Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007)

66 reports from pages 12–15 · 57 Best Buys20 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Dodge Ram 3500 4-door dually automatic diesel

Steven Reeves, Delta Junction, Alaska · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

“I’ve had a string of bad luck with pickup trucks. But my most recent worst buy, actually ended up being a best buy,” says Reeves.

He divides his time between Arkansas and Alaska. Considering that he drives between the two states sometimes several times a year, the reliability of his truck is very important.

Reeves had an older model Dodge that was notorious for electrical malfunctions. While searching for a reliable used truck, he was asked by the salesperson what it would take to get him to purchase a new truck.

“I said, ‘Well, I’ve got an airplane that I’ve been wanting to sell. How about you take that on trade?’” Reeves says.

So he ended up with a new 2007 $35,000 Dodge Ram 3500 4-door dually automatic diesel. Still nervous, however, he made the dealer promise that if he did have any problems with the truck, the dealer would do whatever he had to do to fix it or make it right.

Reeves decided to wait until he had over 500 miles on the truck before he speeded it up over 55 mph. When he did that, it became obvious that the truck had serious driveline problems.

After giving the dealership three chances to fix the problem and they couldn’t resolve it, Reeves deemed the truck unusable and asked that it be replaced by the dealership.

“He did what he said he’d do,” Reeves recounts. “He let me pick out a new one – I gave up some options and they paid me the difference. That was in December, and so far, I really like this 2007 Dodge Ram 2500. I like it better than the other one!

“That dealer did what he said he’d do, even though a deal like that is not part of the dealership policy and they really don’t have to do that sort of thing,” he says. “That will keep me coming back.”

Best Buy

Zip-It drain cleaner

Mark Newhall, Lakeville, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

“I got a Zip-It drain cleaner from inventor Gene Luoma several years ago when the product was first featured in FARM SHOW. Since then, I’ve bought several more for friends and family. It’s a handy little tool that I use for regular cleanout of drains.

“The Zip-It is simply an 18-in. long piece of tough plastic with jagged teeth cut into the sides and a finger hole at the upper end. You just push it down into a sink or floor drain and pull back. The teeth drag out hair and other stuff that typically clogs up. It’s small enough to slip down past the stopper mechanism and tough enough to drag back out without breaking or tearing off. In just seconds, you can clear out a plugged drain.

“Once you’re done, just rinse it off and hang it on a hook somewhere. Zip-It is available in all the big home and hardware stores like Wal-Mart and Home Depot, or you can go to the website at www.zipitclean.com.”

Worst Buy

Hitch-Rite quick change universal

Wesley McWethy, Fallon, Nev. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

“The Hitch-Rite quick change universal trailer ball hitches are truly industrial-strength units. Not junk, like some other multi-ball hitches on the market. It has a 7,500-lb. clevis capacity and is fitted with 1 7/8, 2, and 2 5/16-in. balls. The 2 5/16-in. ball has a 10,000-lb. capacity. There’s also an easy 8-in. vertical adjustment. (Hammerlock Industries Inc., ph 800 755-8345; www.hammerlock.com).”

Best Buy

McCormick Deering self-propelled combine

John G. Ruff, Logan, Kan. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

“I’m still using a 1958 McCormick Deering self-propelled combine that my Dad bought. In the fall of 2006, this combine finished its 50th harvest - and, coincidentally, so did I. There have been only three times this combine didn’t finish a harvest because of serious breakdowns.

“I wish I could brag that this combine has only needed a small number of repairs during those 50 years but it hasn’t worked that way. There aren’t many original parts left on this machine now. Almost everything has been repaired, rebuilt or replaced at least once, some parts several times.

“This combine doesn’t have many of the features modern combines have but it has several features that they don’t. For instance, it’s an easy combine to adjust and it usually does very good work. I can do most of the repair work myself.

“Getting repair parts for it has never been a problem. IHC’s backing of its product has been fantastic. The dealer doesn’t always have the parts I need in stock but he can get them.

“I’m hoping both this combine, and myself, finish our 60th harvest together in 2016.”

