Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014)

83 reports from pages 12–15 · 76 Best Buys20 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

CPO Tools

Wayne Leighan, Madison, Va. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“I’ve been purchasing reconditioned tools with great savings through CPO Tools (ph 866 308-4276; www.cpotools.com). They sell great tools in excellent condition. I’ve purchased a Hitachi jigsaw, a Milwaukee battery-powered grease gun, 2 Porter Cable 18-volt Nicad tool sets, and much more. All these tools still work great.”

Best Buy

Kubota 5240 4-WD diesel loader tractor

Bill Mahle, Ahwahnee, Calif. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“Our 2008 Kubota 5240 4-WD diesel loader tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission works great. We use this tractor on our 5-acre ranch to do everything from hauling dirt to rototilling our horse arena. The loader is equipped with quick-change brackets, making it easy to remove the bucket and replace it with forks. This tractor starts great in cold weather and is easy on fuel.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere chainsaw + 3 more

Russell S. Smith, Waco, Texas · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“Last summer my 30-year-old Deere 16-in. chainsaw finally quit working. I was told it was built by Echo, so I bought a 2013 Echo CS-352 chainsaw. So far it has performed just as well as the Deere.

“I still use my 1991 Dodge 250 as my everyday pickup.

“My 1951 Ford 8N is my new tractor; my 1946 Deere B is the old one.”

Best Buy

AJ Windows

Jeffrey Oelke, Pittsville, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“In 2011 I bought new aluminum windows at Home Depot made by AJ Windows. The windows leaked air, which caused the inside casing to mold and as a result I had to replace the inside trim. The windows lost a lot of heat during the winter. I paid a lot of money for these windows, but now I’ll need to spend more to fix them.”

Best Buy

O’Keeffes Working Hands hand cream

Gordon Fuller, Barriere, B.C. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“O’Keeffes Working Hands hand cream is the best hand care product I’ve ever used (ph 800 275-2718; www.okeeffescompany.com). I bought it because I had dry, split and cracked hands. It stopped all the cracking and keeps my hands soft. I also use it on my elbows and heels, and my wife uses it extensively, too. It’s one of the best products I’ve ever used. The company also makes a foot cream.”

Best Buy

Kioti DK45 tractor

Steven Feigner, Talent, Ore. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“The 2009 Kioti DK45 tractor I bought used equipped with a front-end loader and backhoe has performed flawlessly and has an easy-to-use, 3-pt. hookup system. Makes it easy to remove and attach a backhoe.”

Best Buy

Kinze planter

Louis Giesting, Batesville, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“We bought our first Kinze planter used 6 or 7 years ago to plant corn, and it still works like new. We soon bought another one just to plant beans. Both planters are built rugged and are simple to operate. All sorts of aftermarket attachments are available for them and they hold up to our tough soils, even when planting no-till. We get great emergence and stands, which is key to getting good yields.

“Both planters have required only routine maintenance and we plan on using them for many more years, even though they were built in the 1990’s. The corn planter is an 8-row, 2500 model which lifts and turns for narrow road transport. The bean planter is a 12-row, 15-in. 82D model. There weren’t a whole lot of them made, but we really like it for beans since all the row units are on the same toolbar. We can get parts for these planters from our Case IH dealer, which is a bonus.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 4-WD pickup equipped + 1 more

Louis Giesting, Batesville, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“My 1995 Dodge Ram 2500 4-WD pickup, equipped with a 12V Cummins turbo diesel engine and 5-speed transmission, is as tough as a $2 steak. It still has the original headlight bulbs, and the interior is almost perfect after 18 years. This pickup has about 220,000 miles on it. We used to be Ford guys, but now we own four Cummins-powered Dodges. They have great drivetrains.

“I bought a new radiator from General Radiator Corporation with a 5-year warranty and had an experienced mechanic install it. However, within 9 months I had to take the radiator out because a fitting was leaking. It was a lousy product and didn’t even fit into the pickup very well. I told them I wanted my money back, but they would only offer me store credit that was about half the value of the original radiator. I ended up buying a radiator from another company and have had no problems with it.”

Best Buy

Dish TV

Emil Smith, Franklin, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“We’ve had nothing but lousy service from Dish TV for the 2 years we’ve been locked into their program. I can say nothing good about them, and we’re not complainers.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD pickup + 1 more

Ron Stoltz, Lambertville, N.J. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“I’m closing in on 150,000 miles with my 2009 Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD pickup. It runs like a top with no major problems.

