Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008)

83 reports from pages 12–15 · 70 Best Buys24 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Bixby corn stove

Robert D’Amato, Morris, New York · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

“In June, 2007 I bought a Bixby corn stove for $4,800 from a local dealer who said it was state-of-the-art. Just hit the start button and it would provide clean, cheap heat in 10 min. But when we started using it last November, we got a strong popcorn smell and lots of smoke, but no heat. The dealer said to clean it out and try again. It didn’t help so I removed the corn baffle and disconnected the burn pot. I used a 1/8-in. drill bit to clean out dozens of holes in the grate. Put it all back together and had the same problem.

“The dealer said my corn must be bad. I changed corn and had the same results. I finally called the company direct and they suggested some adjustments inside the stove to regulate feed and exhaust. At last we got a little heat but not nearly the 5,000 btu’s it’s rated for. We used it until March, when the burn pot began to fill so fast it would smother the fire and fill the room with smoke. I got through the rest of the heating season by turning the stove on and off manually, even though this is supposedly a computer-controlled stove. We could not leave the house with the stove running.

“I tried the dealer one more time and he suggested burning wood pellets. Same result.”

Best Buy

Paloma tankless water heater

Tommy Scott, Albuquerque, New Mexico. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

“I have a possible solution for the Colorado reader in your last issue who had a problem with his Paloma tankless water heater. We bought one two years ago and it would also shut down unexpectedy. I did some research on the failure codes and found that I needed to buy a ‘high altitude’ module which is needed for altitudes close to or over 5,000 ft. Albuquerque is at 6,000 ft. so I ordered a module online and the heater has worked great ever since. We can run both showers, the washing machine and the dishwasher with no problem.”

Worst Buy

Kodiak work boots

Tom Gullion, Hamilton, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

He’s disappointed with his Kodiak work boots. “They came apart between the heel and the sole. The boots are over a year old but had hardly been worn. I wouldn’t complain except that these boots cost $130 so you expect a lot more. I have a friend with two pairs who had the same problem. When we contacted the company, they said if you don’t have a receipt, they’re not interested in hearing from you. So much for customer service. I’m going back to $30 boots from Walmart which last a lot longer than Kodiak boots.”

Best Buy

Kubota B6100 tractor + 1 more

Larry Genge, Glovertown, New Foundland · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

Larry likes his 1985 Kubota B6100 tractor that he bought used with 858 hours. “We use this tractor for landscaping work, log handling, and snow clearing with homemade attachments that include a bucket, forks, and blade. This tractor starts well in cold weather, requires little maintenance, and is fuel efficient.”

A Stanley-Bostitch 3 1/2-in. framing nail gun rates as his “worst buy”. “After going through just 8 to 10 boxes of nails the gun started jamming up. I took it back to Home Depot while it was still under warranty and they sent it to an authorized Bostitch repair shop, which said the O-rings were worn out and weren’t covered by warranty. I called the company’s helpline, but the representative would only say ‘we’re sorry’. An O-ring kit to solve the problem sells for $45, and there’s also a $40 labor charge to install it.”

Worst Buy

Vitasalus water filtration system

Elias Nyberg, Stow, Mass. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

Elias isn’t happy with a Vitasalus water filtration system. They advertise a Metalmaster model to handle heavy metals and iron in drinking water. The system worked for about two weeks, then tremendous iron buildup occurred and within weeks everyone’s hair was bright red. All our dishes and the dishwasher turned a reddish brown. The sinks were stained and every water jug and pan in our house was destroyed, not to mention all the white clothes which had to be thrown away.

“The company refused to acknowledge anything was wrong and tried to derail making any refund by saying our system was installed incorrectly, even though I had a plumber and water specialist check out the operation when it failed. After months of fighting with them - and they had my returned merchandise - the company refunded only a small portion of the original cost. I wouldn’t recommend this product to anyone.”

Best Buy

Woodmizer sawmill

Carl Gustafson, North Brookfield, Mass. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

A used Woodmizer sawmill rates as Carl’s “best buy”. “I used it recently to saw a couple of 14-ft. hardwood planks to repair my hog loading pen. The company has a great customer service department and a great parts inventory. Their sharpening service checks out the blades, sharpens them and returns them, usually in about one week. I also use the mill for custom sawing for other people as time permits.”

