Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008)

77 reports from pages 12–15 · 70 Best Buys18 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Kubota tractors ranging

Ray Bjorgaard, De Soto, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“During the last 32 years I’ve owned eight different Kubota tractors ranging from 16 to 63 hp, and never had a bad one. I used a 19 hp B8200 model for 16 years to do commercial landscaping. Four years ago I traded that tractor for a 34 hp B2910 model, which I love.”

Best Buy

Case 1840 skid loader

Todd Rufenacht, Wauseon, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“My 1992 Case 1840 skid loader is a flawless machine. We’ve used it at least twice a day on our dairy farm for 15 years and now it has more than 7,000 hours on it. The biggest repair was replacement of the water pump at about 4,200 hours.”

Best Buy

John Deere 3320 tractor equipped

Theodore David Shields, Sr., Camden, Delaware · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“In October of 2005 I bought a new Deere 3320 tractor equipped with a 300 CX front-end loader. The tractor now has 56 hours on it but I’ve only been able to use the loader itself for about four hours. The pins and bushings on the loader were loose. The amount of slop in the pins was what you’d expect to find in an old, wornout loader that had been abused and not greased regularly.

“In my opinion, the craftsmanship on this loader is of inferior quality. The dealer that I bought it from sent someone out to tell me that everything is within company guidelines. I’ve waited all my life to own a new Deere tractor, and now all I’ve got is something made with inferior parts made in China. I always thought Deere was like mom and apple pie. Everyone thinks their tractors are 100 percent American made. Deere should advertise the truth that their 300 CX loader is assembled in Canada with parts imported from China. I wonder where the tractor itself was made, and where the parts on it came from?”

Best Buy

Advance grain trailer parked

Barry and Lana Love, Hardisty, Alberta · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“This photo shows our Advance grain trailer parked beside Highway 13 about two miles west of Hardisty, Alberta. The trailer buckled last July with 27 tons of wheat on it, even though the trailer has a legal weight limit of 30 tons. I bought the trailer new in 1998. It has fewer than 60,000 miles on it and has been used only for farm work. We have two engineer’s reports that say the trailer buckled due to a structural flaw. I think the company should stand behind its products. Ever since this accident, we’ve been leary when working around these trailers.”

Best Buy

Bag Balm

Alfred Gustafson, Vinton, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“Years ago, when farmers milked cows by hand, they used a product called Bag Balm on cow teats (Dairy Association Co., Inc; ph 800 626-3610; www.bagbalm.com). It’s a medicated ointment with lanolin in it that softens and moistens the skin. I recently started using this product on my dry, itchy skin and it worked great. It’s much less expensive than drugstore medications. It still comes in packaging that has remained virtually unchanged for more than 100 years.”

Best Buy

Nextel wireless phone service

Paul Anderson, Cole Harbor, N. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

Paul likes Nextel wireless phone service. “If you spend 90 percent of your time within Nextel’s service area, they offer a far superior wireless phone service to anything cellular. I bought my Nextel Motorola i580 phone in August of 2006 and have had very few dropped calls - only about a dozen that I can remember. Their call clarity is far superior to what I was using in the past.

“The phone is rubber-armored and built to military specs. I have the one-button, direct connect with my employees included in my service that works like a walkie talkie. It’s not the cheapest service out there, but I have noticeably lower blood pressure and less frustration ever since I got rid of my old wireless service.”

Best Buy

FARM SHOW is my best buy

Larry Thompson, Chouteau, Okla. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“FARM SHOW is my best buy. It features amazing stuff to build and read. Wow! It helps unlock the brain and makes a person at the very least go out and build something new. What other product does that? I always look forward to the next issue.”

Best Buy

Anschutz 22 Rim Fire model 1710

Bob Norby, Moorhead, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“I like high quality guns and own an Anschutz 22 Rim Fire model 1710. I bought it for about $1,300. This same company makes the Olympic competition models that sell for up to $10,000 so I figured it would be a great gun. Unfortunately, the trigger is a joke. It’s supposed to be adjustable but it’s not.”

