Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011)

82 reports from pages 12–15 · 76 Best Buys15 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Bobcat A300 loader tractor

Richard Eltgroth, Sauk Centre, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“I like my Bobcat A300 loader tractor. With the push of one rocker switch it changes from being a skidsteer to all-wheel steer. I have had it for about 5 years. It can really push hard, and will lift 3,000 lbs. up to 10 ft. high with its 81 hp. Kubota diesel engine. One joystick controls the steering and another controls the bucket.”

Best Buy

Kubota M6040 tractor + 1 more

Darrel Bates, Philadelphia, Miss. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“It handles like a dream and has good power and lugging ability,” says Darrel about his 2009 Kubota M6040 tractor. “This is my sixth Kubota tractor and they’ve all worked good.

“My Tufline SF300 ATV pull-type fertilizer spreader works great (www.monroetufline.com; ph 662 328-8347). It comes with a large 600-lb. capacity hopper and spreads evenly up to 35 ft. Dual lever control spreads to the left or right, or in a full 180-degree pattern. It cleans up easily and also pulls easy.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2520 compact tractor

Michael Myers, Fredonia, Kan. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“It has only 25 hp, but this little beast does it all,” reports Michael about his 2008 Deere 2520 compact tractor. “We use it with a 4-ft. tiller, a 1-bottom moldboard plow, and with a bucket and rear blade to move snow. It’ll bush hog a 4-ft. swath no matter how high the weeds.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Jeep Cherokee + 1 more

Dwight A. Pfeiffer, Prairie Home, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“In 1998 I bought a 1996 Jeep Cherokee used with about 10,000 miles on it. It has no rust on the body and starts every time, and the tires still wear even. It gets 19 mpg. Now this vehicle has about 286,000 miles on it and the only repair it has needed was to overhaul the transfer case. I wish everything else I owned was as reliable as this Jeep.

“My Chuck Wagon utility vehicle is my worst buy. It has no power and can barely pull itself up our driveway. I’ve had to replace the throttle cable twice, and it’ll probably go out again soon. I thought I would use this machine to haul firewood, but that’s out. Now it’s just an expensive golf cart with a bed on back.”

Best Buy

Harman PC45 corn stove

Randy Hinzmann, Zumbrota, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“This stove heats great and has been trouble-free,” says Randy about his 2007 Harman PC45 corn stove (www.harmanstoves.com). “We have a St. Croix corn stove in the basement, but the Harman model puts out twice as much heat burning the same amount of corn. The auto-start function is a real plus, too. I like not having to mess around with wood pellets or starter bricks.”

Best Buy

Snapper walk-behind mower + 1 more

David Weidner, Chambersburg, Penn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“About 15 years ago my wife came home with a new Snapper walk-behind mower, and it works every bit as good today as it did then. I’m not great at providing regular maintenance, so in the fall this mower goes straight into the shed until the next year. The following spring, out it comes and away we go. It’s hard to believe it’s still working so well.

“We knew that some day the Snapper would go to mower heaven, so we got a great deal on a Troy Bilt walk-behind mower. Our problems began right away. The forward clutch never seemed to work right, and the dogs in the wheels also malfunctioned. Finally, I took the machine’s little plastic transmission apart but couldn’t get the worm gear to mesh. Back in the shed the mower went, maybe for forever.”

Best Buy

Honda Ridgeline

Jim Gelley, Ponoka, Alta. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“Over the years I’ve owned many different makes of 1/2-ton pickups, but my 2011 Honda Ridgeline is the best ever. It has front wheel drive, which is where the drive wheels should be on a 1/2-ton pickup. If I hit a patch of ice this pickup goes into 4-WD automatically. Also, there’s a good-sized waterproof box under the main box. I also owned 2006 and 2008 Ridgelines.”

Best Buy

Reese 2400 HL drum mower

Jim Love, Pattersonville, N.Y. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“My 2008 Reese 2400 HL drum mower will mow anything, anytime, anywhere, wet or dry, without plugging up. It’s also easy to service. After I bought this mower I sold both my haybines and also my tedder. This machine mows faster than my haybines ever did, and there’s a lot less to go wrong on it. Requires a lot less power. When it’s equipped with a tedder attachment it’ll dry hay as fast as a tedder can. And when you’re done haying you can use this mower to top your pastures. It’s built to last. I wish all equipment worked as well.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DR walk-behind mower + 1 more

Glen Ray Goodson, Galax, Va. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“My 2008 DR walk-behind mower is built tough and is dependable. No problems. However, I don’t like the wheels and tires on it.

“My Stihl MS80 and MS 250 chainsaws have to set idle for a long time before they will run well. The chains won’t stay on the bar even though they’re properly tensioned. I’ve tried everything I can think of to fix these problems without success. These saws also guzzle gas.”

