Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009)

78 reports from pages 12–15 · 71 Best Buys14 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Reese drum mower + 1 more

Steve Rodgers, Wellman, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

“Last year I bought a 1988 Reese 6-ft. 9-in. drum mower. I had been frustrated with my sickle mower which tended to plug up, especially in thick stands of legumes. I wanted something faster and more reliable with faster drydown. I couldn’t justify a mower-conditioner but I was impressed with the speed of disc mowers. I observed, however, that disc mowers often have expensive drivetrain issues with bearings, gears, shafts, and leaky seals. With limited time and a tight budget, I want to be mowing and not fixing.

“The Reese mower has a simple belt drive. I was able to easily rebuild my machine with new belts, knives and common-size bearings at a reasonable cost. I also bought a new windrow spreader attachment through Tigerco, the Reese distributor, and like how it spreads mowed hay for faster drying (ph 800 432-4020; www.tigercoinc.com). The drum mower lets me mow at high speeds without plugging up, even in tough conditions.

“I worked for more than 12 years as an agricultural engineer designing farm machinery, and I can honestly say the Reese drum mower is among the most well thought-out, well constructed farm machines I’ve ever seen. My only regret is that I didn’t buy one much sooner.”

Best Buy

Jitterbug cell phone

P. J. Ranck, Heath, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

“My Jitterbug cell phone is my best buy. My wife has a Verizon phone and contract and we thought it was time that I had a cell phone, thinking I could get on her hours for very little cost. Not so. We found the Jitterbug, and pay only $15 a month with all the minutes I need. Even better than the price is the simplicity of the phone’s operation. Also, it has better coverage than Verizon.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 Lariat Supercrew pickup

Mike Knodell, Fisk, Mo. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

David’s impressed with his 2005 Ford F-150 Lariat Supercrew pickup. “Three years, 98,000 miles, and no repairs of any kind. The 5.4-liter engine is by far the smoothest engine I’ve ever owned and has plenty of torque at any rpm’s. The cab is so much quieter than the competition that it’s almost embarrassing. The engineering and quality of this vehicle is outstanding.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 dually flatbed pickup

Bill Zalesky, Wilber, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

He likes his 1997 Dodge 3500 dually flatbed pickup equipped with a diesel engine and 5-speed transmission. “I bought this pickup used with about 200,000 miles on it. I put it through an oil analysis program, and every time I have the oil changed they tell me to add 500 miles onto the next oil change interval. Now I’m up to changing the oil every 9,500 miles but it still doesn’t use any oil. This pickup does more than I ever imagined.”

On the “worst buy” list is “anything that’s made in China. If it’s electrical, it burns out. If it’s metal, it stretches, bends, or breaks after only one or two uses. I won’t buy China-made products any more. My last experience was with a no. 50 sprocket on my silage cutter. It took two hours to take the sprocket apart, and 1 1/2 hours to put it back together. Then all the teeth on the sprocket bent back after only two hours of use. I was fit to be tied.”

Best Buy

Polaris MV7 ATV handles great

Randall D. Brooks, Peterstown, W. Va. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

“My 2005 Polaris MV7 ATV handles great. It’s a military issue model that was sold to the public for one year. It has two fuel tanks, a winch on front and back, a 2-in. receiver hitch, and armored steel on the bottom and sides. It weighs about 1,200 lbs. and has handled anything that I hook onto it.”

Best Buy

White MTD 27-ton vertical/horizontal log splitter

Terry Saxton, Beaver Island, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

“My White MTD 27-ton vertical/horizontal log splitter with a 5 1/2 hp Tecumseh engine is my best buy. It starts winter or summer with just one pull. One time an exhaust valve stuck after I had put three tablespoons full of Slick 50 in the motor oil. I drained the oil and replaced it with fresh oil, which solved the problem. No more Slick 50 for me.”

