Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997)
94 reports from pages 14–17 · 91 Best Buys23 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →
Best Buy
“Our 1983 Steiger 1000 series 4-WD tractor equipped with a 325 hp Caterpillar 3406 diesel engine has been trouble-free and is our best buy. We operate it at about 85 percent of its total capability, but the power train still shows little sign of wear. We’ve put 4,800 hours on it, riding in the relaxing comfort of the super quiet cab. It still has the original Goodyear 30.5 by 32 tires, but they’ll have to be replaced in the next year or two. This tractor will likely provide another 20 years of service, and then I’ll probably rebuild it if necessary. I don’t believe there’s another 4-WD tractor on the market that’s as good, which is probably why the company went broke. Their tractors never broke down so they never needed expensive repairs.
“My 1996 Flexi-Coil 5000 air drill is a best buy. I used it last fall to seed 100 acres of rye and 300 acres of soft white winter wheat. It’s easy to fill the drill with fertilizer and seed -just swing the hydraulic-operated auger under the hopper tank and open a chute. Another great feature is that the carrying wheels are all out front and the packing wheels are on back, with no wheels at the center of the frame next to the shanks. The 12-in. row spacing provides excellent trash clearance in heavy stubble. I haven’t used the machine enough yet to find any flaws in performance. I’m looking forward to seeding without having to do much maintenance or trouble shooting.”
Best Buy
Murray says he likes his Arctic Cat snowmobiles but has trouble getting parts for them. “I have no complaints about the snowmobiles themselves. They’re excellent. Mine had more than 7,000 miles on it before it needed any major repairs. Two winters ago the primary clutch needed repairs and I had to wait more than four weeks for parts. Last winter the engine had to be repaired and I waited five weeks to get it back. I was told that parts had been shipped, but they never arrived.
“Arctic Cat products are excellent. But what good is their product if they can’t supply parts?”
Best Buy
Leverett likes his Claas 46 round baler. “I used it to make more than 4,000 bales without ever breaking the original shear bolt.”
Best Buy
“My 1986 Deere 160 riding mower performs with excellence and is my best buy.”
Best Buy
“My best buy of all time is a 1976 Deere 110 garden tractor. I use it to mow 1 1/4 acres of grass, plow snow, grade the driveway, blow snow, pull a cart, and do work in the garden. I use it so much that I wore out the engine. I won’t do without this tractor.”
Best Buy
A pair of 1991 Case-IH tractors - models 9180 and 9280 - rate as Daniel’s “best buys”. “The 9180 has about 2,900 hours on it and the 9280 about 1,300 hours. Both tractors require very little maintenance, have a lot of power (375 hp), and are easy on fuel.”
Best Buy
Arthur’s had good luck with his Mott 36-in., trail-mount, 8 hp flail mower which he bought used. “I use it to do trimming work on our Christmas tree farm. It’ll mow grass and weeds of any height and density without plugging up and spreads the clippings evenly without clumping them together. It doesn’t get hung up on gopher mounds or tree stumps.”
Best Buy
“About 10 years ago I bought a new 3,000-bu. Brock grain bin. After two years it ‘kinked’ in the middle and the company won’t fix it.”
Best Buy
Philip’s impressed with his three Mirafount hog waterers. “They’re very good waterers and the company provides excellent service. They gave me improved replacement lids on one waterer after my sows ruined the first set, and they also provided free updates for the valves. I’ve never dealt with a better company.”
Best Buy
“My best buy is my 1996 Feterl 10-in. dia. auger. Last year I planted only about 200 acres of corn, but I had a good crop and I knew that my 7-in. dia. auger would be inadequate, so I replaced it. I did feel a little foolish bringing home an auger of this size, but it allowed me to keep up with my combine. I love the swingaway hopper. I didn’t have to shovel even one scoop of spilled corn.
“I bought a 1978 International1440 combine three years ago and had to repair or replace every major component on it including the engine and transmission. After going over about 80 percent of the machine I now have a machine that’s dependable and will last until I’m ready to trade for a new model.”
Best Buy
John nominates his Dickey John 2000 grain loss monitor as his “best buy”. “It has paid for itself two or three times a year ever since we bought it. The monitor kit for our New Holland TR-70 combine came with sensors only for the shoe. We complained and the company sent out two more sensors for the rotors. We installed the extra ones in the same place they’d install on an International combine. You absolutely need four sensors in order to make the monitor work correctly.”
Best Buy
A White 6100 vertical fold, 12-row planter is Gerald’s “best buy”. “I bought it last year when it was 3 years old. It’s easy to set and operate and does a good job of placing seed.”
