GM: what farmers say
127 reports in FARM SHOW · 102 Best Buys26 Worst Buys
GM pickup
8 Best Buys1 Worst BuyEd likes his Deere Z445 zero-turn riding mower and also his Deere 345 lawn tractor. “No problems with either one. I bought a used Deere 5410 4-WD tractor that’s also a best buy. My 2012 GM pickup has about 80,000 miles on it while requiring only new tires and brake pads. It’s by far the best truck I’ve ever owned.”
On the “worst buy” side, “My Honda string trimmer went through three new carburetors but still lacked power. I finally gave up and bought a Husqvarna trimmer.”
“I bought a used 2012 Chevrolet Silverado 1/2-ton 4-WD pickup with about 68,000 miles and just finished a 3,200-mile round trip to Brownsville, Texas with no problems. I’ve owned a 2008 GM pickup for more than 8 years. It needed a lifter replaced at about 202,000 miles but has otherwise been a good pickup.”
Dave has more than 455,000 miles on his 1998 Dodge Ram 2500 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. “It’s an outstanding pickup and, despite all the miles, still doesn’t make any rattling noises. The engine is original and has never been touched. I installed new fuel injectors at about 390,000 miles, and took the top side of the Bosch pump off at the same time to replace a spring.
“We use this pickup in our business, often pulling a 20-ft. utility trailer fitted with a scissors lift. I bought my first Dodge in 1994 and have owned Dodges ever since. They’re the most trouble-free vehicles we’ve owned. But I can’t say the same about GM pickups. Of the four GM models I’ve owned, only one wasn’t a lemon. We were always having to repair something whether it was with the electrical system, transmission, engine, or air conditioner, and there was always lots of noise.”
“I’ve put about 294,000 miles on my 2003 GM diesel pickup and have only replaced the transfer case. This pickup has no rust, no leaks, and uses no oil. It gets 23 mpg on average and will pull anything I can hook on behind it.”
Robert’s satisfied with his 2007 GM extended cab pickup. “It has about 45,000 miles on it, with the only problem being a burned-out parking light. It gets 17 1/2 mpg both in town and on the highway.”
“Over the years I’ve owned almost 20 different Chevrolet or GM pickups, mostly K5 Blazers, which I consider the best all-around pickup ever built. None of my pickups has ever let me down.”
Andrew’s the satisfied owner of a 1987 GM pickup. “I drive a mail route and have put almost 300,000 miles on this pickup, with very few repairs. It still starts easy and doesn’t use much oil. I think it still has a lot of miles left on it.”
Robert’s the satisfied owner of several Allis-Chalmers tractors including a 1949 B and a 1955 WD45 equipped with a front-end loader, and a D17 equipped with a diesel engine. “The tractors have required very few repairs. All of them are still working good. I had an Allis-Chalmers 7010 tractor that developed a hole in one of the cylinder walls because we used the wrong anti-freeze. I haven’t had any other problems with it.
“I’ve used two Allis-Chalmers round bal-ers since 1959. On one of them the twine eyelet in the hood wore down about 1/8 in. It takes a lot of twine to do that.”
“My 1983 Deutz DX120 tractor still runs great.
“Over the years I’ve had 14 different Chevrolet and GM pickups. The last one I bought was a 1995 4-WD 1/2-ton model equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine. It has about 35,000 miles on it and has been trouble-free.”
Ray’s impressed with his 1985 Deere 2550 tractor equipped with a cab and air conditioning. “No problems. It sure is nice to have a heated cab in the winter and air conditioning in the summer.” On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1995 GM extended cab pickup. “At 9,000 miles the dealer had to install a new engine because the old one rattled every time it was started. However, that didn’t solve the problem. I was told that I should use a Fram PH-5 oil filter instead of the AC-Delco filter that I was using, but that didn’t solve the problem, either. I’ve found out that others are having the same problem. I think the company should recall these engines.”
GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped
5 Best Buys2 Worst Buys“In 2004 I bought a used 2001 Dodge quad cab 3/4-ton, 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5.9-liter Cummins diesel engine and manual 6-speed transmission. I like it so much that I wouldn’t trade it even for a new pickup of any brand. I bought it with 64,000 miles, and now it has about 172,000 miles but still runs and drives great. I really like the Cummins engine. It starts right up even in the coldest weather, and still uses less than a quart of oil per every 6,000 miles. It gets about 17 mpg around our farm and up to 22 mpg on the highway with plenty of power. Repairs have been limited to some U-joints and rear axle seals and a set of brakes. My goal is for this pickup to reach 450,000 miles. I love diesel engines and use them everywhere I can.
“My 1994 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter diesel engine and automatic transmission was a worst buy. In 10 1/2 years and 194,000 miles, it went through three transmissions and one set of engine heads, had numerous oil leaks, and many other problems. It went through at least three fuel injection pumps, which cost $2,000 apiece to replace. The gauges quit working, the air conditioning failed, and there were overheating problems. Altogether I spent about $18,000 on repairs. Then the engine oil cooler line blew out due to a poorly designed snap-in coupler, which wore out and destroyed the engine.”
A 1997 Dodge Ram 1500 pickup equipped with a 318 cu. in. gas engine and automatic transmission rates as Clifton’s “best buy”. “It’s a great vehicle although it’s underpowered a little when hauling a load. It had about 120,000 miles on it when I traded it in for a 2000 Dodge Ram 1500 equipped with a 360 cu. in. gas engine and automatic transmission. On that model the transmission never worked correctly, and the dealers who worked on it only made it worse. Finally I traded it in for a 2006 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a diesel Duramax engine and automatic transmission. It’s an excellent pickup. On a recent 400-mile trip it used only 17 gallons of fuel (23 1/2 mpg). I’m well satisfied with it.”
“One of my best buys ever was my 1997 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with a Power Stroke diesel engine. I put more than 87,000 miles on it without any problems. It was a great pickup with a great engine. Six months ago I traded for a 2001 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with the new Duramax engine. I’m well satisfied with it. It gets more than 18 1/2 mpg in town and more than 20 mpg on the highway.
“My 1995 Sears Kenmore oven is a worst buy. The problem is that the burners don’t work right. We’ve had to replace them many times. In addition, the oven doesn’t heat accurately.”
A 1999 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 6000 Vortec V-8 engine rates as Thomas’s “best buy”. “It has all the power I need and is the best pickup I’ve ever owned. It rides great and is reasonably fuel efficient.
“My worst buy is my Generac electric pressure washer. It couldn’t generate enough pressure, which was very disappointing. The attachments for it are flimsy and hard to put on. I called the company but it didn’t do any good.”
“My 1991 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in., V-8 engine is my best buy. It runs great and I haven’t had any problems with it. It has plenty of power to haul my livestock trailer.
“My 1987 Chevrolet S-10 pickup runs great and is also a best buy.”
“It’s my best buy ever and just keeps on running with very little maintenance,” reports Gary, pleased with his 1964 Wheel Horse garden tractor. “The Kohler engine has a lot of hours on it but has never had problems. Same for the drivetrain. It does a great job of mowing.” On the minus side, “I’ve had a lot of problems with the front drive wheels not engaging on my 1989 GM 3/4-ton pickup. The problem is that the front driveshaft is poorly built. The pickup gets only fair mileage and it rides rough. I had to install a new, expensive alternator soon after I bought it.”
“I like my 1989 GM 3/4-ton heavy duty pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine. It has 110,000 miles with few problems. It’s comfortable to ride and will pull just about anything. The limited slip differential really helps - I wouldn’t own a pickup without this feature. It gets about 16 mpg. “My 1991 Case-IH 3309 mower-conditioner is my worst buy. While shopping around we saw several of these models with broken frames. We picked a used one that didn’t have a broken frame and reinforced it before taking it to the field. The frame held up okay but we kept breaking spindles. After breaking four or five of them we found some hubs that would fit the wheels, but they had shafts that were 1/2 in. larger in diameter than the original shafts. We had a machine shop make new spindles and haven’t had any problems since we made the change. Neither the dealer nor the company would help. I think White-New Idea makes them for Case-IH. They’re still selling this mower with the same spindles and frame.”
