Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005)

67 reports from pages 12–15 · 55 Best Buys27 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

I’d pay good money to get my old tractor back,” says Gary, who says hi

Gary Malone, Palisade, Neb. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

“I’d pay good money to get my old tractor back,” says Gary, who says his purchase of a 2002 Ford New Holland bi-directional TV140 tractor has resulted in 35 on-farm service calls so far with no end in sight. “We bought the tractor in November, 2003 and after two weeks the rear main seal began to leak. We took it in and 10 days later it was leaking worse. They put a sleeve on it that slowed the leak but didn’t stop it. We decided to live with the drip.

“The next problem was that we couldn’t level the front 3-pt. hitch. You’d pick up a bale and it would angle down and the bale would slide off. A mechanic looked at it 8 or 9 times. Finally a blockman came out and put a metal plate on it to make it work.

“On our old bi-directional Versatile 9030, we changed the air filter once a year. This tractor plugs up every 30 hrs. and those filters are expensive. The dealer can’t seem to fix.

“I like the engine and transmission but it goes through oil – about half a quart every 30 hrs. My old 9030 tractor never did use a drop of oil.

“The muffler and exhaust pipe have been changed three times. They burn out. The air conditioner wouldn’t work. The dealer tried to tell us the cab has lots of glass so it’s normal that it would be a bit warmer. I finally took it to another New Holland dealer who fixed the problem – a seal was missing in the compressor. Unfortunately, it cost me $1,800. Now it’s so cold in the cab I have to turn it down.

“Recently, the tractor has begun losing power after about 30 min. of use. We use it for feeding cattle and in the middle of the job, it’ll start lugging down so it hardly runs. We’ve checked the fuel pump, injectors, filters and anything else we could think of but nothing solves the problem. The dealer has already been out 5 times and can’t fix.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Troy-Bilt string trimmer + 1 more

Patricia A. Peirce, Hagerstown, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

Patricia nominates her 2003 Troy-Bilt 22-in. string trimmer as her best buy. “My husband and I built a house where nothing has ever been before and we’re trying to clear the land. This string mower goes through grass, weeds, brush, and small saplings like nothing I’ve ever seen before. I’m a small woman, over 60 years old, but I have no trouble starting the mower or using it. If it ever goes bad you can be certain I’ll buy another one just like it. It has seen some hard work in the past two summers that I’ve used it. My sister-in-law saw it working and bought one for herself. She likes it also.”

Kencel and Audra J. Matheny, three bolts that had broken off. Later, more bolts broke off the front wheels.

“Neither the dealer nor a company representative ever came out to help with the problem. So last summer, with 256 hours on the tractor, we wrote a letter to the company. We told them we paid $26,500 and got nothing but an unsafe, unusable tractor along with poor customer service. The company shipped a supply of higher grade wheel studs at no charge to our dealer, with instructions for installation, and they covered the cost. The dealer came out to our place to install the wheel studs at no cost.”

Worst Buy

Landini Globus 65 tractor

Clarksburg, W. Va. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

They had problems with their 2002 Landini Globus 65 tractor but fortunately the company took care of them. “We had researched Landini tractors on the internet and liked what we read. But in the summer of 2003, while doing our first cutting of hay, Kencel found three lug bolts that had broken off the left front wheel. The dealer had to order replacement bolts from the factory in Italy and it took two weeks for them to arrive. The dealer replaced only the

Worst Buy

ELK shingles

Ed Buechler, Belgium, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

“ELK shingles are by far the worst shingles I’ve ever bought. They’re high-priced but have a long warranty. However, the warranty is totally useless. The company wanted photos, then they wanted shingles off the house. Then they came out and took more photos and more shingles to send to their so-called laboratory. When all is said and done, their warranty is useless. We’ve made many phone calls to the company, but they just drag their feet and pass the buck.”