Best Buy
Leo’s impressed with his Massey-Ferguson 8120 tractor. “I own four other brands of tractors and none of them can touch this Massey for running smooth and having a quiet cab.”
Best Buy
Charles likes Dynamatrix cow mats (Dynamatrix, Inc., Box 783, Winona Lake, Ind. 46590). “These 2-in. thick mats are made from recycled tires. We bought one to try it out and put it in a heavily-used stall in our free-stall barn. It stayed put without having to be fastened down, so we bought some more.”
Best Buy
Dave’s the satisfied owner of a Clarke-Delco hot water pressure washer. “We haul it to five different farms within a 7-mile radius so it gets banged around a lot. However, it’s been sturdy and reliable. The hot water helps remove grease and manure better than our cold water washers, and we really like the rotating nozzle because it keeps the operator from getting constantly splashed in the face or body.”
Best Buy
Gordon’s impressed with his 1991 Ford 276 Bi-Directional tractor equipped with a 2360 loader. “It made it possible to feed cattle in the two wettest springs and the worst winter on record. We couldn’t have handled the mud and snow with the equipment we had before. The four wheel drive, matched with a good balance of weight and power, makes it agile, maneuverable, and amazingly capable. Hydrostatic drive provides the operator with almost total control in any situation.”
Best Buy
“My 1992 Deere 670 utility tractor is easy on fuel and starts well in cold weather. We bought a 3-pt. tiller to use with it and had a minor problem with a 3-pt. hitch pin which the dealer promptly replaced. Otherwise, no problems. I’m well pleased with it.”
Best Buy
An International 990 conditioner rates as Donald’s “best buy”. “I bought it used at an auction on the advice of a friend. It cost about one third as much as the Hesston model that my buddy bought. I’ve used it hard for two years and maintenance has been limited to replacement of knife sections and a pitman bearing. It’s a super machine.”
Best Buy
Timothy’s happy with his 1992 Deere 626 5-wheeler which he bought used. “It’s easy to maintain and drive as it has only forward and reverse gears. It always starts, is very stable, handles well, and has a bed that dumps for easy unloading. It pulls our small utility trailer with ease. One weak point is that it should have better brakes.
“We had problems starting our McCullough 610 chain saw. Whenever we did get it started and turned it on its side, it would stop. Another problem was that the oiler never worked. I traded it in for a Poulan which is the best saw I’ve ever owned.”
Best Buy
“I bought my 1994 Polaris XLT snowmobile used last fall with 3,400 miles on it, and it now has 5,500 miles with no problems at all. The 580cc 3-cyl. engine has a lot of power and hasn’t even fouled a spark plug yet. I’d recommend Polaris snowmobiles to anyone interested in trouble-free riding.”
Best Buy
Brian’s impressed with his 1995 Westfield 13-in. dia. grain auger. “It will unload 750 bu. of wheat in only 3 1/2 minutes, which allows the truck to return to the field before the combine has a full grain tank.”
Best Buy
William nominates his 1994 Universal 4-WD tractor as his “best buy”. ”It sells for about $12,000 less than comparable models made by North American manufacturers. It has a lot of power and will handle a 72-in. heavy duty roto-tiller with ease. It’s easy on fuel, handles nice, has good visibility, a lot of clearance, wide tires, and good traction.”
Ray Tolton (Amroy Farms Ltd.), ‘customer service’. They told me the machine was more than six months old, then hung up the phone.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My dad bought my best buy 1978 International 1086 tractor in the mid 1980’s and I bought it from him in 1990. Together we’ve put 8,000 hours on it and all we’ve ever had to replace was the clutch.
“My 1992 Case-IH 9230 4-WD tractor can pull a 35-ft. deep tiller with ease and is stingy on fuel. The cab is so comfortable I can ride in it for 12 hours without getting tired.”
On the negative side, he lists his Deere 1209 Haybine. “The wobble box lasted only about 150 hours. Another problem was that the reel teeth were poorly designed and broke very easily.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“We’re well pleased with our Case-IH 5220 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a self-leveling front-end loader and grapple fork. It’s well designed and the front wheel assist drive system is built heavy. The cab is quiet and has a lot of room, with control levers that are easy to reach. It’s a good tractor. The quick detach bucket on the loader is also well designed.
“Our worst buy is our Case 1594 4-WD tractor. The hydraulic pump had to be replaced three times and the powershift transmission had to be rebuilt. The engine had to be overhauled twice and then it broke into pieces when a piston rod broke in two and punched a hole in the side of the engine. The only good thing was that our dealer was helpful.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My 1990Chrysler New Yorker car was my worst buy. I had to have the heads on the engine changed four times in the first 60,000 miles. The repair costs were covered by the warranty but it was still a nuisance.