Best Buy

Hydra-Spread manure spreader

Steve & Bob Schmidtmeyer, St. Henry, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

These dairymen, with manure from 190 cows to spread, like their Hydra-Spread manure spreader with vertical beaters. The upright beaters spread in a wider, thinner pattern. They say the spread pattern is at least 30 ft. wide, which means they can make fewer passes through the field, with less compaction. The vertical beaters also break up the manure better so there are fewer large clumps. The spreader has a hydraulic push plate, rather than apron chains, and a hydraulic close gate on back to hold in wet manure.

Best Buy

Subaru Outback wagon + 2 more

Joe Bacon, Spring Valley, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 12

“My 1999 Subaru Outback wagon is a wonderful best buy. It has 225,000 miles and has performed flawlessly, requiring only scheduled maintenance and tires.

“Secondly, my Kubota AWD L5030 tractor has been great. With 50 hp, it can really get a lot of work done and it starts and runs smoothly on even the coldest Wisconsin mornings. There’s a good reason why Kubota owners are so loyal to the brand.

“Finally, my Troy-Bilt 8 hp tiller has really earned its keep, tilling our large garden for 12 years. It’s well worth the money.”

Best Buy

Ford 2600 tractor

Larry Johnston, Linden, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“My 1978 Ford 2600 tractor, which I bought used in 1991, is my best buy. I use it every week and have replaced only a starter motor. It has required only routine maintenance. This tractor always starts and operates without fail. I’ve used it for snow plowing, brush hogging, mowing, plowing and disking, rototilling, and landscape raking. It’s very fuel efficient.”

Best Buy

Farmall Super C tractor + 1 more

Stewart G. Ellis, Clearbrook, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“I’ve had my Farmall Super C tractor for more than 25 years and have used it for everything. My son drove it and my grandchildren, too. Now my great grandsons are starting to use it. It’s my best buy.

“Before my 1998 Dodge Intrepid had even 30,000 miles on it, the check engine light started to come on. The problem was caused by a bad gas cap and the repair cost me $900. I traded it in for a 2004 Dodge Intrepid, but after that car had about 38,000 miles on it the same problem happened again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Troy-Bilt Big Red garden tractor equipped + 1 more

Cliff Erwin, Springfield, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“My 2004 Troy-Bilt Big Red garden tractor equipped with a 24 hp, 2-cyl. Briggs & Stratton Intek engine and automatic transmission and 54-in. deck is my best buy. This machine has performed well in maintaining our five acres of grass and trees. It runs smooth and is quite maneuverable for a conventional yard tractor. After almost 200 hours of service, it still has the original belts and blades.

“My 2004 Poulan Woodsman 2150 LE chain saw equipped with a 16-in. bar is my worst buy. This chain saw is difficult to start, and it’s even difficult to restart after it has run for a while. This is my second model. The first one wouldn’t start at all so the dealer replaced it. However, when this saw finally starts it cuts well and has plenty of power.”

Best Buy

Allied 595 front-end loader

Gary Ewen, Dougherty, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

A 1999 Allied 595 front-end loader rates as Gary’s “best buy”. “I bought this loader new after looking at almost every brand on the market. With help from a neighbor, I mounted it on my International Harvester 966 tractor in just one short afternoon.

“All the mounting brackets fit perfectly -no cutting, drilling or grinding was required. I was able to buy the loader painted red to match the color of my tractor. I ordered it with an 8-ft. bucket since my main use for it is pushing snow.

“The bucket comes equipped with quick-tach mounting brackets, which I really like. I just drive into the bucket, raise it, and install two pins. It’s as easy as hooking up to a wagon.”

Best Buy

Farm Pro tractor

Jerry Richardson, Indianapolis, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“My 2003 Farm Pro tractor runs good and is fuel efficient. However, the fan blade has already been replaced twice. The new blade had cracks in it when I bought it. But whenever I call for help all I get is an answering machine. I ordered the fan blade last summer but still don’t have one that I can use.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kinze 16-row Edge Vac bulk fill planter + 1 more

Ron Anderson, Clarion, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“Last year we bought a Kinze 16-row Edge Vac bulk fill planter. It’s our worst buy. This planter messed up the population and spacing on all our corn acres. The worst 160 acres had to be replanted, and all the rest had real poor seed spacing ranging from 2 in. to 6 ft. This happened even though the monitor indicated everything was okay. We replaced the monitor, seed unit, a bristle auger (the bristles fell off), and cracked bucket chains but that didn’t help. Another problem is that the bulk fill tank is complicated and hard to clean out.