Worst Buy

Husqvarna zero turn riding

Jim Dunn, Jefferson, Mass. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

Jim nominates his Husqvarna zero turn riding mower as his “worst buy”. “This mower is almost useless on my hilly lawn and won’t hold a slope of more than about five degrees. Worse yet, if I don’t go super slow, the uphill drive wheel will lose traction and the machine will go downhill out of control. The mulching kit clogs constantly, and the mower does a poor job in high grass no matter how slow I go. I was better off with my 35-year-old Simplicity lawn tractor.”

Best Buy

Echo chain saws

Jeff Redsicker, Spencer, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

“I’ve owned and operated Echo chain saws for more than 32 years for our sawmill and firewood business. They’re the best saws we’ve ever used. One time we accidentally ran a tractor wheel over a saw, but it was no problem. We just replaced the handle and put the saw back to work. In all these years we’ve never had an engine failure.”

Worst Buy

John Deere G110 riding mower

Denis Kehrer, Virden, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 12

“We bought our 2005 Deere G110 riding mower after we moved to a farm house on three acres.

“The G110 has a 12-in. wider cut than our old Deere 160 and is supposed to have more than twice as much power. However, the first thing we noticed was that it didn’t cut any more efficiently and bogged down almost as often as the old machine. The second time I used it in heavy grass, the plastic discharge chute broke off when one of the 1/2-in. tabs on the molded chute tore off due to the stress of pushing through heavy 7-in. grass. On the way back to the machine shed, the hood fell completely off and now has to be held on with a bungee cord. Also, the ground clearance on this machine is so poor it gets stuck nearly every time we use it. We then have to get a truck to pull it loose because it’s not possible to simply dismount and put the machine in gear due to safety devices.

“By the end of the first full season we had to replace the battery. Also, the top of the front tires had tilted inward at about a 60 degree angle, making steering almost impossible. When we had the mower serviced before winter, we had to have the entire front assembly torn down to replace a number of parts. The service department said this has been a common problem. Fortunately, the warranty covered most of the expense.

“The following spring, I was cutting near our house and found it necessary to back up and turn around. As I did so, the small beam that supports the front wheels broke in half and I had to push the mower to the machine shed, where it sat for three weeks until the dealer finally came out to take it back to his shop. His reply, ‘Well, sometimes things break’. My response to him was ‘And, sometimes people buy their $4,000 lawn mowers from other companies.”

Best Buy

Shindawa weedeater

Norman Palmer, Montgomery Creek, Calif. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“Our 1991 Shindawa weedeater is our best buy. It has aged with no major problems - just new spark plugs. We recently bought a new model that’s just as good but a lot more powerful. We still use the old one. We’ve purchased other weedeater brands, but none can compare.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Paslode cordless framing nail + 1 more

Bill Taylor, Meriden, N.H. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“My Paslode cordless framing nail gun is my best buy. It doesn’t have a hose to drag around which allows me to tackle many construction projects by myself. It eliminates the need for someone to hold the board while a nail is started. It’ll shoot spikes as well as 8-penny nails.

“My Kuhn-Deruban round bale unroller is my worst buy. The chain was much too weak to handle 1,500-lb. silage bales, which caused individual links to snap all the time. We fabricated our own replacement links, but after a while we got tired of doing that and just parked it. We’re waiting for an opportunity to trade it in.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3830 4-WD loader tractor equipped + 1 more

Rob Tolson, Callao, Va. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

Rob likes his Kubota L3830 4-WD loader tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission and 4-in-1 bucket. “It has 232 hours on it but still runs like new. The 4-in-1 bucket works great and is a real time-saver. I can do just about anything with it.”

One of his worst buys ever was a Deere 332 riding mower with a 48-in. deck. “This mower never would cut the grass right, and then the engine blew up. I had the engine replaced and that one blew up, too. We finally junked it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 250 pickup equipped + 1 more

E. T. Guanin, Greenville, Georgia · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“I’m impressed with my 1990 Dodge 250 pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. Cummins diesel engine. The odometer shows about 400,000 miles but it has been broken for the past six years. I use this pickup to haul wood out of the woods on two trailers. It’s a tough truck in every way. For example, I weigh 275 lbs. but the seat is still like new.”