Worst Buy

NorTrac 20 hp 4-wd diesel

William P. Goshorn, Bondurant, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“My 2000 NorTrac 20 hp 4-WD diesel tractor is my worst buy. In the spring of 2005, a bearing wore out in the tractor’s timing gear, destroying two gears and the aluminum case. I went to Northern Tool and spent more than $100 for the wrong parts, which the company wouldn’t take back. I never did get the parts I needed from them. Poor customer service. I found the correct parts at Homier Distributing (www.Homier.com; ph 800 348-5004) for just $65.”

Best Buy

Witzco Challenger 50-ton 3-axle lowboy

Pete Johnson, Huntsville, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“I bought a Witzco Challenger 50-ton, 3-axle lowboy trailer in 1999 from a local distributor. I was happy with it so in late 2005 I decided to buy another one. It was delivered in February, 2006. However, the new trailer wouldn’t lift up after being loaded so I called the company. They told me I had the wrong pump and sent out a new one. The new pump didn’t help. Now the company won’t do anything about the problem. I think it needs a bigger motor.”

Worst Buy

Montana tractor

B. W. Donaldson, Memphis, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“My 2005 Montana tractor is my worst buy. I’ve reported on the problems with this tractor before but failed to mention two other defects. The square towbar holder on the underside split out while carrying a load of hay. Also, the adjuster for keeping a piece of equipment level has got to be tied off or it will unadjust itself.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Pontiac GT-6 hard top rectractible + 1 more

Gene G. Allen, Topeka, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“My 2006 Pontiac GT-6 hard top rectractible convertible is a fun car to drive even for a 70-year-old. It looks like a two-door hardtop with the top up from both the inside and outside. I can switch from hardtop to convertible in only 30 seconds by pushing a button. This car gets 30 mpg, accelerates well, and handles like a sports car. It makes me feel 30 years younger.

“My 2002 Polaris 325 Magnum ATV is my worst buy. The cheap spring clamps on the hoses to the oil cooler failed, dumping out two quarts of oil under the ATV and causing total engine failure. Even though the factory recalled more than 100,000 of these units for factory modifications they just played dodgeball concerning my problem. They wouldn’t stand behind their product.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chicago electric power tools + 3 more

Randy Robey, Tehachap, California · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 12

“I’m a handyman/mechanic and purchase tools regularly. Some of the stuff I’ve purchased from Harbor Freight is good, and some of it is junk. I like the Chicago electric power tools I bought from them, including a 10-in. industrial tile/brick saw. It has been left outside in the rain and snow but it’s waterproof so it still works good. After one year of use, all it needed was a new $5 drive belt.

“On the other hand, the brushes on my Chi-cago 1 3/4 hp router burned out after only one hour of use. Then, after I replaced the brushes, a switch burned out, all on the same day.

“A Central Hydraulics 12-ton hydraulic pipe bender, bought at Harbor Freight, works good for standard pipe but will kink if used on tubing or EMT conduit.

“My Clear Water 1-in. pump is a worst buy. In the first six months of operation the pump would seize after it sat for a day or so. I have to stick a knife or key in the fan to free it, then start the pump. Another problem is there’s no freeze drain on the bottom of the pump housing. It does work well when it’s running and it only cost $35.”

Best Buy

Can Am Supply rust converter paint

Gordon S. Arnold, Fillmore, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

Gordon says Can Am Supply rust converter paint is a “great product” but that the company’s marketing could be improved. “The problem was that a salesman wouldn’t stop calling us. He called 50 to 60 times in three months. He called prior to delivery of the product to see if it had arrived, he called to see how we liked the product, and he continued to call us all last summer to the point of harassment. I told him never to call again and he laid off for two weeks, but then he resumed calling.”

Worst Buy

Mike says Chinese gas and diesel motors and the products powered by th

Mike Krajcik, Perry, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

Mike says Chinese gas and diesel motors and the products powered by them are “worst buys”. “With the flood of cheap Chinese mechanical products into North America, my only advice is, don’t buy them. They’re often copies of other patents. Nice paint and low price are alluring but whatever you buy will end up in the corner of the shed, right next to the garbage pail.”

Best Buy

American Eagle windmill

Norman Maisel, Quemado, New Mexico · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

Norman likes his American Eagle windmill which he uses to drive a compressor to aerate ponds (ph 440 236-3278; www.pondaeration .com). “This windmill is all it’s advertised to be. It’s easy to assemble and set up and it looks good. It will pay for itself in two to three years in electricity savings.”

