Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007)

80 reports from pages 12–15 · 69 Best Buys25 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Montana 4-WD 38 hp

B.W. Donaldson, Memphis, Tenn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

He’s disappointed with his 2005 Montana 4-WD, 38 hp loader tractor. “The support brackets for the bolts that secure the front-end loader sheared off. Then, with less than 100 hours on the tractor, the clutch assembly went out. It has a dry disc-type clutch system. Now the engine rpm indicator has failed.

“I’ve used this tractor to bush hog my property, but because of problems with the clutch system this tractor should be used only on flat ground. I paid $18,000 for it. No more off-brand tractors for me.”

Best Buy

EZ Boardwalk portable sawmill

Merle Hazen, Protection, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“I like my 2006 EZ Boardwalk portable sawmill and have nothing but positive things to say about it. It has performed flawlessly on several thousand board feet of eastern red cedar, walnut, Catalpa, and locust. I especially like how the cutting head sits at an angle to the log. It lets you enter the log at full speed instead of having to ease into it.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Silverado HD Duramax pickup equipped + 1 more

Ralph Morgan, Bloomfield, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

Ralph’s the proud owner of a 2002 Chevrolet Silverado HD Duramax pickup equipped with a diesel engine and Allison transmission. “This truck outpulls the last one I had and has power to spare.

“My Bully Dog Power Pup engine programmer made this truck much more fun to drive and improved the fuel efficiency by 3 mpg (ph 866 285-5936; www.bullydog.com).”

Best Buy

Gravely 2260 zero turn mower

Daryl Bueger, Redmond, Oregon · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“I’m absolutely amazed how good my Gravely 2260 zero turn mower works. It’s built rugged and is safe and easy to operate. It has reduced my mowing time by half. I like it so much that after mowing two acres I still don’t want to get off it. It’s equipped with a 21 hp Briggs & Stratton twin V-engine.”

Best Buy

Stihl 029 chainsaw + 2 more

Donald Borton, Delavan, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

He’s happy with the Stihl 029 chainsaw he bought 20 years ago. “I use it to cut an average of five cords a year. No problems. When it’s warm it requires only one pull to start.

“I bought a small Kubota L2550 tractor in 1984 as a chore tractor and still use it all summer long. No problems in all those years.”

Ron J. Stoen, Stoen Farm Supply, pickup. To make it work even better, we designed an electric lift that lets us raise or lower the plow right from the pickup cab. It works so good that we made up several units for sale.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Snow Sport aluminum snowplow + 2 more

Lowry, Minn. ph 800 323-5769 · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“I like my Snow Sport aluminum 7-ft. snowplow that mounts on the front receiver hitch of my says Weaver, pleased with his 2005 Chevrolet Silverado 2500 HD Turbo Diesel pickup.

On the minus side, he lists his 2004 Kubota TG 1860 18 hp diesel lawn tractor. “The power steering failed just after the warranty expired. It would have cost more than $400 to repair so now I use this tractor without power steering. It has only about 140 hours on it but already I’ve had to replace the ignition switch, starter, starter solenoid, and battery, and now it has a cracked fuel tank. The engine has always been hard to start, even with a preheater, whenever the temperature drops below 70 degrees. I paid a premium for this tractor but it turned out to be junk. I wish I had my Deere riding mower back.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 40C crawler tractor + 2 more

Jim Taylor, Onaway, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“I like my mid 1950’s Deere 40C crawler tractor which I bought used about 15 years ago. It has required only routine maintenance and always starts and works great.

“My Stihl 028 Super chainsaw is a best buy. All I’ve replaced are the bars and chains. It’s a dependable saw.

“My Dremel contour sander is my worst buy. I wasn’t able to even finish sanding one chair that we were refinishing. Now all I have is a plastic box and a bunch of new sanding pads.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt 368 circular saw + 1 more

Lisa Young, West Palm Beach, Florida · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“My DeWalt 368 circular saw is my best buy. I bought it for my husband for Valentine’s Day. He says it’s one of the best saws he’s ever owned. It cuts smooth and clean. He uses this saw at work and at home and loves it.

“My 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee is my worst buy. At speeds under 25 mph the brakes sometimes failed. The vehicle had less than 3,000 miles on it when this problem started happening. I was told by the dealer that there was nothing wrong. After this problem happened in front of my son’s school I got rid of the vehicle. As a side note, a co-worker of mine has the same problem with their 2007 Jeep Commander.”

Best Buy

Swisher 4-wheeled trail-behind mower

Lyle Oakes, Montrose, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“My Swisher 4-wheeled trail-behind, 60-in. mower does a good job and is my best buy. It can be set to trail offset or straight behind the towing vehicle. By pulling a 46-in. mower along with it I can mow about a 102-in. wide swath. Also, it doesn’t scalp on uneven ground.”

