Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012)

80 reports from pages 12–15 · 76 Best Buys10 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Qwicktie bale tie system

Cliff Bennett, Baldonnel, B.C. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“I have ordered numerous products I’ve read about in FARM SHOW over the years and have been very satisfied. However, I have had a very bad experience with a Qwicktie bale tie system from Qwicktie, LLC in Scotland, S. Dak. We talked on the phone many times and I agreed to order two sets of their baler twine tie arms and sent a check that cleared my bank soon after. Since then, all attempts to reach the company have failed for the past 5 months. I would caution anyone from dealing with this company and, in general, only send payment C.O.D.”

Best Buy

Honda Rancher ES ATV + 1 more

Steve Carey, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“This might be a great putt-around vehicle but it was not made for a rancher in the mountains,” says Steve about his 2006 Honda Rancher ES ATV. “The body kept shifting, with many fasteners falling out multiple times. The engine cuts out going up steeper hills, it doesn’t have the power to pull a small trailer, and we had to replace the starter, the rear brakes, and the shifting is rough. Also, the choke sticks at random.”

On the positive side, he likes his Case IH Maxxum 125 tractor. “It’s equipped with the 6.7 Cummins and has all the power needed on a working ranch. It pulls a 605L Vermeer baler during haying season, a 300-gal. spayer in the fall, a Haybuster hay chopper to fill bunks in the winter, and a tandem disc, seeder and land roller in the spring. I call it my office.”

Best Buy

EdenPure electric heaters

Thomas Jones, Williamstown, Ky. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“I’ve read reports in past issues from people dissatisfied with EdenPure electric heaters. I have two 1,000-watt EdenPure units that I like. I did have trouble with the first units I received but the company sent me new upgraded heaters at no expense to me. I’ve been using them now for 3 years with no trouble.”

Best Buy

Airstream dust helmet

Larry Anderson, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

After having an allergic reaction after cleaning grain bins, Larry started using an Airstream dust helmet (ph 800 328-1792; www.airwareamerica.com). “Over the years, my allergies grew so severe that I now have a sealed room inside my house where I spend most of my time. If I go outside that room at all, I wear the latest Airware American helmet, a Trend Airshield Pro helmet. Twin filters with 98 percent efficiency increase filtration by 400 percent over the older helmets. The 8-hour NiMH battery pack can be quickly changed out with a fresh battery pack. Sells for around $500.”

Best Buy

Caterpillar D5B SA crawler tractor

Michael Zimmerman, Versailles, Mo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

Michael is pleased with his 1980 Caterpillar D5B SA crawler tractor. “We replaced the whole undercarriage with all new parts and also installed a 540 and 1,000 rpm pto off a White 2-150 wheel tractor. In addition, we replaced the original fuel injection pump with an Interim Scroll Fuel injection pump off a Caterpillar D7G, set at 200 hp. A bigger manifold and turbocharger helps engine exhaust temperature to run cooler. The changes helped boost engine horsepower from 165 to 200 hp.

“This crawler works great to pull a 7-shank Sunflower deep ripper 14 in. deep. It has a 6-speed and hydraulic steering. It’ll outperform any 4-WD wheeled tractor doing tillage work and burn less fuel, with less soil compaction and very little slippage. It also rides better in the field than wheeled tractors. We have two of these on our farm and are well-pleased with them.”

Best Buy

I put up with fungus under my fingernails for years

C.F. Marley, Nokomis, Ill. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“I put up with fungus under my fingernails for years. I never believed an internal medicine could clear up the problem until my doctor told me taking one tablet of the prescription medicine Terbinafine each day for the first week of the month for 4 months would cure the problem. I tried it and in 4 months, I had grown a complete new set of fingernails. After years of topical treatments, I finally found a solution.”

Best Buy

Over Rust

Darrold Isham, Flint, Mich. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

Darrold’s impressed with Over Rust, a chemical formula that stops and prevents rust (ph 800 541-7483; www.fertilizerdealer.com). “It does away with the need for sand blasting or wire brushing. Just paint it on and let it dry. All the rust will be gone, never to return.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 14-volt 1/2-in drive + 1 more

Robert Bauer, Hastings, Minn. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“My DeWalt 14-volt, 1/2-in. drive impact tool has a lot of power for its size. It gets into small spaces and is lightweight, unlike an 18-volt impact tool, which is heavy and clumsy. I take this tool up my silos for making repairs, and it works great for climbing up and around my combine. I use it almost every time I’m in the shop. I love it.

