Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004)

83 reports from pages 12–15 · 74 Best Buys27 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

EZ Foot Pedal Starter

Marie Blocher, Mesquite, Texas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

Marie recently installed an EZ Foot Pedal Starter on her lawn mower and says it’s her “best buy” (Step Start Corp., Monroeville, Ala. ph 334 356-4860; www.stepstart.com). The foot pedal starter was previously featured in FARM SHOW’s Vol. 28, No. 2. The unit fits most walk-behind mowers without a rear bagger and attaches to the mower handle with four adjustable clamps. Once attached to the mower, the cord is never pulled by hand. To start the mower you simply step on a pedal.

“Not many products these days come with everything you need for installation, but this one does, right down to the tie-wrap that holds the spark plug wire,” says Marie. “I like it because I don’t have to rely on friends or neighbors to start my mower for me. Like most seniors, I want to keep doing as much as I can for myself as long as I can. The exercise I get pushing my mower keeps me from losing any more of my fitness and strength as I age.”

Worst Buy

Small Engine Warehouse

Jerry M. Cloyd, Hopkinsville, Ky. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

“My worst buy is a replacement engine for my Deere lawn tractor that I bought from Small Engine Warehouse in Dunkirk, Ind. The engine wasn’t too difficult to install, but I couldn’t find the right threaded bolt that’s needed to attach the electric clutch to a shaft. I even tried using metric bolts, but nothing worked.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Royal silage corn + 1 more

Wayne Braun, Durant, Iowa · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

“My worst buy was Royal silage corn from Graziers Supply. There were a lot of cracked and damaged kernels in the bag, that didn’t germinate. As a result, even though I had a planted population of 25,000 seeds per acre my actual stand was only about 18,000 plants per acre. The stalks reached a height of only about 6 ft. and weren’t girthy at all. Also, they were goosenecked and had poor root growth. Because of the poor results of this corn variety, I was forced to chop a normal corn variety for silage. I actually got about 25 percent more tonnage off the normal variety even though it wasn’t bred for high silage yields. Both varieties were planted the same day, and under identical circumstances. When I called the company they told me I was the only one to complain and that they’d get back to me, but they never did.”

Jeanne and Steen Frederiksen, ph 205 594-5971). It does a great job. Cattle

Best Buy

Wicks digital thermometer + 2 more

Redwater, Alberta · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

“We like our Wicks digital thermometer, which we use to check the cows in our herd (Professional Equipment, Inc., Hauppauge, N.Y. ph 800 334-9291; www.professionalequipment.com). It delivers a 10-second readout, which is fast enough that we can check more animals and also catch problems earlier than we could before. It sells for about $15 (Canadian).

“We’re pleased with our Ford New Hol-land 8360 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a Quicke 980 front-end loader. In my opinion, Quicke is the only loader that’s designed better than a Deere loader.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet hydrostat riding mower

R.L. Sellars, Bolton, Miss. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

R.L. nominates his 1997 Cub Cadet hydrostat riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck as his “best buy.” “I use it to mow five acres of lawn. It requires only minimal maintenance and after seven years of hard use is still going strong. I changed the bearings in the deck when the machine was four years old, and I also replaced the battery.

“In 1995 I bought a used 1967 Cub Cadet for $900. I used it for three years and liked it so much that I bought the above new model in 1997. I sold the 1967 model to my uncle for $600, and he’s still using it.”

Best Buy

International Harvester Farmall 856 diesel tractor

Hal D. Stephens, Solomon, Kansas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

Hal likes his 1969 International Farmall 856 diesel tractor, which he bought used. “I bought it when I switched from using a small square baler to a big round one and needed more power. This tractor never fails to start. It does a good job of handling all my equipment.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1998 Sears string-type weed trimmer. “From the beginning, this weed trimmer would run for only 20 to 30 minutes before it would quit. I had to wait for it to cool down, and even then it was hard to start. I returned the trimmer to the company service center five different times before I finally gave up on it. It’s still setting in my shed. However, I’ve had good luck with other Sears products.”

