Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008)

88 reports from pages 12–15 · 73 Best Buys24 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

John Deere Gator

Harold Hamilton, Eagleville, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“In reference to Gary Alford’s statements in a recent issue about poor starting problems with his 2005 HPX 4-WD Deere Gator, I can say I had the same disturbing problem with my 05 HPX Gator. When I would shut it off for 15 minutes on a 90 degree day, I’d have to choke it to death to restart it.

“After two visits to the dealer with this problem, we finally found a solution. We traded it in for a diesel Gator which we are more than pleased with. It starts great and uses only half as much fuel as the gas model.

“One problem: It should have power steering because it steers hard. I have a Deere diesel lawn tractor with power steering so if they can put a unit on there, they should be able to add it to the Gator.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota BX 1500 sub-compact tractor

J.O. Rogers, Kemp, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“My Kubota BX 1500 sub-compact tractor does a great job cutting grass. It works about 75 percent as fast as a zero turn mower but is much more versatile. It has a 3-pt. hitch so I can use it with a tiller, blade, or a rough cut Bush Hog. Also, it can mow in muddy conditions without getting stuck or leaving wheel ruts like a zero turn mower.”

On the negative side, he lists drills and drill bits made in China. “If I buy a Chinese tool it’s with the idea that it’s a one-time use disposable tool. If the tool lasts any longer than that it’s a pleasant surprise.”

Best Buy

Dickey-john mini + 1 more

Lowell C. Lawler, Clare, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“I’m impressed with my Dickey-john mini GAC plus battery-powered, handheld moisture tester. It’s the most accurate portable moisture tester I’ve ever seen and is advertised to have ‘grain trade’ accuracy. Every time we checked this unit it was never more than three tenths of a point off from the readings on a commercial tester.

“My 1980 Kinze 800-bu. grain cart has required only routine maintenance. It’s a best buy.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 535 baler + 1 more

Gene Loge, Cooperstown, N. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“My used Deere 535 baler is still in good shape. It has an automatic tie system and bale kicker, so each bale requires two motions - depressing the clutch to stop and opening the gate hydraulically, which saves wear and tear on artificial knees and arthritic hands.

“My Ritchie 300 fiberglass drinker is my worst buy. It’s rated to handle 125 beef cows. However, the drinking reservoir is so narrow that livestock have to turn their heads 90 degrees just to get at the water. Even then, their mouth doesn’t fit and they dribble and slurp so much water that during the winter an ice cone develops around the drinker. To prevent dangerous slips, I have to chip the ice away twice a week.”

Best Buy

Magellan 3100 GPS auto navigation system

Berk Palmer, Ridgeway, S.C. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

Berk likes his portable Magellan 3100 GPS auto navigation system. I purchased it for a business-pleasure trip to Florida. It doesn’t show photos or play music like some of the other units on the market. However, it will take you to an address and bring you home with ease. And, because it’s portable, I can use it in any vehicle. It’s pre-loaded with newer, updated maps of all 48 lower states.”

Best Buy

Shindaiwa chainsaw

F.D. Oakes Jr., Bowdoinham, Maine · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“My 2006 Shindaiwa chainsaw is my best buy. It’s advertised as an arborist’s saw because the operator’s handle is over the power head rather than at the end. This saw has great balance and is less tiring to operate on the shoulders and back because the weight is closer to the body. It’s an excellent saw for limbing. It doesn’t leak fuel or bar oil when it’s stored or carried in the back of a car. It’s more expensive than other saws but has never been in the shop.”

Best Buy

FuelMeister biofuel system

Hermann Weber, Attica, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“I process used vegetable oil in my FuelMeister biofuel system(ph 866 636-6130; www.fuelmeister.com) to turn it into diesel fuel, which I use to power my truck and tractor during the summer and my home furnace during the winter.”

Best Buy

Ram 1500 4-WD quad-cab pickup equipped + 1 more

Richard Vracar, Monticello, Florida · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“My 2000 Dodge 1500 4-WD Quad-Cab pickup equipped with a 360 cu. in. engine is my best buy. It had about 142,000 miles on it when I finally traded it in. I replaced the brake pads and rotors at about 100,000 miles, changed the oil and filter at 15,000-mile intervals, and changed the spark plugs twice. I changed the spark plug wires once and cleaned the pickup’s K&N air filter at 60,000 and 120,000 miles. That’s all it ever needed.”

Best Buy

Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped

George Hydrick, Utopia, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“Our 2002 Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine is our best buy. It has custom toolboxes that replace the original bed (Manning Equipment, Lytle, Texas ph 214 649-7438). This pickup has about 200,000 miles on it but still runs as good as when I bought it. The toolboxes have paid for themselves just by keeping my tools in one place. No more searching in the bottom of a toolbox for tools.”