Best Buy

Kubota ZD28 zero turn riding

Brandon Pletcher, Pierceton, Ind. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

“We like our two Kubota ZD28 zero turn riding mowers, which are both equipped with 28 hp diesel engines. One is a 2002 model with a 60-in. deck. It runs and starts right up with heat glow plugs and does a great job of mowing. It has required very few repairs, with the worst being a clogged fuel filter and a new battery. The 2006 model has a 72-in. deck with a fiberglass canopy and it works great, too. Both models are fuel efficient with minimal vibration. They just keep on going and hold their battery life, even through winter storage.”

Best Buy

Kubota 8450 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Harold A. Sprague, Whitingham, Ver-mont · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

A Kubota 8450 4-WD tractor equipped with a 12-speed transmission rates as Harold’s “best buy”. “I’m surprised at how easily it starts. I do wish there was a little less difference in speed between the transmission’s high and low ranges. This tractor is easy on fuel.

“My 1985 Ford 5610 4-WD tractor has only about 2,100 hours on it but has a noisy rear end and the front-end shimmies badly.”

Best Buy

Johnson Drainage Plow

Jeff Kohlnhofer, Lakeville, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 12

Jeff and his brothers at Kohlnhofer Farms are well-pleased with their Johnson Drainage Plow - a do-it-yourself, tractor-pulled tile plow (ph 319 885-4496; www.johnson drainageplows.com). “This thing is a beast. After five years and more than 50 miles of tile, it still looks like new. We used it early this spring and it pulled big chunks of frost out of the ground without missing a beat. Last year alone we put in 20 miles of tile, pulling the plow with our Deere 9420 tractor.

“We did a lot of research before buying this plow. When I compared the amount of steel in this plow to other plows, there was no comparison. And there’s not an ounce of wear on it at this point.

“We don’t use a laser leveler. In fact, everything we know about tiling we learned from Johnson Drainage Plow when we bought the plow. We use 4 and 5-in. dia. tile in our heavy clay soil.

“This spring, for the first time, we did a custom job with the plow. Our neighbor had a quote of $15,000 for about 12,000 ft. of tile. We did the job for about 40 percent less and everyone was happy. We finished the job in about 10 hours.”

Best Buy

CobraHead weeder

Wendy Wellnitz, Lanesboro, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“We found the CobraHead weeder at a farm show (ph 608 423-9119; www.cobrahead.com). It turned out to be the best weeding tool I’ve ever used. The design is based on an old push cultivator tine, but modified with a diamond shape steel tip.

“When you set the tip behind a weed or weed clump and pull on the handle, the tip slips into the soil and under the root mass with hardly any pressure. Pull up a little, and the weed clump pops out.

“It works great for breaking up soil clumps and loosening the soil before transplanting, too. It’s like a mini-plow, but works great with a chopping action as well. If you can’t find it at a store, you can order it online at www.cobrahead.com. It’s not cheap at $24.95 but it’s worth it.”

Best Buy

Mil-waukee 7 1/2-in circular saw

Emil E. Smith, Franklin, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My Mil-waukee 7 1/2-in. circular saw is quiet and powerful. I’ve used it to build a cabin and also have done a lot of roofing work with it. It has so much power I can hardly slow it down. Before I bought it I used a Skil circular saw, which was so loud I had to use ear muffs. Also, it didn’t have nearly as much power. This saw can rip through an old plank like nothing. All my shop tools are made by Milwaukee.”

Best Buy

Nitron fertilizer + 1 more

Jeffery Goss, Jr., Springfield, Mo. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“I like Nitron fertilizer. It’s natural, non-synthetic, and priced economically.”

A 2007 electric-operated Weed Eater rates as Jeffery’s “worst buy”. “This machine caused trouble from the beginning. The machine kept losing its head and had to be re-threaded. It also used up a lot of line, and sometimes it would chew up the line for no apparent reason. Within a week we took it back for a refund.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3410 4WD tractor equipped

Mike McCullough, Missoula, Montana · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“It works perfect for my small horse boarding operation,” says Mike, happy with his 2002 Kubota L3410 4WD tractor equipped with an HST 35 hp, 3-cyl. diesel engine. “I’ve put more than 900 hours on it with almost no problems. I use it with a front-end loader with a quick-tach, 9-ft. backhoe equipped with subframe, rock rake, grader spreader, hydraulic-operated post pounder, scraper blade and more. All these units can be mounted either on the tractor’s 3-pt. or loader. This tractor is always ready to take on the toughest jobs. I have my dealer service it on a 100-hour schedule, and I change the oil and filter on a 50-hour schedule. I grease the joints every 10 to 15 hours of operation.”

