Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012)

86 reports from pages 12–15 · 73 Best Buys20 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Getting rid of moles with traps is frustrating because new moles keep

Alton Eliason, Northford, Conn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“Getting rid of moles with traps is frustrating because new moles keep coming as fast as you can trap them. I’ve found that solar-powered Mole Chasers that stick into the ground and set up a vibration work very effectively to keep lawns and gardens mole-free. They sell for $9.95 at Harbor Freight (www.harborfreight.com; 800-444-3353).”

Best Buy

Mahindra 4110 4-WD 40 hp tractor equipped

Tavish Presswood, Canton, Ga. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“I like my Mahindra 4110 4-WD 40 hp tractor equipped with a front-end loader. This tractor has a great power-to-weight ratio and is heavy enough to maintain good traction on all 4 wheels. I use it to pull a plow and a big Taylor-Way disk equipped with 26-in. dia. discs. I use the loader for everything from hanging up deer carcasses for processing to moving dirt, pushing over small trees, and much more. I previously owned a 2005 snowblowers that were real hard starters. However, after I started using Sea Foam these machines usually start right up on the first or second pull. Sea Foam also helps to clean spark plugs.”

Best Buy

D&R walk-behind brush mower

Glen Ray Goodson, Galax, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

Glen’s the satisfied owner of a D&R walk-behind brush mower. “It sips fuel and does a good job of cutting, with no cleanup afterward like you have with a sicklebar mower. It’s dependable and gets into places too small for a tractor.”

Best Buy

Nite Gard alarm

J. Reese, Bloomington, Ill. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

He likes the Nite Gard alarm he uses to protect livestock against predators (ph 800 328-6647; www.niteguard.com). “The red blinking light is sensed as an eye and becomes a threat to the predator. It’s simple to use and keeps varmints off my property, including deer and coyotes.”

Worst Buy

Lifetime Homes

Larry D. Keim, Davenport, Neb. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“About 3 years ago we bought a Champion home from Lifetime Homes in York, Neb. We asked them several times to fix cracks in the walls and replace the front door because it leaks every time it rains. However, they haven’t even had the courtesy to return my phone calls. I’m disappointed in the company.”

Best Buy

Firestone truck tires

Ed Gorham, Gladewater, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“I went through 3 sets of Firestone truck tires in just one month. The first set were the wrong tires for my truck and caused it to ride like a hay wagon. The local Firestone service manager doesn’t know tires, so I tried to call the company but got no help. I won’t buy Firestone tires again.”

Best Buy

Suhner grinding

Marc Anderson, Caneyville, Ky. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“I work in a metal fabrication shop where we’ve just started using Suhner grinding and flap wheels (www.suhner.com). We had been using carborundum gold grinding wheels and CGW flap wheels on mild and stainless steel. However, the Suhner Magic Disc we use for grinding lasts 3 times as long and works twice as fast, and it’s not much more expensive. The Suhner 60 grit zirconium flap wheel also works great and lasts 4 times as long. We also use Suhner 80 and 120 flap wheels, which do an adequate job.”

Worst Buy

Dutchman trailer

Donald Strick, Eckley, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“My Dutchman trailer is my worst buy. The brakes on it quit working before I could even drive 5 miles. The plumbing was faulty and pushed the bathroom wall out. I had to pull the trailer 150 miles to Denver to get it fixed. The floor squeaked and they told me to just put in more screws. Whenever it rained water would leak into the front room floor.”

Best Buy

Kubota KX121-3 excavator

Mike Barker, Humboldt, Tenn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“This is really a working machine. It does a lot more than I expected,” says Mike about his 2010 Kubota KX121-3 excavator. “I use it to clean fence rows and to install drainage pipe, as well as many other jobs. It’s easy on fuel.”

Best Buy

Rahn ballfield groomer + 1 more

Blaine Kalahar, Champlin, Minn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“I like my Rahn ballfield groomer (ph 800 298-1707; www.rahngroomer.com). It consists of a staggered series of steel street sweeper gutter brooms that are used to level dirt and dethatch grass. It can also be used to prepare the outfield grass for overseeding. It flexes when it hits an obstruction, allowing us to go right over the top of the bases in our ball field without disturbing them.” Mahindra 5500 2-WD tractor, which I also liked a lot.”