Worst Buy

Harbor Freight Tools

Roger Skow, Dafter, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

Roger says the two Chicago Electric 3 hp electric motors he purchased from Harbor Freight Tools are his “worst buys”. “One motor arced and shorted out on the initial start. The second motor ran for only one hour before the windings melted and shorted out.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet Avalanche + 1 more

Richard Kruse, Indianapolis, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

A 2002 Chevrolet Avalanche rates as Richard’s “best buy”. “It has about 140,000 miles on it and only the brakes and tires have been repaired or replaced. I can drive to the field or church in comfort.

“My Deere 250 skid loader is my worst buy. It has had hydraulic hoses and pump problems with fewer than 500 hours. The engine and other components work fine but the hydraulic problems are costly.”

Best Buy

GM Scottsdale 3500 pickup equipped

Chester Palmer, Miami, Okla. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

Chester’s pleased with his 2003 GM Scottsdale 3500 pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison automatic transmission. “This is the quietest, easiest riding pickup I’ve driven in years. It has all the power I need to pull my 7 and 20-ft. trailers even when they’re loaded. It starts great in cold weather and performs well in the hottest weather. It gets only about 11 mpg which isn’t good enough, but in every other way it’s a great pickup.”

Worst Buy

Net 10 prepaid cell phone

Bart Buehler, Nampa, Idaho · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“My Net 10 prepaid cell phone is my worst buy. This is the same company as TracFone. Activation of this phone and later adding air time is a big hassle. Activation has to be done via a landline phone so they have a name and location. As a result, you’re less anonymous than you might think.”

Best Buy

Koender windmill

Sherwood Botsford, Warburg, Alberta · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“While it’s way too soon to tell how well it will work, I’ve just finished putting up a Koender windmill for aerating my pond. The engineering on this mill is clever. Except for the compressor at the top pivot, the entire mill is made from heavy gauge galvanized sheet metal.

“However, it was the most aggravating assembly job I’ve ever done. The holes don’t quite line up, so the instructions tell you to use a tapered punch to force alignment. There are no star washers, so you have to hold both ends of the bolt through the entire tightening process. Some of the bolts are located where you can’t get a socket wrench on them, so the whole process has to be done with an open end wrench, making 1/6 of a turn at a time.

“The metal edges are sharp enough that when I was done putting it together (it took about two days) my hands were really beat up with small cuts and scrapes.

“I wrote to the company about these problems, spelling out in detail what was wrong and what I thought they could do to fix it. They never replied.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6715 4-WD tractor equipped

James A. Murdock, Whitewater, Mon-tana · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

James nominates his 2004 Deere 6715 4-WD tractor equipped with a 740 Classic loader and grapple fork as his “best buy”. “This is the first new loader tractor I’ve ever bought. I use it with a Haybuster bale processor to feed cows, and with a New Holland 788 round baler. It’s one of the most comfortable tractors I’ve ever operated. It has a heated cab which is really nice in winter.”

Best Buy

Farmall Super M + 1 more

Norm Benson, Garretson, S. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“The 1952 Farmall Super M I bought in 1966 is the best tractor I’ve ever owned. I had to replace the engine head about 10 years after buying the tractor. It hasn’t required any other major engine or transmission work. The Hobbs engine hour meter on it quit working at 17,750 hours, but I estimate that it now has about 19,000 hours. It has been painted twice so it still looks great. I use it with a Dual front-end loader most of the time.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet Silverado 1500 extended cab pickup

William G. Wentz, Jr., Goodlettsville, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

A 2006 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 extended cab pickup rates as William’s “worst buy”. “At 4,200 miles the transmission had to be replaced, and the new one had to be repaired soon afterward. Then the company had a factory recall for the calibration of ethanol, which lowered the fuel efficiency to only 9.6 mpg in town. The pickup is still under warranty so I’ve scheduled another ‘recalibration’. This is the last GM vehicle I’ll ever buy.”

Best Buy

Kubota 8200 4-WD loader tractor

Solon R. Etheredge, Jr., Leighton, Ala-bama · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Solon uses his Kubota 8200 4-WD loader tractor in his haying operation. “My only complaint is that the fuel filter is hard to change because the loader frame is in the way. I think Kubota makes great machines. I also own a Kubota L-2250 4-WD loader tractor, a Kubota riding mower, and a Kubota RTV 900. No problems with any of them.”

Worst Buy

Ram 3500 Laramie dually pickup equipped

Grady H. Peay, Springfield, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My 2005 Dodge 3500 Laramie dually pickup equipped with a diesel engine is my worst buy. It has repeatedly gone back to the service department ever since I bought it. This pickup doesn’t have any get-up-and-go power. Last year we went on two long trips and I didn’t think we were going to make it back home. The pickup would quit and then run again.”