Best Buy

Yamaha Rhino 450

Rick Lutt, Dallas, S. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 12

“My 2006 Yamaha Rhino 450 is a great utility vehicle. I use it to do a lot of spot spraying. It’s really nice to be able to drive with either hand and control your speed with your foot, instead of having to use your hand like you do with an ATV. It has adequate road speed and plenty of power. The only negative is that I have to remove the center console in order to check the oil.”

Best Buy

New Holland TN 60-A 2-WD tractor

Richard A. Marble, Farmington, Maine · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

Richard nominates his 2005 New Holland TN 60-A 2-WD tractor as his “best buy”. “We use this tractor on our 136-acre farm for haying and for general farm work. We also use it to harvest wood for firewood and building materials. I’m pleased with how much power it has. So far it has been trouble-free.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Yardman 420 push mower equipped + 2 more

Charles E. Hogue, Monroe, Oregon · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“I like my 2005 Yardman 420 21-in. push mower equipped with a Honda 5 1/2 hp engine. It always starts on the first pull.

“My 2004 Murray garden tractor equipped with a Briggs & Stratton 21 hp engine starts every time. No problems.”

On the negative side, “My 2003 Husqvarna riding mower equipped with a 18 hp Kawasaki engine was fouling spark plugs every 25 hours. I took it in to my dealer who was just replaced the plugs, but kept the mower for up to three months at a time. The problem was that gas was leaking into the engine oil, but neither the company nor the dealer would stand behind it. I finally got it repaired at another shop at my own expense.”

Best Buy

PJ gooseneck trailer

Bryan Martin, Pine Grove, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

A 2006 PJ 24-ft. gooseneck trailer rates as Bryan’s “best buy” (ph 800 452-9116; www.pj-trailers.com). “I use this trailer almost every day during the summer to haul vegetables to local produce auctions. It has been a dependable trailer and is just what I needed.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bobcat T200 skid loader + 1 more

Fred Iozzo, Wayne, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

Fred’s impressed with his Bobcat T200 skid loader which he bought used. “I can’t believe how great this machine is. Over the years I’ve owned three Bobcats and all of them ran good, but this one is incredible.

“My Ryobi metal-cutting saw is my worst buy. It lasted only about one hour before it quit working. No parts are available and no one would even try to fix it.”

Best Buy

Udderly EZ hand-pumped milking machine

Ray Hoem, Buhl, Idaho · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“I’m pleased with our Udderly EZ hand-pumped milking machine (EZ Animal Products, ph 866 507-7773; www.UdderlyEZ.com). It makes it easier and safer to milk out colostrums for newborn foals. It can also be used to milk sheep, goats and other animals. “We purchased it to help with our flock of 165 sheep. It’s a wonderful tool and helps considerably in our flock management,” says Ray.

Best Buy

Jeep Cherokee 4-WD wagon equipped

David L. Smith, Amarillo, Texas · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

A 1997 Jeep Cherokee 4-WD wagon equipped with an in-line 4.0-liter, 6-cyl. engine and automatic transmission rates as David’s “best buy”. “My wife bought this vehicle new in 1998 and has had no trouble at all with it. It has more than 145,000 miles on it. I’ve replaced two sets of brakes and six sets of tires as well as a battery. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance. My wife has talked about replacing it for two years, but she hasn’t found anything else that has caught her eye.”

Best Buy

Oliver 1600 tractor equipped

James Valiquette, Escanaba, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“My 1960’s Oliver 1600 tractor equipped with a 6-cyl. gas engine, which I bought used, is my best buy. This tractor was a one-owner model and I bought it for only $4,000. I use it on my small 80-acre farm. It starts on the first couple of turns no matter what the weather conditions. I use it with my 8-ft. snowblower and to go out in the woods to cut firewood. It’s a great tractor.”

Best Buy

Subaru Sambar mini truck

Harry Dawson, Rome, Ga. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

A used 1993 Subaru Sambar mini truck that he bought a year ago rates as Harry’s “best buy”. “This mini truck has performed flawlessly. It’s equipped with a 5-speed transmission and push button 4-WD with an extra ‘double low’ 4-WD gear. It has an AM radio, air conditioner, and a good heater. It had about 75,000 miles on it when I bought it.

“It’s the handiest machine on my farm. I can’t understand why someone would pay $8,000 or more for a 4-WD Gator or a Kawasaki Mule and freeze during the winter, when they can get a Subaru Sambar with more carrying capacity and for less than half as much money. One additional benefit is that in my state I can get a license tag for it and drive it on the road at 40 to 50 mpg. It works great for running errands.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Little Giant ladder + 1 more

Clyde J. Cole, Hurdland, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“I like my Little Giant ladder, but the company never sent the hinge that converts it to a scaffold. I contacted the company more than a year ago about this matter but they never replied.