Best Buy

Farmall Cub tractor

Bill Gregor, Lawton, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 1948 Farmall Cub tractor is a best buy. During the winter I use it almost every day in the woods, pushing snow while using chains on the tires. I also use it to cut hay. I put a new clutch in it about 30 years ago, but the engine has never been overhauled.”

Best Buy

International Harvester Farmall 560 tractor equipped

Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My best buy is an IH Farmall 560 tractor equipped with an F-11 front-end loader. My dad bought it new in 1958. The first six years this tractor was used for field work. Since then it has been used primarily for loader work, cleaning barns, and moving snow. We use it every day during winter to feed livestock, and it has always been a good starting, reliable tractor. I wish it was new again.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller

Cliff Wendricks, Keyser, W. Va. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 2007 Mantis rototiller has exceeded my expectations. The ground where I set up my garden was rocky but this little tiller was able to work through it. One of the teeth broke but the company covered it under warranty. I had a new part in about 1 1/2 weeks.”

Best Buy

Case IH MXM 130

David Stromberger, Windsor, Colo. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“In 2005 I traded in two, tried and true IH tractors for a new 2004 Case IH MXM 130. It developed electrical problems at 80 hours and always had trouble starting. So I traded for a new 2006 MXM 130 model. It made it to 160 hours before it developed the same electrical problems. Both tractors were equipped with semi powershift transmissions. I’d put the tractor in gear and sometimes it would move, and other times it would flash an error code and refuse to move. The dealer put 50 hours into diagnosing the problem. He finally got it fixed but couldn’t say for sure what the problem was. So I got rid of that tractor, too.”

Best Buy

Ford Escort LX equipped

Ned Edelen, Bryantown, Md. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“It’s the best car I’ve ever owned,” says Ned about his 1998 Ford Escort LX equipped with a 2-liter engine and 5-speed manual transmission. “This car has more than 386,000 miles and consistently gets 40 mpg. The tires on it have averaged 115,000 miles. The water pump lasted 375,000 miles. It still has the original clutch and exhaust system. There’s no body rust and only minor dents from hitting two deer, one of which was a 6-point buck that flipped onto the roof. The only parts that have failed were the harmonic balancer and the alternator. I change the oil at 8,000-mile intervals. I expect this car to make it to 500,000 miles.”

Best Buy

Zoller pumps

Robert Szabo, Westland, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“I bought Zoller pumps to use in a small fish pond. The box the pump comes in says it’s okay to operate the pump for 4,000 continuous hours, but when I got the pumps home and took them out of the box, the instructions said ‘don’t use continuously’. These pumps don’t last and are unrepairable. The company wouldn’t help.”

Best Buy

Bellsaw M-14 circular sawmill + 1 more

Paul Rairdon, Clearbrook, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

Last fall Paul bought a used Bellsaw M-14 circular sawmill made in the early 1990’s and mounted it on a 40-ft. schoolbus frame. An Allis Chalmers WC tractor supplies the power. “It easily handles 16-ft. logs. Not bad for the $1,200 I paid for it.

“The General Electric automatic coffee maker I bought at Wal-Mart was an expensive, programmable unit that lasted only two months. For some reason this unit had to be delimed with white vinegar every two to four days just to keep it working.”