Best Buy

Farmall B tractor

Jon Stende, Aurora, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

“I’d be lost without my Farmall B tractor. I use it to do many jobs on my 10 acres, such as to cultivate gardens, cut brush, and drag our driveway. I use a removable dump box on back of the tractor that hauls 1/3 yard of sand or 1/4 cord of wood. By attaching sides onto the box I can also use it to haul mulch or brush. The box bolts onto a pair of 3-in. angle irons that mount on two drawbars. A J-hook at the bottom of the box curls around a pipe that fits between the angle irons. The box is secured with a pipe that drops through two eye-hooks that are screwed into the front part of the box. I simply remove the pipe to dump the box.

“I also mount a gas engine-powered water pump on back to fill barrels at a nearby lake to water gardens. A jib crane lifts the barrels on and off.”

Best Buy

Rodex 4000 underground blaster

LeRoy Young, Craig, Colo. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

“Two years ago I bought a Rodex 4000 underground blaster to get rid of pocket gophers and prairie dogs on our ranch. After I bought it I was told the state of Colorado outlawed the use of this device because the company, Rodex Industries, wasn’t licensed to sell it in my state. Soon thereafter, the company went bankrupt and I was told I couldn’t get my $1,400 back because the owner was insolvent. I was able to use the device only twice before it stopped working. It can’t be repaired due to non-serviceable parts.

“Now I find this company is back in business as Rodex Sales and Service. They’re advertising on the internet as ‘the original manufacturers of the Rodex 4000.’ They now sell the unit for $1,825.

“I urge anyone who has done business with these people to call the Bankruptcy Court in Idaho and complain.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Goldoni tractor + 1 more

Jon B. Coppa, MD, Patagonia, Arizona · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 12

“My 2002 Goldoni tractor is my best buy. It cost only about half as much as a comparable Deere model. The tractor is 32 in. wide. The tractor’s rear lift hydraulic cylinder developed a bad leak after one year of use, but the dealer replaced the cylinder at no charge, with no hassles. The rear lift is rated at 1,100 lbs. It’s a good tractor.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Hanna/Blackstone injector pump for soluble fertilizer. “The pump wouldn’t inject soluble fertilizer into the drip irrigation manifold at rated pressure. The same problem happened with a factory replacement. The company doesn’t seem to be too concerned with the pump failure. However, I’ve had great performance from Amid and Advantage Controls pumps.”

Worst Buy

Ford 1710 tractor

Melvin VanFosson, Gilroy, Calif. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

Melvin says his Ford 1710 tractor is his “worst buy.” “I’ve had this tractor repaired six different times. The problem is that the hydraulic system leaks badly and runs completely dry in only about four hours. A Ford tractor mechanic says the company offers a kit to fix the problem, but he can’t find any and I can’t afford to buy another tractor. I’d like to hear from anyone who knows how to solve this problem. From what the mechanic told me, it’s a common fault with this model.”

Worst Buy

Yamaha

Gary Eddy, Chester, W. Va. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

He lists three Yamaha ATV’s as his “worst buys”: a 1999 600 Grizzly, 2000 600 Grizzly, and 2000 Kodiak 400. “These rigs all run too hot. The fan comes on like it’s supposed to, but then they start running funny like the choke is on and pressure builds up in the gas tank. Another problem is that after a while the fuel gauges on top of the tanks became discolored and fog up. The dealer replaced the gauges, but that’s all they would do to help out.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-150 XL pickup equipped

Joe Grasso, Ancram, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

A 2003 Ford F-150 XL pickup, equipped with a V-6 engine and automatic transmission, rates as Joe’s “worst buy.” “The engine’s intake manifold leaks, and there’s a knocking sound in the pickup’s front end. Both front doors leak water onto the door sill and the rear window leaks, too. Also, the entire length of the tailgate is rusted. This pickup has only about 10,000 miles on it. The dealer can’t seem to fix any of the problems.”

Best Buy

Stihl 028 chain saw equipped

Pam Sparks, Queen City, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“Our 1988 Stihl 028 chain saw equipped with an 18-in. bar is our best buy. We use it to cut firewood, drop thorn trees, and clear brush. It never fails to start and has required very little maintenance. All we have to do is keep the air filter clean and the gas tank full. This little jewel still has the original spark plug, and it fires right up on the first crank.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Farmall F-30 tractor + 1 more

Chuck Duffy, Solon, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“My grandpa always talked about the 1932 Farmall F-30 tractor that he bought new. He sold it many years ago, and I always wondered whatever happened to it. One day I asked him who he sold it to and when he told me I started looking around for the owner. Finally I found him about 12 miles from my home and I’m now the fourth owner of this tractor. It’s not in running condition. But you should have seen the look on my grandpa’s face when the tractor came into our driveway loaded on a trailer, with the original 2-row mounted corn picker on it, which he also bought originally.

