Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011)

76 reports from pages 12–15 · 71 Best Buys15 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Great Plains wide twin row + 1 more

Jim Niemann, Litchfield, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“Our 2005 Great Plains 40-ft. wide twin row planter works great. We use it to plant all our corn and most of our soybeans in twin rows spaced 8 in. apart on 30-in. centers. It plants 16 double rows and has a total of 32 planting units.

“We were the first farmers in our area to try this planter before it went on the market. When the company made 60 planters in their first full year of production, we bought one. The planter drops corn seed so accurately that the off-setting plants form diagonal patterns it. across the field. It attracts a lot of attention from passersby.

“We’ve conducted many population trials, using half the planter on twin rows and the other half on single 30-in. rows, at many different populations. We’ve found the higher the twin row population, the greater the yield increase.

“To harvest twin row corn we use a 2010 Drago 8-row head, which is also a best buy.”

Best Buy

Daniel sells the Indexable Mudsaw Blade, which is designed for sawmill

Daniel D. Miller, 52915 Batesville Rd., Quaker City, Ohio 43773 · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

Daniel sells the Indexable Mudsaw Blade, which is designed for sawmills. It comes with 5/8-in. wide carbide inserts with 4 sharp edges. By loosening some wedge blocks, you can turn each carbide insert to a sharp side without having to remove the blade from the mill. According to the company the design keeps the blades sharp for a longer period of time; they remove frozen mud off logs faster in winter; and maintenance costs are lower.

The blade comes with a universal 3-bolt mount and a 3/4-in. dia. center mounting hole. Carbide and spare parts are available.

“This saw performs well,” says Miller. “A friend builds them for me and I sell them in my shop. I use them on my own sawmill and have installed many units for customers, who are all happy with them. They work especially well on sawmills where spring tension is used to hold the saw against the log, because the blade requires very little pressure and not a lot of horsepower.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 4 hp electric + 1 more

Carl from Avon, Conn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“I really like my 2011 Sears Craftsman 4 hp, 18-in. electric chainsaw, which I bought just 6 months ago. It weighs 14 lbs. and is the most powerful electric chainsaw sold by Sears. I replaced the original chain with a PowerSharp self-sharpening chain (ph 800 223-5168; www.powersharp.com), which I bought at a local Sears hardware store.

“The biggest advantage for an electric chainsaw compared to gas models is you don’t have to restart the saw time after time when working on a big project. There are no cold or warm engine problems to deal with. Just pull the trigger and away you go. The saw has a 15-amp power draw so it does draw quite a bit of current.

“I highly recommend this saw for small to medium projects near the house. I use it to cut firewood. It’ll slice up 3-ft. dia. trees with no problems. I’ve had electric chainsaws before, but most were 2 hp models. My 4 hp model has a lot more power, and not much can stop

“The saw is equipped with a tool-less chain adjustment that makes it easy to change the tension or re-attach the chain if it comes off, which doesn’t happen often. There are no tightening screws at all.

“I paid $100 for my chainsaw and liked it so much that I bought a second unit.”

Best Buy

Kubota 520 payloader + 1 more

Jim Lyboldt, Bernhards Bay, N.Y. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“My 2007 Kubota 520 payloader has more than 1,000 hours on it with no problems. I use it with quick-tach implements including a loader bucket, auger, and snowblower.

“My 2008 Dodge Ram 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup has had many problems. The transmission leaks and the pickup went back to the dealer twice for that but still didn’t get fixed. I finally traded it for a Chevy.”

Best Buy

Farmtrac 2098 DT360 4-WD tractor + 1 more

Ronald Adams, Louisville, Miss. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“I recently bought a used Farmtrac 2098 DT360 4-WD tractor with 205 hours. It performs great and doesn’t burn much fuel no matter what I do.

“My 2006 Mercury Marque was only 4 years old, with about 40,000 miles on it, when the paint started to blister and come off. However, the company wouldn’t help because the warranty had expired.”