“My Unverferth 1225 rolling basket came equipped with a spike tooth harrow in front of the rolling baskets. However, the harrow plugged up the first time I used it and I had to remove it. That part of it was a waste of money and now it lays in a corner of my shed. The rolling basket does work well and I wouldn’t be without it. Other than the harrow, it’s a great machine.”

Best Buy

John Deere Gator 825 utility vehicle

Jim Gisselberg, St. John, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

A 2011 Deere Gator 825 utility vehicle rates as Jim’s “best buy”. “It starts in all weather. The snowplow attachment is easy to put on. I use this machine for spot spraying, carrying three 26-gal. tanks in back with 40-ft. boomless spray nozzles. Some of the hills here in the Palouse region are fairly steep, and the only downside is that I can’t use engine compression to slow down when going downhill. I always have to use the vehicle’s brakes.”

Best Buy

Bison hand-operated water pumps

Jillian and Steve Hartley, Cherryfield, Maine · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

“Our Bison hand-operated water pumps don’t freeze up in the winter, don’t need priming and work fast – after 7 pulls the bucket is full (ph 800 339-2601; www.bisonpumps.com). They’re made with great attention to detail and we don’t think we’ll ever need to repair or replace any part. How many products can you say that about?”

Best Buy

David Bradley walk-behind garden tractor + 1 more

Ricky Garrett, Commerce, Ga. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I bought a 1964 David Bradley walk-behind garden tractor equipped with a Tecumseh 6 hp engine at a local tractor show, as well as some implements for it, including a turning plow, disk harrow, and cultivator, for $350. When my grandfather and I got the tractor home we got it running, but it had a weak spark and carburetor problems. We installed a carburetor kit and points and condenser, and now the tractor runs like new. It always starts on the first or second pull. I used the tractor this year to plow our garden and disk it. Words can’t describe how much this little tractor has impressed me.

“Seven years ago I was given a 1941 Farmall A tractor as a Christmas present. It wasn’t a pretty sight. It had an old automobile seat, the engine was frozen solid, and the carburetor was gummed up. We started by removing the cylinder head and soaking the pistons with penetration oil. Then we fabricated a wooden block to fit inside the cylinder and hit it with a hammer to break it free. We replaced the head gasket, water pump and fan, the fan belt, and starter. The tractor is now more than 70 years old but still going strong. It just goes to show that back then, stuff was really built to last.”

Best Buy

Magna Grecia hoe

Chuck Hays, Kamloops, B.C. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I like my Magna Grecia hoe (ph 250 598-0588; www.scytheworks.ca). It’s made from high silicon hardened steel, with a small chopping blade on one side and two 12-in. tines on the other. It’s designed to loosen the soil and cultivate between rows in gardens. I use mine, along with a broadfork in less rocky soils, to prepare some garden plots. The hoe works particularly good for pulling out grass roots around the edge of garden spaces.”

Best Buy

Ford Explorer

Gordon B. White, Orofino, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

A 1998 4-WD Ford Explorer rates as Gordon’s “best buy”. “I’ve put more than 190,000 miles on it with no major problems. Many of the miles were in 4-WD and off-road. When driving on the highway in 2-WD it averaged 22 to 24 mpg. I traded up for a 2004 Ford Explorer and am well-pleased with it, too.”

Best Buy

Honda H6522 diesel tractor equipped

Paul Overgaard, Plentywood, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“It never quits but just runs and runs and is a real workhorse,” says Paul about his Honda H6522 diesel tractor equipped with a 6558 loader and a tiller. “I wish they would put this tractor back in production. Also, I wish I could find tiller tines and a Honda 6575 backhoe for it.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 4-WD crewcab pickup + 1 more

Greg Perry, Casper, Wyo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I bought a used 2007 Ford F-150 4-WD crewcab pickup with about 48,000 miles. It rides smooth and quiet and the stereo has an incredible sound. It can haul a cord of wood in the bed while pulling a car trailer with an 11,000-lb. load.

“In 2010 I got a Sears Craftsman cordless drill as a Christmas gift. The batteries don’t hold a charge and the drill chuck won’t tighten up enough to keep from slipping. New batteries are as expensive as the drill and don’t keep a charge for more than 15 min. The loss of power gets frustrating when I’m working on a job away from an electrical outlet. I bought a new charger thinking that would solve the problem, but it didn’t.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F-350 crewcab longbed + 1 more

Cody Barnett, Gooding, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

Cody’s the satisfied owner of a 1994 Ford F-350 crewcab, longbed pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine and standard transmission. “It runs great with no major problems and gets 15 to 20 mpg, which I think is pretty good.