On the negative side, “I’ve had to replace the blades six times on my 2006 Deere L130 and the center mandrell twice. Then the deck that holds the mandrell broke out. A friend who operates a machine shop cut some metal to cover the damaged portion and bolted the mandrell back in. If I don’t see a big change in the performance of this mower, I won’t ever buy a Deere again.”

Worst Buy

Valby 3-pt mounted wood chipper

Dennis R. Ewert, Mukwonago, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“My 2008 Valby 3-pt. mounted wood chipper is my worst buy. I bought it with the optional hydraulic feed. However, the hydraulic motors on the feed started leaking after 30 minutes of use. I had to replace the motors twice, and then the safety bar wouldn’t reverse the in-feed. Fortunately, the dealer refunded my money. This was supposed to be a heavy duty model that could handle a 9 1/2-in. dia. log.”

Best Buy

Stihl Super 90 gear-drive chainsaw

Philip Armstrong, Vilas, N.C. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

Philip’s the satisfied owner of a 1980 Stihl Super 90 gear-drive chainsaw with an Alaskan mill attachment and a 5-ft. bar. “I’ve used it to saw more than 10,000 board feet of slabs, always using a synthetic oil mix. I’m on my third spark plug. This saw always starts by the third or fourth pull. Not bad for a 28-year-old saw.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet K3500 pickup equipped

Mark Rubbert, Redmond, Oregon · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“My 2005 Chevrolet K3500 pickup equipped with a Duramax engine is my worst buy. It blew its first set of fuel injectors at about 3,000 miles and has gone through a second set since then, as well as two injector pumps. It gets 40 percent less mpg than my 2002 model, which is almost identical to this one. Also, this pickup is underpowered. I put both pickups on a dynamometer, and found the 2005 model has 15 percent less power. The dealer can’t solve the problem. I’m told the mileage on the newer Chevy pickups is also poor. I recently bought a used 2003 K2500 model that gets 22 mpg.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota G1800 diesel riding mower + 1 more

Mark L. Ballard, Royse City, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“It starts every time, runs smooth and mows evenly. Also, it has a lot of power and maneuverability,” says Mark about his Kubota G1800 diesel riding mower equipped with a hydrostatic transmission.

“My worst buys are any tools from North-ern Tool and Equipment. Whether they’re electric, pneumatic, or even hand-operated, these tools are cheaply made and usually break after only one or two uses.”

Best Buy

Case IH 7130 tractor + 3 more

Jim Mitchell, Eaton, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“I bought my Case IH 7130 tractor new in 1989. Over the years this tractor has required only minor repairs. Last summer I checked the main engine bearing at 7,000 hours, but it showed no wear.

“My 2004 Kinze 3600 planter is a best buy. I used a 2600 model for 10 years with great results. The 3600 model is built heavy and is a joy to use. No problems.”

On the minus side, he lists his 1990 Sukup 12-row ridge-till cultivator. “It’s not built heavy enough. The company sent me ‘free’ parts for four years, but finally I gave up and bought a Buffalo 6430 model, which is a great cultivator.”

Best Buy

Silver Stream wood hoop building + 1 more

Jeff Berens, Holland, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

Jeff’s the satisfied owner of a Silver Stream wood hoop building (ph 877 547-4738; www.silverstreamshelters.com). “It was fairly easy to set up, and is very bright and well ventilated inside. When we bought the kit it took us a while to actually put the building up. When we got started, we found we had the wrong size cover. We called the company and they sent us a new cover at no charge.

“Our Premier poultry fence isn’t easy to move and didn’t hold up well. It sagged badly so we had to put on extra posts, which took more time.”

Best Buy

Wisconsin AK 4 hp gas engine

Ralph R. Look, Wichita, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“A Wisconsin AK 4 hp gas engine I bought in the mid 1940’s is still going strong. We’ve used it on a table saw, air compressor, grain auger, grain elevator, and hay elevator. One time when it was on a bale elevator it got shot by a 12-ga. shotgun, destroying the fuel tank. The engine was headed for scrap until I intercepted it, found another fuel tank, and put it back to work. It’s still running great.”

