Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002)

45 reports from pages 14–17 · 38 Best Buys16 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Deines 1800 zero turn riding + 1 more

Pete Lamp, Waterloo, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“My Deines 1800 zero turn riding mower is my best buy (Deines Mfg., P O Box 266, Rasnom Kan. 67572 ph 785 731-2271). It’s equipped with an 18 hp engine and a 5-ft. front-mount deck. I’ve used it for two years without any problems. It has a tilt-up deck which I really like for cleaning the deck after use. I have a lot of trees in my yard so the zero turn feature really comes in handy. It’s priced 20 percent lower than any of the other zero turn mowers I checked out, and it’s made in the U.S.

“I use hay tarps made by Western Ag Enterprises, Inc. to cover my small square bales (8121 W. Harrison, Tolleson, Arizona 85353 ph 800 347-8274). These tarps are made from lightweight poly that’s reinforced with a 2-ft. board on one side for superior strength under high winds. The tarps are designed to conform to the stack so wind can’t get under them. All of the tie-down straps are built into the hem so I don’t have to buy any rope. It comes folded so when I go up on the center of the stack and unfold it, I can just pull it out and everything falls in place. Then I go down and walk alongside it and tie it down. It has gone through 90 to 100 mph winds that blew roofs off many of the area’s barns.

“If you put more than one tarp on a stack you can overlap the tarps like shingles and use straps across the top of the stack to keep them tight on top. A rain flap is sewn into the hem to deflect water from the side of the stack. I’ve used one tarp for six years with no problems.”

Best Buy

Brown Carburetor Co

Ted Wilson, Clanton, Ala. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“One of the best buys I ever made was the Fish carburetor manufactured by Brown Carburetor Co. I bought it several years ago, and it has been the most reliable and cost efficient carburetor I’ve ever used. It saves greatly on fuel efficiency and paid for itself the first year I used it. Unfortunately this carburetor is no longer available, as I found out recently when I tried to buy another one.”

Best Buy

John Deere 25EV chain saw + 1 more

E. Yastrubecki, Paynton, Sask. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“I like my Deere 25EV chain saw which I bought new in the spring of 1984 and am still using. This saw was made in Japan by Kioritz. I’ve lost count of how many bars and chains I’ve worn out over the years, but this little saw just keeps on running. I use wood to heat my shop so it gets a lot of use.”

A Deere 318 garden tractor rates as his “worst buy”. “The rear output shaft kept breaking while the tractor was still under warranty. Neither the dealer nor the company were very helpful. I think if it would’ve been a $90,000 tractor they’d have been glad to assist, but since it’s just a garden tractor they couldn’t care less. I’ll never buy another green machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grizzly cordless drill + 1 more

Dave Mertell, Independence, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“My 1999 18-volt Grizzly cordless drill works great for a 1/2-in. model and is reasonably priced. It gets a lot of use.

“My Ryobi 14-in. metal cut-off saw is my worst buy. The motor armature burned out after only about two months of use. I called the company’s service department and was told they didn’t sell individual parts and that I’d have to buy an entire new motor. This tool is now sitting in a landfill.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 4-door + 2 more

David E. Beck, Buffalo, N.Y. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“Our 1998 Dodge 4-door ‘K’ car, which we bought used, is a best buy.

“Our 1991 Pontiac Sunbird 2-door car runs good and is also a best buy. We bought it used with about 140,000 miles on it. It has a 4-cyl. gas engine that’s easy on fuel.

“The 1985 Ford pickup that we bought used is our worst buy. It’s equipped with a 302 cubic inch, fuel-injected engine. We’ve had a lot of electrical and fuel problems with this truck.”

Best Buy

Ford 4000 tractor equipped + 1 more

Henry Mullaix, Independence, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“My best buy is a 1972 Ford 4000 tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine and front-end loader. I bought it used three years ago. It now has more than 2,400 hours on it. No problems at all.

“My 1965 Massey Ferguson 65 tractor equipped with a 4-cyl. gas engine is a best buy. I got it from my dad who bought it new and then retired. It now has more than 1,700 hours on it.”

Worst Buy

Case 2290 tractor

John B. Sisco, Burchard, Neb. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

A 1979 Case 2290 tractor rates as John’s “worst buy”. “It has about 5,500 hours on it. The rear end went out twice, the powershift transmission has gone out three times, and the intermediate shaft in the transmission fell out. I’ve had to spend about $30,000 during the last eight years on repairs and on a new engine and fuel injection pump.”