“The Troy-Bilt garden tractor I bought from Lowes literally fell apart and is my worst buy. This wasn’t a genuine Troy-Bilt product, but the company licensed their name to it. We had trouble with it from the start. I finally got Lowes to come out and take it back. Lesson learned.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

McCormick MTX 150 front wheel assist + 1 more

Dennis Smith, Marshalltown, Iowa · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“My 2008 McCormick MTX 150 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a McCormick L160 front-end loader has a lot of power and is fuel efficient and quiet. The loader is built heavy. I use it with a bucket-mounted bale spear and dozer blade. The joystick control is smooth and easy to use, and the shuttle shift transmission works great for loader work.”

On the negative side, he lists his White rear-fold, narrow row planter. “I had to do more work on this planter in 2 seasons than I did on my IH planters in 25 years. It has about 60 grease zerks and they’re always plugged. The row units are built too light. It’s hard to change crops and population settings, and the planter squeaks terribly going through the field, which drives us crazy. We were happy to get rid of it and go back to Case IH.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight

David Nemeth, Campbell Hall, N.Y. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“My friend needed a new engine for his log splitter, which had been in a flood. We went to Harbor Freight and bought a Predator engine. It ran for only about 3 hrs. before the ignition quit. The company replaced it, but that one ran for only a few hours before it seized up. The company promptly gave my friend his money back.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 1070 utility tractor + 2 more

Steve Bennett, Newport, Wash. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 12

“I’ve had very few problems with my 1996 Deere 1070 utility tractor which I use with a frontend loader, backhoe and Farm King 6-ft. snowblower. I had to repair a broken tab on the front wheel driveshaft cover and replace the battery cable. The snowblower has performed well with no problems.

“My Cleary pole building is without a doubt the worst buy I ever made. It took the construction crew more than 3 mo. to complete what should have been a 10-day project. It was like watching the Three Stooges in action, and they ended up getting the building so out of square that the roof trusses wouldn’t go on. They had to dismantle what they had done and reset the posts, but the building still ended up out of square.

“The roof has leaked from day one. I had a crew come out every year the building was under warranty to fix the leaks but each year the leaks would start again, often in the same spot. Now I have to go up on the roof every summer and do whatever I can to minimize the leaking.

“When they finished the building I refused to let them put the Cleary sign up on it. I use this building, but I’m careful not to store things where they could get damaged by water. The company no longer operates in my area and I can see why. Live and learn.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna professional chainsaws + 1 more

Driskel Bros. Tree Service, Nevada, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“We’ve used Husqvarna professional chainsaws for more than 20 years and are well satisfied with all of them, including the 372, 385, 390, and 3120 models. They withstand all kinds of treatment and keep running no matter what the weather. We make sure to keep the filters clean and use only good fuel.”

On the minus side, “Our Stihl 131 extended reach, telescoping tree trimmers run okay right after we buy them, but soon start missing and backfiring. The dealer told us we need to adjust the top end rockers every 100 hrs. or so. We bought 3 of these tree trimmers at $699 apiece, but we won’t buy any more.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 crew cab pickup

W.E. McClusky, Big Sandy, Texas · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“Our 2012 Dodge Ram 1500 crew cab pickup equipped with a Hemi engine isn’t as fuel efficient as advertised. The pickup needed a new alternator at 6 months before it even had 10,000 miles on it. The automatic lights are iffy and work only sporadically. Yet the dealer says there’s nothing wrong.”

Best Buy

Stanley wet/dry vac

Dean Skare, Baraboo, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

A Stanley 3-gal. wet/dry vac rates as Dean’s “best buy”. “This small vac is really handy for cleaning up spills and for use inside cars and trucks. It works great for blowing stuff out from under seats and for cleaning fabric seats.”

Best Buy

CBS Performance Automotive designed + 1 more

Willard Wamsley, Clarksville, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

Willard’s impressed with electronic breakerless ignition from CBS Performance Automotive designed to replace points and condensers in older tractors (ph 800 685-1492; www.pertronix.com). He’s also had good luck with permanent replacement load control shaft seals for Deere 30 and 40 series tractors offered by Boling Machine Shop (ph 660 699-3717; www.bolingmachine.com). “Both products work great and perform as advertised.”

