the seat has no stops and will fall off the front or back of the base without warning. This seat is not only cheaply built but dangerous. I welded stops on both sides of the seat so this problem won’t happen again.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 18-volt cordless 1/2-in drive + 1 more

Delbert Hayes, Norwalk, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 15

“I like my 2005 DeWalt 18-volt cordless 1/2-in. drive impact wrench. It has 300 ft. lbs. of torque. It’s real handy - I take it with me everywhere to remove wheels and to drive 3/8-in. lag screws when installing fence braces.

“My 2004 Alemite 12-volt cordless grease gun is convenient and works fast for greasing corn heads and combines.”