Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001)

62 reports from pages 14–17 · 52 Best Buys27 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best BuyWorst Buy

J & M 750-bu grain cart equipped + 1 more

Alec Yeager, Hendley, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“My 1999 J & M 750-bu. grain cart equipped with a hydraulic-operated spout is my best buy. It pulls easy and smooth in the field and dumps fast without vibrating. The hydraulic-operated spout makes it easy to fill a truck without overloading one side of it.

“My 1999 Convey-All belt-type tub conveyor is my worst buy. I bought three of these units for use in my grain cleaning business. However, I’m convinced the company’s engineers didn’t have a tape measure or a notepad when they designed this machine. It moves only about one third as much material as advertised and is a bit crude. Fortunately, it has enough capacity for what I use it for.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Isuzu pickup equipped + 2 more

Arnold Fish, Bremerton, Wash. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“My 1981 Isuzu pickup equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. I bought it used in 1988. It has more than 262,000 miles on it, yet I still drive it every day. The engine has never been taken apart although it does use some oil now. The starter and alternator are original. The transmission had problems shortly after I bought it and had to be rebuilt and upgraded. This pickup has only about 57 horsepower so it shouldn’t be used for hauling big loads or for pulling trailers - However, it has been reliable and gets more than 30 miles per gallon. I attribute much of its longevity to the Chevron Delo 400 15/40 motor oil I use in it. I use Delo motor oil in all my equipment.

“My 1973 International Harvester 1310 1-ton pickup, which I bought used, is my worst buy. I tried to fix it up but it broke a piston the first time I really put it to work. Fortunately, I was only out about $1,200 and the time I spent working on it.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 1/2-ton longbed pickup

C.A. Wilder, Dallas, Texas · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“My 1993 Chevrolet 1/2-ton longbed pickup has more than 220,000 miles on it and is my best buy. It hasn’t required any major repairs. All I have to do is change the oil and transmission fluid regularly. This pickup still looks good, too. I put new Hoosier tires on it about every 50,000 miles. I guess I’ll drive it until the wheels fall off.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 3500 equipped + 1 more

Jerry Kroll, Montague, Mich. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“This pickup is a pleasure to own,” reports Jerry about his 1999 Dodge 3500 equipped with a Cummins DSL engine and 5-speed transmission. “I own five different trailers and have yet to find anything that this pickup can’t pull easily. It has a comfortable ride and gets 24 miles per gallon. I’ve put more than 40,000 miles on it without a breakdown. I’m well satisfied with it.”

On the negative side, he lists his 1996 Gehl 2175 9-ft. mower-conditioner. “The third year I owned it the conditioning roll shaft broke. I had an expert analyze the metal in the shaft and he concluded that the problem was poor metal. My dealer wouldn’t help at all. I had used the machine to cut only a total of about 1,500 acres. I had to spend $3,000 on repairs. I was able to cut only five more acres with it before the main shaft coming off the gearbox broke. I traded the machine in for a Hesston 1340 12-ft. model and haven’t been back to the company since.”

Best Buy

Case backhoes

Roland Tordeur, Green Bay, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“I’ve owned three Case backhoes in the last 20 years and they’ve all been best buys. I sold my 1980 580 C model when it had about 6,800 hours on it. It required very little maintenance. When I sold it I actually got $2,000 more than I had paid for it. My 1994 580 SK model had about 5,000 hours on it when I traded it off for a new 2000 590 Super L, which is the best one I’ve had. It has a lot of power and comfort.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

MacDon 9300 swather + 1 more

Tommy Carey, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“My 1997 MacDon 9300 swather has plenty of power. I like the big tires front and back which allows it to ride smooth even over center pivot irrigation tracks. It has a comfortable air ride seat and a quiet cab.

“My Water Ace submersible water pump is my worst buy. I used it in a sump for pumping livestock water. One day the pump burned out. The dealer gave me another pump but it failed, too. Each time all the oil in the pump leaked out which made a big mess in the water. I switched back to a better known brand and haven’t had any more problems.”