Best Buy

Ram Grand Caravan

Loraine Tichenor, Sparta, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“Our 1996 Dodge Grand Caravan has almost 140,000 miles on it but still drives and rides like new. It’s nice to get in and out of and is much nicer than a lot of new vehicles. I’m 90 years old and hope this van lasts for as long as I can drive.”

Best Buy

Durafork steel-tined fork

Carole Ruttan, Bracebridge, Ontario · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“I use a Durafork steel-tined fork for picking up horse manure (ph 888 978-7759; www.globalindustrial.com). I’ve used these forks for 42 years and recently bought my third one. The other 2 are still usable with minor repairs. It’s a fantastic product for horse owners.

“I can’t believe someone hasn’t made a salt lick holder that can last longer than a week. The hard plastic ones on the market are easy to crack, and pieces break off with normal use by horses. It doesn’t matter which brand I try, they all end up the same.”

Best Buy

Bosch 4100-09 table saw

James White, Wilkie, Sask. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“Last January I bought a Bosch 4100-09 table saw. While I was putting it together I noticed, to my disappointment, some vital screws were missing from a piece on the saw’s rip fence. They seemed to be specialty metric screws that my local industrial supply store couldn’t get, so I called the company right away.

“They sent me an illustrated parts list so it was easy to find the exact part number for the missing screws. They sent them right out. Their customer support was by far the best I’ve received from any company.

“I haven’t had a chance to use the saw much, but so far I’m impressed with how easy it is to operate and how neatly it folds for storage. I bought this saw based on extensive internet research, which turned up mostly positive reviews. I’m looking forward to putting it to the test.”

Best Buy

Mower Deck Axle Co

Harold Westfall, Whitney Point, N.Y. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“My best buy is a storage system made by Mower Deck Axle Co., which allows me to store and work on my 60-in. mower deck in a vertical position (ph 607 863-4208; www.moweraxle.com/tractorstands.html). All I have to do is remove the rear anti-scalp wheels and replace them with the wheel and axle system, allowing the unit to be easily rolled around. Storing the deck in the vertical position saves space.”

Best Buy

Ambrosia apple

Ron Carey, West Chester, Iowa · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“About 3 years ago I tried my first Ambrosia apple and it was the sweetest and juiciest apple I’ve ever eaten. Ambrosia instantly replaced Washington Delicious as my favorite apple. Its history can be found at www.ambrosiaapples.com. Unfortunately, these apples are hard to find in stores. I inquired about purchasing some trees, but learned that they’re patented in Canada and only sold to licensed growers.”

Best Buy

CBS Performance Automotive

Gerald Fedler, Fort Madison, Iowa · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“I was having a lot of trouble with my 1954 IH Super MTA tractor burning up the points. After less than 20 hrs. of running time I would have to replace the points. I talked to my local IH dealer and he told me they were having good luck with breakerless ignition systems from CBS Performance Automotive (ph 800 685-1492; www.pertronix.com). I had them come out and replace the points, and now it’s like having a new tractor. I don’t have to worry all the time about whether I need to work on the points or not. I also made the change on my 1941 Farmall M, and plan to on my 1948 Allis Chalmers Model C.”

Best Buy

Ford guy whose 2001 + 1 more

Gene Huffman, Rockville, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

Gene is a Ford guy whose 2001 Ford Ranger pickup has about 95,000 miles with the only problem being a vacuum leak from a 3-in. hose. “My Ford 7000 and 5900 tractors have also been trouble-free. I use my Ford 340 skid loader for brush and wood removal and for other chores. I like my 2008 Ford Mustang which is equipped with a 400 hp engine and 5-speed transmission.

“I’m happy with the Hammond Equipment replacement belts I bought for that the Multiplaz has, and the cost of running it is almost zero compared to any other form of cutting or welding. I think the way it cuts stainless steel is the most impressive thing it can do. When we were cutting out circles and plate in stainless using the Multiplaz hole cutter, it was amazing. It cut right through, with a pretty clean cut. The amount of gear necessary to compete with the Multiplaz could easily go over $5,000. The fact that the machine can run on 110 volts or 220 volts and has a brain to switch over to the proper voltage that it’s plugged into makes it easy to use.