Best Buy

Toro electric leaf blower

Ken Sachs, Antioch, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Ken’s happy with his Toro electric leaf blower. “I use a gas-powered model to blow leaves in our 1/2-acre back yard. But it also works great to blow snow off the porch and it also works great in front of our garage, and to blow crud out of our shop. One of the best uses is to blow leaves out of our gutters. It turned a half day job in which I had to go up and down ladders, into a 20-minute job where I can just walk along the edge of the roof.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Cat-erpillar 470 combine + 1 more

Darrell Erhardt, Flasher, N. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Darrell’s “well pleased” with his 2007 Cat-erpillar 470 combine. “This combine is easy to work on. I had a small problem setting the machine, but the dealer helped me by phone to fine-tune the settings.

“My 1999 Ford F-350 4-WD pickup, which I bought used, is my worst buy. It had about 20,000 miles on it when I bought it, but 10,000 miles later the transmission went out which cost me $4,000. The transmission repair shop told me Ford doesn’t build its transmissions heavy enough.”

Best Buy

Melaleuca cleaning products

Roxann D. Burkey, Fresno, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“I’m well pleased with Melaleuca cleaning products which I began using 2 1/2 years ago (ph 208 522-0700; www.melaleuca.com). There are no phosphates or harmful chemicals in any of their cleaning products, and they’re concentrated so fewer containers go into landfills. I’ve used several of their products on our goats, horses and dog in order to get rid of flies and fleas and soothe itchy skin. The company also sells personal care, nutritional, and health care products. I don’t sell for them. I just like the product.”

Best Buy

GM Sierra Meteor 350 3/4-ton 2-wd

Eugene F. Kallaus, Burlington, Colo. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Eugene nominates his 1994 GM Sierra Meteor 350 3/4-ton, 2-WD pickup equipped with a 5-speed manual transmission as “best buy”. “I put a new clutch in at about 150,000 miles. I drive this pickup every day in my sales job. I drove it until the end of 2003 when I purchased a new Chevy pickup. When I stopped driving the 1994 model it had about 497,000 miles on it but still had the original drive train. The engine had never been worked on. My 2003 model already has more than 153,000 miles on it, and I think it’ll go at least 500,000 miles, too.”

Best Buy

Norwood portable sawmill

J.R. Wismer, Jordan, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“I like my 2007 Norwood portable sawmill (Kilworthy, Ontario ph 800 567-0404 or 705 689-2800; www.norwoodsawmills.com). It’s priced right. We assembled the mill and trailer package ourselves with very little prior experience. We were able to mill enough lumber to build an addition to our hunting camp over the summer, so this machine has already paid for itself.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2210 4-WD tractor equipped

Edgar Wille, Morrison, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“This little tractor has done everything I’ve asked it to do,” says Edgar, pleased with his 2003 Deere 2210 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader and 54-in. finish mower. “I use the mower to cut five acres of grass, and I use the loader for everything from hauling to digging, moving dirt, grading gravel, and removing snow. It’s a good, all-around tractor.”

Best Buy

Echo 280 chainsaw

William LePage, Elk River, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

William’s the satisfied owner of an Echo 280 chainsaw. “I bought this saw on eBay four years ago and have used it to cut 75 to 100 cords of firewood every year. It seems we’ve been blessed with Dutch Elm and Oak Wilt disease, so there’s no end to our supply of wood. It’s equipped with a 12-in. bar, and as long as the chain is sharp it’ll easily cut through 10-in. dia. tree branches. It’s a great saw.”

Best Buy

Tear Mender

Art Olive, Stacy, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My best buy is a cloth and canvas repair product called Tear Mender (ph 773 927-9442; www.tear mender.com). I spent 40 years trying all kinds of iron-on patches and fabric cement for patching work clothes, but was always bitterly disappointed and went back to sewing. Finally I’ve found a product that works. This stuff sets up quickly, holds strong, and stands up to repeated washing. And it’s easy to use -just cut out the patch, apply the product, and put the patch on the clothing. If you’re in a hurry you can even patch clothing while you’re wearing it. The patch can go on either the outside or inside, but applying the patch on the inside looks a little neater.”

Best Buy

Air Ride suspension kit

Curt Koenig, Sloan, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Curt’s impressed with the Air Ride suspension kit he installed under the cab on his Deere 8300T tracked tractor (Air Ride Technologies, Central City, Neb. ph 308 946-2420). “This is by far the best aftermarket product I’ve ever bought. Reduces wear and tear on expensive electronics and lessens operator fatigue. I’m installing a kit on my other tractor. It takes eight hours to install but is worth it many times over.”