Best Buy

John Deere 3520 tractor

Benny Davis, Boonville, N.C. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“My 2007 Deere 3520 tractor is equipped with a frontend loader. The first time I used it was to move 18-in. dia., 10-ft. long logs with forks installed on the loader. It performed great and I never had to leave the cab. It has been a dream machine, and at 62 years of age I need all the ease of operation I can get. It’s powered by a turbocharged diesel engine that doesn’t know when to quit. Before I bought this tractor I looked at other brands, but this model has a more user friendly cab, great visibility, and controls that are easy to reach.”

Best Buy

Grasshopper ZTR mower equipped + 2 more

Kenneth R. Sanders, Brownsville, Ky. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“This machine mows beautifully,” says Kenneth about his 2007 Grasshopper ZTR mower equipped with a Kubota diesel engine and 60-in. mid-mount deck. “I don’t get tired using this mower, even though I use it to cut several acres of yards every week. The diesel engine runs great and the mower has all the blade and ground speed I could want. It’s also easy on fuel.

“I also like my 2002 Ford 4-WD crew cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a Powerstroke engine. It runs and drives great and has a comfortable seat. No problems after about 92,000 miles. It’s also fuel efficient.

“I bought a used 2000 Dodge pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. It only has about 130,000 miles but doesn’t ride or drive well at all. This pickup always seems to need something whether it’s transmission work, electrical problems with the blower motor, and so forth.”

Best Buy

Animat cow comfort rubber

Mark Heeter, Martinsburg, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 13

“The dairy farm where I’m employed made the costly mistake of buying Animat cow comfort rubber flooring. It was installed in a sand-bedded, alley scraper-cleaned freestall barn. The product wasn’t fastened correctly and was constantly ripping up. The only thing more worthless than this product was the company’s service.”

Best Buy

Milwaukee 28-volt Sawzall impact wrench

Mark LaSalle, Manning, S.C. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Mark likes his Milwaukee 28-volt Sawzall, impact wrench, circular saw, and drill. “All these tools have the power to handle any job. I’ve used them on everything from house remodeling jobs to junkyard runs. On any one day, I’ve never needed more than the two batteries that come with each tool.”

Best Buy

Chomper Simplex 14S firewood processor

Francis Kryzsko, Grand Forks, N. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Francis likes his Chomper Simplex 14S firewood processor that’s powered by a Honda 24 hp engine (Rainier Hydraulics, ph 800 457-9136; www.chomper.net). The company says it’s the only 100 percent automatic firewood processor. No log lifting is required. All cutting is done with a shear blade that never needs sharpening. The processor is equipped with an adjustable splitter head that can be adjusted to split two or four ways, depending on log diameter. An 8-way splitter head is also available.

“This machine feeds the log, shears it to length, and splits it. It’s a very complex machine but it’s simple to operate,” says Kryzsko. “A full length tree can be cut and split into firewood with just a few hydraulic lever controls. Moisture is forced from the tree as it’s processed. My machine has been trouble-free with a minimum of maintenance. It’s a real traffic stopper when I operate it near any public activity.”

Worst Buy

Kubota T1600H tractor

Donald Osborn, Richfield Springs, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“The shop manual for my Kubota T1600H tractor is my worst buy. The manual doesn’t provide any pressure information for the hydrostat transmission and no step-by-step instructions on disassembly and reassembly. I paid almost $40 for it.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 30 LED wand-type rechargeable flashlight

Gale Goff, Chandler Heights, Arizona · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Gale likes his 2008 Sears Craftsman 30 LED wand-type rechargeable flashlight. “It’s very bright and long lasting for its small size. It provides instant emergency light for power failures and for night trips - it’s 500 ft. to our mailbox - and for irrigation inspection and inspection of car and machine problems. It has a hook on one end so it can be used as an under-hood worklight.”

Best Buy

Ford 350 4-door pickup equipped

Prause Ranch, China Spring, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

They like their 2002 Ford 350 4-door pickup equipped with a diesel engine. “It has more than 70,000 miles with no problems except for a leak in the fuel filter. It gets 16 to 17 mpg empty, and 12 mpg pulling a 16-ft. gooseneck trailer loaded with cattle. It also gets about the same mileage pulling a 31-ft. travel trailer. It has been back to the dealer only one time, for some kind of valve timing sensor. It cost about $36,000, which used to be the price of a good home.”