Best Buy

On any given day I use my Multiplaz 3500 to repair cast iron and fabri

Daniel Nolan, Traverse City, Mich. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

On any given day I use my Multiplaz 3500 to repair cast iron and fabricate gates. Three months ago my MIG broke so I switched to the Multiplaz 3500 and have never looked back. It has a 220v adapter so I can weld and cut to the full extent of the machine even when only household 110 volts is available as a power supply. I can weld many different types of metals and alloys, even solder and braze. It saves me money because I don’t need to buy shielding gases or expensive fuels. The welds look very clean and there is a small heat-affected zone. I don’t need heavy protective gear. In fact, I can weld in short sleeves and #5 shade sunglasses, which helps a lot with endurance and productivity on long, hot days.

Best Buy

I’ve done just about every kind of welding in the past 45 years and I

Dale Schoepflin, Ellinwood, Kan. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

I’ve done just about every kind of welding in the past 45 years and I have to say the Multiplaz 3500 has worked very well for me. It does everything the company says it will, although the documentation was poor. It does a beautiful job of welding. A friend welded 2 pieces of 1/16-in. steel with as nice a bead as you’d ever see. Penetration was phenomenal. I built a lawn cart just to get the hang of it, and by the time I got done I was doing some real nice work. I’ve deliberately made some bad welds and then was able to re-build them into real quality-looking beads. It’s a lot like working with an oxy torch, only it gets 3 times as hot. I did a little stainless and was real impressed. For portability you can’t beat it. It doesn’t matter if you plug it into 110 volts or 220 volts. I think 99 percent of the time you can use 110 and never trip a breaker. After using this I’ll probably never use my acetylene again. I think I can even use it to weld copper. For people who are in remote areas, if they’ve got a generator and a Multiplaz, they can repair or build just about anything. You can also bend metal. Heat up 1/2 to 3/8-in. thick steel and it’ll bend like butter. Not a lot of heat invasion like you’d have with a torch.

Worst Buy

Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup

Larry Land, San Luis Obispo, Calif. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

The cost of the Multiplaz 3500 tool is a great selling point. No other tool has the flexibility my Hesston 5500 round baler (ph 334 627-3348). The belts fit right and the service was great.

“I’ve always had a lot of problems with my 1989 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup so, as payback, I’m going to cut it down and convert it into a rough and tumble 4-WD rig. I plan to use it for every trashy job I can find.”

Best Buy

After seeing the story on the Lubricheck tester in FARM SHOW (Vol

Matthew Peterson, Rexburg, Idaho · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 13

“After seeing the story on the Lubricheck tester in FARM SHOW (Vol. 36, No. 4), I ordered one. The day it arrived, I checked the oil on 23 engines. I had just returned home and taken over the farm. Some of the engines hadn’t been run in years. I got good readings, and the oil looked good on most of them. I had only 3 that showed a need to change oil at the time, and 2 or 3 that were close to needing oil changed. I saved a lot of money on oil immediately.

“I saved even more money on a Case 4494. The Lubricheck tester indicated problems only 100 hours after an oil change. It gave me high readings and blinking lights indicating metal in the oil. When I drained the oil and checked the oil pan, I found filings. I tore it apart this winter and found broken rings and worn bearings.

“The biggest advantage for me is that I have a number of tractors that get a small amount of usage every year. Recommendations are to change oil every 3 months or at least once a year; yet they may get less than 300 hrs. on them. I’m able to save a lot of money by verifying oil quality before doing a routine oil change.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 455 rear-wheel-steer lawn tractor + 1 more

Robert Cashman, Munster, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

Robert’s happy with his Deere 455 rear-wheel-steer lawn tractor. “I use it to mow 4 acres with a lot of buildings and trees on it. The rear wheel steering lets me get in and out of tight spots.”

He’s disappointed with his Sub-Zero 550 refrigerator-freezer. “The thermostat on it has been replaced 4 times. The freezer is supposed to be frost-free but has never worked right. I had to spend money to add a drain heater and a heater for a refrigerator button (a factory modification). I thought I was buying the best, but instead I ended up with a poorly engineered lemon.”

Best Buy

Stryker 3403 log splitter

Dick Gallien, Winona, Minn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I like my 3-pt. mounted Stryker 3403 log splitter (ph 800 248-4681; centralboiler.com). It features a 2-way splitting action that splits wood in both the forward and reverse stroke. My model has both a 2-way and a 4-way blade and a hydraulic log lift/table that’s rated at 550 lbs. The company offers self-contained and skid loader-powered models.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-150 XL 4-WD pickup + 1 more

Mark Swihart, Mansfield, Ohio · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I bought my 2011 Ford F-150 XL 4-WD pickup used with about 4,300 miles on it. It’s equipped with a 3.7-liter, V-6 engine and automatic transmission. This is a no-frills model, which I really like. It has a manual transfer case and roll-up windows, with no extra stuff to worry about or a dash full of knobs and switches to break. It gets 15 to 16 mpg in town and 23 to 24 mpg on the highway, which I think is great for a 4-WD pickup.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Rage II Evolution chop saw equipped with a carbide-tipped blade instead of an abrasive wheel. “When I used it on 1/8-in. thick angle iron the blade only lasted for 12 to 15 cuts. I returned it and bought a new abrasive saw.”