Best Buy

Landini 65F ag crawler tractor

Mike Zimmerman, Versailles, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

He’s pleased with his 1999 Landini 65F ag crawler tractor. “I bought it used in 2006 with only 1,600 hours. The tractor has a 65 hp Perkins engine with a 16-speed transmission, 3 pt. hitch, pto, double hydraulics, and hydraulic steering.

“This 65 hp crawler will outperform any 4-WD tractor in the produce patch. It has less slippage and reduces soil compaction when tilling ground. Our fields are usually a little on the wet side early in the spring and, with the crawler, we can till fields one or two days earlier.

“We also like using it with our plastic mulch laying machine. The soil is soft and fluffy after tilling and the crawler keeps compaction to a minium so that there’s plenty of loose soil to cover the edges of the plastic. With tracks, we don’t feel every hump and bump in the field and therefore it holds equipment more level. We also like it at harvest time to bring in produce when fields are wet.”

Best Buy

Bryan Parker’s pony motor conversion

Mark Williams, Bonesteel, S. Dak. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 12

“I saw the article in FARM SHOW about Bryan Parker’s pony motor conversion for old Caterpillar engines (ph 575 465-0276). It’s a bolt-on conversion kit with no need to drill holes to mount it. Bryan does what he says and answers all your questions before and after the sale. If anyone has an old dozer with a bad pony motor, I highly recommend checking this out rather than letting the machine sit.”

Best Buy

Kubota

Mark Kjar, Spotsylvania, Va. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I wanted to buy a front-mounted blade for my best buy Kubota but the dealer wanted $2,100 for a factory unit. Instead, I bought a rear-mount 3-pt. blade from Tractor Supply Company, as well as a few hydraulic cylinders, some hoses and couplings. With some miscellaneous steel, a little hardware and paint, I spent a total of about $700 to mount the blade on front. What I like about it is that it lets me keep the belly mower on, unlike the factory unit. The plow comes off by removing two pins and unhooking the hydraulic couplers. My tractor came equipped with a loader so the hydraulic control valves remain in place.”

Best Buy

Satoh loader tractor equipped

Richard Groth, Naperville, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I like the chainsaw blade sharpener I bought from Harbor Freight. I only need to take a small amount of metal off to sharpen the blade. It works perfect. There’s a little stop that you push the teeth against, and after you lock the stop in place you pull the grinding wheel down. Once one side of the chain has been sharpened, you rotate it 90 degrees the other way to sharpen the other teeth. I bought this unit 2 years ago for $20; now it sells for about $35.

“About 40 years ago I bought a Satoh loader tractor equipped with a 2-cyl. diesel engine, and it still works great. I use it with a 4-ft. bucket, a 42-in. Satoh rototiller, and a 4-ft. Woods mower. I have a big garden on my 3-acre property so I use it a lot. It’s a 15 hp tractor, but it feels like it has 45 hp. The only parts I’ve replaced were the starter and solenoid.

“This tractor has a dual range transmission with 6 forward speeds and 2 reverse. It also has a 3-pt. hitch and a 2-speed pto. After I bought the tractor the company was bought out by Mitsubishi, which stopped making the tractor a few years ago. However, I understand there’s a salvage yard in Roanoke, Virginia that still supplies parts.”

Best Buy

Simple Green all-purpose cleaner

Christine Hoormann, St. Louis, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“For years, my husband Ken has been using Simple Green all-purpose cleaner in his garage on everything from greasy parts to tire whitewalls (ph 800 228-0709; www.simplegreen.com). He passed along a tip to me that he heard at a car show: Simple Green can also be used to do laundry. If Simple Green won’t take a stain out of clothes, nothing will. We buy the concentrate by the gallon.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husqvarna 372 XP chainsaw equipped + 1 more

Arthur Freymiller, Fennimore, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“My 2000 Husqvarna 372 XP chainsaw equipped with a 24-in. blade has plenty of power for its size, starts easy, and handles well. It has never been in the shop. The only repair was to an anti-vibration spring, and I also had to buy a new air filter.

“After I used my MTD riding mower a few times it wouldn’t start. The dealer found a valve retainer had broken. The engine was built in China and no parts were available. Neither the company nor WalMart would help.”

Best Buy

Black+Decker cordless pole chainsaw

Rick Smith, San Luis Obispo, Calif. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I find electric chainsaws are wimpy, so when I bought my 2005 Black & Decker cordless pole chainsaw I knew I was taking a chance. I used it on 12 pine trees and more than 40 live oaks, which the fire officials had ordered me to ‘limb up’ to 6 to 10 ft. above ground. The $140 Black & Decker works like a dream and made quick work out of cutting hundreds of branches up to 3 in. in dia. It’s a lightweight saw, but it works perfect for my needs. My only complaint is that the battery takes 8 hours to recharge.”

Best Buy

Ford F-250 pickup equipped

Martin Wright, San Angelo, Texas · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“It has more than 400,000 miles on it but still runs great,” says Martin about his 1999 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine and automatic transmission. “I replaced the water pump and radiator at about 250,000 miles. If I ever need a new pickup it’ll be another Ford equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine.”