Best Buy

Polaris 6-WD utility vehicle

George Vonderheide, LaFarge, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“My 2004 Polaris 6-WD utility vehicle has great traction for going up steep and slippery hills, easily crosses rough terrain, and carries a heavy payload. It has a big 8-gal. gas tank so it can go a long time without refueling. The 6-WD isn’t needed most of the time, but when it’s needed it does a great job.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toro personal-pace walk-behind lawn + 2 more

Albert Patterson, Taft, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“My 2008 Toro Personal-Pace walk-behind lawn mower is my worst buy. It cuts good and has plenty of power, but it bags poorly if the grass is even the slightest bit damp or thick. Also, the transmission went out after only 20 hours of use. The dealer fixed it under warranty but it took two weeks. It lasted another few weeks before it hit a 1-in. stick and bent the crankshaft, and that wasn’t covered by the warranty. It cost about $200 and took two months to get it going. It still vibrates badly.

“My Honda HR 214 Easy Start mower is a best buy. It’s at least 12 years old and must have more than 5,000 hours on it, but it still keeps on going. It smokes, and it has a homemade starter and bicycle cables in it, yet it always starts on the first pull and just won’t die. It cuts and bags as good as a new model. It has hit bricks, pieces of concrete, rebar, rope and wire, but still runs smooth. It’s a good, dependable mower. If Honda still made this model, we’d buy another one.

“My 1996 New Holland 163 rear-folding hay tedder is a best buy. We bought it last spring after our old, worn-out M&W tedder went to pieces in the field. We haven’t had a bit of trouble with the new one. It pulls good behind a pickup, picks up all the hay, and is easy to maintain. It doesn’t use any gear oil, only grease. And it’s so quiet that I have to keep looking back to make sure it’s still working. I look forward to using this machine for years to come.”

Best Buy

Kubota B7100 tractor

Gerald H. Atkins, Westport, Oregon · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

Gerald’s impressed with his 1992 Kubota B7100 tractor. “In 1996 my homestead flooded, and I used this tractor to move logs and rocks, to dig channels in 2 ft. of water and mud, and for general clean up work. It’s still running strong.”

Best Buy

Nortrac

John W. McClain, Panguitch, Utah · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“I’m satisfied with my 2004 Nortrac (Jimma) 25 hp 4-WD diesel tractor. which I bought through the Northern Equipment catalog. The tractor came equipped with a backhoe and front-end loader. I’ve used it to clear land for our new home and work shop, and to dig trenches for septic, water and power lines. I’ve also used it as a bulldozer, trencher, hole digger, grader, wood hauler, snowplow and wood chipper. It does more than I could ever expect and uses only about one gallon of fuel per hour. It has 520 hours on it but has never failed to start.”

Worst Buy

Case IH MXU130 tractor

Jeffrey Campbell, Mossleigh, Alberta · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“My 2006 Case IH MXU130 tractor is as noisy as the old 1175 model we used 25 years ago. The air conditioning hasn’t worked properly for more than 15 months. The steering doesn’t work consistently, and the motor has a small oil leak. My next tractor will be a made-in-Canada tractor - a Buhler Versatile.”

Worst Buy

Generac generator

Robert C. Thurner, Hebron, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“The Generac generator that I use on my motorhome is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and won’t shut off properly. I get quite disgusted when it doesn’t run because it happens when there isn’t any electricity to plug into. I’ve had it worked on several times, but with no results.”

Best Buy

Stihl Boss 029 model

Robert Mercer, Stanton, Neb. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“Over the years I’ve cut a lot of wood, but this is by far the best chainsaw I’ve ever used,” says Robert, pleased with his Stihl Boss 029 model. “Nothing compares to the speed and ruggedness of a Stihl.”

Best Buy

Honda water pump

Wilmer Dufresne, Forest Lake, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“In 2000 we bought a used Honda 3-in. water pump, and it’s an amazing machine. It ran almost continuously for four years, except during the winter. It’s not used as much any more, but still gets used quite a bit. During a heavy rain storm a few years ago the pump ended up in about 4 ft. of water. We changed the oil, dried it out, pulled the recoil, and it started right up.”