Best Buy

Farmi 456 3-pt mounted winch

August Andersen, Long Eddy, N.Y. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

August likes his Farmi 456 3-pt. mounted winch. “I use it on my 70 hp tractor and it does an excellent job. It really comes in handy for retrieving tractors and wagons stuck in muddy fields. The cable can reach up to 150 ft. away.”

Worst Buy

Berkline deluxe recliner chair

Dak. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

Burton likes his 1983 Sears chainsaw. “We use it every year to cut enough firewood for the entire winter, and after we’re done it’s always ready to go for the next winter. It has never let us down.

“My 2000 Berkline deluxe recliner chair equipped with a heat and back massager is my worst buy. The back brackets and the metal frame rivets broke. It has been in the shop for three weeks and still hasn’t been fixed.”

Best Buy

John Deere Gator AMT 622 utility vehicle + 1 more

Calvin Ray Wilson, Campbellsburg, Ky. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

A 1990 Deere Gator AMT 622 utility vehicle rates as Calvin’s “best buy”. “I’m well pleased with it and haven’t had any problems at all. It’s by far the handiest machine I own and is a lot of fun to drive for checking fields and small hauling jobs. Saves a lot of wear and tear on my pickup. It’s equipped with an electric dump bed which makes it ideal for hauling dirt and rocks. I don’t know what I’d do without this vehicle.

“My 1997 Ford F-250 XLT 4-WD supercab pickup rides and handles like a car and is a best buy. I bought it used two years ago and haven’t had any problems with it at all. The 4.6-liter, V-89 has engine is easy on fuel, even though this pickup has an automatic transmission. I like being able to shift to 4-WD on-the-go. I also like the cab, which has plenty of room. I’ve always owned Ford pickups and this is the best one yet.”

Best Buy

New Holland TR 87 combine + 1 more

Howard Braun, Saline, Mich. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

Howard owns a 1997 New Holland TR 87 combine. “I had some problems with it the first year while harvesting wheat. The dealer changed the concaves, which solved the problem. Now it works fine.

“We’ve had problems with Goodyear implement and front tractor tires. When the tires are about half worn they open up where they’ve been spliced together.”

Best Buy

GM Z71 Sierra 1/2-ton extended cab pickup

Jess Rodgers, Douglas, Wyo. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“My 2000 GM Z71 Sierra 1/2-ton extended cab pickup equipped with a 5.3-liter, V-8 engine and automatic transmission is my best buy. It rides great and has a “Tow-Haul” transmission mode which allows it to tow very well. I use it to pull loaded 16-ft. livestock trailers over country roads. The only negative is that I don’t like the lights coming on automatically. Also, sometimes cows inside the trailer shake the pickup enough while it’s parked to set off the pickup’s theft alarm.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped

Nelson Nolt, Womelsdorf, Pa. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“It’s the best pickup I’ve ever owned,” says Nelson about his 1986 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.9-liter diesel engine and 4-speed transmission. “It has more than 300,000 miles on it but still uses very little oil. It gets 14 mpg. The engine has never been touched except for a rebuilt fuel injection pump. It still steers tight without wandering all over the road. My next pickup will definitely be a Ford.”

Best Buy

SnowFlame 2100 corn burning stove

Phil Funk, Dallas Center, Iowa · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“We’re happy with our SnowFlame 2100 corn burning stove. We used it to heat our 1,800 sq. ft. house from Thanksgiving Day to last May and it burned only about 150 bushels of corn. It performed even better than advertised. It’s a neat, clean, and attractive unit that cost about $1,400. We burned wood for 24 years to heat our house, but we find that heating with corn is much cleaner, safer, and a lot less work.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 pickup

Doug McAlexander, Cedar Grove, Tenn. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“I bought my 1989 Ford F-250 pickup three years ago. I found that when the temperature dropped to about 50 degrees the pickup was hard to start.