“My best buy is my 1982 Case 2390 tractor. It has 2,800 hours on it with no problems and just keeps on running.”
Best Buy
“Our two 1989 Deere 9600 combines are our best buys. We’ve used them to harvest more than 2 million bu. of crops. Each one has more than 2,700 hours on it with very little downtime.
“We’ve also had good luck with several Versatile tractors made from 1980 to 1988.”
Worst Buy
Renee’s disappointed with his 1995 Deere 9450 20-ft. grain drills and Deere drill transport hitch. “They were advertised as minimum till/no till drills, but we had problems using them in stubble and also in disked or cultivated ground which resulted in a poor crop. The company wouldn’t do anything about it. I’m very disappointed in both the drills and the company.”
Best Buy
“My 1994 Polaris 300 4-WD ATV was a reasonably good machine. However, the engine seized up, apparently due to a defective or poorly designed oil injection pump. It cost $800 to repair. I called the company and got
Best Buy
Douglas likes his 1995 NOMA all-wheel steer 43-in. riding mower equipped with a 15 hp Kohler engine and hydrostatic transmission. “I have a large lawn with a lot of trees. The all-wheel steering makes it easy to mow around them. I can turn in a 13 1/2-in. dia. circle so despite the trees I don’t have to do much trimming afterward. The hydrostatic transmission is smooth and easy to operate. The mower has grease fittings on the bearings, king pins, universal joints, etc., which makes it easy to service. It was priced at a reasonable $1,549. No problems at all in the first year of use.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Allan’s the owner of a “best buy” 1988 Steiner S-20 4-WD tractor equipped with a 20 hp engine and 4-ft. front-mount mower. “It has a lot of power and traction and can handle even the toughest mowing conditions. It has center steering which makes it very maneuverable for mowing around bushes and trees. I use a hydraulic-operated angle blade on it for snow removal or light grading jobs. A variety of other attachments are available which makes it a versatile machine.
“My Hesston 4570 in-line square baler makes firm, square bales that are easy to load on my stack wagon.”
On the negative side, he lists his 1992 Ford Explorer. “The engine valve cover gaskets leaked, and to replace them the fuel injection system had to be removed. The job costs $300 or more.”
Best Buy
“Our Knight 8024 twin slinger manure spreader handles everything from very sloppy manure to straw-filled pen manure equally well with no leaks and no ‘bridging’. I feel sorry for anyone who tries to sell any other brand. They don’t have a chance.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Don’s impressed with his 1992 Bobcat 843 skid steer loader. “After 4,800 hours all I’ve had to replace were four hydraulic hoses that had rubbed together and worn through.
“My 1987 New Holland 555 skid steer loader is my worst buy. The wheel seals have had to be replaced every year. The brakes are poorly designed. The Perkins engine was also a disappointment.”
Best Buy
His “best buy ever” is his 1978 Tuff-bilt garden tractor. “I bought it used several years ago. It’s almost 20 years old, but I could still sell it for twice as much as it cost new. It’s powered by a 16 hp, 1-cyl., air-cooled engine. It drives a hydraulic pump which drives a 3-speed transmission. The manufacturer was based in Cummings, Ga., but went broke. It’s an excellent machine that’s much sought after. If another company would start making this machine again I think it would sell like hotcakes.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Richard likes his five Kubota tractors which include 1995 L2350 and 1990 L2050 models. “We use them on our nursery. They’re very fuel efficient, easy to maintain, and simple to operate. However, the price of Kubota tractors has risen about 30 percent in the past three years so we don’t know if we’ll buy another one very soon.”
“Our 1996 Bobcat 873 skid steer loader is a worst buy. We use it to operate a hydraulic tree spade. We bought it after trading in our 1995 model, which also had a lot of problems. Numerous hoses burst, wiring was incorrectly installed at the factory, and it had many leaks. The company’s regional service manager failed to notify us about several field modifications that our machine needed. Our 1996 model has only 370 hours on it but has recently developed problems with the drive motor. I hope the bugs on this model will be worked out.”
Best Buy
“It cuts clean and is easy to adjust,” reports Timothy about his 1996 Deere 820 mower conditioner. “I have hilly land but it holds the hills well.
“My 1996 Dodge W-350 diesel pickup performs well, has a lot of power, and is fuel efficient. My only complaint is that the sheet metal is too thin, which allows the bed to get bent and dented way too easy.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Jim’s happy with his 1995 Deere 450 grain drill. “I like it because it’s easy to set the seeding rate. Also, I like the double disc openers and the press wheel design. Overall, it’s a good drill. My only complaint is that it’s made from light material.”