Best Buy

Miller Trailblazer portable welder-generator

Greg Reif, Claflin, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 2008 Miller Trailblazer portable welder-generator has far exceeded my expectations. I use it in my welding business where I build custom cattle facilities and make repairs to farm equipment. This welder-generator has an infinite heat range adjustment so I can use it to do all types of stick welding. It’s the only machine I know of with two generators - one for welding and one for powering grinders and other tools. I use it every day. It’ll run about 16 hours on 12 gallons of gas. I’ve owned three other portable welder-generators, but this one is by far the best.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2320 4-WD compact tractor

Jason Lyon, Roblin, Manitoba · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“It’s a nimble little tractor that has surprised me many times with its performance,” says Jason about his 2007 Deere 2320 4-WD compact tractor. “It’s powered by a 24 hp, 3-cyl. Yanmar diesel engine, which has plenty of torque and is easy on fuel. The 4-WD is easy to engage and has gotten me out of more jams than I can remember, especially when I’m using my 3-pt. mounted snowblower. I use it with a 62-in. drive-over mower deck, which is easy to install and does a flawless job of mowing grass whether it’s wet or dry.

“If I want I can use the tractor’s twin-touch hydrostatic pedals at the same as the individual wheel brakes, since they’re on opposite sides. I’ve used other brands of compact tractors where the pedals are all on the same side. It only works to use them when using cruise control. Deere was definitely thinking when they designed this tractor. I know it’s only a Yanmar in Deere skin, but it’s worthy of the Deere badge.”

Best Buy

Sonic Mole repellers

J. N. Cole, Ottawa, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“In 2007 I bought five Sonic Mole repellers from Northern Tool for $16.99 apiece. I was doubtful if they’d work, but within two weeks the moles packed up and moved. However, this product appears to be good for just one season. The O-ring seal would not keep moisture out so a lot of corrosion developed around the batteries. I plan to order more units and waterproof them myself.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

BCS 10 hp rototiller + 1 more

Doug Fedderke, Defiance, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 1975 BCS 10 hp rototiller is my best buy. I bought it used from my brother’s father-in-law. It sat outside for years. All I did was change the oil, spark plug, and filters and it always fires right up. I like being able to change implements on it. I’d definitely buy another one.

“My Sears Craftsman LT1000 17 hp riding mower is my worst buy. It’s on its third transmission and has been a pain from the start. When I let off the clutch I can pop a wheelie in sixth gear. I wouldn’t recommend this mower to anyone.”

Best Buy

DR cutter

Stephen Charles, Seneca, S. C. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

Stephen likes his DR cutter. “I already own an original DR cutter but this new version is a Cadillac compared to the original. It has three forward speeds, big balloon tires, and electric start. It’s one tough machine. I loan out my original model to folks who want to clear off bushes, but I keep this new one at home.”

Best Buy

Stihl BG85 blower

Chuck Hodel, Eureka, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“A few years ago I bought a used Stihl BG85 blower. It starts easy and has a lot of velocity. We use it to blow material off our driveway, grass off our batwing mower, and trash off our combine. It’s a handy tool.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman lawn tractor equipped

Jack B. Elliott, Florence, Ontario · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“My 1999 Sears Craftsman lawn tractor equipped with a 20.5 hp, 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton engine and 42-in. mower deck came with an extended warranty. The company replaced blades and belts as required, changed the oil, replaced a faulty carburetor, and replaced the batteries at no charge during warranty. I use it to cut at least one acre of lawn around farm buildings and to mow down tall weeds and small brush in the surrounding area. Over the years I’ve used about six different riding mowers, but this is by far the best one.”

Best Buy

Aeroller lawn aerator attachment

J. R. Sheehan, Collierville, Tenn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 13

“I used an Aeroller lawn aerator attachment kit to convert my front-end tine rototiller to a yard aerator and really like it (ph 316 519-2168; www.lawn-aerator-attachment.com). I used to rent a yard aerator once or twice a year so this kit paid for itself in one use. The aerator’s hollow core aerator tines make up to 3-in. deep holes in the lawn to pull soil cores. The rollers are made of solid cast iron, which adds about 40 lbs. to the tiller to achieve deeper aeration in heavy clay soil. The rollers also prevent excessive tine penetration in soft soil to keep from tearing up my lawn.”

Best Buy

Sears Recently

Al Hoffmeyer, Grass Valley, Calif. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“Last year I bought an 18-volt drill at Sears. Recently the batteries stopped charging fully.