GM 4-WD 3/4-ton pickup
5 Best Buys3 Worst BuysJohn’s had problems with his 2010 GM 4-WD, 3/4-ton pickup. “A door hinge broke on the driver’s side, the bed started cracking, and spot welds broke. The dealer refused to install a new bed and instead sent the pickup to a body shop for repairs. However, 3 mos. later the repaired bed came apart. Seams broke and side panels cracked everywhere, but the dealer again refused to repair or replace them. I finally replaced the bed at my own expense for $2,500. All this happened with less than 30,000 miles on the pickup.”
“My 1981 Toyota 4-WD pickup, and my 1991 and 1997 GM 4-WD pickups, are all best buys. These compact pickups are reliable and fuel efficient, with plenty of storage space in the cab.”
A 2008 GM 4-WD extended cab pickup rates as Joe’s “worst buy”. “This pickup drives and rides nice but it isn’t a work truck. It’s big, bulky and so tall that I can’t get anything out of the bed without having to climb in. The cab has very little storage space, and the gaskets on the doors leak in high winds. This pickup is poorly designed by people who have no idea what a work truck should be. It also annoys me to have Onstar and satellite radio as standard equipment, when I don’t want either one.”
“My 2003 Deere LX 277 riding mower has never failed to start and is my best buy. It has more than 360 hours on it with no problems and still has the original battery.
“My 2001 GM 4-WD pickup is dependable and a best buy. I replaced the tires at about 47,000 miles and the battery when the pickup was five years old. It now has about 55,000 miles on it.”
“My 1995 GM 4-WD pickup equipped with a V-6 engine is my best buy. I bought the pickup used as a repossessed model and knew nothing about it, but I’ve put more than 200,000 miles on it with only minor repairs. It’s a very reliable pickup.”
“My 1994 Deere 4620 is an excellent tractor. It has had a few electrical problems but they weren’t too hard to fix.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1992 Chevrolet Silverado 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine. He bought it used in 1996. “It’s a poorly built pickup. The 4-WD should be made to shift like 1971-1976 models. Also, it had many electrical problems. For example, the lights would go out while I was driving at night. New switches for it weren’t cheap. I finally sold it 3 years ago at a loss and bought an older 1976 GM 4-WD pickup. At least it’s not loaded with computers and cheap electrical components.”
A 1994 GM 4-WD extended cab pickup rates as Don’s “best buy”. “No problems except for two recalls for minor problems. It rides like a car and gets a respectable 17 to 20 mpg.”
“My worst buy of all time was my Interna-tional Farmall 400 tractor. I always knew when I went to the field with it that I wouldn’t be able to stay out all day without it breaking down. “My 1991 GM 4-WD pickup is a worst buy. It had problems with the alternator, starter, cruise control, brakes, and transmission. Also, the paint started peeling off when it was only a year old and I had to pay $100 for a new paint job. The radiator was too small and would heat up and the controls didn’t work right. “My best buy was my Deere 4020 tractor. I could always depend on it. “I also like my 1996 Dodge 4-WD pickup. No problems.”
GM Sierra pickup
5 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“At about 98,000 miles the number 4 cylinder on the engine on my 2009 GM Sierra pickup started misfiring. The problem seems to be with GM’s cylinder deactivation system. The number 4 lifter was stuck so bad that I had to use a hammer and punch to work it loose. Good thing there was no scoring or contaminant buildup on the lifter, because it’s a major job to replace the lifters.
“After researching the problem I installed a device sold by Range Technology (www.rangetechnology.com; ph 888 997-6515). It plugs into the OBD port and keeps the engine in V-8 mode at all times, preventing the vehicle’s Active Fuel Management system from dropping cylinders. The pickup’s fuel efficiency actually improved a little after I installed the device. You can go online and find a lot of information about the problems with GM’s cylinder deactivation system.”
“I enjoy driving my 2012 GM Sierra pickup equipped with an automatic transmission. In the past I had manual shift transmissions in all my GM pickups. I put almost 200,000 miles on every one except for the last one, which I gave to my daughter at about 60,000 miles. I had to buy a pickup with an automatic transmission because of nerve damage in my left leg, which kept me from using my foot to engage the clutch.”
“My 2004 GM Sierra pickup is my best buy. It replaced a 2000 Sierra that had 92,000 trouble-free miles on it. The new model is really fuel efficient and has had no problems. I’ve been driving GM pickups for more than 20 years.
“My worst buy is my Shivvers grain drying system that I bought for use inside a Butler bin. This computerized drying system has never worked right, and I haven’t been able to get any help from either the company or dealer. I wouldn’t recommend this product to anyone.”
“I like my 2003 GM Sierra pickup. It’s equipped with all the bells and whistles and has superb fuel efficiency.”
James is pleased with his 2002 GM Sierra longbed pickup equipped with a 4.8-liter engine and automatic 4-speed transmission with overdrive. “It’s the right size pickup for what I need. The engine has a lot of power for a small V-8 and gets up to 24 mpg on the highway going with the wind, and 17 mpg loaded with the air conditioning on and going against the wind. On average it gets 21 mpg.”
Curt bought his 1997 GM Sierra extended cab pickup used. He says he likes it but has nevertheless had some problems with it. “I love the pickup itself. It drives great, has a quiet and comfortable cab, and gets a respectable 15 to 18 mpg. But it has had a lot of mechanical problems. It has about 40,000 miles on it now and is in the shop for a coolant leak. At about 30,000 miles, one of the rear wheel seals got ruined. The front end went badly out of alignment. Both the license plate light and the under-hood light had poor connections and quit working. At only about 40,000 miles the transmission went bad, but the company said they wouldn’t help because the pickup was out of warranty. After we expressed dissatisfaction the dealer gave us a slight discount on the repair cost. Even so, my total repair bill after only about 15 months of ownership has already been $3,500.”
GM 1/2-ton extended cab 4-wd
4 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“In 2000 I bought a used 1994 GM 1/2-ton extended cab 4-WD pickup with about 125,000 miles on it. It now has more than 240,000 miles on it but still has the original engine. It’s a best buy.
“My 2005 Polaris 400 Sportsman 4-WD ATV actually rides smoother than most cars and performs well. I use it to check on cows and calves and to do other chores. My only complaint is that it has plastic composite racks.”
Two years ago Jerry bought a used 1999 GM 1/2-ton extended cab, 3-door Sierra pickup equipped with a 5.3-liter, V-8 engine. It’s his “best buy.” “It has a quiet, comfortable ride, and handles well. It now has more than 55,000 miles on it. The only problem happened when a wire came off an electric window motor on one of the doors.”
Terry’s “best buy” is a 1997 GM 1/2-ton extended cab, 3-door, shortbed pickup equipped with a Vortex 350 cu. in. engine. “It’s an absolute pleasure to drive and runs great. It has a lot of power and is reasonably fuel efficient, especially considering the available power. It has more than 51,000 miles on it with only routine maintenance.”
Chris is impressed with his 1997 Ford F-150 extended cab pickup equipped with a V-6 engine and automatic transmission. “It rides like a car but works like a truck. It can haul 2,200 lbs. of fertilizer or a 24-ft. travel trailer with no problems. I did have to install overload springs on it.
“My 1993 Deere 2755 tractor has been trouble-free. I use it to pull a mower, baler, forage harvester, and rotovator. I really like the air-conditioned cab.
“My 1996 Massey Ferguson 253 4-WD tractor has 48 pto horsepower and works good for what I use it for. It does have its faults. For example, the levers for the remote hydraulics, pto, 4-WD, and hand brake are all clustered too close together. The driver always has to look down to make sure that he’s grabbing the right lever.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1994 GM 1/2-ton pickup equipped with a V-6 engine. “Parts fell off, the body rattled, and it had a terrible seat. If I drove it any more than two hours at a time, when I got out of the cab I would walk like I was 90 years old. I finally traded it in two years ago for a new Ford F-150 pickup. It works great. There’s no comparison between the two.”