“My 2005 Chevrolet 3500 Duramax dually pickup is my worst buy. Everything on it that could go wrong did go wrong so it was always in the shop. It gets only 3 to 4 mpg. Now at about 120,000 miles it’s ready for the junkyard.”

Best Buy

Fiskars ropeless pruning stik

Jeff Lang, Newport News, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I like my Fiskars ropeless pruning stik (ph 866 348-5661; www.fiskars.com). It has a rotating cutting head that lets me use it at any angle, and it’s lightweight but strong and easy to operate. It handles up to 1 1/2-in. dia. tree branches and makes clean, smooth cuts. I can use it to reach down low into rose bushes or to trim up high. The no-rope design takes all the frustration out of trimming work. It’s a great tool for anyone with arthritis. It was well worth the $39.97 I paid for it at Home Depot.”

Worst Buy

Cub Cadet ZT50 zero-turn riding mower

Vern Nielson, Mendon, Utah · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

Vern’s “worst buy” is his Cub Cadet ZT50 zero-turn riding mower. “The biggest problem is with the blades, which have notches cut out of them and bend at the notch. In 3 years I’ve had to replace 2 sets of blades at a cost of $51 per set. Also, one front wheel broke off and the other wheel has bent, and the tires have been replaced. I think the entire mower was designed to wear out in 2 to 3 years.”

Best Buy

Polaris Ranger 400 electric-powered 4-wd

Herbert Korando, Jacob, Ill. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I think the world of my 2010 Polaris Ranger 400 electric-powered, 4-WD EV utility vehicle. It has 620 hrs. on it without a bit of trouble. It’s powered by a 30 hp, 48-volt high efficiency AC-inducted electric motor and comes with eight 12-volt batteries. It also comes with its own recharger that plugs into a standard 110-volt AC outlet. The company says it’ll go 50 miles on a single charge. I recharge it every night so I never run out of power.

“I run all over our place with it and cover a lot of hilly terrain. I use it to do all my spraying, including drainage ditches. If something happened to my Polaris EV, I’d buy another one right away.”

Best Buy

Work Sharp knife

Robert Russin, Millerton, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

Robert’s impressed with his Work Sharp knife and tool sharpener (ph 800 597-6170; www.worksharptools.com). It uses flexible, replaceable abrasive belts to sharpen a broad range of knives, including straight-bladed knives, curved knives, filet knives, serrated knives, gut hooks and almost any other shape of knife blade. “Three different grit belts, from coarse to fine, are available,” says Russin.

The sharpener comes with two precision angle guides – a 50-degree guide for hunting and outdoor knives and a 40-degree model for thinner blades and kitchen knives. The unit can also be used to sharpen other common tools including scissors, axes and hatchets, mower blades, garden shears, shovels, and most any tool with a blade.

Best Buy

Meadow Creature broadfork

Chuck Hays, Kamloops, B.C. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I use a broadfork every spring to cultivate our large gardens without tilling and recently purchased the Meadow Creature broadfork (www.meadowcreature.com). This tool is built like a tank but isn’t too heavy to use. It lets me turn over and prepare the soil fast and with little effort. The tines are cut from heavy-gauge steel and welded to a stout tube crossbar. They easily penetrate the soil, and the broadfork works well to loosen and aerate the soil without mixing the layers together.”

Best Buy

Sears Craftsman 24 hp riding mower

Bob Williams, Lebam, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

“I use my 2005 Sears Craftsman 24 hp riding mower to mow lawns for local disabled vets. I go over 5 to 6 acres every 3 weeks on land that has everything from blackberry briars to mole hills on it. In 7 years I’ve replaced just the battery and a belt and used 2 cans of Fix-A-Flat on the front tires. I think this mower will keep going for at least another 7 years.”

Best Buy

Ram 3/4-ton pickup equipped

Paul Steffes, Edson, Alta. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 13

A 1997 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a diesel engine rates as Paul’s “best buy”. “I bought this pickup used a year ago with about 300,000 miles on it and have put on about 15,000 miles. The fuel economy is excellent – on a recent 600-mile trip hauling a ton of cargo it averaged 34 mpg, at an average speed of about 65 mph. The tachometer always stayed below 2,000 rpm’s.”