He isn’t impressed with his 1995 Deere 7300 planter. “One problem is that it’s built out of light material. Another is that it’s a plateless planter which makes it hard to set the seeding rate, especially for cotton. I traded in my Deere 7100 planter which was 12 years old, and it worked a lot better than this one.
“I’ve owned three Deere 4240 tractors and liked all of them. Hardly any problems at all.”
Best Buy
“My International 574 tractor equipped with a quick-tach front-end loader is my best buy. It’s a tough tractor.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“We’ve used our Welger RP-200 round baler for five years with no major problems. The twine tieing mechanism could be improved, but overall it’s not a bad baler.
“My 1987 Ford F-150 pickup is my worst buy. The 6-cyl. engine is hard on gas. By the time the pickup was only two years old it had gone through four starters, an alternator, and a heater core. I was very fortunate to be able to sell it.”
Worst Buy
Larue’s disappointed with his Deere 450 manure spreader which he bought used when it was one year old. “I use straw to bed my beef cows, and the spreader grabs large gobs of strawy manure and leaves piles in the field. It doesn’t work right without the optional top beater, which sells for almost $1,000. I think the top beater should be standard equipment so the spreader could handle any type of manure. At the very least, the top beater shouldn’t be so expensive.”
Best Buy
“My best buy is my 1990 New Idea 484 round baler. It makes 4 by 5-ft. soft core bales and has an electric tie system. I’ve used it to make hundreds of bales every year without ever having to stop. The only repair has been replacement of a few bolts that came loose on a bearing holder. The dealer provided them free of charge. I also had to replace a roller bearing which turned out to be a very easy job and cost only a few dollars.”
Best Buy
Raymond’s impressed with his 1989 Deere 575 skid steer loader. “‘Reliable’ and ‘per-
(Continued on next page) formance’ are two good words to describe it. It has more than 1,500 hours on it but still performs like new. We put on a new set of tires and replaced two front lights that burned out. Otherwise, just regular maintenance. It has excellent hydraulic lifting capacity for its size although the hydraulics could work a little faster. Also, it starts right up in cold weather.”
Best Buy
“I like my 1996 Kan-Am 16-ft. blade. Works great for rebuilding terraces and can move a lot of dirt in one pass.”
Best Buy
Chuck likes his 1996 Sears Craftsman 3/8-in. portable drill-driver. “This 9.6-volt model is lightweight, well balanced, and easy to handle. It has adjustable torque that’s more than adequate even for driving lag screws. It also has enough power to reverse screws that can’t be started by hand. Makes driving wood and sheet metal screws a snap. This drill is one of the handiest things since pockets in a night gown. I’ve never been dissatisfied with anything bearing the Sears Craftsman label.”
Best Buy
“My 1994 Deere 920 mower conditioner is well built. I’m impressed with the impeller conditioning system. I use a Deere 2350 50 hp tractor to pull it.
“I also like my Deere GT42 garden tractor. The 14 hp engine handles a 48-in. mower with ease.”
“I find Goodyear Dynatorque II tires to be very rough riding on the road at certain speeds. I replaced them with Armstrong tires which I like much better.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My Case-IH 7210 Magnum tractor starts well in cold weather, and the remote control for the 3-pt. hitch makes it easy to hook up implements. My only complaint is that the quadrant for third and fourth reverse gears is not in a straight line from the quadrant for the first and second reverse gears, which makes it awkward to use.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his New Idea 3222 side slinger manure spreader. “It does a reasonably good job of spreading all types of manure. However, the beaters have to be cleaned out thoroughly in freezing weather to prevent problems. My main complaint, however, is that the walking beam tandem axles aren’t built nearly heavy enough. I had to have a machine shop reinforce them. I looked at a similar spreader and the owner had the same problem. A company representative agreed with me that the axles should be built heavier.”
Best Buy
“I like my 1996 Deere 5400 4-WD tractor equipped with a Deere 540 front-end loader. We use it to feed silage and have more than 700 hours on it. It starts right up in the winter. It does the work of a Deere 2350 4-WD tractor, but is much easier to use around the barn and in the woods with a log winch.”
Best Buy
Chuck had problems with the Harvest Ser-vices feederhouse chain he installed on his International rotary combine. “It consists of three chains with plastic paddles between them. It worked alright in straw or soybeans, but in corn I couldn’t keep the chains in time with one another so it was always running crooked. After harvesting only about 20 acres gether, I’ve owned eleven different Chevrolet diesel-powered pickups since they came out in the 1970’s. It has dual wheels which make tracks for our 18-ft. livestock trailer and allow it to go right through snow where I wouldn’t even try to go with other brands. The diesel engine is fuel efficient and has a lot of power. I’ve never had any problems with the engine on any diesel-powered truck.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My 1983 Kubota 4950 tractor equipped with a front-end loader is my best buy. It always starts in the winter, and the 4-wheel lockup works great and allows it to turn short. The loader also works great. My only complaint is that I wish it had about 10 more horsepower so it would work better on hilly land.