“My 1997 GM 1/2-ton pickup is easy on fuel and performs well.
“Five years ago I bought a used Deere 3140 tractor. I’ve gone over the hydraulic system from front to back but can’t get it to work properly.”
GM 2500 pickup
5 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“The Yardsport 2-WD gas-powered utility vehicle I bought at Menards 8 years ago has been trouble-free. So has the 2000 GM 2500 pickup I bought used 14 years ago.”
“I’m totally pleased with my 2001 GM 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a Duramax 6.6-liter, turbo diesel engine and Allison transmission. It has more than 115,000 miles on it but has been maintenance-free. When pulling a 30-ft. travel trailer to Tucson, Arizona, at an average speed of more than 70 mph it got better than 16 mpg. It consistently averages 18 1/2 mpg in local driving which includes going over local mountain passes. It’s the most user friendly pickup I’ve ever owned. I have no reason to trade pickups again.”
“My 1999 Deere 8200 tractor has a lot of power. Also, it drives and handles nice.
“My 2004 Deere 6615 tractor has a much-improved transmission over the company’s 6605 model.
“My 2003 GM 2500 pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter engine is an excellent work truck with a lot of towing capacity. My 2004 GM 3500 pickup has a lot of power and towing capacity, and it accelerates well. It has a fairly nice ride.
“My 1999 Polaris Sportsman 500 has been trouble-free.”
“It has a comfortable ride, plenty of power and isn’t too hard on fuel,” says Wayne about his 2001 GM 2500 pickup equipped with a 6-liter engine.
“My Deere 265 disc mower is balanced well with the tractor, and its blades are easy to change. I can cut in the field as fast as I care to drive. I use a 50 hp Deere 2240 tractor to pull it.”
“My 1989 GM 2500 pickup is my best buy. It has over 110,000 miles with very few problems.”
GM 1500 pickup
4 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“The 1994 GM 1500 pickup I use in my lawn care business works great. All I’ve replaced are the tires and a brake line. The V-6 engine is fuel efficient and can pull a 17-ft. loaded trailer with no problem.”
“My 2007 Simplicity Champion 20 hp zero turn riding mower is comfortably maneuverable and also does an excellent job mowing. It’s equipped with a 50-in. deck and independent suspension and has cut my mowing time in half. No problems.
“My 1993 GM 1500 pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine and automatic transmission is a best buy. Now it has more than 180,000 miles on it with no major problems.”
He’s the satisfied owner of a 1994 GM 1500 pickup equipped with a V-6 engine and 5-speed manual transmission. “I bought it used with 23,000 miles on it and it now has more than 88,000 miles. It’s a ‘plain vanilla’ pickup, but it runs good and is fuel efficient. I can pull a 1,000-gal. nurse tank with it. I replaced the battery and relined the brakes and also put on new tires at 80,000 miles. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance.
“My 1991 Chevrolet Caprice Classic 4-door sedan has had a lot of problems. The Bose radio system quit and no one was able to fix it. The rear electric windows won’t stay up. The fuel tank broke. The speedometer had to be replaced and then the fuel gauge and odometer became inaccurate. The windshield cracked twice while I was crossing uneven ground, and the alternator had to be replaced. Also, whenever I turn sharp the tires raise the car body up.”
“The best buy I’ve ever made is my U.S. Lever T-post puller. I bought the manuallly-operated version about six years ago and have used it to pull hundreds of metal T-posts with no problems. After I bought it I learned that the company had gone out of business. I bought all remaining stock and will ship one to anyone for $75 for as long as my supply lasts (21401 S.E. 59th St., Newalla, Okla. 74857). They work great. I wish someone would start making them again.
“My 1990 GM 1500 pickup is a best buy. It has about 216,000 miles and all I’ve done is change the oil every 5,000 miles and lubricate it. I change the transmission oil every 50,000 miles. I’ve never owned a pickup as good as this one.
“My worst buy was two Trane heat pumps that I installed in my office and home two years ago. Both have had major problems and I’ve had to replace the motors on both. Now one of them can’t even cool a small office. They’re noisy and use a lot more electricity than other same sized units that I have in other buildings. The company won’t fix them and refuses to return my calls. The warranty isn’t any good as written.”
GM Sierra 4-WD pickup equipped
2 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA 1984 Kubota L235 tractor equipped with a 5-ft. mower deck rates as Alvin’s “best buy”. “I bought this tractor used with 52 hours on it and have spent absolutely nothing on maintenance, other than changing the oil every 40 hours and the hydraulic fluid and filter every 300 hours. It still has the original fan belt. I use this tractor for mowing and rotovating.
“My 1979 GM Sierra 4-WD pickup equipped with a standard transmission is one of my best buys ever. Over the years I’ve had to replace a water pump, starter, fuel pump, alternator, and clutch which is not a bad record for 26 years of use. I often use this pickup to tow the Kubota tractor to various work locations.”
“I use my 3-pt., pto-driven Farmi skidding winch to clean up windfall timber in our woods. It’s my best buy.
“My 1997 GM Sierra 4-WD pickup is my worst buy. It has the company’s version of ABS brakes and I’ve often had them kick in while driving on dry roads. I’ve already had to change the rear seals. I’ve talked to other people who own this same model and they all say they don’t like the ABS brakes.”
“My 1997 White 6105 front wheel assist tractor is my best buy. It has a nice smooth transmission, starts excellent even in cold weather, and pulls through the muddiest part of my feedlot without even spinning a tire. The cab has a lot of glass so I have a great view when doing loader work. The Westendorf TA-28 loader on it is also a best buy. The main loader booms are low enough that they don’t interfere with my vision.
“My 1996 GM Sierra 4-WD shortbed pickup is a best buy. It has never failed me after 25,000 miles. Our last two winters have been very fierce with a lot of snow and cold, but the 305 cu. in. Vortec engine always started right up even though we never used an engine heater or parked it inside a building. I think GM and Chevy make the best pickups on the market.
“My worst buy is my 1981 Deutz DX90 front wheel assist tractor. One problem was that it starts hard in cold weather. The engine has a lot of power - Deutz engines are built strong and you can expect many years of use out of them. I also had a lot of problems with the front part of the power train which cost me a lot of down time and money. On the positive side, the Westendorf WL44 loader that came with it has been trouble-free. This company makes the best front-end loaders on the market.”
GM Sonoma extended cab
3 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I bought a 1991 GM Sonoma extended cab, 4-WD pickup used in 1994 with about 20,000 miles on it. Now it has about 131,000 miles. It’s equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine that gets 21 mpg and has air conditioning, cruise control, power steering, and power brakes. I’ve replaced just the alternator and water pump. I use this pickup every day. It’s always ready to go.”
Allyn says he’s “generally satisfied” with his 1991 GM Sonoma extended cab pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter V-6 engine and 5-speed transmission. “It has adequate power and is reasonably fuel efficient. I do have a few complaints. The instrument and control layout is poorly designed. For example, the fuel gauge swings right toward empty, you have to put the heater control in the down position to turn it off, and the hood pull and brake release knobs are both horizontal and located too close to each other. It has Firestone air-adjustable helper springs from J.C. Whitney, which caused such a rough ride - even without any air in them - that we had to remove them.”
“My Westendorf front-end loader is well designed and built heavy. Anyone who needs a loader should price one.
“My IBM Aptiva computer is also a best buy. It comes with Lotus spread sheets. I added a Brother printer which also faxes, copies, scans, and prints.
“I like my 1998 GM Sonoma pickup but I hate the automatic lights on it. The only way to turn them off is to hit them with a hammer.”
GM (general)
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“I’ve been using GM and Chevrolet pickups for years with good results. However, I experienced poor service and high maintenance with the 1996 to 2000 models, including electronic and fuel injector problems. I don’t plan to buy any more GM vehicles.”

