Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009)

82 reports from pages 12–15 · 73 Best Buys22 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Wonder Earth Part-ners

Rudolph Lee, Waynesboro, Miss. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“I ordered 150 trees from Wonder Earth Part-ners in Myrtle Creek, Oregon, for $1,226. After I received the trees in September, 2007, I ordered another 100 trees for $975, scheduled to be delivered in the spring of 2008. We planted the first order of trees like we were instructed to do. Out of 150 trees, 35 put on green leaves and grew about 6 in. before first frost. In the spring of 2008, just 13 trees out of the 150 survived and we never received the other 100 trees we ordered. They sent us a refund of $750 on the second order but did not reimbuse us for the first order of defective trees.”

Best Buy

Open & Shut + 1 more

Jeff Lang, Newport News, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“My all-time best buy is a nut and bolt loosener and rust penetrant called Open & Shut made by Drummond American and sold by Lawson Products (ph 804 241-9541; www.Lawson products.com). I work in a tractor trailer repair shop where there’s a need for such a product every day. I’m really impressed with it. P.B. Blaster is a good penetrant, but Open & Shut works five times better at penetrating rust.

“For a good demonstration of how fast this product works, fill two Styrofoam coffee cups half full of water, then spray a little Open & Shut in one cup and P.B. Blaster in the other. Open & Shut will penetrate the water and go through the cup before P.B. Blaster does every time. It’s not at all corrosive to metals or to your hands should you accidentally get any on your skin. I’d recommend this product to anyone.

“My Sears Craftsman electric cultivator/tiller works great. I bought it to use in my raised bed vegetable garden but I’ve also used it to work up a 20 by 30-ft. section of lawn. It worked well for that, too.”

Best Buy

Troy Bilt rototiller equipped

Donald White, Smithfield, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“My Troy Bilt rototiller equipped with a 7 hp Tecumseh engine has problems. I change the oil regularly and use a good quality oil, and I always give the engine time to warm up and then to cool down before shutting it off. However, the engine threw a rod right out the side of the block. I’ve heard these small Tecumseh engines are known for doing that. I replaced it with a 5 hp Honda model that does a much better job of powering our rototiller.”

Best Buy

Echo chainsaw equipped + 1 more

George Schneider, Pioneer, Calif. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“My Echo chainsaw equipped with a 14-in. bar is lightweight and cuts through most trees. It starts hard but runs great. It’s wonderful for an old man because it’s so light and easy to handle.

“My 2001 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a V-8 engine has about 90,000 miles, but already it burns about one quart of oil per 1,000 miles. Also, the chrome on the hood has peeled off.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bosch 18-volt cordless drill + 1 more

Andy Petersen, Fraser, Colo. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

Andy’s pleased with his Bosch 18-volt cordless drill. “It lasts a long time on one charge, has a lot of torque, and has the best warranty of any tool I’ve owned. The batteries take only about 30 minutes to recharge, and I can also use them to operate my stereo for about eight hours.

“My 1997 Chevrolet Suburban 2500 LS is my worst buy. If you’ve ever owned a Suburban, you know all about replacing fuel pumps. I went through 6 pumps in 4 1/2 years. When I went to sell the vehicle, I only got 1/6 of what I paid for it because of the mileage and the fuel pump problem.”

Worst Buy

AgriFab garden wagon

Dan Miles, Dalton, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

Dan isn’t happy with his AgriFab garden wagon. “While this garden wagon is functional and seems sturdy, the assembly and finish are poor. I had to drill additional holes in order to make parts align properly. The hardware provided is of low quality, and in less than a year most of the paint has come off in sheets. It’s worth half what I paid for it.”

Worst Buy

Primecell

Pat Warren, Grass Range, Montana · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

Pat isn’t happy with Primecell, a company that specializes in rebuilding batteries. “I sent three 14.4-volt batteries to the company. One battery lasted less than a year. The clips on two of the batteries wouldn’t hold the battery in the drill. Now I have one battery left. When the company rebuilt the batteries, they didn’t do any work on the clips.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2755 4-WD tractor equipped

Skip Besler, White River Junction, Ver-mont · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

A Deere 2755 4-WD tractor equipped with a model 245 front-end loader rates as Skip’s “best buy”. “I use this tractor all year long and it always runs great. It’s easy on fuel and the heating and air conditioning systems work fine. I use this tractor to bale about 5,000 bales a year and to plow snow during the winter.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DR brush mower + 1 more

Alvin Theriault, Stacyville, Maine · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“I use my DR brush mower constantly to cut pastures and overgrown areas. It can pull itself on fairly steep slopes and does a good job on uneven ground.