Best Buy

FarmTek 30

Bob Mack, Osage, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

A FarmTek 30 by 60-ft. hoop building rates as Bob’s “best buy”. “It’s well built and all the parts were easy to put together. We keep our calves in it (www.farmtek.com; ph 563 875-2288).”

Best Buy

Ford 3/4-ton van

John Perkins, Holland, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

John has more than 402,000 miles on his 1995 Ford 3/4-ton van. “All I’ve replaced are the alternator, heater core, fan belts, and radiator. This vehicle still doesn’t use any oil. I change the oil every 5,000 miles. It’s powered by a 6-cyl., 300 cubic inch engine and automatic transmission. I expect this van to last another 500,000 miles.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chicago Pneumatic heavy duty 1/2-in + 1 more

Jim Petty, Pryor, Okla. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

Jim’s the satisfied owner of a Chicago Pneumatic heavy duty 1/2-in. impact wrench. “This tool is the real deal. It’s simple to operate, powerful, and has variable power settings. I love using it. It can apply up to 425 lbs. of torque, yet is very compact for use in tight places.”

On the negative side is an auxillary 5-gal. gas can made by Blitz. “It dribbles and slob-bers over everything whenever I try to pour from it. The can doesn’t even have a working vent on it. It shouldn’t be too difficult to design a small vent like the ones on every other gas can I’ve ever seen. These ‘inside the spout’ vents are the pits.”

Worst Buy

Troy Bilt Pony garden tiller

James Neil Butchert, Issaqua, Wash. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“My Troy Bilt Pony garden tiller is the most dangerous and poorly designed machine I’ve ever used. It has no drag stake to limit forward motion and will jerk out of my grip and go racing across the ground until it hits something or turns over. There should be either a clutch or a throttle on the hand grip with a spring to stop the machine, so you could close the throttle or release the clutch if you lose your grip.”

Best Buy

Por-ter Cable 14.4-volt cordless drill

Luke Doyle, Chesaw, Wash. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“My Por-ter Cable 14.4-volt cordless drill is my best buy. It’s eight years old and has been charged hundreds of times. The batteries don’t last as long any more, but this drill just keeps on going.

“The air-powered brad-nailer I bought from Harbor Freight is my worst buy. I was able to shoot only seven or eight brads before it quit working. The store I bought it from wouldn’t return it or refund my money so I threw this piece of junk away.”

Best Buy

Ford Explorer equipped

Gerrit R. LaFleur, Mont Alto, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

A 1997 4-WD, 4-door Ford Explorer equipped with a 6-cyl. engine rates as Gerrit’s “best buy”. “I’m a die-hard Ford man and have never owned a bad one. This Explorer is no exception. It’s fuel efficient and doesn’t use any oil. The body is in great shape, it has a comfortable ride, and it’ll tow a big trailer with no problems. It has more than 136,000 miles on it but still runs great.”

Best Buy

Ryobi 18-volt cordless drill + 3 more

Terri Cronn, Remah, New Mexico · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

Terri likes his 2002 Ryobi 18-volt cordless drill and screwdriver. “I’ve used it to build two steel-sided barns. We used a 1/4-in. socket for the screws. I’ve done numerous other projects with it as well.

“I saved a lot of money when I purchased my 4-ton Ryobi log splitter. This little electric splitter works almost as well as a 24-ton gas-driven one. It’s small, stores out of the way, and works all day long.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2006 Chevrolet Equinox all-wheel-drive SUV. “During the first month of use both head gaskets had to be replaced, as well as the intake manifold. The carbon canister, which is a plastic evaporative smog box, is bolted on under the car. Gravel from the SUV’s front wheel hit this plastic box and broke it open. Repair cost was about $300. Also, this vehicle doesn’t really have all-wheel-drive. When it gets stuck, only one front wheel and one rear wheel spin.

“I’ve had a constant problem with my Po-laris Sportsman 500 ATV. If it has to go to 4-WD mode, and then out, often one front wheel stays locked in and it pulls to that side so I have to back up to release it. This is very inconvenient. I change front hub oil often, but it still sticks.”