“I like my Chevrolet 1-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter turbocharged diesel engine. This is my second pickup equipped with the 6.5-liter engine. All to-somewhere in one of my fields last year and the company won’t replace it.
“I’m disappointed with my 1995 GMX magnetic water conditioning system. It uses magnets that clamp to the water pipes and are supposed to prevent lime buildup in the water heater and water lines. However, it didn’t work. I would have got the same result if I’d just taped some cow magnets to my water lines.”
Best Buy
“My Hydra-Bed pickup-mounted bale mover saves a lot of time and effort. It lets me load two round bales on my truck and go 60 mph down the highway. Eliminates the need to use a tractor and trailer in the field to load bales. I’ve used the loading arms to also pick up plows, irrigation engines, and anything else I need to move. The arms can also be used to drive in T fence posts and to pull posts out of the ground.”
Best Buy
“I’m impressed with my 1996 Case-IH 7220 front wheel assist tractor. It’s the first piece of red equipment I’ve ever owned. So far it has performed beyond my expectations. It has a lot of power, is fuel efficient, and the transmission runs smooth with excellent gear selections. It has a nice cab with good visibility, a wide door, and easy-to-reach controls. It’s not often you can buy something new without having a few problems. But after one year and 400 hours, no problems. I couldn’t have finished plowing last fall without the front wheel assist.
“My 1995 Deere 425 all wheel steer riding lawn mower equipped with a 54-in. deck is easy to use and is comfortable. We had a couple of minor problems on it which the dealer promptly fixed. It’s an easy machine to operate and has cut our mowing time in half.”
Best Buy
A 1995 Honda 300 Fourtrax 2-WD ATV rates as Jeff’s “best buy”. “I use it for spraying, checking crops, doing chores, and other jobs. All it has needed is regular maintenance. I bought it to replace my 1985 250 Fourtrax which was also reliable. Honda makes good 4-wheelers.”
Best Buy
“I like my 1996 New Holland 654 round baler equipped with the silage bale kit. Except for a few minor problems it’s been trouble-free. The knob for adjusting bale density fell off
Best Buy
“It’s fuel efficient and does a lot of work for a 36 hp tractor,” says Jerry about his Belarus 310. “I use it to farm 18 acres of corn and bean ground. At times I wish it was a 45 hp tractor, but it does well for its size.”
Best Buy
Dick’s impressed with his 1994 New Idea 5209 disc mower. “The thicker the hay the better it seems to cut. It does a great job on down and tangled hay and has never plugged up. I can mow with it as fast as I can stay in the tractor seat. The cut hay dries faster than it does with a sickle mower. It takes only three minutes to change a broken knife.”
Best Buy
“We’re happy with our 1996 8-in. Mayrath swing-away grain auger. It’s easy to get it into the right position and also easy to operate. We’ve used the company’s augers for years with no problems.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Dan’s not happy with his White 271 Rockflex disk. “We broke more axles in two years using this disk than we did in 10 years with our old rigid disk.”
On the “best buy” side, “Our Deere 7800 MFD tractor is almost perfect. It’s easy to operate and has a comfortable cab with an excellent view. It also has a lot of power.
“We like our Gleaner R42 4-WD combine. We had a wet fall last year and the 4-WD paid for itself.
“Our Kinze 2500 twinline 8-row planter is a best buy. It places the seed very accurately which results in good stands. It’s a real pleasure to watch it pivot hydraulically and then drive down the road.”
Best Buy
“My Westfield electric/hydraulic drill fill auger is well made and an excellent product.
“My 1992 Deere 4255 is a super tractor. Why anyone would want more in a tractor is a mystery to me.
“My 1993 Vermeer 504I round baler is easy to operate and virtually trouble-free. It does an excellent job.”
Best Buy
“I like my 1996 Sunflower no-till drill. After one season of use it has proven to be a very versatile machine for all types of tillage systems.”
Best Buy
Paul’s the owner of a 1995 Unverferth McCurdy Perfecta II harrow equipped with “S” tines and a rolling basket. “It makes a nice, level seedbed without any ridges. It keeps the soil loose which results in better water retention and less crusting. It also has better trash flow than culti-mulchers. It’s 3-pt. mounted which makes it handy to use on corners and on small fields.”
Best Buy
Ray likes his used White 598 5-bottom mold-board plow. “It has tremendous flexibility, both in width of plowing and maneuverability around obstacles. It also pulls easy.”
