Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003)

55 reports from pages 12–15 · 49 Best Buys12 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Toyota Tundra pickup

James Norris, Ft. Worth, Tex. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“I saw the story in your last issue about Nissan’s new pickup. In that story you said it’s the first Japanese full-sized pickup and that the Toyota Tundra is 7/8th size.

“I’d like to tell you I’ve got a 2000 Toyota Tundra pickup and it’s a full-sized pickup that’s as big as a Ford F-150 or a Chevy 1500. It’ll out-pull, out-drive and out-run a Ford F-150 pickup, all while burning less fuel. It’s fitted with 16-in. wheels and has tremendous power and wonderful handling. It’s a great pickup and one of my best buys ever.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Suburban

Ron and RJ Parr, Allen, Texas · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“Our 1996 Chevy Suburban has been a nightmare,” say Ron and RJ. They use the truck to travel around the South pulling a 35-ft. Silverstream trailer. “Since we bought it we spend more time at the repair shop than on the road,” they say.

“We broke it in gently, but after we hooked up the trailer for the first time the gearbox on the rear axle went out almost immediately. It was under warranty, but a couple months later it went out again,” they say. Since then the rear axle has been worked on a total of seven times with the rear gearbox being replaced six times in all. “And even when it was working okay it still made noise. We would never buy another new Chevrolet.”

Best Buy

John Deere 425 riding mower

Lyle Moege, Hurley, S. Dak. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“In a recent issue I read about someone dissatisfied with their Deere 425 riding mower. I was worried because I took delivery of a 425 that very same day,” he says. “But green paint did not let me down- I have found it to be a quality product. Especially useful is the all-wheel steer with power steering,” says Moege. “It makes mowing in tight places easy.

“The Deere 425 is an all around excellent product with solid engineering and great maneuverability. It’s my best buy.”

Best Buy

Kroil

James Wilhite, Jefferson, Georgia · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“Kroil is the best penetrating oil I have ever used. I have used several other name brand oils over the years and Kroil beats them all 2 to 1.

“Not only will it loosen frozen threads and stuck screws, but it will also dissolve grease, oil, dirt, and rust. “It can do so many things that it will never be replaced in my toolbox.” (website: www.kanolabs.com).

Best Buy

M&W Gear 4407 round baler

Robert Young, Trenary, Mich. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“My 1999 M&W Gear 4407 round baler is an excellent baler. It has a simple design and works great. I like it better than a lot of the balers sold by big companies like Deere and New Holland. Their balers are more computerized and make bales faster, but this is a good baler for the smaller farmer. I use it to make 4 by 4-ft. silage bales weighing 1,200 to 1,300 lbs. apiece and put up 1,200 to 1,500 bales per year. The baler signals when the bale chamber is full and then I push a button to tie the bale. The first year I used this baler I accidentally backed it up into a bale and bent the bale ramp, but the dealer repaired it at no charge.

“I paid $9,500 for the baler. At the time I bought it I checked out a New Holland baler that sold for $18,500.”

Best Buy

Load Handler

Arty Rubenzahl, Neversink, New York · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“The Load Handler that attaches to a pickup bed is my best buy. I am able to unload large quantities of dirt, gravel, rock, or lumber with just one hand.”

The “Load Handler” consists of a wide belt that lays in the pickup box and is cranked toward the back by a handle mounted on the tailgate. It’s able to move over 3,000 lbs. and fits most pickups. “I’ve even used it to haul firewood.” (ph 800-533-5545; website: www.northerntool.com).

Best Buy

Amsoil

Arden Walizer, Loganton, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“The problems FARM SHOW has had with its 1995 Ford Windstar van - going through five different engines - could probably have been prevented by using Amsoil. It reduces friction and lowers an engine’s internal temperature, which causes the engine to use less oil. My son has a 1999 Dodge Caravan equipped with a 4-cyl., 219 cu. in. engine. He’s an AI technician with responsibility for several thousands cows so he does a lot of driving. His Dodge already has about 180,000 miles on it but the engine still runs great. He started using Amsoil at 10,000 miles and since then has changed the engine oil only five times and the transmission oil twice.