Best Buy

Ford 5600 tractor equipped

Kevin Peters, Morden, Manitoba · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

Kevin’s generally satisfied with his 1980 Ford 5600 tractor equipped with a Ford 777 front-end loader. “We bought this tractor new in 1981 and have never babied it. It pulls like a mule and will come back for more. We’re pleased with how well it has stood the test of time. Our dealer has even offered to give us more money than we paid for it if we’d trade it in. On the down side, the clutch has been replaced a number of times and I burned two lobes on the camshaft. The engine was overhauled in 1993. Our biggest disappointment, though, has to be with the power steering box. A gasket on it has to be replaced once a year because of added stress caused by the loader work.”

Best Buy

Great Bend 760 front-end loader

Mark Albrecht, Cozad, Neb. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

“My best buy last year was the joystick control I bought for my Great Bend 760 front-end loader. The loader is two years old. The first year I used it on a Case-IH 2096 tractor equipped with three hydraulic outlets. I was using all of the outlets to operate the loader so every time I wanted to hook up to another implement I had to disconnect the hydraulics. Then I traded tractors for a Case-IH 7110. It has only two hydraulic outlets so I decided to pipe directly into the pump and buy the joystick control. It works great and is much more convenient to use.”

Best Buy

Kubota front wheel assist

Shilo Smith, Lyons, Oregon · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 14

Shilo nominates his 1998 Kubota front wheel assist tractor as his “best buy”. “We decided to buy Kubota instead of Ford, Deere, or Massey Ferguson because we felt this tractor was more user friendly, and because we liked its glide shift transmission. We use this tractor for a lot of jobs including disking, mowing, picking rocks, and running a backhoe. The only problem we’ve had was with a valve body that wasn’t shifting right. The tractor had only 60 hours on it so we took it back to the dealer and they promptly fixed it. I’d recommend Kubota tractors to anyone .”

Calvin Graber, Graber Jerseys, Inc., with an 8-ft. blade or a 6-ft. bucket to remove snow around our farm. I’ve never been stuck with this tractor, and it starts in any kind of weather. I couldn’t do without this tractor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sudenga cleated belt elevator + 2 more

Parker, S. Dak. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

Calvin says his 2000 Sudenga cleated belt elevator, mounted on a soybean seed trailer, is his “worst buy”. “In the spring of 2000 we spent a lot of money on a Demco gravity wagon equipped with the Sudenga belt conveyor to handle bulk soybean seed. The belt conveyer has been a huge disappointment. It’s extremely heavy, and the mounting brackets for it are a joke. I had to spend many, many hours fixing and replacing links, brackets and safety chains so that I could restrain the elevator for safe transport.

“During the height of planting season, while I was traveling slowly down a local highway, the poorly designed Sudenga linkage and mounting pan crashed onto the road. The dealer I bought it from replaced the mounting pan (it looked like a high school shop project) and made up some better mounting brackets so I could finish planting.

“To make matters worse, the elevator grinds and cracks the seed. It’s equipped with an extendable spout that could also use some improvement.”

On the “best buy” side, he lists his 1996 Case-IH Steiger 9370 4-WD tractor. “We bought the tractor used in 1997 with 450 hours on it. It’s equipped with a high horsepower Cummins N14 diesel engine and a 12-speed powershift transmission. This tractor has exceeded our expectations for power, comfort, and style.

“Our Case-IH 4300 48 1/2-ft. field cultivator is also a best buy. It’s equipped with knock-off shovels and a four-rank Noble drag on back. The only problem was a flat tire or two.”

Best Buy

Drill Doctor drill sharpener + 1 more

Robert A. Lecaptain, Maribel, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

Robert likes his Drill Doctor drill sharpener. “It does a good job of sharpening drill bits up to 3/4 inch in diameter. When I had some problems with the chuck turning hard, the company not only replaced the chuck but the entire machine, claiming that the plastic used on some models absorbs water and swells up, causing the problem.”