Best Buy

Kia Soul

Ken Gardner, Lebanon, Ct. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

Ken’s the satisfied owner of a 2013 Kia Soul Plus car equipped with a 2.0-liter, 4-cyl. engine and 6-speed automatic transmission. “I’m 79 years old and have had both hips and both knees replaced. I’m also 6 ft. 4 in. tall and weigh 240 lbs. What sold me on this car was the ease of getting in and out of it. It has enough headroom so I don’t have to worry about bumping my head going in or out of the car, which is great. It gets more than 30 mpg, has plenty of power, rides great, and has an awesome sound system.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 2500 HD 4-wd pickup + 1 more

Andy Ehlinger, Wabeno, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I bought my 2003 Chevrolet Silverado 2500 HD 4-WD pickup used in 2006 and have put more than 130,000 miles on it. It now has about 170,000 miles and has pulled a 5,000-lb. trailer during much of that time. A sensor went out, but otherwise this pickup has required only routine maintenance. The 6.0-liter gas engine on it has plenty of power.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Ridgid 18-volt cordless tool set. “The drill broke 3 times and had to be sent in for repairs each time. The flashlight didn’t work, and the sawzall broke. The only tool that didn’t break was the circular saw, probably because I didn’t use it as much.”

Worst Buy

Branson 8050 4-WD loader tractor

Coy Woodall, Calvin, Okla. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

Coy’s disappointed with his 2012 Branson 8050 4-WD loader tractor. “At just 16 hrs. it started blowing fuel out the side of the injection pump, and it took the dealer 3 months to get parts to repair it. The front windows leak, and there’s a bad rattle that I can’t find. This tractor is a fuel hog and doesn’t have nearly as much power as the dealer claimed. My old Ford 5000 will outpull it in 2-WD.

“The tractor has a nice, roomy cab, but there’s no place to mount electronic equipment. It has a good air conditioner and the engine starts good in cold weather, but the front-end loader is bulky and hard to remove from the tractor.”

Best Buy

Ford Edge

Allen Kimball, Dover, Ark. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I’ve already put about 6,000 miles on my 2013 Ford Edge, and my only problem is figuring out how to use the many computerized gadgets on it. It has plenty of power and is reasonably fuel efficient. My wife likes it, too.

“The air-powered zip saw I bought from Harbor Freight quit working soon after I bought it. I bought another one but it quit working, too. I’ve generally had good results with Harbor Freight products, but this one is a loser.”

Best Buy

John Deere B tractor + 1 more

Ed Goff, Campbellsville, Ky. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I’ve been using my 1948 Deere B tractor for 54 years, and it’s the only tractor on my 40-acre hobby farm. I started using it in 1959 on my grandfather’s farm. Over the years we’ve owned many other tractors and even operated a Massey Ferguson dealership, but it’s the old Deere B that we kept.

“We bought a 3-pt. hitch for it, which is an excellent value, and a Pertronix kit to convert the point-style breaker distributor to electronic ignition (ph 909 599-5955; www.pertronix.com). Be sure to buy the recommended coil because your existing coil may not work with this kit. I’ve used this kit on everything from my Deere B tractor to cars from the 50’s, 60’s and 70’s.”

Best Buy

New Holland 1411 discbine + 1 more

Larry Shepler, Reynoldsville, Penn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“We traded our New Holland 1411 discbine for a 2013 New Holland 7230. The 1411 was a great machine with few problems, but it had covered a lot of acres. The 7230 just completed a full season with no problems except for a torn clip on the curtains.