“My Cub Cadet zero turn riding mower equipped with a 44-in. deck is my worst buy. The springs kept breaking, and the deck keeps plugging up. The deck somehow wasn’t designed right and plugs up in tall or wet grass.

“Another worst buy was a 110-volt wire welder that I bought from Harbor Freight.”

Best Buy

Suzuki King Quad ATV

Kelly Palmer, Angola, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

Kelly likes his 2005 Suzuki King Quad ATV. “I’ve used it with a 5-ft. blade to push snow so high that people think I used a Bobcat skid loader. I also used it to level 80 tons of sand inside my greenhouses and to pull out trees that would cause problems for my full-size 4-WD truck. I pull two 4-ft. mowers behind it to cut six acres of grass each week. It’s so easy to use that my wife and kids ride it all the time. It’s the best money I ever spent.”

Best Buy

Toyota 4-WD pickup

Larry Danler, Pinedale, Arizona · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“It’s a great little truck,” says Larry about his 1985 Toyota 4-WD pickup. “I bought it used three years ago with about 125,000 miles on it. The previous owner bought it new and never did any engine work on it. I replaced the timing chain at about 150,000 miles but otherwise the engine has run like new. Everything on it, including all the lights inside and out, still work perfectly.”

Best Buy

International Harvester 1055 tractor

Victor R. Greene, Plattsburg, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

Victor bought his 1985 International Harvester 1055 tractor used and is pleased with it, except for the way the battery system is set up. “When I bought this tractor it had two new 12-volt batteries in parallel hookup. The batteries were ‘fighting’ each other and wearing each other down, so that when I tried to start the tractor there was almost no power. To solve the problem, I replaced the two 12-volt batteries with two new 6-volt batteries which I hooked up in series. I cut the battery cable in half and installed new leads to make sure the negative-positive connection was correct. The new 6-volt battery system has the same total cranking amperage as the original 12-volt one. The batteries work fine now and there’s plenty of starting power.”

Best Buy

Johnson HyGrade Grader

Gardner Gray, Pringle, S. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

Gardner is hard put to find enough adjectives to describe his enthusiasm for his Johnson HyGrade Grader (Johnson Mfg., Kulm, Ind. ph 800 874-5600). What makes the Johnson blade different is that it can be hydraulically tilted both left and right and also can be angled both left and right, with all controls operated from the tractor seat. Also, the wheels are located behind the blade, not in front.

Gardner had a contract to build three miles of road for the county and the 12-ft. Johnson pull-type grader made it possible for him to do the job in a very short period of time. “I built three miles of road in rough terrain and relied on a bulldozer for only a small section of the road that was heavy rock,” says Gardner. “Other than that, I completed the entire job in only about 140 hours and saved about $65,000 in professional construction fees. I figure this grader has paid for itself eight times over. The blade is still in excellent condition.”

The blades come in 12, 14, and 16-ft. models. The company says they’re used to clean and maintain waterways, build ponds, dig irrigation ditches, fill in washouts, level building sites, clean feedlots, remove snow, and level field edges.

Best Buy

Can Dig mini excavator

Jack Racz, Wrentham, Alberta · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“I’ve operated track hoes for years but I’m really impressed with my Can Dig mini excavator (ph 800 509-5656 or 250 314-0708; www.candig.com). It works great for digging basements and many other jobs,” says Jack.

The Candig CD11 can be towed by a small car or ATV or even pushed by hand. It weighs only 840 lbs. so it causes little damage to lawns, says the company. Power is supplied by a 5 1/2 hp Honda engine. It comes with mechanical stabilizer, 2-in. trailer hitch, safety tow chain, and retractable tongue wheel. An auger, wood splitter, hydraulic stabilizers, and other accessories are available. A ripper/root cutter accessory allows you to dig through frozen or tough ground, and also doubles as a root cutter. Three different trenching buckets are available.

According to the company, the mini excavator is much safer to use on uneven ground compared to a tracked excavator since they have a low center of gravity and a wide working stance. Access wheels allow the mini excavator to slip through a 28-in. wide yard gate or doorway. The thumb allows you to pick up boulders or logs weighing well over 1,000 lbs., and place them where you wish. A 9 hp model is also available.

Worst Buy

McCullough Eager Beaver chainsaw

John H. Bayes, LaBelle, Fla. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“My McCullough Eager Beaver chainsaw is my worst buy. I hadn’t used it 20 minutes before the spark coil went out. The price for a new coil - if I could find one - was half the price of the entire saw. This saw doesn’t work well for right handed people because the fuel inlet is located on the lower left side of the tank and soon runs out of fuel when sawing horizontally. I eventually drilled extra holes in the saw’s housing to facilitate coil cooling.”