“Buying from a local Iowa company, we expected fair treatment but we don’t feel that we received it.

“We replaced this planter with a Deere 1770 no-till planter before planting beans last year, and we’re pleased enough to call it our best buy.”

Best Buy

Mitsubishi Micro mini 4-wd truck

Ronnie Bryant, Cornelius, N.C. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

A used 1990 Mitsubishi Micro mini 4-WD truck equipped with a 4-speed transmission with a high and low gearbox rates as Ronnie’s “best buy”. “This truck had about 17,000 miles on it when I bought it. It’ll go anywhere a Mule or Gator will go and always keeps me warm and dry. These trucks can haul bigger, heavier loads, and you can buy two of them for the price of one Mule or Gator. Also, they’re really fuel efficient. I bought it from Nat Smith at 4x4 Mini Utility (ph 706-838-5313; [email protected]).”

Worst Buy

Poulan

Donald E. Schultz, Hortonville, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

Donald nominates his Poulan 18-in. Wild Thing chainsaw as his “worst buy”. “We were able to use this chainsaw only for three or four days before the oiler quit working, so we took it back to the store where we bought it and they gave us a new one. We used that model for about two days but then it developed the same problem. They gave us another new saw, but it worked for only about a half hour. This time the store said we’d have to take the saw to a dealer.

“The dealer said they’d have to work on it and that it could be a while before they could do the work. We waited about four weeks and then called the dealer. They told us they had returned the saw to the company, and that they’d send us a new model because the cost to fix ours would be more than what it’s worth.

“It took another three weeks before we got the new saw. We used it once. The second time it wouldn’t start. We’ll definitely never buy a Poulan chainsaw again.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4020 tractor + 2 more

Renell Weeks, Swan Valley, Idaho · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“Our 1968 Deere 4020 tractor, which we bought used, is a best buy. We’ve had a front-end loader on it since 1974. We’ve used it to handle 1-ton bales all this time. The engine was overhauled at 8,900 hours.

“Our Case 1290 tractor, which we bought in 1986, has more than 10,000 hours on it yet the engine has never been overhauled. It’s a best buy. Our only problem was that the right final drive went out about 12 years ago.

“Our Case 8850 swather has about 2,800 hours on it. We use it to cut about 250 acres of hay per year with hardly any major breakdowns. We’ve custom cut a lot of acres with it.”

Worst Buy

LaCrosse two-buckle overshoes

James Brown, Wilton, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

James is disappointed with the quality of his LaCrosse two-buckle overshoes. “This company used to make the ‘Cadillac’ of rubber footwear. I always got three years or more wear out of a pair two-buckle overshoes. However, the last pair I bought didn’t last even one year. They were made in China yet cost the same as the company’s previous models. These overshoes ripped out in the ‘gullet’ and kept ripping out down toward the toe. Now I’m trying out a different brand.”

Best Buy

Reese drum mower

Terry Hall, Berlin, Ct. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

“My 2005 Reese drum mower is a low maintenance, high quality mower. It has very few moving parts and performs well in the harshest conditions, including rain-soaked and blown-down crops. It does the work of two haybines due to the lack of downtime for repairs and the efficient manner in which it performs. Drying time is the same in all conditions.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl 440 Magnum chainsaw + 1 more

Dave DeVito, Mora, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

Dave likes his Stihl 440 Magnum chainsaw. “I had a 20-year-old Stihl 044 chainsaw that burned up in a fire. I used the insurance money to buy a new version of the same model. It runs and cuts as good as the old one, and all the extra bars and chains I have from the old saw fit the new one as well. We have a top notch dealer close by who will take care of things. That kind of support doesn’t happen often enough these days.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists Firestone Trans Force AT tires. “I put a set of these tires on my work truck in February 2006 and they’re just this side of bald after only 11 months and about 30,000 miles. My tire dealer said my truck is overloaded and that I drive too fast. But these tires are rated at just over 6,000 lbs., and I carry 5,000 lbs. on the rear end. I drive at 62 mph which I don’t think is that fast.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tundra front wheel drive + 1 more

Dale H. Hollabaugh, Garfield, Ky. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

Dale’s impressed with his 2005 Toyota Tundra front wheel drive pickup equipped with a V-8 engine. “It’ll pull a 16-ft. gooseneck stock trailer with ease, as well as a 6,000-lb. load of round bales. Many people told me this pickup was too small, but I couldn’t be happier with it.”