“My 25 hp Toro snowblower arrived with a faulty oil line that hadn’t been properly adjusted by the dealer. This machine doesn’t work well in cold weather - I have to heat it first to start it. Even with weights and tire chains it has poor traction, and doesn’t work well on uneven ground.”

Best Buy

Toyota vehicles + 1 more

John D. Gebhart, Watertown, S. Dak. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 12

“I’ve driven almost nothing but Toyota vehicles since 1974, and they’ve all been best buys. The first model was a 1974 pickup followed by a 1974 sedan. Then I bought Toyota pickups in 1980, 1985, 1987, 1989, and 1991, followed by a 1987 sedan, a 1999 van, and a 2000 van. All the pickups and the first sedan had more than 200,000 miles on them, yet I never spent more than $300 on repair bills for any vehicle. The 1987 sedan had about 168,000 miles on it when I traded it. The 1999 van has more than 130,000 miles but has required just one repair, which was for a valve cover gasket.

“All these vehicles were bought used, and I’m still driving the 1985 and 1991 pickups and both vans. Every wheeled thing on my place would be labeled Toyota if that were possible. I operate a light freight business with two trucks on the road, and in more than 10 years I’ve never missed a pickup or delivery because of mechanical problems with my vehicles. All the trucks went about 130,000 miles before requiring muffler changes, and they went about 145,000 miles before needing brake maintenance. I’ve got weigh scale tickets for the 1980 1/2-ton pickup showing I hauled 50 bu. of barley and 2,240 lbs. of shelled corn on the truck. I’ve hauled 1,500 lbs. of dense freight behind the rear wheel wells. Try that with a 1/2-ton pickup from any of the Big Three auto makers.

“When my first pickup had about 140,000 miles on it I got a letter from Toyota saying they knew I was the second owner of the truck, even though I had never contacted them for anything. They explained that during that period of manufacture they got a shipment of defective valve seats from their supplier, and that if I had any trouble with valve leakage I should take it in to the nearest dealer and it would be repaired. The pickup did develop a leaky valve shortly thereafter, and a remanufactured head was installed by a dealer at no cost. My five kids and their families also drive Toyotas.

“My 1988 Arts-Way belly-mounted mower is a best buy (Armstrong, Iowa ph 712 864-3131; www.artsway-mfg.com). The blades have been replaced only once, and all the belts are original. No repairs have been needed. I use it to mow a 4-acre yard.”

Best Buy

Homelite chainsaws

James J. Newell, Jonesville, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“I’m happy with my two Homelite chainsaws. I bought a model 150 automatic in 1971 and have used it to cut my winter’s supply of wood every year since 1979. It has required only minor repairs like the spark plugs, clutch, bar and chain. I still use this chainsaw every year. I bought a Super XL-AO model in 1982 and use it to cut larger trees. It works great, too.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Drill Doctor drill bit sharpener + 1 more

Dale Parker, Buckeye, Arizona · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My best buy is my Drill Doctor drill bit sharpener. It performs exactly as advertised and is quick and easy to use. It has saved me a great deal of time and aggravation.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2006 Jinma model 345 loader tractor with backhoe. “Already this tractor has had a blown head gasket, two bad injectors, a split radiator tank, a blown hydraulic hose, and a leaking rear main seal. Three of the backhoe cylinders failed within the first 20 hours of operation. I’ve had to replace the loader control valve, hoses and quick couplers due to leaks. The valve rockers wore out and new bushings had to be installed. The dealer has been fairly helpful, but this has been an expensive ‘cheap’ tractor.”

Best Buy

Charles is the satisfied owner of a 2008 ph 318 397-2588; www

Charles Brasfeild, Jr., Vicksburg, Miss. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

Charles is the satisfied owner of a 2008 ph 318 397-2588; www.stealth4x4.com). “This electric utility vehicle is well made and the company is very responsive to my questions. It has great utility and traction and runs quiet, and there’s no fuel to pour, spill, or smell. My wife uses it for feeding horses and doing chores. I use it for hunting as well as doing chores around our small farm.”

