Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003)

53 reports from pages 12–15 · 44 Best Buys30 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Caterpillar Lexion 450 combine

Greg Evans, Richwood, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 12

Greg is disappointed with his 2000 Caterpillar Lexion 450 combine. “This combine may be an excellent machine, but the company doesn’t stand behind it. I complained for three years before I finally got Claas/Cat’s attention on a grain quality problem. That was supposed to be their selling point - grain quality, and one-on-one support.

“This machine has other issues as well. The preparation pans under the concave build up with soybean dust, which has to be chiseled off every morning to prevent grain loss. The company’s answer to this was to build a long-handled chisel that I could use on my $200,000 machine. Another problem was the machine’s weight. It would leave much deeper wheel ruts than our Deere 9500 running beside it. Also, grain unloading speed was very slow in comparison,. The company did make regular updates to the machine, but they didn’t want to compensate anyone for being their ‘guinea pig’. Another issue was a warranty that includes parts only, which results in a $500 service call every time we have a problem.

“All these problems were brought to the company’s attention several times and eventually I got a reaction - they wanted to sell me one of their newer models. After watching the machine depreciate at a high rate of speed, I decided to get out while the machine was still worth a little more than scrap price. I traded it in for a used Deere. The Cat/Claas dealer offered me just 50 percent of what I originally paid for the machine three years earlier toward the used green machine on their lot. It doesn’t say much for the Lexion combine when its own dealers don’t think it has any value.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere LX176 lawn tractor + 1 more

Clint Lowe, Jr., Julian, N.C. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 12

Clint isn’t happy with his 2000 Deere LX176 lawn tractor. “With Deere’s reputation for quality, I had high hopes for this tractor. However, I’ve had nothing but trouble with it. Soon after I bought it, it started running rough and required engine work. Then every few months, something else would go wrong. The steering linkage has broken twice, bearings in the mower deck had to be replaced about six months after purchase, and the deck lift handle has never worked right. There have been numerous other problems, too. The dealer has been very helpful, offering pickup and delivery whenever the tractor had to go to the shop.

“I renewed the tractor’s warranty after two years because of all the trouble I continued to have. As expensive as this tractor was, I had hoped that it would last for years without much trouble, especially during the first few years. It only has about 500 hours on it now, and it’s looking like I’ll have to replace it long before I had hoped.”

On the “best buy” side, he lists his 1984 Mercedes-Benz 300SD diesel sedan which he bought used two years ago with 580,000 miles on it. “The engine is original and has never been overhauled nor had any major work done on it. The automatic transmission was overhauled at the time I bought it. This car now has 617,000 miles on it but still runs great. Living out in the country, I have to drive 52 miles to and from work each day. The diesel engine hasn’t missed a beat since I bought the car. I wonder if it will ever quit. I change the oil every 3,000 miles and never have to add oil. It gets about 25 mpg and is an efficient car for its weight and size. The Germans really had it together with this car. I’ve had nine Mercedes Benz cars in the past, but none with as many miles as this one. In my opinion it’s the best car on the road.”

Worst Buy

Harbor Freight

Ken Scharabok, Waverly, Tenn. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 12

“I bought a ‘Nick the Grinder’ chain saw sharpener from Harbor Freight (www.harbor freighttools.com). Most commercial shops take so much off the teeth that after three sharpenings the chain saw chains are almost useless. While it may look like a toy, this is a serious piece of equipment. It’s very simple to set up and takes off only what’s required to get the chain sharp, meaning I can get several times the number of uses out of a chain versus professional sharpening. It sells on the website for $79.99. I estimate the machine will pay for itself in one season of firewood cutting.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Case 220 lawn tractor + 1 more

Andrew Abrams, Marcellus, Mich. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 12

“My 1970 Case 220 lawn tractor is my best buy. My father bought it when I was in junior high school 30 years ago and now it has been handed down to me. It’s powered by a Kohler 10 hp engine which we’ve replaced or rebuilt twice in the past 20 years. We use this tractor to mow and plow snow. The hydraulic drive won’t give up and the mower deck is still in great condition. The only weak spot was the pto clutch, which we became really good at working on. We haven’t had a problem with it for years. This tractor is great for kids to learn to drive since the directional control is right on the steering column. Why doesn’t anyone sell a tractor this well built any more?”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Black and Decker 4-in. angle grinder. “I have a foundry/fab shop and really like how these grinders work. But they won’t last more than a few months.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