Best Buy

Kubota L-225 tractor

Art Spearman, Independence, La. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“In 1978 I bought a used 1976 Kubota L-225 tractor with 106 hrs. on it. I have a small acreage and used this little tractor to mow 3 acres and to tend a small garden. After I retired from oilfield work I started using it to rake and bale pine straw, averaging 15,000 to 20,000 bales per year for 14 years. Now it has more than 4,000 hrs. on it but has only needed replacement of a water pump, bearing, and seal.”

Worst Buy

U.S. Stove American Harvest pellet burner

James Tittle, Pembine, Wis. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“It’s a great stove as far as starting right up,” says James, who has nevertheless had problems with his 2005 U.S. Stove American Harvest pellet burner. “The company responds quickly to technical questions and provided a retro kit to upgrade to easier cleanout. However, I’ve burned out 2 motors at a cost of $139 apiece, and also had to replace 2 agitators. Now the computer is going out and will cost $339 to replace. I wouldn’t recommend this stove to anyone.”

Best Buy

Sea Foam motor treatment

Steve Kwiatkowski, Grand Rapids, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

Steve likes Sea Foam motor treatment for gas and diesel engines (ph 952 938-4811; www.seafoamsales.com). “It helps free sticky lifters and piston rings, helps remove fuel deposits and oil residue, and reduces pinging and rough idle. It also boosts octane in gas and helps start old, stubborn engines,” says Kwiatkowski. “I had 2 walk-behind

Best Buy

Chevrolet K2500 pickup equipped

Mathew J. Hart, Mayer, Minn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

Mathew nominates his 1994 Chevy K2500 pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter, turbocharged diesel engine as his “best buy”. “I bought it used with about 215,000 miles on it and have put another 30,000 miles on it. All I’ve had to replace is the starter. It has a low-geared manual transmission which gives me all the towing power I need. I love this truck.”

Best Buy

Battery Equalizer

Ross W. Keske, Crystal, Minn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“Two years ago I bought a bottle of Battery Equalizer just to see how it would work on a 12-year-old battery used with an electric-over-hydraulic lift (ph 877 656-0067; www.batteryequalizer.com). It brought the battery back to life and it’s now about 14 years old. Works great. The company says it can double the life of any vehicle’s battery by reversing the built-up sulphation that kills batteries as they get older. I just purchased 2 more bottles to use on my forklift.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 pickup equipped

Chuck Morris, Chondrant, La. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“It’s the best diesel pickup I’ve ever owned,” reports Chuck, who bought a used 1997 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter Power Stroke diesel engine. “It now has more than 220,000 miles on it but only uses one quart of oil between oil changes. It has a lot of power and torque and gets about 16 mpg.”

Best Buy

Fiat 500

James F. O’Neill, Las Animas, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“It’s a fun little car to drive,” says James about his Fiat 500. “I’m 6 ft. 4 in. tall, yet I have plenty of room in this car. The only down side so far is that the base model doesn’t have a spare tire – not even a small donut emergency tire. This car’s fuel economy has exceeded the EPA estimates, which is 34 mpg. Sometimes my son rides with me, and he’s 6 ft. 6 in. tall. The looks we get when we’re riding together cause both of us to chuckle.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 2454 riding mower

Roy Gray, Jr., Newsoms, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“My 2007 Husqvarna 2454 riding mower is one of the best mowers I’ve ever owned. I just put the first new battery in it. I use it to cut an acre of lawn once a week, and sometimes twice a week. It never fails to start right up. I’m 79 years old and have hip problems on both sides but I can still cut my grass.”

Best Buy

Graveley 2-wheeled tractor

Richard De Franco, Las Vegas, Nevada · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“It’s the best and most economical tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Richard about his Graveley 2-wheeled tractor (www.graveley.com). “I use it with a snowblower and 42-in. mower deck and have never had a problem. I loaned it to a friend, which was the worst thing I ever did because his barn burned to the ground with the tractor inside. I felt like I lost my best friend.”