Best Buy

Bolens Iseki 212 garden tractor

Michael Gorga, Galway, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“My Bolens Iseki 212 garden tractor is about 25 years old but still runs like a top. I use it to pull a 4-ft. rototiller and to operate a 5-ft. mower. It runs like a dream and always starts right up, even in winter. It has plenty of power and uses less than a half gallon of fuel per hour running at full load.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 3/4-ton pickup equipped + 3 more

Ben Koch, Kersey, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

A 2005 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 5.7-liter Hemi engine rates as Ben’s “best buy”. “We’ve put about 1,200 miles on it, much of the time pulling a horse trailer, with no problems. This is the first time I’ve owned a vehicle equipped with a Hemi engine and I’m impressed. It gets 16 mpg on trips and has a lot of power. The pickup has a roomy cab and the ride is good for a heavy duty vehicle. My wife drives it and likes it, too.

“My Poulan string weed trimmer is my worst buy. It’s hard to start even after it has been warmed up, and the string head always seems to feed either too much or too little string. It’s frustrating to use.

“Back in 1959 my grandfather bought an International Harvester 330 utility tractor equipped with a Wagner front-end loader. It’s still in use on our farm today. It has had one engine overhaul but is still on the original clutch. I don’t know exactly how many hours it has, but I’m sure it’s more than 10,000. I still use this tractor almost every day, and I still have the original operator manuals and sales slip.”

Best Buy

Guardian automatic standby generator

Norm Pounder, Milford, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 14

“From day one, our Guardian automatic standby generator was hard to start and ran rough. Before it was a year old it refused to run, and a hole in one of the pistons had to be repaired. Two months later during a storm it ran for about five hours before it stopped producing electricity. The dealer picked it up, and since then about two months have passed but the dealer still has it. The manufacturer and dealer are arguing as to who’s at fault. Meanwhile, I’ve been offered a ‘rebuilt’ model even though I paid for a new one. My dealings with the manufacturer leave a lot to be desired. A certified letter and two phone calls haven’t produced any results.”

Best Buy

Kubota mini trackhoe + 1 more

Mike Banholzer, Boaz, Alabama · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Mike’s Kubota mini trackhoe, which he bought used, rates as his “best buy”. “I modified it with a hook on the arm so I could move slats on a breeder hen farm. It’s small enough to move around in buildings without tearing up equipment. The slats are 14 ft. long.

“The electronic blade engager on my Deere LT 155 riding mower has gone out twice in four months.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Duramax 3/4-ton heavy duty pickup + 1 more

Loring Kufahl, Wheaton, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Loring nominates his 2008 Chevrolet Duramax 3/4-ton heavy duty pickup equipped with an Allison transmission as his “best buy”. “This pickup has 365 horsepower and 660 lbs. of torque, which is enough power to pull any trailer that we have. It gets 15 to 16 mpg, which is okay but not as good as the 2001 Chevrolet Duramax I traded in. It had 96,000 trouble-free miles.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2007 New Holland 456 sickle mower. “The pulley that hooks up to the counterbalance shaft that drives the sickle and shaft wasn’t machined right. As a result, it came loose and required $770 worth of parts and labor to fix. The dealer ended up fixing the mower at no cost, which I really appreciate.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Woods 1027 front-end loader + 1 more

Michael G. Scott, Junction, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My Woods 1027 front-end loader and hay spike is my best buy. It’s easy to swap out attachments on the loader and is safe to use. I use it on my Deere 2040 tractor and couldn’t get along without it. It’s built much heavier than other models I’ve seen.

“My Poulan 46 cc, 20-in. chainsaw is my worst buy. The problem is that the adjusting knob for the chain tightener keeps coming loose. It’s made from plastic and will probably strip out before too long. I prefer to use my Poulan 330 chainsaw equipped with a 22-in. bar. It has an old-style screw tightener that works much better. Both models lose bolts and screws whenever I use them.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Poulan Pro Tach PT17 chainsaw + 4 more

Jon W. Briel, Cambridge, Maine · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My 2002 Poulan Pro Tach PT17 chainsaw has been trouble-free. I had to replace the spark plug and fuel pickup line. Otherwise it works great.

“My Deere L120 garden tractor has more than 145 hours on it and is a best buy. We use it to take care of more than three acres of reclaimed grass from wooded and pasture land.

“My Homelite PS33 chainsaw constantly leaks oil and is always hard to start. I found out it didn’t have a brake on it. I took it in for repairs but they couldn’t find anything wrong. I’ve also taken the saw completely apart and replaced the plugs and rebuilt the carburetor, but it didn’t help.