“I took the drill to a local Sears store but they wouldn’t work on it and they don’t sell the charger by itself. So I took the charger apart, and wired the terminals to a small 18-volt toy charger module. Bingo, the batteries were back up to full charge.”

Worst Buy

Staber clothes washing machine

Horeb, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“After reading about the Staber clothes washing machine in FARM SHOW, I started saving up for one because my old washing machine had quit working. There have been both positive and negative reports on this machine in FARM SHOW, but I bought one anyway (ph 800 848-6200; www.staber.com).

“Well, this machine kicks butt. I just finished doing a really big backlog of laundry with no problems. The machine uses very little soap, and I can fill it up full. There’s no destructive agitator, and it’s easy to set up. The machine is made from the highest gauge materials. I’ve used it to wash lined pants full of ‘dairy-air’, Carhart coats, insulated coveralls, and cement choked trousers, and all of them came out clean. No redo’s were necessary.

“The machine’s spin is intense so it has to be set exactly level on a solid floor. It’s a heavy machine, and getting it down the stairs was harder than getting the old machine up and out.”

Worst Buy

McCormick C100 tractor equipped

David Ourada, Lucan, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“My 2005 McCormick C100 tractor equipped with an L750 front-end loader is my worst buy. I bought it to do cattle chores. I ordered it with the largest hydraulic pump available, yet the loader moves very slowly unless the engine rpm’s are running at about 2,000 rpm’s. This tractor’s hydraulic performance is very poor.”

Best Buy

Wolverine work boots

William Kane, Oxford, Penn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“The Wolverine work boots I bought at Sears last year are reasonably priced and very comfortable. However, several months after I bought them I noticed large pieces were missing from the soles on both boots. Sears wouldn’t replace the boots because they weren’t their own brand and suggested I call the company. I did and was really impressed with their customer service. They were extremely helpful and have a no-questions-asked replacement policy. I was able to get a comparable style boot of my choice with no hassle. The claims paperwork was emailed to me. The replacement pair arrived promptly. Meanwhile, I bought a new pair of boots at Sears which are wearing fine. After this experience I’m definitely sticking with Wolverine boots.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 855 tractor + 1 more

J. Salyer, Floyd, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“My best buy is my 1997 Deere 855 tractor. I use a backhoe, front-end loader, and belly-mounted mower with it to haul firewood almost every day. It has about 2,200 hours on it. Only the water pump has been replaced.

“The propane-powered weed burner I bought at Northern Hydraulics is my worst buy. It was almost impossible to keep lit.”

Best Buy

Gerber multi-tools

Ron Thomlinson, Goulais River, Ontario · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“I like my Gerber Multi-Tools (ph 800 705-2040; www.rockynational.com). The company offers several different models, each one with different components ranging from a wire cutter and crimper to scissors and serrated knife blades. I own a couple of different models and I never go anywhere without one or the other attached to my belt. The quality of the blades and the strength of the pliers is amazing. After years of hard use, the tip of the needlenose pliers on the multiplier 400 finally failed. But the company repaired it immediately.”

Best Buy

DR Weedeater

Ray Gilbert, Bankston, Alabama · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“I bought a used DR Weedeater. The owner said he had used it only once. We’ve used it successfully many times with no problems. I paid only about half as much as a new one would have cost.”

Best Buy

Kinetico water softener/conditioner + 1 more

Dan Carruthers, Ramsey, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“In one of FARM SHOW’S recent issues someone had a problem with high iron content in their water. We also have very high iron in our water and aren’t supposed to use it for drinking water. So we did some shopping and bought a Kinetico water softener/conditioner. It’s operated by the water itself via a small water meter and switches tanks automatically, using no electricity at all. It comes with a 10-year warranty.

“In the past our bathtubs, toilets and sinks had to be cleaned daily or they wouldn’t get clean. The dishwasher was off limits because the water stained the dishes so badly. Shower heads and sink aerators plugged two to three times a year. However, since buying this water softener we’ve had absolutely no problems. My wife and I think it’s the best buy of our 26-year-marriage. She loves it.