Best Buy

Buick LeSabre

Samuel Draper, Fontana, Calif. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

“We like our 1992 Buick LeSabre. We bought it used two years ago at 97,000 miles and it has been trouble-free. On a 1,000-mile trip it got 30 mpg without using a drop of oil. It’s a best buy.”

A 1998 Electra Beckum electric pressure washer sold by Harbor Freight rates as his “worst buy.” “Right after I bought it the trigger on the wand broke. Then the machine quit working completely.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 790 compact tractor equipped + 1 more

Harmon Lindesmith, Waurika, Okla. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 12

Harmon’s impressed with his 2001 Deere 790 compact tractor equipped with a front-end loader and 72-in. finish mower. “It’s an excellent performer in every way and has been trouble-free. This is my first small tractor. I expected it to work good since I’ve been using big Deere equipment for 40 years with great success.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists a pair of 2002 Cadillac Seville SLS cars. “They’re the worst cars I’ve ever owned. The engines knocked so badly I had to replace the pistons. The wipers quit working, the bearings on the steering shaft went bad, and I had to replace the steering rack assembly, heaters in the seats, and window motors. The power seats and power tilt steering wheel also quit working.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 Hemi Ram equipped + 1 more

Boneta Zeimetz, Mondovi, Wis. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“It’s the best pulling pickup I’ve ever owned,” says Boneta, owner of a 2004 Dodge 1500 Hemi Ram equipped with a 345 hp engine. “I use it to pull a trailer.”

On the minus side, “My 2000 Ford F-150 pickup was recalled for engine problems. Then the transmission went out. Ford had to recall 1.3 million trucks made from 1999 to 2000 because of head and gasket leaks on the engine. Some engines were so bad they had to be destroyed.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Lincoln Continental + 2 more

Tom Mack, Westville, Ind. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“My all-time worst buy was my 1997 Lincoln Continental. In the three years I owned it, I had to take it back to the dealer for repairs at least 20 times. The worst problems were with the engine mis-firing and leaking oil, but there were also problems with the transmission, rear end, suspension system, computer, and interior trim. I traded the car after the warranty expired because I couldn’t afford to keep it any longer.

“My 1992 Ford Taurus was another worst buy. The head gasket blew out at about 40,000 miles, the transmission failed at 50,000 miles, and the entire air conditioning system had to be replaced three times. So much for the company’s motto ‘fix it once, fix it for life.’ It cost me about $1,000 every time I took the car in for repairs.

“My 1998 Cadillac Deville is my best buy. It hasn’t been back to the dealer even once for repairs. I did replace the battery after four years, but that’s normal maintenance. I love this car.”

Worst Buy

Sears Craftsman 4 1/2-in industrial grinder

Ben F. Reeves, Fountain, Colo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“My worst buy was a Sears Craftsman 4 1/2-in. industrial grinder. The first wheel wasn’t even worn out before sparks started blowing out of the motor, so I took it back to the dealer. However, they said they couldn’t pay to have the motor repaired because I didn’t have an extended warranty. That was never mentioned when I bought the machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet 1-ton truck + 2 more

Bill Peacher, Laclede, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“The 454 engine is the only good thing on this truck,” says Bill about his “worst buy” 1980 Chevy 1-ton truck that he nevertheless is still driving at 250,000 miles and counting. “I’ve had to put in 18 different clutch pressure plates and overhaul the 4-speed transmission eight times. The rear brakes never did work right, the driver door fell off three times, the speedometer failed five times, the differential failed twice, and the front end failed three times. The engine went 191,000 miles before the crankshaft broke.

“My best buy is my 1997 Dodge 3500 4-WD pickup equipped with a V-10 engine and 5-speed transmission. It has more than 106,000 miles on it and pulls a big load. With a backhoe or trencher loaded the total weight is more than 28,000 lbs. I haven’t had any problems with the transmission or clutch. Also, it’s very fuel efficient.

“I like my 1992 Dodge Dakota equipped with a V-6 engine, and my 1999 Dodge 1500 pickup equipped with a 318 cu. in. engine. Both models are fuel efficient. I think Chrysler has an exceptional warranty, which is one of the reasons my next vehicle will again be a Dodge.”