Best Buy

Vermeer 554XL round baler

Doug Dewing, Grantsburg, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My 2002 Vermeer 554XL round baler makes 4 by 5 1/2-ft. bales and is easy to operate. No problems. The bale size works well for us, as we sell a lot of horse hay and the bales fit comfortably in back of a 1/2-ton shortbed pickup. With a 4-ft. wide bale I can haul several on a trailer without being overwidth.”

Best Buy

Milwaukee tools + 1 more

Dean Hertzler, Veteran, Wyoming · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My five corded Milwaukee tools are all best buys. They include three hammer drills, a shear, and a screwdriver. The drills have keyed chucks. All these tools have plenty of power. I believe in paying for top quality tools that last.

“The Titan 18.4 by 26-in. turf tires on my 2006 New Holland 3055 windrower have problems. The sidewalls have split in two places, but the company won’t warranty their tires for sidewall splits. The cost to replace one tire is more than $800. I’d like to buy a Firestone tire to replace it, but no two manufacturers make their tires the same dimensions, even though the tires are all called 18.4 by 26’s.”

Best Buy

H&S high capacity hay + 1 more

Greg Kropf, Westphalia, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“We’re well pleased with our 2008 H&S high capacity hay rake. It’s built heavy and does a good job of keeping the rake wheels in contact with the ground. We were advised to buy the 14-wheel version instead of the 12-wheel version because it has a heavier frame. It’s the only rake I’ve owned where the center kicker wheels actually do any good.

“We bought an ETQ 1,000-watt portable generator from Northern Hydraulics and like it a lot. I paid $100 for it and thought I’d probably be able to use it for about six months before it would be used up. However, I’ve used it for more than a year now and it still works great. It’s advertised to go 4 1/2 hours per gallon of fuel, but it does better than that.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3400 34 hp tractor equipped

Steve Curtiss, Hood River, Oregon · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

Steve’s satisfied with his Kubota L3400 34 hp tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission and front-end loader. “This tractor has a low center of gravity so it’s easy to get on and off. It has a positive pto to drive implements, the 3-pt. lift arms are stable without being sloppy, and the loader digs well. The tractor has excellent safety equipment, and the rollbar folds down so it can get into a low shed. It’s reasonably fuel efficient and gets about 18 hours per thankful of fuel.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 diesel pickup

Glen Pinley, Ada, Okla. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My 2004 Ford F-350 diesel pickup is my worst buy. An engine rod went through the side at about 11,000 miles, the transmission had to be replaced at about 29,000 miles, and the turbo changed at 43,936 miles. The truck quit running on the highway at 44,200 miles, and the high pressure oil pump had to be replaced. This pickup had to go back to the dealer more than 10 times in three years. Finally I traded it for a 2008 Ford F-250 diesel model. No problems so far.”

Best Buy

John Deere Gator + 1 more

Charles N. Wells, Sturgis, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“We like our 2008 Deere Gator. It’s equipped with an optional adjustable seat which comes in handy for my shorter wife, and an electric dump bed. This utility vehicle does exactly what it’s supposed to do. We use it all over our farm and yard, even though it was originally purchased by my wife for ‘house keeping’ duties. It has a low bed height which makes loading stuff easy and also provides stability on hilly terrain. The differential lock provides just enough extra traction to get through muddy places.

“This vehicle is easy to service at home and is comfortable to get in and out of for us ‘boomers’. It replaced my wife’s 1985 Honda 250 Big Red. The Honda was also a best buy.

“We’ve also used the Gator to spray fence rows instead of a 4-wheeler. It’s much easier on the spray hand. If we need to get into tight places we still have a 4-wheeler and the Honda for that, but 99 percent of the time it’s the Gator that does the work on our farm.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda 550 rototiller + 1 more

Gloria Ann Baich, Alder Flats, Alberta · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My Honda 550 rototiller is my worst buy. I paid $1,400 for it. The machine starts fine (ph 717 442-9451). Stealth 4-WD electric utility vehicle (West Monroe, La. but puts me through a horrendous workout. It wants to dig down into the ground rather than across it, and then it gets high centered.”

Best Buy

Little Giant ladder system

James Sheedy, Sr., Reisterstown, Md. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“I like my Little Giant ladder system (ph 800 453-1192; www.littlegiantladder.com). This adjustable extension/step ladder came with a video showing how to use it. Equipped with accessories, this ladder can be used wherever the surface isn’t level. It has a platform that’s movable and sure beats standing on a rung.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland TL 100A 2-WD tractor + 1 more

Gary Lake, Front Royal, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“It runs and handles great and has a lot of power,” says Gary, pleased with his 2006 New Holland TL 100A 2-WD tractor. “It’s equipped with a cab, heater, and air conditioning. We use it mainly with a round baler.