“My worst buy is a 1997 Dodge 1500 4-WD pickup which I bought used. I bought a 3-year, 30,000-mile warranty to go with it, and I’m glad I did because I’ve used every bit of the warranty and then some. After test driving the pickup at the dealer I told them the steering system was loose. They installed a new torsion bar in an attempt to solve the problem. However, one month later another torsion bar had to be installed, along with upper and lower ball joints on each side. Then, with about 1,500 miles left on the warranty, the steering system went bad again. This time it required a new $1,700 steering box and still another torsion bar. At the time I was glad I bought the warranty. However, three days after the warranty expired the transmission went out. I’m still driving this pickup because no one else wants to buy it, and the dealer won’t give me much for a trade. No more Dodge pickups for me.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears Craftsman 18 hp riding mower + 1 more

Don Melton, Shelly, N.C. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“I use my 1984 Sears Craftsman 18 hp riding mower to mow 2 1/2 acres. It’s a best buy. The only maintenance it needs is replacing the belts and idler pulleys about every three years. It still mows like it was a new machine.

“My Ariens zero turn mower equipped with a 17 hp engine and 42-in. deck is my worst buy. Three belts had to be replaced within a three-week period. The mower came factory-equipped with 1/2-in. belts, which I replaced with heavier-duty 5/8-in. belts. Now this mower works perfect.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 Super Cab lariat pickup + 1 more

Charles Knesek, Corpus Christi, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

Charles is impressed with his 2004 Ford F-150 Super Cab Lariat pickup. “This is my eighth new Ford pickup in 24 years, and I think it’s the best one yet. All I have to do is change the oil. It runs smooth and quiet, and the 5.4-liter engine has a lot of power. It averages about 16 mpg.

“My Hauler J-93 from Kimball Products is a 4-wheel utility vehicle that leaves a lot to be desired. It’s powered by a 16 hp engine and rides on large, knobby tires that look like the ones found on World War II Jeeps. It has a noisy transmission which had to be replaced twice by the factory. The transmission isn’t quite as noisy now but the noise is still there. The factory won’t do anything more to help. The brakes stick and I have to constantly readjust them, and the paint job is blistering on the hood and fenders. The company sent me a 16-oz. can of spray paint. I did all the labor myself, with no financial help from the company.”

Best Buy

Case 5800 chisel plow

Eugene Weimerskirch, Coulee City, Wash. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“It has the best design and performance of anything in its class,” says Eugene, pleased with his Case 5800 30-ft. chisel plow. “This chisel plow does a great job of penetrating hard soil. The design of the shanks is excellent for clearing trash. The bottom end of the shank is slotted, which makes changing sweep points a much easier job.”

Best Buy

Gear-Venders under/overdrive

Lynn Dunlap, Jim Falls, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

Lynn added a Gear-Venders under/overdrive to his 1999 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a 360 cu. in. engine and 5-speed transmission. He says it’s his “best buy” (Gear Vendors, Inc., ph 800 999-9555 or 619 562-0060; info @gearvendors.com; www.gearvendors.com). “The under/overdrive gives me gears right where I need them for pulling trailers. I use the pickup to pull a 22-ft. gooseneck stock trailer and a 26-ft. fifth wheel camper. Now this pickup does a good job considering it has a relatively small engine.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman gas-powered leaf blower

Bill Welfley, Sr., New Philadelphia, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman gas-powered leaf blower is my worst buy. The head bolts and carburetor bolts kept working loose, causing it to quit running. It cost $109 new, and the company wanted $85 just to look at it. So we put LocTite on the threads, but the bolts still kept vibrating loose. This leaf blower is a piece of junk. Next time I’ll buy a quality product from Stihl.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester 4900 truck + 1 more

James M. Farrak, Barton, Vt. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“My 1996 International 4900 truck is my best buy. It has required only routine maintenance with no major problems.