Best Buy

Case IH 5130 5230 + 1 more

Lamar Hege, Deer Park, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

Lamar owns Case IH 5130, 5230, and 7140 tractors equipped with Cummins diesel engines and powershift transmissions. “These tractors are fuel efficient and easy to operate and, at 5,000 to 7,000 hrs., have had few problems. They have great hydraulics, which is a must for operating our twin hydraulic rakes and other hay equipment. We switched from using Deere 40 and 50 series tractors because they were constantly needing repairs or weren’t able to operate our rakes.

“My Hesston 4790 3 by 4 baler and Hesston 8830 and 9240 swathers are well designed, and parts are reasonably priced.”

Best Buy

Future Steel Building + 1 more

Gary Crews, Rio Linda, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“After my 25 by 40-ft. Future Steel Building was delivered to my property, I and some helpers assembled the building in about one week. I’d recommend this building to anyone.

“The Weyerhauser hardboard siding on my house consists of 4 by 8-ft. panels that are warped and tend to rot. I don’t recommend this siding or any other brand of hardboard or man-made siding. Many of the manufacturers have been sued for product failure.”

Best Buy

Grizzly heavy-duty bench

Jim Wicks, Sr., Lewiston, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“I paid $450 for my 12 by 20-in. Grizzly heavy-duty, bench top wood lathe (ph 800 523-4777; www.grizzly.com). I bought it to just have fun with for making pens, yo yos, and candlesticks, etc., but I’ve found that it’ll do much more. It’s one of the few pieces of small equipment that turned out to be worth the money I paid for it. It runs smooth and quiet and is built solid. It’s heavy enough that I don’t even have it bolted to a bench top. I’ve enjoyed making many useful projects with it.”

Best Buy

MDS LRB518 rock bucket

Robert Himmerich y Valencia, Pena Blanca, N.M. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“In 2006 we bought an MDS LRB518 rock bucket for our 1956 IH 300 utility tractor. It worked great, and last year we bought a grapple fork for it. The combination of the 2 units greatly increases the bucket’s value.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 260 chainsaw + 1 more

Robert W. Thomas, Orland, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

Robert bought a used 1995 Stihl 260 chainsaw and uses it to cut 3 to 5 cords of wood per year. “This saw has gone through a lot of chains and one new drive sprocket, but it keeps on going. I had to buy a new fuel take-up tube to replace one that was ruined by California’s ‘special gas’. I love this saw.

“My 2007 TYM 330 tractor is my worst buy. I use it on 13 acres to haul gravel, disk, mow and till. At 345 hrs. the rear wheel seals started leaking, and at 365 hrs. the gearshift lever broke at the pin swivel joint. It was easy to replace but now it needs a new handle. I had to replace the battery at 200 hrs., and the hydraulic hose anchor couplings broke from stress at 185 hrs. The tractor’s Kubota engine does work good, however, and may outlast the tractor.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 3/4-ton pickup

Fred Clemence, Ruthilda, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“It has almost 500,000 miles on it, yet the Cummins 5.9-liter diesel engine has never been touched,” says Fred about his 1994 Dodge 2500 3/4-ton pickup. “The manual transmission has been repaired, and there has been some other minor work, but that’s it.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 18-volt impact wrench almost + 1 more

Dan Morehouse, Garrattsville, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“I use my DeWalt 18-volt impact wrench almost every day. It’s relatively light, has plenty of power and doesn’t break if I drop it.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 2008 Dodge 2500 heavy-duty pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine wouldn’t pass inspection at 36,000 miles because the steering arms were shot. By the time the pickup had 50,000 miles, I had installed a new clutch, universal joints, and tie rod ends. I can’t keep the ‘check engine light’ off long enough to get 2 miles away from the dealer so I can trade it. This truck is junk.”

Best Buy

Kubota P-23 tractor

Larry Alles, Weaverville, Calif. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“It’s the all-around best tool I’ve ever bought,” says Larry about his 2004 Kubota P-23 tractor. “I live on 10 mountain acres and use this tractor to move snow, haul manure, dig ditches, and lift things. It’s small enough to fit through my corral gates.”