He isn’t as pleased with a pair of Poulan chainsaws. “They’re the hardest starting saws I’ve ever owned. They flood easily. Three loose bolts fell out of one of the saws the first time I used it.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3400 tractor equipped

Grant England, Gales Creek, Oregon · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

Grant likes his 2006 Kubota L3400 tractor equipped with a front-end loader, 4-ft. bucket, and backhoe. “After months of testing many different tractor brands, including Deere, Case IH, Massey Ferguson and others, I found Kubota to be head and shoulders ahead of all the others. It’s built stronger, has more power, and is less expensive. I used my Kubota to haul timber down off a mountain. Some logs measure 30 in. in diameter by 60 ft. long, but the tractor’s 3-speed hydrostatic system didn’t even grunt. The tractor did everything I asked it to do, and then some.

“I thought I had a problem with the loader controls but the service tech figured it out. I had used the backhoe and when I put it in stow position I accidentally set one of the levers in the detent mode, which affected the loader controls. I learned to be sure of the lever position thereafter.”

Best Buy

Green Light fire ant control

Susan Beasley, Pottsboro, Texas · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 13

Susan’s impressed with Green Light fire ant control with Conserve (A.G. Organics, Prosper, Texas ph 877 447-3330; info@agorganics. com; www.greenlightco.com). It’s an organic granular product for use in home gardens and is designed to kill fire ants and their queen. It’s sold in a 1-lb. container. No water is necessary. You just sprinkle the bait evenly over and around each mound in a 4-ft. dia. circle. You can use it on lawns, around the perimeter of your home, around shrubs and trees, etc. Fire ants quickly find the bait, take it back to the mound, and feed it to the entire colony including the queens. Ants start dying in 24 to 36 hours.

One container treats 10,900 sq. ft., or 22 mounds. Sells for $12.50 plus S&H.

Best Buy

Case 1070 tractor equipped

John Keith, Edmonton, Alberta · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

An early 1970’s Case 1070 tractor equipped with a powershift transmission and cab rates as John’s “best buy”. “I bought this tractor at an auction more than 15 years ago for $3,200. It has thousands of hours of heavy field work on it but has required only routine maintenance. It has gone through one set of tires, one set of batteries, an alternator, and a water pump. It still runs like new.”

Best Buy

Ford 8N tractor fouls

Ronald Fenske, Engadine, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“Recently one of your readers complained that his Ford 8N tractor fouls a lot of spark plugs. My Ford 8N does the same thing but I found a way to solve the problem. A friend told me to start putting fuel oil in the gas, about one ounce per gallon. After about three months I noticed good results. In the past, the carburetor needle would always stick and gas would flood the carburetor and gas would run onto the ground. I had to shut off the gas line valve every time I shut the tractor off. Now I don’t have to do that any more. It very seldom fouls plugs and it also starts a lot better. I also use the same mixture in my Farmall H and Oliver 88 tractors, with good results.”

Best Buy

GM Sierra Classic pickup

Dennis Weber, Gladstone, Manitoba · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“I’ve been driving it since the fall of 1976 with very little downtime,” says Dennis, pleased with his 1977 GM Sierra Classic pickup. “The transmission was rebuilt in 1989 and the engine was replaced in 1991. In 1994, the front fenders and the doors were replaced because of rust and it also received a new paint job. Now it needs new tires again, but it’s well worth the cost.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki 2510 4-WD Mule utility vehicle

Garnet Symington, Macon, Mo. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

A 2000 Kawasaki 2510 4-WD Mule utility vehicle, which he bought used two years ago, rates as Garnet’s “best buy”. “I use it every day to feed cows, fix fences, drag and haul trees, and check pastures. I can go through muddy ground without leaving a track, where my pickup and tractor would make wheel ruts. This Mule deserves its name. I let my wife drive it whereas I don’t think a 4-wheeler would be safe for her to drive.”

Worst Buy

Golden Grain corn stove

Roy Cote, Ft. Morgan, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

Roy nominates his Golden Grain corn stove as his “worst buy”. “I bought it for use as a second stove in our house. But when we were unpacking it we noticed the auger had fallen through the glass door. The manufacturer failed to put in a set screw that holds the auger to the motor. Because of this the auger drive motor wiring had to be rewired, probably because the motor was free to ‘flop’ around during transit.