“My Vicon 423T rotary hay rake does an excellent job of raking dry hay, but it won’t pick up green hay that has been run over. And if I adjust the rake to get it down to that hay, it picks up too many rocks. Another problem is the tine bars only have one bolt holding them on, and they cracked. The company made us buy an upgrade kit to solve the problem. The machine’s height adjustment keeps locking up, and the hitch pins break too easily. This discbine wasn’t built in the Vicon tradition.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 Super Duty pickup equipped + 1 more

Red Miller, Indiantown, Fla. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I like my 1999 Ford F-250 Super Duty pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter Power Stroke diesel engine. I also like my 2006 Scion XA hatchback car. Both vehicles have at least 200,000 miles on them but are still going strong. The pickup can do about anything and is strong enough to pull Texas across the country. The Scion XA gets 30 mpg and still rides as good as new.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 180 diesel

Terry Riegle, Sparta, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“My Massey Ferguson 180 diesel has about 7,600 hours on it and is my favorite tractor of all time. I bought it used in 1976. It had been overhauled that spring, and in 1977 it got a new hydraulic pump. Since then it has gone through two new clutches and the diesel pump and injectors have been cleaned once. It has also gone through 3 sets of tires and now needs a new hydraulic pump again. I test drove a new 180 in 1966 but didn’t buy one. It took me 10 years to get one and I’ll never let go of it.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman push mower equipped + 1 more

Marvin Eberly, Mt. Pleasant Mills, Penn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“My 2012 Sears Craftsman 21-in. push mower equipped with a Briggs & Stratton engine starts right up with just one or two pulls. This mower is easy to operate and seldom plugs up since I enlarged the discharge hole in the deck.

“I work on Freightliner trucks regularly and find that they’re poorly designed, with key components located in hard-to-reach areas. I’ve driven and repaired other truck brands and consider Freightliner one of the worst. Their frame rails seem to be spaced closer together, which makes anything located around the lower half of the engine difficult to access.”

Best Buy

Scaltrol SC 100 water treatment unit

Bob Muller, Delanson, N.Y. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“We have very hard water that comes from a hillside spring. It’s so hard we couldn’t even keep an automatic dishwasher in our house. Then we installed a Scaltrol SC 100 water treatment unit (ph 678 990-0858; www.scaltrolinc.com). It did such a great job that we became a dealer.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-150 pickup

Katherine Vojtko, Monongahela, Penn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“My husband and I find the navigation system on our 2012 Ford F-150 pickup to be useless. On our first trip with the vehicle we wanted to drive from Pittsburgh, Penn. to Plymouth, Mass. The navigation system instructed us to drive through the state of Maryland, but Maryland is south of Pittsburgh and clearly not in the northeasterly direction that we had to go. We never use the navigation system now, relying instead on our iPhones. Also, if we want to change our route with the Ford navigation system, we have to stop the vehicle.”

Best Buy

New Holland Boomer tractor

Paul Reinders, Brookfield, Wis. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I had a problem with the brakes on my New Holland Boomer tractor with cab. The tractor wouldn’t stop right away when the brakes were applied. I had to start braking 10 ft. or so before I needed to stop. The company couldn’t help and even their engineers had the same problem. I finally traded for a Kioti.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mantis rototiller + 2 more

Perry Hathaway, Claypool, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I’m disappointed with the 20-lb. Mantis rototiller I bought to till my wife’s raised garden beds. When going forward the tiller jumps like a rabbit. I called the company and they said to run the engine at half throttle and till pulling backward. However, the advertisements and the salesman didn’t say to till backward. Another problem is that 5-in. tall weeds wrap around the tines and build up to the point where they eventually kill the motor.

“My New Holland TN75 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a Quickie front-end loader starts poor in cold weather and has poor visibility. The controls aren’t very handy either.

“My 1984 White 2-55 front wheel assist loader tractor has more than 11,000 hrs. on it. I use it to feed cattle, handle bales, plow snow and do other loader work. It starts good in cold weather.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford Lincoln Mark LT 4-wd pickup + 1 more

Rommie B. Smith, Shelbyville, Ky. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 14

“I bought my 2006 Ford Lincoln Mark LT 4-WD pickup used in 2007 with about 26,000 miles on it. It now has about 150,000 trouble-free miles and is in excellent condition. It’s on its second set of tires and still has the original battery. It gets 18 to 22 mpg with a very comfortable ride.

“I’ve bought four Eden Pure electric heaters within the last 5 years. Each performed well for one season, but then either the thermostat or the heating unit fails. The company always says the heaters are out of warranty so I should return them to the factory for repairs at my expense.”

Best Buy

Kubota B6000 4-WD tractor

Don Mays, Michigan City, Ind. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

Don bought a used 1978 Kubota B6000 4-WD tractor for just $900 and uses it with a tiller and snow blade. “I do commercial garden tiling and this is the best tractor I’ve ever owned. It’ll tear up anything, including hard clay soil.”