Worst Buy

MacDon R80 discbine

Robert Schindler, Colfax, Wis. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

A MacDon R80 16-ft. discbine rates as Robert’s “worst buy”. “Before I bought this discbine I told the company sales rep that I farm hilly ground, and he assured me that this new machine would work on my hills just fine. Well, it doesn’t. The hydraulic drive system cavitates going up hill and as a result the machine won’t cut hay. The dealer has been out many times, along with other company reps. They’ve tried many things to solve the problem in the last 4 years, but nothing has helped. I use a 220 hp tractor to pull the machine, but even it sometimes doesn’t have enough power.

“The company has offered to buy it back at a fraction of what it’s worth. Looks like I’m going to take a big loss.”

Worst Buy

Bobcat Toolcat 5600

Chuck Bristol, Almont, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“I did my homework for 3 years and finally bought a Bobcat Toolcat 5600 to replace my loader tractor, forklift, and Deere Gator. The Toolcat is a handy machine, but in less than 2 years the hydraulic pump seals failed 6 different times. I was very disappointed. This machine turned out to be my worst buy in 40 years of farming.”

Best Buy

New Holland TN70A 4-WD tractor equipped + 2 more

Garen Reinking, Littleton, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“I like my 2006 New Holland TN70A 4-WD tractor equipped with a Bush Hog M446 front-end loader. This tractor starts instantly in cold weather. It’s fuel efficient and handles most tasks suited for a 70 hp tractor with ease. It’s a reliable unit.

“Last year I bought a ditcher made by General Utility at our local Deere dealer. This unit is made in China and uses soft hollow steel for the shank and shoe holder. After traveling 50 yards making a 9-in. deep ditch at a very slow speed, the shank was already bent. By the time I went 75 yards the shoe holder was bent. The machine had no warranty.”

Best Buy

Ferris zero turn riding + 1 more

John M. Gilbert, Boonville, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“My Ferris zero turn riding mower works great and reduces my mowing time by half (ph 800 933-6175; www.ferrisindustries.com). I have 75 Black Spruce trees on my property to go around. This mower handles that easily. It’s a great mower.

“My 1972 Cub Cadet riding mower is still going strong. I use it to mow more than 2 acres every week and couldn’t be happier with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Metabo angle grinder + 1 more

John Cotner, Falmouth, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“I like my Metabo 6-in. angle grinder with quick connect tool change (ph 877 619-5602; www.cpometabo.com). The wheels are easy to change, and it comes with an electronic soft start that’s easy on the body. This tool fits comfortably in my hands and has a good safety switch. I like it so much that I bought the company’s 4 1/2-in. grinder and a hammer drill, too. All these tools work great. They cost a little more money, but they’ll outlast me.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2008 Ford F-350 dually pickup equipped with a 6.4-liter diesel engine. “I bought this pickup used in 2010 with low miles. The transmission immediately started to shift rough and would ‘hammer’ into gear when turning corners. The dealer said this was normal, part of the fuel efficiency system. The problem would clear for a month or so each time they reprogrammed the computer. Another problem was that the exhaust filter shut down which stalled the pickup on the highway. I’ve owned Fords all my life, but this is the third Ford lemon I’ve had in a row and will be my last.”

Worst Buy

Ford Expedition SUV equipped

Michael Cumston, Priest River, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

Michael’s disappointed with his 2005 Ford Expedition SUV equipped with a 5.4-liter engine. “The center seat/armrest metal broke at the hinge, the rear flashers blow fuses, and water ran into the rear hatch and caused the rear wipers to short out.

“Soon after I bought this vehicle the brake shoes broke, and then at 1,079 miles the engine blew up when a valve embedded inside a piston. On the replacement engine, the spark plugs fouled out constantly and cost $12 apiece to replace and $200 for labor. The fuel injectors malfunctioned and even though there was a company recall on them, they said I had put 15 miles too many on my vehicle so I had to pay. The rig’s 2 catalytic converters went bad and cost $1,000 apiece to replace. Another problem is that water and sand get into the spark plug hole through rubber seals and cause the engine to misfire. This SUV is a $41,000 piece of junk.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 576XP

Jeff Bond, Anaconda, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“I log trees at an elevation of 8,000 ft. here in the mountains so I need a powerful saw. My 2010 Husqvarna 576XP always starts even when it’s below zero. The 28-in. bar is long enough to take down most trees and lets me limb them without bending over.”