Robert isn’t as impressed with his 2001 Chevrolet Impala. “I took delivery one day toward the end of June. It was a hot day and the air conditioner wasn’t working right. On my second trip to the garage they discovered that the air conditioner was low on freon. When I speed up on the highway, the air conditioner shifts down. I have to drive more than 40 miles before it shifts back up at about 60 mph. The dealer can’t find anything wrong and says I’ll just have to get used to it. This winter I had to drive 15 to 20 miles before I could get warm air into the car. My feet were always cold.

“Another problem is the electric adjustable bench seat - I still haven’t figured out how to adjust the seat for comfort. It rides like an empty lumber wagon and is hard on my back.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2355 4-WD tractor equipped

La Rue F. Whitmoyer, Muncy, Penn. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

He’s the satisfied owner of a 1990 Deere 2355 4-WD tractor equipped with a Deere 245 front-end loader. “This tractor has a cab, air conditioning, and a heater so it’s comfortable to use all year long. I use it with a 3-pt. bale wrapper to wrap round bales. I use a bale hugger on front of the tractor to move bales to the side of the field. During the winter I haul the bales to a feedlot which is often muddy and icy. I also use this tractor doesn’t have a cab - the left side dash cowling has to be removed first so that you can disconnect the clutch spring. But in order to do this, first you have to remove the lower window on the left side of the cab.

“The door hinges are weak and the door seals aren’t very effective. The engine oil fill is poorly located, and I have to practically drip oil in a little at a time in order to keep it from overflowing out the fill spout.

“Considering what this tractor costs, it’s disappointing to have to deal with a cab that’s this poorly designed. I believe these cabs were built outside the company, but so what? I think my four-year-old child could do a better job. The cabs on the company’s 20 series tractors have a different design and look much better. However, after the experience we had we’ll be taking a closer look at other tractor brands next time.”

Best Buy

the Pet Protector underground dog house

Stephen Hunter, Coshocton, Ohio · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

After reading about the Pet Protector underground dog house in the last issue of FARM SHOW, Stephen bought one (Pet Protector, LLC, 600 S. Main, Newkirk, Okla. 74647 ph 580 362-3412). “We bought the first one sold in Ohio. We’ve only had it in for a short while, but initially our dog has been a little scared of the steps. Looks like it’ll take some time to get used to it.”

Best Buy

Roger owns a brush mower equipped with a 46-in

Roger A. Ussery, Columbia, Ky. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

Roger owns a brush mower equipped with a 46-in. lawn mowing head and powered by a 12 1/2 hp gas engine. “This mower does what the company says it will do. I used it to clear 10 acres of overgrown brush and then used the lawn mowing head to keep it mowed.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 5500 tractor

Fred Hansen, Santa Rosa, Calif. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

“Our 1998 Deere 5500 tractor is our worst buy. We bought a Deere model because in the horsepower range we were interested in the company kept its tractors simple, without using a lot of electronics, etc. The tractor itself is designed well enough, but before I bought it I had major reservations about the cab as it didn’t appear to be up to the company’s previous standards.

“Sure enough, most of the problems we’ve had with the tractor have been directly or indirectly related to the cab. For example, to service the battery you have to remove six bolts and take off both an outside cover and the step. To access the air cleaner, you have to remove a side grill support first because the air conditioning condenser hoses block normal access. To adjust the clutch - which is a major undertaking on a tractor even if it

Best BuyWorst Buy

Wood-Mizer hydraulic operated bandsaw + 1 more

John F. Wohlwend, Foxboro, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

“My 1999 Wood-Mizer hydraulic operated bandsaw has performed as well as the company said it would. I bought it to build a barn, a cabin, and a hunting lodge. None of the 2 by 4’s ever needed to be planed because of how smooth it cuts.

“My 1995 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup was my worst buy. The frame bent doing farm work so I sold it and went back to using my 1969 GM 3/4-ton for hauling hay on our farm.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-350 pickup equipped + 2 more

John Anderson, Marysville, Wash. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

“One of my best buys ever was my 1997 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with a Power Stroke diesel engine. I put more than 87,000 miles on it without any problems. It was a great pickup with a great engine. Six months ago I traded for a 2001 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with the new Duramax engine. I’m well satisfied with it. It gets more than 18 1/2 mpg in town and more than 20 mpg on the highway.

“My 1995 Sears Kenmore oven is a worst buy. The problem is that the burners don’t work right. We’ve had to replace them many times. In addition, the oven doesn’t heat accurately.”