“My Paslode framing nail gun is the handiest tool I’ve ever owned. It’s powered by a gas ‘fuel cell’. A single gas bottle will drive about 2,000 3-in. nails.”
Read the whole story →GM 3500 pickup equipped
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My 2004 GM Duramax HD 2500 pickup, equipped with an Allison transmission, is my best buy. I bought it used two years ago with about 28,000 miles on it. It has a lot of pulling power.
“My 1990 GM 3500 pickup equipped with a 454 cu. in. engine is also a best buy. It has more than 220,000 miles on it but is still going strong.”
“I’m happy with my Kioti DK35 tractor. It has eight speeds forward and backward. It starts easy in cold weather and is a pleasure to drive.
“I like my 2000 GM 3500 crew cab pickup equipped with dual wheels. It has more than 60,000 trouble-free miles on it.
“My 2005 DR pto-operated wood chipper can handle tree limbs up to 4 1/2 inches in diameter with no problems. It came with extra blades. No problems so far.”
GM Canyon extended cab
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My 2016 GM Canyon extended cab Duramax diesel pickup has about 40,000 miles on it with no problems. It gets 32 to 35 mpg on the highway and pulls a trailer loaded with a 40 hp. tractor with ease.”
Stanley likes his 2006 GM Canyon truck. “It has plenty of power to pass vehicles and to climb hills. We use it hard on our farm for hauling and towing, and it has survived our rough roads.
“My 2008 Arctic Cat ATV is made of cheap plastic, and one time while I was chasing cows the lights fell out.”
GM S15 pickup
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My worst buy is my 1998 Dodge Dakota pickup equipped with a 3.9-liter, V-6 engine. The bumpers rusted under the paint and bubbled out during the first year. That problem was repaired under warranty, but then the same problem happened again. The bolts snapped off on the exhaust manifold and also on both sides of the engine, and the upper ball joints wore out at about 30,000 miles. When I tried to change the spark plugs for the first time, the threads broke off in the engine. Now I’m just waiting for something else to go wrong. I never had any problems with the 1990 GM S15 pickup I owned previously. It was a much better vehicle.
“My Case 220 lawn tractor is my best buy. It’s probably more than 20 years old, but I’ve never had a problem with it. No other lawn tractor, including Deere models, compares to the quality of the old Case tractors.”
“It’s the best vehicle I’ve ever owned,” says John about his 1985 GM S-15 pickup which has more than 216,000 miles on it. “I’ve never replaced a front end part on it and it doesn’t cut tires like new Ford pickups do. It’s powered by a factory-installed 2.2-liter diesel engine. I park it in the same place every day on a concrete floor and there are no oil stains there at all. It doesn’t leak or burn oil. I can’t understand why the EPA doesn’t require more diesel engines in vehicles. They’re twice as fuel efficient as gas engines, and under Maryland emissions tests they’re considered non-polluting.
“My worst buy is my Coleman 7,000-watt generator which I bought a few years ago. For years it sat in my garage waiting for the time when I would really need it. Well, Hurricane Floyd came along and I really needed it. However, it ran only for about nine hours before it stopped working. I took it apart and found that the plastic cover that housed the end bearing had melted. I called the company and they said they still use this same plastic housing on their new generators. I wonder if the company’s engineers have ever had to depend on this generator the way I did.”
GM Sierra 1/2-ton pickup
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I like my 2009 GM Sierra 1/2-ton pickup. I salvage wood from barns and corn cribs as a business so this pickup has hauled a lot of big loads, yet it’s still performing well even with more than 120,000 miles on it.”
“I like my 2002 GM Sierra 1/2-ton pickup.
“In the fall of 2001 I bought a new 42-in. Yard Machine riding mower equipped with a Briggs & Stratton 14.5 hp overhead valve engine. I used it to cut grass for only about 15 minutes before it started smoking so bad that I couldn’t even see where I had already mowed. The dealer gave me a replacement model to use temporarily and tried to get Briggs & Stratton to send a new engine, but they refused.”
GM Sierra 1500 pickup
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“It has more than 95,000 miles on it but doesn’t use any oil and still has the original spark plugs,” says Charles, impressed with his 1992 GM Sierra 1500 pickup. “I use it to tow an 18-ft. trailer loaded with a Deere B tractor. This pickup still doesn’t have any rust and the paint on it looks like new. The only major repair it needed was replacement of a rear transmission seal.”
On the negative side, he lists his 1997 Pontiac Grand Am. “It has less than 50,000 miles on it, but already I’ve had to turn the brake drums and replace the front rotor and alternator. The dealer had to fix the headlights and service the engine sensors twice.”
William’s impressed with his 1989 GM Sierra 1500 pickup equipped with a gas engine. “It has more than 264,000 miles on it but still runs strong. It has needed only minor repairs over the years, although I did have to repaint it. I love this pickup and don’t ever want to give it up.”
GM Sierra 1500 4-WD 1/2-ton pickup
1 Best Buy1 Worst BuyEric’s the satisfied owner of a 2010 GM Sierra 1500 4-WD, 1/2-ton pickup. “So far everything on this pickup works perfect, with no design flaws.
“The Honda GX200 5 1/2 hp engine on my Johnson transfer auger won’t start in cold weather and the company can’t seem to fix it. I took it to the dealer and contacted company headquarters. The problem is a poor fitting choke valve. If anyone has a solution for this problem, please let me know.”
A 1985 TroyBilt rototiller rates as Thomas’s “best buy”. “I use it every year to plant 2 acres of onions, and it always starts on the first pull. I know I can count on this tiller year after year.”
He’s had electrical problems with his 2003 GM Sierra 1500 4-WD pickup. “The lights inside the cab and the headlights work only when they feel like it. At night, before I drive anywhere I have to start the pickup and set the emergency brake, then get out and walk to the front of the vehicle and bang on the headlights to get them to work. I have to do the same for the interior lights. The dealer and other shops in my area don’t have a clue what’s wrong.”
GM Sierra 1500 SLT crewcab pickup
2 Best Buys0 Worst BuysHe’s the owner of a 2019 GM Sierra 1500 SLT crewcab pickup. “It’s a very comfortable vehicle that gets exceptional fuel economy, and it pulls trailers quite well. My wife loves this pickup.”
Kurt’s impressed with his 2014 GM Sierra 1500 SLT all terrain 4-WD pickup equipped with a double cab. “It doesn’t handle like any pickup I’ve owned in the past – and I say that in a good way. The creature comforts, amenities, ride and handling on it are impressive, as is the torque and responsiveness of the 6.2-liter direct gas-injected engine.
“This pickup pulls like no other and still consistently gets more than 20 mpg on the highway at 60 mph. It has cylinder deactivation that isn’t recognizable except for the fact that you can view on a display that it’s running on 4 cylinders. If you’re in the market for a new pickup, take this one for a test drive.”
GM 1/2-ton 4-WD pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1987 Chevrolet 1/2-ton 4-WD pickup, 1990 GM 1/2-ton 4-WD pickup, and 1992 Chevrolet 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup are all best buys. I put about 185,000 miles on the 1987 Chevrolet model and sold it for half of its original new price. The GM model had about 232,000 miles on it when I sold it for $6,500. The 1992 Chevrolet model has about 165,000 miles on it and is still going strong. No engine repairs have been necessary on any of these vehicles. I used 15-40 Deere diesel oil in all three vehicles. We also own a 1995 GM Yukon that has about 84,000 miles on it, but we did have to repair the rear differential on it. However, I still think it’s a good vehicle.
“My worst buy is Armstrong self-adhesion floor tile. The glue on back of the tiles comes up through the joints. It never seems to dry which allows the tile to slide and opens the joints for months after it’s laid down. On the positive side, this tile is relatively inexpensive - about 50 cents per sq. foot. I guess you get what you pay for.”
GM 2500 4-WD 4-door extended cab pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysTim likes his 2000 GM 2500 4-WD 4-door extended cab pickup. “I really like the cab. It offers great access for extra passengers and is handy for keeping things inside out of the rain or snow. The engine has a lot of power and is fuel efficient. It has a push button 4-WD engagement switch which has saved me more than once in off-road conditions.