“If I sprayed ether into the air filter it would start right up. So I ordered an ether assist starting kit from a salvage yard - the kind used on IH 86 series tractors - and installed it on the engine. I made a bracket and bolted it on with the two bolts that hold the fuel filter on. I drilled a hole in the bottom of the air filter to attach a 1/8-in. dia. plastic line from the ether assist. I accomplished this by using a 1/4-in. dia. pipe nipple, coupling and reducer in the air filter. I put a push button inside the cab. One split second push on the button and the truck starts good. It cost about $60 for the ether assist and supplies to install it.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5410 tractor 3 1/2

James L. Bryant, Camden, Ark. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“I bought a Deere 5410 tractor 3 1/2 years ago. They had a recall on the clutch push rod last summer and replaced it with a new type of rod. Last February I was using the tractor to pile up brush and the new rod came loose. I didn’t get the tractor stopped until I got up into the brush pile. I’m glad I wasn’t burning the brush or else I would have burned up my tractor. I stopped the tractor by turning off the key. The problem was that the nut on the upper end of the push rod had come off. The company needs to redesign this rod so the nut won’t come off.”

Best Buy

Ram D150 4-WD 1/2-ton power + 2 more

Glen Ray Goodson, Galax, Va. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“My 1979 Dodge D150 4-WD 1/2-ton Power Wagon pickup has about 320,000 miles on it and is still going strong. It’s a dependable pickup. All I’ve done is grease the brakes and change the oil, belts, and hoses.

“My 1950 Ford 1 1/2-ton dual wheel flatbed truck has required only routine maintenance and is a best buy. It runs better now than it did when it was new.”

Wayne and Glenda Tankursky, front turn signals were changed during a recall. This was my second V-70 model. I gave the first one back after putting only about 1,500 miles on it. The rotors had warped and the transmission leaked. I think Volvo has gone downhill ever since Ford bought them.

Best BuyWorst Buy

Vermeer Rebel 5500 round baler + 2 more

Barduell, Ky. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“We’re well pleased with our new Vermeer Rebel 5500 round baler. We bought it after using a Gehl model for 23 years. We also bought a new Vermeer wheel rake. Both machines do a great job.

“Our 1992 Chevrolet Caprice car equipped with a small V-8-liter engine is a best buy. It gets more than 30 miles per gallon on trips and drives great.

“The worst buy we ever made was a Howse 7-ft. pull-type mower. The blade broke the first year while we were mowing clean, light weeds. Then the second year the whole bottom section that holds the blades broke. The company wouldn’t do anything to help.”

Best Buy

John Deere 8400T wide track tractor

Steven Holl, Conrad, Iowa · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

Steven likes his 1999 Deere 8400T wide track tractor. “This tractor has outstanding flotation, traction, power, and comfort. It’s equipped with tracks spaced 120 in. apart. I like them because they don’t scuff the ground very much when turning. The tracks take a lot of roughness out of the field. Also, steering is so much easier than with my older wheeled tractor. I’ll never go back to a wheeled tractor.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 455 garden tractor equipped

Loren Burger, Bartlesville, Okla. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“My 1998 Deere 455 garden tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower is my worst buy. One problem is that the air intake is located low and behind the left front wheel, which allows dust and dirt kicked up by the wheel to be drawn into the air cleaner. Also, the vacuum gauge that indicates a dirty filter doesn’t work properly. The dealer says this gauge was designed to be used on larger tractors. Deere might know how to build large tractors, but it’s obvious that the people who design their small tractors have never used one in the real world.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Volvo V-70 car + 1 more

Jeff Cathcart, Hope, R.I. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“My 2000 Volvo V-70 car is my worst buy. It has only about 8,000 miles on it but has already been back to the dealer five times. It came equipped with a faulty spark plug; the ARS system didn’t work; there was a recall on the trunk latch; the hazard switch failed; one of the power window switches failed; and the

“My 1988 Volvo 240 DL was my best buy. I sold it with about 285,000 miles on it, and even then the engine still didn’t use a drop of oil. The battery and exhaust both lasted more than 200,000 miles. As far as I know this car is still being driven.”