Worst Buy

Carhartt coat

Ken Smekofske, Wenatchee, Wash. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My worst buy is a Carhartt coat. I bought it only eight months ago but already it looks like it has been worn for five years. I don’t work any more, so I just wear the coat whenever I go outside to feed our horses and chickens. Already I’ve had to replace the zipper, and the coat’s lining is torn and worn out.”

Worst Buy

Delta bandsaw

David Keith, Rockford, Iowa · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

David’s the disappointed owner of a 2000 Delta bandsaw. “The upper and lower wheel assemblies were out of alignment when I bought it. As a result, the blade wouldn’t track correctly and rubbed on the blade guard. After trying to make the company understand the problem and after receiving parts not even related to the problem, I gave up and repaired it myself. This has been an expensive saw to own. I used to be a fan of this company, but no more.”

Best Buy

Pequea rotary hay rake

Joe Sawyer, Gilford, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“I’m thrilled with my 2007 Pequea rotary hay rake (ph 717 354-4343; www.pequeamachine.com). It’s equipped with four large flotation tires on a walking axle, which eliminates any bouncing on rough ground even at 6 mph. It fluffs hay up into high, even rows. It’s a pleasure to use.”

Best Buy

Tribco kevlar-lined brakes

Dan Dolence, Grey Eagle, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

Dan’s impressed with Tribco Kevlar-lined brakes, clutches, and other parts that would otherwise be lined with asbestos, bronze or other types of friction linings (Tribco, Inc., Cleveland, Ohio ph 216 486-2000).

“We used these brake linings on my Farmall 450 tractor, and it eliminated the problem of brake grab or brake lockup,” says Dolence. “If you have an old Farmall with disc brakes that grab and lock up, try these discs. If they don’t solve your problem, then there’s something else wrong.”

Best Buy

Simplicity Champion 20 hp zero turn + 1 more

Roger Parks, Moweaqua, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My 2007 Simplicity Champion 20 hp zero turn riding mower is comfortably maneuverable and also does an excellent job mowing. It’s equipped with a 50-in. deck and independent suspension and has cut my mowing time in half. No problems.

“My 1993 GM 1500 pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine and automatic transmission is a best buy. Now it has more than 180,000 miles on it with no major problems.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Astro van equipped

W.D. Cooper, Fayetteville, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My 1993 Chevrolet Astro van equipped with a 4.3-liter, 6-cyl. engine has more than 361,000 miles on it yet has required only routine maintenance. I use this van to haul about 500 lbs. of horseshoeing tools and supplies. It still gets 18 to 20 mpg. Can anyone beat this performance?”

Best Buy

MacDon 9350 swather heads + 1 more

Bill Clark, Miniota, Manitoba · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

A 2002 MacDon 9350 swather heads his “best buy” list. “I use it with a 972 25-ft. header and a 922 16-ft. hay header. This machine is a pleasure to operate and requires little maintenance.

“I’m disappointed, however, with the 2002 30-ft. MacDon 960 draper header we mounted on our Deere 9600 combine. The problem is that in certain wheat crops it wants to backfeed under the canvas, causing damage to the canvas. We’ve tried speeding up the header and adjusting the adapters closer to the feeder, but it hasn’t helped. Next time I think I’ll try using a Deere draper header.”

Best Buy

Ford 1520 tractor equipped + 4 more

William R. Townsen, Camden, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 1989 Ford 1520 tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine does a good job of handling my 5-ft. Bush Hog finishing mower. I use it to pick up and carry our 1991 Troy-Bilt Tomahawk chipper-shredder equipped with an 8 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. It’s a best buy, too.

“I use my 1997 MTD riding mower to pick up and grind leaves for compost. The material is blown into a home-built box that I mounted on a garden trailer. The box is open on front and has screen sides and a back door along with a tin roof.

“My 1991 Woodchuck wood stove works great (Meyer Mfg., Dorchester, Wis.).

“I haven’t had good luck with Poulan chainsaws, either electric or gas-powered.”

Best Buy

Volkswagen Jetta equipped + 1 more

Lorne Orr, London, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“It never gets less than 50 mpg and gets more than 60 mpg at times,” reports Lorne about his 1998 Volkswagen Jetta equipped with a diesel engine. “I don’t know why more vehicles aren’t available with diesel engines. This car is dependable and economical.

“I use my New Holland skid steer loader every day and it’s a best buy. I couldn’t farm without a skid loader.