Best Buy

Ryobi Planer

Wayne Hopkins, Spartansburg, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“I’ve made a lot of furniture with my Ryobi Planer but it still works great and is my best buy. It’s easy to replace the knives after sharpening them. It’s also easy to adjust.”

Best Buy

Zena mobile welding system

Roman Stoll, Odon, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“My Zena mobile welding system is my best buy (ph 615 897-2011; www.zena.net). It’s a high frequency DC welder that attaches to any engine, converting it into a powerful mobile welder that you can take anywhere. Any electric start engine will power it.

“No problems. I like how it welds - all the controls are at my fingertips. It has a boost button to start a tough weld. There’s no power at the rod end until I push the weld button. Best of all, it’s a lot less expensive than other models,” says Roman.

Best Buy

Bobcat 843 skid steer loader

Neil Klingelhoter, Randallstown, Md. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“I’m impressed with my 1997 Bobcat 843 skid steer loader. It’s equipped with twin round bale spears and can handle two 500-lb. bales with ease. It makes unloading and storing hay much easier than if I was using a loader tractor. It works fast, is easy to maneuver, and can just nudge the bale when storing it which makes for a neat and safe operation. We’re in the process of adding another skid loader to our haying operation.”

Best Buy

Bixby Maxfire 115 corn burning stove

Mike Yutzy, Dundee, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“”My Bixby Maxfire 115 corn burning stove is my best buy. I like its simple push button ignition and the automatic clinker ejection system. I also like being able to fill the hopper with almost two bushels of fuel, without having to worry about refilling it more than once a day. That’s with the stove turned up all the way. And of course, it helps keep our gas bill down.”

Worst Buy

John Deere tractor sound clock

Joe Strueder, Franksville, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“I received a John Deere tractor sound clock as a gift and, even though I didn’t buy it, it’s a disappointment. It features 12 of the most notable Deere tractors, past and present. Every hour on the hour an authentic tractor sound of one of the twelve featured tractors will play. I was excited to hear the sounds of the different tractors but I got nothing but static. They all just sound like scratches.”

Best Buy

Bobcat 763 G skid steer loader

Irwin Z. Nolt, Jr., New Holland, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My best buy is my Bobcat 763 G skid steer loader equipped with a cab. I bought this unit used at an auction when it was two years old with 2,000 hours on it. Now it has about 3,000 hours with few repairs. I use it to move dirt, break concrete, sweep, and as a grabbing bucket that works well for brush clean-up and for collecting logs for firewood. The view from the cab is great - the best I’ve ever seen.”

Best Buy

World Tree Technologies

Maurice R. Leighton, Placerville, Calif. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“In February I ordered five “Empress Splendor” trees from World Tree Technologies in Scottsville, Arix. These fast-growing trees had been featured in FARM SHOW. My check has been cashed but I have never received my trees. I made four phone calls to the company and each time they promised immediate delivery. But nothing has ever happened. I called one more time in May and they promised to return my check but I still have not received the trees, my money or had any other contact with the company.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 18 hp riding mower

Bob Aubrey, Batavia, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 1980’s Sears garden tractor powered by a 16 hp Onan engine and equipped with a 2-speed transmission (low and high range) and 48-in. mower deck is my best buy. I bought the tractor used at a flea market for $200 with about 1,000 hours on it. Now it has more than 2,000 hours, but it still works as good as new. This little tractor has a lot of power and is virtually indestructible - it can even pull a van with the transmission in low range. I use it with both a front and rear-mounted blade as well as a sickle mower.

“I own a newer Sears Craftsman 18 hp riding mower that’s also equipped with an Onan engine and standard transmission, and it’s a best buy, too. I mounted an exhaust stack on it like the ones found on bigger tractors. The Onan is a wonderful engine - you just touch the starter and away it goes. I have a pair of great twin tractors!”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 2 more

Lester Rose, Yellville, Ark. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“At one time I owned a 1979 Ford F-150 pickup, which was a worst buy. I tell people I actually bought two identical pickups the same day, because it was both the first and the last Ford to ever be parked in my driveway.

“My next new truck was a 1987 Dodge D-50 which we drove for 116,000 miles in four years and four months. I loved it. We now own a 1993 Nissan Sentra which I really like. We bought it used with about 64,000 miles after it had been in an accident and restored. Now it has more than 159,000 miles, and it seems like 300,000 miles might be within its range. I’ve never owned such a trouble-free car. I also have a 1996 Dodge 3/4-ton diesel pickup with about 207,000 miles. It gets 23.4 mpg on the highway and can move a mountain.”