Best Buy

Polaris 4-WD ATV equipped

Wade Biwer, Fish Creek, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“My best buy is my 1993 Polaris 350cc 4-WD ATV equipped with a water-cooled engine. I use it all year long to plow snow and to pull a trailer around for small hauling jobs. I also do a lot of trail riding with it. It has about 9,000 miles on it but has required only routine maintenance. I wish all machines would work as well as this one.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4010 tractor + 1 more

Robert T. Valentine, Wolsey, S. Dak. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

“I retired from farming in 1994. At the time of my retirement I had a Deere 4010 tractor which I had bought used and operated for 16 years. The only work I had to do on the engine was to rebuild the water pump twice and replace the fuel pump once. I really liked that tractor.

“I also had a best buy International Har-vester Wheatland 560 tractor equipped with a diesel engine. It was a very rare model that was sold mainly in the winter wheat areas of western North Dakota and Montana. It had a quite short wheelbase and a short turning radius, which made it ideal to use on my double Rowse mower.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Poulan ES300 electric chain saw + 1 more

Neil G. Gow, Appleton, N.Y. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

Neil’s the satisfied owner of a Poulan ES300 electric chain saw. “I bought it for $90 at Home Depot and it has worked well all winter. The automatic oiler is superb. The saw is on its second chain but shows no signs of slowing down. I’m not sure how much wood I’ve cut with it, but I did recently clean up about 40 gallons of sawdust. My only problem is the ribbing I take from my friends who own gas engine-operated saws.

“My Dish 500 satellite receiver is my worst buy. It has been a marginal product from the start. Poor functioning, poor technical support, and a less-than-helpful dealer. It starts losing channels in the slightest drizzle, and the only solution is to buy a $60 weather cover that should have been included in the original price. After owning a PrimeStar dish I’m very disappointed with this one, but DirecTV bought out PrimeStar so I can’t go back. I plan to return to using a plain old rooftop antenna.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Remington 870 Express 12-gauge shotgun + 1 more

Will Brewer, Jackson, Miss. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My 1998 Remington 870 Express 12-gauge shotgun is my best buy. It works well, didn’t cost much, and has never had a malfunction of any kind. Disassembling and cleaning it is a simple job. My family and friends have used this gun as much as I have. I added an aftermarket sling to make it easier to carry on long treks.”

On the negative side, he lists the Briggs & Stratton vertical shaft engine on his Murray riding mower. “I bought this mower to cut a small yard. It soon developed an engine miss that got progressively worse. I took it to the nearest authorized Briggs & Stratton repair center. They made the repair but charged $50 to the retailer I bought the mower from. I was told the problem was that there was trash in the fuel. I have several small engines that use this same fuel with ‘trash’, and they all run well. To prevent the problem from happening again, I bought a new gas container and made sure the fuel was impeccably clean. However, the next time I used the mower the same problem happened again. I returned the mower to the authorized Briggs & Stratton warranty center. They charged me $50 this time, saying the problem was my fault.

“Before I left the dealer I tried to start the mower, but it wouldn’t start. The dealer kept the mower so that a factory representative could check it out. The rep said that the diaphragm in the carburetor had been damaged by dirt in the fuel. Then I took the mower home but couldn’t keep it running for even an hour. I finally junked the mower. I’ll continue to use the other Briggs & Stratton engines that I already have, but I don’t plan to purchase any more new ones. Factory support is poor at best.”