“Reading and following the owner’s manual often makes the difference between best and worst buys.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 318 riding mower

John Rempel, Kleefeld, Manitoba · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“It was a lemon from the beginning and is my worst buy ever,” says John about his 1990 Deere 318 riding mower. “I use this machine only for garden tilling. It had a lot of transmission problems. The first two transmissions were covered by the warranty, but I had to repair the next two at my own expense. It cost me $1,200 each time. Something is wrong with this machine more often than not. The tiller bearings had to be replaced right after the warranty expired. At one point the pto, clutch, and valve seat on the engine also had to be replaced. I could take out the valve seat with my bare fingers. I had to bring it to a machine shop where they put in a new seat.

“I paid $4,500 for repairs. It now has 538 hours on it so I only put on about 30 hours per year. It turns out I’ve spent almost $9 per hour on repairs for every hour I’ve used the machine, not including routine maintenance costs for tune-ups and oil changes. It was tuned up twice last year. I can’t afford to buy a new machine, or to make any more repairs on this one.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Patz 98 silo unloader + 1 more

Peter Sidlauskas, Amsterdam, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

Peter’s the satisfied owner of a 2004 Patz 98 silo unloader. “This is a good machine, once I got it broke in. It can take on frozen haylage or corn silage with ease.”

He’s unhappy with his Georgia work shoes. “They’re the most poorly made shoes I’ve ever bought. In barely three months the soles cracked and a heel ruptured. That’s China craftsmanship? The shoes were comfortable when I first wore them, until the soles separated.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet S10 pickup

Graham Robertson, Westminster, Md. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“I bought my 1984 Chevrolet S10 pickup used more than 10 years ago. It now has about 400,000 miles on it but is still going strong. We use it to haul feed, as well as sheep and lambs. We call this pickup our ‘gray ghost’ because it refuses to die.”

Worst Buy

New Holland 617 disc mower

Mike Schmidt, Durham, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“Our 2003 New Holland 617 disc mower is our worst buy ever. The first time we used it, one end of the machine fell apart and came through the canvas. Also, there was no oil in the gearbox so it had to be rebuilt. Then a bearing in the gearbox went out. Later, the power shaft broke even though the machine hasn’t even cut 400 acres yet. We had the powershaft repaired at a local shop because our dealer no longer wants to see this machine.

“The operator’s manual doesn’t include any phone numbers for the company. The manual just says to see your dealer, and when you get the phone number from the dealer and call the company, they tell you to see your dealer. This disc mower has spent more time at the dealer than it has in the field. Now I won’t even give this machine shed room.”

Best Buy

Ford 250 Super Duty pickup

Ferrel Collins, Clay City, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 2008 Ford 250 Super Duty pickup runs and drives good and is very stable on the road. It gets 10 to 13 mpg empty and 6 to 8 mpg pulling a trailer. My only complaint is that the fuse block in the cab is hard to service.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

MacDon 9250 swathers + 2 more

Dean L. Freeborn, Rickreall, Oregon · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

Dean’s impressed with his 2006 and 2007 MacDon 9250 swathers. “We’ve operated MacDon swathers for several years, and these 9250 models are really good machines. We’ve used them to cut several different kinds of grass seed and hay. As long as you keep the sicklebar sharp they’ll cut through the crop.

“The 2004 Case IH MXM 155 tractor I bought last year is my worst buy. It has had numerous problems with the electrical system, hydraulics, leaks, fuel pump, etc. We bought this tractor to keep from putting so many hours on our older Magnums, but unfortunately we still had to use them because the MXM 155 is down all the time.

“My Case IH 7220 and 8030 tractors work great. Too bad the company doesn’t build these models any more.”

Worst Buy

Crary Bear Cat EZ trim mower

Peter Janssens, Alexandria, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 2000 Crary Bear Cat EZ Trim mower is my worst buy. The belt-driven pulley on top of the trimmer assembly split in half the first time I used the mower. All the spot welds came loose. The company’s help line wasn’t of much help. There have been numerous other problems with this machine.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5205 56 hp 4-wd tractor + 1 more

Ian Brent Fetterly, Lanark, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My new Deere 5205 56 hp 4-WD tractor equipped with a 541 front-end loader is my best buy. It always starts, even in the coldest weather. I’ve buried this tractor up to the frame in mud but have always been able to get out. It’s fuel efficient and easy to service with a clear and concise owner’s manual. No problems. It’s a simple, basic tractor that gets the job done.

“My Stihl 270 chainsaw starts hard and guzzles gas. It has frequently been back to the dealer. It won’t start in cold weather so I built a warming box to keep it warm during the winter. Another problem is the anti-kickback cutting chain won’t cut. This chainsaw is fragile and temperamental and only runs on high-test gas.”

