Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999)

62 reports from pages 14–17 · 57 Best Buys18 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Ford F-250 4-WD pickup

Ron W. Felce, Forest Grove, B.C. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

Ron’s still driving his 1974 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup which has a whopping 675,000 miles on it. “It was originally a heavy duty 3/4-ton. In 1982 it was damaged in an accident so we converted it to a 1-ton model and equipped it with an 8-ft. flat deck, 1-ton rear end, and dual wheels. We also replaced the original 360 cu. in. engine with a 428 cu. in. high performance engine which has been rebuilt twice over the years. The pickup had some rust so we replaced the hood and doors and put fiberglass floorboards in the cab. It still looks great. We use it to haul cows, firewood, and hay - sometimes all three in the same day. With its heavy-duty running gear it can pull almost anything, including 8-ton hay wagons. I wish the company would build trucks like this again.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped

Reno Bertoia, Baldwinton, Sask. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

Reno owns a 1989 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped with a 460 cu. in. engine. “It has more than 180,000 miles on it but still runs good. I had to change the wheel hubs a year ago and also a ring gear and starter, but I still think it’s a good pickup. Consumer Reports magazine said this model was a lemon, but I don’t know where they get their information.”

Best Buy

Stihl 028 AV chain saw + 2 more

Steve Floyd, Eustace, Texas · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“I like my 1985 Stihl 028 AV chain saw. It has had only one spark plug in 14 years but still never fails to start. It’s the best chain saw I’ve ever owned.”

On the minus side, he lists his 1993 Deere 111 riding mower. “It wouldn’t mow evenly and the Briggs & Stratton gas engine kept breaking down. It spent more time in the shop than it did on my lawn. After using it for two years I finally traded it in for an IH Cub Cadet which I really like.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 heavy-duty extended cab

Richard Neal, Caldwell, Texas · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

Richard’s happy with his 1999 Ford F-250 heavy-duty extended cab pickup equipped with a turbocharged diesel engine. “It has more pulling power than any pickup in its class and is one of the quietest diesel pickups on the road. I really like the two extra rear doors which are standard equipment.”

Worst Buy

Kodiak push-type floor sweeper + 1 more

Klydon Farms, Brandon, Manitoba · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“My 1998 Kodiak push-type floor sweeper makes it almost fun to clean the cement floors in my shop and Quonset building. It’s quite expensive so I resisted buying it for a long time, but I finally broke down and spent the money. Now I’m glad I did.

“The 1998 20 hp Honda twin cylinder motor that I use to operate my grain auger is my worst buy ever. I own other single cylinder Honda motors and they work great, but this twin cylinder model is a piece of junk. It’s difficult to start in cold weather, runs poor in humid, cold weather, and stalls repeatedly once the temperature falls below -15 F. I installed a new ‘winter front’ primer pump and a low temperature carburetor, but they haven’t helped much. The company replaced the motor but the new one doesn’t work any better. It would make a good boat anchor.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

GM extended cab 1/2-ton + 1 more

Greg Butler, Croton, Ontario · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“It’s equipped with a Vortec 305 cu. in. engine that has a lot of power and is easy on fuel,” says Greg about his 1997 GM extended cab 1/2-ton 2-WD pickup. “It has needed only regular maintenance. The cab is nicely laid out. The back seat can be a little tight for bigger people but is still handy. If this pickup keeps on performing like it has, my next pickup will definitely be another GM.”

On the negative side, “The pickup came factory-equipped with Goodyear Tiger Paw Uniroyal tires which were awful. I hated them from the start and replaced them at 20,000 miles. They had no ‘bite’ at all and would squeal whenever I turned, even if I turned slowly.”

Best Buy

Honda + 1 more

Ray Meardi, Hylo, Alberta · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“I like my Honda 3-in. and 2-in. water pumps. Even after they sit idle over the winter, I can start them right up again with just a couple of pulls.

“I’m also pleased with my 1997 portable bandsaw sawmill made by Montana Saw-mill Mfg. It’s simple, relatively inexpensive, and does the job of bandsaw mills that cost twice as much. I paid $5,000 for it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland 640 silage + 2 more

Ron Ratzlaff, Avon, S. Dak. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“My New Holland 640 ‘silage special’ baler makes nice, tight round bales every time and has been maintenance-free.