Worst Buy

Harvestore silo

David Swanson, Mount Morris, N.Y. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

“Our 25 by 65-ft. Harvestore silo is our worst buy ever. It’s hard to get feed in and impossible to get it out. The Goliath unloader that we used in it was also terrible. It broke and we had to winch it out of the silo with a Cat D8, which broke it to pieces. The bottom rings of the silo burned out. It cost a lot of money to fix.”

Best Buy

Blitz Buildings, Inc

David L. Stowers, Elwood, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

David’s impressed with a 30 by 54 by 14-ft. farm building that he had put up on his farm last year by Blitz Buildings, Inc. (Box 108, Huntingburg, Ind. 47542). “I purchased this barn over the phone. The office manager and I discussed my needs and the barn’s purpose. I never met the manager or his crew. The site was prepared and within a week the barn was fully functional. Everything we talked about was noted and planned for. The building crew did a great job of cleaning up after themselves, even discarding cigarette butts. If I ever need another building I won’t hesitate to call this company again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kroil + 5 more

Lowell Patterson, Eighty-Four, Penn. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“Lowell’s impressed with Kroil, a penetrating lubricant (Kano Laboratories, Box 110098, Nashville, Tenn. 37222 ph 615 833-4101; Website: www.kanolabs.com). “I used it mixed with 30-weight non-detergent motor oil to repair a badly rusted 1982 Ford pickup. The pickup’s kingpin began to seize a while ago which caused increased binding and made it hard to steer. The grease zerk wouldn’t take grease. I couldn’t justify the proper repairs so I was in a real fix.

“I sprayed Kroil into the yoke seams, jacked up the wheel, and worked the lubricant in by steering right and left with the engine running. I waited 15 minutes or so but there didn’t seem to be any improvement so I went into the house. Two hours later, when I went back out and got in the pickup I noticed right away that it steered much easier. I had to repeat the treatment twice more over the next few days before the grease zerk began to take grease.

“I used this same procedure on an old Ford F600 freight truck that belonged to a cousin. The truck was almost unsteerable, and he had to drive it from Pennsylvania to California. I applied Kroil to all the linkage and joints which solved the problem in short order. The company claims Kroil will creep into a joint as tight as one millionth of an inch. It sure helps on tight stuff.

“Our Jonsereds turbo chain saw is a best buy. The only repair it has needed was to the crank assembly. Otherwise this chain saw has performed superbly.

“My Porter-Cable circular saw and 1/2-in. heavy duty drill are both outstanding tools. I do a lot of home improvements so I can’t tolerate poor performance in power tools.

“I want to warn readers to avoid power drills with Rohti German-made drill chucks - I can guarantee they will fail. These chucks are found mostly on 1/2-in. hammer drills sold by Milwaukee, Bosch, Dewalt, and Sears Craftsman. The problem is that the chuck weakens rapidly to the point where it’s impossible to keep it tight for even a few revolutions. If anyone has such a tool they should remove the chuck, send it back to the tool manufacturer, and ask for an American-made chuck. I did that for a Milwaukee drill and got a good chuck.

“I’m intrigued with Hammerite paint (MasterChem, Box 368, Barnhart, Mo. 63012 ph 800 325-3552). It might be the only paint that can be successfully painted directly over rust. It has powdered glass in it which makes it durable.“ 3,500 miles. It uses less than a half quart of oil between oil changes.”

Best Buy

Mantis rototiller + 1 more

Rodney Barnes, Hemet, Calif. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“My Mantis rototiller is an excellent product. I’ve used it for 17 years. I had it tuned up about 10 years ago and again about two years ago. The tune-up cost less than $60 and now it runs as good as new.

“My Dodge Caravan has well over 200,000 miles on it. It’s powered by a 3.3 V-6 engine and has a 4-speed automatic transmission. It hasn’t required much maintenance, and it often gets 30 mpg or more on the highway. I’ve used it to haul loads weighing up to 1,800 lbs., and it still handles and performs well.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 446 round baler

Jim Singleton, Arcola, Sask. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“My 2000 Deere 446 round baler is my worst buy. It has problems ejecting bales out of the bale chamber. The problem is that the chamber was made too small. Some modifications were made at the dealership to stretch the chamber out, but it didn’t help and straw still won’t feed into the throat properly.”