“We had to replace both blower motors due to noise (one stopped running). The circuit board had to be replaced, and the vacuum adjusting screw has been adjusted so many times that it will probably need to be replaced. The company says they test every stove before it leaves their warehouse. However, I haven’t been able to keep this stove running for more than 12 hours at a time. It just shuts off. Also, it’s very hard to light.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 pickup + 1 more

Bryan Moeller, Geneseo, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“It’s the best truck I’ve ever owned,” reports Bryan, pleased with his 1997 Dodge Ram 3500 pickup. “I bought it used in 2001 with about 139,000 miles on it. Now it has more than 217,000 miles on it and has required very few repairs. The automatic transmission failed at about 190,000 miles. I replaced it with a custom built transmission from Goerend Trans-mission, Inc. to make better use of the power my truck produces. I highly recommend this company (ph 563 778-2719; www.gbtransmissions.com). I now have almost 400 hp at the rear wheels. It’s mostly a play truck since I drive an 18-wheeler, but I do use it to tow heavy farm equipment or occasionally a gooseneck livestock trailer.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ferguson 30 tractor + 1 more

Mike Allen, Skippers, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“My all-time best buy was my Ferguson 30 tractor. My dad bought it before I was born and we still use it on our farm today. Over the years we bought many other Ferguson and Massey Ferguson tractors and they all worked great. As farms grew in size, so did the size of the equipment and tractors. The last Massey Ferguson I bought was a 160 hp, front wheel assist model. As the dealers went out of business in my area I decided to try another brand.

“That resulted in my worst buy - a 1998 Case 180 hp, front wheel assist row crop tractor. This tractor came from another state and had only about 1,200 hours on it. It has had a long list of problems. Here’s all the components that had to be replaced: the head gasket (three times), fuel injector (numerous times), water pump, vacuum valve for the turbo (twice), brake pedal switches, rear wheel bearing and seal, upper lift arm rocker shaft bushings and seals, both rear tires (after they separated), door shock, shifter accumulator (one also had to be recharged), throttle cable, shifter cable, fan belt tensioner, all six injectors, injector pump, both lift arm connector blocks.

“This tractor has about 3,100 hours on it. Now the 3-pt. lift has started to act up again so this will mean more shop time.”

Best Buy

Kubota M9000

Wes Mills, Red Bay, Alabama · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“My 2005 Kubota M9000 and M6800 tractors are both best buys. They start well and run smooth. They also ride well and have quiet, fuel efficient engines. The M9000 is my first 4-WD tractor, and I hope I’m never without a 4-WD tractor again.”

Best Buy

Vermeer 3-pt mounted 7-rotor

Bernard Nash, Indianola, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“Three years ago I bought a new Vermeer 3-pt. mounted 9-ft., 7-rotor disc mower and it’s my best buy. I use it to mow all kinds of hay ground and also to mow pasture and road banks. I use my International Harvester 656 diesel tractor to pull it. This machine takes only about half as much fuel as my 9-ft. sickle conditioner did to mow the same area and works at least twice as fast. It runs smooth and never plugs up, even on ant hills or in multiflora rose bushes. It’ll mow the heaviest crop of matted-down alfalfa without plugging up.

“There are several people in this area who have large lots of perhaps 20 acres who let me mow their grass twice each summer. I then bale it with my Vermeer 605C baler in June or July which results in a good yield of a grass and clover mixture. Then I cut again in late August or September for a much smaller yield. My mower leaves these lots looking as if they were mowed with a finish mower, and the landowners are quite pleased with how they look.

“This disc mower also runs quiet, because it uses a single shaft drive running out through the bar to individually drive each rotor, which eliminates the need for idler gears.

“This mower has been a pure joy to operate. I doubt that I’ll ever use a sickle mower again.”

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 135 tractor

John Beck, Bismarck, N. Dak. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“I bought my 1966 Massey Ferguson 135 tractor used with about 1,300 hours on it, and it’s my best buy. I use it on my 8-acre tree farm. It’s very dependable and doesn’t have a lot of modern electronics to cause problems. The transmission has six speeds forward and two reverse. It’s a quality-built machine.”