“My Eagle air compressor never worked right. I’ve spent more time working on it than using it.

“My Axis HVLP paint system is a best buy. No problems (ph 877 477-7823; www.aircraftspruce.com). It’s furnished with 20 ft. of air delivery hose and a spray gun.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tacoma pickup

Gary Rauch, Belpre, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My 1996 Toyota Tacoma pickup is my best buy. It’s durable, dependable, cheap to operate, and fuel efficient. I take my hat off to Toyota for the way they stand behind their product. There was a frame perforation problem in the pickup due to faulty metal. The company spent a lot of time and money to repurchase the trucks involved. I’ll definitely buy another one.”

Best Buy

Scag Tiger Cub zero turn riding

Michael A. Eilbes, Theresa, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My 2006 Scag Tiger Cub zero turn riding mower equipped with a 23 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and 61-in. deck is my best buy (Scag Power Equipment, www.scag.com). It cuts well at about 10 mph, and the blades are easy to change. It’s also built heavy. I’ve already put about 125 hours on it with no problems.”

Best Buy

Lee’s Trap Works

Chuck Hays, Black Pines, B.C. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“After trying many different gopher traps and poisons, I read about a trap from Lee’s Trap Works in FARM SHOW (Lee Schwartz, Swift Current, Sask. ph 306 778-2083; www.leestrapworks.com). I ordered a ‘test batch’ of 10 traps and am so pleased that I’ve ordered 20 more and am organizing my neighbors to make a large group order. We have a large gopher problem in our area, and that’s going to change thanks to this trap. My subscription just paid for itself ten times over.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 3500 diesel pickup + 1 more

Gary Graham, Albright, W. Va. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Gary nominates his 2005 Dodge 3500 diesel pickup as his “best buy”. “It has great power and is reasonably fuel efficient. No problems.

“My 2002 Chevrolet 2500 pickup is my worst buy. I was always a Chevrolet fan until the purchase of this piston-slapping, rusting-rotor pickup. The company’s customer service and the Better Business Bureau were equally disappointing.”

Worst Buy

Vermeer Rebel 5400 baler

Joe Rupnick, Soldier, Kansas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“The Vermeer Rebel 5400 baler that I bought new a few years ago is a worst buy. The company won’t do anything to fix it. I wrote a letter to the Kansas attorney general, who contacted the company. The company told them they had solved the problem, yet no one from the company ever came out to look at it. It plugs up nine or ten times for every 50 bales.”

Best Buy

Case MXV 125 tractor

John Boor, Horseheads, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My 2004 Case MXV 125 tractor has had one electronic problem after another. It has spent more time at the dealer than in the field. The problems were never resolved, so we traded for a stripped-down Case MXM 40 equipped with a standard shift transmission. No problems. Our 1971 Case 870 has more than 10,000 hours on it. We still use it to do light work all summer long.”

Best Buy

Energizer quick

Ted Yaworsky, Wakeman, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“I like my Energizer ‘quick switch’ flashlight that runs D, C, or AA batteries so you can use whatever you have handy. This flashlight also makes it easy to change the bulb (ph 800 383-7323; www.energizer.com).”

Best Buy

Red + 1 more

Al Leister, Cream Ridge, N.J. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Al’s pleased with an electric fuel shut-off valve for antique tractors that he bought from Red he notes.

Miller also tried a multiple tower unit from Robert Shrock at Imperial Diesel Ma-chinery, Kinsman, Ohio. It only draws three to four amps. Although he could see why the fuel-saving unit should produce positive results, he reports that he has not yet seen any benefit.

Best Buy

Advanced Energy

Richard Miller, Bloomfield, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

He installed an Advanced Energy unit on a Deere stationary diesel. He says it draws as much as 40 amps and gets so hot that it actually produces steam. He has tried it with various settings and amp draws, but has yet to see any benefit in fuel reduction. “I think it draws so much juice out of the battery that it makes the alternator work too hard,”

Best Buy

Advanced Energy + 1 more

Eddie Elliot, Bozeman, Montana · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Elliot says his hydrogen generator from Advanced Energy is saving fuel, but not as much as he had hoped. Elliot is an over-the-road trucker and reports a 0.2-mile per gallon increase. At times he has seen as

much as a 0.7 increase, which he feels

would more than pay for itself if it was con-

tinuous. He drives 2,500 miles each month,

facing fuel bills as high as $8,000 a month, Rock Mfg. (ph 641 780-1748; www.red rock mfg.com). It’s a small spring-loaded brass solenoid-activated valve that fits in the gas line and wires to the ignition switch. When the ignition is off, the valve is closed. It opens automatically when the ignition switch goes on.