Best Buy

Ram 1-ton crewcab 4-wd pickup

Leora Patterson, Roseburg, Ore. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

Leora’s the proud owner of a 2003 Dodge 1-ton crewcab 4-WD pickup. “We bought it to transport boats and trailers. It has a comfortable ride, and the 5.9-liter Cummins diesel engine and automatic transmission have been trouble-free. It has about 380,000 miles and still gets 21 mpg on the highway. I wouldn’t hesitate to buy another one.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Lucas Tool Box Buddy lubricant + 1 more

Stephen Gredler, Orlean, Va. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

Stephen likes Lucas Tool Box Buddy lubricant (ph 800 342-2512; www.lucasoil.com). “It’s an aerosol penetrating oil and rust preventative. I’m impressed with its versatility. It can be used on rusted or frozen nuts; as a surface rust dissolver; or as a surface additive to prevent rust for one year. It’s also a good gun oil, cleaner, and rust preventer.”

On the negative side, he lists his Heat-Mate kerosene heater. “It has a synthetic wick, which doesn’t work as well as cotton. As a result the wick has to be raised 1 in. to get decent heat. The unit’s cooktop is perforated along the sides, just above the main body of the stove perforations. That allows hot gases to escape the cooktop dome too early and lowers the temperature of the cooktop, which lowers the stove’s total btu’s.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Silverado Z71 extended cab pickup + 2 more

Robert Fluker, Warsaw, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“I love everything about my 2011 Chevrolet Silverado Z71 extended cab pickup. The way it rides is awesome, and I love the hands-free Bluetooth headphones.

“My 2009 and 2011 Yamaha Grizzly 4-wheelers are built tough. I’ve put more than 1,000 miles on them in one year with no problems. They’re smooth riding machines.

“My 2011 Stihl 290 chainsaw lacks power. I took it back to the dealer who said I should sharpen the chain, but it didn’t help. I put on a new chain but that didn’t help, either. I’ll probably have to trade up to a bigger saw and use this one for trimming tree branches.”

Worst Buy

POR-15 paint

Larry Holmes, Warsaw, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

Larry’s disappointed with POR-15 paint, a rust-preventive coating that’s designed to be applied directly onto rusted metal surfaces. “I used it to paint the underside of 2 riding mower decks last January. After 30 hrs. of mowing the following spring, the only paint left was where the grass had never hit the deck. I’ve bought regular paint locally that has stayed on just as well or better, and I paid a lot less for it. You can’t prevent rust if the rust-preventive coating isn’t there.”

Best Buy

Kubota B3030 loader tractor + 1 more

Larry Hecht, Poulsbo, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“I’ve used my 2008 Kubota B3030 loader tractor to maintain about 5 acres of blackberries and alder saplings. I used the loader to dig everything down to the roots, then burned the material and planted pasture grass and fir trees. I couldn’t have done it without my Kubota. It was up to every task without missing a beat.

“I’ve gone through 3 different Sears Craftsman cordless drills because the batteries keep failing. Unfortunately, the replacement batteries cost more than the original drill with batteries. I’ve learned my lesson – no more Craftsman drills.”

Best Buy

Ram Intrepid

Ron and June Culverhouse, Port Orchard, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“My wife loves her 1995 Dodge Intrepid. It has plenty of room and is comfortable and easy to drive. It gets 19 mpg in town and 30 mpg on the highway. The 3.5-liter, V-6 overhead cam engine has all the power we need.”

Worst Buy

Bad Boy Buggie XTO electric utility vehicle

William H. Ayers, Kingston, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“My worst buy was a 2011 Bad Boy Buggie XTO electric utility vehicle, which I bought for use in my woodlot. It was advertised as an advanced performance, all terrain UTV. However, it doesn’t have enough ground clearance and there’s no engine compression to hold it back on steep terrain. The headlight didn’t work, and part of the battery fill system was missing.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota ZD25F zero-turn riding mower + 2 more

Daryle Welker, Clifton Springs, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

A 2005 Kubota ZD25F zero-turn riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck rates as Daryle’s “best buy”. “It does a great job of mowing and saves me 45 min. every time I mow the lawn. Also, it doesn’t use much fuel.”

On the minus side, “My 2010 Snap-On MG1200 and MG725 1/2 and 3/4-in. air impact wrenches are both worst buys. I owned Ingersol Rand composite-style wrenches in the past, and they had more power and were quieter and much lighter.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Geo Metro

Tim Wolfinbarger, St. Maries, Idaho · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 14

“After I wore out my 1995 Chevrolet Geo Metro, I bought a 1999 model. Both were best buys. I drove the 1995 model more than 75 miles per day to work and back and replaced the tires every 1 1/2 years. The 12-in. tires cost only $24 apiece. I changed the oil every 2,000 miles, but the engine uses only 3 1/2 quarts. I did a timing belt change at 150,000 miles and a tune-up at 100,000 miles. At 200,000 miles I traded it in.”