“My 2000 Belarus 4-WD tractor equipped with a cab and front-end loader is my worst buy. It has two solid oil lines that come together in front of the engine and are connected by a 6-in. length of rubber hose. Unfortunately, the hose blew a hole and all the engine oil ran out, causing the engine to lock up. It happened at 670 hours.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight

James Rodlund, Stillwater, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“My best buy is a wood floor nailer and stapler that I bought at Harbor Freight. I had to lay about 700 sq. ft. of hickory wood flooring in my hallway, kitchen, and family room. This tool worked beyond my expectations, and it cost only about one third as much as other floor nailers that I looked at.”

Best Buy

Pedee Jeans + 2 more

Dana Davis, Sequim, Wash. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“I like my Pedee Jeans (Doug and Elaine Haga, Monmouth, Oregon ph 503 838-5955). These durable, handmade jeans are designed to last twice as long as regular commercial jeans, thanks to their lock stitch construction and reinforced stress areas.

“My Wesco work boots are also a best buy.

“And my 1991 Dodge diesel pickup has more than 250,000 miles with no problems.”

Best Buy

Bosch router + 1 more

Roger Lee, Parsons, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“I’m impressed with my Bosch router and guide kit. I use it on our ranch-style house which was built in the early 1950’s, which like all older homes requires ongoing maintenance. The windowsills on some windows were rotting on the outside edge so I used the router to rebuild about 4 in. of the outside edge. Now I’m in the process of rebuilding the wooden doors on a garage that I built in 1978. I paid $219 for it at Lowe’s. It’s a great tool.

“On the garage door joints I’m using a beadlock kit that works well (www.beadlock.com).

“My Sears 42-in. riding mower cuts uneven and is my worst buy. After I’m done mowing the lawn looks like I gave it a bad haircut. The company offers a wheel leveling option that attaches outside the mower deck to keep the mower level. But why should I have to purchase a leveling option on a new mower?”

Best Buy

Makita cordless tools work + 1 more

Karl P. Retzlaff, Morris, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

Karl’s got a “beef” with cordless tools. “Why are replacement batteries for these tools so expensive and so hard to find? When the batteries on Coleman and Sears Craftsman tools wear out, you can no longer use the tools. Makita cordless tools work better. I haven’t tried Milwaukee or DeWalt cordless tools. I’m running out of room to store my useless Craftsman and Coleman cordless tools.

“I bought a 5-ft. Rhino brush mower to replace my 3-pt. mounted Woods belt-drive brush mower. The shear pin breaks if the mower barely touches the ground, and the pto shaft rattles terribly if I turn just a little. Finally I parked this mower in the trees and started using the old Woods mower again. The Woods mower has been a real time saver and is built well. I’d buy another one.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bolen riding mower + 1 more

Carl Smith, Hopewell, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“My 2007 Bolen riding mower is my worst buy. The deck is falling apart, the engine runs a while and then cuts off, it lacks power, rides rough, and is hard to steer. I was given a Murray riding mower in 1992 that is still running strong. I gave it to my neighbor last year when I bought the Bolen model, which was a big mistake. I should have spent the money on another Murray.”

Best Buy

Sea Foam motor treatment

Casey Schrock, Elkhart, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

Carl’s happy with Sea Foam motor treatment (Sea Foam Sales Co., ph 952 938-4811; www.seafoamsales.com). “I got an unbelievable deal on a Honda motorcycle. It had been sitting in a barn for two years and refused to start because of gunk in the carburetors. The previous owner had tried everything short of pulling the carburetors off and rebuilding them, but nothing would clean them. I put a small auxillary tank on the motorcycle and ran a 50 percent mixture of Sea Foam through the carburetors. At first the engine would barely run at full choke so I let it sit for a day to work its magic. When I started the engine the second day it would run with the choke off. I rode it for a half hour and it idled smooth as can be. Now the engine starts right up every time. It saved me the time, money and hassle of rebuilding the carburetors.”