Worst Buy

Universal Grain and Biomass corn burning boiler

Rick Etherington, Garner, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 2006 Universal Grain and Biomass corn burning boiler is my worst buy. I poured a concrete slab for it and set up a bulk bin, and had a heating contractor and plumber hook up the air-heating coils in our basement. The dealer was told this was a 250,000 btu heater. However, the book that covers the installation procedure was terrible and we had operating problems from the start. The boiler would shut itself down whenever the water temperature went over 180 degrees, and the bearings in the feed auger went out.

“I had to babysit this machine from the start. The boiler required upkeep every day and couldn’t be trusted. My dealer was very understanding and finally took the unit back. Now we’re looking for another model to replace it.”

Worst Buy

Simplicity 1823 riding mower

James L. Oetker, Cumming, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 2005 Simplicity 1823 riding mower is my worst buy. The problem is the power steering has a quarter turn of play. I took the mower back to the dealer and he called the factory rep, who told them that eight out of nine power steering units do the same thing.

“Another problem is that every time I get into heavy grass the mower’s drive belt slips, unless I put belt dressing on it. I don’t think the springs on the tightener are built heavy enough. This mower should have been recalled. I use it to mow our local cemetery, but it’s an embarrassment because I can’t drive in a straight line due to the play in the power steering.”

Worst Buy

USI Clothing

Larry Cristo, Savanna, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

A pair of overalls from USI Clothing rates as Larry’s “worst buy”. “I read a story on the company in FARM SHOW and ordered a pair. However, when the overalls came they were small enough to fit a young boy so I tried to call the company, but they wouldn’t answer their phone or return my calls. This went on for weeks, so I called my credit card company and cancelled the charge. Lo and behold, the company finally called me. I told the company rep why I cancelled my payment. He was apologetic and asked that I give him a chance to send me the correct size. So at my own expense I returned the overalls to him and included a check for payment of a new pair in the correct size. (I couldn’t use the credit card because I had already cancelled the first payment to them). He received my check, deposited it, and it cleared. A month later he called to tell me he was sending me the overalls. But a month later I still haven’t received them, and they’re no longer returning my calls.”

Best Buy

Recon 300 hay conditioner

David Milleville, Sanborn, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

David is a dairyman and also produces hay for the horse market. He praises the Recon 300 hay conditioner because of the way it speeds up the hay making process, and at the same time makes better quality hay (ph 800 561-0132; www.agshield.com).

“I especially like the way this conditioner keeps dust out of the hay. That’s very important because horses can’t tolerate dust in their hay. The old saying, ‘You have to make hay while the sun shines’ is as good as ever. But I find that using the Recon 300 greatly speeds up what the sun is able to do, and I end up with greener hay in a shorter period of time.

“In the past I would cut the hay and leave it on the ground for as long as three days. The Recon 300 has cut the time at least by half.”

Milleville has used Recons for more than eight years and is now on his third one. “What this machine really does is give the hay an additional crimping, and at the same time it can lay windrows over on dryer ground. And since I can make the hay sooner, I end up with a greener bale,” says Milleville.

Worst Buy

Bush Hog zero turn model

Jim Dick, Mountain Lake, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“I’m 60 years old and have been farming for 38 years. My absolute worst buy in all that time is my 2004 Bush Hog zero turn model ZT 180 mower. Already, two gearboxes and two pto shafts have gone bad. Then right before the warranty expired last year, the Kohler engine started acting up. When the engine gets warm it backfires and runs on only one cylinder. Last summer this mower spent more time in the dealer’s shop than on my farm. The electronic modules, valves, carburetor, fuel filter, and fuel pump have all been replaced.

“This mower has gone to the regional Kohler distributor twice to be worked on, but nothing has changed. My dealer tells me there’s nothing more they can do. I tell them to just replace the whole engine, but they won’t do it. I wouldn’t recommend this machine to anyone.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4020 equipped

Raymond Thomas, Linton, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 1972 Deere 4020 equipped with a wide front axle is a pleasant tractor to drive. It was the last year these tractors were built. It’s equipped with a powershift transmission and 95 hp diesel engine. It also has dual remote hydraulic outlets, a quick hitch, and hydraulic power brakes.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 361 chainsaw + 1 more

John E. Palmer, Exeter, N.H. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My Stihl 361 chainsaw is my worst buy. It has no power and it vibrates. It had two right side cutters together that made it cut crooked. I wanted to get credit for this saw and upgrade to the next model. However, the dealer said he couldn’t because too much time had passed. I have a McCulloch saw that’s more than 30 years old, and it cuts better than this saw.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 455 Rancher chainsaw

Matt Davis, Tehachapi, Calif. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 2006 Husqvarna 455 Rancher chainsaw is my best buy. It runs great and is easy to maintain. No problems.