Best Buy

McCulloch 2014 Eager Beaver chainsaw

Alan Altenbach, Reedsburg, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“The McCulloch 2014 Eager Beaver chainsaw I bought in 1964 is my best buy of all time. It’s equipped with a 14-in. blade. For years it was the only chainsaw I owned. It always starts on the first or second pull, even in cold weather. I bought an 18-in. chainsaw of another brand four years ago, but I still grab the McCulloch unless I’m cutting extra big or very hard wood.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 2500 HD Duramax pickup + 2 more

Dan Bodas, Pittsburg, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“My 2001 Chevrolet 2500 HD Duramax pickup has an added power chip, Banks exhaust, and K&N filter so it has plenty of power to pull anything I want. It gets 20 mpg if I drive at less than 70 mph.

“My 2000 Kubota L4300 loader tractor with cab has been used every day since I bought it with no breakdowns. I use this tractor to haul two big round bales, one on front and one on back. It can load the bales two high on a gooseneck trailer. I like the three remote hydraulic outlets.

“I also like my 2006 Kubota ZD25 60-in. riding mower.”

Best Buy

Ingersol lawn tractors

Joe Pukas, Binghamton, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“My two 2007 Ingersol lawn tractors are both best buys. One is a 20 hp model and the other a 23 hp model. The worksmanship and high quality of materials used to build these tractors is unbelievable. They’re built with heavy steel and have an all-welded assembly with no pressed steel. They also have a high quality paint job. The tractors were formerly built by Case.”

Best Buy

Ram W250 pickup equipped

Rachael Crowe, Skull Valley, Arizona · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“A 1993 Dodge W250 pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my best buy. It has more than 276,000 miles and counting. It gets 19 mpg and can haul a 1,300-lb. load on bad roads. I wouldn’t trade this pickup in at any price.”

Best Buy

DR field

Mark Johnson, Baudette, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 13

“My 1999 DR 26-in. field and brush mower is powered by a 15 hp Kawasaki engine that runs great and is easy on fuel with plenty of power. This mower will climb any hill that I can walk up. The mower deck follows uneven terrain and does a good job of cutting grass, weeds and brush.”

Best Buy

Ram 4-door shortbed pickup equipped + 1 more

Bud Weaver, Choctaw, Okla. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

Bud’s the proud owner of a 2002 Dodge 4-door shortbed pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and 6-speed standard transmission. “I used this pickup on a trip out west to tow a 27-ft. Airstream camper that weighed about 6,000 lbs. We wrote down every gallon of fuel that we used and found that we averaged 15.98 mpg. I’m well satisfied with this pickup but not too pleased with the short bed on it.

“My 1997 Chevrolet equipped with a 350 cu. in. Vortec engine is my worst buy. It got only 12 mpg on a similar trip and had major engine and drivetrain problems. With only about 30,000 miles on it the pinion gear and seal went out and I had to replace the crankshaft and bearing.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

International Harvester 856 tractors + 1 more

Chris Dunham, Green River, Utah · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My three 1970 International Harvester 856 tractors are all best buys. Even though they’re very old they do a good job. They hold up better than some of my tractors that are much newer.

“I bought a 1995 Fiat F130 tractor and am very disappointed with its overall power. The tractor runs hot, the 3-pt. hitch doesn’t work, and the remote valves don’t function properly. The electric 4-wheel drive lock won’t work properly, either.”

Worst Buy

John Deere HDX 4-WD Gator equipped

Gary Alford, Edwardsburg, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My 2005 Deere HDX 4-WD Gator equipped with a 20 hp gas engine is my worst buy. This machine is cold blooded even when the outside temperature is above 90 degrees. The carburetors have been upgraded a few times but they still don’t cold start well. Also, this machine steers hard.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 9760 combine + 1 more

Kenn Keyser, Van Wert, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

Kenn’s the satisfied owner of a 2004 Deere 9760 combine which he bought used last summer. “We previously owned two smaller Deere combine models - a 7720 Titan II and a 9600. This new machine has more than replaced those two. It has amazing capacity and the ability to eat those green-strawed beans that have become so common. We were able to operate in wheat at 5 mph and in beans at 5 to 6 mph with a 635 Hydraflex. Even with an 8-row header in 180 bu. plus corn, I wasn’t able to overload the machine at speeds of more than 6 mph.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2004 Hardi Navigator sprayer. “The foam system on it never worked properly. Hardi has done almost nothing to fix the problem which should have been fixed under warranty. Also, only Hardi parts will work on Hardi sprayers. Even their hosing is odd-sized so you have to buy all replacement parts from the company. They also have no factory service reps to deal with problems that come up in the field. Instead, they rely totally on their dealers. I won’t purchase another product from this company.”