Best Buy

Case 4894 4-WD tractor + 1 more

Dan Gray, Dewberry, Alberta · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

Dan’s impressed with his 1984 Case 4894 4-WD tractor. “It’s equipped with a diesel engine that runs smooth and is fuel efficient, and with an electric-over-powershift transmission that has worked flawlessly. I like the relative simplicity of older tractors, and I think the company got this model pretty much right.”

Dan says he’s also well pleased with Milligan Canola-based diesel fuel additive (Milligan Bio-Tech, Inc., Foam Lake, Sask., Canada ph 306 272-6284; www.milliganbiotech.com). The company’s website says the product can result in up to a 13 percent increase in fuel efficiency, and up to a 50 percent decrease in engine and injection pump wear.

Best BuyWorst Buy

Landini tractors + 1 more

William Richter, Erie, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“We’re well satisfied with our six Landini tractors, which we use in our vineyard. We especially like the 6530 F model, which has more than 8,000 hours on it. The engine has never been touched except for the injectors. Our two newest models are a 70 F and an 80 F. They’re both 4-WD and work great except for problems we’ve had with the electronic dash, which our dealer is working on.

“Our Drill Doctor is our worst buy. We had a hired person use it to sharpen drill bits. It took a long time to sharpen the bits, and after about twenty 3/8-in. bits had been sharpened we were informed the wheel was worn out and had to be replaced. Now we’re looking for someone to sell this lemon to.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-350 extended cab + 1 more

Richard Francis, Moundsville, W. Va. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

Richard is disappointed with his 2003 Ford F-350 extended cab, longbed 4-WD pickup. It’s equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine and a 5-speed automatic transmission. “The problem is that it isn’t very fuel efficient. I can drive it at 70 miles per hour with the engine running at 2,000 rpm’s, but it still won’t average more than 17 mpg. It has about 12,000 miles on it, with about half of those miles on the freeway and without pulling a load. My 1990 heavy duty Dodge 250 4-WD pickup has about 150,000 miles on it but still gets more than 20 miles per gallon.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3100 4-WD tractor equipped

Ronald Headley, Georgetown, Ky. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“I really like my Kubota L3100 4-WD tractor equipped with a Kubota front-end loader. I use the loader to dig building foundations. It has a lot of power for a small tractor and outperforms most other small tractors. And, with 4-WD it has a lot of traction.”

Best Buy

Toro lawn mower

James C. Doughty III, Farmington, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“Our ‘personal pace’ Toro 22-in. lawn mower is our best buy. It’s easy to start which my wife appreciates. It bags, mulches, and discharges out the side. The bag is easy to empty out without having to be shaken, so I don’t have to wear myself out.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere Sabre riding mower equipped + 1 more

Timothy Locke, Bremen, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

A 2002 Deere Sabre riding mower equipped with a 17 hp engine and 48-in. deck rates as Timothy’s “best buy.” “It cuts better than any other mower I’ve owned. I replaced the battery, but otherwise it has required only routine maintenance.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2003 Troybilt walk-behind weed trimmer. “If you try to use it on anything other than flat ground it’ll cut down into the dirt, which causes it to use up massive amounts of string.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped

John Blanque, Franklinton, La. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

A 2002 Sears Craftsman garden tractor equipped with a 23 hp engine and 48-in. deck rates as John’s “best buy.” “I use it to cut 15 acres and it never causes any problems. I also use it to pull up to 1,000 lbs. of firewood on an old airport luggage cart. I bought it with an extended warranty, which was cheaper and better than what Home Depot and Lowe’s were offering with their garden tractors.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 2210 lawn tractor equipped

Larry Vink, Topeka, Kansas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

Larry isn’t satisfied with his 2003 Deere 2210 lawn tractor equipped with a 5-ft. deck. “The problem is the deck won’t stay level after I set the 3-pt. hitch. As a result, every time I back up with an implement the turnbuckles on the 3-pt. bind. I removed the turnbuckles and put chains on the 3-pt., which solved the problem. “

Best Buy

Hummer + 1 more

Richard “Red” Guthrie, Early, Texas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“My 2003 Hummer is an excellent truck, but dealer service has been worse than poor. I wrote a certified letter to the general manager but never got a response. Three trips of 300 miles each to the dealer did no good so I made my own repair and sent the dealer the bill with a threat that I’d publish the story if they didn’t pay for my expenses. They did. The stainless steel exhaust system leaks at the welds. The wiring for the reverse setting on the video camera burned out due to improper installation. Other things got warrantied only after threats by my attorney.