Best Buy
“I’ve had good luck with my 1995 Murray 42-in. riding mower equipped with a 14 1/2 hp engine and 5-speed transmission. I’m starting my third cutting season with it and all I’ve bought for it is motor oil for scheduled oil changes. I use it to cut 1 1/2 acres a week from April through October. The Briggs and Stratton OHV engine works great. The company really did its homework when they designed this mower. Also, it’s priced right.”
Best Buy
Wilbur likes his Miller-Pro rotary rake. “It rakes clean and makes a loose, fluffy windrow without ‘roping’ the hay like my old Deere rake did. All the controls for it are located next to the tractor seat, including the hydraulic lift and pto controls, so there’s no need to get off the tractor. It also turns short.”
Best Buy
“I’m impressed with my two 1996 Belarus tractors - a 530 2-WD and a 420A 4-WD. Both are rugged, dependable, simple, and easy to maintain. They have big engines and plenty of gears and hydraulics. In many ways, Belarus tractors are superior to other tractors while remaining low priced. I bought both of these 60 hp class tractors new for a total of $20,000.”
Best Buy
“My 1994Deere 7800 tractor is a pleasure to drive. The 19-speed powershift transmission shifts smooth yet is aggressive.
“My 1994 Case-IH 600 forage blower does an excellent job with a minimal horsepower requirement.”
Best Buy
“I’ve put 2,400 hours on my 1988 Case-IH 3594 front wheel assist tractor and it’s a best buy. It has a lot of power and doesn’t use any oil between changes. It’s almost a perfect tractor.
“I like my 1988 Gravely riding mower equipped with a 50-in. deck. Works great.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Quentin’s “worst buy” is his 1995 A-Maize-Ing Heat corn burning furnace. “I have to constantly adjust the air, fuel, and draft ratios. Also, I’ve had problems with clinkers jamming the feed auger. It would probably work better in a milder climate.”
On the positive side, he lists his 1996 Agri Matic step-up milking parlor stalls. “My dealer installed the double-4 parlor in one end of our existing stanchion barn. The cows step up 14 in. onto the milking platform to be milked and exit out the front. It saves a lot of wear and tear on my knees because I don’t have to kneel down beside the cows in order to milk them.”
Worst Buy
“I’m not happy with the two Shelter-All fabric hoop-type buildings that we put up three years ago. They were supposed to have a ‘no tear’ fabric on them, but after four days of high winds much of the fabric ripped away from the supporting structure. Holes the size of a pin soon developed into big tears. I also had problems with nylon straps on the supporting structure, and some steel pieces on the structure fell off and went through a wing on my sprayer. The slip fit members of the supporting structure were held together during erection with off-the-shelf duct tape, not specially prepared and supplied tape as advertised.”
Best Buy
“Our best buy in recent times is a White 160 tractor with front wheel drive and a Cummins engine. It was much cheaper than the competition and does lack some frills. But it runs smooth, starts good, and has done everything we want it to.”
Best Buy
“My best buy of all time is a 1977 Case 53 hp 990 tractor. I bought it used in 1984 with 2,986 hours and it now has 6,404 hours with only a handful of repairs. It’s economical to run and is so handy to have. I wouldn’t want to be without it.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My son and I each bought a Subaru Legacy wagon in 1995. Neither has been back to the dealer. We just put in gas and change oil. The all-wheel drive is great on snow and on gravel roads.
“My worst buy is a 1996 Ford F-250 4-WD. It gets only 10 mpg and has no power with a load on. It won’t even go the speed limit on the interstate and it has a vibration at 30 to 45 mph that two visits to the dealer hasn’t solved. At less than 5,000 hrs., they now plan to replace both drive shafts. One other annoyance: the spare tire didn’t match the other four tires.”
Best Buy
“My 1996 Bush Hog riding mower is one of the best mowers I’ve ever used. The 18 hp engine has a lot of power. This mower doesn’t scalp the lawn and tall grass and weeds don’t bother it at all. The only problem is that at times my feet and legs get a little dirty.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
A 1994 Ford 1520 tractor rates as Tom’s “best buy”. “It has performed perfectly and has more power for its size than any other tractor I’ve ever seen. All we’ve done is change the oil and filter. “My 1997 Makita cordless drill is my worst buy. It’s poorly balanced, and the reversing switch is poorly located which makes it hard to use. Also, the circuit breaker that protects the motor kicks out too easy.”
Best Buy
“My 1996 Case-IH 1840 skid steer loader equipped with a diesel engine and cab is my best buy. It has more than 200 hours on it with no problems, and I don’t expect any. The cab is really nice to have when the wind is blowing or it’s snowing and cold. A skid steer loader has so many uses that I couldn’t farm without one. I wish that I could switch between the bucket and bale fork by simply pushing a button like on the company’s 1845 model.”