Best Buy

John Deere 435 round baler equipped

David Millsap, Abingdon, Va. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I like my 1997 Deere 435 round baler equipped with a net wrap attachment. I bought this baler used in 2007, but it has performed like new. It makes 4-ft. wide bales that I can transport 2 wide on a trailer. I use it to make a 4 by 5-ft. bale and have weighed several bales that average 1,200 lbs. Net wrap reduces spoilage and helps the bales keep their shape for more than 2 seasons. Nothing beats a green baler. I know because I’ve owned red ones and yellow ones in the past, but I went back to green.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2305 MFWD utility loader model

Brian Dyck, Headingley, Man. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“They did their homework when they built this tractor,” says Brian about his 2008 Deere 2305 MFWD utility loader model. “The controls are convenient to use, and the 200 CX loader can be set up in less than 1 min. I use the tractor with a 62-in. mid-mount mower which cuts level, and with a front-mount snowblower that throws snow out up to 50 ft. Even with turf tires, the front-wheel assist keeps the tractor going right through mud and snow.”

Best Buy

Kubota BX25 TLB tractor

Ed Snider, Kitchener, Ont. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

Ed’s the proud owner of a 2010 Kubota BX25 TLB tractor. “It’s a handy tractor for our small property and eliminates the need to push a wheelbarrow or dig postholes by hand. The loader handles all our snow moving jobs as well.”

Best Buy

Morton 36 + 3 more

Phil Carter, New Era, Mich. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

Phil’s happy with his 2010 Morton 36 by 45 by 14-ft. building, which he uses as an agrichemical handling facility. “It’s a high quality building. The construction crew and foreman were a pleasure to work with and always took the time to answer questions and address any concerns we had. The salesman always went out of his way to make sure we were 100 percent satisfied. You can buy cheaper buildings, but if you want a top notch product this company is your only choice.

“Our CornPro bumper pull, 18-ft. livestock trailer handles nice and has torsion axles, which I like. However, the paint job is the poorest I’ve ever seen. There appears to be no primer under the paint, which is badly rusted after little use. Our salt-covered roads probably are the cause of the rust, but a manufacturer should use a painting process that would last.

“I really like our Bush Hog zero turn riding mower, which we use on 4 acres of lawn around our farmstead. It has reduced our mowing time by half and uses only about 1/2 gal. of gas per hour. It also works great in tight spaces. You use a foot pedal to raise the mower deck, which leaves your hands free. My only complaint is with the Honda engine, which runs cold blooded until it warms up. Also, the battery has to be recharged if the machine sets idle even for just a couple weeks. It could use a higher quality battery.

“Our Bush Hog Trailhand utility vehicle has much higher ground clearance than a Gator or Mule. We use it for general farm chores and to check our orchards. Our employees use it to pick up big chunks of wood left over from tree trimming work, and to handle insect mating disruption devices out in the trees. My grandkids love to drive it, and it helps them learn how to safely operate equipment. The front receiver hitch is useful for pushing wagons and also accepts a 6-ft. snowplow.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6415 MFWD tractor equipped

Ray Schwarz, Gower, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

Ray’s the satisfied owner of a 2007 Deere 6415 MFWD tractor equipped with cab. “This size tractor really fits our needs for both loader work and field work. It has some features found on high-end tractors but without all the electronics. The 4-cyl. engine has power and is easy on fuel. We installed Euro-style fender extensions so the windows always stay clean.”

Best Buy

I’ve owned 5 other new tractors in the past, but none came close to th

Jeff Neiman, McCreary, Man. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I’ve owned 5 other new tractors in the past, but none came close to the outstanding reliability of lifting, you can haul more with less effort. The 3 wheels stabilize the load so it won’t tip over as easily. A foot-operated brake locks it on slopes. We use it to haul firewood, manure, bricks, stones and yard waste. It’s one of the best presents my husband ever bought me.”

Best Buy

Wesley Enterprises + 1 more

Laura Meyer, Borden, Ind. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“The ‘Will Borrow’ from Wesley Enterprises in Silex, Mo., is a kit for wheelbarrows that adds two back wheels and a horizontal handlebar extension that’s about waist high

(www.carrilitecorrals.com). This is a great

product for women or people with back

problems. Since you roll the load instead and performance of this one,” says Jeff about his 2003 Deere 7810 MFWD model.

Best Buy

Miller 212 Auto Set welder + 1 more

Jason Peterson, Boyceville, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

Jason’s impressed with his Miller 212 Auto Set welder. “This machine does a great job welding aluminum and steel. You can let the machine set the wire speed, or you can set it yourself.

“I bought my Snap-On 3/8-in. air drill to replace an Ingersol Rand 3/8-in. model. However, it had less power than the Ingersol Rand and even had less power than our cordless drill. So I returned it and rebuilt the Ingersol Rand model for $35, which saved me a lot of money.”