“I use my Deere Gator 4 by 6 every day on our farm and kennel. It’s a great machine, but Deere won’t recognize the engine warranty. It’s a very extensive warranty that’s twice as long as the Deere warranty. However, the engine has been tuned up three times and I’ve always had to pay for parts and labor, even after I pointed out the problems were clearly covered by the warranty.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet heavy duty pickup + 1 more

Francis Remsik, Marysville, Wash. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 13

“I like my 2001 Chevrolet heavy duty pickup equipped with an 8.1-liter engine and Allison transmission.

“I also like my 2003 Amana upright freezer. Both the pickup and the freezer are running flawlessly, so far.”

On the “worst buy” side, “I had problems with the limited slip differential on my 1993 Chevrolet pickup.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4020 tractor

Nancy C. Hainline, Springfield, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My 1965 Deere 4020 tractor is my best buy. It had problems with the ignition starter, hydraulics, and radiator. Overall, though, it’s my favorite workhorse for work on hills and for hauling big bales. I wish the accelerator shifter wasn’t located between the dash and the steering wheel. It can be scary if you accidentally bump it while driving on hillsides. Sometimes the tractor dies and then the brakes and power steering quit working.”

Worst Buy

Snapper riding mower

Mahlon Wright, Schuyler Falls, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My 2001 Snapper riding mower is my worst buy. This mower works more like a dozer blade than a mower. It rusted so bad that all the paint fell off. This year the engine started, but then as soon as I let off the brake it stalled. I fixed that problem only to find that once I got the engine going, the mower deck stalled. The only way it would run is if I took the switch out of the socket and let it hang.”

Best Buy

Tornado performance booster + 1 more

Mark S. Cappalella, Alamogordo, N. Mex. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Mark likes his Tornado performance booster which he uses on a pair of Dodge pickups - a 1988 D-250 equipped with a 5.2-liter V-8 engine and a 1995 Dakota equipped with a 3.9-liter, V-6 engine (ph 800 603-4383; in Canada 800 553-1872). “The stainless steel booster installs inside the air intake of electronically fuel-injected vehicles. It creates a swirling motion, forcing air around corners and bends and through intakes. According to the company the product causes your engine to burn fuel cleaner, faster and more completely for greater power and fuel economy. It’s said to increase mileage 7 to 24 percent and results in a 4 to 13 hp increase. “This product caused both my vehicles to show improvement in performance and economy. With fuel prices soaring, it’s a big help,” says Mark.

He also likes his Fuel Boss magnetic fuel saver (ph 800 603-4383; in Canada 800 553-1872; website: www.jcwhitney.com). “It helps my 1963 Chevy run smoother and cleaner,” says Mark.

Best BuyWorst Buy

Royal Purple synthetic oil + 1 more

W.M. Goolsby, Auburn, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

He likes Royal Purple synthetic oil (Royal Purple, Ltd., ph 888 382-6300 or 281 354-8600; www.royalpurple.com). “I started using this oil on a trial basis eight years ago in such machines as my truck, tractor, and lawn mower. It has proven itself in lowering friction in both gas and diesel engines. I get better mileage on gas engines and more hours on my tractor cutting brush. Plus, I don’t have to change oil as often.

“My 2003 Sears Craftsman leaf blower is my worst buy. It worked okay the first couple of times I used it, but then it started having problems. I always run the gas out of 2-cycle engines before I put them in storage. When I got the blower out to use it last spring, it wouldn’t crank. It has only about two hours of running time on it.”