“I use Amsoil in almost all my equipment including 15 tractors, most of them antique models, as well as two New Holland 4-WD tractors. And yes, I am an Amsoil dealer.”

Worst Buy

Maytag dishwasher

M.L. Lindsay, West Monroe, La. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“My new Maytag dishwasher is my worst buy. It doesn’t do a good job cleaning dishes and doesn’t heat the water or sanitize as claimed, and any debris that happens to be left on the dishes is distributed throughout the dishwasher and ends up glued to the dishes. If you don’t load the bottom shelf before the middle shelf, the middle shelf will sag down into the bottom shelf and as a result you can’t pull it out. Another problem is that the dishes come out wet. If a few granules of detergent fall outside the cup and onto the door latch, the latch won’t fasten. The granules have to be brushed away in order for the latch to work.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet LT 1/2-ton pickup

Allen Clow, Lancaster, Minn. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“My 1999 Chevrolet LT 1/2-ton pickup is my best buy. It has more than 100,000 miles and has performed perfectly since the day I drove it out of the showroom. It drives wonderfully and consistently gets 17 to 20 mpg. I always read with amusement about people who complain about problems with brakes or other little things that wear out. A lot of times people create their own problems because of poor maintenance.”

Best Buy

Envirotec corn burning stove

Robert Murphy, St. Thomas, Ontario · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“Our Envirotec corn burning stove has reduced our heating bills by half and is our best buy (Caneco Mfg. Inc., Box 9042, Sub. 40, London, Ontario, Canada N6E 1V0 ph 519 686-7298; email: [email protected]; website: www.cornstove.ca). Not only are we saving money but we’re living more comfortably, too. It has one of the safest heating units I’ve ever seen.”

Best Buy

Blaster penetrating oil

Kent Cartwright, Genoa, Nevada · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

Kent likes Blaster penetrating oil. “Over the years I’ve tried most of the penetrating oil products on the market, as I’m always bringing home some rusted machine that needs work. One time I used Blaster on a front disc brake caliper bleed fitting that was nothing more than a lump of corrosion, and it dissolved all the rust.”

Worst Buy

Kubota M110 tractor

Jack Merritt, White Plains, Ga. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

Jack’s disappointed with his 2000 Kubota M110 tractor. “I bought the tractor equipped with air conditioning to use in my hay fields in our hot, humid summers, but so far I’m still sweating it out. The air conditioner has never worked from day one. The problem is that the radiator fan sucks up trash and I can’t keep it cleaned out. As a result the air conditioner blows hot air. It gets so hot inside the cab I can’t even stay in the tractor. I’ve contacted the company service rep several times with no results. I have more than $50,000 invested in this tractor but I can’t even use it. I can’t trade the tractor in because I would lose money, and I can’t sell it because no one wants this tractor because of its reputation.

“I’m very disappointed in this tractor and with the company in general. I’ll never buy another Kubota product nor will I recommend one to my friends. The Kubota ad slogan says they ‘pull through every time.’ Well, the only thing my Kubota is pulling me through is hot air.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 1 more

James Arndorfer, Humeston, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My 2000 Ford F-150 pickup performs well and has done everything I expected it to do. It’s also fuel efficient.”

On the negative side, “I bought a Morton garage-type building equipped with two 9 by 8-ft. overhead doors. The door openers won’t work unless I’m standing just outside, or sometimes inside, the building to help raise the doors. I bought this building from Morton as a package that included doors, door openers and a cement floor. I’ve called the company and have also stopped in several times. However, the secretary always says the salesman is out of the office.”

Best Buy

Ram pickup equipped

Ray Alexander, Fredericton Junction, New Brunswick · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

Ray says he likes his 1992 Dodge pickup equipped with a diesel engine, but that it has nonetheless had problems. “The diesel engine is far superior to the 6.3-liter diesel in the Chevrolet pickup that I previously owned. Overall, the Dodge is a better pickup. However, after five years the paint began to fall off and now it’s a real mess. This pickup has hardly ever been driven during the winter. My next pickup won’t be a Dodge.”