Worst Buy

New Holland 5610S tractor

James C. Coates, Marshall, N.C. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“My 2000 New Holland 5610S tractor is my worst buy. After 20 hours the electric fuel pump shorted out. It was repaired, but now it uses twice as much fuel. It also wouldn’t work properly in warm weather. The tractor had been sitting so long at the dealer that the clutch was stuck. They replaced the pressure plate and clutch but it still doesn’t shift right. I’ve already put four quarts of oil into the engine even though it has only 50 hours of use. It also leaks hydraulic oil and power steering fluid underneath. The tires have a lot of dry cracks in them. They wanted $8,000 to trade for a new smaller tractor. I’ll never buy a New Holland product again.”

Best Buy

John Deere 7410 tractor equipped + 1 more

Ken O. Turner, Mantee, Miss. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

Ken nominates his 1999 Deere 7410 tractor equipped with a Deere 720 front-end loader as his “best buy”. “This tractor has a Power Quad transmission which allows me to shift from forward to reverse without clutching. It works great for loader work, baling hay, and mowing brush in tight spaces, and other jobs. I only have to clutch when changing between ranges. Another plus is that it has a quiet cab with great visibility. The cab stays cool during summer and warm in winter.

“My 1987 Dodge Ram Charger equipped with a 318 cu. in. V-8 engine was one of my worst buys ever. It had electrical and brake problems from the beginning. The second day I had it, it stalled and the dealer had to send a tow truck to pick it up. This problem continued on and off for the next 10 years. We finally gave up when the dealer said it would cost $1,500 to repair and wouldn’t be guaranteed. The engine worked great and was very dependable. But no more Dodge pickups on my farm.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Silverado long wheel base

Dennis Davis, Spruce Pine, Ala. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“I like my 1990 Chevrolet Silverado long wheel base pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in. engine. It runs great. This pickup has more than 484,000 miles on it and still has the original engine. The engine has never had any kind of mechanical work done to it, other than to change spark plugs. I change the oil every

Best Buy

John Deere 4430 tractor

Lloyd Hermanson, Outlook, Sask. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“It’s the most trouble-free machine I’ve ever owned,” says Lloyd about his 1976 Deere 4430 tractor. “The engine, transmission, and rear end have never been taken apart. It has more than 13,000 hours on it but still runs as good as the day I bought it.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 pickup

Jack Compton, Plainview, Texas · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“My 1992 Ford F-150 pickup is my best buy. I’ve read in different consumer magazines that I should avoid this model, but I’m well pleased with mine. It has more than 140,000 miles on it. My only expenses were to repair a switch on the automatic transmission, and to install new brake shoes and a new U-joint.”

Best Buy

SLIME

Nicholas L. Genovese, Bainbridge, N.Y. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

A tire sealant called SLIME rates as Nicholas’s “best buy” (Access Marketing, 800 Farroll Rd., Grover Beach, Calif. 93433; www.slimesealant.com). “After making just two passes with a new two-wheeled spreader in my horse pasture, both tires went flat. I discovered that thorns from numerous Hawthorn bushes had caused several punctures in each tire. Installing tubes wouldn’t help because they would puncture as well. I installed SLIME in each tire and it worked perfectly. Once installed into the tire, SLIME remains a liquid, evenly coating the inside. When a puncture occurs, the escaping air forces SLIME into the hole where it creates a long-lasting, flexible plug. It’s a permanent fix, unlike other latex aerosol products that are only temporary repairs. It repairs punctures up to 1/4 in. in diameter.

“I finished going over several acres of Hawthorn-laced pasture without getting another flat tire or even losing any air pressure. I was so impressed that I also used the product on several tractor tires that had slow leaks. It stopped them from leaking as well.”

Best Buy

John Deere 9100 tractor

Ron Kozoway, Ryley, Alberta · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

Ron’s impressed with his 1999 Deere 9100 tractor. “It has a lot of power and a good hydraulic system. The gauges for the hydraulics, transmission, and antifreeze are very convenient. My only complaint is that the engine oil fill port is located so that unless you use a flexible spout on the funnel you can’t pour oil without spilling it. Also, for some reason the rear-mounted Halogen lights attract dust whenever we pull implements across the field. The dust clings to the lights and reduces rear visibility by about 80 percent.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota pickup

Brian C. Schroeder, Marengo, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

Brian’s happy with his 1988 Dodge Dakota pickup. “I bought it used in 1992 with about 42,000 miles on it. Now it has more than 314,000 miles on it but still has the original engine. I have nothing but good things to say about this pickup.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford 8N tractor + 1 more

William D. Shirley, League City, Texas · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 16

“I like my 1952 Ford 8N tractor. I bought it used in 1996 and haven’t had any problems with it. It’s a pleasure to operate.