“My New Holland LX885 skid steer loader has about 1,200 hours on it and is a best buy. The only problem was a fuel injector that went bad. However, the repair work was covered by warranty. In my opinion it’s the best skid steer out there.”

“A 1996 Polaris Sportsman 500 is my worst buy. The repair bills on it never seem to end. Repair work has included a camshaft, U-joint, two drive belts, and both clutch pulleys. Also, it wouldn’t shift into range easily. No dealer wants it as a trade-in so it’s costing us about 90 cents a mile to own.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 pickup

W.C. Waltz, Jr., Chinchilla, Pa. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

He says a 1988 Ford F-350 pickup with a 7.3-liter diesel engine was his “worst buy” ever. “The company spent more than $50,000 doing warranty work on this pickup but still they wouldn’t take it back. Instead they just keep fixing it over and over and over. Luckily I had an extended warranty policy so all the repair work was covered except for a $25 deductable.”

Best Buy

DR brush mower + 1 more

Gary Ronan, Lindstrom, Minn. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

Gary’s impressed with his DR brush mower (Country Home Products, Vergennes, Vt.). “I have several acres of brush, sumac, and buckthorn and I had tried every way I could think of to get rid of them without success. Hand-held brush cutters were just too slow and sickle bar mowers couldn’t deal with the sumac, some of which is over 1 in. dia. But the DR mower cuts down almost everything I point it at. I use the company’s stock blade on it. They offer a 5-lb. blade but I haven’t had to use it. I bought what the company now calls their ‘Classic’ model. However, next time I’d get their gear drive model because it has a reverse gear which would be nice to have from time to time.

“My 1997 Century Mig 140 welder is a best buy. It’s a 110-volt model which works great as a spot welder. One negative is that most of the welds it makes have the appearance of chicken droppings. I’ve also used the company’s 220-volt models with no problems so I suspect that the appearance has to do with the 110-volt power.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Northern Hy-draulics + 1 more

John Preikschat, White City, Sask. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“My 1994 1-ton engine hoist from Northern Hy-draulics has a simple design and is reliable. It’s easy to partially disassemble for transport when I loan it to friends.

On the “worst buy” side, he doesn’t like Westward knife guards designed to replace the original guards on New Holland sickle mowers. “The castings are rough and have a slightly different design than the New Holland guards in the mounting area. This results in reduced cutting ability, especially in heavy or damp conditions.”

Best Buy

Proven Pumps Corp., Inc

Marion Frank, Loudonville, Ohio · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Marion likes his model 360 A.C. pony pump made by Proven Pumps Corp., Inc., (1440 N. Spring St., Los Angeles, Calif. 90012). “It’s a nice little pump. By hooking a garden hose up to it I can move water to my sheep. As long as the impeller is wet it’ll self prime to 7 ft. I bought it from Northern Hydraulics (Box 1499, Burnsville, Minn. 55337 ph 612 894-8310).

Best Buy

Lincoln Town car

Neil Noble, Shelburne, Ontario · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“I bought my 1988 Lincoln Town car used five years ago and it’s the best car I’ve ever owned. It has 134,000 miles on it but still doesn’t use any oil. It gets 28 mpg and has a comfortable ride. I drive in a lot of bad weather but I always feel safe with this car. It has a frame under it like the frame on a pickup.“ his best to fix it, but the problem is in the design. I’ve used New Holland hay equipment for several years and have been satisfied with it. However, this baler has shaken my faith in New Holland equipment.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husqvarna 266 chain saw + 1 more

Abe Hanson, Worsley, Alberta · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“It continues to work well for me year after year with only regular maintenance. No major problems,” says Abe about his 1985 Husqvarna 266 chain saw.

His “worst buy” is his 1997 Deere 5200 tractor. “The collar shift transmission is almost impossible to engage without grinding the gears. I also had problems with the clutch, and the starter had to be rebuilt, all at less than 120 hours. The noise level is so high that I can’t operate it comfortably without using ear plugs.”