“My 2000 GM 3500 1-ton pickup is my worst buy. It’s equipped with a Vortec 350 engine which went out at about 60,000 miles. The fuel injector failed twice, causing the engine to go bad. Also, gas got into the oil as I was driving down the highway. Fortunately, I have an extended warranty on this vehicle.”

Best Buy

Kubota mower + 1 more

Tom Wallace, Jamestown, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“My 2004 Kubota mower is a rugged piece of equipment. I bought it new last spring and as of late November it already had more than 1,000 hours on it. I use it with a Hayban trail mower that offsets to the side of the Kubota, resulting in an 84-in. wide cut.

“My 1997 Chevrolet S10 pickup is my

Contact: FARM SHOW Followup, Roger Zummach, 62746 110th St., Hutchinson, Minn. 55350 (ph 320 587-3572). worst buy. The engine lacks power and had to be repaired three times.”

Best Buy

Volvo 940 car + 1 more

Mark Powers, East Pausstine, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 13

“I bought my 1993 Volvo 940 car used with about 216,000 miles. It now has more than 250,000 miles but still runs perfect. Over the years I’ve bought many high mileage Volvo cars and have found that you can’t wear them out. Unfortunately, I haven’t had the same luck with Ford or GM pickups.

“I bought a new 1989 Ford 1-ton pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine. The engine went bad at about 89,000 miles and cost $6,000 to fix. I traded it for a 1994 GM 1-ton pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter diesel engine, and it has had a lot of problems with the electronic injection. Both heads cracked at about 65,000 miles and had to be replaced. It has about 94,000 miles on it and has a severe blow-by problem, so it’ll be going to the shop again soon. If Volvo ever made a 1-ton crew cab dually pickup, I’d buy it.”

Best Buy

K & N air filters

Rick Adolphson, Grantsburg, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“I’m well pleased with the K & N air filters I use on my cars (K&N Engineering, Inc., ph 800 858-3333 or 951 826-4000; www.knfilters.com). I had a car that ran good but blowby was soaking the paper filter. After switching to a K & N filter the car’s fuel efficiency improved by four miles per gallon, and it also runs better and uses less oil. I’ve also installed these filters on several vehicles with good engines and gained noticeably more power and several miles more per gallon on each one. One vehicle that burned just a little oil has completely stopped burning oil. These vehicles all have anywhere from 100,000 to 300,000 miles on them.

“My parents have had problems with the automatic transmissions in all three of their late model Chrysler front wheel drive cars equipped with V-6 engines. The problems developed with a New Yorker at 112,000 miles and with a Concord LXI which started acting up at a little over 100,000 miles when they traded it in. Their brand new 300 model had a lot of water in the transmission, and they’re still waiting for a replacement transmission. The dealer wanted to install an older rebuilt transmission in this brand new car. But my mom contacted Chrysler and it paid off because the dealer was told to install a new transmission.”

Best Buy

Heatmor outdoor furnace

Harry Semler, Sterling, N.Y. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

Harry likes his 2002 Heatmor outdoor furnace. “It’s safe to use, doesn’t leave a mess in our house, and maintains an even 70º temperature at all times. Our house feels warmer because hot water is always circulating through the heat exchanger in the gas furnace’s plenum. As a result, when the thermostat calls for heat we get a blast of warm air right away, whereas with our gas furnace we always got a blast of cold air when the fan first came on. It uses a reasonable amount of wood, and we can even burn a lot of junk wood. We also use it to heat our hot water.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Tractor Supply Company + 1 more

Leonard Gilbreath, Meridian, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“The 27-ton wood splitter I bought nine years ago from Tractor Supply Company is our best buy. Over the years I’ve used it to split about 100 cords of wood.

