Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002)

47 reports from pages 14–16 · 42 Best Buys14 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

John Deere 20 hp

Lee Schafer, Houston, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“Everything on this tractor works really well and is simple to operate,” says Lee, impressed with his 2002 Deere 20 hp GT 245 garden tractor. “I use it with a 30-in. tiller, 48-in. blade, and 54-in. mower deck. This tractor is built heavy and is easy to service. Also, it’s easy to change implements.”

Best Buy

Kubota 4-WD model equipped

Loyd A. Cline, Walnut-Cove, N.C. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“I’m well pleased with this tractor and haven’t had any problems with it,” says Loyd about his 1998 Kubota 4-WD model equipped with a front-end loader. “I used it to clear about five acres of land. It has done a lot of work that I didn’t think it could do.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere tractors + 2 more

Doug Reich, Versailles, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“All of our Deere tractors have been best buys, including a 4450, 4430, 8100, 4020, 2640, and 5520. All of them are easy to operate and reliable, strong performers. The people who designed these tractors put a lot of thought into what they were doing.

“My 1997 Arctic Cat 454 Bearcat ATV is my worst buy. It has had numerous electrical problems and has already gone through seven bal joints. The CV boots split within the first year, and the front end started chattering after only about 18 months. Also, the machine went through a lot of spark plugs, the fan motor burned up, a brake cable locked up, and the gear shifter splines wore out. Resale is terrible”.

“My International Harvester 585 has been a reliable tractor but you tend to forget that after you sit on it awhile because of the lousy ergonomics. Also, this tractor is terribly underpowered.”

Worst Buy

Briggs & Stratton gas engine

Terry W. Loy, Batesburg, S.C. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“The company wouldn’t stand behind the warranty,” says Terry, unhappy with the Briggs & Stratton gas engine on his lawn mower. “In June 2001 I bought a Swisher 60-in. trailing mower equipped with a Briggs & Stratton gas engine. I pull the mower behind a lawn tractor equipped with a 42-in. deck and use it to cut 4 1/2 acres of grass. From the beginning, this engine used 2 to 4 oz. of 30W Valvoline oil every time I cut the lawn, even though I followed the maintenance schedules and instructions in the owner’s manual.

“At the beginning of this year the engine started to use more oil and smoke was coming out of the exhaust. Then it started blowing oil up into the air cleaner. After replacing the air cleaner several times and trying 40W oil for a couple of mowing jobs, I made a wet and dry compression check. I found the pressure was a lot higher when the engine was hot than when it was dry. So I contacted Wisconsin Magneto, the warranty representative for Briggs & Stratton. The engine has a two-year warranty and was worn out in less than a year. Yet they said they wouldn’t honor the warranty because of lack of proper maintenance.

“I was given a phone number to call at Briggs & Stratton so that I could appeal the warranty rejection. Meanwhile, I had to buy a new engine so I could keep up with my yard.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 pickup equipped

Kenneth Wilde, Fortuna, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“It’s easy on fuel, has a lot of power, and rides and handles great,” says Kenneth about his 1994 Dodge Ram 1500 pickup equipped with a V-6 engine. “I bought the pickup used two years ago and have over 124,000 miles on it now. The only trouble I had was with the starter, which I had to replace. Now the engine will start no matter how cold the weather gets. It doesn’t use a bit of oil.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Duramax 1-ton 4-WD pickup equipped

Willie Worthy, Euaro, Mont. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“My 2001 Chevrolet Duramax 1-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. Compared to the ‘97 Dodge it replaced, this Chevy has more power and stability, better brakes, and is easier on fuel. It gets 12 mpg at 75 mph when towing a 13,000-lb. load, and 22 mpg at speeds up to 75 mph without a load.”

Best Buy

Kubota 3010 HST tractor

Kenneth E. Caffrey, Polson, Mont. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

Kenneth likes his Kubota 3010 HST tractor. “I’m retired from farming. I appreciate this tractor because it’s easy to handle. The hydrostatic transmission is controlled by foot pedals so I can go forward or backward without having to use my hands. Cold weather is hard on me so I added a cab and heater. I use the tractor with a box scraper, Bush Hog mower, front-end loader, and backhoe. All of these implements work good.”