Worst Buy

Toyota Tundra pickup

Dave Hudson, Springfield, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My worst buy was my 2000 Toyota Tundra pickup. I had to spend a lot of money on repairs in the three years that I owned it. The starter went out ($350); the electric switch for the 4-WD went out ($365); the horn relay went out. Also, a serpentine belt had to be replaced at a cost of $70. Of course, these problems all happened right after the warranty expired. The pickup averaged only 15 mpg.”

Best Buy

Alo Quicke front-end loader

Robert D. Geer, Jr., Ledyard, Ct. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My Alo Quicke front-end loader is my best buy. I bought it to mount on my Massey Ferguson 263 4-WD tractor. The loader can be taken off or put on in only two to three minutes. It came equipped with a quick tach bucket and optional soft drive that allows the loader arms to ‘float’ during road travel or field use, easing fatigue on both the tractor and the operator.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Grizzly branded + 1 more

Mark Vimont, Independence, Ore. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My worst buys are 9 by 1/8-in. grinder discs from Grizzly, branded ‘CWA’ which stands for Camel Wheel Abrasives. This product is made in Israel. The discs visibly wore down while I was cutting a rusty barrel. By contrast, CAI grinder discs made by Enco in Plattsville, Ontario, work great. (Enco, Fernley, Nevada 89408; ph 800 965-5857; www.use-enco.com).

Best Buy

John Deere 6110L 65 hp tractor

Roger Lamont, Owen Sound, Ontario · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Roger nominates his 2000 Deere 6110L 65 hp tractor as his “best buy.” “It’s my only tractor. I use it to do everything on our farm, plus to do custom work. It always starts easy and has a fast hydraulic flow for loader work. It’s also easier to maintain than other tractors I’ve owned in the past. One problem is that the anti-sway blocks and support hang down 1 1/2 in. lower than the drawbar support and catch on rocks and tree stumps, etc. Lock pins on telescopic draft links are almost impossible to use during the winter for mounting a snowblower. I removed them and made my own more simple locks. Another problem is that it’s difficult to see the draw-bar from the tractor seat. Also, I wish it shifted more smoothly.”

Best Buy

Captivator® Fly Trap

Wayne Dorsett, Kirkland, Wash · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“I just love my Captivator® Fly Trap because it works so well. I’ve found that it’s easy to get the reusable half-gal. jar 2/3 full of flies in about a month. They pack down as time goes by. This product is manufactured by Farnam Horse Products (www.Farnam.com). I used their fly bait paste with water as the attractant. It uses fly pheromones to attract the flies and really works great. It’s sure better than chasing them with a fly swatter!”

Best Buy

Bombardier Sport 650 ATV

R.W. Ballard, Show Low, Arizona · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My 2002 Bombardier Sport 650 ATV is my best buy. I bought it used with 44 miles on it. I paid $8,000 for it and the trailer it was on, plus a small garden cart. It has a lot of power and torque. We use it with a winch to move burned trees as well as boulders, and it never skips a beat. We use it almost every day. It’s the best money we’ve ever spent.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota BS22 lawn tractor equipped + 1 more

W. LeClair, Francestown, N.H. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My Kubota BS22 lawn tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower deck is my best buy. It runs great and is fuel efficient and easy to maintain. It also does a nice, clean job of cutting grass. It’s a durable machine.

“My Woodmizer LT 70 sawmill constantly required repairs and is my worst buy. I expected a better product for the $40,000 I spent on it. Every time I try to use it a new problem comes up.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 5420 2-WD 65 hp + 1 more

Bill Miller, Jackson, Miss. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Bill’s happy with his 2002 Deere 5420 2-WD, 65 hp tractor. “This is my second Deere 5000 series tractor. My other one was a 5400. The 5420 has an improved operator station which is isolated from the frame. It has a comfortable ride, is easy to operate, is built strong, and has been trouble-free. I’ve never had a bad experience with a Deere product. I also like my Deere MX10 cutter and a 2003 Deere 4310 MFWD compact utility tractor.