“I installed the valve on my Ford 8N tractor. In the past I had to manually shut off the fuel every time I turned off the engine. Since I installed the valve the tractor starts right up every time,” says Leister.

Best Buy

John Deere 111 garden tractor

Ray Haffner, Springfield, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“I acquired a 1981 Deere 111 garden tractor from my father’s estate. It has always been well maintained and still mows lawns as good as new. I picked up a second Deere 111 as a junker at a garage sale for $30. It had been terribly neglected. I restored it and built a little cargo box on back. It gets a lot of second looks at tractor shows.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4450 MFWD tractor equipped

John Nye, Delta, Utah · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

John’s the satisfied owner of a 1986 Deere 4450 MFWD tractor equipped with a Sound Gard cab. “I bought this tractor used for $40,000 in 1990 with about 700 hours on it. At first we used it on our Connecticut farm. Then in 1995 we moved our dairy operation to Utah where we’ve used the tractor to feed 1,600 cows every day. The tractor now has about 42,000 hours on it. A new engine was installed at 25,000 hours, and the transmission was rebuilt at about 35,000 hours. We’ve replaced the water pump, batteries, and starter, but there have been no big problems. so even the 0.2 increase will pay off after 2 to 3 months.

“I plan to keep working at it,” he says, adding that, “Advanced Energy has provided good support when I’ve had questions. However, they didn’t send a promised replacement circuit breaker and amp gauge. If I could get the full 15 percent improvement they talk about, I would become a dealer.”

Best Buy

Advanced Energy

Ell Kramer, Fredericksburg, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

The 85-year-old has had consistent results with his Advanced Energy unit, seeing increases of 2 to 3 mpg and as much as 6 1/2 mpg in his Dodge diesel pickup with 4-WD. He notes that different driving conditions can make a big difference in mileage.

“I had a guy install the unit, but I wired it myself,” says Kramer. “It was very easy. I’m happy with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Eagle Research + 1 more

Charles Peterson, Holiday Island, Ark. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

Peterson bought a unit from Eagle Research but saw no improvement in mileage. He requested a refund and received a check.

“My 2007 Deere 444 J articulating wheel loader is my worst buy. We bought it after another loader burned up in a fire. We put about 4,000 hours a year on it so we needed to replace it as soon as possible. However, it took six months to get it and it had numerous computer problems, mostly relating to thinking it has water in the fuel. You can’t use it until you fix the problem or short out the sensor wires to fool the computer. The company says they’re there for you 24-7, but they don’t provide any parts at the dealer. All you really need nowadays to fix equipment is an internet connection and a mechanic. Dealers have become useless. This tractor was a waste of money.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford tractor equipped + 1 more

David S. Chalmers, Marcelona, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“In 2004 I bought a reconditioned 1973 Ford 2000 tractor equipped with a 40 hp engine for $5,000. It works great, has a lot of power, and maneuvers well in tight places.

“My 1997 Murray 14 1/2 hp riding mower is my worst buy. I’ve had problems with the so-called automatic drive transmission. I couldn’t get the transmission back into drive after putting it in neutral. It has gone through three different transmissions.”

Best Buy

Toro Super Recycler mower

Adam Moore, Woodbridge, Va. · Vol. 32, No. 6 (2008), p. 15

“My mother purchased a 2003 Toro Super Recycler mower with a Key-Lectric starting system. She has bad shoulders and is unable to start regular pull-start mowers so she needed an electric start. The mower has a ‘guaranteed-to-start’ warranty for five years. She began having trouble starting it after the first year and it also burned oil. Each year the starting problem got worse and it burned more oil. Finally, it wouldn’t start at all. The dealer replaced the carburetor at our expense, but we still had trouble starting it and the oil problem got even worse.

“I’ve written three letters to the company, but they’re not willing to stand behind their products. They claim I was using old fuel, and that all mowers burn oil.”