Best Buy

McCormick XTX 145 front wheel assist

Tom Jurenka, Hingham, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

Tom’s impressed with his 2010 McCormick XTX 145 front wheel assist tractor equipped with an L175 front-end loader with grapple fork. “I put 550 hrs. on this tractor moving round bales and pulling a field sprayer equipped with a 1,500-gal. tank and 100-ft. boom. This tractor is easy to operate and the controls are well placed. I especially like the finger tip shift control and how it shifts smoothly up or down. A hydraulic hose failed but was replaced under warranty. Also, there was a factory recall of a computer control. Otherwise, this tractor has worked great.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kaito Voyager dynamo + 1 more

Richard Green, King Ferry, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

“I like my Kaito Voyager dynamo and solar-powered radio with short wave and AM FM as well as NOAA weather bands (ph 866 524-8676; www.kaitousa.com). I have a collection that includes about 38 various radios, but this little unit is the best. It sells on the company website for $69.95, but I bought mine from Sportsman Guide for $49.97 (www.sportsmansguide.com). Fortunately this radio doesn’t have digital tuning. It’s really designed for sane, simple use and runs for hours when the charge mode is used. It’s also battery, solar and AC-powered. I really like it.

“The bar-mounted chainsaw sharpener I bought at Northern Tool is my worst buy. The owner’s manual doesn’t come with instructions on how to set up and use this product. I made 13 different phone calls to the company’s customer service department and spoke with many ‘supervisors’ in customer service, two of whom hung up on me. I finally received an envelope with written instructions for the product’s use.”

Worst Buy

Rataway Fragrance

Lee Roy Nix, Mountainair, New Mexico · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Lee Roy’s disappointed with Rataway Fragrance. “Rats, mice, squirrels, and even rabbits were getting into the engine compartment of my motorhome. You’re supposed to dilute this product with a gallon of distilled water and spray it on surfaces such as wiring, engines and other parts of vehicles. However, after using it as instructed over a period of 4 months, I haven’t noticed any decrease in rodent activity whatsoever. I’m totally dissatisfied with this product.”

Best Buy

SealLube seal expander

Bob Sokoly, Wyckoff, N.J. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Bob’s impressed with SealLube seal expander, which is designed to stop rubber oil seal leaks in engines, transmissions, power steering and hydraulic systems (ph 800 434-9192; www.seallube.com). An 8-oz. bottle treats up to 10 quarts of oil.

“I bought it because I own a 1952 Massey Harris tractor that had a leaky hydraulic pump. I mixed a bottle of SealLube in with the hydraulic oil, and within a half hour the leak stopped and it hasn’t leaked since. I’d recommend this product to anyone.”

Best Buy

John Deere LX 280

Tommy Nelson, Crawfordsville, Ore. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“It wasn’t cheap, but it’s the best riding mower I’ve ever used,” says Tommy about his 2006 Deere LX 280. “I recently went back to the dealer and had all new belts put on it for the first time.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 18-volt impact wrench

John Kennedy, Seligman, Ariz. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

John’s the satisfied owner of a 2011 DeWalt 18-volt impact wrench. “I use this wrench on anything with big bolts and to remove nuts when changing tires. I like it because I don’t need an air hose or compressor and because it’s easy to take to remote locations. It has a lot of power as long as you have a good battery.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5225 MFWD tractor equipped + 2 more

R.D. Marsh, Salem, Ore. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

He likes his 2006 Deere 5225 MFWD tractor equipped with a cab, power reverser transmission, and front-end loader. “Deere made a winner when they came out with their 25 series tractors. This tractor has a quiet cab, is comfortable, and has adequate power. If you don’t overload or abuse it it’ll provide excellent service. I also own a Deere 5525 model that works great. Both tractors are built rugged, as are the 500 and 600 series front-end loaders that I use with them.