Best Buy

Mighty Dumper trailer

Norman Roth, Wellesley, Ontario · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“We’re pleased with our Mighty Dumper trailer (John B. M. Mfg. Ltd., www.johnbm mfg.com). This dump trailer has an automatic tailgate with a grain door. We use it to haul grain and gravel and to stack manure in wind-rows for composting.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4310 tractor equipped

Richard Begolka, Atlanta, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“I like my 2003 Deere 4310 tractor equipped with a hydrostat transmission. I use it to do commercial mowing with a 6-ft. finish mower around about 20 large hog confinement buildings, plus some other mowing. This tractor is a pleasure to use with the hydrostat transmission, and it’s quite easy on fuel.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 7710 2-WD tractor equipped

Dan Kibbe, Waterford, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“Our worst buy ever was a new Deere 7710 2-WD tractor equipped with a powershift transmission. There was trouble from day one with the electronics, but the biggest problem was with the transmission. It would go into park and into a gear at the same time. The dealer said they couldn’t do anything until it broke.

“After the warranty had expired, one side of the transmission case finally blew out. Of course, we were stuck with a big repair bill because the company said it was out of warranty, even though the dealer had documented records of all the times he had looked at it. We were still having some problems with the transmission after they fixed it so we traded it off.”

Best Buy

Harbor Freight tools

George Schneider, Pioneer, Calif. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“I often read negative comments about Harbor Freight tools in FARM SHOW. However, I have a different philosophy. I use Harbor Freight to buy tools that I don’t necessarily need on a long term basis. For example, instead of renting a 1/2-in. drill for two days at a cost of $10 a day, I’ll buy a cheap drill for $29 and toss it after I’m done with the job. That way I don’t worry about spending all my time renting and returning a rental. I don’t expect to find ‘professional’ tools at Harbor Freight in the first place.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Maurer hopper bottom grain + 2 more

Jeffrey M. Heiser, Vesper, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 2006 Maurer 34-ft. hopper bottom grain trailer pulls easy and is my best buy. It has sight windows on the side of the trailer so I can always see how much grain is left inside.

“My Classic outdoor wood burning furnace is easy to hook up and is a best buy. Burning wood sure beats buying LP gas.

“I’m disappointed with the parts distribution provided by AGCO. I ordered parts for my Massey Ferguson tractor from AGCO. They repeatedly had to be sent back or else they didn’t come at all. Our dealer tried to help. There’s no excuse for this mess.”

Best Buy

Farm Master forage mixer + 1 more

Marlin Oberholtzer, Ephrata, Penn. ph 717 738-3264 · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“I bought my Farm Master forage mixer new about four years ago and it’s my best buy. It has only a 3 hp motor but does a great job of mixing feed. It also has many stainless steel parts and digital scales. I can’t say anything bad about this machine.

“My three Horst bunk feeders are all best buys. It’s a stationary, belt-type feeder that runs the length of my feed bunk and about 7 ft. above it. A ‘plow’ moves back and forth, pushing feed off the belt and into the bunk. It works great, and it costs far less than comparable commercial models. I put three feeders in for less than half the cost of one feeder from a name brand company. A local man here makes them.”

Best Buy

Volkswagen Jetta equipped

Marvin Hammer, Bartow, Fla. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 2006 Volkswagen Jetta equipped with a diesel engine is my best buy. It’s comfortable to drive, handles well, and performs great. Best of all, it always gets at least 40 mpg, even in stop-and-go driving, and at least 45 mpg on the highway. The fit, finish and quality are excellent.”

Best Buy

Black+Decker chop saw + 1 more

Denny Williams, Trevor, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“I love my 1983 Black & Decker chop saw. I use it every day. Four years ago the handle broke so I wanted to buy another one. However, I found out the company doesn’t make these saws any more so I replaced it with a DeWalt model. Unfortunately, I was able to use that saw for only two years before it burned up. Then I bought another DeWalt but it quit working, too, so I had another handle put on the Black & Decker and that’s what I use.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota B7100 tractor + 1 more

Richard L. Miller, Elwood, Ind. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 1982 Kubota B7100 tractor is my best buy. I haven’t spent a dime on this tractor except for a new radiator cap. I traded it in for a 2004 Deere X585 equipped with a 62-in. belly mower, and it’s my worst buy. It’s equipped with a model 45 loader, a quick-tach snowblower, and a canvas cab. The mid pto is poorly engineered which makes it difficult to attach equipment. The tractor was leaking oil onto my cement floor, so I took it to the dealer for repair work. The tractor was there for a week but the dealer still couldn’t find the problem. I had to pay $141 just to have it checked out, and it wasn’t under warranty since the cause of the problem wasn’t found.”