“My Computrol II planter monitor with hydraulic seed drive is a best buy (Fulk Planting Services, Platte City, Mo. ph 816 858-5836). I installed it on my Deere 1750 vacuum corn planter and got the best seed spacing I’ve ever had. The push button-operated, hydraulic population control is a great feature for varying soil types and for contest fields. I like how it displays the actual – not average – seed spacing to within 1/4 in. on the monitor screen. It’s a must if you plant corn and soybeans because it lets you adjust the planter to get the correct spacing before the crop emerges.”
GM 2500 Duramax
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Stihl 044 chainsaw starts after only a few pulls, and its cutting action makes it a real animal.
“My 2003 GM 2500 Duramax is a good, reliable pickup. I use restaurant grease and waste oil to power it, which saves a lot of money. I’ve noticed that the nearer to zero the fuel cost gets, the less mileage matters. A front wheel bearing went out at 60,000 miles, and an upper ball joint at 70,000 miles. But overall, it’s a good pickup.”
GM 2500 HD extended cab 4-wd
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2013 GM 2500 HD extended cab 4-WD pickup has never been to the dealer for any problems. It has a quiet, comfortable ride. The 6.0-liter engine has a lot of power but still gets 16 to 17 mpg.
“My DeWalt 18-volt cordless drill has very poor torque when drilling metal. Also, the batteries didn’t last long so I constantly had to buy new ones. I finally got rid of it and bought a Milwaukee model. Now I have a high torque drill with batteries that will last a long time.”
GM 2500 HD 4-WD pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDave’s happy with his 2003 GM 2500 HD 4-WD pickup equipped with an 8.1-liter gas engine and 5-speed Allison transmission. “This pickup has a lot of power and runs smooth. It’s totally reliable no matter what the job. Also, it’s not as tall and bulky as some of the newer trucks.”
GM 2500 Sierra extended cab pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My Ten-nessee walking horse never breaks down and is well tempered but spirited. It doesn’t affect the ozone or contribute to bad air. It’s always dependable, and always goes the distance. It has good brakes, starts easy, and accelerates fast.
“My 1994 GM 2500 Sierra extended cab pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter turbo diesel engine is a worst buy.
“This truck has a history of problems but the most recent was last November. I was driving home on a four-lane road at about 45 mph. As a stoplight went from green to yellow, I applied the brakes only to feel the brake pedal go rapidly to the floor. The brakes were gone, with no warning at all. I rolled through the red light still pressing the pedal hard to the floor and downshifting the automatic transmission.
“Lucky for me, the intersection wasn’t busy. I found out the brakes failed due to rapid fluid leakage. After getting the truck home, I discovered a hole in a metal brake line behind the fuel tank. There was no kind of backup braking at all.
“I called GM to let them know and hopefully prevent someone else from having the same problem, but I really don’t expect to hear back from them.”
GM 3.1
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2006 P & J 36-ft. gooseneck trailer has good quality paint, nice ramps that are easy to use, good quality landing gear, and quality deck material.
“GM 3.1 and 3.4 V-6 engines made from 1996 to 2002 have experienced failure of intake gaskets and head gaskets. They seem to have problems between 70,000 and 100,000 miles. Repair costs are $700 or more. If you ignore the coolant loss, you’ll lose the engine. Some blame GM’s Dex-Cool; others blame poor design. I’ve done so many intake gaskets in my auto repair shop that I think I can do it blind folded.”
Gabe Aquirre, Blue Diamond Glass Co.,
GM 3/4-ton 2-door pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2001 GM 3/4-ton 2-door pickup equipped with a Duramax engine is my best buy. It averages 18 mpg in city driving, about 17 mpg on the highway, and about 14 mpg when pulling a trailer. It has more than 97,000 miles on it but has required only routine maintenance. The engine has unbelievable power, and the Allison transmission is the best. The only problem is the high price of diesel fuel.”
GM 3/4-ton 4-WD pickups
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysJohn’s impressed with his 1997 Yamaha Big Bear 4-wheel ATV. “I don’t know what we did before we bought this ATV. We use it for almost everything. We had a few minor problems with it, but the dealer promptly took care of them.
“Over the years I’ve bought three different GM 3/4-ton 4-WD pickups and they’ve all been best buys. They’ve all been reliable and needed only a few minor repairs.
“My 1997 PMI 1511 round baler is my worst buy. The drive sprocket fell off and one end of the baler pickup fell off causing it to fold up like an accordion. The pickup had to be replaced and the company wouldn’t help at all. After I got it back the rollers started scraping, hydraulic cylinders broke, and some bearings gave out. I finally replaced it with a New Holland 664 baler.”
GM 3500 1-ton pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 1996 International 4900 truck is my best buy. It has required only routine maintenance with no major problems.
“My 2000 GM 3500 1-ton pickup is my worst buy. It’s equipped with a Vortec 350 engine which went out at about 60,000 miles. The fuel injector failed twice, causing the engine to go bad. Also, gas got into the oil as I was driving down the highway. Fortunately, I have an extended warranty on this vehicle.”
GM 4-door dually pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It had about 135,000 miles on it when I bought it, and now has about 402,000 miles,” says John about his 1994 GM 4-door dually pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter diesel engine and automatic transmission. “The engine was replaced at about 68,000 miles. I change the oil and filter every 2,500 miles. I rebuilt the transmission once myself and rebuilt all the front suspension. I’ve put on a couple water pumps and changed the fuel injectors once. The engine has never had the injector pump or turbocharger replaced. It gets about 15 mpg.”
GM Brigadier tandem diesel truck
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“One of our best buys was a used 1979 GM Brigadier tandem diesel truck equipped with an automatic transmission and 20-ft. grain box. It’s easy to operate - anyone can drive it.
“Our worst buy was a Flexi-Coil 820 cultivator. We bought the cultivator new along with a new Flexi-Coil 1720 air tank in the fall of 1994 for use in seeding the following year. We traded in an Eclipse 700 cultivator equipped with a 1110 air tank.
“When we started seeding peas with the unit, we found right away that the machine wasn’t planting at a uniform depth. Seed depth ranged from 0 to 5 in. all across the machine. We stopped seeding and contacted our dealer, who in turn contacted the company. After numerous attempts over a 4-year period by the combined forces of the specialists of both New Holland and Flexi-Coil, the machine was finally made to seed fairly level. However, due to the uneven seeding depth of the machine, we suffered a tremendous crop loss and consequently a large financial loss as well, on 200 plus seeded acreage.
“Rather than taking responsibility for the loss we suffered, the company chooses to attack my farming practices and my own lack of ability to level the machine, even though the specialists of both the dealer and manufacturer were unable to do so. The company also stated that if the machine wasn’t satisfactory I should have bought a replacement machine.
“We feel it’s the responsibility of the dealer and manufacturer to be sure that the machines they sell do the job that it was meant to do, and that the responsibility of making the initial settings should be done by the dealer and manufacturer experts. We also feel that it’s very unfair to expect us to do things that the specialized factory and dealer personnel can’t do. I’d like to hear from anyone with a similar experience or any comments regarding our situation.”
GM C 1500
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2019 Ford F-150 pickup rides 10 times better than my 2014 GMC 1500, and I sure hope the brakes and rotors last longer. I’ve owned 3 different GM 1500’s in the last 10 years, and the brakes and rotors didn’t last much more than 28,000 miles on any of them.”
GM C-2500 pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysJack’s 1998 GM C-2500 pickup has more than 383,000 miles on it, and he still drives it every day. “This pickup has performed well over the years with only minor problems. I have no plans to replace it any time soon, and everything on it still works as it should.
“My 2011 Sears 22-in. push mower had a lot of problems. First there was an oil leak, then there were carburetor problems. To change oil you have to turn the machine over on its side to pour the oil out through the dipstick tube. There’s no drain plug.”