“My 2003 Dodge 1-ton longbed pickup equipped with a 4-door cab, High Output Cummins diesel engine, and 6-speed manual transmission is a best buy. It rides and drives wonderfully. No problems. We added a K&N air filter kit which we’re quite happy with (ph 800 858-3333; www.knfilters.com). This pickup is the best hauler I’ve ever driven. I’ve owned several Fords and GM pickups over the years, but my Dodge has a lot of power and will walk away from them. There’s a reason you see so many Dodge pickups pulling livestock trailers, fifth wheel rigs, and machinery trailers, etc. on the road. It gets 18 to 21 mpg empty and 14 to 16 mpg towing a heavy load, which I think is pretty good.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Milwaukee 18-volt cordless tools + 1 more

Dean Powell, Kent, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“I like my Milwaukee 18-volt cordless tools and the batteries that power them. Ever since the company replaced 14 different batteries on my cordless tools because of a recall, not one battery has died. Altogether I have more than 24 Milwaukee tools and like all of them. I seldom buy another brand.

“My 1999 International 4700 single axle truck equipped with a 444 cu. in. engine lacks power. This truck has only about 17,000 miles on it but has had many problems. First the fan thermostat quit working which caused the engine to overheat. Then the instrument panel quit working and cost $800 to fix. I only drive this truck when necessary in order to avoid more repairs. The overhead bin for papers doesn’t work – what ever happened to glove compartments? I also had to replace the starter.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 crewcab pickup equipped

M. Bogden, Corbett, Ore · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“No problems with my 2004 Ford F-350 crewcab pickup equipped with a diesel engine and manual transmission. We love not having an automatic transmission. This pickup hauls whatever we need and the ride is comfortable.

“Our worst buy is ethanol. We live in the boonies so we have to stock up on gas, and in order to store the gas we have to add a conditioner to it. That helps keep the gas stable but if we don’t have a bottle of the conditioner around, the gas goes bad and is only good for burning brush.”

Best Buy

Byers tilt-a-hitch + 1 more

Kevin Holland, Sandy, Utah · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Kevin likes his Byers Tilt-A-Hitch (ph 618 616-1790; www.tiltahitch.com). “It’s really handy for loading tractors, antique cars or riding mowers onto a flatbed trailer with short 5-ft. long ramps. By pulling a pin, you can stay hitched to your pickup while you crank the front end up with the trailer jack. Lets you tip the back end to the ground.”

He’s impressed with his 2000 Port-A-Cool shop-style, portable evaporative cooling unit (ph 800 695-2942; www.port-a-cool.com). “I just aim it where I’m working-under a tractor or car or in the yard. It hooks up to a garden hose and has a float-type shut-off, or you can pour a couple of buckets of water in the fill area on back of the unit. It only works in areas with low humidity.”

Best Buy

Kioti tractor equipped

Richard Albrandt, Sterling, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“My 2010 Kioti tractor equipped with a front-end loader is dependable and easy to maneuver around trees and buildings. No problems. I often use it with a 3-pt. mounted rototiller. The only downside is that it starts hard in cold weather.”

Best Buy

Ford tractors + 1 more

Raymond Karwoski, Bath, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“I like my two Ford tractors -a 1947 2N and a 1951 8N. I bought both used; the 2N in 1964 and the 8N in 1968. Both have been dependable and required only routine maintenance over all our years of use.

“My 2004 Cub Cadet 1022 garden tractor has caused more trouble in 8 years than the Deere 112L garden tractor I bought new in 1985 and retired in 2003.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota pickup equipped

J.D. Lyall, Tonkawa, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

J.D. is satisfied with his 2008 Dodge Dakota pickup equipped with a 3.7-liter 6-cyl. engine. “I downsized pickups after selling my cattle because I no longer had a trailer to pull. This little utility pickup runs good and suits me fine. No problems after 40,000 miles. It isn’t as fuel efficient as advertised, but it still burns less fuel than my larger Dodge Ram 1500.”