“My 1998 Troy Bilt trimmer/mower is my worst buy. I’ve had problems with it from day one. The string wouldn’t stay on the head and the head wouldn’t stay in one place. The cast aluminum case is corroding and I can’t do anything about it. It’s powered by a 6 hp Briggs & Stratton gas engine which is the only good thing about it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sophtec water conditioner softens + 1 more

Douglas Brown, Alleman, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“Our 2000 Sophtec water conditioner softens our water magnetically without requiring any salt or electricity. It almost completely eliminates hydrogen sulfide odors. It’s a great product.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Sears Craftsman bench top belt and disc sander. “We didn’t use it for more than a year after we bought it. The first time we used it the motor started smoking. Since the product was more than a year old, the company wouldn’t honor the warranty. I think this sander was defective the day it was made.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram Dakota 4-WD pickup equipped + 1 more

E. Woody Johnson, Osakis, Minn. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“Our Dodge Dakota 4-WD pickup, equipped with a 3.9-liter, V-6 engine, is a best buy. It starts good and rides and handles nice. It has more than 160,000 miles on it but has required few repairs, and it still doesn’t use much oil. My only complaint is that it isn’t very fuel efficient - no better than my former full-sized Dodge pickup which had a V-8 engine.

“My Poulon ‘Wild Thing’ chain saw is my worst buy. It starts hard and often quits running when I’m using it, and it won’t start again until the motor cools off. The oiler system is poorly designed and always leaks out whenever the saw is stored in its case. I’ve owned many saws over the years and am a small engine mechanic, so I think I know what I’m talking about. This saw is junk.”

Best Buy

New Holland 144 hay inverter

Luke Swantz, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“Our 1990 New Holland 144 hay inverter is an excellent machine. It handles hay very gently without knocking off leaves like a conventional hay rake or tedder. It speeds up drying time by 12 hours, or more. It also doesn’t rope up the hay like a conventional rake does.”

Worst Buy

Dixon zero turn riding

Bill White, London, Ontario · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“My Dixon zero turn riding mower is my worst buy. I really like how it cuts, but I’ve had problems with two shafts. The problem is that the shafts are too soft and bend next to the bearing. Both times I had the shafts tested and found that they weren’t. The company wouldn’t help at all. I had to spend about $700 on repairs.”

Best Buy

Belarus 805 tractor

Terry Schmidt, Chapman, Kansas · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

“My 1993 Belarus 805 tractor has been an economical, dependable tractor and is my best buy. It’s easy to work on and parts for it are reasonably priced. The hydraulic hoses and electrical components on it aren’t built with the same quality as they are on more popular tractor brands, but these components can be easily replaced.”

Worst Buy

Harbor Freight tools

Joseph deNatale, Pittsfield, Maine · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 17

Joseph says Harbor Freight tools are his “worst buy”. “I’ve purchased several of the company’s tools for use in my apple orchard. Even though their tools are priced cheap they’re usually okay for occasional use. However, when some of the tools became defective I soon discovered the company’s customer service leaves a lot to be desired.

“I bought a titanium-plated drill bit set and a cold chisel set. Several of the drill bits were so soft I could bend them by hand, and when I used some of the chisels they shattered. I sent the tools back to the company and asked for replacements. I also told them about some significantly dangerous manufacturing defects that I had noticed in the tools so they could correct them for future buyers. The company never replied, so I wrote them a letter asking about the status of the returned items. They sent back a form letter that told me to call their customer service department. I called them and was told that all customer service representatives were busy. I waited more than 40 minutes before I became to springtime – you need to recalibrate the impatient and finally hung up. I sent three more letters to them but never got a written response. I was always referred by form letter to their customer service department.

“After writing four letters and spending a total of more than 2 1/2 hours on the phone waiting to talk to someone, I finally got through. The person I talked to said they couldn’t find the tools I had returned. The entire experience was an exercise in frustration.”