Best Buy

Leatherman multi-tool

Samuel B. Shirk, Penn Yan, N.Y. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“My Leatherman multi-tool is the most-used tool I own and is built more rugged than cheaper imitations. It’ll take some abuse, although it’s not indestructible.

“Harbor Freight tools may be okay for light tinkering, but they’re definitely not meant for serious repair work.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Arlington metal storage building

Merle Erickson, Couderay, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

“My worst buy is my 10 by 12-ft. Arlington metal storage building made by Arrow Group Industries and sold by Menards. My wife and I put this building together in October 2010. However, when we had our first good snowfall the roof collapsed completely. The side walls buckled outward, destroying the building and damaging lawn furniture and a lawn tractor stored inside. No one would honor my claim.”

Best Buy

John Deere RX73 9 hp riding mower

Ronald E. Friedrich, Kenyon, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 12

Ronald likes his Deere RX73 9 hp riding mower, which he bought used 8 years ago. “I needed a cheap mower for a building site with a lot of weeds and brush. If I can drive over the brush, this machine will chop it, and if I get stuck it’s light enough that I can pick the machine up out of the hole. It starts good and requires only routine maintenance.”

Best Buy

John Deere 730 diesel tractor + 1 more

David Boyd, Honea Path, S.C. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“In 1978 I bought a used Deere 730 diesel tractor from a local dairy farmer, who was the original owner. I’ve used this tractor to plow, plant, cultivate and to pull an Allis Chalmers 90 combine to harvest about 70 acres of soybeans. I’ve also used the tractor to bush hog, pull up trees, and to do many other chores. Over the years it has required only a few minor repairs.

“In 1998 I bought a used Kubota B7200 tractor equipped with a belly-mount mower deck, and both the tractor and mower have required only minor repairs. The tractor now has about 1,900 hours on it. I plan to make a 3-pt. mounted, 12-gal. spray tank and 8-ft spray boom unit and mount it on the tractor. I’ll use it with a wand on small areas and fence rows.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Eby Maverick gooseneck livestock trailer + 1 more

Glenn Allen, Mt. Vernon, Ohio · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

Glenn likes his 2010 Eby Maverick 24-ft. gooseneck livestock trailer (ph 888 442-1961; www.tantivytrailer.com). “This trailer is built strong but light, and pulls so easily down the road that I hardly even know it’s there. It’s low to the ground which makes it easy to load, and cattle don’t slip on the tread plate floor.”

He’s disappointed with his 2009 Pro Track tandem axle, dual gooseneck beavertail trailer. “One month after I bought this trailer rust started showing through the powder coat paint. The problem continued to get worse, with paint peeling off. I notified the company but got nowhere, even though I sent photos to them twice. I guess the 2-year limited warranty is effective only if you don’t make a claim.”

Best Buy

General Motors customers

Neil H. Noble, Shelburne, Ont. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“We used to be solely General Motors customers, but in the last 15 years we’ve switched to Ford. The reason was that GM stopped selling full-size, rear wheel drive vehicles. Currently, we’re driving 3 Fords – a 2004 Grand Marquis, a 2004 4-WD F-150, and a 2005 4-WD 500. All were purchased new from a reputable dealership. We now stand by Ford products.”

Best Buy

Kubota ZD18 zero turn riding + 1 more

Thomas C. Stanford, Lester, Ala. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“I like my Kubota ZD18 zero turn riding mower equipped with a 54-in. deck and 18 hp diesel engine. It has more than 1,100 hours on it while requiring only routine maintenance. It still runs like new.

“My Bush Hog 3008 8-ft. mower left a 2-ft. wide streak on the right side that was 6 to 8 in. taller than the rest of the cut. The company said they had never heard of anyone else with this problem and wouldn’t replace my mower. I ended up trading for a smaller model from another manufacturer that isn’t built as heavy, and losing $1,800 on the deal. No more Bush Hogs for me.”