Best Buy

Georgia steel toe work

Jon Peterson, Bottineau, N. Dak. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“I find Georgia steel toe work boots to be incredibly warm and comfortable (ph 877 795-2410; www.georgiaboot.com). I work in the oil field industry and live on a farm and these boots have held up to 3 winters of hard use. In the past, I’d usually get only 1 winter or so out of a pair of work boots.”

Best Buy

Ryobi cordless self-propelled walk-behind

George Schneider, Fort Steele, Wyo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“My Ryobi cordless self-propelled walk-behind mower is supposed to be maintenance-free, but it’s not. The mower’s cover kept all the dust and debris inside, and as a result the top bearing ‘walled out’, ruining the motor. After it was repaired the battery charger quit, and the lower bearing also went bad.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4010 tractor

Dan Klingbiel, Sointula, B.C. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“My Deere 4010 tractor always starts right up, has plenty of power, and doesn’t use much fuel. It’s sized just right for our 10-acre farm. I looked at other small tractors, but settled on this one because we have a Deere mechanic here on the island where we live. I haven’t had to use him, though.”

Best Buy

Heftee Lift 2000 lets me position

Richard A. Willems, New Windsor, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

Richard nominates his Heftee Lift 2000 as his “best buy” (ph 800 755-7540; www.heftee.com). It can lift up to 2,000 lbs. up to 6 ft. high in 30 seconds, and is adjustable for a variety of wheelbases.

“I repair lawn mowers, and the Heftee Lift 2000 lets me position them at a convenient height. I can even raise the mower high enough to remove the blades while standing. I also own a Heftee deck cart, which lets me remove the deck with the mower raised. I also bought a Heftee 250 lift for use with walk-behind mowers. Now I never have to get down on the floor to work on mowers.”

Best Buy

Case IH 2388 combine + 1 more

Vickie Malugg, Wittenberg, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“We like our 2004 Case IH 2388 combine. For years we harvested with a Case IH 1688. Switching to the 2388 has been a great experience. It has an operator friendly cab.

“We use a 2009 Deere header transport cart to move our Case IH 2606 combine head. The problem is this cart has no suspension. As a result, we can go only about 30 mph following behind our trucks or else the cart will start to bounce. Also, the rock trap on the combine makes the machine hard to load and unload from the cart.”

Best Buy

Kubota L3400 4-WD loader tractor + 2 more

Tim Stephens, City of Central, La. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“This tractor has done everything I’ve asked it to do,” reports Tim about his 2007 Kubota L3400 4-WD loader tractor, which he uses with a Woods finishing mower. “The system has auto-release points in the hydraulics that won’t let you tear it up, which I think is great. It may not be perfect, but it’s close to it. The Woods mower is also a best buy.

“I like the frame and overall construction on my 2010 King Cutter 6-ft. bush hog. However, already the seals are leaking and the grease fittings are loose. And I’m disappointed how it performs in tall grass.”

Best Buy

Mac Tools 1/4-in drive air ratchet + 1 more

Stephen Wilson, Rogersville, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I like my Mac Tools 1/4-in. drive air ratchet (ph 800 622-8665; www.mactools.com). I bought 2 of these ratchets and they’re a delight to use. They’re polished and smooth on my hands and are built tough. A 1/4-in. drive air ratchet may be too small for working on farm stuff, but it works great for repairing lawn mower engines. Also, you can work on most new cars with 1/4-in. drive tools.

“In 2008 my father’s estate gave me a new 2004 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup. We went out to California to pick it up with only 1,242 miles on it. We made it back from California just fine, even though the pickup bed was loaded and we were pulling a trailer loaded with 3,500 lbs. of stuff. Now this pickup has almost 20,000 miles on it and there are problems. The Allison automatic transmission shifts funny, and the heater/air conditioner switch panel doesn’t work. The switch cost $222 to replace and the pickup’s warranty has expired. This pickup isn’t built as good as my old 1957 model. Anyone could keep that pickup going.”

Best Buy

Kubota B7501 HST tractor

Robert Frear, McBride, B.C. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

A 2005 Kubota B7501 HST tractor rates as Robert’s “best buy”. “This tractor has a heart of gold. I had a crippling stroke and wasn’t too impressed with the selection of wheelchairs out there, so I decided to buy this tractor, too. Now I get more done than I ever could when I was young and healthy. Wheelchairs are by default self-defeating, while Kubota tractors are enabling to the highest degree.”

Best Buy

WD-40 Smart Straw spray lubricant

Robert L. Newman, Gold Bar, Wash. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

Robert likes WD-40 Smart Straw spray lubricant (ph 888 324-7596; www.wd40.com). The aerosol can comes with a permanently attached straw that sprays 2 ways. You flip the straw up for a precision stream and down for a regular spray action. “You don’t have to worry about losing an unattached straw or having to look for a straw that pops out,” says Robert.