Worst Buy

New Holland 1002 bale wagon

Arthur Duckworth, Stanley, N.C. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My New Holland 1002 bale wagon is my worst buy. The dealer I bought it from ran many magazine ads indicating that all their equipment is fully reconditioned and tested in their shop. So I bought the bale wagon sight unseen based on the strength of the company’s reputation and claims, which was my first mistake. The unit shipped to me wasn’t equipped as described. For example, it had been modified by adding a hydraulic cylinder to lift the pickup head, which required a valve splitter and two hydraulic remotes to run it instead of one as I had expected. One of the push-off springs was broken, and the push-off channels and guides were bent. One of the push-off guides had the wrong size cable adapted and the unit wouldn’t function correctly. Also, it leaked hydraulic fluid like a sieve.

“I emailed the implement dealer several times but never got a response. I also called several times and finally talked to a shop manager who assured me they would cover the cost of repairs. I repaired the unit to make it functional - making only the necessary repairs - and then sent the dealer an itemized bill as instructed. The bill was less than $300 because I did most of the work myself. However, I never received the money or got any response at all from the dealer to my followup emails and calls. Here are the lessons I learned: never buy equipment sight unseen and deal only with reputable people.”

Best Buy

DR weed trimmer

Stuart D. Hardee, Conway, S.C. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

Stuart is impressed with his pro model DR weed trimmer. “I really love it. I bought my first model in 1995. It was stolen two years later so I bought another one right away. I use it to mow a grave yard at my church and have found it to be a lot less tiring than using a ‘weedeater-type’ trimmer. All I’ve done is change the oil and buy a new battery. If anyone has problems with the lines breaking, then they’re probably buying cutting line from someone other than DR. If you buy the cutting line from them and install it in the cutterhead as instructed, you won’t have any problems - or at least I haven’t. This machine is definitely my best buy.”

Best Buy

MSE + 1 more

Jim Dinklage, Orchard, Neb. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“I’ve been in the livestock business for more than 30 years and have never used a feed additive product that has impressed me like MSE (multiple stabilized enzymes). It’s an all natural enzyme and live microbial product produced by Natur’s Way of Horton, Kansas (ph 785 486-3990). In 1997 my 170 head of pre-conditioned calves got sick about 30 days after they were weaned. They had runny noses and were coughing and had temperatures of more than 105 degrees. Instead of using an antibiotic in their feed ration I fed them MSE, and within three days the cattle returned to normal health. I’ve continued using MSE and haven’t had a sick animal since then. Another advantage is that I was able to stop purchasing commercial feed supplements. That’s because MSE extracts more non-digestible proteins from my homegrown feedstuffs. As a result, my cattle gain weight more efficiently and at less cost. MSE is 100 percent safe at any amount and can be used with any type of livestock.

“My 1994 Suzuki King Quad ATV has almost 13,000 miles on it. It has been to the shop only once, and that was for a tune-up just in the last 1,000 miles.”

Best Buy

CPR Engine Products + 1 more

Jeff Fultz, Elizabethtown, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My father, Irvin Fultz, is an automotive products distributor for CPR Engine Products (The S & S Group, 1018 Barnett Road, Columbus, Ohio 43227 ph 614 235-2773; email: [email protected]; website: www.cprauto.com). We think all their products are best buys, especially their diesel fuel conditioner (Irvin Fultz, 10503 W. 100 S., Hope, Ind. 47246 ph 812 663-9307). My father supplies several local school districts with diesel fuel conditioner for their bus fleets. These products actually perform as advertised. I use the diesel fuel conditioner in my Deere tractor and also in my Cummins engine-powered Dodge pickup. It keeps the fuel from gelling and also improves fuel efficiency.