Best Buy

Kaufman gooseneck flatbed trailer + 1 more

Neal Galloway, Lynch, Neb. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

Neal nominates his 2010 Kaufman 24-ft. gooseneck flatbed trailer as his “best buy”. “I saved $2,000 by picking it up at the factory in Beaver City, Neb., instead of buying it from a local dealer. I’ve used this trailer to haul everything from tractors to windmill towers. It pulls good.

“Diamond tools used to be a good brand, but I can hardly cut wire with the pliers I recently bought. Later I discovered their tools are now made in China, but you have to look hard because it’s in very small letters. I returned my pliers to the dealer and they replaced it.”

Best Buy

Toyota 4-WD pickup

Larry J. Snaza, Brooklyn Center, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“I bought a used 1986 Toyota 4-WD pickup with about 100,000 miles on it. It now has more than 240,000 miles. I’m well pleased with this pickup’s fuel economy and how it starts right up in cold weather.

“FARM SHOW is my worst buy. Several years ago I sent information about a device to hold up tailgate windows on pickup toppers with worn shocks. I never saw it in the magazine or heard from you. Recently a friend of mine saw the same idea published in a recent issue, with someone else getting credit for it. He might have seen it on my truck.”

Best Buy

Gravely zero turn riding

Ed Dillard, Dade City, Fla. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

Ed’s the proud owner of a 2009 Gravely zero turn riding mower equipped with an 18 hp engine and a 40-in. deck. “This mower has reduced my mowing time in half and cuts nice and level, even in high grass. The deck and frame are built heavy, and it’s easy to adjust mowing height from the seat. The dealer replaced spindle bearings after 2 years at no cost under the machine’s 3-year warranty.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 372 chainsaw + 1 more

Charles Sassmen, Reedsport, Ore. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“I use my 2010 Husqvarna 372 chainsaw, which is equipped with a 36-in. bar, to fell timber and to cut firewood. Runs great with no problems.

“My 2000 Dodge diesel pickup is by far the best pickup I’ve ever owned. I installed an aftermarket computer chip in it that added about 100 hp. I use this pickup to pull a 24-ft. livestock trailer and a 30-ft. flatbed, and it has plenty of power to pull them fully loaded. I installed new brakes, but otherwise this pickup has required only routine maintenance. It has more than 250,000 miles on it.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Caprice Classic

Tony J. Vikla, Lonsdale, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“In 1995 I bought a used 1992 Chevrolet Caprice Classic with about 35,000 miles on it. The car now has more than 555,000 miles with the same engine and transmission. I installed a new head gasket in the engine at about 250,000 miles and that was the only work ever done on the engine. It uses about a quart of oil every 1,500 miles. I still drive the car, but now the frame is starting to rust.”

Best Buy

Kubota L4330 tractor + 1 more

Thomas Elsbernd, Rising Sun, Ind. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

A 2004 Kubota L4330 tractor rates as Thomas’s “best buy”. “Other than scheduled maintenance, this tractor hasn’t required a single repair. Even the lightbulbs on it are original.

“My 2008 Swisher ZT 2766 zero turn riding mower came new off the truck with a burned-up wiring harness. The problem was the throttle cable had been run directly across the solenoid terminals. The dealer supplied a replacement mower which worked good for the first 40 hours, but then the throttle cable broke. Again, the problem was due to sloppy installation.”

Best Buy

Nissan Titan pickup + 2 more

Mike Mitchell, Berlin, Mass. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“My 2005 Nissan Titan pickup has a nice look and ride but isn’t reliable. I had to replace the front axle, 4-WD, transmission, rear axle, and tie rods. The engine works good, but the running gear is unreliable.

“I use my 1968 International Harvester 544 tractor like a construction-grade tractor. The loader on it is sturdy and well built. The tractor has required some minor repairs, including shimming the main bearing and rewelding the 3-pt. top link. There were also minor problems with the shift linkage.