Best Buy

Case 16 hp garden tractor

Lawrence Fish, Sanborn, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“It’s the best lawn and garden tractor I’ve ever owned,” says Lawrence about his 1980 Case 16 hp garden tractor equipped with an Onan engine and 48-in. mower deck. “After one year of use the gears in the oil pump broke, and of course the warranty had just expired. Also, the engine seized up. However, Onan supplied a new engine and the dealer installed it for $125. Since then I’ve been using this tractor all year long. I don’t think 26 years with the same engine is too bad.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Mule 550 utility vehicle

Howard Cigelske, Beaver Dam, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My Kawasaki Mule 550 utility vehicle is a handy machine for doing chores. It saves gas compared to using a pickup, and the dump box comes in handy for hauling stones, brush, or other cargo. It’s an excellent vehicle for fixing, checking and changing pasture fences and for checking on our livestock’s water supply.”

Best Buy

Bob-cat 753 skid steer loader

David Bell, Houlton, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

A 2000 Bob-cat 753 skid steer loader rates as David’s “best buy”. “I use this machine hard for grading, loading, and tearing out concrete. It has about 1,200 hours on it yet I’ve replaced only the battery. This skid loader has unbelievable engineering and dependability.

“My Harbor Freight 1-in. rotary hammer didn’t have much power and wore out quickly. Many of Harbor Freight’s tools are good values, but for electric tools that I’ll use hard and often I stick to more expensive name brands.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2120 60 hp tractor

Mitch Plemmons, Leicester, N.C. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

Mitch bought a Deere 2120 60 hp tractor made in Canada and says it’s his “best buy”. “This tractor was made sometime between 1968 and 1972. I paid $3,500 for it. When I got it, it didn’t look the best because someone had painted it an off-color green and yellow. I gave it a new paint job and new decals, and now it looks great. It runs like a top and has been a really good tractor with no problems. It was well worth the money. I guess not all odd-ball tractors are bad.”

Best Buy

Toro Z4200 zero turn riding

Melvin Fisher, Lebanon, Penn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My 2007 Toro Z4200 zero turn riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck is my best buy. The deck is easy to remove for cleaning. Even though the mower comes with a hose connection fitting on the deck, I like to remove the deck and clean it with a pressure washer. The mower has a 3-year warranty.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Toyota Camry + 2 more

Wilford Secker, Selby, S. Dak. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My 2002 Toyota Camry has more than 148,000 miles on it but still runs like new and has been trouble-free. It gets 32 to 38 mpg.

“My Minnesota gravity box equipped with a 12-ton running gear is my worst buy. The frame and axles on it bent after only a dozen loads, even though we were hauling less weight than it was rated for. Now we use Kilbros wagon boxes and gears, which are built much better.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet C-30 truck

Brian Seckman, Weston, W. Va. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

Brian’s impressed with his 1970 Chevrolet C-30 truck. “I bought this truck from a family friend who used it to haul cattle to and from the stockyards. I use it to haul big firewood-butt logs that I use in my Taylor outdoor woodburning stove. This truck is a real workhorse - it’ll handle whatever I load it up with.”

Best Buy

Arctic Cat 2-WD ATV equipped + 1 more

Jay C. Reiner, Stewart, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My 2006 Arctic Cat 2-WD ATV equipped with a 250 cc engine is my best buy. It has plenty of power and it’s a joy to ride. Great for either work or play.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2005 A-Maize-ing Heat corn burning furnace. “The dealer told me this furnace could burn corn, wood pellets, or even cherry pits. However, the first time I tried it - using all wood pellets - the auger motor burned out at a cost of $100. The outside temperature was 10 degrees below zero so I had to hand feed the stove every hour or so just to keep our house warm. The dealer said I should mix the pellets with corn instead of using just pellets. I wish he would have told me that sooner. Another problem is the stove doesn’t work properly whenever the outside temperature is above 30 degrees. It can be 78 degrees inside the house yet the furnace will still kick in even though no heat is needed. It uses about 50 lbs. of corn per day.

“Another problem is the dealer doesn’t know any more about how the furnace works than I did when I bought it. I’ve called the company several times but get only a recording, and my calls are never returned. The company needs to make this furnace easier to light. At times I had to use a whole $7 bottle of starter gel, yet still couldn’t get the furnace going. It’s cheaper to just keep it going and waste one bushel of corn than to hassle with trying to start it up every day. I’d never buy another one and don’t recommend them to anyone.”

Best Buy

Xtreme Charge XC 100 5-stage maintenance charger

Paul Evinczik, Jamestown, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My Xtreme Charge XC 100 5-stage maintenance charger is my best buy (PulseTech Products Corp., ph 800 580-7554; www.pulsetech.net). I’ve used it to restore a number of sulfated batteries. It has the ability to remove lead sulfate crystals from the lead plates so they will then accept a charge. It also increases a battery’s cranking amps and results in longer battery life - up to three times longer. Pulse Tech has a variety of battery problem solving chargers and maintainers.”