“There’s even a kit you can purchase to use the conditioner in your car. You use one bottle in the gas tank, one bottle in the oil, and one that gets sucked in via a vacuum hose. After this, your car is guaranteed to pass any U.S. vehicle emissions test (even in California) for the next 200 miles.

“The conditioner actually breaks the water in gasoline down into such small particles that it will combine with fuel and pass through the fuel injection or carburetor. It contains no alcohol. My family had a garage for 20 years and we had little faith in additives (either oil or fuel) until we started using these products. They’re made by a small company in Ohio.”

On the minus side, he lists his 1995 Honda Accord EX equipped with a 2.2-liter V-tec engine and 4-speed automatic transmission. “The engine needed a lower end rebuild at 50,000 miles. The electrical system had a lot of problems from the battery all the way back to the tail lights. It also had rust problems in the rear quarters. I’ve owned 1978 and 1985 Accords, both of which went almost 300,000 miles and excelled in every way. The 1995 model performed like a newborn colt on ice.”

Worst Buy

Toro battery-powered electric lawn

Michael Cresanto, Pittsburgh, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My 1997 Toro battery-powered electric lawn mower had one problem after another. The motor quit working after the warranty expired. The batteries also failed, and replacement batteries weren’t available because the manufacturer quit making spare parts for the mower. After the charger quit working, I threw the whole thing into the garbage and went back to using a gas engine-powered model.”

Best Buy

Case 430 loader tractor

Fred Dilling, Hagerstown, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My 1964 Case 430 loader tractor is my best buy. I bought it used and am its third owner. This tractor has always been used on a dairy farm, but it wasn’t well cared for before I bought it. However, it has always worked well for me and is economical to operate.”

Best Buy

GM 4-WD pickup equipped

George R. Moser, Hardy, Va. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 13

“My 1995 GM 4-WD pickup equipped with a V-6 engine is my best buy. I bought the pickup used as a repossessed model and knew nothing about it, but I’ve put more than 200,000 miles on it with only minor repairs. It’s a very reliable pickup.”

Best Buy

Westendorf front-end loader

Henry C. Gutchak, Clio, Mich. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“It’s one of the best loaders on the market,” says Henry about his 2000 Westendorf front-end loader. “I use it on my 1967 Allis Chalmers D17 tractor. I have a New Idea 486 round baler that makes 5 by 6 bales, and this loader picks them up with ease. One person can quickly change from bucket to bale spear without having to get off the tractor.”

Best Buy

Roper riding mower equipped

Marvin Knoop, Shell Lake, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

A 1984 Roper riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck and 3-pt. mounted 4-ft. tiller rates as Marvin’s “best buy.” “The tractor is powered by a Briggs & Stratton 16 hp gas engine that still has the original spark plugs in it. I’ve replaced two belts and a few bearings in the mower deck. Otherwise, no problems. Unfortunately, the company that made it is no longer in business.”

Best Buy

GM 1/2-ton extended cab

Jerry Duerkop, New River, Arizona · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

Two years ago Jerry bought a used 1999 GM 1/2-ton extended cab, 3-door Sierra pickup equipped with a 5.3-liter, V-8 engine. It’s his “best buy.” “It has a quiet, comfortable ride, and handles well. It now has more than 55,000 miles on it. The only problem happened when a wire came off an electric window motor on one of the doors.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 pickup

Francis Puype, Payson, Ariz. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“It has more than 175,000 miles on it but still drives like new,” says Francis, pleased with his 1997 Dodge 1500 pickup. “It has been back to the garage only once, and that was just for a new fan clutch.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 14.4-volt cordless electric drill

Edward R. Schumann, Maynard, Minn. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“My wife bought me a DeWalt 14.4-volt cordless electric drill for Christmas three years ago, and I like it a lot. Everything on it works great. However, the batteries don’t hold their charge very long. I think the company should come up with an improved replacement model and offer it to all owners of the current model at a discount.”