“My 2001 Troy-Bilt 6 hp Econo-Horse tiller is my worst buy. It has less than 10 hours on it. The gearbox pulley and drive gear went out. I also had problems with the carburetor. I put two floats in the carburetor before I finally gave up and installed a complete new carburetor. It’s equipped with a Tecumseh engine, but I think another brand would work better.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford 5000 tractor + 1 more

Coy Woodall, Calvin, Okla. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My 1973 Ford 5000 tractor has been used, misused, and abused but, like the old Timex watches, it just keeps on ticking. I’ve spent very little money on it. I wish I could buy a new tractor exactly like this one.

“My 2002 Chevrolet Silverado 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 6-liter, V-8 engine is my worst buy. It has no pulling power, gets stuck easy, and wanders all over the road.”

Best Buy

John Deere 445 garden tractor

Rich Vink, Topeka, Kansas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Rich likes his 2001 Deere 445 garden tractor. “In my opinion, the Deere name still stands for dependability and resale value. I’ve owned four Deeres over the years and will always be a Deere person. This tractor could use improvements to the power steering system, and the 22 hp fuel-injected Kawasaki engine drinks fuel. Another problem is the spark plug boots rub on the engine compartment panels.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sears Craftsman LED flashlight + 1 more

Dick Combs, Worth, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My Sears Craftsman LED flashlight is my best buy. It’s made from stainless steel and rubber and has five bulbs. The ‘on’ button has three settings - bright, brighter, and brightest. It uses four AA batteries, and the first ones I put in months ago are still going strong. It’s a handy, durable flashlight.

“My Cub Cadet 7254 lawn tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower deck is my worst buy. I first time I started it, the belt came off after I went only about 100 ft. I put the belt back on but the same thing happened again. There have also been other problems.”

Best Buy

Rodenator Pro

P. Van Pelt, Rushford, Minn. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My Rodenator Pro does a great job of getting rid of pocket gophers and woodchucks (Meyer Industries, Midvale, Idaho ph 800 750-4553). I’ve used it this year on more than 300 acres of hay and beans and have virtually eliminated these critters for good. Dealer service has been great. Two years before I bought the Rodenator I had purchased a Rodex 4000. However, I experienced nothing but mechanical failures with it and also got the run-around from the company. So I traded the Rodex in for the Rodenator Pro and am glad I did.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Murray MTD riding mowers + 2 more

Charlie Bratton, Albuquerque, N. Mex. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Charlie’s impressed with his three Murray MTD riding mowers. “These machines are well-built and easy to maintain. They’re equipped with Tecumseh engines which require very little maintenance. Parts for them are readily available.

“I own three Ford Ranger pickups - years 1987, 1996, and 1999 - and they’re all best buys. They’re dependable, fuel efficient, and well-built.

“My Ryobi 18-volt cordless drill is my worst buy. The problem is that the chuck doesn’t hold the bits tight. Also, the batteries lose their charge too soon.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight

Steve Nelson, Winston-Salem, N.C. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

Steve likes his Harbor Freight 1-in. SDS rotary hammer drill. “I was installing an automatic lift on my garage door and burned out a 1/2-in. hammer drill. Then I bought the Harbor Freight drill. It does an awesome job, and I was able to buy it on sale for only $65. I recommend buying a model that both rotates and hammers.”

Best Buy

Allis-Chalmers G tractor

Bradley Moore, Krypton, Ky. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 14

“My 1948 Allis Chalmers G tractor is my best buy. I bought it from my brother in 1980. I’ve used this little tractor to mow hay and brush, as well as to plow and cultivate. It has been used in some places where other 4-wheeled tractors couldn’t go - up steep mountain sides to a garden, and down steep hills and banks to a small bottom land garden that required winching the tractor back up to the top again. It has the same rear tires my dad put on it in 1966. It’s a dependable tractor.”

Best Buy

Case 110 tractor equipped

Arnold D. Ross, Webber, Kansas · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

Arnold nominates his 1999 Case 110 tractor equipped with a front-end loader as his “best buy.” “It’s a real joy to operate and doesn’t use much fuel. Also, the loader is easy to take off and put on. It has a powershift transmission. We had to replace the power shift relays which the company paid for. I’d buy another one of these tractors in a minute.”