“The 2006 6 by 8-ft. greenhouse I bought for my wife from Harbor Freight is my worst buy. I got it home only to realize the installation instructions for it were incomplete. While I was putting it together the cheap aluminum bolts kept snapping so I replaced them with steel ones. Also, the clips that are supposed to hold the panels in weren’t strong enough to handle high winds so I had to glue them all in.”

Best Buy

Versatile 835 4-WD tractor

Myron Bentrager, Arlington, Kansas · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

A 1980 Versatile 835 4-WD tractor rates as Myron’s “best buy”. “I bought this tractor used several years ago largely because of its reputation, and it has performed well. It’s simple, rugged, powerful, and reliable. I really like it. It’s a much better tractor than the Case 2470 4-WD tractor that it replaced. There are a lot of these older Versatiles still being used in our area.”

Best Buy

Hydra Mac 8B skid loader

Don Salmen, Wessington Springs, S. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 1976 Hydra Mac 8B skid loader is my all-time best buy. I have no idea how many hours are on it. Both the engine and the hydrostat have been overhauled once. I use this machine several times a day and would be lost without it. When I retire and move to town it’s coming with me.”

Best Buy

EZ Boardwalk portable sawmill

Danny C. Hutto, Abbeville, Ala. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“After two years of thorough research, I recently purchased an EZ Boardwalk portable sawmill and it’s my best buy (7959 Shelby 348, Emben, Mo. 63439 ph 573 633-2135). After watching demonstrations of several different mills, I found the ‘angle cut’ design a big help in reducing the amount of force needed to move the saw blade through the log. In fact, in softer woods the blade has to be held back some. Also, the twin V-belt pulley design ensures maximum torque from the Honda engine to the saw head.

“It comes with a 6-in. by 20-ft. solidly constructed, heavy duty track which I really like, as it eliminates the need to assemble and disassemble multiple track pieces for basic use, important for portability. Also, the track and frame are very sturdy and stable. The trailer package makes this sawmill easy to transport anywhere, whether over the road or on your property.

“It’s apparent that whoever designed this unit took the operator’s needs and ease of use into consideration. They paid attention to many minor details that make this sawmill easy to use.

“This saw will cut all sizes and types of logs up to 40 inches in diameter.”

Best Buy

Kohler engine + 1 more

John A. Rissler, New Enterprise, Penn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My compliments to Kohler and Hustler Turf for supporting their products after the sale. My 2006 Hustler zero turn riding mower equipped with a 66-in. deck cuts excellent in all conditions and works great on hills. By the end of this year we’ll have put more than 1,800 hours on it, which is more than most people will put on a mower in a lifetime. I’ve had to replace only one deck belt, at 670 hours.

“The mower’s 30 hp Kohler engine originally had a power loss when going uphill, but Kohler remedied that by installing a new intake elbow to prevent flooding. Also, it consumed 20 oz. of oil per 12-hour day (believed to have been partially caused by carburetor flooding). We added oil every day until the mowing season was over. Then at 850 hours Kohler paid for installing new updated piston and ring sets. Now this engine uses only minimal amounts of oil like any other engine. The company’s support system really helped and will be a big factor in our future buying decisions.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 3500 pickup averaged + 1 more

Francis J. Nemetz, Negaunee, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“In your last issue there was a worst buy from an Oklahoma reader who claimed that his 2006 Dodge 3500 pickup averaged only 6 mpg, even when running empty. I think this is impossible. There would be a continuous trail of dense black smoke behind this truck if it did get such poor fuel mileage.

“We recently made a trip to Pierre, S. Dak. from Marquette, Mich., pulling a tandem dump trailer. We were fighting a head wind on the way out but still averaged 16.1 mpg. The pickup we used was a 2006 Dodge 3500 4-WD model equipped with an excellent Cummins diesel engine and automatic transmission. It’s definitely a best buy.”

Best Buy

Jackson add-on power steering

Rodney Davis, Arundel, Maine · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

Rodney bought a Jackson add-on power steering kit for his 1963 Ford 4000 tractor and says he likes it except for one problem (ph 620 357-6546; www.jacksonpowersteering.com). “It works good except the drag links are too light and will bend. Stronger drag links should be supplied with the kit. I’ve put steel rods inside and welded on steel sleeves in order to keep the clamps from slipping.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Case 580 loader backhoe + 1 more

Allan Schiefelbein, Whitemouth, Manitoba · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My best buy ever is my 1969 Case 580 loader backhoe, which I bought used 18 years ago. I paid $4,500 for it and it has paid for itself many times over. I’ve used it and abused it but it has required no major repairs. The loader is built strong and fast and accurate, and it works nice for handling manure or bales or even doing landscaping work. The weight of the hoe provides good stability. The best part is it still helps me make money.