1988 Deere AMT 5-wheeler powered + 2 more

Neal and Mary McCleary, Elkton, Md. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 12

“Our 1988 Deere AMT 5-wheeler, powered by a Kawasaki engine, is our worst buy. The engine needed a new starter which cost me $540 because engine parts can be purchased only from a Deere dealer - not a Kawasaki dealer. Replacement brakes for this rig are also overpriced. I won’t buy a Deere Gator equipped with a Kawasaki engine ever again.

“The Firestone 18.4 by 34 radial tires on my tractor have bulges and ride rough on hard roads. Unfortunately the company won’t replace the tires. They said the problem is caused by rusty wheel rims. I had Goodyear tires with the same problem but the company replaced two of them free of charge.

“Our 2002 Deere 926 disc mower equipped with an impeller conditioner is a best buy. It cuts fast and does a good job of conditioning. The only problem is that the windrow lever catches on everything and either falls down or breaks. We finally solved the problem by turning it around. Also, the tongue is far too long and should be shorter.”

Best Buy

Gravely walk-behind tractor

Bruce Graham, Tyler, Texas · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“My 1957 Gravely walk-behind tractor has lasting value and is one of my best buys of all time. I bought it from my father in 1977 after using it as a teenager in the late 1950’s to mow our 1 1/3-acre yard.

“When I bought the tractor, it was equipped with a 50-in. mower which I used for a number of years. The tractor had been refurbished with updated features such as electric start, a hood with lights, a remote accessory engagement lever, a riding sulky, and a paper cartridge air filter.

“I overhauled the tractor in 1988 and made quite a few modifications. I installed an oil bath air cleaner off a Volkswagen car, increased the overall drive gear ratio, reversed the carburetor mounting, added an oil pressure gauge on the left handlebar, and mounted Troybilt switches in the end of each handlebar. One was a starter switch and the other was a kill switch for the magneto.

“The tractor still has its original Gravely engine equipped with a cross-flow head. Later on I added a Dodge 383 exhaust valve equipped with a free-valve rotator mechanism of my own design. It also has an alcohol water infusion system. The magneto was recently rebuilt and is now running in top form. This tractor also is equipped with an optional dual wheel traction kit and a steering sulky that makes it very maneuverable. In 1988 I traded the mower deck in for a smaller 40-in. model. Over the years I’ve accumulated a number of attachments that are all of the original Gravely design. This tractor uses no oil and I expect it to last through my generation.”

Worst Buy

H & S hay tedder

Ellis R. Hill, Zanesville, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“Our H & S hay tedder is our worst buy. We have to replace all the teeth at least once or twice a season. Our neighbor has owned a Krone tedder for two years and says he hasn’t had to replace a single tooth. He owned an H & S model before he bought the Krone.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Bosch 24-volt saw + 1 more

Wayne Todd, Denton, Montana · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“My Bosch 24-volt saw and my Bosch 24-volt drill both work well. They have a lot of power and a long battery life per charge. Also, both tools are user friendly.

“My HTP 160 wire feed welder works erratically and is my worst buy. It’s hard to adjust the wire speed, and the amperage always seems to fluctuate. It also runs into the duty cycle limit sooner than it should. The company was helpful at first, but all their repairs and advice didn’t help much. I wish I had bought a Miller welder instead - it would have been well worth the extra cost.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota B-20 tractor equipped + 1 more

William C. Harris, Frederick, Md. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

A Kubota B-20 tractor equipped with a frontend loader and backhoe rates as William’s “best buy”. “I bought it used with only 285 hours on it. It’s a small industrial heavy duty model with a lot of power, but it’s small enough to get between trees, go up hills, and fix ponds on our 35 acres.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Polson chain saw equipped with a 20-in. bar. “It’s equipped with an automatic choke but it still starts hard.”