Worst Buy

Dakota Alert

Tim Sollman, Clayton, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

Tim isn’t happy with the driveway alarms he bought about seven years ago from Dakota Alert. “The alarm system wasn’t working so I returned it to the company for repairs. They said the product wasn’t under warranty and wouldn’t even look at it to see if it could be repaired. However, they said they would sell me a new system. They said parts aren’t available for this unit. I guess they haven’t heard of Radio Shack.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram D250 pickup equipped + 1 more

Robert Ellis, High Hill, Mo. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

A 1991 Dodge D250 pickup equipped with a Cummins 5.9-liter engine rates as Robert’s “best buy”. “I’ve had very few problems with the engine.

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1990 Ford pickup. “The problems it had were too numerous to mention. I had always been a Ford person, but this pickup converted me into a Dodge person.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kawasaki Prairie 400 4-WD atv + 7 more

David J. Peckham, Callaway, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“It gets a lot of hard use, but we’ve had very little trouble with it,” says David about his 1998 Kawasaki Prairie 400 4-WD ATV. “The company took care of a few minor problems. I have an artificial leg so I appreciate the automatic transmission. The floor board design is also helpful. There are more powerful ATV’s on the market, but after riding them for a while I really came to appreciate this machine.”

“My 1979 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup is a best buy. It has been all over the country and has been in a few tangles that required some hospitalization, but it came away better for it all.

“My 1972 Deere 4620 and 3020 tractors are dependable and are best buys.

“I’m well pleased with my Deere 535 round baler. I’ve owned Hesston and Gehl models before but this is the best.

“My biggest disappointments have been with my Case-IH 470 and 480 21-ft. disks. In my opinion, these discs were nothing but glorified sheet metal. I sold both of them and bought a Deere 14-ft. model. I can cover the same amount of ground as I had been covering with the two Case-IH models, and do a better job. No problems.

“My Hesston 6650 swather is a disaster. I don’t understand how a company can even put its name on a machine like this. I wish I still owned my Deere 1600 14-ft. hydraswing swather.

“I was given a kit to raise the rear bench seat in my 1985 Ford Supercab pickup. It was purchased through J.C. Whitney and was something that I had asked for. However, it’s a worst buy. The bolt holes in the brackets were about three sizes too big, the washers were too small, and I had to reshape some of them to fit. I was really disappointed with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Milwaukee + 1 more

Terry Swearingen, Wyanet, Ill. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My Milwaukee 7-in. side grinder is my best buy. After two years of heavy use, it shot sparks out of the motor vents and lost power. I boxed it up and sent it to a company service center. In less than a week they sent it back to me prepaid with a new armature and brushes. It was covered by the warranty so they didn’t charge anything. Milwaukee power tools may cost a little more, but they’re definitely worth it.

“My Deere 9500 combine, which I bought used, is my worst buy. The company found out they had some combines with soft crank-shafts under the straw walkers and implemented a cost-share program to replace them. It turned out the previous owner didn’t participate in the program so the combine sat on the dealer’s lot for most of the program’s duration. We used this combine for two years before we even knew about the crankshaft problem. By the time we found out about it, the program had expired and the dealership changed hands. Our only recourse was with the company, but a factory block man said he couldn’t help us. We’re disappointed the company wouldn’t stand behind this product.”

Best Buy

J-B Weld

Alan Millikan, Germanton, N.C. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

J-B Weld rates as Alan’s “best buy” (J-B Weld Co., Box 483, Sulphur Springs, Texas 75483 ph 800 529-3530 or 903 885-7696).

“I still have the original package that I bought with the price sticker on it. I know I’ve saved hundreds and maybe thousands of dollars by using this product. It’s worth many times more than what it sells for,” says Alan. J-B Weld is sold as an inexpensive alternative to welding, soldering, and brazing and can be used to repair damaged welds and solders. It comes packaged in two tubes. One contains liquid steel/epoxy resin, and the other contains hardener. When mixed together in equal portions, a chemical reaction occurs that turns the mixture into a compound that’s said to be as hard and tough as steel.