“I had to replace the transmission twice on my Honda Harmony mini tiller. The engine starts easy, but the transmission is unreliable and doesn’t stand up to normal use.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Lexus RX300 sports utility vehicle + 1 more

Terry Buenzow, Hawkeye, Iowa · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 13

“My 2000 Lexus RX300 sports utility vehicle is quiet, comfortable, and reliable. The fuel economy is decent, too.

“My 2010 Frigidaire dishwasher is my worst buy. The pump on it has gone out twice already, and the machine is so noisy I don’t want to run it when I’m home. Yet the advertising for it said we’d be surprised at how quiet it would be.”

Best Buy

Polaris Ranger 800 XP 6-wd utility vehicle

Mike Rice, Lakeview, Ore. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I use my 2010 Polaris Ranger 800 XP 6-WD utility vehicle every day to patrol a gas pipeline construction project, where I’m often driving in mud up to the machine’s belly pan. It has a soft canvas cab with doors and windshield, which I installed last fall. Even at outdoor temperatures of well below zero I stayed warm and comfortable. It’ll climb hills far in excess of the manufacturer’s suggested limits.”

Best Buy

Case 800 case-o-matic diesel tractor

Burdell Bohn, Bristol, S. Dak. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“My best buy is the Case 800 Case-O-Matic diesel tractor I bought used in 1971. I used this tractor for farm work, the last 20 years with a hydraulic-operated loader. Other than a rebuilt diesel pump the tractor has been trouble-free. It’s still going strong.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 pickup + 1 more

John Emerson, Cape Fair, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

John’s the satisfied owner of a 2004 Dodge 3500 pickup that’s equipped with a 24-valve 5.9-liter Cummins diesel engine and 6-speed manual transmission, dual wheels and 8-ft. bed. “This pickup has good low-end torque for pulling a 35-ft. hay trailer and a 24-ft. livestock trailer. It gets 17 1/2 to 18 mpg empty. The fuel injection pump was replaced under warranty, and that has been the only repair required in about 45,000 miles.

“My Belarus 4-WD tractor had a lot of electrical problems. It went through 2 starters and an ignition switch. The rubber lines used to connect the oil cooler were always leaking, and the fuel injection pump had to be rebuilt twice. This tractor is crudely machined and parts are expensive. However, once you get going it does pull good. The harder I work this tractor the better I like it.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 crew cab dually + 1 more

Chuck Springer, Byron, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I’ve got more than 206,000 miles on my 2001 Ford F-350 crew cab dually 4-WD pickup, which is equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine. I use it to pull a 5-horse trailer and farm wagons. I’ve even used it to pull two 350-bu. wagons with a gross weight of more than 57,000 lbs. I had problems with the transmission at about 90,000 miles, but I’ve abused the pickup regularly since then and it has held up well. The pickup still uses only a half pint of oil between changes.

“I’ve got more than 150,000 miles on my 1998 Sooner 5 horse trailer equipped with living quarters. My main complaint is with the trailer’s aluminum window frames and side compartment doors, which started pitting after about 4 years. I complained to the company but they referred me to their supplier instead of standing by their product. Of course, by the time I got around to doing something about it the warranty had expired. Also, the rear door hinges are poorly designed and had to be replaced.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Case 2390 tractor 5 + 1 more

Wayne Dick, Hutchinson, Kan. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I bought a used 1980 Case 2390 tractor 5 years ago with about 4,500 hours on it, and now it has more than 7,000 hours. It has required only routine maintenance.”

He’s disappointed with his 2008 Case IH JX80 front wheel assist tractor. “I’ve had numerous electrical and hydraulic problems with this tractor from day one, and it has been in the shop more than in the field. My dealer got tired of working on it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husqvarna chainsaw quit working + 1 more

Marvin Hammer, Bartow, Fla. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“My Husqvarna chainsaw quit working and I needed something in a hurry to cut up a fallen tree. So I bought a 2010 Sears Pro 18-in., 42cc model on sale for $150. The easy-adjust feature on this saw allows you to adjust the chain in only about 30 seconds, which greatly extends bar life. I was so impressed with the saw that I immediately bought a spare in case the company discontinues them.”