Worst Buy

Howse post hole digger

Gary Abernethy, Hickory, N.C. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

A Howse post hole digger rates as Gary’s “worst buy”. “The gearbox went out twice even though I had used the machine to dig only about 100 holes. The universal joint also went out. The only place I could buy a new U-joint was at a company dealer 50 miles away. But the company repaired both gearboxes. My only cost was to ship the broken gearbox back.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 946 discbine + 1 more

Douglas Wenger, Lebanon, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“My Deere 946 discbine is my best buy. It cuts close even in down hay. I flipped the knives over for the first time after cutting 500 acres. It takes only about 10 minutes to change the knives and costs $22. The cost to operate this machine is quite low.

“My Generac 3500 psi pressure washer is my worst buy. At 20 hours the pump - made by Caterpillar - blew up. Caterpillar wouldn’t warranty the pump because they said it had run out of oil. Yet I know the pump was full of oil when I started it that morning. A pair of local mechanics looked at the pieces and they both said the journals weren’t scarred and that the problem was a faulty connecting rod. Caterpillar wanted $1,200 for a new pump, yet I only paid $1,100 for the entire washer, which is equipped with a Honda engine. I ended up installing an AR pump for $500.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty pickup + 1 more

Carlton W. Sturgeon, Isle Lamotte, Vt. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

Carlton says his 2001 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty pickup equipped with an 8100 engine and a 5-speed Allison automatic transmission works great and is his “best buy”. “The engine-transmission combination on this pickup is the best I’ve ever seen. I use the pickup to haul my 21-ft. gooseneck trailer loaded with two tractors, and it has power to spare.

“My Ford F-150 pickup was one of my worst buys ever . When I left the dealer’s lot, I only got one mile down the road before the service light came on. Later, rain water poured in on the passenger side of the floor. The first winter the pickup wouldn’t start at temperatures of 20 to 25 degrees above zero. The dealer checked it out but couldn’t find any problems. When the pickup had 40,000 miles on it I traded it in for a Chevrolet with 98,000 miles, paying $500 to boot. It was the best move I ever made.”

Best Buy

Buick LeSabre + 1 more

Eldon Harvey, Ft. Pierre, S. Dak. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“I’m well pleased with my 1989 Buick LeSabre which I bought used five years ago. It has more than 320,000 miles on it and the only expense I’ve had is for new tires and a steering rod. The fuel-injected engine starts right up even at temperatures down to 35 degrees below zero. I’ve never had to add oil to the engine.

“My International Harvester 544 tractor has a carburetor with an electric shut-off. It used too much gas and finally ruined the engine. I had to spend more than $2,000 to have the engine overhauled, and after that the engine worked for only two or three months. I couldn’t use the tractor all last summer because the the company apparently doesn’t make the short needle valve any more. I’ll probably have to get a carburetor that takes the long needle valve.”

Best Buy

John Deere Model 420T tractor + 1 more

Brad Smith, Mayport, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

Brad nominates his 1956 Deere Model 420T tractor as his “best buy”. “I rescued this tractor from its previous owner. He was using it as a parts tractor so he could rebuild another one. I built a 3-pt. hitch platform for it to haul firewood, tools, dirt, bales, ear corn and my grand children. I also take this tractor to antique tractor pulls and shows.”

On the minus side, “My Black & Decker cordless cut saw has limited power and a very short battery charge. I wouldn’t buy another saw from this company.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 2500 pickup

Donald Holland, Savannah, Mo. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

“It starts and runs well, is easy to service, and has a comfortable ride,” reports Donald, pleased with his 2002 Chevrolet 2500 pickup. “I had a 1989 model that I sold before purchasing this one. It had more than 200,000 miles on it. I used nothing but ethanol in it. I also use nothing but ethanol in my 2002 model. It gets about 17 mpg and has had no problems. I like the location of the instruments.”

