Mantis: what farmers say
44 reports in FARM SHOW · 36 Best Buys8 Worst Buys
Mantis rototiller
25 Best Buys6 Worst Buys“The first time I used my Mantis rototiller, the tines bent and wadded up like cardboard.
“With my Worx weedeater I’m lucky to get 15 min. on a battery charge.”
“I’m disappointed with the 20-lb. Mantis rototiller I bought to till my wife’s raised garden beds. When going forward the tiller jumps like a rabbit. I called the company and they said to run the engine at half throttle and till pulling backward. However, the advertisements and the salesman didn’t say to till backward. Another problem is that 5-in. tall weeds wrap around the tines and build up to the point where they eventually kill the motor.
“My New Holland TN75 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a Quickie front-end loader starts poor in cold weather and has poor visibility. The controls aren’t very handy either.
“My 1984 White 2-55 front wheel assist loader tractor has more than 11,000 hrs. on it. I use it to feed cattle, handle bales, plow snow and do other loader work. It starts good in cold weather.”
“I’ve put hundreds of hours on my 2005 Mantis rototiller with no problems, other than replacing the ignition coil. I seldom use my heavier rototiller because the Mantis is so convenient to use.”
“My Mantis garden rototiller is small but works good and is easy to operate. I used it hard last spring in my big garden and am well satis¿ ed with how it operates. It’s easy on fuel.”
“My Mantis garden rototiller is my worst buy. When it was delivered to me it wouldn’t start, and the company told me to take it to a repair shop. However, the shop couldn’t get it started and had to consult with the company. It has been in three different repair shops, but no one has been able to get it to run more than 15 min. Now it sits idle in my garage while I hand dig my wife’s flower beds.”
“I like my Deere 4600 tractor equipped with a 460 front-end loader, which I bought used with 350 hours on it. A landscaper had used this tractor so I installed new ag tires on it. So far, I’ve used it to move more than 2,000 cubic yards of sand and snow with no problems.
“My 2000 Mantis rototiller runs great and has required only one tune-up since I bought it.”
Scott’s impressed with his 2004 Dixie Chopper Silver Eagle zero turn riding mower equipped with a 50-in. deck. “I put 50 hours a year on this mower, and my wife and daughters love to use it, too. I’d definitely buy another one, but I don’t think this one will ever wear out.
“My 2008 Mantis rototiller is hard to start and won’t stay running. I’ve adjusted the carburetor according to the operator’s manual and the DVD, but it only runs for about 5 seconds and then dies.”
“My 2008 Mantis rototiller is lightweight but rugged, and the attachments for it work great.”
“My Mantis garden rototiller has worked flawlessly for four years. It operates exactly as the operator’s manual describes, and the manual was exceptionally well written. Tilling the garden is a breeze with this machine.”
“My 2007 Mantis rototiller has exceeded my expectations. The ground where I set up my garden was rocky but this little tiller was able to work through it. One of the teeth broke but the company covered it under warranty. I had a new part in about 1 1/2 weeks.”
“My 2008 Lincoln MKZ car handles well and has a solid feel. It gets 28 mpg on the highway.
“The Mantis rototiller I bought 15 years ago still starts and runs good.”
Lloyd’s happy with his 1995 Mantis rototiller. “All I do is put gas in and pull the starter rope. It always starts in about three pulls. Last year I finally bought a new spark plug for it.”
“My 2007 Mantis rototiller is small but does a good job. It’s lightweight, and it does a good job either tilling or cultivating.”
“My DeWalt 13-in. planer is my worst buy. It wouldn’t feed boards through properly so I took it back to the dealer. He cleaned the feed rolls and charged me for it, which I thought was unfair because the planer was still under warranty. It still didn’t work right.
“My Jet 13-in. planer is also a worst buy. After I use it to plane a couple of boards it gets hot and the safety switch shuts off. Then I have to wait five minutes before I can restart it.
“My Mantis rototiller starts good and has plenty of power, and is light enough that I can carry it with one hand. I like to use it to plant Christmas trees, loosening the soil before planting each seedling.”
“Last summer I bought a Mantis rototiller which I really like. When it arrived I didn’t think much about it until I began using it. This little rototiller tore up our hard clay ground with no trouble at all. It’s easy to start and also easy to operate between the rows.”