Best Buy

Kershaw 1600 pocket knife

Robert McIlmoil, Hamilton, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I received a Kershaw 1600 pocket knife as a gift in 2005, and I carry it with me everywhere I go and use it daily. It has held up extremely well compared to other knives I’ve had in the past. It has an internal spring that flips the blade open so I can open it using just one hand. Two weeks ago the spring broke, so I contacted the company to see if I could purchase a new spring. Instead, they said they would send me a new spring free of charge and I received it just 3 days later. Excellent customer service backing up an excellent product.”

Best Buy

Fuji FinePix JV camera takes great + 1 more

Michael Rhodes, Capron, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“Our Fuji FinePix JV camera takes great photos and is easy to use. It also works great for making movies and is an amazing product for its size. And, it’s reasonably priced.

“Our Eden Pure quartz infrared portable heater gobbles electricity and boosted our electricity bill from an average of $90 per month to $315. It didn’t save any money heating our home.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-250 pickup equipped

Gene Comstock, Milton, Penn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“My 2011 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a 6.3-liter, V-8 gas engine and 6-speed automatic transmission is my worst buy. The company claims ‘best in class economy’ for this pickup. Yet it gets only 13 mpg empty and 10 mpg when towing a 7,000-lb. GVW trailer. The engine is gutless, and the transmission is constantly shifting gears with mild acceleration. As a result, I’m always trying to find a power band that doesn’t exist.”

Best Buy

Kubota L260 + 1 more

Donnie Matthews, StockBridge, Ga. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“My late 1970’s Kubota L260, which I bought used, is a great tractor. My only maintenance cost was $10 for a used battery.

“The hose and spray gun on my Husky electric pressure washer started leaking, causing pressure problems. Neither the company nor Home Depot would help. So I cut off the electric cord and hooked it up to a big fan, and then threw the pressure washer away.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 pickup equipped

Paul Pearce II, Chesapeake, Va. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

Paul’s had problems with his 2006 Ford F-350 pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter diesel engine. “I bought this pickup in August 2007. Since then it has left me stranded on the side of the road at least twice a year. Sometimes I was pulling a trailer, and sometimes I was out of town on vacation. Fortunately, I had bought an extended bumper-to-bumper warranty or I’d have spent about $24,000 on repairs.

“The last time the pickup broke down, the extended warranty had expired by just 400 miles and the company wanted $900 to replace the fuel injection control module. I was so mad I called Ford’s corporate office, but they told me to call the Better Business Bureau. So I had the pickup towed away and swore not to spend another penny on it.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Simplicity Landlord garden tractor + 2 more

Duane E. Ingram, Lincoln, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I use a 48-in. snowblower on my 2002 Simplicity Landlord garden tractor. The snowblower can easily clear 8-in. deep snow from my driveway in no time. I also use the snowblower to clear my neighbor’s driveway and to clear snow around buildings.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2009 Shindaiwa “long shaft” weed eater. “I don’t like the counterclockwise rotation of the string, and using this ‘long shaft’ weed eater gives me a sore back. I wish I still had my Echo 1100 series curved shaft model. That was a good machine.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

TroyBilt rototiller + 1 more

Thomas Cooke, Lubec, Maine · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

A 1985 TroyBilt rototiller rates as Thomas’s “best buy”. “I use it every year to plant 2 acres of onions, and it always starts on the first pull. I know I can count on this tiller year after year.”

He’s had electrical problems with his 2003 GM Sierra 1500 4-WD pickup. “The lights inside the cab and the headlights work only when they feel like it. At night, before I drive anywhere I have to start the pickup and set the emergency brake, then get out and walk to the front of the vehicle and bang on the headlights to get them to work. I have to do the same for the interior lights. The dealer and other shops in my area don’t have a clue what’s wrong.”

Best Buy

MillerMatic 35 wire feed welder + 1 more

Brad Trelka, Junction City, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I like my 1983 MillerMatic 35 wire feed welder. I use it almost every day. One time I melted the leads right off. I took the welder in to have it fixed, and it worked like new again. I’d recommend this welder to anyone.

“In 2009 I bought an Ingersoll Rand 13 hp portable air compressor from Northern Tool & Equipment. It’s equipped with a 30-gal. tank and a Honda engine that delivers 25 cfm at 175 psi. I ordered the unit in May but didn’t receive it until October 15.

“Once I started the compressor it ran for only about 30 seconds before the drive belt flew off. I aligned the pulleys and put the belt back on, and it worked a little longer. I did everything according to the owner’s manual but got no help from Northern Tool. We were becoming the laughing stock of service trucks in our area because a tank of gas in the truck would last longer than the belts on the compressor.