Best Buy

Volvo + 2 more

Bill McLaren, Maidstone, Sask. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I bought my first Volvo new in 1979 and my fifth one – a used 2007 XC90 model – last October. No other car comes close to the Volvo for performance.

“My 1980 Steiger Bearcat tractor has almost 6,000 hours on it. I use it to pull a 40-ft. Conservapak seeder equipped with a liquid caddy. It burns less than 6 gal. per hour.

“During harvest I use my 1955 Deere 70 tractor with a 51-ft. swing-away auger. This tractor is also easy on fuel.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2305 compact tractor

Andy McGregor, New Glasgow, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

Andy’s impressed with his 2008 Deere 2305 compact tractor. “I use this tractor for cutting grass, moving snow, tilling gardens, grading driveways, and so forth. Deere’s rear Quick-Hitch, quick connect front-end loader, and mower deck were all easy to install. This is a well-engineered tractor. The only negative is the paint on the wheels is cracking and the seat is rusting, even though I store the tractor inside a heated garage.”

Worst Buy

Ford Super Duty F-250 pickup

Gerald Palmer, Ward, Ark. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“My 2005 Ford Super Duty F-250 pickup is my worst buy. I started having problems with the engine with only 5 miles on the pickup, and since then it has been back to the dealer 6 or 7 times. They said they replaced all the engine computers. Whatever they did, fuel efficiency dropped by 6 to 8 mpg and it still doesn’t run right.

“The problem is that when I’m pulling my 15,000-lb. camper and going up a long hill, the engine wants to race freely. The engine blower kicks in, and then after I top the hill the truck doesn’t want to slow down. Instead, it just wants to run faster and I have a hard time getting slowing it down.

“I told Ford that someone is going to get hurt or even killed because of this problem. Now my pickup is out of warranty and I’m out of luck.”

Best Buy

Juicer

Dorothy Sonsalla, Baraboo, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“One lazy wintery Sunday afternoon, as my husband sat in his Lazy Boy watching football, I turned on the kitchen TV. There was Jack LeLaine selling his Juicer. We had an abundance of apples and I had used them in as many ways as I could think of. Off I went to Farm and Fleet to buy this juicer. The grandkids and I had fun trying different berries and veggies, but it took about 6 apples to make 1 cup of juice. When I took the machine apart I found a lot of juicy mush under the lid. Lots of juice lost. My Juicer now sits in the basement and I just eat the apples instead.”

Best Buy

WD Metal Buildings + 2 more

Harvey Fischer, Giddings, Texas · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“A 2010 40 by 100-ft. metal barn put up by WD Metal Buildings of Pleasanton, Texas, is my best buy. The company was easy to work with and their subcontractors took real pride in the building’s fit and finish. It was constructed exactly to my specs. Excellent quality materials, exceptional workmanship, and on-time completion. A great value.

“My 2008 Zetor 8441 tractor is powerful, fuel efficient, and comfortable to operate. It’s equipped with an on-board air compressor that I use with a Rohrer air-powered T-post driver. I attach the air supply to a small air tank that I carry in the tractor’s bucket and attach the T-post driver to the air outlet on the tank. Then I load up the bucket with T-posts and off we go.

“The Rohrer air-powered T-post driver is well built and easy to operate. It’s an amazing labor saver and is also a best buy (ph 800 980-7599; www.rohrermfg.com).”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-250 XLT Super duty extended cab + 3 more

Ernest B. Copley, Portland, Tenn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I like my 2006 Ford F-250 XLT Super Duty extended cab pickup equipped with a 5.4-liter gas engine and automatic transmission. It has about 22,000 miles on it. It came with a B&W Hide-A-Ball and tow package and has no trouble handling our travel trailer and gooseneck trailer.

“I like my 1997 New Holland 3930 4-WD loader tractor equipped with a diesel engine and shuttle shift transmission. I use it with a Woods 5-ft. tiller and 6-ft. rotary cutter. The tractor’s original battery lasted 13 years.