Best Buy

REM 1026 grain vac

Maurice Kostichok, Insinger, Sask. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“Our 1992 REM 1026 grain vac has a lot of capacity for its size and has been trouble-free except for a V-belt and a bearing which we had to replace. There just aren’t many parts on it that can go wrong. It works great for unloading grain bins - in fact, we seldom have to use an auger to unload the bins any more. Custom truckers are impressed by its performance.”

Best Buy

International Harvester 86 + 1 more

Jim Briggs, Marsing, Idaho · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Jim likes his International 86 series tractors. “They’re good tractors and you don’t need a computer degree in order to work on them. Maintain them properly and they’ll last forever.

“I’ve had problems with the electronic clutches on my International 5088 tractor. Otherwise it’s a good tractor, too.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Corsica car equipped

Les McEwan, Altamont, Manitoba · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Les is unhappy with his 1995 Chevrolet Corsica car equipped with a 2.2-liter 4-cyl. engine. “It has been a nightmare from the day we bought it. The car began blowing head gaskets during the first year, but we were reassured that many of these cars had been shipped with defective head gaskets and that the problem had been corrected.

“However, two months after the warranty expired the engine developed a serious coolant leak. The car was returned to the dealer who told me that it needed yet another new head gasket. By this time the warranty had expired and they were going to charge $900 to do the work. I thought that was too much for a 4-cyl. gas engine so I took the car to a machine shop. They discovered that the head was warped and that the original valve train had been incorrectly assembled. To add insult to injury, when I appealed the case to GM, I was told that the problem was my fault because I hadn’t flushed the coolant at 30,000 miles, even though we had never been able to keep the same anti-freeze in the engine for more than seven months.

“The re-machined head managed to stay on the car for more than a year, but then it cracked apart and had to be replaced due to defects in the casting. Because this has been a long-standing problem with this car and was documented back to the warranty period, we again appealed to GM but to no avail. They’ve generously offered to list me as a dissatisfied customer on their computer file. To date this car has had three heater cores, two radiators, an alternator, and two heads, with no signs of improvement.

“We have three cars, four pickups, two grain trucks, five tractors and many other pieces of farm equipment on our farm, but this car has been the single most expensive piece of equipment to maintain that we’ve ever had.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet heavy-duty 1/2-ton pickup + 2 more

Jerry Richter, Newell, Iowa · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“I like my 1997 Chevrolet heavy-duty 1/2-ton pickup, especially the newly-designed power steering. It rides and drives excellent.

“My 1999 Sudenga 10-in. dia., 71-ft. long grain auger is well made and has a flexible hopper that’s easy to use.

“I like my Deere 9600 combine. I use a 30-ft. platform on it to harvest soybeans. My only complaint is that the machine is underpowered when harvesting beams with tough stems.”

Best Buy

John Deere 336 baler + 3 more

Dave Gilbert, Onoway, Alberta · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Dave has a small hobby farm and says he has purchased a lot of older equipment over the past 25 years that still works well. “One best buy was a Deere 336 baler which I bought used 14 years ago. It continues to make consistently good bales with no problems. I’ve used it to make about 30,000 bales and have had to replace only two shear pins.

“My International Farmall 460 diesel tractor is easy on fuel and equipped with a torque amplifier which makes it an ideal baling tractor. It doesn’t have power steering but is still easy to steer. The only problem is that it’s hard to start. I have to use glow plugs.

“I use my Massey Harris 444 gas tractor as a loader and chore tractor. I added power steering so the tractor is easy to steer even with the loader on it. It’s one of the best starting tractors I’ve ever had and just keeps on running with minimal repairs. The only problem I had was finding a replacement high pressure seal for the Webster electric/hydraulic pump. They seem to be impossible to find. This would be a perfectly good hydraulic pump if it weren’t for problems with a $10 seal.

“I purchased my McCormick Deering WD6 tractor about 20 years ago for $450. Although I use this tractor only to operate a side delivery rake now, it still runs well and has never needed any major repairs. I wonder if the tractors being made today will be running 40 years from now, or will they be in the junk yard?”

Best Buy

John Deere 2355 utility tractor

Thomas Spurliwg, Ft. Lipton, Colo. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Thomas likes his 1992 Deere 2355 utility tractor. “It has more power and is more fuel efficient than the Deere 730 it replaced. One complaint, however, is that using the clutch and backing up at the same time is difficult because the seat doesn’t swivel. Also, the 3-pt. lever is mounted too low, making it hard to reach conveniently when backing up.”