“My 2003 Home Products weedeater is my worst buy. I can’t keep string in it, and I’ve already had to put a $42 gas tank on it. The tank came loose at the seam.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet heavy duty

Joel Gargagliano, Pierson, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

Joel nominates his 2001 Chevrolet heavy duty Duramax pickup equipped with an Allison automatic transmission as his “best buy.” “It has about 133,000 miles and all it has ever needed is a new rear wheel seal. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance. About half of those miles were for hauling a 28-ft. fifth wheel enclosed cargo trailer, so I’m hauling gross loads of about 15,000 to 20,000 lbs. most of the time. This pickup has a lot of power and gets 12 to 16 mpg hauling a trailer and 19 to 20 mpg empty.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 029 chain saw + 3 more

William G. Hurd, Meriden, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

A Stihl 029 18-in. chain saw rates as William’s “worst buy.” “It always started hard, and then one day it wouldn’t start at all. I took it to the dealer who said it would cost $300 to repair. I brought it back home and then bought a Sears Craftsman 18-in. chain saw that cost about half as much as it would have cost to repair the Stihl. The Sears model has already cut more wood than the Stihl ever did, and it starts a lot easier. It has been trouble-free.

“My General Motors cars, trucks, and pickups, as well as my Massey Ferguson tractors and implements, have all been best buys.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Exmark zero turn mower + 1 more

Eric Averwater, Batavia, Ohio · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“My 2004 Exmark zero turn mower equipped with a 27 hp engine and 60-in. deck is my best buy. It makes mowing grass a fun job. My wife loves to cut grass with it. It’s very comfortable to drive, and the control layout is natural to your body. Also, the drive system is smooth and positive with no play in the steering levers. When mowing, I never need to run over already-mowed grass because it turns so simple and quick.

“My Lanair HI 100 waste oil furnace is my worst buy. Right out of the box it developed electrical problems. I made a phone call to the company’s technical service people, and they were quite helpful and sent repair parts out the next day. But I had to install the parts myself and send the bad parts back. After the first year the firebox developed cracks and the company sent me an upgraded replacement, but the quality just wasn’t there. The relatively low price was a big reason I bought this brand. I guess it’s true you get what you pay for.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet WT 1500 pickup equipped + 1 more

Larry King, Maryville, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“My 1968 Chevrolet WT 1500 pickup equipped with a Vortec V-6 engine and automatic transmission is my best buy. I bought it used with a lot of miles on it and replaced the brake rotors, pads, drums and shoes. Now it has more than 170,000 miles on it but still doesn’t use any oil. It has a smooth ride.

“My 2000 Sears Craftsman lawn tractor equipped with a 23 1/2 hp Kohler engine and 60-in. deck has had a lot of problems. Fortunately, I purchased a maintenance contract when I bought the mower. The deck had to be replaced, as well as the rear end, transmission, battery, fuse, and blades. A blade shaft snapped off at the bearing. Now the juncture of the fender assembly is splitting under the seat where it joins the frame. It’s impossible to mow evenly. Also, the entire front axle and steering rod had to be replaced.”

Best Buy

Allis-Chalmers B-12 garden tractor

Kent and Deanna Schwendiman, Ucon, Idaho · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“The Allis Chalmers B-12 garden tractor I bought used about 32 years ago is my best buy. I don’t know exactly how old it is. I use it every spring to till my garden and every winter to clean my driveway, as well as my neighbors’ driveways. I also use it to mow my lawn every week, and my children made spending money using it to mow lawns for widows. This tractor may be sick and tired, but it still does the job.”

Worst Buy

Flowtron electric leaf eater

Lois Hunt, Heber, Ariz. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

Lois nominates her 2003 Flowtron electric leaf eater as her “worst buy.” “I used it two or three times and had to replace the plastic cutting lines each time after only about one minute of use. Then the motor jammed, and I gave up on this product. It was a total waste of money. I could probably cut up leaves faster using a pair of scissors.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped

Royal Hohl, Salina, Kansas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

A 2002 Sears Craftsman riding mower equipped with an automatic transmission and 48-in. deck rates as Royal’s “worst buy.” “The day I brought it home I was setting it up when the spring to the neutral shift rod came off and wouldn’t stay on. Also, the electric clutch that controls the blade engagement locks and won’t engage the blade. It happens every time I use the mower. The deck has to be cleaned often so I can keep it running. The transmission is so weak that in reverse gear the mower will barely back up on level ground. However, the engine does have a lot of power and starts and runs good.