Worst Buy

Sloan Express

Gary Snyder, Marionville, Mo. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

Gary had trouble with replacement no-till planter opener discs sold by Sloan Express (120 Nth College, Assumption, Ill. 62510 ph 800 934-9777). “These disc assemblies should not be sold for no-till use. The bearing isn’t adequately supported and wallows out of the housing that contains it.”

Best Buy

John Deere 335 lawn

Mike Myers, Fredonia, Kansas · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Mike’s the satisfied owner of a 2000 Deere 335 lawn and garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. deck. “The tractor is powered by a 20 hp Kawasaki engine and handles anything we throw at it. We use it to mow lawns for many local homeowners, churches, and businesses. It always cuts a smooth, even swath and is easy to handle and maintain.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere chain saw equipped + 1 more

Tim King, Pegram, Tenn. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

“I like my Deere chain saw equipped with a 20-in. bar and chain. It does an excellent job and always starts right up on the first pull. I’ve never had to work on it other than to do normal cleaning and maintenance. It just keeps begging for more work.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1999 Troy-bilt “Bronco” rear tine tiller. “If you happen to snag a root, the tiller swings you around and your hands get stuck on the handles. I paid $740 for it and used it only twice for a total of four hours. I complained to Lowes, the home improvement retailer where I bought the machine, and also to the manufacturer. They both said ‘tough luck’ I’ll never buy another Troy-bilt product again.”

Best Buy

John Deere 1770 16-row no-till planter + 1 more

Larry Gregerson, Herman, Neb. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Larry’s impressed with his 2002 Deere 1770 16-row no-till planter. “I can fold the planter from the tractor cab. Once it’s folded, it’s no wider than the dual wheels on my tractor. The company sent people from the factory to monitor the planter’s performance in the field and to evaluate some minor changes and updates. Support has been great.

“My 2001 Deere 9650 STS combine does a fine job. It has plenty of capacity for my 8-row corn head and 25-ft. platform.”

Best Buy

Case backhoe

Lorin Peters, Greenfield, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

“My son mounted a Case backhoe on a 4-wheel trailer that we had been using to haul our skid steer loader. All we do is hook it up to our International Harvester 1066 tractor and it’s ready to go. We use it to install water lines. Works fine and has saved us many hours of hard work and expense.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Mil-Stack bale loader + 1 more

Pat Field, Pendroy, Mont. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Pat’s the satisfied owner of a 2002 Mil-Stack bale loader for handling mid-size square bales weighing up to 1,600 lbs. (Mil-Stak, Inc., 1350 Glenway, Fruitland, Idaho 83619 ph 208 452-6045). It works perfect and lets one person pile a lot of bales in a hurry. We mounted it on our New Holland 1068 automatic bale stack wagon, which we had been using to load and unload small square bales.

The add-on attachment picks up bales in the field and loads them onto the stack wagon. To switch back to small square bales, you simply unbolt the unit and replace the original small square bale loader.

“This bale picker speeds things up a lot,” says Field.

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2001 Dodge Durango equipped with a 4.7-liter engine. “It drives nice but gets only 13 1/2 to 14 mpg, which I think is terrible. We previously owned a 1998 Durango equipped with a 5.2-liter engine and it got 14 1/2 mpg. The smaller engine should do better. My old 1972 Dodge pickup equipped with a 400 cu. in. engine gets 12 mpg, and it’s 30 years old.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Polaris 300 4-wheeler + 1 more

Randy Edwards, Kenmore, N. Dak. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

A 1999 Polaris 300 4-wheeler rates as Randy’s “best buy”. “I use it for everything from dragging our driveway to spraying crops, checking fields, and hauling rocks. I haven’t had to spend anything on repairs. All I do is keep it filled with gas.

“My 1993 GM K2500 4-WD pickup was one of my worst buys ever. In the first 9-month’s during which I drove 9,000 miles, I had to replace two engines, a rear end, a transmission, and a computer part. On the day I bought the pickup, the muffler fell off before I even got home.”

Worst Buy

Buell M2 motorcycle

Tom Woods, Graham, Wash. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Tom’s the owner of a 1999 Buell M2 motorcycle which he says is his “worst buy”. “The motorcycle itself works good, but parts for it are all but impossible to get. I’m still waiting for touch-up paint that I paid for two months ago.”