Best Buy

Hesston 1160 hydraulic swing swather/conditioner

James E. Yoder, Bonanza, Ore. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“It has performed with flying colors,” says James, pleased with his Hesston 1160 hydraulic swing swather/conditioner. “I had a field that was plowed the previous fall but filled up with volunteer grain anyway the following spring. I let the grain grow to chop for hay. I was concerned that the swather wouldn’t track to either side of the row as it’s supposed to, but it worked perfectly. What’s more, the swather’s never plugged in heavy grass or alfalfa, either.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 066 chain saw equipped + 1 more

George E. Lutgen, Jr.: Lowell, Ind. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

George has had good luck with his 1997 Stihl 066 chain saw equipped with an interchangeable 25 and 36-in. bar. “It’s easy to start, is lightweight and has plenty of power. It’s easy to change bars and chains, and the slack adjuster on the side to tighten the chain is easy to use.”

On the negative side, a 3/8-in. Snap-On ratchet built in a 1/4-in. flex head body is one of his “worst buys”. “The ratcheting head breaks every time you use it. My dealer doesn’t stock the replacement head so it’s been broken more often than not.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grasshopper 725 mower equipped + 2 more

William L. Kentner, Bossevain, Man. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

William’s made two “best buys” in the last couple of years.

“My 1997 Grasshopper 725 mower equipped with 52-in. deck and Kohler engine starts well and has plenty of power. I like the ease of handling and self-dumping bagger. They both come in handy in my lawn mowing business. My only complaint is that there are no dealers in southwestern Manitoba for parts or service work.

“Another ‘best buy’ is my 1997 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped with a Powerstroke diesel engine. It’s got good ground clearance and tons of power. For example, it’ll pull a 24-ft. trailer loaded with two antique tractors with ease. It also provides great visibility. My wife would like to see a light on the gearshift and a ‘booster’ handle on the passenger side.”

On the negative side, William lists his 1996 Snapper self-propelled 21-in. mower powered by a Briggs & Stratton engine. “I used it a month before I discovered the air filter hadn’t been installed at the factory. The dealer told me the engine was ready to go and took five months to get the new motor. I traded it later in the season for a Deere that has worked fine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

White American 80 + 1 more

Wilson Burkholder, Dayton, Va. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“The WhiteAmerican 80 we bought used with 752 hours on it is a best buy. It’s equipped with a 3.9-liter Cummins engine, 6-speed transmission and 3-speed powershift, which give it plenty of power and torque. It also has a fantastic hydraulic system that makes it a pleasure to operate. It now has 2,500 trouble-free hours on it.

“We installed an aftercooler boosting horsepower to 115 so it’ll pull our forage harvester and power drainage tillage.

“Our worst buy was a 440 Mustang skid steer loader. It was very hard to get started, even in the summer. Various other problems included catching fire. We finally traded it off on a Case 1835B which proved to be a good machine.”

Best Buy

Jessee Machine quick-hitch

Neal McCleary, Elkton, Md. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Neal and his wife nominate their Jessee Machine quick-hitch for Deere loaders as their “best buy” (1739 Nord Ave., Chico, Calif. 95926; ph 530 342-5379). “The only thing we changed was the release latches, which were located too high. I simply cut them down and welded them back on to solve the problem.”

Best Buy

Ford 661 + 1 more

Dick Chatterton, Avon, Ill. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“Of all the tractors we’ve ever had on our farm, the handiest and most dependable has been our 1960 Ford 661,” says Dick. “It’s easy to operate, handle and service and is equipped with a two-stage clutch and power steering.”

Dick’s also impressed with his 1990 Deere 175 riding mower. “We’ve mowed hundreds of acres over the years and basic maintenance has kept it running like new. The motor and transmission have been completely trouble-free.”

He also liked the deal he got from Harbor Freight after he broke the handle on a new ball peen hammer the first time he used it. “The company not only replaced the broken hammer, but sent me their entire five-piece hammer set free-of-charge.”