“The deck is mounted too low. I’ve adjusted it according to the owner’s manual, but even with the adjustment lever at its highest level, the bottom of the deck is only about three inches above the ground. If the deck didn’t have four anti-scalping wheels I think it could be lowered all the way to below-ground level. Another problem is that the magnet holding the hood down came off within the first couple of hours of use.

“I’ve owned Sears Craftsman equipment for many years, but lately I’ve found their products to be weak and poorly made. My Craftsman rototiller had such flimsy handles that the tubing around the welds broke during the first season of use.”

Worst Buy

Black+Decker leaf blower/vac

David Keith, Rockford, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“My Black & Decker leaf blower/vac is my worst buy. The first time I used the blower the armature burned out. The company repaired it under warranty and sent it back to me. But the second time I used it the same thing happened. Since the warranty had expired, I was stuck with a worthless piece of junk that I was able to use less than two hours. I’ll never buy Black & Decker tools again.”

Best Buy

Warn Works model 3700

Aud M. Kinser, Graham, Texas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

A Warn Works model 3700 DC power winch sold by rates as Aud’s “best buy” (www.gowarn.com). “I use this winch on my 3/4-ton pickup to haul 1,600 lb. hay bales up onto the bed. It takes only a few seconds to do the job. It works great and sure beats hand cranking.”

Worst Buy

Cub Cadet 1527 garden tractor equipped

Victor Thornton, Carrolton, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

“My 2003 Cub Cadet 1527 garden tractor equipped with a mower deck is my worst buy. It won’t bag grass or leaves - it just plugs up. There’s rust all over the tractor coming from under the paint, and even on the deck. The mower deck cuts unevenly, which really makes our lawn look bad. However, the engine runs great.”

Best Buy

Drill Doctor + 2 more

David Niehaus, Baldwin, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

David’s impressed with his 2004 Drill Doctor. “I’m always in need of a sharp drill bit. I can’t sharpen drill bits by eye and all the other drill bit sharpening gadgets on the market are better left at the store. Last Christmas my wife surprised me with a Drill Doctor 750 which handles up to a 3/4-in. dia. bit. Wow! Now I can have a sharp bit in minutes that will cut great and last a long time.”

On the minus side, he lists his Porter Cable 4 1/2-in. side grinder. “I try to buy the best tools I can afford, but my decision to buy this side grinder for more than $125 turned out to be a mistake. It burned up the first time I used it. I drove 60 miles to return it to the dealer and got a replacement. However, a couple of weeks later that one failed, too. Lesson learned. I threw it away and went back to using my old Black & Decker 4 1/2-in. grinders. They last a long time and the company will rebuild them for about $50. And they offer a one-year guarantee.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mercedes-Benz 260E sedan + 1 more

Marty Gallaher, Hartford, Ala. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 14

Marty’s impressed with his 1989 Mercedes-Benz 260E sedan. “We bought this car used in 1996 with about 100,000 miles on it. Now it has 500,000 miles but still doesn’t use any oil. It’s one of five Mercedes that we own. They all last a long time.”

A 1999 General Electric double oven rates as his “worst buy.” “We paid about $1,000 for it, but it quit working after only about 14 months. We were told it would cost about $250 to replace the computer board. We complained that an oven should last longer than ours did and not cost $250 or more to fix. They gave us a $70 coupon off our next General Electric purchase but I have no plans to buy another General Electric product. We put the oven out for the trash man to pick up and then bought an oven without a computer in it.”