Like metal, J-B Weld can be formed, drilled, ground, tapped, machined, filled, sanded, and painted. It stays pliable for about 30 minutes after mixing, sets in 4 to 6 hours, and cures fully in 15 to 24 hours chains to mess with.”

Best Buy

Melroe Bobcat 773G skid steer loader + 1 more

John Knierim, Glasgow, Mont. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

John’s happy with his Melroe Bobcat 773G skid steer loader and a Miller 250 amp Bobcat engine-drive welder. “Both of these machines were expensive up front, but I wouldn’t farm without them. We use them almost every day. The skid loader has run trouble-free from day one and has required only routine maintenance. We’ve used the welder to repair many cultivators in the field. It’s a real time saver because we don’t have to waste half the day just getting the machine moved back to the shop so we can repair it.”

Best Buy

Ryobi 12-volt 3/8 cordless

Richard W. Bergman, Gleason, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“I like my 1997 Ryobi 12-volt, 3/8 cordless drill which we use to tap maple trees. We can tap about 50 trees before the battery has to be recharged. A fuse burned out on the charger last fall but it cost only 75 cents to replace.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tundra 2-WD SR5 pickup equipped + 1 more

James R. Hursh, Cropwell, Ala. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

James is impressed with his 2000 Toyota Tundra 2-WD SR5 pickup equipped with a V-8 engine. “It has a lot of power and pulls a load with ease. It gets about 18 mpg which I think is reasonable. It also has plenty of ground clearance and a comfortable ride.

“My Northstar log splitter, which I bought from Northern Hydraulics, is powered by a Honda gas engine and does an excellent job. For years I had been splitting wood by hand so this hydraulic-operated splitter is a real labor saver.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 4-piece set

John Schuster, Cuba City, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

John owns a DeWalt 4-piece set of battery-operated tools which includes a skil saw, sawzall, drill, and light. They’re all operated by an 18-volt battery. “I used it when I built a 20 by 24-ft. garage with a 12 by 24-ft. lean-to on the back side. The saw and sawzall used up the battery faster and lasted about one hour if they were used hard. However, I got three to four hours of use at a time from the drill unless it hit sappy wood. I’d recommend this 4-piece set to anyone.”

Best Buy

Gravely 817 garden tractor

Ralph Grote, Decatur, Ind. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My best buy is my 1978 Gravely 817 garden tractor. I use it with a 50-in. mower deck, 30-in. tiller, and a snowblower. It’s a real four-season machine. In 1982 I bought a 4-ft. sicklebar mower and adapted it to the tractor’s pto and hydraulic lift. I use it to mow side ditches alongside our county roads. I also made a sprayer boom that lets me be on the road and still reach fence lines along fields. I’ve also used the boom to spot spray thistle patches in our fields. I made my own cab. This tractor seems indestructible.”

Best Buy

Belarus 400

Charles F. Batson, Hope, Ark. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My Belarus 400 AN tractor has performed well after the factory replaced a casting that was out of round. The test is, would I buy another one? Yes - tomorrow.

“I attended a farm show recently. They had eight brands of tractors on display, and seven of them were made in other countries.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 425 garden tractor + 2 more

Charles T. Koenig, Cuero, Texas · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My 2000 Deere 425 garden tractor is my best buy. I owned a smaller Deere garden tractor for 10 years before I bought this model. It still has the same great quality.”

“My 1993 Ford 5610 II tractor equipped with wide rear tires and an extra flow hydraulic pump is a best buy.

“My Sears Craftsman high wheel trimmer is my worst buy. The problem is that it leaks oil. I should’ve known better because I had previously owned a Sears riding mower which needed repairs almost every week. However, when my DR trimmer finally wore out I decided to try Sears one more time, which was a mistake.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kent Discovator + 2 more

Neal Niebruegge, Nebraska City, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My 1998 Kent Discovator does a good job of leveling the soil, has a lot of trash clearance, and is easy to adjust.