“I still like my 1988 Chevy Suburban, which is equipped with a 350 cu. engine with throttle body fuel injection. We bought it used in 1994 as our family vehicle. Since then my wife has started driving mini vans but I’m still driving the Suburban. The children are gone now but we still travel a lot. Now it has about 313,000 miles but is still going strong. I change the filter every 5,000 miles and the oil every 15,000 miles. I use Mobil 1 full synthetic oil. I converted the Suburban to a work truck by folding the back seats down and sliding in a bed liner. It still gets 16 to 17 mpg.

“The paint job still looks good and everyone is surprised when they find out what year it is. I just run it through the car wash every month.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 crew cab pickup

Jimmy Dew, Guthrie, Okla. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“My wife and I are thrilled with our 2009 Dodge Ram 1500 crew cab pickup equipped with a 5.7-liter, V-8 engine. It gets about 20 mpg on the highway. The cab has a lot of storage area, and the ride rivals that of a luxury sedan or may be even better. We test drove a Dodge in 2002 and at that time you couldn’t run fast enough to give me one. However, they’ve made a lot of improvements in the new Dodges. I recently test drove a 2009 Ford F-150 and a 2009 GM Sierra, but my Dodge has a better fit and trim than either of those models. We definitely recommend Dodges.”

Best Buy

Deines HT 2072 zero turn commercial + 1 more

Bernard Geisel, Sturgeon Bay, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“My Deines HT 2072 zero turn commercial riding mower is my best buy (ph 800 624-6774). It’s an all-steel mower with no plastic or aluminum on it. You buy direct from the factory as they have no dealers. The mower was delivered right to my door with no dealer mark-up, all set up and ready to mow. It’s a fantastic machine - no problems.

“My Woodchuck 4000 wood and coal furnace is a best buy (ph 715 654-5132; www.woodchuckfurnace.com). The company is a long-time builder of the excellent Meyer forage chopper boxes. Skimping on quality apparently isn’t an option for them. Even my installer was impressed with the ruggedness and workmanship of this furnace.”

Best Buy

Whirlpool natural gas

Rex Fulton, Midland, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“In January 2008 I purchased a Whirlpool natural gas, 40-gal. water heater from Lowe’s. This past January it quit working. The gas control valve had to be replaced. The repairman said we were lucky the valve had lasted almost a year because many of them only last about six months. This heater is made in Mexico.”

Worst Buy

GSI grain bin

Tim Bloomquist, Drayton, N. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“I bought a GSI grain bin from CMC in Fargo, N. Dak. A short time after the bin was put up the side walls failed, making the bin totally useless. I contacted both CMC and GSI, located in Assumption, Ill. Neither company would make any effort to help.”

Best Buy

Stihl MS 290 chainsaw + 1 more

Wesley J. Martin, Vassar, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

“My 2008 Stihl MS 290 chainsaw runs good and is easy to start and handle. It also cuts fast. I really like it.

“The muffler came loose on my Husqvarna 350 chainsaw after just a few hours of use. I took the saw back to the dealer who was of no help. I had to buy new bolts and gaskets to repair it. However, it wasn’t long before the muffler came loose again, and by this time the piston and cylinder were shot. I called the factory and they said they’d send the dealer a parts list to repair the saw, but they never did. I’ve been cutting logs and firewood for more than 50 years and maintain all my saws before going to the woods. But I won’t buy a Husqvarna saw again.”

Worst Buy

Bostich 3-in-one nailer/compressor kit

Bob Potter, Stuart, Okla. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

Bob is disappointed with the Bostich 3-in-one nailer/compressor kit he bought at Lowes. “The air compressor failed within two weeks and was replaced by the store. The new compressor failed the same day and was replaced again. Then a week later the third compressor failed. Every time I went back to the store to replace the compressor I’d find someone who said they also had problems with this tool.”