GM C-70 truck equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1988 GM C-70 truck equipped with a fuel-pinching diesel engine is my best buy. I use it for dump truck operations in the worst possible conditions. After 10 years the only repairs have been two sets of belts and one radiator repair. I ordered this truck with the heaviest possible chassis. It was very expensive but proved to be cheap in the long run.”
GM Canyon 4-WD pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s a handy truck for doing small jobs,” says Dale about his 2010 GM Canyon 4-WD pickup. “This pickup is dependable even though I did have to replace the water pump, and it drives extremely well. It has about 125,000 miles on it and seems to be holding up well considering how much I use it.”
On the negative side, he lists his 2010 Ford F-250 Super Duty 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.4-liter diesel engine. “Its fuel economy is terrible, especially when pulling trailers. So far this year it’s getting only 9.2 miles per gallon.
“I’ve had endless problems with sensors, the 4-WD system, a leaky radiator, broken intake manifold bolts, torn seats, broken brake calipers, and a hole burned through the exhaust manifold. I have to admit this pickup does pull well when it’s not in the shop. But I can barely afford to operate it.”
GM Canyon Denali pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It rides like a high-priced car and has all the bells and whistles I’ll ever need,” says Michael, happy with his 2018 GM Canyon Denali pickup. “It’s equipped with a 4-cyl. turbocharged diesel engine that gets 25 to 30 mpg and is rated to tow up to 7,700 lbs., so it can tow my car trailer with ease. With 181 hp. and 275 lbs to ft. of torque, this pickup should last a long time.”
GM Duramax 1-ton pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I like my 2006 Ski-Doo Skandic SWT snowmobile. We built some 4-ski sleds to pull behind it and then used them to haul 2,000-lb. loads 50 miles into the Brooks Range of Alaska. No other machine I know of could have done this with the ease this machine did the job. I’ve owned snowmobiles since the mid 1960’s, but nothing compares to this one.
“I bought my 2005 GM Duramax 1-ton pickup used with less than 70,000 miles on it, but it has had a number of electrical issues. First, the transmission went bad, then the fuel transfer pump quit while I was on a trip up north where I really needed both fuel tanks. Over the years I’ve had to limp home twice on failsafe mode.”
GM Duramax 3500 pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysMike bought a used 2004 GM Duramax 3500 pickup equipped with an Allison transmission. After three months and about 30,000 miles, he says it’s his “best buy”. “It’s a nice truck with a lot of power for big trailers and on hills. My only complaint is that I wish it was more fuel efficient. It gets only about 13 mpg.”
GM Duramax HD 2500 pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2004 GM Duramax HD 2500 pickup, equipped with an Allison transmission, is my best buy. I bought it used two years ago with about 28,000 miles on it. It has a lot of pulling power.
“My 1990 GM 3500 pickup equipped with a 454 cu. in. engine is also a best buy. It has more than 220,000 miles on it but is still going strong.”
GM Envoy
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I’m well satisfied with my 1985 Massey Ferguson 1040 diesel tractor equipped with a Massey Ferguson 232 front-end loader. And I like my 1998 Deere 425 garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck. Both tractors are well-built and have required only routine maintenance.”
On the minus side, “The transmission on my 2001 Ford Escape failed at 51,000 miles. It happened when I was 250 miles from home and after the warranty had expired. The transmission cost $3,300 to repair and was at the dealer for 2 1/2 weeks. I also had to spend $400 on a rental car while the vehicle was in the shop. I immediately replaced the Ford with a 2003 GM Envoy, which I really like. However, just in case anything goes wrong I bought it with an extended 100,000-mile warranty.”
GM Envoy XL
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1991 Deere LX178 lawn tractor equipped with a water-cooled engine has worn out 2 mower decks, yet has required only routine maintenance. It still doesn’t use any oil.
“My GM Envoy XL has more than 92,000 miles on it and is a best buy.”
GM Geo Metro 4-door car
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1995 GM Geo Metro 4-door car is my best buy. It drives like a dream and is very fuel efficient at 50 mpg. It starts good and has front wheel drive so it handles well even on icy roads.”
GM Jimmy Sierra Classic
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I’m well pleased with my 1996 MigMaster 250 wire-feed welder made by ESAB. It costs considerably less than big name welders yet does twice as good a job. It offers phenomenal flexibility in switching from heavy to light metals. I can use it to do heavy welding and then switch to welding thin car body tin. “My worst buy is my 1988 GM Jimmy Sierra Classic. One reason is that it uses way too much fuel. Another is that the paint came off but the company won’t do anything about it even though they admit the paint job was faulty. So we drive it without paint to help advertise for GM.”
GM Jimmy SLE
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“It pulls easy and does a good job of placing seed in all conditions. It’s also almost maintenance-free,” says Jeff about his Deere 750 no-till drill.
On the negative side, he’s not happy with his 1997 GM Jimmy SLE. “When we drove it off the lot the cruise control didn’t work and it was in the shop for five days before they were able to find the problem.”
GM K1500 4-WD extended cab pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysMaurice likes his 1995 Bourgault 3195 air seeder which he uses with a 1989 Bourgault 536-40 field cultivator. “The air seeder has performed well and the tank is easy to clean out; however, setting and verifying the seeding rate is a bit time consuming. The cultivator has good trash clearance and few parts that can wear out. “My 1996 GM K1500 4-WD extended cab pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in. Vortec engine is a fine truck except that it has a real thirst for gas. It averages only 18 to 19 mpg. I think it should get 22 mpg. “Our 1987 Versatile 2000 pull-type combine does a good job. It has a lot of capacity and is easy to set except in flax. The company had the right idea as far as combine design goes, but they should have beefed up the machine so that it would stand up better. We use a 165 hp tractor to pull it and haven’t had any serious problems. However, other farmers who use higher horsepower tractors to pull the same combine have had considerable problems. Deere is now making a combine similar in design to this one.”
GM K1500 Z60 crew cab pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I’m well pleased with my 2012 GM K1500 Z60 crew cab pickup. It gets more than 18 mpg on short trips and 22 mpg on the highway. I drove this pickup in our local Christmas parade and got several compliments on its looks.”
GM K2500 4-WD pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA 1999 Polaris 300 4-wheeler rates as Randy’s “best buy”. “I use it for everything from dragging our driveway to spraying crops, checking fields, and hauling rocks. I haven’t had to spend anything on repairs. All I do is keep it filled with gas.
“My 1993 GM K2500 4-WD pickup was one of my worst buys ever. In the first 9-month’s during which I drove 9,000 miles, I had to replace two engines, a rear end, a transmission, and a computer part. On the day I bought the pickup, the muffler fell off before I even got home.”
GM K2500 Sierra pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysGene has about 320,000 trouble-free miles on his 1995 GM K2500 Sierra pickup. “The engine has never been worked on, and all I’ve replaced are the brake pads and tires. I live at an elevation of about 8,500 ft. so I do almost all mountain driving.”
GM S10 pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1997 GM S10 pickup, equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and manual transmission, had about 114,000 miles when I bought it. I paid $4,000 for it. It’s small, lightweight, easy to maintain, and fuel efficient.”
GM S-15 4-WD pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1991 GM S-15 4-WD pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine is my best buy. I bought it used in 1995 with 42,000 miles on it. Today it has more than 233,000 miles. One summer I hit two deer. Both times it cost more than $3,000 for repairs to the front end. However, neither the engine nor the transmission have ever needed work. It’s the best vehicle I’ve ever owned.”
GM Scottsdale 3500 pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysChester’s pleased with his 2003 GM Scottsdale 3500 pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison automatic transmission. “This is the quietest, easiest riding pickup I’ve driven in years. It has all the power I need to pull my 7 and 20-ft. trailers even when they’re loaded. It starts great in cold weather and performs well in the hottest weather. It gets only about 11 mpg which isn’t good enough, but in every other way it’s a great pickup.”
GM Sierra 1500 4-door pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My best buy is my 2000 GM Sierra 1500 4-door pickup. It’s a smart looking, good riding, and good driving pickup with a quiet cab. It’s also easy on fuel and has comfortable seats.