Best Buy

Tool Shop sliding compound miter

K. George Van Every, Page, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“I’m well pleased with my Tool Shop 10-in. sliding compound miter saw. It was the best $100 I’ve ever spent. I don’t use it that much but for a cheap saw it works great when I need it. I used it to remodel my dad’s house with no problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl chainsaw + 2 more

Delmar Butler, Chandler, Okla. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“My 1977 Stihl chainsaw still starts and runs great. I’ve replaced the bar and several chains, but it has required no other repairs.

“My 2006 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a Power Stroke engine is my worst buy. It gets poor mileage, and the cooling fan roars at low temperatures. Also, so much mud builds up around the doors that I can’t get in or out without getting dirty.

“My 2006 Ford Expedition is a worst buy. By the time it had 23,000 miles I had already replaced all the tires. It rattles, and dirt around the rear door gasket causes leaks.”

Worst Buy

Wayne sump pump

Ralph R. Look, Wichita, Kansas · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“The Wayne sump pump I bought in 1995 is my worst buy. It sat in the box for a year before it was put to use, so I didn’t feel that I could return it.

“The first problem was with a float that slides up and down on a brass rod and would move up to turn the pump on. As the water was pumped out, the weight of the rod was enough to cause it to follow the float down and turn the pump off early, rather than let the float move down to the bottom of the rod and then turn the pump off. As a result, the pump cycled on and off much too often.

“I contacted the company and was told they’d check it out and get back to me, but they didn’t. I fixed the problem by adding a small spring above the pump to help offset the weight of the rod, and it worked. Recently, I caught the sump nearly full because the pump had failed to turn on. It appears the rubber seal on the float switch had aged and taken a set and the weight of the float wasn’t enough to pull the switch down to the ‘on’ position.

“Otherwise, this pump has worked well. But if I hadn’t checked and found the sump full, I would’ve had wet carpet. Based on my experience, I wouldn’t buy another Wayne sump pump.”

Best Buy

Zims crack cream

Mary A. Bowlin, Cuervo, New Mexico · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

Mary says Zims crack cream is her “best buy” (Perfecta Products, Inc., ph 800 319-2225 or 330 549-1900; www.crackcream.com). “My husband has had painful cracks on the end of his fingers for years, but this cream cleared them up. Now he has no more pain.”

Best Buy

Wonder Earth Partners sending

John Giardina, Cayuga, N.Y. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“In April, 2007, I ordered 10 Empress high-growth trees from Wonder Earth Partners, sending a check for $152.75. I received a note saying they were sold out and that the trees would ship in the fall. About mid-September I got a small cardboard box with 10 sets of roots that didn’t look good. We planted them anyway into prepared ground as per instructions. Not one of the trees came up in the spring. After repeated calls to the company, we have not been able to get a refund, or even a response, even though the trees were 100 percent guaranteed.”

Best Buy

Frost Heaters Inc 612-978-9565

Jack Kaspari, Bovey, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

Jack’s pleased with the aftermarket engine heater he installed in his 2005 Volkswagen Jetta diesel. He bought it from Frost Heaters Inc. (612-978-9565; www.frostheater.com). “My dealer told me there was no such heater but I found this one and it’s very well made and compact. It heats engine coolant to provide quick starts on cold northern Minnesota mornings. These custom heaters fit Golfs, Jettas, Beetles and Passats with TDI diesels. You can’t use frost plug heaters on these engines.”

Worst Buy

Bixby corn/pellet stove

Paul J. Miller, New Richland, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“I read two ‘worst buy’ reports in a recent issue of FARM SHOW on the Bixby corn/pellet stove. I suspect those gentlemen did not have their stoves properly adjusted because I have used a Bixby stove to heat my house for three years. It’s very efficient and low maintenance. Definitely performs as advertised. We’re very pleased.”

Best Buy

Thermobile

David Kluth, Menomonee Falls, Wis. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“I love my Thermobile AT 307 waste oil heater (ph 262 882-4203; www.thermobile.us). It produces 100,000 btu’s of portable heat for my shop. It’s easy to install using $150 worth of class B double wall chimney pipe. I liked it so much that I became a dealer.” balebandit.com).