Best Buy

Polaris Ranger 4

Carl Coffman, Shawnee, Okla. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“Recently I bought a used 2003 Polaris Ranger 4 by 4 to use on our acreage. My wife grew up on a wheat farm in northwest Oklahoma but now suffers from Alzheimer’s. I thought the Ranger would be a good way to get her outdoors. The bench seat lets me take her with me when I do chores.

“The Ranger has far exceeded my expectations. I use it almost every day. I wanted to add a top and windshield to provide shade and wind protection in cold weather. So I recycled some 5/8-in. thick pressure-treated decking to create a nice looking top, which I painted white. To make a windshield I had planned to attach plexiglass to the machine’s roll cage. However, I was advised by friends that the plexiglass would crack as the roll cage flexed.

“Looking around the barn, I spotted a discarded storm door and cut the frame to the required size. Then I installed a piece of plexiglass in the frame and, using the storm door hinge, attached the ‘new’ windshield to the roof. At the lower end of the windshield frame, I put a piece of Velcro on the windshield and roll cage. As a result the windshield stays in place, and the flexing of the roll cage doesn’t affect the windshield.”

Best Buy

Hitachi EX-60 14 excavator

Ken Hertz, Brush Prairie, Wash. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

He’s pleased with his 1996 Hitachi EX-60 14,000-lb. excavator, equipped with 2-ft. grouser tracks. “I live in a swampy, soft area and the grouser tracks’ 2-ft. width keeps me on top of the softest earth. I use this machine for moving dirt, digging ditches, and as a crane. I can pick up to 3,000 lbs. with it, even in real rough ground where a loader tractor wouldn’t stand a chance.”

Worst Buy

Jenn Air dual fuel range

David Pearson, Isanti, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My worst buy is a 2007 Jenn Air dual fuel range electric oven and gas cooktop. The warranty has expired and now we can’t find a service man within a reasonable driving distance. The appliance store we bought it from has gone out of business.”

Best Buy

Delavan semi portable milker

Bill Kennedy, Sicamons, B. C. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

Bill still uses a Delavan 4-gal. semi portable milker that’s 50 to 60 years old. “I bought it used 15 years ago and use it to milk our goats. It works flawlessly and has never needed repairs. This milker is a blessing to people with arthritis.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt DC 750 cordless drill + 1 more

Jim Hoover, Moore, Idaho · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My DeWalt DC 750 cordless drill is a 9.5-volt, 2-speed variable drive model that performs like a much larger drill. I just finished using it to put in 200 1 1/2-in. wood screws, yet it’s still going strong on the same battery. The two-speed variable drive is really nice when you get a hard screw to put in.

“My two 2008 Sears 19.2-volt cordless drills are both worst buys. One is a 3/8-in. model and the other a 1/2-in. model. I’ve had both drills less than a year and all three batteries died prematurely. Sears wants almost as much for the batteries as I paid for the drills. The drills themselves worked fine.”

Best Buy

Ryobi electric log splitter

Kimball Petty, Little Deer Isle, Maine · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

Kimball likes his 2007 Ryobi electric log splitter that he bought at Home Depot for $300. “I share it with four households that split two cords a year, and we all like it. I’ve used it to split 24-in. dia. straight grain oak with no problems. It’s quiet, odorless, and runs only when it’s actually splitting. It’s easy to transport and, with the addition of a bungie cord, the controls work well for one-handed operation.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Van Dale barn scrapers save + 1 more

Troy Lenssen, Lynden, Wash. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 2001 Van Dale barn scrapers save us a lot of time. I use them to clean my freestall barn 12 times a day with no problems. I replaced some bearings and switched to ropes instead of cable, which is better for the cows.

“My Albers Accu-lock stanchions are poorly built. I got 20 panels and I have to use a pipe wrench at one end because the handle at the other end only unlocks half of them. Cows get stuck constantly or it unlocks and they walk away. The company said I would have to live with the problems. I’ll never buy from them again.”