Best Buy

Ford 1715 tractors + 1 more

Robert Draginis, Navarre, Fla. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

“Two years ago I bought a pair of used Ford 1715 tractors, which I think are the best tractors ever built. They’ll run all day on just a little fuel, and they’re easy to work on.

“My Chinese-built Kama tractor is poorly built. There are loose bolts everywhere, and the warranty is no good.”

Best Buy

New Holland 50/50 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Donald Brown, Amissville, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Donald’s happy with his 2009 New Holland 50/50 4-WD tractor equipped with a floor shuttle transmission. “It’s a dependable, well-built tractor with a good view from the cab and simple features. At times the brakes make a loud rubbing noise, but I can live with that.

“My New Holland TN 60D 4-WD tractor has a left hand shuttle that goes into gear only when it wants to, which makes it a real nuisance. It once left me stranded in the middle of the road. I’ve spent about $2,000 at my dealer trying to solve the problem but nothing has helped. Also, the tractor doesn’t have enough road speed and power. If you want to do anything other than work a garden, this tractor is underpowered.”

Best Buy

Stihl MS250 chainsaw equipped

Matt Stewart, Seabeck, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Matt’s satisfied with his 2010 Stihl MS250 chainsaw equipped with a 2.77 cu. in. engine and 18-in. bar. “I heat my house primarily with wood and this saw has performed flawlessly. It has plenty of power for big jobs, and the 18-in. bar handles big logs just fine. It also works great for light duty trimming due to its light weight. This is my second Stihl saw, and I’ll definitely buy another one when the time comes.”

Best Buy

Kohler propane-powered generator equipped

Herbert D. Thompson, Creston, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 14

Herbert’s impressed with his 2012 6,000-kw Kohler propane-powered generator equipped with automatic start and stop. “I bought it because my wife has coronary obstructive pulmonary disease and requires oxygen 24 hours a day. This unit will instantly supply power when the electricity fails. It has worked beautifully when we’ve needed it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Troy-Bilt Mustang zero turn riding + 1 more

James Buckman, Charlotte Hall, Md. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I like my 2010 Troy-Bilt Mustang zero turn riding mower equipped with a Kohler 22 hp, V-twin engine and 50-in. deck. It’s comfortable and handles like a dream, and it starts easy. The safety features on it are just right, and it’s easy to maintain.”

He isn’t happy with his 2005 Rockwood travel trailer. “I’ve tried everything to keep the roof from leaking, but the only thing that works is to park the trailer on a tilt. The bathroom has no leg room, and the floor plan is poor.”

Best Buy

Arctic Cat 366 ATV

Wayne Gadow, Colville, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I use my 2010 Arctic Cat 366 ATV to plow snow off my 1/4-mile driveway. It works a lot faster than my Branson 3510 tractor, although that has been a great small farm tractor. The Arctic Cat has a lot of power and traction so I haven’t had to use tire chains. This machine purrs like a kitten in the dairy section of a grocery store.”

Best Buy

JCB 1110 skid loader

Denny Steckelberg, Coillette, Wyo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I love my 2002 JCB 1110 skid loader. It’s equipped with a side access door which makes it easy to get in and out of the cab, and is handy if you need to get out with the bucket raised a little. It’s powered by an 82 hp turbocharged Perkins engine, which works great. I never run out of power, just traction sometimes. No mechanical problems. Great machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota L3200 4-WD tractor + 1 more

Lee L’Heureux, Aztec, N. Mex. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

A 2011 Kubota L3200 4-WD tractor rates as Lee’s “best buy”. “I had some Russian olive trees on my place that needed to be removed. The Kubota outworked my Massey Ferguson 65 tractor in lifting and pulling the trees out of the ground. Some of the credit goes to the 4-WD.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2008 Dodge 2300 2-WD pickup. “When I’m driving and have to take my foot off the gas pedal and then step on it again, the vehicle shutters and jerks. I’ve been to the dealer 8 or 10 times. They tell me the problem is due to carbon buildup, and that I should drive the pickup up and down a steep hill at 80 mph to blow the soot out. There has to be a better way.”