Best Buy

Stihl FS81 Weed Trimmer

Gary Heckathorn, Navarre, Ohio · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My 1988 Stihl FS81 Weed Trimmer has been trouble-free. It’s hard to beat Stihl for ease of starting and rugged service. Their products run when you need them to, and they’re not always in the shop for repairs. You get your money’s worth.”

Worst Buy

Ariens 1434 mini-zoom riding mower

Rich Hennig, Lisco, Neb. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My worst buy is my Ariens 1434 Mini-Zoom riding mower. It’s underpowered, and the idler pulleys are the riveted type that keep breaking because of belt tension. The pulleys cost more than $100 from the dealer, but only about $20 from the NAPA store. Also, the electric clutch kicks in so fast that often the belt comes off whenever the clutch is engaged. It’s not a good machine.”

Worst Buy

My unit is for sale

Merlin Wooley, Beaverton, Mich. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My unit is for sale. I just can’t get it to work. The company sent me a bigger die which helped some but I can’t make burnable pellets out of wood byproducts, which is what I bought it for. The pellets just fall apart, even though the company told me it should work fine. I paid $3,500 for it.

“It might work better with distiller byproducts, which are more like putty. I wanted to use shavings from a wood flooring mill, which are coarser than sawdust.

“When I contacted the company, they gave me a recipe they said is guaranteed to work: 12 cups sawdust, 6 cups soybeans, and 1/2 cup water. But I don’t want to have to go out and buy soybeans, especially at today’s prices.

“After I got the machine to my shop, it leaked oil. A coupling between the motor and power shaft was out of line. I had to redrill holes and grind down the welds.

“I bought the machine because 40-lb. bags of wood pellets are selling for $4.75 right now and I thought I could get something going. I’m disappointed. If you’re interested in a machine, I recommend you take the material you want to pelletize to Pellet Pro first and try it out.”

Best Buy

Last year FARM SHOW published a report on my Pellet Pro machine and I

Joe Duffy, Hornell, N.Y. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“Last year FARM SHOW published a report on my Pellet Pro machine and I had responses from individuals and manufacturers across the country who had ideas for making it work. But I finally gave up and took it back to the company. They gave me my money back.

“I found that it works good on softer food materials like soybeans and distiller’s grain but not so good on wood products. I have a sawmill and wanted to use my own sawdust. The company suggested I mix it with distillery byproducts but we don’t have an ethanol plant anywhere near here. And besides, the byproducts cost $125 a ton.

“I don’t give up easily and tried different moisture contents. Nothing worked.”

Best Buy

It’s the only do-it-yourself pellet-making machine out there and I hav

Ted Walrich, Colton, N.Y. (ph 315 265-2127 or [email protected]) · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“It’s the only do-it-yourself pellet-making machine out there and I have nothing bad to say about it. But then, I am a dealer. However, I didn’t become one until after I bought a machine and found out how well it works. To make good quality pellets, you just have to find the best method.

“It doesn’t make any difference what the material is but there are certain procedures to follow for different kinds of materials. The company doesn’t provide the best set of instructions but they haven’t been in business that long and are still figuring everything out themselves.

“There are two basic kinds of materials to make pellets from: Dry products like grasses, cornstalks or sawdust; and wet products like distiller’s grains, green sawdust, and other products with 16 to 40 percent moisture content.

“With dry material, you have to add a binding agent to make a good pellet. The good thing about working with dry material is that it’s ready to burn when the pellets come out.

“With wet material, you often don’t need a binder but when they come out, they’re too wet to burn. So you have to go through a drying process to bring them down to 12 to 13 percent moisture to burn successfully in a stove.

“We’re all new at this so there’s a lot of experimenting going on. It’s almost more of an art form than a science. For example, there’s a big difference between sawdust from hardwoods and sawdust from soft woods, and it makes a difference if you’re using a circular sawmill or a bandsaw mill, which has much finer sawdust.

“It would be nice if there were a detailed pellet maker’s manual but there isn’t. I may scare some customers off by telling them the facts, but I’d rather do that up front than have them buy a machine and not be happy.

“It’s important to chop material up so it fits through a 1/4-in. screen. You can’t just take hay off a big bale and pelletize it. I kiln-dry my own lumber and use shavings from our planers and joiners and I have to run them through a hammermill so there are no chunks or long slivers to plug up.

“There are three different electric-powered models, a diesel-powered model, and a pto-powered model. Capacity ranges from 65 to 650 lbs. per hour.

“There’s tremendous interest in pelletizing right now. It’s been a learning process for the whole company.”