Best Buy

Rhino Tuffy brush cutter

Donald Albright, Perkins, Okla. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

Donald is the satisfied owner of a Rhino Tuffy 6-ft. brush cutter. “It’s light enough that my 50 hp tractor can pick it up, yet it’s tough enough for any mowing job. I can go one gear faster than I can with any other mower and it still does a great job.”

Best Buy

Kubota 4-WD tractor

Erling Swiggum, Dodgeville, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

A 2001 Kubota 4-WD tractor rates as Erling’s “best buy.” “It starts easy in cold weather and drives nice. The muffler is mounted low so I don’t have to worry about knocking it off when going through doors, etc. I like being able to go in 4-WD both forward and backward. Also, this tractor is easy on fuel. If I ever do run out of fuel it’ll start right back up again without having to be primed first.”

Worst Buy

Meg-Mo lawn mower blades

Ray V. McDeid, Mead, Wash. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“My Meg-Mo lawn mower blades are my worst buy. Early last March I wrote company owner Roy Megli a letter, enclosing a close-up photo of my 6-ft., 3-blade, 3-pt. finish mower and inquiring about his blades. He called me on March 31, saying he could make a 3-blade set and ship them the following week. I agreed to let him charge my Visa $224.85 which included shipping and handling. After two phone calls, I finally received the blades 37 days after placing the order.

“I had my blades off and was putting the new ones on when I discovered he had sent the wrong blades. My photo clearly showed I needed left hand, counter clockwise blades, but he sent the opposite. He offered to send me the correct blades but I declined and told him I didn’t like his blades. They’re built too light, and he sent the wrong ones and I didn’t have time to unbolt and bolt a dozen blades on account of his mistake.

“I had to argue with him to get him to agree to pay the shipping charge to return the blades. He wouldn’t credit my Visa, but on May 8 he agreed to pay me the $224.85 plus $21 shipping (I didn’t charge him ‘handling’).”

“I nominate FARM SHOW as my best buy. I save each issue for a long time, then when they get dog-eared and worn, I pass them on to others.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 18-volt circular saw + 1 more

Joshua Abernathy, Covington, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“My best buy is my Sears Craftsman 18-volt circular saw, drill, and flashlight set. It has more than enough power - the batteries on it stay charged longer than any other brand I’ve used. As a result, the saw cuts tough, treated hardwood lumber with ease.

“My Mantis rototiller is a best buy. My only complaint is that the dealer I purchased it from doesn’t stock many spare parts such as special grease for the gearbox, air filters, or accessories. However, the rototiller itself works great. I’m really impressed with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Fielder’s Choice seed corn

Bob Stewart, Fishers, Ind. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“My worst buy was not really a buy at all. I ordered six bags of Intellicoat-treated Fielder’s Choice seed corn last winter for a comparison trial. When I got the seed it wasn’t the treated seed that I ordered. In fact, it wasn’t treated at all so I asked to return it. After many phone calls I finally got my refund but it was for $136 less than what I paid. And that doesn’t count the 80-mile trip I made to pick up the seed at the company’s drop-off point or the 180-mile trip I made to return the seed to their seed plant. Not a bad profit for this company, considering they still have the product. I’ll never buy from this company again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-250 4-WD 4-door + 1 more

Larry M. Preston, Pace, Fla. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“It has more than 324,000 miles on it but is still going strong,” says Larry, satisfied owner of a 2000 Ford F-250 4-WD, 4-door, long wheelbase pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter turbocharged engine and automatic transmission. “I use it to pull a 30-ft. gooseneck trailer. With a loaded trailer, total gross weight is 28,000 lbs. I replaced the water pump at 281,000 miles and the battery at 296,000 miles. I had to replace the second battery at 320,465 miles. I replaced the injector wiring harness and inside valve covers at 300,000 miles. The left front wheel hub and wheel bearing assembly were replaced at 291,000 miles. Considering what I’ve put this pickup through, it has really held up well. I plan to see just how long it’ll keep going.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Sony digital camera. “It’s cheaper to buy a new camera than to have this one repaired. I got no help from the company.”