Best Buy

NorthStar pressure washer

Terry S. Galbreath, Calhan, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I bought a NorthStar pressure washer in 1993 (Northern Tool & Equipment, ph 800 221-0516; www.northerntool.com). After 20 years of nearly daily use and some maintenance here and there, it was tired. So I bought a new one with a hose cart, at about half the cost of a Hotsy, and it’s also a great machine. I expect it to outlive me.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ski-Doo Skandic SWT snowmobile + 1 more

Mike Roub, Chuckaloon, Alaska · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I like my 2006 Ski-Doo Skandic SWT snowmobile. We built some 4-ski sleds to pull behind it and then used them to haul 2,000-lb. loads 50 miles into the Brooks Range of Alaska. No other machine I know of could have done this with the ease this machine did the job. I’ve owned snowmobiles since the mid 1960’s, but nothing compares to this one.

“I bought my 2005 GM Duramax 1-ton pickup used with less than 70,000 miles on it, but it has had a number of electrical issues. First, the transmission went bad, then the fuel transfer pump quit while I was on a trip up north where I really needed both fuel tanks. Over the years I’ve had to limp home twice on failsafe mode.”

Best Buy

Dolmar chainsaw

Gordon Elliott, Norwood, Ont. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“It’s lightweight yet has a lot of power,” says Gordon about his 2011 Dolmar chainsaw. “The decompression valve makes it easy to start. I like the design of the spike bar – it has a toothed stop for holding the saw steady against wood.”

Best Buy

Makita tools + 1 more

Merrill J. Smith, Deer Park, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I’ve had great success with Makita tools, both corded and cordless, including drills, a chopsaw, 7.2-volt flashlight, sawzall, and 1/4-in. hex impact driver. The flashlight was left outside on the ground all winter underneath 4 ft. of snow, but when I found it the following spring it was still charged and worked fine. I use the impact driver nearly every day and haven’t had to recharge the lithion battery in it yet after almost a year.

“The battery-powered sprayer I bought at Northern Tool would hardly spray far enough out to clear my feet, and the batteries lasted only about 20 min. before they went dead. I also bought a water well pressure tank from Northern Tool. It was advertised as an 80-gal. model but turned out to be only 35 gal. I called to see why and was told the ad meant it ‘performed like 80 an gal.’. What a farce.”

Best Buy

Ford Jubilee tractor

Walter McFarland, St. Johns, Fla. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

A 1953 Ford Jubilee tractor rates as Walter’s all-time “best buy”. “We still use this tractor every day. At first my dad used it with a root rake and bush hog to get rid of palmetto trees. He also used it to level countless loads of dirt, to pull engines, and to haul cars and logs.

“The tractor’s hour meter broke in 1977 so I don’t know how many hours it has now. The clutch and brake pedals have been used so many times that the edges on my work boots have worn down to a knife-sharp edge. Numerous times the tractor’s front end has come off the ground from popping the clutch.

“We converted the tractor to 12 volts, rebuilt the hydraulic system, and replaced the radiator, clutch, and front tires. It still has the original rear tires. Regular maintenance is the key to why it’s still running.”

Best Buy

John Deere 757 zero-turn riding mower + 1 more

Terry D. Bobo, Guthrie, Okla. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Terry’s impressed with his Deere 757 zero-turn riding mower. “This machine has plenty of power, works fast and just keeps on running. It did have a valve problem early on, but the dealer promptly took care of it.

“The Masterbuilt Smoker I bought at Bass Pro Shop worked okay for a year, but then the electronic time and temperature control went out at a cost of $300. Neither Bass Pro nor the company would help. My wife then bought another model, but it lasted only 2 years before a door gasket fell apart. I contacted the company but they said they don’t keep parts and wouldn’t help. I think this company builds smokers to sell, not to service.”

Best Buy

Toro Titan MX5480 riding mower equipped

Harry Rehberg, Blooming Grove, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I like my Toro Titan MX5480 riding mower equipped with a 23 hp Kawasaki engine and 54-in. deck. It works somewhat like a skid loader. My wife has adapted it for her own personal use and I use it occasionally. It works fast and makes short work of our sometimes overgrown fields.”