Best Buy

Stihl 064 chain saw

David Simpson, Elmore City, Okla. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

A 1989 Stihl 064 chain saw rates as his “best buy”. “Factory specs had the saw running at 12,500 rpm’s. I had the dealer re-tune it to 11,000 rpm’s. I run the oil/gas ratio about 45:1 instead of the factory 50:1 and use a 20-in. bar on it. There’s no telling how many cords of wood this saw has cut. I’d recommend it to anyone.”

Worst Buy

Mercedes Benz E-300 car equipped

Susan N. Kustosz, New Milford, Ct. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 13

A 1996 Mercedes Benz E-300 car equipped with a diesel engine rates as Susan’s “worst buy”. “I bought it used three years ago. The car went into ‘lock-out mode’ and wouldn’t start. It was in the shop for five weeks. It went into lock-out mode again and was in the shop for six more weeks. When I went to pick up the car at the shop it wouldn’t start, and no one in our area could get the car to start. I finally got rid of it.”

Best Buy

Ford Ranger 4-WD pickup

Harry Craft, Eagle Rock, Va. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“I’m the second owner of a 1986 Ford Ranger 4-WD pickup with more than 297,000 miles on it. I’ve spent very little money on it, and it goes like a mountain goat. I’ve owned many Ford products and never had one that didn’t far exceed my expectations.”

Best Buy

FARM SHOW is my best buy

Jim Gray, N. Cambria, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“FARM SHOW is my best buy. Over the years I’ve subscribed to many magazines, but yours has the most practical ideas, and it’s also fun to read.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado extended cab pickup + 1 more

Frazier Paugh, Palmyra, Mo. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

Frazier’s the proud owner of a Chevrolet Silverado extended cab pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine. “The extended cab comes in handy for carrying extra passengers. I didn’t think I’d like the split bench seat but I do. I also like the Duramax engine.”

On the negative side, he lists his BCS 945 garden tiller. “The tines turn forward instead of backward. As a result, we have to make an extra trip across the garden for each row we make. We wanted the tines to turn backward but were told that isn’t possible. The only good thing is that we got an electric start model which is much easier to run than a pull start.”

Worst Buy

Tree Lounge deer stand

T. Kirk, Edgerton, Mo. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“Our Tree Lounge deer stand is our worst buy. After testing it out, we think this stand is dangerous, particularly when you’re trying to climb up or down the tree. We asked for our money back, but the company refused.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Whirlpool dishwasher caught

Yvonne Trujillo, Cimarron, N. M. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“The worst buy recently submitted by M.L. Lindsay of West Monroe, La., on a Whirlpool dishwasher caught my attention. I had the same problem with my Whirlpool dishwasher not getting my dishes clean or heating the water. I found out that my water pressure was too low, which was causing the water level in the dishwasher to be so low that it affected the wash and heating cycle. Ever since I corrected this problem I have beautifully clean dishes. They might have either low pressure or a kinked hose. They can check this by opening the door when the dishwasher is in the wash cycle. If very little water is being sloshed around, that’s the problem.” 800 533-5761 or website: cut and rake hay and feed hay during the winter. I’ve also used this tractor a lot to operate a Bush Hog mower. The clutch had to be replaced twice and the water pump once. Otherswise no problems.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 637 26 1/2-ft disk

Ron McCoy, Crookston, Neb. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“My worst buy is a Deere 637 26 1/2-ft. disk that I bought new three years ago. I traded away an International 490 for it. It didn’t work right so the dealer sent a man out who worked on it all day to no avail. It still didn’t do a decent job of disking so the company sent out a trouble shooter. Unfortunately, I knew more than he did. So a year later Deere sent out two engineers from the factory. They were on the cell phone all the time they were working on it. They thought they had it fixed, but after they left it still didn’t do a decent job of disking. This disk has a 3-bar harrow on back that’s so unbalanced it eventually caused two bolts in my tractor drawbar to break. The engineers told me this disk was designed on a computer. I’ve now purchased a Sunflower disk that works great. My dealer told me the company won’t do anything else to help out.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 2500 heavy duty crew + 1 more

Terry L. Guntharp, Jonesboro, Ark. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“My 2002 Chevrolet Silverado 2500 heavy duty crew cab pickup equipped with a turbocharged diesel engine and Allison transmission is my best buy. It has about 24,500 miles and performs great. I really like the way the engine and transmission work together when hauling a load, especially when I’m driving on hills. The engine has a lot of power on take-off and runs great empty or loaded. When I first bought this pickup it got about 16 mpg. The more I drive it, the more fuel efficient it gets. I’m now getting about 20 mpg.