“My Richie Thrifty King 100-head energy-free cattle waterer is my worst buy. The problem is the inserts for the lid bolts are mounted in such a way that the insulation gets saturated with water, making it useless. I’ve installed a 1,200-watt submersible heater and the riser pipe is heated, yet it still freezes. I plan to replace this unit with a regular fountain and burn this headache.”

Best Buy

EZ Boardwalk manual sawmill

Craig Smith, Livingston, La. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“I’m absolutely delighted with the EZ Boardwalk manual sawmill that I bought about one year ago. I lost a good deal of timber during Hurricane Katrina and didn’t want to waste the potential lumber. I shopped for several months, then saw this mill, among several others, at a demonstration hosted by the Louisiana State University’s Ag Center. I recognized that it was built stronger than the others (larger carriage wheels, high quality bearings, etc.) and had more clever ideas (angle cut, throttle and blade engagement, etc.). Also, it cost about $1,800 less than other comparable models. Furthermore, I’m delighted with the manufacturer and its willingness to help.

“This mill earned bragging rights recently when I sliced a 32-in. oak log and a 32-in. pine log into slabs. I’m still amazed that a manual sawmill can do this, and do it so well. I’ve cut about 25,000 board feet with this unit so far, and it’s still in great shape. I expect it’ll last a lifetime. I highly recommend this mill to anyone in the market for a sawmill.”

Best Buy

Honda Foreman 400 ATV equipped

Corban Bigbee, Broken Bow, Neb. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My 1997 Honda Foreman 400 ATV equipped with a foot-operated shift lever is my best buy. It has survived working with cattle, and also a center pivot irrigator running over it, without any structural damage. It now has almost 30,000 miles and 3,000 hours but is still purring away as strong as ever, with no major problems. I’d recommend this machine to anyone.”

Best Buy

Dakota Driveway Alarm

P.J. Ranck, Gratiot, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“Our Dakota Driveway Alarm is our best buy (Dakota Alert Inc., Elk Point, S. Dak. ph 605 356-2772). Safety and security is a top priority for us. Hidden in a bird house, this alarm provides advance warning of vehicles or walk-ins. It’s a durable, quality product.”

Worst Buy

Mantis rototiller

Gar Harris, Garden Grove, Calif. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

Gar’s unhappy with his Mantis rototiller. “This unit is a 20-lb. multi-purpose tiller, edger, aerator and dethatcher. It was advertised as being easy to start and requiring minimum maintenance - just add grease and clean the spark plug. But this machine has always been hard to start. The company sent a new plug and fuel filter but that didn’t help. I haven’t been able to use this rototiller for two years.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Omnex T110/R160 radio remote control + 1 more

Allen Schlabach, Fredericksburg, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

Allen likes his Omnex T110/R160 radio remote control (ph 800 663-8806; www.omnexcontrols.com). “I purchased this 18-function remote control two years ago to use with my new hydraulic hoof-trimming chute. It has been trouble-free, even though I use it five days a week. I really like the ability to be away from the chute and still catch the cows as they enter the chute. It’s especially valuable when I have to load cows by myself.

“My 1998 Hotsy 761A pressure washer is my worst buy. The Wisconsin Robin engine and Hawk pressure pump on it are reliable and are still being used. However, the hot water burner didn’t work the first time I tried to use it. While it was still under warranty I took it back to the shop many times, but when I got it back it never worked for more than a few months at a time. I finally got tired of throwing good money after bad and removed the heater. Now I’m using this unit as a cold water washer.”

Worst Buy

A 2005 Rascal 4-wheel scooter rates as Jay’s “worst buy”

Jay Vics, Menands, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

A 2005 Rascal 4-wheel scooter rates as Jay’s “worst buy”. “Within the first month the right front wheel fell off. I called the company several times but they never returned my calls. Seven months later the seat fell off and I had to have it welded on. Two months after that two tires went flat and I had to buy two new tubes. I put a stop on payments but still could get no response from the company. Last year I got a copy of my credit report which showed that they wrote me off as bad debt.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota 3010 DSL tractor + 1 more

Pete Hinson, Foley, Ala. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

Pete’s impressed with his 2001 Kubota 3010 DSL tractor. “It has required only routine maintenance - no problems. It’s like a Timex watch - it takes a lickin’ but keeps on tickin’. We use it to scrape dirt and with a finish mower to cut six acres of lawn. We also use it to yank out an occasional tree or bush. I just can’t say enough good things about this tractor.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his DR trimmer. “It’s built tough and I thought it would run forever. However, after four years it quit working. It blew a head gasket and a valve stuck, and I can’t seem to fix it. It’s almost as cheap to buy a new one as it is to repair the motor.”