Best Buy

Jay Dee Enterprises, Inc + 2 more

Mike Hanley, Cashton, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

Mike nominates replacement V-belts sold by Jay Dee Enterprises, Inc. as his “best buy” (3465 Lost Nation Road, Unit 15, Willoughby, Ohio 44094 ph 800 989-0162 or 440 946-9367; website: www.jdv-belts.com). The company bills itself as a farm market supplier of “quality V-belts at economical prices.” If they don’t have a scarce replacement belt in stock, they can have one custom made.

“They sell an endless belt which can be cut to any length. It was a life saver for us,” says Mike. “We used one on a 1960 Deere 430 crawler equipped with a Deere 90 loader. The hydraulic pump on this crawler is mounted up front, so to replace the fan belt and also the generator belt you have to just about totally disassemble the entire front end of the crawler. We broke the generator belt on a Sunday, and I ordered a replacement belt off the company’s website that night. Monday morning I got an email from them stating that the order had been received. The package was delivered on Tuesday via Fed Ex, and ten minutes later we were rolling. The smallest order they take is 10 ft. so we have plenty left for future use.

“Our Deere 430 crawler is also a best buy. It has a factory 3-pt. and pto and is a handy little workhorse. Not everyone needs a big D8 Cat sitting in their shed. We totally rebuilt it from the radiator cap all the way back to the drawbar. We use it with a rotary mower in our pastures, and we also use it with a 3-pt. rear blade to move dirt. I would think there would be a market for this size crawler, except that today it would probably be made overseas and would be overpriced. If it were made again today it would have to be built with 1960’s made-in-America quality.”

“I like the Pengo auger teeth we mounted on our Deere 31 3-pt. posthole digger. The abuse this digger has been through in rocks is unbelievable but the teeth still look like new. I bought the auger teeth years ago while they were still being made by an independent company located in California. The company has since been bought out and is now headquartered in Laurens, Iowa (ph 800 599-2011; website: www.pengocorp.com).

Best Buy

John Deere 6 + 3 more

H.H. Reeves, St. George, S.C. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 14

“Our 1998 Deere 6 by 4 Gator is our best buy. We’ve spent only about $300 on repairs.

“The Sears 300-amp electric welder we bought in 1957 still works fine. No problems.

“Our Sears 80-amp battery charger is more than 25 years old, and the only repair it ever needed was to a fan motor. This battery charger still works great.”

On the minus side, “Everything that could go wrong, did go wrong on my Deere 4435 combine. The wheels came off, the elevator housing wore out, and the straw chopper blades came out and cut a hole into the sheet metal on back of the combine. The front wheel housing doesn’t line up with the transmission shaft, and electric switches controlling the hydraulics don’t work. This machine was made in Germany so some of the bolts are metric and some aren’t. As a result you need two sets of wrenches to work on this machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kawasaki Mule 2510 + 1 more

Wayne LeClair, Francestown, N.H. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“My 1997 Kawasaki Mule 2510 has performed great with no problems. I use chains on the rear tires during the winter which allows me to use the machine all year long.

“My Milwaukee 14-in. handheld cut-off saw is my worst buy. The arbor nut easily overtightens during use. Also, the saw’s housing broke within the first month of use.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toyota pickup + 1 more

Robert Martin, Bennington, Okla. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“I bought my 1986 Toyota pickup used in 1987. It now has more than 230,000 miles on it but is still going strong. Several years ago I mounted a bale spear on the bed and also put heavy duty leaf springs on back so I can haul round bales. It does a great job. No problems so far.

“My 2002 Rhino TW120 mower is my worst buy. I was able to use it for only a few hours before a gearbox went out on it. The company sent us a new gearbox, but a few days later it went out, too. A mechanic said the gearboxes they used were the wrong ones for that model. The company sent us a new mower but it wasn’t long before the driveshaft broke on it. We had it fixed and now the mower works alright.”