On the “worst buy” side, he lists the Goodyear Wrangler tires on his pickup. “All four tires separated down the center. Friends of mine had these tires on their trucks and work vans and had the same problem. The company didn’t provide much help.

“I purchased retread tires from High-Tec Retreading in Edgemont, S. Dak They’ve held up well and, at $49.99 per tire, are a real value.”

Best Buy

Bill Reeks

Greg Neymeyer, Northfield, Minn. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“I bought plans for a do-it-yourself bandsaw mill from Bill Reeks in Cromwell, Ky. He supplies wonderful plans with lots of color photos. In fact, if you should need more than one set, you’re money ahead to just order the extra copies right from him. The cost of having them copied is more than if you’d ordered extra copies direct from Bill. Besides that, he personalizes each order, which is a nice touch.”

Worst Buy

Ram 2500 pickup equipped

Henry Boutin, Carlyle, Sask. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“My 1998 Dodge 2500 pickup, equipped with a 24-valve diesel engine and 5-speed transmission, is my worst buy. It’s a good solid pickup, but it’s hard on fuel and the dealer claims the fuel efficiency can’t be improved. At about 50,000 miles a lock nut backed off inside the transmission, which caused fifth gear to quit working. The dealer wanted $1,000 to repair it. I called the Daimler Chrysler headquarters but they didn’t seem the least bit interested. I had the transmission repaired at a reliable transmission shop for $450. My dealer said they had already repaired more than 30 pickups that had the same problem. I’ll buy from Ford the next time around.”

Worst Buy

Husqvarna 136 chain saw

Paul Price, Goldston, N.C. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“My Husqvarna 136 chain saw is my worst buy. It starts hard whether it’s hot or cold out. After limited use it started leaking fuel, and we’ve had trouble getting it repaired. When it does run, it cuts fine and has ample power for its size.”

Worst Buy

Owen Corning roofing

Danny Hudson, Middleton, Tenn. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“My worst buy is Owen Corning roofing. I built a new home in 1992 and used this roofing because I thought a name brand with a guarantee would be the best way to go. Boy, was I wrong. Within the first year the roofer had to come back three different times to replace shingles. I called the supplier and they said that the roofer had installed the shingles wrong.

“For five years I got the run-around and for five years the roofer had to keep coming back. The problem was that the tar tabs weren’t holding. The company that sold the roofing went out of business. I called Owen Corning to see about my guarantee. They told me to read the fine print. Apparently, the tar tabs are guaranteed for only five years. Also, they told me the 25-year guarantee covered only the sand on the shingles. You’d think a company as big as this one would guarantee its entire product, as the public is led to believe. But then on second thought, maybe that’s how they got so big.”

Worst Buy

Ram 2500 4-WD pickup equipped

Gaston Hamoline, Domremy, Sask. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“My 1998 Dodge Ram 2500 4-WD pickup, equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and automatic transmission, is my worst buy. The steering box was hard to turn, which causes the vehicle to wander unpredictably. I really have to keep my eyes on the road. A new steering box solved the problem.

“I also had problems with the automatic transmission. Whenever I put it in gear it would behave like two gears were meshed so the pickup wouldn’t move. I had the transmission and it’s computer controls replaced, but it didn’t solve the problem. So far I’ve had to pay half the cost of the new transmission. I’d like to know if other people have had these problems.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman 2 hp 7 1/4-in

Sam C. Parsons, Sugar Grove, Va. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

Sam says his Sears Craftsman 2 hp 7 1/4-in. Skil saw is his “worst buy”. “I’m a building contractor so I use many different brands of tools. This one didn’t last even one day on the job. I sent it back to the factory for repairs and had to wait about three months to get it back. Then I was able to make only about 10 cuts with it before it blew up again. Again, I had to wait three months to get it back, and this time I got a $45 bill for repairs. That’s when I decided to throw the saw in the trash. I currently use Makita, DeWalt, and Milwaukee tools. No more Sears Craftsman power tools for me.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland 648 Silage Special round baler + 1 more