Best Buy

Ram 1-ton 4-WD pickup

Ward McCown, Troup, Texas · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

Ward’s “best buy” is his 1998 Dodge 1-ton 4-WD pickup. “I bought this pickup a couple of months ago and have used it a lot since then. It pulls trailers with ease and gets great gas mileage. The flatbed on it makes hauling feed and other cargo easy. The four built-in toolboxes makes storing tools easier than other flatbeds. It also handles well in the mud.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped

Pete Shelton, Meeker, Colo. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 15

“It has unbelievable power, whether it’s running on the flats or going over passes at 11,000 ft.,” says Pete about his 1997 Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped with a Powerstroke engine and 5-speed transmission. “It doesn’t seem to know what a load is. The Crew Cab makes it as comfortable to ride in as any car.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Hol-land baler equipped + 2 more

Robert Benscheid, Grey Eagle, Minn. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“I recently bought a mid-1980’s New Hol-land baler equipped with a Model 70 thrower that’s a ‘best buy’. I was going to keep my mid 1970’s New Holland 273 baler equipped with a Model 54A thrower. But the 311 had so much more capacity, ran so much smoother and made nicer bales, I knew I wouldn’t use the 273 anymore so I traded it off.”

On the “worst buy” side, he’s not happy with his Gehl 250 manure spreader. “The apron has a light shear bolt that breaks much too easily. To change apron speeds is also a hassle. You have to pull a rope on a cam about 4 ft. to change one gear. It gets real tiresome.”

He’s also disappointed in his DeLaval Harmony milkers with DeLaval pulsators. “The pulastors are built so flimsy they break easily if dropped or are bumped hard. The milking unit leaves milk in the bowls so when you switch to another cow, milk runs out of the inflations onto your leg.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Cub Cadet 2284 lawn tractor equipped + 1 more

John J. Strickland, Alachua, Fla. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

John’s most recent “best buy” is a 1997 Cub Cadet 2284 lawn tractor equipped with a 60-in. belly mower. “The 24 hp Kohler V-twin engine is powerful and snappy. The 60-in. mower is super rugged with grease zerks for the wheels and spindles so maintenance is easy. It’s user-friendly and has nice colors and style.”

One of John’s “worst buys” is a 1994 McCulloch 16-in. chain saw. “It’s a nightmare to work on because it assembles and disassembles like a Chinese puzzle. And there are a lot of plastic parts to break.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Westendorf TA46 loader + 1 more

Mark J. Hammer, Ida Grove, Iowa · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“I recently purchased a Westendorf TA46 loader, after owning a Westendorf TA42 loader for 14 years. I never touched the TA42 with a welder except to replace a worn out tooth on the bucket. I put the TA46 on a different tractor and if it’s as good as the TA42 I’ll be very pleased.”

Mark’s “worst buy” is a DeWalt 358 7 1/2-in. dia. circular saw. “The saw only lasted one month past the warranty before the motor shorted out. I’ll never buy another DeWalt tool again.”

Best Buy

EasyCut sickle system

Michael Reed, Yellow Jacket, Colo. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“I give this company an A-1 rating,” says Mark, pleased with the way the manufacturer stood behind the EasyCut sickle system (S.I Distributing, 03221 Barber Werner Road, St. Mary’s, Ohio 45885; ph 800 368-7773) “The EasyCut didn’t work in my case because of our unusual soil conditions and a severe gopher and prairie dog problem. But the company stood behind the product and refunded all my money, including S&H. It’s the most professional, honest company I’ve ever dealt with. Lots of integrity.”

Best Buy

Morton buildings + 3 more

John Heide, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“After 19 years, our Morton buildings still look like new. Also, our 1991 MacDon 7000 swather cuts and works well in our tough Montana wild hay, but the paint and decals are in terrible shape. Our Deere 468 baler is an excellent baler that makes good bales and never misses tying.”

On the other hand, he doesn’t like his Sears Craftsman power washer. “If we’d known there is no way to drain it, we wouldn’t have bought it. They say you have to store it in a warm place to prevent damage form freezing.”