Best Buy

Nissan Sentra car equipped

David Karl, Montrose, Colo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My 1994 Nissan Sentra car equipped with a 1.6-liter engine and standard transmission, which I bought used with 109,000 miles on it, is my best buy. I’m retired and deliver papers as a part time job, and I drive about 600 miles per week so fuel is a big expense for me. Fortunately, this little car gets 48 mpg.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped + 1 more

Charles Lipsett, Harmony, Maine · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My 1982 Chevrolet 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine and automatic overdrive transmission is my worst buy. It went through many transmissions, four sets of heads, three injector pumps, and an untold number of starters and batteries. I’ll never own another Chevy. I gave it away and now own a Dodge pickup.”

Best Buy

Farmall Cub tractor

Everett W. Gustafson, Brockway, Penn. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My 1948 Farmall Cub tractor is my best buy. I still use it regularly. It has a nicer, smoother running engine than all my other small tractors. All I do is walk up to it, check the oil and gas, and maybe check the radiator once in a while. There’s no hood to open. Then I just get on it and go to work.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland 1495 self-propelled haybine equipped + 2 more

Randy Brooks, Peterstown, W. Va. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“It works fast and does a great job,” says Randy, pleased with his 1980 New Holland 1495 self-propelled haybine equipped with a 12-ft. head. “I’m able to cut 15 acres with it in only two hours.

“My New Holland L775 skid steer loader is a best buy.

“My Vermeer 605C round baler is my worst buy. If the hay is a little green or wet, it clogs up in the baler’s front corners.”

Best Buy

Yanmar 27 hp 4-wd

Mike Talbott, Riverton, Wyo. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My 1988 Yanmar 27 hp, 4-WD tractor, which I bought used, is my best buy. It has a 3-cyl. diesel engine and 4-speed pto, with nine forward speeds and three reverse. It has so much traction that in first gear and low gear it’ll climb a tree. I’ve put 300 trouble-free hours on it.”

Best Buy

Forrester

John R. Carlson, Harrison, Maine · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“Last February I bought a Kioti 40 hp front wheel assist tractor and also a self-loading log trailer called the Metavic. Both the tractor and the log hauler are sold together as a unit called the Forrester, and it’s my best buy (Payeur Distributions, Inc., Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada ph 802 467-1055; www.payeur.com).

“The company strips the Kioti tractor down and armor plates everything that could be affected by working in the woods. The tractor has an expanded metal grill on the front and sides, with steel plates protecting the underside. Both sides are hinged and secured with lynch pins, allowing me to swing them out for access to the engine. A small hydraulic-operated blade on front can be used to level off trails in the woods. The blade can be folded over the hood in wooded areas. A ROPS protects the operator, and there’s a metal shelf on one side for storing my chain saw, fuel, etc. Tire chains can be used during the winter.

“The trailer is equipped with side stakes and can handle logs up to 12 ft. long. To operate the controls, the operator stands on an expanded metal stand that mounts on the hitch, so he doesn’t have to get on the tractor to load a log. The boom supports a 360 degree rotating grapple and a hydraulic winch with 110 ft. of cable, which allows me to park on a road and drag trees out of the ditch for loading. If I want, I can use the grapple to hold a log up for cutting without even having to bend over. The company also offers several options for the Metavic, including a tilting platform for transporting your tractor, firewood or other items; a dumper bed; and a backhoe excavating arm.

“I paid $36,950 for the entire unit, which was was delivered to my farm. I bought it after watching other units operate in our area. I’m 78 years old and I hope this unit will let me work for many more years in the woods.”

Best Buy

New Idea 5209 disc mower + 2 more

Walter Pinkowski, Jr., Argyle, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My New Idea 5209 disc mower is my best buy. The machine I have was the company’s first prototype and was used for demonstrations. I use it to cut about 450 acres of hay every year. I replaced a long shaft that drives the discs, and I replaced the turtles and shields once. My only complaint is that the hitch should be built heavier.