“I just read an your last issue about a 1996 Chevrolet Suburban that the owners had a lot of trouble with it. They said they had bought the vehicle new and had broken it in ‘gently’. In my opinion, this was the wrong thing to do. I’ve been buying new cars and trucks since 1972 and I break them in like I’m going to drive them for the rest of the vehicle’s life. I haven’t had any major problems with any of these vehicles within the first 100,000 miles. I’ve always been told you should break a vehicle in just like you’re going to drive it.

“My 1975 International Harvester 564 tractor equipped with a 6-cyl. diesel engine is a best buy. I bought it used in 1985 and have used it hard every summer since then to

Best Buy

Case-IH Maxxum 175 tractor + 2 more

Gary Lichti, Millbank, Ontario · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“We like our 2003 Case-IH Maxxum 175 tractor. It has a comfortable ride and a lot of power.

“Our 1990 Case-IH 5120 85 hp loader tractor is a best buy. We put about 13,000 hours on the first engine before we had to replace it. The new engine is still going strong.

“The Surge Westfalia automatic take-offs we use on our milk cows have performed flawlessly.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mitsubishi + 1 more

Nicholas Jansen, Coos Bay, Ore. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“My 1984 Mitsubishi (Satoh) 670D tractor equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. I bought it from a dealer who was going out of business for $7,400, and he sold me all the parts books, etc., for $10. The only problem I’ve had was an 85 cent snap ring that broke, allowing a front wheel to come off. This tractor has about 1,100 hours on it. I use it to operate a wood chipper, 60-in. tiller, post hole digger, grader blade, disc, plow, and wood splitter. I also use it for yarding logs and building roads.

“My Husqvarna 136 chain saw is my worst buy. I bought it for use around our tree farm. It came with a one-year warranty. At 16 months the motor stopped working. The dealer’s only response was that I must have sharpened the chain wrong and made it work too hard. I won’t buy another Husqvarna product again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram Dakota pickup + 1 more

John Relihan, Brunswick, Ga. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“My 1989 Dodge Dakota pickup is my best buy. After 14 years it still doesn’t use any oil.

“My 1999 Packard-Bell desk top computer is my worst buy. It never worked as it was supposed to and crashed often. It went through two power supplies in one year. The week after the warranty expired, the computer went “blue-screen”. I trashed it and bought a Dell computer.”

Best Buy

Toro 300 + 1 more

Lockwood Doench, Bethel, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

Lockwood likes his 2002 Toro 300 series Wheel Horse Classic garden tractor equipped with a 15 hp Kohler engine and 8-speed transmission. “This machine is built with quality. We use it to pull a ground-driven manure spreader and also to mow small pastures.”

On the minus side, he lists his 1997 Ford F-350 Dually pickup equipped with a 460 cu. in. engine. “At 25,000 miles the exhaust pipe deformed where it attached to the exhaust manifold, causing the oxygen sensor to have a false reading. The pickup started running badly, but the dealer said there was nothing wrong. We had a replacement pipe installed by an independent repair shop. The pipe was redesigned to prevent the problem from happening again. Too bad the dealer didn’t know how to solve this problem.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt 14.4-volt cordless drill + 1 more

Russ Zortman, Woodland, Penn. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“My 1995 DeWalt 14.4-volt cordless drill is my all-time best buy. It’s eight years old but will still drill 1/2-in. dia. holes in 1/4-in. thick plate steel. The only maintenance it ever required was a new chuck about five years ago. With just one spare battery pack, I’m ready for any drilling task on our place.