“My 2007 Husqvarna 350 chainsaw had a fuel line leak and a fuel tank leak from the factory. I had to pay the labor for the repair work because a year had passed before I took it in. The saw works good now.

“I like my 2009 Dixon zero turn riding mower equipped with a 26 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and a 50-in. deck. I show this machine no mercy but it’s built strong. My wife can operate it better than I can.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Cub Cadet 2165 riding mower + 1 more

Joseph Widmann, Eagleville, Penn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“My Cub Cadet 2165 riding mower has 232 hours on it, most of which have been troublesome. The Briggs & Stratton V-2 engine went through three sets of plugs in less than 52 hours. The carburetor and fuel pump often malfunction; the ignition module failed twice; and the electric deck power switch has been replaced four times. Finally I took the machine to another dealer 26 miles away who replaced the switch and another ignition module. Now it’s working okay.

“My 2000 Chevy Silverado pickup is a worst buy. The camshaft timing sensor failed and the brakes are constant trouble –the front discs and pads have been replaced three times and the rear ones twice with only 63,000 miles on the pickup. The transmission coolant lines have rusted through, as well as the brake lines. I’ve replaced them one or two at a time. Local mechanics blame these problems on salt brine that’s spread on roads during the winter.

“Next, the alternator bearings gave out with a loud squeal when I was 40 miles from home. The original General tires developed soft and worn sidewalls and had to be replaced before 33,000 miles. This pickup can’t haul much more than a garden tractor or a dozen sheets of plywood, which is hardly a heavy load. It does ride and handle nicely, but I’m going back to Dodge.”

Best Buy

Toyota T-100 pickup

Clarence Macdonald, Pittston, Maine · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

A 1993 Toyota T-100 pickup rates as Clarence’s “best buy”. “After I bought this pickup it underwent a company recall for faulty head gaskets, which was botched by the dealer. A local garage reset the valves and the engine hasn’t been touched since. This pickup now has more than 242,000 miles on it and is still going strong.”

Best Buy

John Deere X340 riding mower equipped + 1 more

Rick Bodenhamer, Gillette, Wyo. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“I’m happy with my 2007 Deere X340 riding mower equipped with a 54-in. deck. I use it to mow about 5 acres on our place. It’ll mow everything from range land grass to sage brush and even a rock or two.

“My 2008 Can-Am Outlander 800 4-wheeler has more than 2,000 miles on it and does everything I want (ph 877 469-7433; www.can-am.brp.com). It pulls a wagon and hauls a load of fence posts and other fencing materials. After the work is done I take it to the Big Horn mountains and play. It’ll crawl over just about any rock as well as push water up to its headlights. Mud is no problem for it - the deeper the better. It has plenty of power. There’s nothing like a good ride after mowing and building fence.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tacoma pickup equipped + 1 more

Mel Durr, Hilda, Alberta · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 14

“My 2009 Toyota Tacoma pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine has more than 150,000 miles with no problems.

“The transmission has been replaced twice on my 2001 Dodge 3/4-ton diesel pickup, but the engine still runs great. The pickup’s steering arm fell off while I was pulling a livestock trailer on the highway. I called the company but they told me the warranty had expired and that they couldn’t help. I was 5 min. from sure death, as I had just come through some winding roads with oncoming traffic.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Circle C 30-wheel crop + 1 more

Jeff Boothe, Walnut Ridge, Ark. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

Jeff grows rice and soybeans and is impressed with his Circle C 53-ft., 30-wheel crop residue rake (ph 800 367-1847; www.superhaytoday.com). It’s a larger version of the company’s standard wheel rake. Company president Ivan Cook says as far as he knows it’s the world’s biggest rake. It’s equipped with walking beams and rubber-encased tines with depth bands for constant contact with the ground. The rake teeth are in front of the depth band, adjusted to clear the ground yet gather stubble without picking up dirt and rocks.