Best Buy

Karcher G2500PH gas power washer

Vernon Boettcher, Elmore, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“In 2006, I bought a Karcher G2500PH gas power washer from Menards with a Honda engine. About a year ago the pump started to pulse. I tried to get it repaired but got the runaround after many tries. The last person I talked to was someone out of the U.S. I finally took it to the dump.”

Best Buy

Zetor 8540 4-WD tractor equipped

John Lang, Monmouth, Oregon · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“This tractor has exceeded all my expectations and is truly a quality machine at an affordable price,” reports John about his 1999 Zetor 8540 4-WD tractor equipped with a cab. “It’s fuel efficient, has plenty of power for its size, has a roomy quiet cab, and excellent hydraulics. I’d definitely buy another one.

“The hand tools I purchased from Harbor Freight, including punches, chisels, and hooked pry bars, are my worst buys. They’re all made of poor quality steel so they bend or break and get dull very easily. They’re no good at all.”

Worst Buy

Magellan Maestro 3100 portable

Ron Melchert, Seymour, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

Ron likes his Magellan Maestro 3100 portable GPS auto navigation system. “Before purchasing the Magellan I tried out a different brand but returned it about a week later. The Magellan is a much easier unit to operate and is a lot more user friendly.”

Best Buy

Texas Blaster sandblaster

Carl Wray, Valparaiso, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“I like my Texas Blaster sandblaster which I read about in FARM SHOW’s Vol. 30, No. 5 (ph 877 380-5829; www.texasblaster.com). The sandblaster holds 140 lbs. of blast media and runs on 7 cfm at 80 psi. It’ll clean 1 sq. ft. per minute and blast for an hour and a half on a tank of sand. It has a 14-gal. tank and an easy-pour funnel for fast loading. It’s fitted with 10-in. dia. hard rubber tires.

“It’s a well balanced unit that can adjust the sand output to the point that I can hardly see it. It really does a good job of cleaning,” says Wray.

Best Buy

R.E.A.M Sparkplug adapters

Edward M. Truty, Knox, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

Edward’s pleased with R.E.A.M. Sparkplug adapters (ph 989 743-9148; www.reamproducts.com). “My Allis Chalmers B tractor would foul the plugs every two weeks. I bought these spark-plug adapters to install platinum plugs and I didn’t have to change plugs all season.”

Best Buy

New Hol-land TC26DA HST tractor rides rough + 2 more

John Thies, Perry, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My New Hol-land TC26DA HST tractor rides rough. The cab on my New Holland TD95D loader tractor needs more leg room. Also, the front upper portion of the cab restricts my visibility when I use the tractor to stack bales in our barn.

“My International Harvester Super H tractor is an all-time best buy. I often drive it in antique tractor parades.”

Best Buy

Kubota M9000 tractor handles great + 5 more

Darrel Bates, Philadelphia, Miss. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My 2002 Kubota M9000 tractor handles great and has had no mechanical problems. It’s also easy on fuel.

“My 2007 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a Hemi V-8 engine rides rough and gets only 11 mpg. The dealer had led me to believe it would get 17 to 18 mpg because of the new technology that shuts down four cylinders when not needed, but it never did. I traded this pickup for a Ford F-150, which gets a more reasonable 16 mpg.

“My Ferris walk-behind mower never performed right and the company wouldn’t help in any way. I think Scag and Toro make the best lawn mowers.”

Best Buy

Kunafin Insectary

Victor Rodriguez, Farmington, Ky. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My best buys are the wasp parasites I bought from Kunafin Insectary to control fly populations (ph 800 832-1113; www.kunafin.com). The company grows and sells the parasites specifically to control flies. I have two breeder chicken barns where flies were a big problem. A friend told me about Kunafin and I found out the product really works. Unlike chemicals, the parasites can be used anywhere flies are a problem.”