Gar’s unhappy with his Mantis rototiller. “This unit is a 20-lb. multi-purpose tiller, edger, aerator and dethatcher. It was advertised as being easy to start and requiring minimum maintenance - just add grease and clean the spark plug. But this machine has always been hard to start. The company sent a new plug and fuel filter but that didn’t help. I haven’t been able to use this rototiller for two years.”
Tom says his 1971 International Harvester 454 diesel tractor, which he bought used, is his “best buy”. “It’s just the right size for small jobs and is powerful and agile. Easy to use and dependable.
“My 2006 Mantis rototiller is my worst buy. It runs and looks good but has very flimsy digging tines - if I hit the least little rock or root the tines will bend. Because of this problem I’m disappointed in the machine’s overall usefulness.”
“My 2003 Mantis rototiller cuts through tough, hard soil. It always starts right up in all weather conditions. No maintenance problems.”
“My 2003 Mantis rototiller is lightweight, easy to start, and easy to handle. I use it to do a variety of jobs. It has served me well.”
“Our Mantis electric-operated rototiller is our best buy,” says Nancy. “It does everything the advertisements say it will do and has a lot of power, with 2-speed operation. My husband loves it. Now he doesn’t have to rototill my flower beds or garden any more because the Mantis is so easy to handle that it’s no problem for me to operate.”
“My 2004 Mantis rototiller is my best buy. It’s so light I can pick it up with one hand and throw it in my pickup. It weighs about the same as a Weed Eater. But when it comes time to till, this rototiller is unbelievable. It digs like crazy. I’ve hit rocks with it that were almost as big as the tiller but didn’t break anything. This is one tough machine.”
“I thought I made a mistake last year when I bought my Mantis rototiller, but it turned out to be my best buy (ph 215 355-9700; www.mantisgardentools.com). The rototiller came in a small box that weighed only about 20 lbs., and it looked like a toy compared to other tillers on the market. When I started the motor, it sounded like a big bee. However, I quickly found out this machine really tears up the ground. And the drier the ground is, the better it works. It pulverizes soil to the size of corn kernels and works great to weed the garden. I’ve also used it to cut away and terrace a 6-ft. high by 8-ft. wide hard clay bank - a job that took about two hours. One time I even used it to cut an 8-in. deep trench for burying a cable to an outbuilding, and to cut a 36-in. deep trench for a building foundation. I was able to make the trench so straight I didn’t even have to use forms below ground.
“Gibbs Oil is the best penetrating oil I’ve ever found (ph 800 555-3167; www.gibbsoil.us). It’s expensive at about $20 per can, but it takes very little oil to do the job. This oil contains no silicone, water, kerosene, acids or cheap fillers. It can be used to spray into door locks to prevent freeze-ups, to wipe a door jam to keep doors from freezing shut, and to eliminate corrosion on battery terminals. It takes about 20 minutes of soak time for a badly rusted bolt and nut, or about two days to free a stuck engine.”
“My 1994 Dodge Ram 2500 pickup pulls everything I hitch it to. It’s also fuel efficient.”
On the negative side, “My Mantis rototiller starts hard and the tines clog up too easily. However, this rototiller does have guts for its size.”
“I noticed in the Vol. 29, No. 1 issue of FARM SHOW that a reader had a problem with his Mantis rototiller. I bought one and had used it extensively for about 18 months and thought it was an incredible machine. It chews through dirt easily and quickly. I also bought the dethatcher and it works great for power raking gravel from the lawn back onto the driveway.
“However, after about 18 months it started lagging, and then it wouldn’t stay running. I took it apart several times and even cleaned the carburetor, but nothing I did would solve the problem. Eventually I got through to the company and was quickly given the correct settings for the carburetor, then was told about the spark arrestor screen in the muffler. I was told if it was plugged, the tiller wouldn’t run.
“Sure enough, I took the muffler apart again, cleaned the spark arrestor screen, and the machine has been running great since then. I think the spark arrestor is some requirement for California, so it’s a newer addition to small engines, and worth looking at for other small engine problems.”
A 1994 Dodge all-wheel-drive Grand Caravan rates as Bruce’s “best buy.” “It’ll climb a hill even if there’s 10 in. of snow on the ground.