Boothe grows soybeans on 2-ft. wide beds and uses the rake to gather soybean residue into windrows, which he then burns. “It works great. The rake cleans the ground without raking up clods and without putting pressure on the teeth. The walking beams allow the tines to follow the contour of the beds,” says Boothe.

On the negative side, he lists his 48-ft. dia., 38,000-bu. GSI grain bin equipped with a 50 hp centrifugal fan. “We were able to operate the fan for only 5 days before the bearings went out, destroying the shaft. Five days later a work crew installed new bearings and rebuilt the shaft. We operated the fan for 5 more days but then the fan ripped from the bin and flipped the motor. Five days later the crew installed a rebuilt fan. But later that day, I discovered the fan was installed backward. I called the company and 2 days later they installed a new, smaller fan, but by that time the rice in the bin was ruined. We took a $30,000 loss.”

Worst Buy

Dove Tec corn stove

Jim Johnston, Flesherton, Ont. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“My Dove Tec corn stove is poorly designed and often plugs up and stops working. I had to dismantle the stove just to remove the auger. The dealer came out and tried to fix it but couldn’t. Our house had to be cleaned because of smoke damage.”

Best Buy

Breaking New Ground Resource Center

Allan Kuhl, Desboro, Ont. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

In 2005 Allan had a hip replaced due to arthritis and has worked with the Breaking New Ground Resource Center at Purdue University to find ways to help get his work done (ph 800 825-4254; www.workshop.agrability.org). The organization is a clearing house for information on commercially available products and homegrown ideas from farmers and ranchers designed for farmers with disabilities.

“With the help of this program I’m able to farm 355 acres with my wife and other family members and friends,” says Allan.

Best Buy

Rupp hydraulic-operated calf chute

Tom Ruffatto, Stevensville, Mont. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“My Rupp hydraulic-operated calf chute is my best buy (ph 712 261-1108). It works fast and smooth and is easy on calves. The company’s customer service is great. We recently had a hydraulic problem with the chute, and owner Phil Rupp drove 1,150 miles one way to bring us a new chute. Their chutes make branding and working calves an easy job.”

Best Buy

Your First Tractor

Roy Harrell, Yatesville, Ga. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“My best buy is an informative book I bought on Amazon.com called ‘Your First Tractor’. This book is described as ‘the tractor buyers’ protection guide’ and was written by three brothers who were raised on a farm and have operated a tractor repair shop for more than 30 years. The book contains a lot of country humor to keep the reader interested. I think even city slickers would buy this book for the humor alone. Even my wife read it and enjoyed it immensely.

“The book not only helps you decide what size tractor you need to handle the jobs on your farm, but it also warns the prospective buyer about the pitfalls and ‘gotchas’ found in the tractors being sold today. It covers old and new tractors and explains which brands hold up best, which ones have readily available parts, and which ones have a decent resale value should you ever decide to sell.

“I was amazed to find that many popular American brand name tractors are really just poor quality tractors from India, China, or Eastern Europe.

“The book can save a prospective tractor buyer hundreds or even thousands of dollars in unexpected expenses by knowing what to look for, what to look out for, and how to safely and profitably maintain and operate a tractor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Troy-Bilt Super Bronco garden tractor + 1 more

Robert Trimbo, Vancouver, Wash. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“Robert’s disappointed with his 2006 Troy-Bilt Super Bronco garden tractor. It hasn’t made it through a season without a breakdown or engine problem. I had to replace assorted springs and belts. Now it needs a carburetor and is leaking oil. Fortunately, my 12-year-old Sears Craftsman riding mower is still running.”

Best Buy

McFarlane Reel Disk

Aaron Marley, Nokomis, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

Aaron uses a McFarlane Reel Disk to prepare his ground for no-till planting of both corn and soybeans. “It’s equipped with ultra-shallow concave disk blades that loosen the top 2 to 3 in. of the soil, yet leave a firm seedbed that ensures accurate seed depth at planting. The leading disk blades penetrate the soil and slice residue into manageable pieces. The disk has enough weight to force the no-till coulters into the ground deep enough to allow my planter to work at optimum depth.