Best Buy

Cox Row Zone

Melvin Knaack, Gladbrook, Iowa · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

“My best buy is the 1992 Cox Row Zone unit that I pull ahead of my planter. It’s a one-trip planting system that carries most of the fertilizer load. The Cox frame and planter raise and lower independently. Fertilizer is mixed under the row so only the plant can use it, boosting yields with only about half the fertilizer. It lowers the cost of herbicide and insecticide inputs because trash is left in the middle of the rows, mixed with soil in mini ridges. Chemicals are placed in narrow row bands on the dome of the row ridge

“It makes a great seedbed and has reduced what I spend on planter parts by about 75 percent.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 021 chain saw + 1 more

Blake Engleka, Poquoson, Va. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Blake nominates his Stihl 021 chain saw as his “best buy”. “It does an excellent job of cutting and is a great saw for the money. No problems at all.

“My worst buy was my 1997 Remington Viper .22 caliber gun. The first day I got it, it jammed and it took us about 30 minutes to solve the problem. Every time I use this gun it jams.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Harvestore silo + 1 more

Erling Swiggum, Dodgeville, Wis. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

“My Harvestore silo is my best buy. It’s easy to fill and unload. I do have to run the unloader occasionally whenever I start to fill the silo so the unloader doesn’t bog down. This silo helped me double my milk production from about 350,000 pounds a year to 699,000 pounds. It will pay for itself in three years. “ quart of oil every 3,000 miles. I’d buy another one of these in a flash.”

On the minus side, he lists his Yard Man lawn and garden tractor equipped with a 17 hp engine and 42-in. mower deck. “Whenever I back it up, the front wheels toe-in so severely that at times the tractor wheels start spinning and the tractor won’t move. The deck is just as poorly engineered, with no way to adjust tension on the deck belt. Replacement belts from the company are poor. After only a few hours of use they stretch and slip.”

Best Buy

American Steel Buildings Corporation

Glen Swier, Colton, S. Dak. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Glen’s had problems with a building that he bought last year from American Steel Buildings Corporation. “I wanted a building that could be used both as a machine shed and grain storage shed. So last fall I went to the Dakota Fest farm show in order to gather information from different companies. At the show I met a salesman for American Steel and ended up purchasing a 51 by 100-ft. arch building.

“While hiring people to do foundation work for the building, I discovered that I didn’t have the right floor plans. I called three different company representatives about the problem, but not one returned my calls. Frustrating.

“The building was finally put up and we did receive all the materials for it. However, there would have been no way for us to put the building up ourselves, like the salesman said we would be able to do. We ended up hiring a contractor and it took him two weeks to do the job.”

Best Buy

Ram Dakota 2-WD extended cab pickup

Mark Brubaker, Rochester, Ind. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Mark has more than 231,000 hard miles on his 1992 Dodge Dakota 2-WD extended cab pickup. The pickup is equipped with a V-8 engine and an automatic overdrive transmission. “All I’ve had to replace was the starter, distributor, and fuel pump. The pickup still has its original water pump, alternator, and fan belt. It runs great and uses only about one

Best Buy

Micada add-on hopper bottoms

Jim Jacobsen, Luverne, N. Dak. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

Jim nominates Micada add-on hopper bottoms for grain bins as his “best buy”. “About five years ago I had a grain bin that had a lot of rust and was in need of repair, so I started looking for a hopper bottom for it. I checked with several companies that made hopper bottoms and decided to go with Micada. The company was nothing but professional. They delivered the hopper bottom to my farm and set it up. It converted my old bin into a new drying hopper bin that dries down any product I put in it. The salesman I worked with helped me choose the aeration system to fit my needs.

“Since I bought that first hopper bottom I’ve purchased four others and plan to buy more. In my opinion it’s the best one on the market.” (Micada, Box 57, Hope, N. Dak. 58046 ph 800 270 2701).

Best Buy

Ride King 8 hp riding mower

Joy Roberts, Deer Park, Wash. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 15

“My 1991 Ride King 8 hp riding mower is my best buy. I can’t say enough good things about it. It’s the best money I’ve ever spent. I use it on an acre of grass that is neither smooth nor level and has a lot of unkept edges. This 3-wheel mower turns on a dime. That makes it easy to trim all edges of the lawn and eliminates the need for a push mower to finish the job. Repairs have been few and far between and relatively inexpensive.”