“I had to borrow a compressor from a customer, while the shiny new compressor on my truck was nothing more than a boat anchor. I called Ingersoll Rand and they scheduled a technician to make a service call. The company wasn’t happy that I had bought the compressor from Northern Tool instead of from one of their sales outlets. The technician came out 3 or 4 times and found the pulley on the compressor was machined wrong so the belt wouldn’t ride in the sheave properly. He changed the pulley, but again the belt came off. Then the technician talked to an assembly line worker at the factory, who said the belt had the wrong tension level. We made an adjustment and that seems to have solved the problem. Now the compressor is out of warranty so I’m on my own. So far so good, though.

“My neighbor purchased a similar air compressor from Harbor Freight about the same time for $1,000, while mine cost $2,450. His compressor is made in China, but he says nothing has gone wrong and he’s well satisfied with it. I think we might want to rethink the American pride and quality of products.”

Best Buy

Brute 3 000 psi

Lee Webb, Morris, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I like my Brute 3,000 psi pressure washer equipped with a Briggs & Stratton engine (ph 800 743-4115; www.brutepower.com). It starts and runs well and removes hardened dirt and grease from my skid loader without needing detergent. It comes with 4 different tips for different applications. One tip can be used to remove old paint in preparation for painting tractors.”

Best Buy

Braber Agriease 3-pt mounted

Dick Day, Norfolk, Neb. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

Dick’s impressed with the Braber Agriease 72-in., 3-pt. mounted snowblower he bought at Northern Tool & Equipment (www.northerntool.com). “I was skeptical of a 72-in. snowblower that sells for about half or less of comparable units. So I did research on Braber Equipment and asked some questions before buying this unit. The customer support folks at Northern Tool helped put me in touch with the right person at Braber, and he was able to answer my questions about quality, pricing and parts availability. I felt so comfortable with his answers that I immediately ordered one.

“Upon arrival, I expected to see a snowblower that resembled a high school metal shop project. But what I received instead was a well constructed piece of equipment that will still be working long after I’m gone. The fit and finish is the same as what I see on other brands sitting on implement dealer lots. The first time I engaged the pto I thought it was broken because the machine ran so quiet.”

Best Buy

Honda Foreman 500

Eugene Hawes, Baker City, Ore. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

Eugene is a fence contractor and rancher who likes his 2007 Honda Foreman 500 and 2000 Honda Foreman 450 4-wheelers. “I bought both machines new and use them all year long for building fences, checking on irrigation systems, and blowing snow. These machines are true workhorses and have required only general maintenance.”

Best Buy

Danner boots + 1 more

William T. Angus, Rhodes, Mich. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I have about a dozen pairs of U.S.-made Danner boots, and they’re all great (ph 877 432-6637; www.danner.com). I’ve worn these shoes since 1994 and have 2 pairs that have been resoled twice. Chinese-made Danner boots are also available, but I have no first hand knowledge of them and won’t buy them. Unfortunately, you have to buy U.S.-made Danner boots online as most retailers won’t sell them in stores. The boots start at $200 and go up. However, once you invest in quality footwear you won’t buy cheap boots again.

“We bought a Staber washing machine after reading a lot of good things about it. These washing machines are made in the U.S., use little water, and are designed so the owner can easily repair them. Now I know why. We spent $1,000 to buy our machine a few years ago, and about a year later the pump motor went out. The new motor was about 60 percent bigger so it barely cleared the housing. That tells me the original motor was undersized from the factory. A year later another part on the machine broke.

“If you don’t get the detergent level just right, this machine will overflow. It’s easy for the load to become unbalanced, which causes a lot of vibration. That can cause the main seal to rip and the main flywheel to come loose. Also, the mounting on the flywheel became elongated and I had to repair the pot metal. I can’t afford a new seal.

“Often when loads get unbalanced the timer will trip up and stick. As a result, my wife can’t just put in a load and do other chores; she has to babysit the machine. Now the machine needs $500 worth of parts to get it working again, but I won’t put even one penny into it. For the money I’ve spent on this machine, it should have come with a boatload of spare parts.”

Worst Buy

Chrysler Town

Darnell Carrer, Roxboro, N.C. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My worst buy was my wife’s 2005 Chrysler Town and Country van. At 24,000 miles, when the 3-year warranty had already expired, the driver’s side window motor had to be replaced at a cost of more than $400. The rack and pinion gear started leaking at about 35,000 miles and the repair would have cost more than $600, but fortunately the shop replaced it at no charge. At 39,000 miles the water pump started leaking, and that cost more than $200 to resolve. Now the van has just over 40,000 miles on it and the remote door locks don’t work.”

Best Buy

Montana 4045 tractor

T.M. and W.D. Bysel, Kansas City, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My 2005 Montana 4045 tractor works as good as a Kubota but cost a lot less. It’s an excellent tractor.