Best Buy

Jiffy bale shredder

Enoch Aarrestad, Debden, Sask. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“So far, it’s been trouble-free,” says Enoch, happy with his 1998 Jiffy bale shredder (Westward Products Ltd., 6517 67th St., Red Deer, Alberta, Canada T4P 1A3; ph 403 340-1160). “We use it to feed 160 cows and 110 backgrounders. We find it uses a lot less power than other machines we’ve used. We’re also able to control the length of cut and speed of feed discharge by adjusting the speed of the rocking cradle, which moves the bale back and forth over the cutting knives. My only beef is that there are only three short pegs on each side to hold the bale steady in the cradle. Occasionally, it doesn’t move the bale back and forth so it could use more pegs, in my opinion.”

Best Buy

Great Plains no-till drill

Ricky Kirkpatrick, Cottontown, Tenn. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“It has performed flawlessly planting rye, grasses, and clovers as well as soybeans, oats and wheat into standing stubble and corn stalks,” says Ricky about his “best buy” 1996 Great Plains 10-ft. no-till drill. “It’s straightforward to operate and maintain, and to set up for different situations.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 466 baler + 2 more

Charlie Sassmen, Reedsport, Ore. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

Charlie likes his older model Deere 466 baler, which hasn’t given him any problems in two years of use, putting up 400 tons of hay per year. “It bales every bale perfectly and never misses tying one.”

He’s also pleased with two Ford 5000 diesel tractors he owns. “One’s got 3,000 hours on it, the other’s got 2,00 hours on it. They never give us a bit of trouble and are easy on fuel.”

On the negative side, he’s disappointed with his 1998 Deere Saber lawnmower equipped with an 18 hp engine. “It breaks every time I set foot on it. First, it was the steering bar. Then it was a bearing out of the mower deck. Next, a cut-out switch went out on the engine and it wouldn’t start. We finally took it back and traded it for a 1998 Craftsman with 21 hp engine which we haven’t had any trouble with so far.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 Super Duty 4-wd pickup equipped + 1 more

Donald Hutson, Paris, Ky. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“It tows six 1,800 to 2,000-lb. round bales with ease,” says Donald, pleased owner of a 1999 Ford F-250 Super Duty 4-WD pickup equipped with 5.4-liter engine, automatic transmission, and 4:10 axles. “The truck handles extremely well and has ample power. We like the style of the new Louisville Line. We also like the straight axle and lock in and out manual front hubs.”

He also likes his 1996 Vermeer Super K baler. “We’ve made over 3,000 bales with it, no problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester 2250 loader + 2 more

Jim Winters, Finch, Ont. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

Jim’s “all time best piece of equipment” is his 20-year-old International 2250 loader. “It still works great and the best part is the ease with which it goes on and comes off the tractor.”

He’s also happy with both his 1997 Case-IH 1020 flex head and his 1998 Case-IH 600 forage blower. “The head works exceptionally well in down and tangled beans. With the automatic header height control, it’s one of the most satisfying machines I’ve ever operated. As for the forage blower, we had a Model 56 blower for 15 years and thought it was great - until we tried the 600.”

On the negative side, “It’s not exactly the worst product I’ve ever owned, but our New Holland 311 baler gave us considerable trouble. Most of it was with the driveline. I purchased the baler new in 1990 and replaced three or four U-joints per year. When we couldn’t seem to find the root of the problem, I finally replaced it with a 575. It’s a much better machine.”

Best Buy

John Deere 750 drill

David Williams, Croton, Ont. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“It does a good job of metering seed for accurate planting,” says Jim about his Deere 750 drill. “After trying other types of drills, we came to the conclusion that you’ve got to match your drill to your soil type. The 750 is best-suited to ours.”

Best Buy

D.R. Trimmer/Mower

Homer W. Christman, Otterbein, Ind. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“It’s a nice machine and is easy to assemble. I was the problem,” says Homer, who found his arthritis prevented him from properly using the D.R. Trimmer/Mower he bought last year. “I had to lean forward to push down on the handle as I walked because of my back pain. That lifted the cutters too much off the ground for it to trim correctly. The company refunded my money promptly when I returned it to them.”

Best Buy

Case-International 685 tractor + 2 more

Debbie McCollum-Foe, Lockport, N.Y. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

Two of Debbie’s “best buys” are her 1990 Case-International 685 tractor and her 1998 Deere Gator 4 by 2. “The tractor is really easy on fuel and is handy for cutting hay and raking. The Gator is a handy tool for odd jobs around the farm. The automatic dump is especially helpful.”