Best Buy

Snapper walk-behind brush cutter

Jeff Knacht, Pine Island, Minn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

Jeff bought a used Snapper 25-in. walk-behind brush cutter equipped with a 13 1/2 hp engine. “I’ve been using it to clean up a grove of trees on our farm that has a lot of dead trees and downed wood in it. I use this machine to mow weeds and brush right up to the downed trees, and then saw up the wood and move on to the next one. I actually have fun operating it, and it does a great job.”

Best Buy

John Deere LT155 riding mower + 1 more

Levi Jefferies, Ludington, Mich. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I bought my 1998 Deere LT155 riding mower to resell and make a profit. I cleaned it up and changed the oil and blades, then sold it. The next year the buyer called and said he had mowed his 3-acre lawn once a week without a single problem. This machine was built to last.

“Our 2006 Sears Craftsman 33-in. snowblower has yet to provide one week of reliable service. It snaps shear pins in the drive and auger even when the snowblower doesn’t hit anything, and it also eats up belts. Another problem was that bolts rattled loose because they weren’t properly tightened at the factory. We replaced the shear pins with grade 8 bolts, but they still break.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 026 chainsaw equipped + 1 more

Joe Hummert, Jonesburg, Mo. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I’ve used my 2012 Stihl 026 chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar to cut more than 10 cords of wood, without a single problem. It’s easy to service and has plenty of power. I can service anything on it with one wrench. It’s a good, lightweight saw.

“The All Power 3,500-watt propane portable generator I bought at Northern Tool is my worst buy. When I put a 15-amp load on it the motor killed. By my calculations 3,500 watts equals 28 amps, so this generator doesn’t perform as advertised.”

Best Buy

Arctic Cat 500 4-WD ATV

Phil Ruble, Nebo, Ill. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“Our 2004 Arctic Cat 500 4-WD ATV was my dad’s primary farm vehicle until he passed away in June 2012. It has almost 14,000 miles on it now but has required only minor repairs. We do all the regular maintenance and use Arctic Cat synthetic oil. I only wish it had a brake on the handlebar.”

Best Buy

Case 85XT skid loaders + 1 more

Marvin Vlietstra, Kalamazoo, Mich. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

Marvin likes his 2005 and 1999 Case 85XT skid loaders. “They have a lot of hours on them but have been trouble-free. The Cummins engines in older Case skid loaders are the best ever built. These 85XT’s will easily keep pace with the much newer and larger Deere 332D skid loaders.

“We bought 2 new Deere skid loaders in 2012 – a 320D and a 332D. The 320D has required extensive work on the drivetrain – all 4 drive chains had to be replaced as well as both drive motors. The company honored the warranty, but now that it has expired I’m afraid the problems will continue. Case makes a much sturdier machine although I do like the heated cabs on the Deeres.”

Best Buy

Tafe 4-WD tractor equipped

Ed “Magnum” Force, Barbourville, Ky. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I like my 2010 Tafe 4-WD tractor equipped with a 36 hp diesel engine and hydrostatic transmission. I’m hard on equipment because I want my money’s worth. This tractor performs flawlessly, even though I’ve used it standing almost 90 degrees straight up.”

Best Buy

Jeep Patriot equipped

Mark Fielder, Webster City, Iowa · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

Mark’s 2008 4-WD Jeep Patriot, equipped with a 2.4-liter engine and 5-speed manual transmission, has more than 167,000 miles on it. “It still has the original battery, brakes, exhaust, etc., and I’ve only spent about $150 on repairs. It gets 28 to 30 mpg, doesn’t use any oil, and drives great on snow and ice. Also, it has a lifetime powertrain warranty.”

Best Buy

Kubota 2500

John Vandersluis, Mendon, Mass · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“It’s the best tractor I’ve ever owned,” says John about his 1999 Kubota 2500. “I’ve put about 1,100 hrs. on it doing such jobs as hauling wood using a winch and operating a backhoe. I’ve also used it to operate a 1,200-watt pto generator, which I ran for 3 days straight one time. It’s equipped with quick-tach brackets for mounting forks on front and back.”

Best Buy

GMC dually pickup

James R. Godwin, Dothan, Ala. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I love the 2001 GMC dually pickup I bought used. My only complaint is the door mirrors are way too small. I use this pickup to pull a livestock trailer and fifth wheel camper, and the mirrors are so small that I can’t see out past the fenders.