Best Buy

Valtra C-90 tractor

Richard Thomas, Madison, Mo. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

Richard nominates his 2006 Valtra C-90 tractor as his “best buy”. “This tractor is a state-ofthe-art 90 hp tractor - shuttle shift transmission with 24 speeds forward and reverse; joystick hydraulic controls mounted on the fender for outside override of the 3-pt. hitch; a heavy-built front-end loader; and non-directional, all-wheel-drive tires. The tractor always starts when it’s cold outside without having to be plugged in, and it uses less than two gallons of diesel per hour. I grow hay and feed cattle so I use this tractor all year long.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Polaris Ranger + 2 more

Dennis Huwe, Bagley, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“My 2006 Polaris Ranger is my best buy. I’ve owned six different Polaris ATV’s and all of them have been trouble-free.

“My Tracfone cell phone is my worst buy. When we went to Arizona last winter it took two different phones, three weeks, and many hours of my time to get it working properly. I finally switched to an Alltel cell phone, which has been trouble-free everywhere I go.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Jonserud chainsaw equipped + 1 more

Joe Konwinski, Silver Creek, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 14

“My 2007 Jonserud chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar is my best buy. It’s easy to start, well balanced, has a lot of power, and is lightweight.

“My 2007 Poulan 18-in. Wildthing chainsaw is my worst buy. It leaks bar oil whenever it isn’t being used and it’s also hard to start. If it does start, it’s hard to keep it running. It doesn’t have much power, either.”

Best Buy

Toyota Prius hybrid car

Peyton E. Smith, Covington, Tenn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

Peyton’s pleased with his 2005 Toyota Prius hybrid car. “Previously I owned a 2000 Prius and liked it. I traded it in for the new model because the new one has more amenities, such as side air bags and cruise control. Both cars were excellent with outstanding fuel mileage of 50 to 55 mpg on the highway and 40 to 45 mpg in the city. I’ve put a total of 95,000 miles on these cars with only minor problems, and they were covered by the warranty.”

Worst Buy

Staber clothes washing machine

Chester R. Wallace, Belle Chasse, La. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2007 Staber clothes washing machine, a stainless steel commercial large load model, is my worst buy. First, the delivery from UPS was a nightmare. Then once the machine was delivered and I hooked it up, I found that I couldn’t wash my queen-size comforter because it won’t fit in the machine. The stainless steel water hoses ‘installed from the factory’ were cross-threaded and leaked. The outside of the washer drum is growing mold and slime on it and stinks.

“Recently we started the machine up and came back to find it had stayed in the spin cycle for six straight hours. When we called the company to return the machine, we were told we’d have to pay to ship it back and we’d have to pay a ‘restocking fee’. So we’re stuck with it and have had to resort to washing big stuff elsewhere.”

Best Buy

Beltone hearing aids

Roy E. Miller, Tamms, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“I’ve never been satisfied with my Beltone hearing aids. I gave the company a check for $4,000 but they refused to refund any money. I made more than 20 trips back to their office, but they couldn’t get the hearing aids adjusted correctly. I’d like to know if anyone else has had problems with this company.”

Worst Buy

Hardi Navigator sprayer equipped

Fred V. Gustoff, Manito, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

Fred isn’t happy with his Hardi Navigator sprayer equipped with a 45-ft. boom. “The first time I tried to use this sprayer, the plastic pipes on the pump broke. I had 550 gallons of spray in the tank with no way to unload. I had to get another sprayer to get the work done. It took the dealer two weeks to repair the pump.

“Later on, two 8-ft. plastic pipes inside the tank popped off. I had to haul it 44 miles back to the dealer to get it repaired. Evidently the plastic can’t take the pump’s pressure. It cost me more than $300.”

Best Buy

Kubota L-2800 8 + 1 more

Gerald Shaw, Manchester, Mich. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2005 Kubota L-2800 8 by 4 tractor is well-built and is easy on fuel. The transmission required a minor adjustment at 100 hours, but the work was done at no charge and the machine was returned the next day. I’d buy another one without question.

“My Mighty Mac pto-driven brush chipper is a best buy. I’ve used it on thousands of tree limbs and brush, yet the teeth are still sharp. It’s a perfect machine.”

Best Buy

Stihl MS 260

Art Malone, Lake Jackson, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2007 Stihl MS 260 and 1987 Stihl 012 chainsaw are both best buys. The 012 model always starts and runs well, and the 2007 model is just as reliable. I don’t like all the plastic that’s on the new saw, but that’s how everything is made today.”