On the “worst buy” side is a 56 by 104-ft. Walters building. “The building itself is generally good but the warranty is terrible. We’ve been trying to get wind damage fixed that occurred under warranty fixed. All we get are empty promises and missed appointments.”

Best Buy

Ram 3/4-ton pickup putting + 1 more

Tom Holm, Idaho Falls, Idaho · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

Tom has had good luck with his 1996 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup, putting 136,000 miles on it in dusty, rough conditions and mud.

However, he does have one complaint. “They should put a better air filter system on the engine. It’s definitely a Mickey Mouse set-up. The second week I had it I got dirt in the engine so I took it back to the dealer. He told me Dodge sometimes had trouble getting the air filters sealed and that a little dirt wouldn’t hurt anything. I told him it certainly doesn’t do any good, either.”

Tom added extra leaf springs to the truck’s suspension so it rides more like a 3/4-ton pickup.

Another of his “best buys” is a Deere 4440 tractor he bought new in 1981. “We haven’t had any trouble with it in thousands of hours of use.”

Best Buy

Hydra-Mac 1700 skid steer loader

Nelson E. Miller, Millersburg, Ohio · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“A lot of dealers promote their engine horsepower, but what you really need is a good hydraulic pump and this one has it,” says Nelson, happy with his 1997 Hydra-Mac 1700 skid steer loader (Hydra-Mac, 1110 Pennington Ave. S., Thief River Falls, Minn. 56701; ph 800 364-0686 or 218 681-7130). “It handles well and has plenty of hydraulic power. I like the ease with which it starts in cold weather. Also, the Hydra-Mac quick-tach plate will accept any attachment that Bobcat and Case make.”

Best Buy

Westendorf TA26 front end loader

Floyd Stivers, Stroud, Okla. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“My only regret is that I didn’t buy one years ago,” says Floyd, whose “best buy” is a 1997 Westendorf TA26 front end loader. “It’s a true quick-tach loader, taking only a few minutes to attach and detach. That makes it practical to take off when it’s not needed. I’ve seen a lot of other so-called ‘quick-tach’ loaders that take two hours or more to install and remove.”

Worst Buy

Bur-row Barn Builders

Gordon Daniels, Stewartsville, Mo. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

Gordon’s “worst buy” is his 40 by 60-ft. metal machine shed constructed in 1991 by Bur-row Barn Builders. “The roof leaks like a sieve. The roofing sheets were put on wrong originally, resulting in an uneven edge at the bottom of the roof. The company put on a new roof but it still leaks. There’s no sealer under the bottom side of the roof. Foam was applied on the ridge top but the wind blew it out so that leaks, too. All the rafters are bowed and the shed has big sliding doors with poor quality latches.

“I called the company and the president came out to our farm. He admitted that our complaints were valid and later sent us a letter stating that the company would do everything in their power to make the repairs. However, they never did. I called an attorney who said that, because it’s an out-of-state company, the best I could do would be to go to small claims court but that means a limit of $1,500 in compensation. So I’m stuck with a barn that leaks.”

Best Buy

Kinze planter equipped

Dale Brandt, Freeburg, Ill. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“I traded my Deere 7000 6-row planter and Deere 15-ft. no-till drill for a used 8-row Kinze planter equipped with splitter row units. It’s my best buy because I can use the same planter for both corn and beans. The planter is three years old but had been used to plant only about 150 acres a year so it was still in great shape. I paid $25,000 for it whereas a new one of the same size would cost at least $32,000. I’m using it this spring to plant 800 acres of Roundup Ready soybeans and figure that I’ll save $4,000 to $5,000 in seed thanks to the increased accuracy. In my opinion, the value of no-till drills will drop way off this year because the low wheat prices mean a lot of farmers will plant beans instead of wheat. Another reason for this trend is that Roundup Ready soybeans can be grown cheap.

“I gain width by switching to an 8-row planter instead of a 6-row. Using the same machine to plant both corn and beans isn’t a disadvantage because there’s only a few days a year where I need to plant both crops at the same time. If necessary I can rent another planter.”