Worst Buy

Bush Hog mower

Denise Thomson, Napa, Calif. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

“Our 2001 Bush Hog 48-in. mower is our worst buy. We bought to pull behind our 4-wheeler and mow between rows of grapes in our vineyard. At first I was happy to have this narrow little mower and was told that it would be lightweight enough that I could easily hook it up to the ATV by myself. However, the first time I used it the hook-up cables snapped off. It took more than a half hour to hook it back up just so I could take it back to the house. After that one of the wheels fell off, and then an axle broke. My husband had to modify the mower in order to make it stronger and easier to operate.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Oliver 1800 tractor equipped + 1 more

Mark Heesch, Rosemount, Minn. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

Mark’s the owner of a 1962 Oliver 1800 tractor equipped with a diesel engine and 3-pt. hitch. He says it’s his “best buy”. The entire tractor has been rebuilt and restored from the ground up. My total investment was only about $7,000. No matter what task I use this tractor for, it exceeds my expectations. It’s equipped with fluid-filled tires and fender-mounted fuel tanks. Once the fuel tanks are topped off, this tractor has unlimited traction, which is handy when pulling my home-built 10 ft. box scraper.

“My 1987 Snapper riding mower with a 42-in. deck and rear-mount engine is my worst buy. I use it on our 2-acre lawn. Every other time I use it something seems to go wrong. I’ve had problems with the fuel line plugging up, the belt jumping off a pulley, a blade disengaging, and one time a tire came completely off the wheel rim. It has also had electrical problems.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 35 tractor

Bernard Taylor, Gandeeville, W. Va. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

“My 1962 Massey Ferguson 35 tractor, which I bought used several years ago, is a best buy. I wanted to use the 3-pt. to operate a rear-mount scoop, so I replaced the mechanical top link with a hydraulic top cylinder that lets me use the 3-pt. like a frontend loader. The cylinder is operated by a double spool valve that I bolted to the tractor’s main housing, just ahead of the tractor seat.

“I use the 3-pt. scoop to haul gravel and dirt and dig out rocks. It’s a lot easier to hook up than a front-end loader, and it’s not as hard on the tractor’s front axle or steering system. Massey Ferguson offered a double spool valve on this tractor when it first came out but then discontinued it. I bought the cylinder and valve used from a local tractor dealer. The valve has two handles - one to tilt the cylinder up and one to tilt it down.”

Best Buy

Krone 3-pt spinner rake + 1 more

John Strockoz, Little Marsh, Penn. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

“My best buy ever is a Krone 3-pt. spinner rake. It’s equipped with tandem wheels that ride over the fields quietly, and because it’s 3-pt. mounted I can quickly move the rake from field to field. Last year I bought a Krone 3-pt. disc mower equipped with finger crushers, which I also like. I had been using New Holland mowers for a long time and didn’t realize there was a better brand on the market

“I recently purchased my second Deere 6210 tractor and really like it. Both 6210’s have been trouble-free.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota riding mower equipped + 1 more

Pete Hinson, Foley, Ala. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

Pete says his 2001 Kubota riding mower equipped with a diesel engine is his “best buy”. “We use it to cut about six acres of grass. It’s really fuel efficient - we can make several cuttings on a tank of fuel. It has an adjustable seat and adjustable steering, and the operator can change gears without having to stop. It works great. No problems.

“Our 2000 Sears 19 hp riding mower is our worst buy. We’re glad we signed up for the extended warranty because repair men have had to come out to our place 12 or 13 times. None of the problems have been major, but they’re all aggravating. The warranty ended on July 16, and of course the next day we couldn’t get the mower to start.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Remington Powerflite chain saw + 1 more

Robert Johnson, Irvington, Ky. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

“I’m happy with my Remington Powerflite chain saw which I bought new in 1993 for $40. I used it right up until last year and it never failed to start. It was loud, but hands down it was the best saw I’ve ever owned.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1998 Chevrolet K1500 4-WD pickup. “During the first 12,000 miles the EGR valve went out, a seat latch broke, and the anti-lock brake sensor fried. Before the pickup even had 36,000 miles on it the seals went out of the rear end, saturating the rear brake shoes. The dealer installed new seals, but when I got it back there was no oil in it. At 39,000 miles the U-joints went out because they didn’t put any grease in the cups at the factory. At 43,000 miles the second EGRvalve went out. When the third EGR valve went out at 64,000 miles, I installed a stainless steel gasket between the valve and intake. The pickup now has about 80,000 miles on it and is still going. I’ve got my fingers crossed hoping that nothing more will go wrong.”