Best Buy

BouMatic Companion tie-stall barn take-offs

Wayne Horton, Randolph, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

Wayne’s impressed with his BouMatic Companion tie-stall barn take-offs. “They’re well designed and make milking in a tie-stall barn a lot easier job. Even with one person milking I have no problems with six units in our 62-cow barn, and I don’t have to worry about over milking the cows. I did have a few problems with setting adjustments, but they were promptly taken care of by the dealer and have been trouble-free.”

He says his BouMatic Companion milk yield indicator is his “worst buy”. “I decided to have one unit installed on one of my Boumatic take-offs. I wanted to try it out before I bought them for all six take-offs. I bought it for checking milk weights and Somatic cell counts on fresh cows. However, it has been a nightmare since day one. The milk weights can be anywhere from right on the money to 10 lbs. off for no reason at all, when compared with weights taken when the DHIA tester is in each month. And the dealer hasn’t been able to get the Somatic cell setting right yet.”

Best Buy

Recently our satellite TV company told us we would no longer able to g

C.F. Marley, Nokomis, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“Recently our satellite TV company told us we would no longer able to get a favorite channel. We were told the broadcaster had switched satellites and we would need a new receiver, which would cost $99.

“We thought about it for a while, then we recalled that we had an active contract that included that channel. So we called the satellite company and reminded them of that. There was no further argument. The company put up a new receiver at no further cost to us. The moral of the story? If you lose a favorite channel, don’t spend any money until you check your contract.”

Best Buy

Case IH 80 snowblower

James Kluver, Fairmont, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

“My Case IH 80 snowblower is the best snow-blower I’ve owned. I can see the blades turning and it never shears pins. It does a nice, clean job of blowing snow. It takes less power for the tractor driving it and is easy on the pto. Also, it never plugs up.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram diesel 4-wd + 1 more

Loren Harris, Spring Creek, Nevada · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 14

Loren likes his 2006 Dodge diesel 4-WD Mega Cab pickup. “It has a lot of power and torque and a roomy cab. It’s much more comfortable to drive and has more user friendly controls than the Ford diesel we had before.

“My 2003 Ford pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine is my worst buy. It caused us nothing but trouble. It rode stiff and the engine was always having problems. I’m a third generation Ford owner but never again. This pickup ran great when it was running, but it wasn’t reliable.”

Best Buy

Kubota 1500

Barry Nestle, Alvin, Texas · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“When I traded my Kubota 1500 for a new Kubota BX23 compact tractor, I did it to get a backhoe. But I ended up with a whole lot more. I can use the backhoe and the loader together, and later remove the backhoe to pull a 4-ft. Bushhog, posthole auger, belly mower and box blade. It handles them all well.

“Since the company where I worked closed down, I have found part time work with the tractor. I put in fences, dig ditches and mow fields. I’ve mowed 3-ft. tall grass with the Bushhog, taking a 2/3 bite with each pass.

“When my daughter wanted to build a house behind mine, I used the backhoe to dig ditches for water lines, build two drainage ditches and three French drains.

“I also built two attachments for it. One is a cable plow for burying wire. It gets cable down a foot below ground. I also built a grapple fork for the loader that attaches in place of the bucket.

“The grapple fork has fingers cut out of 3/8- in. steel plate with 1 1/2-in. square tubing for framing. The top jaw is in two sections, with each one operating on a different cylinder to open and close them. That way the unit can twist if I am grabbing something that is uneven side to side.

“The pitch is controlled by the bucket cylinder. To get the hydraulics for the jaw cylinders, I had to put a tee on existing lines and run it through an extra control valve, but it works great. When opened completely, it has about a 2 1/2-ft. jaw opening, tip to jaw tip.

“I’ve picked up telephone poles, brush and all kinds of stuff. My daughter had a bunch of sheet rock left over from building the house. I just picked it up with the grapple and threw it into the dumpster. It saves my back and a lot of time. I even tore down an old barn with it.

“This little Kubota has been my best buy ever.”

Worst Buy

Waterwise Co

Vernon Stolte, Watertown, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“The water distiller I bought from Waterwise Co. is my worst buy. It sat in the box for two or three months before we tried to use it. But when I put it in use it worked only for about six months or so before the boiler gasket started to leak. Not long after that it started to shut off in mid cycle. This went on for a while, and then it quit working altogether. I called the company, and they said to send the machine back and they’d check it out.