“The gang angle can be set aggressive for more soil movement to bury residue or can be set passive to leave more residue on the surface. The disk is available in a 12-ft. wide rigid frame model, and in 20, 25, 30 and 44-ft. folding frame models.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 4-WD pickup + 1 more

Marvin Roemmick, Rapid City, S. Dak. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“The 2005 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup I bought used is my best buy. I use it as a farm/ranch vehicle, and my daughter uses it to go to horse shows, pulling a 4-horse trailer. Her tack alone weighs as much as two quarter horses. We’ve used this pickup to haul gravel, hay, and sawdust. It’s a good pulling pickup, loaded or empty.

“In 1980 I bought a used 1953 Ford Golden Jubilee tractor and have used it for pushing snow, leveling dirt, and baling hay ever since I replaced the tires and a clutch.”

Best Buy

Lil’House outside wood heater

Cindy Bentley, McArthur, Ohio · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

Cindy’s impressed with her 2010 Lil’House outside wood heater (ph 417 581-7755; www.outsidewoodheater.com). “We live in a 3-bedroom block home with a full basement and have a newer model, propane furnace. It usually takes four 500-gal. tank fill-ups per year to heat the house to 68 degrees. We were spending a fortune on propane but still weren’t warm. Then my husband and I bought the Lil’House heater and installed it ourselves. It came with clear, easy-to-understand directions so we were able to have it up and running in a day.

“We installed the heater duct directly into our dining room window, which is centrally located in our home. We brought the cold air return out of one of the basement windows. It was the first winter we actually stayed warm inside the house. There were days when the thermostat read 85 degrees. If it got too warm, I just opened a window, turned on a fan and praised God that I didn’t have to pay for that heat. It was awesome. I never dreaded going out to put wood in the stove because I was looking at that propane tank knowing I wasn’t having to pour money into it. My Lil’House heater paid for itself in the first year. I’d recommend it to anyone.”

Worst Buy

Mantis garden rototiller

Bud Newton, Cochranville, Penn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“My Mantis garden rototiller is my worst buy. When it was delivered to me it wouldn’t start, and the company told me to take it to a repair shop. However, the shop couldn’t get it started and had to consult with the company. It has been in three different repair shops, but no one has been able to get it to run more than 15 min. Now it sits idle in my garage while I hand dig my wife’s flower beds.”

Best Buy

Kubota M5040 tractor equipped

Al Kilburg, Zwingle, Iowa · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“I like my 2010 Kubota M5040 tractor equipped with a front-end loader and cab. This tractor is easy to use in tight places, has adequate power for moving snow, and a good hydraulic system to handle wood that we use in our outside wood burning stove. I also bought a Kubota BX2360 tractor with belly-mounted mower. It works great to mow my lawn.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tundra + 1 more

Ron Stoen, Lowry, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“My 2010 Toyota Tundra is the best pickup I’ve ever owned. I was always made fun of for buying a foreign truck but, low and behold, this truck was built right here in Texas.

“My Country Clipper zero-turn riding mower reduced my lawn mowing time by half and does a better job than any mower I’ve ever used. It’s equipped with a tip-up deck.”

Best Buy

New Holland 595 big square baler

Bernard Fehringer, Sidney, Neb. · Vol. 35, No. 4 (2011), p. 15

“I like my early 2000’s New Holland 595 big square baler, which I bought used with 3,000 bales on it. It makes 3 by 4-ft. bales. I’m sure the original owner traded this baler in because he couldn’t make it work. The problem was he didn’t keep it lubricated. The tucker fingers need regular greasing and are hard to see without consulting the operator’s manual. Also, the autolubes use a lot of oil so you have to keep refilling the reservoir often. Ever since I fixed the problems and lubed this baler properly, it makes bales without a single missed tie or other malfunction.”