Best Buy

John Deere 265 riding mower + 1 more

William A. Hauck, Ferndale, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“Our 1987 Deere 265 riding mower has taken a licking but still works great. We’ve replaced the deck belts and bearings but it has had no major problems. We also like our 2010 Deere 2305 tractor.

“Our DR field and brush mower is equipped with a 5 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and on just about every start it pulls the starter cord out of my hands, inflicting pain in my hand. I should have bought an electric start model.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet 1641 riding mower equipped + 1 more

Leonard Baylor, Carlton, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“This is one tough machine,” says Leonard about his 1999 Cub Cadet 1641 riding mower equipped with a 48-in. deck. “The deck has tangled with wire fencing and rocks but has stood up to it. All I’ve replaced are a belt, blades and an electric clutch connector to the pto. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance.

“My 2004 Ford F-150 pickup gets only about 10 mpg pulling a trailer and 12 to 13 mpg empty. The same models now being offered by Ford are advertised to get closer to 20 mpg. Why can’t the company offer some kind of a retrofit kit that would make my model more fuel efficient?”

Best Buy

Tube-Line Bale Boss II big square bale + 1 more

John C. Haldemann, Chinook, Mont. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“Our 2012 Tube-Line Bale Boss II big square bale processor-feeder is a great machine (ph 888 856-6613; www.tubeline.ca). It’s built heavy and makes a nice windrow, and we can also use it to bed animals.

“Our 2012 Dodge 1/2-ton crewcab, 4-WD shortbed pickup equipped with a 5.7-liter, V-8 gas engine works great. It gets good mileage as it automatically switches to 4 cylinders for easy going on the highway, yet it has tremendous power when we need it. It’s equipped with an automatic transmission that switches to manual for braking when going down hills. I love good pickups, and this one really fits the bill.”

Best Buy

King Kutter 3-pt mounted

Kenneth Shields, Cedaredge, Colo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“It does a nicer job and works faster than any other soil conditioning implement on the market,” says Kenneth about his 2010 King Kutter 72-in., 3-pt. mounted rototiller. “I use this machine with my Deere 5400 60 hp tractor on my own farm, as well as to do custom work. It’s built extremely rugged and holds up even in rocky soil. The Deere tractor is also a best buy.”

Best Buy

Polaris RZR Side

Matt Pettet, Ontario, Ore. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“It has less than 1,000 miles on it but uses oil like crazy,” says Matt about his 2008 Polaris RZR Side By Side utility vehicle equipped with an 800 cc engine. “The engine oil goes from the ‘full’ mark to the ‘add’ mark in less than 50 miles, and the company doesn’t seem to care. I checked on the internet and found this appears to be a common problem for that year.”

Best Buy

Soap Nuts instead

Lois Link, Castile, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“We use Soap Nuts instead of laundry detergent to wash our laundry and think they’re fantastic (ph 306 752-0709; www.buysoapnuts.com). A 2-lb. bag will wash more than 330 loads. According to the company, Soap Nuts can also be used in place of hair shampoo and to replace other household cleaners. You can even use them to make your own dishwasher soap. They eliminate the need for fabric softener and are non-allergenic.”

Best Buy

Wheel Horse 1257 tractor equipped + 1 more

Bill Shultz, Millbrook, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Bill’s 1966 Wheel Horse 1257 tractor equipped with a 4-speed transmission is still going strong. “It has required only minor, everyday maintenance. I’m now restoring it, and hopefully it will last another 46 years.

“Tractor Supply Company changed its line of paints without telling their customers. I’m just hoping I have enough paint to complete the restoration of my tractor without the hassle of trying to match colors.”

Best Buy

John Deere 200CX front-end loader

Brian Gilbertson, Melfort, Sask. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Brian’s glad he bought a Deere 200CX front-end loader for his Deere 2305 tractor. “About 3 years ago our Deere 318 garden tractor and snowblower were having problems. I took the tractor and snowblower to the dealer for repairs, and while there a salesman told me there was a good price on new garden/yard tractors. I ended up buying a new Deere 2305 tractor plus a new snowblower, tiller and mower. I also bought a 200CX loader, which is a best buy. I’ve found endless uses for this loader around our yard. I’d be at a loss without it.”

Best Buy

Mantis XP rototiller equipped

Daniel Burgoyne, Mahone Bay, N.S. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Daniel’s the satisfied owner of a 2011 Mantis XP rototiller equipped with a Honda 35cc, 4-stroke engine. “This rototiller is reliable, easy to handle, and has a lot of power for its size. The tines turn fast, creating a good seedbed. The tiller is also lightweight so it’s easy to transport.”