“I paid about $400 for the distiller, and it cost just under $30 to send back. The company called me and wanted $98 to repair the unit. They just about completely rebuilt the machine, without honoring the warranty, and then sent it back to me. We’ve had the machine in use for seven or eight months now, but the same problem is happening all over again.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 270 skidsteer loader

Adam Dufour, Salem, Ind. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My 2004 Deere 270 skidsteer loader is my worst buy. The engine oil filter was loose and leaking when the dealer delivered the unit, and there was a problem with a hydraulic fitting. The seat belt safety switch failed the first day of use. At 100 hours the left side wheel motor began turning only half as fast as the right side, and it took the dealer eight weeks to solve the problem. When he finally got it fixed the unit was plagued with leaks - hydraulic oil and anti-freeze - because it had been taken apart and put back together so many times. I sold the unit before it was even a year old.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland TC35 DA tractor equipped + 1 more

Walter Betzel, River Falls, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

Walter’s the satisfied owner of a 2005 New Holland TC35 DA tractor equipped with super steer and 4-WD. “I love the super steer system - it makes any job I do with this tractor fun. It has a lot of power for its size and uses less fuel than my riding mower. The quality of the entire tractor is great.”

On the worst buy side, he lists his 2004 Cub Cadet 5284 and 2005 Cub Cadet 6284 4-WD tractors. “The 5284 went through four hydro transmissions in only six months and 35 hours. They couldn’t get another transmission for a few months because they’re made in China so I traded it for the 6284 model. However, it had the same transmission trouble - the hydro wouldn’t hold up going from forward to reverse.”

Best Buy

Loftness Kwik Pik rock picker

Brian Buysse, Ghent, Minn. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

He nominates his 2006 skid loader-mounted Loftness Kwik Pik rock picker as his “best buy”. “It has a hydraulically reversible reel that separates rocks from dirt, which we really like. The reel sweeps rocks into the bucket, instead of us having to drive the bucket into the dirt.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 9560 combine

Robert S. Young, Jerseyville, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“Our 2006 Deere 9560 combine is our worst buy. We used it for only about 80 hours when a line came off the fuel injector and caught fire. It burned the wiring off the engine. We ordered a new fuel line and it came the next day but it was the wrong one. They sent another one out and it was wrong, too. We finally located one in Vincenne, Ind. So we drove 190 miles one way to pick it up. Our insurance paid to get the combine going.

“Then one day I was cutting beans and backed up and saw smoke in the stubble. I got out the fire extinguisher to put the fire out. We let the combine sit and called the dealer. They came out but couldn’t find anything wrong. After we got done harvesting my son was cleaning the combine when he took the shield off and noticed two burned places on the side of the feederhouse. The bearings were out on the dust fan. Now the combine is sitting in the shed and hasn’t been repaired.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Trane Exterior forced air heating + 2 more

Larry M. Wilkerson, Griffithsville, W. Va. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My all-time worst buy is the Trane Exterior forced air heating and cooling system that we purchased for our farm house. It’s only six years old but already the heat exchanger has had to be replaced twice and the circuit board panel has also been replaced, along with two other repairs. The first heat exchanger was replaced when the unit was only a little more than one year old. At one time it was out of service for 30 days.

“My best buys have been three Toyota Tundra pickups from different model years. I haven’t had a single problem with these pickups. They’re the first vehicles I’ve bought new or used without some kind of problems.

“I’m also pleased with my Kubota 900 UTV. It’s a wonderful, versatile machine. Its 3-cyl. diesel engine is so fuel efficient that I almost forget to put in any fuel. It can haul tremendous loads with little effort, and the hydraulic dump bed works with the greatest of ease.”

Best Buy

McCulloch 610 chainsaw

Mike Bollendorf, Saulsbury, Tenn. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“More than 32 years ago I bought a used McCulloch 610 chainsaw for $100 and have used it on our farm ever since then. During a severe ice storm in 1994, I and others ran the saw day and night removing trees.

“I accidentally drove my tractor over this saw twice and had to make new housing parts with J.B. Weld. I’ve also replaced the spark plug, air filter, chain and bar several times. The muffler is burned out and I couldn’t find another, so now it’s very noisy.

“This machine has never failed to start and never requires more than five pulls. If I haven’t used it for some time I pour the old fuel out and replace it with a fresh gas/oil mixture. A local fire department has an abrasive saw, used to cut car bodies open, with the same McCulloch engine on it that has served them well for more than 25 years. Neither saw has ever been in a repair shop.”