Worst Buy

Swisher

E.L. Warner, Chapin, S.C. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My Swisher 42-in. ZTR mower is my worst buy. The cutting height indicator went bad the first time I used it. Then the dust covers on the caster wheel shafts, along with the shaft retainer washers, disappeared. The machine now has only 22 hours on it but already there’s a problem with the left hydraulic motor - the pulley came loose on the shaft. I returned it to Northern Tool for repairs under warranty. However, the company dragged its feet on repairing this unit.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 equipped

Cornie Van Lant, Chandler, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“I think it’s the best pickup ever made,” says Cornie, pleased with his 2004 Dodge 2500 equipped with a high output diesel engine. “The engine has a lot of power and starts even in the coldest weather. It gets about 20 mpg. It’s a super truck.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 1/2-in

Kevin Short, Honor, Mich. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My DeWalt 1/2-in. VSR hammer drill is my best buy. I do stone artwork with old farm equipment incorporated into it. I’ve used this drill for four years to drill hundreds of holes in all kinds of stone, and it has never let me down. I wouldn’t hesitate to buy another one.”

Worst Buy

Kodiak rotary cutter

James Hutchinson, Whiteville, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My 2004 Kodiak rotary cutter is my worst buy. Every time I try to put the pto in gear the blades lock up so tight that I have to take a large hammer and beat them loose. My dealer had the company send new blades and other parts so I could make the repair, which I did, but the same thing happened again. The company didn’t pay the dealer to repair the cutter or offer me compensation for my many trips to the dealer. I was going to purchase a heavier duty cutter, but the company said steel prices had gone up so much they couldn’t give me a break on another cutter.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford New Holland TL-100 front wheel assist + 1 more

William B. Erickson, Roseau, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“This tractor is absolutely a joy to drive and operate,” says William, pleased with his 2004 Ford New Holland TL-100 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a 52L quick-tach front-end loader. “It’s amazing what this tractor can pull. Also, it’s really fuel efficient.”

He’s unhappy with DeWalt cordless tools. “The rechargeable batteries don’t stand up to normal use, and it seems like they’re always out of warranty when something goes wrong.”

Best Buy

Shindaiwa 488 + 1 more

Tim Broer, Iowa Falls, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“Chain saws tend to be a high maintenance item and hard to start. But my Shindaiwa 488 always starts and cuts well. It has a lot of power and is well made.”

“Southmeadow Fruit Gardens was mentioned as a best buy in a recent FARM SHOW issue. But my experience has been that they’re difficult to work with. I bought one of their 112-page antique apple tree catalogs and never received it. I made phone calls and sent letters and emails but got no response. Now I’m out the money I sent. Buyer beware.”

Best Buy

Satoh Beaver 4-WD tractor

Rupert T. Allgood, Calvert City, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My 1970’s Satoh Beaver 4-WD tractor is a little marvel. It’s powered by a 2-cylinder, 15 hp diesel engine and has a 3-speed pto and eight forward speeds. The engine has been trouble-free. I thought this tractor was expensive when I bought it, but over time it has turned out to be quite economical.”

Best Buy

Versatile tractors

Mitch Auer, Broadview, Mont. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My father and I own three Versatile tractors and they’re all best buys. They include a 1979 model 800, 1976 model 835, and 1982 model 935. These tractors are dependable and rarely break down, and they have great Cummins engines. They’re fairly inexpensive and they never stop running.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Featherlite 4-horse gooseneck trailer + 1 more

Dale Garner, Vincennes, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My 2003 Featherlite 4-horse gooseneck trailer is well built. The company built it to my specs, and they were happy to add any convenience that I wanted. I had living quarters added onto it by Showtime Conversions of Middlebury, Ind. This trailer is built entirely of lightweight aluminum so my Chevy 3/4-ton crew cab pickup has no trouble pulling it.

“My New Holland 254 combination rake/tedder is my worst buy. The ground wheels aren’t built sturdy enough for the weight of the implement. It does a poor job of tedding hay, with no uniformity. It takes two people to hook the implement up to my tractor, and I have to almost lay on the ground to operate the levers so I can switch from tedding to raking. I’ll never buy another one.”

Best Buy

Case-IH 2388 combine equipped

Gary Baker, Mechanicsville, Iowa · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My Case-IH 2388 combine equipped with an AFX rotor is an excellent machine. It has a comfortable cab, a lot of power, and enough capacity to handle a 30-ft. platform or an 8-row corn head and unload on-the-go at speeds of more than 4 mph. The new AFX rotor is definitely an improvement over an already excellent threshing system.