Best Buy
“I like my Kuhn 3-pt. mounted Gyrorake. Because it’s 3-pt. mounted I can raise it up out of the way and drive over wind-rows. It’s very maneuverable and works great for flipping hay over and windrowing at fast speeds. Also, it sweeps clean and gentle on grass.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My Westfield 13-in. dia., 61-ft. long auger equipped with a swinging low-profile hopper is my best buy. It raises hydraulically which makes it easy to handle and it has a lot of capacity which really speeds up harvest.” On the minus side, he lists Firestone 12.00 by 16 4-rib front tractor tires. “The tires are so soft that sunflower stalks will puncture them. Both tires failed by about 2,000 hours - they broke just outside the bead.”
Best Buy
“My 1995 Deere 5300 MFWD tractor equipped with a Deere 540 front-end loader is my best buy. It’s hard to believe what it will do. The shuttle reverser works great. It’s been completely trouble-free.”
Best Buy
Kevin nominates his 1992 Polaris 350 2-WD ATV as his “best buy”. “It’s easy to drive and handle. I really like the automatic transmission because I can just hit the throttle and go. It’s a very versatile machine. I mount a sprayer attachment on it in order to spot spray weeds.”
Best Buy
“My 1993 Case-IH 5140 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a front-end loader is my best buy. It has more than 5,000 hours on it without ever being in the shop. It’s the best loader tractor I’ve ever owned. The shuttle shift transmission works great for loading snow, feed, and manure. The front wheel assist has been trouble-free and works so well that at times it seems like I don’t even need the rear wheels. I liked it so well that I bought a Case-IH 5250 tractor last year. “I’ve had a lot of problems with the Bradco backhoe which I mounted on our New Holland skid steer loader. The digger itself works well, but if I dig too deep the cap on the boom-mounted hydraulic cylinder pops off. It happened seven different times. I lost a lot of oil and spent a lot of time repairing the cylinder. So far, the company hasn’t done anything to help. I’m really disappointed. I called them five times but they never returned my calls.”
Best Buy
James is the satisfied owner of a 1996 Case-IH 5250, 105 hp front wheel assist tractor. “It handles well, is easy on fuel, and has a lot of power. I can’t say enough good things about it. “Our 1997 Dodge Dakota Club Cab pickup handles easy and has a lot of power. This is our third Dakota pickup and we’ve been happy with all of them.”
Best Buy
Dale owns a “best buy” 1995 Deere 8300 tractor. “I test drove this model and a Case-IH Magnum tractor for two days, pulling identical Earthmaster tillage implements, and there was no comparison. The Deere has a superior ride and a cab door that’s easier to enter and exit. Also, the cab’s expanded glass area provides excellent visibility.”
Best Buy
“It has a lot of power and does a good job,” says Gerald, pleased with his 1995 Cub Ca-det 1440 riding mower. “It has a lot of ower and does a good job. It’s built to last.”
Best Buy
“My Case-IH 5130 tractor has only 86 hp but does the work of the 130 hp tractor that it replaced. “MyGreat Plains 10-ft. no-till drill does a good job in corn stalks and saves time. “My Hesston 12-wheel rake works fast. I can use it in the field at the same time as the baler. It leaves windrows so wide I hardly even have to weave the baler.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“I like my 3 hp, 2-cycle, compact DR trimmer/mower (Country Home Products, Ferry Road, Box 89, Charlotte, Vt. 05445). “I have a large lawn with a lot of trees and shrubs to trim around. With an ordinary weed whacker my back would give out in 25 to 30 minutes, but my DR trimmer lets me do all the trimming in one shot. I also have better control of the cutting head. No more back aches. “My Case 644 Wheel Loader, bought used, is my worst buy. It runs good but is so underpowered I can’t even push the bucket into a pile of loose gravel. What a wimp.”
Best Buy
“My 1996 Niemeyer rotary hay rake makes an extremely fluffy windrow even in tough hay. As a result the hay dries much faster in the row. We can rake about 20 percent faster than we could with our former hydraulic drive, parallel bar rake.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Francis is impressed with his 1996 Howse 6-ft. 3-pt. rotary shredder. “It has four knives so it stays sharp over a longer period of time. It’s also built heavy enough for years of use. However, I wish the gearbox had a drain plug so that it could be drained and flushed periodically. “My 1996 De Walt VSR 3/8-in. keyless electric drill is my worst buy. It worked alright for a while, then close to the 1-year warranty it started snapping and popping. Also, it wouldn’t always start when I pulled the trigger. It had only 5 to 10 hours of use on it.”