“I think all electric tools from Harbor Freight are worst buys. I’ve had problems with my 18-volt drill-drivers, 4-in. grinder, and sawzall. They have no bearings - only bushings that fail quickly.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 4-WD crewcab

Robert Olson, Alexandria, Minn. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I’ve owned more than 25 new pickups in the past 50 years, and this one is the best yet,” says Robert about his 2009 Ford F-150 4-WD crewcab FX4. “It has about 34,000 miles on it. The ride, drive, gas mileage, pulling power, visibility, comfort and handling on it are fantastic.”

Best Buy

Just For Copper

Tim Gasser, Prairie Du Sac, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I use called Just For Copper (ph 866 304-5335; www.justforcopper.com). It comes in a small applicator tube and lets you work with copper pipe the way you’d work with pvc pipe. When applied to copper it generates a chemical reaction, providing a hermetic weld that’s watertight and air tight, with no need for solder. “I did some copper plumbing with this product and it works fantastic,” says Gerald.

Best Buy

B&W turnover ball hitch + 1 more

Danny Thomas, Whitewood, Sask. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I’m happy with the B&W turnover ball hitch I installed on my Dodge 3500 pickup (ph 877 774-6473; www.sdtrucksprings.com). It has the largest load capacity of any fifth wheel hitch ball on the market and leaves the floor of the truck box smooth. There are no annoying rails or plates.

“I like my Sirius satellite radio boombox, which I use in our shop and house. When you’re limited by location to mostly boring AM radio channels, the sound quality and variety of formats with this setup are terrific. A 1-year subscription costs $160, which I

Worst Buy

Bixby pellet stove

Wayne Tabor, Louisville, Ky. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My Bixby pellet stove is difficult to regulate and produces excessive amounts of ash. The convection motor failed, and a new motor costs $296 plus an additional $170 if you don’t return the old motor. I called the company for technical assistance, and they had the gall to inform me they charged $25 for each 10 minutes of advice. No wonder they’re in receivership.”

Worst Buy

Chevrolet 2500 pickup

David Silloway, Randolph Center, Vt. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My 2008 Chevrolet 2500 pickup is my worst buy. It had to be jump-started 10 times and the battery was replaced twice. Then the company decided to install a dual battery system at no charge. Hopefully this will make the vehicle work as well as my 2001 Chevy.”

Best Buy

New Holland TC 210 tractor

Dana L. Ellsworth, Brushton, N.Y. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My 2004 New Holland TC 210 tractor worked great, until at about 900 hours when the starter had to be replaced. I’ve had 6 starters put on it, by 3 different dealers, in the past 18 months. All the starters had gear noses that were too long which caused them to rub against the flywheel, and then the tractor would stall out. As a result, this tractor has been sitting idle in our yard for almost a year. I’m about ready to scrap it out.”

Best Buy

Gorilla Tape

W.H. Bunting, Whitefield, Maine · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I think Gorilla Glue is highly overrated, but Gorilla Tape is absolutely wonderful. In fact, last year I gave away 10 of the large-size rolls for Christmas presents. Two years ago I used this tape to ‘weld’ together various pieces of thin, rusted-out, hard-to-weld sheet metal strippers on a Deere 14T baler. Deere wanted $70 for new strippers but the tape is still holding fine.”

Best Buy

Teter Hang Ups

Fred Space, Sussex, N.J. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I’m 82 years old and I’ve farmed my whole life. Through the years of hard work I developed a bulged disc in my spine. I went to a spine doctor and got some ‘epidural’ steroid shots at $1,200 per treatment. They worked for a few weeks, but then the pain came back. Then a friend told me about an ‘inversion table’ called Teter Hang Ups (ph 800 847-0143; www.teeter-inversion.com). You fasten your feet into clamps, and then when you raise your arms the unit tips upside down so you hang by your feet. Your spine then stretches so that the bulged disc retreats. I use it 10 min. at a time, twice a day. It has worked like a miracle and completely eliminated my back pain. It cost less than $400.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6430 Premium IVT tractor + 1 more

Randy Scott, Ottumwa, Iowa · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

Randy’s impressed with his Deere 6430 Premium IVT tractor. “When going down the road the tractor automatically drops the engine rpm’s while maintaining a constant speed. It saves a lot of fuel.

“My Case IH 125 Maxxum Economy tractor had slow hydraulics to start with, and the clutch wouldn’t ‘feather’ when hooking up implements. I had this tractor in the shop twice under warranty. When the warranty expired the tractor went off down the road, never to return.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt cordless 1/2-in drill + 1 more

Hobart Stewart, Republic, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

Hobart’s pleased with his DeWalt cordless 1/2-in. drill. “We’ve used this drill to screw on metal roofing and siding, to drill pilot holes, and to extract numerous screws and nuts. The batteries last a long time.