“I don’t really have any worst buys. I’ve learned that the best time to buy a new piece of equipment is just before the company introduces its new model. One time I bought a corn planter and a forage chopper that were new models. Both machines went back to the dealer for rebuilds - the planter twice and the chopper once.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota extended cab 4-wd

Lawrence S. Jackson, Hamilton, Mo. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“I like my 1993 Dodge Dakota extended cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5.2-liter fuel-injected engine. I bought it used with about 166,000 miles on it. Recently, I put more than 12,000 miles on it in one month. It couldn’t run any better if it was new.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 2-WD 1/2-ton pickup

Stanley Dirksen, Davis Junction, Ill. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“A 2004 Chevrolet Silverado 2-WD, 1/2-ton pickup equipped with a 4.8-liter engine is my best buy. It handles well and rides great even with the heavy suspension system. It gets about 17 mpg around home and 20 mpg on the road, which I think it pretty good. The cab is as tight and quiet as any pickup that I’ve ever owned. I’m well satisfied with it.”

Best Buy

Murray 15 1/2 hp riding mower + 1 more

Gordon E. Harris, Mattison, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

Gordon likes his Murray 15 1/2 hp riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck but has had problems finding parts for it. “I use it to mow my lawn, to cut weeds, and even to cut down a big patch of Jerusalem artichokes. About one year ago the rear end started to go bad. I bought it from Fleet Farm and now I can’t find parts for it.

“My best buy is a 1988 Dodge van, which I bought used four years ago. It has a 318 cu. in. engine and a lock-up torque converter which acts as an overdrive. It gets about 20 mpg or so. My wife and son both like it almost as much as I do.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

GM Sierra 1500 pickup + 1 more

Charles Rodgers, Harveyville, Kansas · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“It has more than 95,000 miles on it but doesn’t use any oil and still has the original spark plugs,” says Charles, impressed with his 1992 GM Sierra 1500 pickup. “I use it to tow an 18-ft. trailer loaded with a Deere B tractor. This pickup still doesn’t have any rust and the paint on it looks like new. The only major repair it needed was replacement of a rear transmission seal.”

On the negative side, he lists his 1997 Pontiac Grand Am. “It has less than 50,000 miles on it, but already I’ve had to turn the brake drums and replace the front rotor and alternator. The dealer had to fix the headlights and service the engine sensors twice.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless drill driver + 1 more

Richard Fryzek, Estes Park, Colo. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“My 2001 Sears Craftsman 18-volt cordless drill driver has power and is a tough tool. I’ve used it to build several decks. It’s durable, and the battery charge lasts a long time.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2004 FlowTron leaf eater. “It wouldn’t do anything the manufacturer said it would. The cutter string lasted about seven minutes. It was supposed to mulch pine needles but it wouldn’t touch them. I’m disappointed with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford 7710 2-WD tractor eight + 1 more

William R. Warner, New York Mills, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

“I bought my 1982 Ford 7710 2-WD tractor eight years ago with 2,900 hours on it. Now it has 4,500 hours and has never needed any major repairs. It runs efficiently and has a quiet and comfortable cab. The air and heater always work, and it’s easy to drive. My daughter started driving it when she was 13 years old.

“My 1995 Murray lawn mower equipped with a 3 1/2 hp Briggs and Stratton engine is my worst buy. It never started without having to be primed and cranked a dozen times. We finally bought another mower equipped with a 5 hp Honda motor, and it usually starts on the first pull.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DR trimmer mower equipped + 1 more

Kenneth M. Hart, Mineral, Va. · Vol. 29, No. 2 (2005), p. 15

Kenneth likes his DR trimmer mower equipped with a 6 hp electric start motor. “We needed something to maintain a family cemetery lot and ordered this mower on a 6-month trial basis. One requirement was it had to cut tall and tough material close to gravestones and fences. It worked even better than we hoped.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists Slip-Ons designed to cover round bales. “A good idea and a good company to do business with. However, I make 4-ft. dia. by 5-ft. long bales and the covers made for bales of this size are too short to prevent water from accumulating at the bottom of the bale. It results in more spoilage than I’d probably get with uncovered bales stored on pallets.”