Best Buy

Toyota

Steve Wilkinson, Panama City Beach, Florida · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My wife always liked the way Jeeps handle. We had three of them. However, after 50,000 miles they would just fall apart, engines and all. Finally I convinced her to switch to Toyota and we haven’t had one problem in more than 150,000 miles on a Toyota Land Cruiser and Toyota Tacoma pickup. No problems. They’re dependable and ride great.”

Best Buy

New Holland L160 skid loader

Tom Johnstin, Marietta, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

A 2007 New Holland L160 skid loader rates as Tom’s “best buy”. “I had a small Case 1825 skid loader for 11 years that performed well. However, my operation outgrew it and I needed a larger and more comfortable model. The L160 is perfect and is so much more comfortable to use. It’s equipped with a hydraulic-operated bucket release which I think is wonderful. It lets me change attachments from the driver’s seat just by pushing a button.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Central Boiler outdoor furnace + 1 more

Dale Valley, Brant, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“My 1999 Central Boiler outdoor furnace is my worst buy. After the third year it started to leak water along welds on the back side of the water jacket. I had a neighbor fix it, but then three weeks later the front side started to leak. I contacted the dealer who wanted it sent back to the factory, so I paid them $150 to take it back. They tried to say it was my bad water that caused the problem, even though there was no rust inside the water jacket. I had added the chemicals to the water as required.

“They voided my warranty and wanted $2,500 for a new water jacket, or they would weld up the old one and send it back. That’s what I had them do, but when the stove came back it actually leaked worse than before. So I added four cans of Aluma Seal (designed for auto radiators) to the water and that slowed it down to where I only had to add water twice a week. However, it wouldn’t stop leaking so I used it one more year and then got rid of it. I figured it cost me $1,500 per year for four years to heat my house, and I still had to cut my own wood. It was a real headache.

“Five years ago I replaced the unit with an Aquatherm and haven’t had any problems. With the Central Boiler unit, every three weeks I had enough ashes to fill a 55-gal. drum whereas with the Aquatherm unit I have maybe a 5-gal. pail per week. The Aquatherm unit is much more efficient.”

Best Buy

John Deere

Clarence C. Olson, Madison, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“I used to say, ‘You can’t farm without a pickup.’ Now I say, ‘You can’t farm without a Deere Gator.’ I love my 4 by 6 diesel because it goes anywhere and is especially handy for fencing work. It has a low box which also makes it easy to pick up rocks in the field. The diesel models are heavier and have a lot more power than the gas models.”

Best Buy

Honda 300

Dan McKinnon, Airdrie, Alberta · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

Dan’s the satisfied owner of two 2000 Honda 300 ATV’s and one 2003 Honda 350 4-WD ATV. “These machines require very little maintenance and just never quit. We use them every day in our feedlot and on pasture.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

West-ern Ag Labs doubled + 1 more

Colin Rosengren, Midale, Sask. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 14

“A crop nutrition planning service provided by West-ern Ag Labs doubled my barley yields and resulted in the barley being accepted for malt (Saskatoon, Sask., Canada; ph 306 978-0373; www.westernaglabs.com). The company uses a plant root simulator to measure plant available nutrients. Using this method they were able to measure potassium deficiencies, which is critical to growing good quality malt barley and maintaining the low protein required without sacrificing yields.

“My 2003 Case IH MXM140 tractor is my worst buy. I bought this tractor used with 600 hours on it and now it has about 1,300 hours. I’ve had problems with almost everything on this tractor. The pressure regulator valve blew out almost immediately, the self-leveling front-end loader doesn’t work right, the front wheel hubs on one side went out twice, the pto quit working once with an internal snap ring broke, the hydraulic detents don’t work right, and the cab is dirty because whenever I open a window, dirt falls in. Also, the tractor’s electrical system had a short one day and blew fuses. Of course, the problem disappeared when the mechanic came out.

“On the plus side, because of the front axle design and cab suspension this tractor rides like a dream in the field. Unfortunately, it spends more time in the shop than in the field.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4430 tractor

Gary Haak, Clinton, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

“Our Deere 4430 tractor has more than 8,500 almost trouble-free hours on it and is still running strong. A few years ago we had to get the reverse gear on it fixed, but otherwise this tractor has required only routine maintenance. We use it for everything from cultivating to baling, plowing, and hauling gravity wagons. My grandfather has an identical tractor with more than 11,000 hours on it. It still has the original engine. This tractor is definitely a best buy.”