“Our 1998 Massey Ferguson 283 tractor equipped with an Alo front-end loader is a best buy.”

Worst Buy

Polaris 700 Sportsman ATV

John Westerhoff, Alexandria, Neb. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

John’s unhappy with his 2004 Polaris 700 Sportsman ATV. “I bought it after I took my 1995 Polaris 425 Magnum in last December for some work and they made me a deal on a new Sportsman. The machine had only 39 hours on it last June when I was driving through the woods and was suddenly engulfed in smoke, with flames bursting out around my legs. Fortunately, I was only about a half mile from home so I drove as fast as I could up to a water hydrant and put the fire out.

“Then I loaded the machine on a trailer and took it to the dealer. He said the fire happened because the valve cover gasket had blown out and oil had run down on the exhaust manifold and caught fire. They replaced the gasket, but when they went to put water in the radiator it leaked out. Neither the dealer nor the company would stand behind the damaged radiator. The only item they would cover under warranty was the gasket. I know the radiator wasn’t damaged before the fire happened because a 4-wheeler simply wouldn’t have run without water in the radiator.

“I had a bad feeling about my purchase after I read a FARM SHOW report about someone else who had a similar experience. I definitely wouldn’t buy another Polaris again and am telling all my neighbors to stay away from them.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Massey Ferguson 1040 diesel tractor equipped + 3 more

Ray Bulthuis, Ramona, Calif. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“I’m well satisfied with my 1985 Massey Ferguson 1040 diesel tractor equipped with a Massey Ferguson 232 front-end loader. And I like my 1998 Deere 425 garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck. Both tractors are well-built and have required only routine maintenance.”

On the minus side, “The transmission on my 2001 Ford Escape failed at 51,000 miles. It happened when I was 250 miles from home and after the warranty had expired. The transmission cost $3,300 to repair and was at the dealer for 2 1/2 weeks. I also had to spend $400 on a rental car while the vehicle was in the shop. I immediately replaced the Ford with a 2003 GM Envoy, which I really like. However, just in case anything goes wrong I bought it with an extended 100,000-mile warranty.”

Best Buy

Northern Tool Co

Ed Gibson, Santa Cruz, Calif. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“The hydraulic log splitter I bought from Northern Tool Co. is a great machine, but the shipping and handling charge cost me about one third the total price of the machine. I should have bought it from a local dealer.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Yanmar 2220D 4-WD compact diesel tractor + 2 more

Randal Hatcher, Spanishburg, W. Va. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

A 1990 Yanmar 2220D 4-WD compact diesel tractor rates as Randal’s “best buy.” “The diesel engine has a lot of power and is economical to operate. It starts as easy as a gas engine, even in winter. This tractor has been trouble-free and is a good machine.

“My 2002 MTD Yard Machine lawn tractor equipped with an 18 1/2 hp engine is my worst buy. Five minutes after I first tried to use it, it started falling apart. The variable-drive unit has fallen off three times, the pulleys on the deck have fallen off twice, the differential came loose, the front axle wore out, and the cowl broke after it worked loose. This machine is described as a garden tractor, but in my opinion it doesn’t even qualify as a lawn mower.

“My Simplicity bandsaw mill is a worst buy. It’s designed better than a Woodmizer and has a solid frame, but the construction work on it is terrible. It’s badly welded and the blade guides don’t work. To fix the problem, the guide mounts will have to be cut off and new ones fabricated. Also the drive belt rubs the exhaust on the engine, causing premature wear. In my opinion, you’d be much better off building your own sawmill, or paying the extra money for a Woodmizer or Norwood model.”

Worst Buy

Makita 4 1/2-in grinder hard

James A. Helleso, Las Vegas, Nevada · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“I use my 1996 Makita 4 1/2-in. grinder hard for welding projects, but it never fails to keep going.

“My 2003 Harbor Freight 9-in. grinder is my worst buy. After the first few hours I used it, ‘white stuff’ started coming out and it soon quit working. The warranty had expired so it wasn’t worth fixing. I learned my lesson - always buy quality tools.”