Best Buy

Deutz D5206 tractor

Calvin R. Wilson, Campbellsburg, Ky. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“A few years ago there was a “best buy” report in FARM SHOW on my 1975 Deutz D5206 tractor. I still own that tractor and it still runs great. I later bought a used 1975 Deutz D6806 tractor which is also a best buy. No problems at all. Deutz tractors are easy to handle, have good pto’s, and are cheap to operate.”

Best Buy

Honda rototiller

Claude Jahn, Cambridge, Wis. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

Claude says his 1987 Honda rototiller is his “best buy”. “It’s equipped with a 3 1/2 hp, 4-stroke OHV engine and 24-in. wide front tines and has two forward gears and one reverse. I’ve used it 20 to 25 hours each year and it still starts right up on the first or second pull. It’s equipped with an advanced automatic decompression feature that makes the starter rope easy to pull. This rototiller can cover more than twice as much ground as other comparable size models I’ve used in the past, while using only about half as much fuel. It can work up any type of soil, including tough sod, with little effort required by the operator. This machine makes rototilling fun, not a chore.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Massey Ferguson tractors + 1 more

Chris Runstedler, Listowel, Ontario · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“We’ve owned about 25 different Massey Ferguson tractors over the past 35 years and all of them have been best buys. Perkins diesel engines have great lugging ability, start well in cold weather, and are easy on fuel. The transmissions have generally performed well. Best of all, Massey tractors cost 10 to 40 percent less than comparable size Deere or Case-IH models and are every bit as good or better.

“My newest model is a 6180 which is equipped with a creeper gear transmission and front 3-pt. hitch and pto. I bought it to operate my pto-driven Meri Crusher which I use to clear land and grind up tree stumps and brush. I was told that using the Meri Crusher would be a challenge for my tractor’s pto driveline. Apparently a lot of tractors can’t handle the Meri Crusher but after running the crusher for more than 100 hours with my 6180, I’ve had no problems. The tractor is a pleasure to drive and the Dynashift transmission is fantastic. Best of all, this tractor costs about $25,000 less than a comparable Deere without the factory-mounted front 3-pt. hitch.”

On the “worst buy” side, Chris lists the Cummins 855, 315 hp, 6-cyl. diesel engine that powers his 1989 Ford tandem axle feed truck. “At about 60,000 miles the piston head came off the number 5 cylinder and completely ruined the engine. The 3-year warranty had expired but the dealer told us that Cummins would ‘treat us right’. However, the company paid for only about $1,500 of parts and we had to pay the balance - more than $9,000 (Canadian). Other truck fleet owners we talked to said we should complain. We finally talked to the top representative of Cummins in Canada but he didn’t want to hear about it. We own 20 different diesel-powered machines and have never had an engine failure like this, but then we had never owned a Cummins diesel before either.”

Best Buy

Case-IH 1466 tractor

Neil Wehr, Sigourney, Iowa · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“Last fall we bought a Case-IH 1466 tractor and used it to pull a chisel plow. It has a lot of power and performed well. The only problem was a chipped tooth on a bull and pinion gear which we promptly repaired.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 pickup + 1 more

Richard D. Pilgrim, Nevada, Iowa · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“My 1997 Ford F-150 pickup is my best buy. It rides comfortably, shifts smooth, and at 17 to 18 mpg is fuel efficient. The 4.6-liter engine has plenty of power to pull my flatbed trailer.

“My 1997 Mercury Sable car is the hardest riding car I’ve ever owned. I think my F-150 pickup rides better. The car also makes too much wind noise.”

Best Buy

Dual mini backhoe attachment

Roger Hubmer, Mankato, Minn. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

Roger’s satisfied with his Dual mini backhoe attachment designed for skidsteer loaders. “It’s an affordable alternative to the higher priced backhoes on the market, selling for only about $1,600. We use it to repair field tile, etc. It can dig a trench 5 1/2 ft. deep.”

Best Buy

Westendorf front-end loader + 3 more

Conrad Wright, Greentown, Ind. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 17

“My Westendorf front-end loader is well designed and built heavy. Anyone who needs a loader should price one.

“My IBM Aptiva computer is also a best buy. It comes with Lotus spread sheets. I added a Brother printer which also faxes, copies, scans, and prints.

“I like my 1998 GM Sonoma pickup but I hate the automatic lights on it. The only way to turn them off is to hit them with a hammer.”