Best Buy

Ford pickup equipped

Omer Baucom, Lawton, Okla. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

Omer’s “best buy” is his 1989 Ford pickup equipped with a 302 cu. in. engine and automatic transmission. “I bought this pickup used in 1990 with 25,000 miles on it. I put more than 200,000 miles on it, then two years ago I gave it to my son. It’s still going strong. Other than routine maintenance, the engine has never been touched.”

Worst Buy

John Deere GT235 lawn tractor equipped

Charles W. McDonald, Inwood, W. Va. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My Deere GT235 lawn tractor equipped with a 20 hp Briggs & Stratton engine is my worst buy. The engine started fouling spark plugs when it was only a month old. The air filter would become clogged with oil and would choke the engine until the plugs fouled. The company says they don’t warranty electrical parts. We would replace the air filter and install two new plugs and it would run good for four to six hours, but then the same problem would happen again. In three years we’ve replaced more than 50 spark plugs and 25 filters.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 7810 MFWD tractor + 1 more

D. Cramer, Ringwood, Okla. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

He nominates his 2002 Deere 7810 MFWD tractor as his “best buy”. “This is a nice tractor. It’s comfortable, quiet, has a good ride, is efficient and productive, and is built strong for its size. At the end of the day I don’t feel as beat up and worn out as I do with our other IH tractors. It actually helps get things moving on our farm early in the morning, because whoever gets to the field first gets to drive the 7810.”

He’s not impressed with his New Holland 1441 15-ft. discbine. “This machine won’t cut alfalfa without leaving a lot of it in the field. It leaves huge streaks of uncut hay between each cutterhead, It won’t cut short hay at all, and it beats the leaves off the hay as it throws it into the crimper. Also, it puts a lot of dirt in the windrow. The dealer said the blades would last 300 to 400 acres, but in our sand they could hardly finish 80 acres. The blades had to be changed daily. It’s a high maintenance machine, and its resale value was horrible. I’d never buy a New Holland discbine again.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 4500 tractors + 1 more

James J. Anthony, White Bluff, Tenn. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My son and I bought two Deere 4500 tractors and they’re both worst buys. The seats on both tractors cracked and came apart from the seat frame, and the plastic engine cover grille and steering instrument housing cracked and fell apart. Also, the shift lever and gears came apart. I got no help from the dealer. The loader bucket on my son’s tractor shakes the entire tractor to the point it pulls the bolts out of the frame. The engine works great, however, as do the hydraulics.

“We both bought Deere Gators, too, and they’re also worst buys. The seats fell apart within a year.”

Best Buy

Last issue FARM SHOW featured a company that recently started importin

Joe Duffy, Hornell, New York (607 324-2971) · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“Last issue FARM SHOW featured a company that recently started importing a line of pellet-making machines from China. My partner runs a sawmill so we bought a machine. We’re in the initial stages of learning how to make pellets and we’ve had some problems. So far we’ve tried sawdust, wood shavings and wood chips, mixing them with water and other ‘binders’. It’s not as easy as promised and we’re wondering if anyone else out there has some ideas for us. This machine is supposed to produce 600 lbs. of pellets per hour but we haven’t come anywhere near that. So far we haven’t tried plant material such as grass or cornstalks. The company tells us we need to get the right moisture content but they don’t seem to be able to tell us what that is. Our machine has a good 15-hp diesel engine that’s hand-cranked. It starts good. The company also has electric-start models. All the instructions that came with the machine are in Chinese.

“If anyone out there has any ideas on how to improve it’s performance, we’re looking for help.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota 30 hp tractor + 1 more

Fred Lowry, Sr., Draper, Utah · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“My 2003 Kubota 30 hp tractor works great at my small horse training facility.”

On the negative side, “My Deere ‘quick switch’ unit for hooking up to 3-pt. implements is my worst buy. It works great if the implement is perfectly level ground. However, it’s almost impossible to use if the implement you’re hooking up to is on uneven terrain.”

Best Buy

Ford Expedition equipped

Michael Hernson, Parkton, N.C. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 15

“I like my 1998 4-WD Ford Expedition equipped with a 5.4-liter engine. It’s the best all-around vehicle I’ve ever owned. It can haul eight large 1,000-lb. bales with ease or pull our 28-ft. camper. It has a nice, comfortable ride for making day trips and plenty of room for passengers. At 204,000 miles it has had no major problems. It gets 15 1/2 to 17 1/2 mpg.”