“Our Troyer V-top trap is also a best buy. We bought it last May and have already trapped 150 sparrows with it. We’re very happy with it.”
GM Sierra 1500 Kodiak z71 crew cab
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s a pleasure to operate and is fuel efficient,” says Mac about his 2015 GM Sierra 1500 Kodiak Z71 crew cab pickup.
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2014 Dodge Ram 1500 quad cab 4-WD pickup equipped with an EcoDiesel engine. “I bought this pickup because it was advertised to get 30 mpg. However, a year after I bought it and with about 20,000 miles the EcoDiesel engine started hammering as if a main bearing had failed.
“The dealer told me to drive the pickup in for inspection, but I never made it because the engine blew about halfway there. He said metal shards in the oil filter had caused the oil pressure to drop, and he ordered a new engine on October 18. However, I didn’t get the pickup back until December 4 and by that time I already had my Sierra.”
GM Sierra 2500 heavy-duty pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysGary’s impressed with his 2009 GM Sierra 2500 heavy-duty pickup equipped with a 6.6-liter turbo diesel engine and an Allison automatic transmission. “It performs great and has plenty of torque and power to pull our 9,000-lb. fifth wheel trailer through Colorado mountains with ease.
“At about 33,000 miles we were driving on a 2-lane highway when we heard a very loud noise. The vehicle suddenly lost all power, and I had to stop and pull over to the side of the road. It was a scary moment because at the time I was trying to pass someone. The engine still idled but I could only creep along at about 15 mph.
“Then I looked under the hood and found that a rubber hose had blown off the turbo. I put the hose back on and then drove to the dealer, who saw that the turbo was dirty and greasy and replaced it under warranty.”
GM Sierra 3/4-ton 4-WD supercab longbed pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2000 GM Sierra 3/4-ton 4-WD supercab longbed pickup became a worst buy when cracks developed in the box corners just behind the cab. These cracks developed at about 16,000 miles and eventually cost me $1,600 to have repaired. GM takes no responsibility, blaming poor road conditions, which I think is ridiculous. We’ve lived and farmed in this same location for 30 years and never had this problem with my last four GM pickups. The problem seems to be common, so I recommend other 1999 to 2003 owners check closely with a mirror - your headache rack/canopy may be the only thing holding your box together.”
GM Sierra 3500 4-WD dump truck equipped
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My worst buy is my GM Sierra 3500 4-WD dump truck equipped with a Duramax diesel engine. Within 11,000 miles I have had each fuel pump replaced at least once. I’m on my third set of front tires, due to a broken ball joint when I bought the vehicle. Also, I’ve been towed twice after running out of fuel because when the fuel pumps fail they short out the fuel gauge. Worst of all, I’ve been without a work truck for 45 days this year because of all the time this truck has been in the shop.
“My Sirius Satellite radio adds a new dimension to both long and short road trips. There’s a tremendous variety of programming to listen to and I rarely lose the satellite signal, even in the mountains of West Virginia.”
GM Sierra Classic pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I’ve been driving it since the fall of 1976 with very little downtime,” says Dennis, pleased with his 1977 GM Sierra Classic pickup. “The transmission was rebuilt in 1989 and the engine was replaced in 1991. In 1994, the front fenders and the doors were replaced because of rust and it also received a new paint job. Now it needs new tires again, but it’s well worth the cost.”
GM Sierra Classis 1500
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA 1998 Deere 5410 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader and a cab, air conditioner, and heater rates as Charles’ “best buy”.
He’s also happy with his Deere 425 garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck. “It’s a 20 hp model so it has a lot of power for mowing my lawn. It has reduced my mowing time by up to one hour compared to the 18 hp mower I had been using.
“My 1999 GM Sierra Classis 1500 series pickup has performed exactly as I expected. It’s a best buy.”
GM Sierra Duramax 3500 diesel pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My Porter-Cable 10-amp Tiger Saw has plenty of power to do any job and is my best buy. It’s priced below $100.
“I only use my 2004 GM Sierra Duramax 3500 diesel pickup on the highway but at 4,060 miles the turbocharger failed, ruining the engine. The dealer and GM fought over who would pay for repairs, and I was in the middle. It took 40 days to replace the engine and turbocharger and I took a big financial loss. This pickup is on call seven days a week for emergencies.”
GM Sierra K1500 pickup rides
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1981 IH 986 tractor has required mostly just routine maintenance. I used it as my tillage tractor at first, but now I use it for planting and mowing.
“My 2016 GM Sierra K1500 pickup rides and handles nice. It’s more fuel efficient than my previous 2013 model, which was also a great pickup.”
GM Sierra Meteor 350 3/4-ton 2-wd
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysEugene nominates his 1994 GM Sierra Meteor 350 3/4-ton, 2-WD pickup equipped with a 5-speed manual transmission as “best buy”. “I put a new clutch in at about 150,000 miles. I drive this pickup every day in my sales job. I drove it until the end of 2003 when I purchased a new Chevy pickup. When I stopped driving the 1994 model it had about 497,000 miles on it but still had the original drive train. The engine had never been worked on. My 2003 model already has more than 153,000 miles on it, and I think it’ll go at least 500,000 miles, too.”
GM Sierra SLE 4-WD model equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s the best riding pickup I’ve ever owned,” says Phil about his 2008 GM Sierra SLE 4-WD model equipped with an extended cab. “It gets good mileage and has more than enough power. It’s powered by the old 327 engine that was the best of its time. My 1999 Chevrolet Tahoe rides nice and gets good mileage, and my 2002 Dodge Ram diesel pickup is excellent in every category.”
GM Silverado pickup equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2007 GM Silverado pickup equipped with a diesel engine and Allison transmission is my best buy. It pulls loads well and is fuel efficient.”
GM SLE extended cab 4-wd
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA 1989 GM SLE extended cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6.2-liter diesel engine rates as his “worst buy”. It has more than 156,000 miles on it. “I bought it used in 1996 and had to replace the alternator, water pump, vacuum pump, and injection pump. I had to replace the fuel pump twice. I also had to replace a lot of other stuff including the 5-speed automatic transmission. My total cost was about $6,000. It all went to waste when a cheaply-made oil cooler line popped out of the engine and the lack of oil ruined it.”
GM SLE 2500 4-door quad cab 3/4-ton
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I’m well satisfied with my 2007 GM SLE 2500 4-door quad cab 3/4-ton pickup.
“I also like my 2004 Massey Ferguson 9790 self-propelled combine. No problems. I use it to harvest wheat, rye, oats, barley, and peas. Visibility is good and it handles well. It has a lot of power.”
GM SLT 1500 4-WD suv
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I bought my 2000 GM SLT 1500 4-WD SUV as a backup model for winter use. I’m impressed with its large size and the available options such as auto select, 4-WD, electric windows and mirrors, cruise control, and stereo. This SUV is fuel efficient and handles great in bad weather. The leather interior is well made and durable.”
GM Sonoma 4-WD 4-door pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My worst buy ever is my 2003 GM Sonoma 4-WD 4-door pickup. I bought it new off the lot and have treated it like a baby ever since, but last week at only about 48,000 miles one of the front wheel bearing hubs went out and had to be replaced at a cost of almost $500. Before that, at about 40,000 miles, both front lower ball joints had to be replaced at a cost of $525.
“This pickup is stored inside when not in use. It has never been used for 4-wheeling and has had all the recommended service called for in the operator’s manual. In the past I owned a 1989 Nissan pickup that went about 286,000 miles, and all I replaced on it were the spark plugs.”
GM Sonoma SLS extended cab pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysAdolph’s “best buy” is his 1994 GM Sonoma SLS extended cab pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter 6-cyl. engine. “It’s a joy to drive and has power windows, power door locks, a tilt steering wheel, and cruise control. It has almost 50,000 miles with hardly any problems. Comfortable seats and handy controls.”