Best Buy

Texas Refinery Corp

Ronald Cunningham, Portland, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I switched to using Texas Refinery Corp. (TRC) Moly Pro Spec IV 15W-40 engine oil in my 1972 International B-275 tractor, and I’m glad I did. It reduced oil consumption from a quart every 8 to 10 hours to a quart every 25 to 30 hours. An expensive oil got inexpensive, real quick. I’m sure others might not get exactly the same results, but for me it was definitely worth the money.”

Best Buy

Takeuchi TL250 skid loader

Donald Thomas, Boonsboro, Md. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“We tried 3 other brands but this one was the best,” says Donald about his Takeuchi TL250 skid loader (ph 706 693-3600; www.takeuchi-us.com). “It’s a good, low maintenance machine with fewer moving parts and better grading ability. The rollers and sprockets on it cost only about half as much as other brands.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Worx GT weed trimmer + 1 more

Jessica Fernandes, Deer Park, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Jessica nominates her 2012 Worx GT weed trimmer as her “best buy” (ph 866 354-9679; www.worx.com). “After mowing my 1 3/4-acre lawn I was too worn out to use my old weedeater. I didn’t like having to mix the gas and do a lot of pulling to get it started. With the Worx GT I just install the battery and away I go. It weighs only 5 1/2 lbs. so my arms don’t get sore, and there’s no mixing gas and no pulling to start. It’s equipped with an adjustable spacer that protects plants, flowers and garden furniture from damage while I’m using it.”

She’s disappointed with her 2006 Frigidaire electric convection oven. “After 4 years the bottom element on it quit working. I tried to get a replacement but was told the element wasn’t the problem but instead it was the computer chip in the clock. I paid just over $500 for the oven yet they wanted $199.95 for the part, plus $125 and mileage to come and repair it from the same store where I bought it. No more Frigidaire anything for me.”

Best Buy

Red Wing boots + 1 more

Ben Parks, Austin, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I’ve purchased 4 pairs of Red Wing boots over the past 15 years. I do a lot of walking at work but find these boots are hard to wear out. The heel, soles and leather hold up well and are practically indestructible.

“I recently purchased my second set of B.F. Goodrich all-terrain TA truck tires. The first set lasted 5 years and went more than 60,000 miles with no problems. In fact, they still had tread on them. The only reason I replaced them was because of weather-cracking between the treads.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 quad cab 4-wd

Brian Egan, Nine Mile Falls, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Brian’s impressed with his 2001 Dodge 2500 quad cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a turbocharged diesel engine. “It has more than 307,000 miles yet I’ve spent less than $1,000 on repairs. It still runs and drives like new and has plenty of power, and it averages 19 1/2 mpg. The batteries and shocks are original, as is most everything else. I’ve driven this pickup in all kinds of bad weather and in eyeball-deep mud. It’s the best vehicle I’ve ever owned. I should have bought two more just like it.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet Yanmar SC2400 garden tractor equipped + 2 more

John W. Collins, Sherburne, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

John likes his Cub Cadet Yanmar SC2400 garden tractor equipped with a 60-in. deck and 48-in. loader bucket. “I had an old T340 crawler equipped with a big bucket that I rebuilt and used it to move dirt. Then my son bought the Cub Cadet for me and mounted a 12-in. auger on back. It worked so well that I sold the crawler. The Cub Cadet is a great tractor.

“While building a 12 by 40-ft. addition on my 24 by 40-ft. garage some of my old shop tools died, such as a Sears 1/2-in. electric drill and a Milwaukee sawzall. So I went out and bought a Porter Cable sawzall, circular saw and drill, and a Hitachi 18-volt cordless impact driver. They’re all best buys. I’m 84 years young, and the Hitachi impact driver saves my arm since driving screws is a lot easier than driving nails.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 266SE chainsaw

Robert McMahon, Knoxville, Tenn. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

Robert’s impressed with his 1983 Husqvarna 266SE chainsaw. Over the years I’ve put 5 to 10 gal. of gas per year through it, which comes out to about 200 gal. total. I’ve used it to cut firewood that was too big to split. I’ve replaced the fuel line and spark plug once, the anti-vibe mounts twice and many bars and chains. I use 50:1 oil mix in 2 gal. of gas instead of 2 1/2 gal. The saw still starts good and runs fine. I wish everything was made this well.”