Best Buy

Honda + 2 more

Fred Balmer, Folson, New Mexico · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Fred’s a fan of Honda ATV’s. “They can go thousands of miles with very little maintenance. I put more than 30,000 miles on one model and have put at least 10,000 miles on two others, and we use them in very rough ranching country. On the other hand, I wore out a Yamaha in only about 7,000 miles.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 2002 Ford F-150 Super Crew pickup equipped with a 5.4-liter gas engine has more than 110,000 trouble-free miles. However, due to poor engineering it’s almost impossible to change some of the spark plugs. Some shops won’t even work on them. I don’t know why manufacturers don’t use a small diesel engine in their light duty pickups. My Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a Powerstroke engine has more than 170,000 miles on it but still has the original glow plugs, brakes, etc. It’s also very fuel efficient. No more gas engines for me.”

Best Buy

Miller Bobcat 250 engine-driven welder

Christian Uthe, Wellsville, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Christian likes his 2007 Miller Bobcat 250 engine-driven welder. “It has performed flawlessly both for welding work and for generating auxillary power to operate shop tools. I use it on my truck in my welding business.”

His 2007 Harbor Freight sheet metal cutter rates as a “worst buy”. “This metal cutter is advertised to cut 16-gauge steel, but it wouldn’t do that for me. Even when I used more air pressure and cfm’s than required it would only ‘nibble’ an inch of metal at the most without locking up. It does cut 18-ga. steel really well.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Massey Ferguson 2300 tractor equipped + 1 more

Chester Grabski, Devon, Alberta · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Chester likes his 2005 Massey Ferguson 2300 tractor equipped with a 23 hp diesel engine. “It’s equipped with a front-end loader and belly-mounted mower deck, as well as a pto and 3-pt. hitch. This tractor is very handy for cutting grass and the loader works great for moving snow and lots of other jobs. It has a plug-in so it always starts right up in an unheated shop.

“My 2001 Honda 250 4-wheeler ATV is my worst buy. The shifter had to be replaced three times at a cost of about $1,000 each time. The rest of the machine works okay.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 7400 MFWD tractor + 1 more

Dennis Drake, Ault, Colo. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Dennis likes his Deere 7400 MFWD tractor but says it has nevertheless had some problems. “It’s an excellent tractor with great traction and power for its size. However, it has a really poor 3-pt. hitch. We have to push the hitch down with a front-end loader just so we can hook it up. The company said in time it will get better, but that hasn’t happened.”

He’s disappointed with his AgriTronics Gatekeeper. It uses a heat sensitive eye to detect cattle trying to pass through a gate opening. When it detects one, it’s supposed to activate a loud siren that scares them away. “The problem is the eye doesn’t see,” says Drake. “Also, my cattle got used to the noise of the siren and would walk right through the gate. I also tried it on horses but after three weeks it didn’t work on them, either. I called the company but they wouldn’t help.”

Best Buy

Bobcat 5600 Toolcat utility vehicle

Cletus Arnold, Roodhouse, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

“My 2006 Bobcat 5600 Toolcat utility vehicle is my best buy. I use it with a post hole digger, 6-ft. mower, and bucket. I have about 100 acres of pasture land on which I’m replacing the fences and removing the hedges. All the attachments fit on the front of this vehicle, making it easy to see what I do. It’s easy to operate and saves a lot of time.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Finn hydraulic-operated wood grapple + 1 more

Garry Overton, Gatineau, Quebec · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Gary likes his 1999 Finn hydraulic-operated wood grapple equipped with a rotator and a 52-in. opening. “I mounted the grapple and rotator on a 5-ft. boom on my loader tractor and use it to skid and load firewood and pulp from 2 ft to tree length. Eliminates the need to climb on and off the tractor all the time to hook and unhook skidding chains and chokers.”

On the “worst buy” side, “I used my 2006 Jonserud 2038 chainsaw only lightly, but even so it didn’t last 25 hours.”