Best Buy

Bad Boy zero turn riding

Otto L. Holley, Blanchard, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I like my 2008 Bad Boy zero turn riding mower powered by a 26 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. It has a good, heavy steel deck that’s stronger than the decks on most bush hog mowers. It doesn’t have a lot of extras and everything on it is easily accessible. I really like the Briggs & Stratton engine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere D110 riding mower + 1 more

Jeff Howard, Malta, Mont · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“My 2011 Deere D110 riding mower runs fine and does a great job cutting my lawn.

“The pipe threaders I bought at Northern Tools are my worst buy. I needed a cheap set of pipe threaders to keep in my truck for repairs around the ranch. I really wasn’t expecting too much. However, the 1-in. die chipped on the first use and the 1 1/4 and 2-in. dies left very rough threads. I should have spent more and bought Rigid pipe threaders.”

Best Buy

Challenger RB45 round baler

James Keiper, Little Falls, Wyo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“It’s the simplest, best-built baler I’ve ever used,” says James about his 2004 Challenger RB45 round baler. “Everything on it is made in the U.S., and there are no bells or whistles-just quality construction. No problems. We’ll buy another if this one ever wears out.”

Worst Buy

Red Wing insulated logger boots

Joseph E. Bruggeman, Taberg, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Joseph likes the 6 1/2 hp OHV horizontal shaft motor on his Harbor Freight wood splitter, for which he paid $99.99 plus tax. “I can start the motor with no more than 2 pulls and it’ll run all day on 1 1/2 to 2 tanks of gas, depending on how fast I set the throttle. I increase the engine rpm’s on bigger blocks of wood, but normally 3/4 throttle is all it needs.

“I’m not happy with the Red Wing insulated logger boots I bought 3 1/2 years ago. I’ve worn Red Wing logger boots for 30 years, but the last 2 pairs were bad. The laces lasted only 2 to 3 months and then I had to go back to buy more. The shoe’s eyelets chew the laces up. The boots cost more than $200 a pair, which I think is too much. I recently bought a pair of Carolina logger boots at a discount for only $85.”

Best Buy

Wenz range shift kit

Francis E. Hanna, Lowville, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“The Wenz range shift kit we bought for our Case IH 886 tractor 4 years ago makes the tractor shift easier and with more precision (ph 800 808-7885; www.ihdisgusted.com). We bought the kit because the tractor wouldn’t shift into the right gear or would lock up, which made it dangerous to use, especially in park and reverse. This kit corrected those problems and we’re well pleased with it. I’d recommend it to any 86 series tractor owner.”

Best Buy

Haulmark enclosed trailer

Vincent Smith, Trout Creek, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Vincent’s disappointed with his 16-ft. Haulmark enclosed trailer. “The spring shackles were positioned opposite on each axle, and as a result only one axle supported the trailer’s weight. The electric brake tabs were bent up against the backing plates, so only the axle without weight on it had brakes. Another problem was the roof construction-at least 28 different screws missed the roof’s support beams. A very poorly built trailer.”

Best Buy

Ferguson TO-30 tractor

Kenneth Bedell, Naselle, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“My 1953 Ferguson TO-30 tractor is still in original condition and is my best buy. I inherited this tractor along with a Bush Hog mower and use it to maintain my property and to mow fields for my neighbors. It still runs great and is fuel efficient. It’s almost 60 years old, yet it always starts right up and does whatever I ask it to do.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

White 2-135 tractor + 1 more

Rupert Theuerer, Spring Valley, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I had good luck with a 1981 White 2-135 tractor I bought used in 2000, so when a neighbor sold his farm 3 years ago I bought his White 2-155 with about 8,000 hrs. on it. I use this tractor mostly to pull a 1,500-gal., 120-ft. field sprayer up and down our hilly fields at speeds up to 9 mph. I can easily spray 100 acres per hour. Both tractors have required only routine maintenance.

“My Sears Craftsman tools are worst buys. This company used to build fair value tools, but not any more. For example, their punches break easily. I no longer buy from them and instead buy professional tools. They cost more up front, but they last.”