Worst Buy

Harbor Freight Chicago electric dual

Paul E. Maurice, Auburn, Mass. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My worst buy was my Harbor Freight Chicago electric dual Mig 151 welder. While the price was attractive, the machine wasn’t. It’s made mostly of model airplane plastic and conked out after consuming less than one spool of wire. The flimsy wire feeder isn’t user serviceable, nor is the hard-wired gun.

“The only thing worse than the welder itself, was the dismal customer support following its failure. We’ve had a terrible time trying to get our money back.”

Best Buy

FarmerGPS guidance system

Joe Bahe, Stanley, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“I’m happy with our FarmerGPS guidance system (ph 780 990-4052; www.farmergps.com). It runs on a Windows laptop computer and connects to any GPS via a standard serial cable. We read about it in FARM SHOW (Vol. 30, No. 1).

“We bought this software last spring to use when spraying no-till soybeans and it did a good job,” says Bahe. “We mounted a laptop computer in the cab, which made viewing easy. It maps and has an integrated lightbar. This system is also very affordable and costs only a fraction of what other GPS systems cost.”

Best Buy

Kuhn 15-bale accumulator

Jim Weitzel, Middlefield, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My Kuhn 15-bale accumulator and grapple is my best buy. It has allowed me to almost triple the amount of hay I can put up in a day. It has a very simple design and is reasonably priced. It takes the drudgery out of making small square bales.”

Best Buy

Solid Steel steering stabilizer kit

Don Charlton, Athabasca, Alberta · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

Don’s happy with the Solid Steel steering stabilizer kit he installed on his 2002 Dodge 1-ton pickup (ph 306 842-4346; www.solidsteel.biz). The kit is designed to provide additional support to the steering sector shaft and eliminate sector shaft play in the steering box. It also helps keep the pickup frame from flexing at the steering box mounting point.

Installation takes about a half hour and requires no drilling or welding.

“The improvement made by this steering stabilizer kit was remarkable,” says Don. “The company’s service was absolutely first class, with easy-to-follow instructions regarding installation. I was impressed with the exceptional service.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Prairie 650 4-wheeler

Andrew L. Naylor, Johnson, Vt. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“I think it’s the best 4-wheeler ever built,” says Andrew about his 2002 Kawasaki Prairie 650 4-wheeler. “I’ve always been a Honda fan, but I decided to try out this Kawasaki model and am glad I did. I use it almost every day on my farm, which is on quite steep land. It has more than 3,650 miles on it but I haven’t had to work on it yet. It has required only routine maintenance. It’s an awesome machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ryobi 18-volt cordless drill + 1 more

J. Pat Branch, Kimberly, Idaho · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My Ryobi 18-volt cordless drill and cordless saw, which I bought at Home Depot, are my best buys. They were reasonably priced. I use them about once a week. When the battery is charged they have plenty of power.”

“My Dell computer was given to me by the Veterans Administration so it isn’t really a worst buy. But I don’t have much luck whenever I try to get service over the phone. I often have to go through three or four people and wait for an hour at a time.One time I was transferred to 12 different people in 2 1/2 hours. I have all this documented.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Honda Recon 250 ATV + 1 more

Dale Hoffman, St. Ansgar, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

“My 2000 Honda Recon 250 ATV works great for picking rocks whenever the ground is too wet for doing other field work. Also, it’ll easily handle a 15-gal. mounted sprayer. It requires only routine maintenance and just runs and runs.

“My Lincoln battery-powered grease gun burned up three chargers the first year because the batteries wouldn’t hold their charge. I paid $30 per charger and $35 per battery. Finally I quit using it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota L31330 HST tractor + 1 more

James Dentici, Weirsdale, Fla. · Vol. 31, No. 2 (2007), p. 15

James is happy with his 2005 Kubota L31330 HST tractor. “I use this tractor for bush hogging, finish mowing, disking, and moving dirt and manure piles. It’s powerful enough for most farm chores. Great company support.

“My 2006 Troy-Bilt Super Bronco is cheaply made ever since the company was taken over by MTD. The steering mechanism loosened after only one month, and the front wheel wobbled after three months. There was a burned oil odor after seven months.”