Best Buy

DR versa-pro + 1 more

T.A. Sampson, Cane Hill, Ark. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My DR Versa-Pro Z-mower is my best buy. I have several other DR products and don’t have enough words of praise for this company and its high quality line of U.S.-made equipment. This riding mower is unique in that the control panel can be flipped so I can reach in under tree lines or tricky places where I wouldn’t want to be riding for safety reasons.

“My 2007 Country Mfg. model 600 spreader breaks down on a regular basis. It seems like the company has sent me a replacement for every moving part on it. Belts and chains fall off regularly, and the chains are so badly corroded I don’t think they’ll last much longer.”

Best Buy

Woodmizer LT-40 hydraulic sawmill

Jerry Misek, Elizabeth, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“The 2001 Woodmizer LT-40 hydraulic sawmill I bought used in 2005 is my best buy. This sawmill is easy to operate and very accurate. It requires very little maintenance and if problems do occur, the company’s support staff quickly responds. The trailer package makes it easy to move from site to site.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hypertherm plasma cutter + 1 more

Chad Travis, Drasco, Ark. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2005 Hypertherm plasma cutter has reduced my acetylene use a lot (GTS-Welco, Inc., ph 800 942-1148; www.gts-welco.com). This plasma cutter has the ability to cut stainless steel and cast iron and will cut through a 1 1/2-in. dia. steel shaft. It works fast and is fun to operate. I installed a Motor Guard air filter on it which was worth the money. It’s basically a roll of toilet paper in a canister that traps dirt and moisture, which saves burning out tips.

“The hay cover tarp I bought from Mis-souri Hay Tarps is my worst buy. The tarp failed shortly after it was installed and was ripped to shreds in the wind. This tarp was really nothing more than the kind of poly tarp you can buy at any chain store, just bigger. The company did send me a replacement, but it didn’t work any better than the first one.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ryobi BC-30 start + 1 more

Robert S. Horne, Rural Retreat, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

Robert likes his 2007 Ryobi BC-30 “start plus” weed whacker equipped with an expand-it attachment system. I have the heavy duty brush cutter, and string trimmer heads. “The brush cutterhead cuts tall grass without tangling and will also cut through brush up to 1 in. in dia. The string trimmer works great for regular grass trimming.

“My 2004 Honda XR 2500 pressure washer equipped with an OHC 5 hp engine is my worst buy. The engine is difficult to start in cold weather. Also, the water pump seized up and ruptured the shaft.”

Best Buy

DR Field Brush mower equipped

Jack Davis, Lincoln City, Oregon · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2005 DR Field & Brush mower equipped with a 17 hp engine is my best buy. I use it to mow my pasture which has a lot of skunk cabbage in it. I’ve mowed in 2 in. of standing water, but the mower never hesitated once. That’s when I was convinced this is a great piece of machinery. I’ve since purchased several other pieces of DR equipment, including a generator which uses the same power head; a DR trimmer/mower for mowing along fence lines; and a 6-ton wood splitter. If the company has what I need, I’ll buy from them first.”

Best Buy

John Deere LX 277 riding mower + 1 more

Enos L. Holloman, Ahoskie, N.C. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2003 Deere LX 277 riding mower has never failed to start and is my best buy. It has more than 360 hours on it with no problems and still has the original battery.

“My 2001 GM 4-WD pickup is dependable and a best buy. I replaced the tires at about 47,000 miles and the battery when the pickup was five years old. It now has about 55,000 miles on it.”

Best Buy

Ram D-3500 1-ton pickup equipped

Neil L. Dunagan, Spokane Valley, Wash. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2000 Dodge D-3500 1-ton pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my best buy. This pickup is fuel efficient, rides like a car, and pulls my 24,000-lb. tandem axle trailer like a dream. I’ve owned Chevys and Fords in the past, but this is my fourth Dodge and by far is the best.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Yamaha 80 cc + 1 more

Robert and Bernardine Specht, Monmouth, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“The 1990 Yamaha 80 cc ATV I bought used in 1997 is my best buy. It runs well and has required only one muffler repair. I use it mainly for yard work with a trailer.

“My 2000 AGCO lawn tractor is my worst buy. When it was four years old the engine had to be replaced. Recently, the transmission failed. Wire got wound up tightly around the driveshaft. Any repairs are very expensive. One redeeming feature is the deck is easy to remove for cleaning.”

Best Buy

Kubota B8200 tractor

Bill Gitter, Coldwater, Miss. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My Kubota B8200 tractor starts and runs good, is easy on fuel, and is the right size for yard work. I use it with a finishing mower and it does a good job. I also own a Kubota L-310 model that’s as tough as iron.”