Worst Buy

Dandelion Dobber

Gilbert Carter, Belgrade, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Gilbert’s disappointed with his 2011 Dandelion Dobber that’s designed to apply weed killer to dandelions. “It’s supposed to treat individual weeds by dabbing on a small amount of liquid weed killer. It consists of a 4 1/2-ft. long, 3/4-in. dia. pipe with a spring-loaded pump at the bottom end. To use it, you simply press the Dobber down over a weed to release some chemical. However, after treating about a half dozen plants the plunger on the activating rod bent, causing it to leak.”

Worst Buy

Cub Cadet vacuum mulcher

Fred Swartz, Penn. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“This is absolutely the worst product I’ve ever purchased – bar none,” says Fred about his 2010 Cub Cadet vacuum mulcher. “The engine is almost impossible to start. I bought this machine at Home Depot but they washed their hands of the matter, saying I would have to go to Cub Cadet. But the company didn’t respond to my warranty request and told me to take the machine 25 miles away to get it repaired. Instead, I bought the parts and repaired it myself. However, it still doesn’t work well.

“This product is heavy, ungainly and just a pain to work with. I definitely won’t buy a Cub Cadet product again. And no longer will I go to a box store to purchase power equipment. How any company could take a quality name like Cub Cadet from the 60’s and 70’s and make it this bad is beyond me.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5325 MFWD tractor

Robert E. Whitehead, Kiowa, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I like my 2008 Deere 5325 MFWD tractor. It’s equipped with a 553 front-end loader, 24-speed shuttle transmission and a fully equipped cab. I really like the quick-tach bucket. I bought a bale spear and pallet forks for the loader, and I can change from one to the other in less than 5 min. The engine runs smooth but is somewhat noisy.”

Best Buy

Kubota GR2120-54 4-WD riding mower

Ken Spiering, Valleyford, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Ken nominates his 2012 diesel-powered Kubota GR2120-54 4-WD riding mower as “best buy”. “I live on a hill and have to mow 3 1/2 acres every week, and this mower performs flawlessly. It has a wide wheelbase and is heavy enough to make it stable even when running sideways on fairly steep slopes. It cuts evenly and is well designed with commercial grade construction. It almost has a zero turning radius.

“Another thing I like is that it has positive hydrostatic drive so the tractor stops when the foot pedal is returned to neutral, even when I’m headed downhill. The 4-WD allows the mower to go up and down hills without slipping and without binding on tight turns. It’s truly a dream machine.”

Best Buy

Argo Conquest off-road amphibious

Reinhard Grenz, Trapper Creek, Alaska · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“The Argo Conquest off-road amphibious ATV I bought in 2002 still performs like new. I’ve taken it over some really rough trails but it has never failed me. Doesn’t matter if I go through snow, swamps, or open water, it’s unstoppable. My friend would like to buy it, but I’m not sure I can sell it.”

Best Buy

Jinma 284

Marc Perkins, Star City, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“My Jinma 284 is a great little tractor. It’s like buying a new tractor with 30-year-old technology. Maybe it’s not as good as some other brands, but it’s at least 3/4 as good for 1/3 the cost. For lighter work it holds up fine, and it’s extremely fuel efficient.”

Best Buy

Sherrill replacement blades

Doug Creswell, Mount Airy, Md. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Doug likes the Sherrill replacement blades he bought for his extendable pole saw (ph 800 525-8873; www.Sherrilltree.com). “I have a lot of old apple trees that needed pruning. Limbs – some quite large – were too high to risk using a chainsaw. The original blade on my extendable pole saw was struggling to do the work, and I’m 77 years old and need all the help I can get. I got on the internet and found Sherrilltree.com in Greensboro, North Carolina. They had the best selection of replacement blades I could find. I bought their 12-in. ARS Razor-Sharp Tooth with Gullets. I tried it and it works great. It did twice the work in half the time and with much less effort.”

Best Buy

Agri-Services wiring harness specialists

John R. Linton, Westminster, Md. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I’m pleased with the wiring harness I bought for my IH 404 tractor from Agri-Services wiring harness specialists (ph 716 937-6618; www.wiringharnesses.com). I saw their advertisement in Tractor Shop magazine. After I was quoted a price the harness came in the mail and it fit perfectly.”