Best Buy

Dickey-john grain tester + 1 more

Walt Schultz, Laurens, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Walt likes his 2006 Dickey-john grain tester. “It works just like the new ones that elevators use except that it’s a little slower to test grain - about 25 seconds. We’ve compared it many times with the local elevator’s tester and found that we were the same or within one or two tenths of a point. It has a printer that prints your farm’s name, grain, moisture, temperature, test weight, date and time.”

Walt says his Headsight Inc. corn header height control is a best buy (ph 574 546-5022; www.headsight.com). It comes with a poly contact arm and a trip mechanism that allows backing up without raising the header. The “no rip-off” sensor design allows backing up without causing damage to the sensing unit or the header. Because the arm is spring-loaded it can return to its natural position. Electrical adapters for unmatched combines and headers are available.

“We had some down corn this year so we decided to put this header control on. We’re happy with it as it plugs into the combine wiring with no need to cut any wires and it also attaches to bolts already on the header. The company helped us fine tune it before it left the shop. In the field, all we have to do is set the height control from the cab. The unit also operates the contour master to keep the header level with the ground.”

Best Buy

Kubota MX 5000 4-WD tractor equipped + 1 more

Ronald Goff, Perry, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

“It starts right up every time and has been trouble-free,” reports Ronald, pleased with his 2005 Kubota MX 5000 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “It has more than 100 hours on it. I use it mostly to mow hay and to do general haying work on 20 acres of hay, and to spread manure.

“My two Olympic chainsaws, models 970 and 962, both work great and are best buys.”

Best Buy

Farmall H tractor + 1 more

Robert Himmerich Valencia · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Robert nominates his 1946 Farmall H tractor as his all-time “best buy”. “We’re the third owner and it was our only tractor for 15 years. We added live hydraulics and a 3-pt. hitch. We still use this tractor every day all year long.”

He’s well pleased with his three Dodge pickups. “We’ve put a lot of miles on them. Our 1989 model has more than 600,000 miles on it, our 1992 has about 350,000 miles, and our 2002 3500 equipped with a Cummins diesel engine has about 135,000 miles. These pickups just keep on going and average a respectable 18 mpg.

“All our equipment is bought used. Some of it requires more tender loving care than others. We start by making sure that anyone who operates a machine uses an operator’s manual. We get a maintenance manual before doing any wrench work. Half of our inventory is someone else’s worst buy, but that’s okay because we feel that most ‘worst buy’ problems come from not reading or understanding the operator’s manuals.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Badger silage wagons + 1 more

Loyal Martin, Philadelphia, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

“I really like my Badger silage wagons. They’ve been trouble-free.”

A 3-pt. mounted, pto-operated concrete mixer from Agri-Supply rates as his “worst buy”. “It cost $599 plus shipping and handling, which I didn’t think was too bad. However, this mixer doesn’t perform as expected. It’s built way too light for mixing concrete. It’s built more like a compost mixer.”

Best Buy

GM 2500 heavy duty 4-wd

John Anderson, Grand Coulee, Wash. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

“I’m totally pleased with my 2001 GM 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a Duramax 6.6-liter, turbo diesel engine and Allison transmission. It has more than 115,000 miles on it but has been maintenance-free. When pulling a 30-ft. travel trailer to Tucson, Arizona, at an average speed of more than 70 mph it got better than 16 mpg. It consistently averages 18 1/2 mpg in local driving which includes going over local mountain passes. It’s the most user friendly pickup I’ve ever owned. I have no reason to trade pickups again.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2320 4-WD tractor equipped

Richard V. Crump, Cahaan, Ct. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

Richard’s the proud owner of a 2006 Deere 2320 4-WD tractor equipped with a 24 hp diesel engine and hydrostatic transmission. “It handles a 5-ft. Bush Hog and a 6-ft. Land Pride rear discharge finish mower with ease. The 4-WD makes it very sure footed on side hills. The hydrostatic drive transmission allows me to drive slowly forward while keeping my 5-ft. rototiller turning at high speed.”

Best Buy

Troybilt tiller

David Terrell, Union, Miss. · Vol. 32, No. 1 (2008), p. 15

David says his 1973 Troybilt tiller is his “all-time best buy”. “I bought it new in 1973 when I didn’t know if I would ever own a tractor, so it got plenty of use in my gardens. After going through three sets of tines and two engines, we retired it in 2003 and bought a new Troybilt. It’s also a mighty fine machine.”