“My all-time worst buy is the Briggs & Stratton Elite series electric generator I bought last February. The first time I tried to use it, the carburetor iced up so bad the engine wouldn’t even run. When I called the toll-free help line, I was told to put the unit back inside the box and use it that way, cutting out a hole for the muffler. While this did work, it seems a strange solution. After using the unit for four months, it stopped working. I again called the help line and was given the name of the nearest warranty center. The generator sat there for two months without being repaired.

“I recently hauled the engine to another warranty center about 30 miles away and am curious how long it will be there. After several calls to the help line, I was given several excuses as to why no one will fix this generator, give me another one, or refund my money.”

Best Buy

John Deere 345 riding mower went

Vern Hillyer, Ariel, Wash. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

“In the summer of 2001, my Deere 345 riding mower went up in smoke after the engine caught fire. That fall I took delivery on a new Deere 445 garden tractor equipped with a vacuum blower and rear-mounted bags, which is my best buy. My only complaint is that I spent more time emptying the bags than I did mowing. To solve the problem I replaced the bags with a 2-ft. long by 3-ft. wide by 3 1/2-ft. high wooden box and hooked the blower up to it.

“I used 2-in. sq. tubing and angle iron to make a bracket that mounts on back of the mower. The box mounts on this bracket and is made from 1/2-in. particle board mounted inside a frame made from 1 1/2 and 2-in. angle iron. There’s a small trap door on top of the box so I can check inside from the seat. The back side of the box is hinged, and the bottom side is removable for easy cleaning. I made a 12-in. sq. extension of the blower tube that hooks up to the box and is filled in with 1/2-in. hardware cloth. I had to extend the hardware cloth down lower for better exhaust. I painted the box black and Deere green. A trailer hitch is built into the box’s frame.

“I mounted two rings on top of the box. By attaching a short chain and using an overhead hoist I can raise and lower the box onto the tractor adaptor. I also added 106 lbs. on front of the tractor.”

Best Buy

John Deere self-propelled rotary disc

Douglas Koehn, Lehigh, Kansas · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 14

Douglas is impressed with his two Deere self-propelled rotary disc mowers - a 2002 4990 model and a 2003 4995. “We use them in our custom business to cut up to 10,000 acres each year. We can cut almost 20 acres per hour at speeds up to 14 mph in the field. The disc heads and impeller conditioners require very little maintenance.”

Worst Buy

Cobalt drill bits

Mike Thompson, Edgewater, Fla. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“The Cobalt drill bits I bought from Northern Hydraulics are my worst buy. They rusted wherever I touched them and went dull almost immediately. I paid $80 for them.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

IPC spray paint + 1 more

Darrell M. Schrock, Arthur, Ill. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“IPC spray paint is my best buy. It goes on smooth and covers very well without running.

“My Hitzer coal stove is my worst buy. The top door was warped which allowed the stove to release carbon monoxide. The stove comes with a 5-year warranty, but I had to pay for a new door even though my stove was only three years old.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Zetor 3320 tractor equipped + 1 more

John Orth, Greeley, Colo. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

A 2002 Zetor 3320 tractor equipped with a 46 hp diesel engine rates as John’s “best buy”. “It has a lot of torque, uses fuel sparingly, and has a comfortable operator’s platform. Also, the tractor’s height can be changed by rotating the drop housings at each axle.

“My 1998 Sears 2-wheeled heavy duty string trimmer is my worst buy. The engine slobbers oil even when it’s not operating. It has no torque to speak of and bogs down easily. The height adjustment on the trimmer head jammed shortly after I started using the trimmer and is unusable. When the throttle hand broke off, I replaced it with a handmade wooden one that works much better.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Hardy outside wood burning + 3 more

John D. Dewell, Scio, Ohio · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“I really like my 1993 Hardy outside wood burning furnace. I had a few problems with it which the dealer promptly corrected. We use it to heat our house and it does a wonderful job. We use it to burn everything, including old tires and tubes, old round bale bags, and garbage. It burns so clean we don’t even have to pay for a garbage service. We even use it to heat our drinking water. It works for us 365 days a year. “ sockets! From now on we’ll stick with Snap-On, Sears Craftsman, or Kobalt tools.”