GM Terrain SUV rides
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2015 GM Terrain SUV rides and drives nice, but I’ve had problems with mice. They get into the car’s ventilation system through a flimsy air filter that’s supposed to keep the air clean, then find their way to the blower fan and get mangled by the fan blades. The stench of the dead mouse then blows into the vehicle. They also crawl inside the vehicle and chew up the interior.
“One time mice stored some dog food in the ventilation system, and the fan blew it onto the passenger side floor. My dealer’s only advice is to mouse-proof my garage, but I said maybe GM should just mouse-proof their vehicles. Why should I have to ride in a newer vehicle that smells like the inside of an old mouse-infected shack?”
GM Tracker equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1990 GM Tracker equipped with a 3-speed automatic transmission is built tough. I’ve put more than 125,000 miles on it and the only repairs have been to replace two valve cover gaskets and a muffler and tailpipe. I use it every day on the highway and as a 4-wheeler for hunting in the fall. It also gets a workout on the farm. It still has the original brakes and shocks.”
GM Yukon sports utility vehicle
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My worst buy is my 1998 GM Yukon sports utility vehicle. It gets only 13.9 mpg, has a very uncomfortable driver’s seat, sways a lot going down the road, and has a poor paint job. Another problem is that air leaks around the passenger door.”
GM Z71 pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysKevin’s the satisfied owner of a 2015 Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison transmission. “It had only one minor problem when the DEF tank heater quit working, but the dealer promptly repaired it under warranty. This pickup consistently got more than 20 mpg and pulled heavy loads with ease. At about 143,000 miles I traded it for a 2018 model just like it.
“My 2005 Kubota 3830 4-WD tractor equipped with a Bush Hog front-end loader has been almost trouble-free. It has a lot of power and the loader works well. The battery lasted until 2018. I’ve never had a battery last that long in any other equipment.
“I like my 2006 Exmark Lazer Z 60-in. zero-turn riding mower equipped with a Kohler engine. Over the years I’ve owned 5 other zero-turn mower brands - Bush Hog, Grasshopper, Bad Boy, Hustler, and Woods - but this one outperforms all of them.
“My dad bought his 1997 GM Z71 pickup in the fall of 1996, and I got it from him the fall of 1997 when he traded for a new model. I’ve put more than 200,000 miles on this pickup, but the engine still doesn’t use any oil and the transmission has never been touched. It has gone through several electric fuel pumps and numerous sets of brakes and rotors. I’ve used it to pull very heavy loads, some more than 10,000 lbs., with no problems. I wish I could buy a new pickup just like this one.”
He’s had problems with his 2015 Retrax retractable pickup bed cover. “Gallons of water leaked into the bed. One time my portable toolbox slid forward while I was braking, and it dented the tray that the bed cover rolls up into. That made it difficult to open and close. That tray should be out of the way of shifting cargo.”
GM Z71 Sierra 1/2-ton extended cab pickup
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2000 GM Z71 Sierra 1/2-ton extended cab pickup equipped with a 5.3-liter, V-8 engine and automatic transmission is my best buy. It rides great and has a “Tow-Haul” transmission mode which allows it to tow very well. I use it to pull loaded 16-ft. livestock trailers over country roads. The only negative is that I don’t like the lights coming on automatically. Also, sometimes cows inside the trailer shake the pickup enough while it’s parked to set off the pickup’s theft alarm.”
GM extended cab 1/2-ton
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s equipped with a Vortec 305 cu. in. engine that has a lot of power and is easy on fuel,” says Greg about his 1997 GM extended cab 1/2-ton 2-WD pickup. “It has needed only regular maintenance. The cab is nicely laid out. The back seat can be a little tight for bigger people but is still handy. If this pickup keeps on performing like it has, my next pickup will definitely be another GM.”
On the negative side, “The pickup came factory-equipped with Goodyear Tiger Paw Uniroyal tires which were awful. I hated them from the start and replaced them at 20,000 miles. They had no ‘bite’ at all and would squeal whenever I turned, even if I turned slowly.”
GM extended cab 2-wd
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The engine on my 1991 GM extended cab 2-WD pickup went out at about 220,000 miles, so I installed a rebuilt GM engine which is still going strong at about 350,000 miles. This pickup still has the original transmission and shocks and has required only routine maintenance. Over the years I’ve replaced three alternators and two starters. It gets 20 to 21 mpg.
“My 1993 Toyota 4-WD pickup works unbelievably well. I bought it used 12 years ago with about 85,000 miles on it and now it has about 125,000 miles. It’ll go almost anywhere and just keeps on running.
“The Warn winch on my 2005 Honda ATV is my worst buy. The cable pulled over the side of the drum, rendering the winch useless and leaving 30 ft. of cable laying out which broke the main shaft across the winch. I got that problem fixed, but then the next time I used the winch the cable wrapped around the gun rack.
“I use my 1986 Honda 250 2 by 4 Fourtrax for hunting and trail riding. This machine has been trouble-free and works unbelievably well. I sold it in 2005 for the same money I paid for it and bought a 2005 Honda 500 4 by 4 Foreman. The Foreman is carrying on where the other one left off and just keeps on running. It burns about a third as much fuel as a Polaris of the same size. It’s a great machine.”
GM heavy duty 3/4-ton
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1990 GM heavy duty 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in., V-8 engine and 400 turbo automatic transmission is my best buy. I drove my first 1990 GM pickup from 1994 to 2006. It had 400,000 miles on it, and half the time I used it to pull a trailer. Then last August I bought a second 1990 GM pickup, with 140,000 miles on it. It’s the exact same pickup. Parts are cheap, and the average farmer can still fix whatever goes wrong. We’re using the pickup that we bought in 1994 for parts.”
GM extended cab 4-wd
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Our 1995 GM extended cab 4-WD pickup starts poor, is hard on fuel, and shifts hard. One time it stopped on the road for no apparent reason. The 4-WD never has worked, even after it was repaired. “Our Gleaner R62 combine is underpowered and has weak concaves and a poor stone trap.”
GM extended cab
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysPaul’s impressed with his 1996 GM extended cab, 3/4-ton longbed pickup equipped with a 454 cu. in. engine and automatic transmission. “It has about 150,000 miles on it but doesn’t show any rust or use any oil, and the interior is clean with no tears. I use this pickup to pull a tri-axle trailer loaded with either a skid loader or a tractor no problem.”
On the negative side, he lists his 2005 Ford 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6-liter diesel engine and automatic transmission. “At about 75,000 miles the engine had to be repaired at a cost of $1,700. The rotors and calipers have been replaced twice, the brake and transmission lines had to be replaced because of rust, and the rocker panels and wheel wells also rusted out. The front seat had to be replaced because of ripped seams, and the pickup’s pollution control equipment needed major work.
“The second set of tires was almost worn out when I finally traded this $40,000 pickup for just $7,000. It was only the second Ford I’ve owned in 50 years. I wonder why?”
GM heavy duty
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The 1990 GM heavy duty, 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup I bought used now has about 174,000 miles on it. People marvel at the way this pickup can pull a 600-bu. load of corn out of the field. It’s a good, solid pickup.
“I like my Massey 1105, 275 and 285 tractors. They’re all equipped with fuel-saving Perkins diesel engines.”
GM pickup equipped
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 1967 Cub Cadet 125 riding mower is my best buy. I bought it used in 1968 and have used it every year to mow my pasture and yard. It has been a trouble-free machine. It’s powered by a 12 hp engine that has been overhauled once and is still going strong.”
On the negative side, “My 2003 GM pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine is my worst buy ever. Over the years I’ve owned 12 different GM pickups, and they were all equipped with V-8 engines that were reasonably fuel efficient, averaging 19 to 20 mpg. However, the 6-cyl. engine on this pickup gets only about 12 mpg.”
GM vehicles
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My best buys have been my GM vehicles, including a 2008 Equinox (over 120K), a 2000 1/2-ton GMC (over 160K), a 1998 3/4-ton Silverado (over 200K), and a 1992 1/2-ton Silverado (over 140K). They just keep going.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.