“I like my Mantis rototiller and also my Mantis sprayer.”
“My Mantis rototiller is an excellent value. It’s relatively inexpensive and works every time. It’s got enough power to level the berm in the middle of our dirt road.”
Charles is the owner of a 2002 Mantis rototiller. “It’s small enough that I’m able to handle it easily yet it does a great job in my garden. However, it doesn’t dig up sod as well as I had hoped it would. The grass gets caught in the machine and plugs it up.”
“My MTD 46-in. riding mower equipped with an 18 1/2 hp Briggs & Stratton engine is my best buy. I use it to cut our five acres of grass. All I’ve spent on it is fuel and time.
“My Mantis rototiller is my worst buy. It just isn’t the machine it’s advertised to be. I plan to return it to the manufacturer.”
“My best buy is my Sears Craftsman 18-volt circular saw, drill, and flashlight set. It has more than enough power - the batteries on it stay charged longer than any other brand I’ve used. As a result, the saw cuts tough, treated hardwood lumber with ease.
“My Mantis rototiller is a best buy. My only complaint is that the dealer I purchased it from doesn’t stock many spare parts such as special grease for the gearbox, air filters, or accessories. However, the rototiller itself works great. I’m really impressed with it.”
Jack says his 1984 Mantis rototiller rates as his “best buy”. “Over the years I’ve spent a total of only about $80 for repairs. It works great in raised garden beds. I use it to make rows and to make compost. I also use it during the winter to chop snow and ice off my sidewalk. I’m 75 years old, but both me and my Mantis are still going strong.”
“My Mantis rototiller is an excellent product. I’ve used it for 17 years. I had it tuned up about 10 years ago and again about two years ago. The tune-up cost less than $60 and now it runs as good as new.
“My Dodge Caravan has well over 200,000 miles on it. It’s powered by a 3.3 V-6 engine and has a 4-speed automatic transmission. It hasn’t required much maintenance, and it often gets 30 mpg or more on the highway. I’ve used it to haul loads weighing up to 1,800 lbs., and it still handles and performs well.”
Mantis garden tiller
6 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I bought a 20-lb. Mantis garden tiller a few years ago. At first it did a good job and started easy. But last spring it quit working, and I discovered the engine wasn’t producing a spark. This machine doesn’t have any points, just a coil next to the flywheel. I installed a new coil but it didn’t help. Then I checked the kill switch to see if I could find a short in the wire, with no luck. I got no help when I called the company. In fact, I can’t remember ever talking to someone who thought they knew so much but had so little common sense. I’ve been working on small engines all my life so I know what I’m doing.”
“My 1994 Dodge Grand Caravan LE 4-WD mini van is my best buy. It works great in snow - one time I was able to drive it up a steep hill with 10 inches of new snow on the ground. It has more than 148,000 miles on it but has required only routine maintenance.
“I like my Mantis tiller and Mantis sprayer. Both machines are more than 10 years old. They’re well-built.”
“I like my 2001 Sears Craftsman 14.4-volt drill/driver kit. It’s equipped with a light, charger, and two batteries. I’ve used it to remodel many rooms and projects, and it always works flawlessly. It has performed beyond my expectations.
“My Mantis tiller with dethatcher and sidewalk trimmer edger is also a best buy. I bought it used in 1991. This little tiller does a fantastic job in small gardens and flower beds and works great for cultivating. My neighbors use it and they keep wanting to buy it from me. However, it will never be for sale but will be handed down to our kids.
“My 2003 Sears Craftsman line trimmer powered by a 32 cc gas engine is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and vibrates bad. I wish I would have spent extra money and bought an Echo or a Stihl.”
A 2001 Honda 4-cycle rototiller rates as Robert’s “best buy”. “It always starts right up and is quiet and easy to control. I like not having to mix oil with the gas. It cost much less than the ‘worst buy’ Mantis tiller we had before.”
“One of our best buys is our 1999 Mantis tiller. We like how it works up the soil and how we can use it to till in smaller areas without pulling out nearby plants. We even used it once to ‘dig’ a trench for underground wires.”
“A 1987 Kubota B-8200 4-WD tractor rates as Gene’s “best buy”. “It’s an excellent tractor that now has more than 2,700 hours on it. I’ve only replaced a fan belt and two sets of front tires. I wouldn’t trade it for a brand new one.