Best Buy

Kuhn 3-pt disc mower

Brian McNeice, Brattleboro, Vt. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“I bought my mid 1970’s Kuhn 3-pt. disc mower used a few years ago and use it for mowing pasture. I wouldn’t part with it. It mows through everything including brambles and heavy burdock and swamp grass at high speeds, and it doesn’t seem to mind rocks that much.”

Best Buy

Cyclone Rake vacuum-powered mulcher + 1 more

Phillip L. White, Murfreesboro, Ark. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“My 2001 Cyclone Rake vacuum-powered mulcher is my best buy (Woodland Power Products, Inc., 72 Acton Street, West Haven, Ct. 06516 ph toll free 888 531-7253). It hitches to your riding mower and turns it into an outdoor cleanup machine. The rig is powered by a 5 hp engine and comes with a 200-gal.collector bag and a big 7-in. dia. vacuum hose. The unit is said to provide 10 times the lifting power of mowers, and 5 to 10 times the capacity.

According to the company, dry materials, like leaves and sticks, are reduced 4 to 8 times in volume as they pass first through your mower blades, and then through a 3,500 rpm mulcher unit. You can use the machine to sweep and pulverize leaves or mow tall grass without clogging or stopping. The unit can pick up just about any lawn debris your mower blades can safely handle including sticks, twigs, and pine needles. The rig has a double-acting hitch design that allows you to steer into and out of tight areas without jackknifing. The unit unloads like a dump truck - all you do is lift and drive away.

“It leaves my lawn looking like a golf course. Pine cones, leaves, and grass clippings are all picked up. I used it last year to make a huge compost pile and have started another one this year.

“My 2001 New Holland Boomer 4-WD tractor equipped with a 45 hp engine is a best buy. It’s fast and efficient and has power to spare. To go forward or reverse you operate a foot pedal, which is a real time saver. This tractor has a very short turning radius and a deceptively powerful hydraulic system. It’s well made and has convenient controls. No problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Lumina 4-door car + 1 more

Charles McClenning, Independence, Kansas · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“My 1998 Chevrolet Lumina 4-door car is my best buy. It has a lot of power and the air conditioner works great. It drives well and the engine doesn’t use any oil. We’re quite proud of this car.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1984 Cub Cadet garden tractor equipped with a 17 hp Kohler engine and hydrostatic transmission. “It has only 864 hours on it, and I haven’t used it at all for the past six years. It uses oil like mosquito repellent but the company wouldn’t do anything about the problem. Another problem is that the tractor always failed to start. The company wanted $1,250 to put in a new engine, not including labor. On the positive side, I love the way this tractor drives, and it has a good hydrostatic transmission. Also, it does a good job of mowing.”

Best Buy

Kubota ZD18F zero turn riding

Floyd Appelgate, Marshalltown, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“My Kubota ZD18F zero turn riding mower equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. It has a lot of power. The deck raises hydraulically, which I like, and the controls are all on the right hand side which is important to me as I have a bad left arm. No complaints so far.”

Best Buy

Ford Escape SUV equipped

Anne and Bob Melchert, Bettendorf, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 15

“I want to warn your readers about the 2001 Ford Escape SUV equipped with a V-6 engine. We really liked ours for the first 48 miles that we drove it, and then we started having problems. We’d be driving along and the vehicle would just stop running. No lights, no power brakes, no power steering - nothing at all. But then it would start back up.

“I took the vehicle back to the dealer and they called a Ford technician in to work on it. The technician called us and said the vehicle was ready to go. However, after I picked it up the same problem started happening again. The company’s technicians had this vehicle more often than I did. My dad ran a copy of the Iowa lemon law off the internet and we then sent a registered letter to the company, stating that we no longer wanted this vehicle because it was unsafe to drive. After about one month someone from the company called and in so many words informed me that the problem was all due to my imagination, even though they had tried to fix the vehicle eight different times. We ended up hiring a lawyer, and went six months without having a vehicle to drive.

“After all was said and done, our replacement vehicle ended up costing us $5,000.”