Best Buy

David Brown 1200A diesel tractor

Lloyd Wrentmore, Logan, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“It uses less fuel than any tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Lloyd, happy with his 1967 David Brown 1200A diesel tractor that he bought used in 1988. “I’ve put one set of 18.4 by 30 rear tires on it, one set of brakes and fuel filters, a new hydraulic filter, new batteries, and a new starter solenoid last year. It doesn’t have any heat plugs on it as it starts off compression. In cold weather I just give it a little shot of ether.”

Best Buy

Mercury Sable LS

David Thomas, Dale, N.Y. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“It’s a comfortable car to drive - easy on gas, quiet, and just about maintenance-free,” reports David about his 1999 Mercury Sable LS.

A chisel set that he bought at Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy”. “The chisels broke under pressure and are poorly made.”

Best Buy

Nissan Versa mini

Gale Oswald, Milford, Neb. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

Gale nominates his 2007 Nissan Versa mini SUV as his “best buy”. “It has a comfortable ride, with no problems. Two years ago we drove it to Phoenix, Arizona and back. It has a roomy interior and best of all, it’s more fuel efficient than what’s posted on the sticker.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Fluke 73 III Multimeter + 1 more

Mark Snider, Cle Elum, Wash. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

Mark’s happy with his Fluke 73 III Multimeter (Everett, Wash. 800 443-5853; http://us.fluke.com). “The settings are easy to read. It’s simple to use and I can hear the tones.

“My Solder It mini torch is my worst buy. The lighting mechanism quit working the second time I used it. I continued to use it, lighting it with a cigarette lighter for a short time, until it quit working altogether.”

Worst Buy

Outback S Lite guidance system

Robert Stewart, Lapel, Ind. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“The Outback S Lite guidance system I bought last April is my worst buy. I never could get it to work although I kept trying all summer. The problem was that it kept dropping the signal. I contacted the company last August and was given a repair order number. I shipped it Sept. 1 with the RO number on the outside of the package as per their instructions. I insured it with USPS and they said the repair facility in Hiawatha, Kansas, received it on Sept. 4. I was told to expect it returned in five working days.

“I called them about three weeks later but they had no record of it. The problem was that the name was misspelled on the original invoice. I corrected that and asked them to check their records for both spellings. The company was supposed to contact the dealer to determine the serial number, which isn’t on the original shipping box. It has now been 50 days since I shipped it, with nothing to show for my $1,000 investment.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt driver drill set + 1 more

Ted Boice, Great Falls, Montana · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“Several years ago I bought a Sears Craftsman 19.2-volt driver drill set for about $100. I really liked its performance and used it almost every day. However, a year or so ago both batteries quit charging so I headed down to Sears to get a couple of new ones. I was told they don’t handle batteries for ‘older’ drills, and that I’d have to go to a service center across town. They wanted $74 for a pair of batteries, which I wasn’t willing to pay.

“Then I went to Sam’s Club and bought two Kawasaki 19.2-volt drills, four batteries, and two chargers for less than $80. I love them and use them all the time. I’ll never buy another electric tool with the Craftsman name on it.”

Best Buy

Pixall Super Jack corn picker

Brian Pahl, Apple Valley, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“We bought a Pixall Super Jack corn picker for picking fresh market sweet corn (Oxbo Corp., ph 800 836-4336; www.oxbocorp.com). This machine does an excellent job of picking corn without bruising it, and it leaves flag leaves on the cob that are attractive to the customer. I’ve never gotten stuck in wet soil with this machine. Also, it’s quiet and doesn’t break down very often. The only limitation is that it won’t pick up down corn, but I’ve made some modifications that help with that problem.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet UTV side-by-side 4-wd garden + 1 more

Gerard E. Quellette, Richmond, Maine · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“My 2007 Cub Cadet UTV side-by-side 4-WD garden tractor equipped with a 20 hp Kohler engine wouldn’t stop dieseling in hot weather. At slow speeds it jerked all the time because of a variable speed belt. Also, the transmission was hard to shift. The tractor was in the shop for almost six months. Both the dealer and the company said they couldn’t fix it because there was nothing wrong, so a year ago I traded for a Kubota side-by-side 4-WD RTV equipped with a 22 hp diesel engine. We’ve used it hard to haul firewood without a single problem. We love it.”