“MyTroy-Bilt rear-tined tiller is my worst buy. It works good in sand or fine soil, but if there are any rocks in the soil it’s dangerous to operate. A Mantis tiller will outperform it 10 to 1 and is also safer to use.”
A 1998 Mantis tiller rates as Mary’s “best buy”. “It’s a great little tiller that’s easy to assemble out of the box and is unbelievably powerful and works fast. It took me only 35 to 45 minutes to till my entire 30 by 80-ft. garden between rows and also between some plants. It’s more versatile than bigger tillers and is also easier to carry around.”
She says her 1994 Cub Cadet 1864 riding mower is her “worst buy”. “It’s hard on gas and also starts hard. I often have to remove the air filter and hold the carburetor butterfly shut with my finger before it’ll even start.”
Mantis rototiller equipped
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My 1988 Mantis rototiller equipped with a 2-cycle engine is still going strong. Last year I decided to give the machine a rest and bought a 2013 Mantis 7624 model equipped with a 4-cycle engine. It starts easy and digs great. It’s heavier than the 2-cycle model yet is still a great bargain. I hope to get 25 years out of it, too.”
“My Mantis rototiller equipped with a Honda engine is handy to use. On rocky ground I pull it backward to keep from jamming rocks in the tines. It works great in small areas.
“My Harbor Freight 1/2-in., 18-volt cordless drill is my worst buy. The problem is the chuck won’t stay in the body of the drill. This tool was cheap so I guess you get what you pay for.”
Mantis 2-cycle rototiller
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I’m not pleased with my Mantis 2-cycle rototiller. After only 10 hours the carburetor malfunctioned, causing all the fuel to leak out through the cylinder and into the carburetor. I contacted the company and was told I’d either have to haul or ship it 150 miles to a service center at my expense, or pay for a carburetor kit and repair it myself. It’s supposed to come with a 5-year warranty, so I guess the company’s customer service says a lot about their warranty.
“I bought about $150 worth of bushes, trees and vines from Four Seasons Nursery, a catalog company that also does business as Direct Gardening, House of Wesley, Inter-State Nurseries, Royal Dutch, Honeycreek Nurseries, Farmer Seed and Nursery, Richard Owen Nursery/Exciting Gardens and Kelly Nurseries, all divisions of Plantron Inc. Counting shipping charges, I spent more than $200 with them last spring and when I received my order it was a couple of big bundles of dead, completely dried sticks. The company warranty says they’ll replace anything that isn’t alive within one year. However, when I requested replacement under warranty the company completely ignored me.”
Mantis XP rototiller equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDaniel’s the satisfied owner of a 2011 Mantis XP rototiller equipped with a Honda 35cc, 4-stroke engine. “This rototiller is reliable, easy to handle, and has a lot of power for its size. The tines turn fast, creating a good seedbed. The tiller is also lightweight so it’s easy to transport.”
Mantis rototiller clogs
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The carburetor on my Mantis rototiller clogs up on today’s gas. The dealer says a new carburetor is needed, at a cost of about $100.”
Mantis garden tiller never
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2002 Fisher 8-ft. X-blade stainless steel snowplow is an incredible plow (ph 800 678-2459; www.4qte.com). I operate a commercial snow plowing business, and this snowplow hasn’t broken so much as a bolt. It’s completely bulletproof. All I’ve done is change the oil and replace the blade’s cutting edge. Hands down, this is the toughest piece of equipment I’ve ever used.”
On the negative side, “My 2007 Dixon Kodiak ZTR riding mower had problems from the start. The first model I bought blew a crank seal after just 5 min. of use, which caused the engine to seize and ruin a customer’s yard with hot oil. The replacement model’s Briggs & Stratton engine suffered from severe electrical issues due to vibration. The electrical system never did work correctly, and as a result the machine spent more time in the shop than cutting grass. The vibration would cause the wires to disintegrate inside their covers. I don’t know how many times I had to push the mower out of a customer’s yard because it quit running. I finally traded it in.
“My Mantis garden tiller never has worked well. The carburetor is unusually susceptible to ethanol problems and has to be replaced regularly.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.