Best Buy

Bush Whacker rotary cutter

Danny Surgenor, Kingsport, Tenn. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 2001 Bush Whacker 7-ft. rotary cutter is built to take on small trees up to 3 in. in diameter (www.bush-whacker.com). I use my New Holland 4630 tractor to pull it. If I can push the tree over with my front-end loader, the Bush Whacker will cut it up. I had been buying a new cutter about every two years until I bought this unit. I changed blades for the first time in 2006.”

Worst Buy

Snowbear wide pickup-mounted snowplow

G. Combs, Concord, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“The Snowbear 88-in. wide pickup-mounted snowplow I bought at Northern Hydraulics is a worst buy. I paid $1,699 for it. By the time I got all the parts for it the 30-day return was up. If I’m not careful, the winch will bend the support arms into the plow - without a limit switch it just keeps on going. The company is aware of the problem but doesn’t have a solution. My driveway is about 200 ft. long. I’ve used this plow about six times and it broke four times. I don’t abuse machinery but the company always seems to infer that I’m abusing it. The price is reasonable, but the machine is built too light for plowing snow unless you live in Florida. The construction and materials on it look like something I’d buy for a lawn tractor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toyota 4-WD pickup + 1 more

Joe Macha, Plainview, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 1981 Toyota 4-WD pickup, and my 1991 and 1997 GM 4-WD pickups, are all best buys. These compact pickups are reliable and fuel efficient, with plenty of storage space in the cab.”

A 2008 GM 4-WD extended cab pickup rates as Joe’s “worst buy”. “This pickup drives and rides nice but it isn’t a work truck. It’s big, bulky and so tall that I can’t get anything out of the bed without having to climb in. The cab has very little storage space, and the gaskets on the doors leak in high winds. This pickup is poorly designed by people who have no idea what a work truck should be. It also annoys me to have Onstar and satellite radio as standard equipment, when I don’t want either one.”

Best Buy

Stihl weedeater

Va. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 1999 Stihl weedeater and 2006 hedge trimmer are both best buys. The only time they’ve been in the repair shop was four years ago, when the internal gas line on the weedeater collapsed. The shop said the problem was due to ethanol in the gas.”

Best Buy

Hitachi 12-volt + 1 more

Steve Nichols, Galesburg, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My most useful tools are my Hitachi 12-volt and Goodyear 24-volt cordless impact wrenches. They work great for removing lawn mower blades and reinstalling them after sharpening. Many tire dealers use them to buzz lug nuts off and on. It makes changing a tire or rotating tires an easy job. I use them for countless other jobs. I don’t think I’ll ever be without a cordless drill again.”

Worst Buy

Honda Foreman ATV

F. K. Mitchell, Greenwood, Florida · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“I’ve had problems with my 1999 Honda Foreman ATV. When I turn the lights on it kills the battery. It also had a starting problem. The starter turned over fine, but the engine wouldn’t crank. I took off the fenders to look for shorts, cuts, or unplugged connectors and finally found that the kill switch on the handlebars was broken. I solved the problem by wiring two wires together. The engine fired up and ran with no problems.”

Best Buy

Case IH Maxxum MX 110 front wheel assist + 1 more

Timothy Yoder, Princeton, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 1999 Case IH Maxxum MX 110 front wheel assist tractor is my best buy. This tractor is considerably heavier than its Deere counterparts, such as the Deere 7210 and 7220 models. The MX 110 is rated at only 95 hp but performs way beyond what I’d expect from a tractor its size. It’s also fuel efficient, averaging 3 1/2 gallons per hour depending on the load. It’s powered by a 5.9-liter Cummins turbocharged diesel which is very reliable. I’ve heard reports of similar models with 12,000 hours or more.

“I’d definitely buy another MX 110. The only major repairs so far have been to rebuild a planetary on a front wheel and a new hydraulic pump. The pump went out due to poor maintenance - the filter and fluid should have been changed sooner. We’re extremely pleased with this tractor.

“My 2006 Case 440 skid loader is also a best buy. It has a two-speed transmission which is handy and also fuel efficient, averaging 1.25 gallons per hour. We’ve had to make only minor repairs such as replacing a fan belt and a solenoid. It starts well in cold weather and has almost 1,800 hours on it.”