Best Buy
Robert likes his 1993 Deere 535 big round baler equipped with surface wrap, converging wheels, and hydraulic pickup lift. “It’s a simple and clean machine that has been trouble-free since day one. The ‘bale track’ monitor is the best on the market for making perfect bales. The only modification I made was to install an electric row shut-off solenoid valve off an old planter, which allows me to control the start of the tieing by simply pushing a button in the cab.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
A 1992 Case-IH 1140 compact tractor equipped with an Alo 180 front-end loader rates as Rick’s “best buy”. “It has enough size and maneuverability for all kinds of jobs, and the loader makes it even handier to use than a skid steer loader. I use it with a Woods 372 6-ft. belly mower. I wouldn’t sell this tractor for twice what I paid for it. Cub Cadet now handles these tractors and I wouldn’t hesitate to buy one from them.” He isn’t impressed with Stockade concrete and steel sealer. “This stuff is junk. It was advertised for use on moldboard plows but it came off after only six months. It might work alright on wooden trailer floors, but I won’t use it again.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
Glenn traded his International 1480 combine in for a 1995 Case-IH 2188 model which is his “best buy”. “It has more horsepower and hydraulic capacity than the 1480 so the header raises faster. Also, the hydrostatic drive transmission doesn’t slip as much and the sieves and fan have more capacity. “One of my worst buys ever was my 1990 Ford F-150 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine. Every time I started out I had to rev the engine way up and slip the clutch or the engine would die. The paint peeled off and the dealer said the company would pay to have it repainted. However, they didn’t.”
Best Buy
Allen likes his “best buy” 1994 Rissler 230 stationary TMR mixer. “It has a unique design that requires little maintenance and low horsepower and results in thorough mixing. I expect it to last a long time.”
Best BuyWorst Buy
“My best buy of all time is my 8,000-lb. Ox 12-volt electric winch. I use it every day on my boom truck which I often use for slaughtering cattle on the farm. It’s 20 years old but has had only minor problems. “My 1992 Deutz GP 220 round baler and 1976 Deutz 6206 tractor are best buys. I bought both of them used and they’ve been completely trouble-free. “My 1994 Chevrolet 4-WD dually pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter diesel engine and overdrive automatic transmission is my worst buy. The fuel injection pump went out and I had to have the pickup towed at a cost of $250. The company paid for only $75 of that cost. The pickup was in the shop for nine days, and two days after I got it back the same problem happened again only this time it was worse. It tended to stall and started hard. “I took it to another dealer who had it in the shop for two days and replaced the fuel injection pump, lift pump, and computer. After that the pickup ran much better, but the engine still missed occasionally. Then the ‘service engine soon’ light came on again and the engine started losing power and missing. The front wheel drive actuator valve had to be replaced twice. The engine oil cooler line broke after only 6,000 miles, and the tailgate kept falling open (there was a company recall on the latches). The pickup’s front end was so far out of alignment that I wore out two sets of front tires after only 19,000 miles. The dealer said he couldn’t line it up properly because of a boom I have on the pickup. I took it to my tire dealer who lined it up, and I haven’t had any more problems after 30,000 miles. “My 1978 Chevrolet 4-WD dually pickup has 460,000 miles on it and we still use it to plow snow and haul hay.”
Best Buy
“It’s easy to operate and does an excellent job,” says Loris about his Valley center pivot that’s designed to irrigate a quarter section of land. “We’ve used several Valley irrigators over the years and they’ve all been dependable. I’m sure this new one will live up to our expectations. The company has never sacrificed quality in any of its products.”
Best Buy
Paul says he’s “well satisfied” with his 1996 Bush Hog mower. “It does a good job and doesn’t overload my tractor in heavy brush. My 1991 Deere rotary mower overloaded my tractor and pulled hard even when it was standing still with no material in it at all. My low horsepower tractor just plays with the Bush Hog, even in heavy brush and 8 to 9-ft. tall weeds.”
Best Buy
“My 1990 Case-IH 1640 combine was simple to maintain and had only one minor breakdown in six years . I liked it so much I traded it for a Case-IH 2144 combine. “My 1993 Deere Gator works great. I put more hours on it every year than I do on my tractor or combine. No problems.”
Best Buy
Mike likes his four Hesston 4900 1-ton big square balers. “We’ve owned several of these balers in the past. We use our current models to make 40,000 to 50,000 bales per year with very few breakdowns. They’ve been very dependable and have a lot of capacity. “In the past we used a 1994 MVE 8000 self-propelled big square bale stacker but it had a lot of problems the first year we owned it so we traded it for a new one the next year. We used it for two years but we couldn’t keep it together. The machines cost $125,000 apiece. Finally we sold it back to the dealer at a big loss.”