“We’ve had problems with our Swisher 34-ton log splitter. The idler pulley came loose from the shaft and fell off. We were able to find the belt and put it back on. But then as we were bringing the splitter in for repairs to the carburetor, the belt fell off again and we had to buy a new belt and pulley. On the plus side, we haven’t found a log this splitter can’t handle.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Horsch Anderson PS 6015 no-till grain drill + 1 more

Eugene Cysewski, Courtenay, N. Dak. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“We like our 2009 Horsch Anderson PS 6015 no-till grain drill. This is our second Horsch Anderson drill, as we upgraded from a 40-ft. to a 60-ft. model. We’ve used it to produce good stands of small grains, soybeans and corn, all planted in twin rows. This drill allows one-pass planting with seed and fertilizer.

“We’re disappointed with our 2010 REM 2700 grain vac, which we bought after an older model wore out. It doesn’t have as much capacity as advertised and had mechanical problems, too. After using the machine for a few hours we traded for another brand.”

Best Buy

Volkswagen Golf tdi-equipped + 2 more

Mark A. Ostwinkle, Maquoketa, Iowa · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“My 2004 Volkswagen Golf TDI-equipped with a diesel engine and 5-speed transmission gets 42 to 50 mpg. It has about 98,000 miles on it with no problems.

“Two years ago I bought a used 1995 Ford F-350 4-WD dump truck equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine with about 70,000 miles on it. It’s a sharp looking truck with a lot of power. A great buy.

“My 1995 Ford F-250 4-WD extended cab pickup started using oil at 35,000 miles. It gets only 9 to 11 mpg, and less when pulling a trailer. Also, the front end requires a lot of maintenance.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Stihl handheld blower + 2 more

Tom Hartman, Decatur, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“Our Stihl handheld blower and Stihl string weed trimmers are best buys. We use them in our lawn business 5 days a week and they work great.

“Our 2005 Cub Cadet lawn tractor equipped with a 46-in. mower deck is a worst buy. It’s the only tractor we ever bought new. The compression release broke inside the engine with less than 100 hours on it. The deck belt wouldn’t stay on and when it fell off, often we would accidentally run over it and ruin it. This tractor spent more time in the shop than in our yard. Finally we sold it 2 years ago with less than 200 hours on it. Now we’re using a 1976 Deere 212 lawn tractor, which has had only minor problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Magna Matic 8000 blade grinder + 1 more

Jim Davies, Platteville, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“I operate a sharpening shop and do a lot of lawn mower blades. After going through 2 Foley blade grinders, in 2007 I bought a Magna Matic 8000 blade grinder which can be used to sharpen regular blades and also mulching blades. This machine does everything I expected it to. Also, the company is very knowledgeable and helpful.

“My 1996 Power King 18 hp Hydro garden tractor is a worst buy. Before the first season of mowing was over I already had trouble with the electric clutch. The dealer stood behind the tractor, but when we finally found out what was wrong the company sent the wrong parts. I still use this tractor to plow snow, but the fiberglass body has cracked and fell apart. Now the body is shot.”

Best Buy

Glow Boy stove

S. Sibold, St. Marys, Ohio · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“We use wood pellets to heat our home, and last year we bought a new Glow Boy stove from Kerns Fireplace in Rockford, Ohio (ph 231 745-6110; www.alternativeheatingandfuel.com). There were a few bugs that needed to be worked out, but the service man took care of them. Then last spring, a fire in the pellet stove climbed the auger and burned into the hopper bin. The dealer was there right away and took the stove to their shop. They had the stove over the summer and part of the fall, then returned it to us. After several days of burning, the stove again caught fire in the auger and spread to the hopper bin.

“Once again, the dealer came to check out the problem. The company called to help and sent us a new, upgraded stove. However, a short time later the stove caught fire again in the auger but this time we caught it before it spread to the hopper. Again, both the dealer and the company were there to provide help. The problem has finally been solved and we love our Glow Boy pellet stove.”

Best Buy

Stihl chainsaws + 2 more

Jed Greene, Ft. Smith, Ark. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“Several years ago I began acquiring Stihl chainsaws, including a 460, 440 Magnum, and two MS 210 models, and I’m thoroughly satisfied with all of them. They’re tough, work hard, have excellent design features, and never let me down. I won’t buy another brand.

“My Shindaiwa B450 brush cutter has tremendous power for its size, starts with 3 pulls every time, and runs forever on a tank of gas. I can’t say enough good things about it.” AmSteel Blue winch rope for pulling logs and it’s an amazing product (ph 785 856-1844; www.customsplice.com). This 1/2-in. rope has a 34,000-lb. rating yet it’ll float on water. It’s much easier to work with than conventional steel cable.”

Best Buy

Caterpillar 908 front-end loader equipped

Scott Freeman, Lucas, Ohio · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“We leased a 2005 Caterpillar 908 front-end loader equipped with a grapple bucket. Even though the Cat loader cost 2 to 3 times more than a skid loader, it can do 3 to 4 times more work. It articulates in the center and can turn short without wearing out the tires. It also has great lifting power and reach and is quick and smooth to operate.”