Bill Smyth, Langley, B.C. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

Bill’s impressed with his New Holland 648 Silage Special round baler. “I’ve used or tested numerous round balers over the past five years, and this one consistently makes the best bales without needing much operator intervention.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Cub Cadet riding mower. “The belts keep breaking and the dealer can’t do anything about it. The maintenance required on this machine is expensive and time consuming.”

Worst Buy

Whip Battery Protector

Alan Smock, Dubois, Ind. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“I bought a product called Whip Battery Protector at the 2000 Louisville Farm Show and it’s my worst buy. It’s made by PRO-TEC of Humboldt, Kansas, and is supposed to prevent corrosion on battery terminals. I applied it to the cleaned terminals on my riding mower and two tractors. What a mistake. The product appears to be oil-based and when it got hot, the material apparently worked its way between the terminal and the battery post, preventing current flow. Before the summer was over, I had taken apart all of the battery connections and scraped the product off the terminals and the battery posts. The product actually caused the problem that it was advertised to prevent.

“When I went back to the Louisville show this year, I stopped by their booth and they were still selling the product. They said they had never heard of any problems but they offered a refund. I urge people not to use this product.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chicago Elec-tric cordless drill + 1 more

Rusty Jamison, Leavenworth, Kansas · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“I like my 3/8-in., 14.4-volt Chicago Elec-tric cordless drill. I bought it for $39.99, which I think was a good price.

“My MTD 10 hp chipper-shredder is my worst buy. Before I bought it I called the company to make sure the machine would handle black walnuts. They said it would so I bought it. However, I’ve found it blows the walnuts right through the side of the plastic hopper.”

Worst Buy

Sears Home Central furnace

Roger Duff, New Holland, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

Roger says his Sears Home Central furnace, which he bought in 1997, is his “worst buy”. “I bought it because their price was about $1,000 less than other models but last January the furnace quit. Sears couldn’t come out for two weeks to make repairs, so I called another furnace repair service. I was informed that the heat exchanger was cracked and that since this company didn’t install the furnace, they would have to charge for repairs. They told me the furnace wasn’t installed correctly which was why the exchanger had failed. However, they said that since the furnace was under warranty, Sears would repair the furnace under warranty.

“When Sears finally showed up, the technician informed me that I would have to pay for parts, but they would cover the cost for labor. When I asked why, I was informed that Sears doesn’t honor the warranty on its products if they’re installed by an independent contractor. Since the service call was the result of faulty installation, Sears then refused to honor any of the warranty and charged the full repair bill for both parts and labor.

“Since virtually all of Sears home services are done by independent contractors, I don’t think the company honors any warranty at all. “ (ph 608 967-2120).

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mahindra 5002 tractor equipped + 1 more

Ernie Downing, Hornbeak, Tenn. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

Ernie’s impressed with his Mahindra 5002 tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “I couldn’t be more pleased. It has done everything I needed without any serious problems or downtime.

“My 1988 Deere 850 4-WD tractor was one of my worst buys ever. It was the hardest tractor to get on or off I ever saw. It had brake problems all the time and also electric wiring problems. I traded it in for the Mahindra model and bless the day that it left our farm.”

Best Buy

Homelite XL2 chain saw

Dan Shannon, Green Bay, Wis. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“My Homelite XL2 chain saw is my best buy. I bought this small, inexpensive saw to save wear and tear on my more expensive equipment when cutting brush, roots, stumps, etc., on my Christmas tree farm. I thought of it as a disposable product that would wear out in two years or so. However, I’ve owned this saw for more than five years and it still starts and runs well. During that time I’ve replaced one bar and about five chains.”