“A question - why don’t they attach screw jacks on front of all zero turn riding mowers?”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Massey Ferguson 135 diesel tractor + 6 more

Kelly Adams, Ladonna, Texas · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I like my Massey Ferguson 135 diesel tractor, Deere 4440 tractor, Gnuse 3-pt. mounted forklift, Honda generator, and Stihl chainsaw. They seldom break down and are easy to repair.”

On the negative side, “Hands down, our worst buy was a Staber clothes washer. It didn’t clean our clothes, and maintenance was also a problem. We had to replace the bearings, pump, a hose, pulley, belt, and motor, and we had electronic problems.

“Replacement parts for this machine are ridiculously expensive. For example, the pump is imported from Italy and the belt that drives it is one-of-a-kind and is available only from the company. Every time I call the company they accuse me of oversudsing, which seems to be the explanation for all the failures on this machine. Also, the company isn’t helpful about how to stop the machine from jumping around and making a lot of noise. Toward the end, the struts needed to be replaced; however, the frame was rotting out so instead we got rid of the machine.

“I got holes in my clothes from the very first time I used this washer. I think the door design on the basket was to blame. It was a stainless steel basket that came with a 20-year warranty, but it was already rusty after only 4 years.

“I now own a Speed Queen clothes washer which I bought used. I replaced the pump on it for $40 and the belt for $20. Best of all, now my clothes are clean again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hawkeye Co energy-free livestock waterer + 2 more

Orville E. Flagen, Ottawa, Kansas · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“The drinker on my 2009 Hawkeye Co. energy-free livestock waterer has never frozen. It’s a great waterer for cold weather. (ph 800 553-1791; www.hawkeyesteel.com).

“My Stihl MS230 chainsaw starts easy and runs great, but it takes 15 min. to fill with gas and the oil caps sometimes fall off. The chain tightener is junk and comes loose soon after I tighten the chain. I wouldn’t buy this model again.”

Greg Weaver, Shelbyville, Ind.: “I had four Exide car batteries go bad and they all had to be replaced. Fortunately, after the fourth one failed the company refunded my money.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6300 75 hp tractor + 1 more

Elmer S. Yoder, Meyersdale, Penn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

Elmer uses his 1996 Deere 6300 75 hp tractor to power his Schulte 9600 snowblower. “The tractor has more than 15,500 hrs. on it and has been repainted and had a minor tuneup; otherwise, it’s still original. It still runs good, doesn’t use oil, and starts great in cold weather. The snowblower cuts through 4-ft. high snowdrifts with no problems. Schulte snowblowers are next to indestructible.”

Worst Buy

Kioti CK30 4-WD tractor equipped

John Jamieson, Monterey, Tenn. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“No problems with my Kioti CK30 4-WD tractor equipped with a hydrostatic transmission. I use a lot of attachments with it that work well. The tractor came with a 4-year warranty plus insurance coverage for loss and damage repairs. My only complaint is that Kioti dealers around here are few and far between but are the only source for replacement filters. Common filters should be made available at auto parts stores.”

Best Buy

Troy-Bilt

John W. Flournoy, Jr., Houston, Texas · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I’ve owned several Troy-Bilt products including a riding mower, a walk-behind self-propelled mower, a small rototiller, and costs $4,850. It can be ordered for 3 by 4-ft. several weedeaters. In the past Troy-Bilt was a great brand. But all of my newer models constantly break down with just light use around our home.”

Best Buy

Claas 340 Rotocut round baler + 2 more

Shawn Gibson, Terra Alta, W. Va. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“I like my 2013 Claas 340 Rotocut round baler. I’ve used Claas round balers for years. Last year, when I was ready to update, I bought a Deere 458 Silage Special because I read that was the way to go. I made 748 bales with it. This baler was so inferior in bale quality and operator ease. I took quite a financial hit to get out of it and bought the new Claas. Now I never have to get off the tractor for any problems.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2011 Deere 6430 4-WD loader tractor with cab. “The dealer told me this tractor would outperform the 110 hp, 6-cyl. model I already owned. However, it was sluggish on the road, weak in the field, and burned 6 to 7 1/2 gal. of fuel per hour. The dealer made numerous repairs to the tractor, but after 600 hrs. I wasn’t satisfied. He gave me a decent trade on a new Deere 7330 tractor, which I do like.”