Best Buy

Toyota T100 2-WD pickup equipped

Duane Helgeland, Wautoma, Wis. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

Duane’s impressed with his 1996 Toyota T100 2-WD pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine. “It has more than 100,000 miles on it but still has the original clutch, battery, and exhaust system. It gets 24 mpg. We’ve used it to haul more than a ton of sand at a time. The only problem was with the air conditioner, and that didn’t happen until recently.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda string trimmer + 1 more

Douglas Meyer, Baytown, Texas · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“Our 1999 Honda 21-in. Harmony self-propelled lawn mower is our best buy. It has been maintenance-free - all we have to do is change the oil. The engine always starts on the first or second pull and runs very quiet. The mower makes a quality cut and has two modes -mulch or bag. The self-propelled ground speed can be adjusted from slow to very fast, so we can do an efficient job of mowing whether the grass is thick or thin.

“Our 2000 Honda string trimmer has a 4-cycle engine that’s easy to start and quieter than other brands, with low vibration. It has a lot of power and will take a string size of up to .105 inches. Because it has a 4-cycle engine we don’t have to mess with mixing 2-cycle gas. It’s also designed to operate in any orientation, so we can easily trim around all sorts of objects without stalling the engine. We haven’t had any problems with it.

“Our worst buy is a set of Durabuilt 1/4-in. drive sockets we bought at Target. We thought we were getting a good deal because they were 75 percent off and were made of chrome-vanadium steel. But when we tried to connect the sockets to the ratchet, they didn’t fit - not one of them. Other brand sockets will fit the ratchet, but not Durabuilt’s own located virtually anywhere in the home. Another model is designed to convert an existing fireplace into a high efficiency heating system. A gold door and side bars are available for added beauty, as are custom colors and etched glass. We liked this stove so much that we became a dealer.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DR mower + 1 more

Robert G. Adams, Humboldt, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“My 2001 DR mower is my worst buy. The string disintegrates whenever it touches cement. I don’t use it any more.

“My two Monarch steel bins are my best buys, with a qualification. The dealer told me these bins were built like battleships, and they are except for the roofs. To save himself a few dollars the dealer didn’t put on the heavy roof but instead substituted a paper-thin roof. We had to add extra rims on top of both roofs to strengthen them so they won’t blow off. The dealer is retired now, and the new owners of the business no longer handle Monarch bins.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears 19.2-volt drill + 1 more

Terry D. Long, Thornton, Iowa · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

Terry’s disappointed with his 2003 Sears 19.2-volt drill. “I used it last June to secure the tin on a storage building that we own. In the process, I had to return the drill four times to get it replaced. In each case the transmission in the drill had stripped the gears. Sears was very helpful each time I came in. I’ve now purchased a DeWalt drill and haven’t had any problems with it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mastercraft 9.6-volt cordless drill + 1 more

Wayne Sabine, Tilley, New Brunswick · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“My Mastercraft 9.6-volt cordless drill is my best buy. I received it as a gift a few years ago and have hardly pounded a nail since then. It’s probably the most useful and versatile tool I own.

“My Carraro 1200 round baler is my worst buy. I bought the first baler in this area from our local Belarus dealer. The dealer spent a lot of time with me trying to get it to work properly. However, he doesn’t seem to get a lot of support from the company. I was able to make only about 1,000 bales before I had to replace the gearbox and clutches at a cost of more than $3,000. The company couldn’t tell the dealer how to take the machine apart.

“Whenever I buy a new piece of equipment I try to buy the shop manual for it. With this baler, all I could get, besides a very basic operator’s manual, was a parts book. It appears the dealer can’t get a shop manual, either. Another company has taken over Carraro and it’s now called Galiani. From what I can find out it’s essentially the same baler.”

Worst Buy

Ram 1500 4-WD pickup

Murray Engle, Wagoner, Okla. · Vol. 27, No. 6 (2003), p. 15

“My 1999 Dodge 1500 4-WD pickup is my worst buy. It rides so rough that I can feel each tar strip on the highway. The transmission failed completely at 7,000 miles and was rebuilt by the dealer. However, I’m still afraid to go very far from home with this pickup.”