Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Goodyear

Goodyear: what farmers say

23 reports in FARM SHOW · 11 Best Buys12 Worst Buys

Goodyear automotive tires

4 Best Buys7 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gene Bontrager, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My best buy is my Grasshopper 623T lawn mower. Between my three sons and myself, we put around 150 hrs. per year on it. It’s low maintenance and I’ve had excellent dealer service. The deck lift actuator went out and was promptly replaced by the dealer under warranty.

“I haven’t been pleased with Goodyear automotive tires. I purchased a new car with a 60,000-mile warranty on tires. At around 15,000 miles all four tires were almost bald so I contacted the local dealer. He communicated with Goodyear who told him they would not warrant replacement or adjustment on tires. No more Goodyear tires on anything I own.”

Worst Buy
Josh Beadles, Ellery, Ill. · Vol. 39, No. 5 (2015), p. 15

“The first day I used my Continental B-9500 anhydrous ammonia controller, the diaphragm blew out. I called the company’s after-hours service number and explained the problem. They shipped a new diaphragm the next morning, totally free of charge. Problem solved. This company stands behind its products. I wish all companies did.”

On the negative side, “I’ve never worn out a set of Goodyear tires because the steel belts always separate while there’s still a lot of tread left on the tires. I wouldn’t use Goodyear tires again if you gave them to me.”

Best Buy
William Norris, Dowling, Mich. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 15

William’s impressed with his 2008 Toyota Tundra 4-WD SR5 extended cab pickup equipped with a 5.7-liter engine and 6-speed automatic transmission. “This pickup has excellent fit and finish, and the automatic transmission is flawless. It pulls our 28-ft. fifth wheel RV like it’s not even there. The 5.7-liter engine is a real beast. The company issued two factory recalls that were quickly taken care of. My only complaint was with the Goodyear tires on this pickup. I replaced them with Michelins, which work great.”

Worst Buy
Stephen Beck, Earlimart, Calif. · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 15

“My 2005 4-WD Ford Ranger is my best buy. I bought it to replace a 1988 Ranger that had about 235,000 miles on it. I like the mid size of the Ranger. It has plenty of power, rides well on and off road, and is fuel efficient.

“Goodyear tractor tires are my worst buy. I’ve never worn out a Goodyear tire. They always fail long before old age sets in.”

Best Buy
John Rempel, Kleefeld, Manitoba · Vol. 29, No. 3 (2005), p. 14

“My 1955 Ferguson T0 35 tractor turned 50-years old last month. When I bought this tractor it was the only one I had at the time. For 20 years I used it to do all our fieldwork. Later on I used it as a second tractor. I still use it to move snow during the winter and to work in our yard and garden during the summer. In 1964 I put new Goodyear rear tires on it. The tires still don’t have any cracks and have two thirds of the original tread left. I had the tractor’s engine rebuilt 20 years ago, and it still runs like a clock. Whenever this tractor isn’t in use I keep it in a shed. It’s an excellent tractor, and I expect to use it for a long time yet.”

Worst Buy
William J. Dietrich, Sr., Goodfield, Ill. · Vol. 27, No. 1 (2003), p. 14

“The Goodyear tires on my earthmover are worst buy. The tires started cracking one fall only about three months after they were installed. Three years later the tires were cracked so bad I could see the cords. Our 4-WD tractor also had Goodyear radial tires on it. The front tires became severely damaged by crop stubble. Rather than rotate the front tires back and move the rear tires forward,

Worst Buy
Allen Bjergo, Corvallis, Mont. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 14

“It’s easy to maintain, has a lot of power, and gets 20 mpg on the highway which I think is pretty good,” says Allen, pleased with his 1998 Dodge Ram 2500 pickup equipped with a Cummins 24-valve diesel engine.

He says the original equipment Goodyear tires on the pickup were a “worst buy”. “Two of the tires simply blew when I went over a small rock. The company wouldn’t help at all.”

Worst Buy
Paul Johanns, Paulding, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 16

Paul says the Goodyear tires on his Oldsmobile Intrigue are his “worst buy”. “I bought the car new last February. It had less than 4,000 miles on it when one of the tires blew out. I filed a complaint with the company but they claimed it was a “road hazard” and wouldn’t do anything about it. I reminded them that the warranty is supposed to cover tires, but they still refused to help.”

Worst Buy
John Miller, Howard City, Mich. · Vol. 24, No. 5 (2000), p. 14

“In the fall of 1998 I bought a Toro leaf blower to blow down cob webs and dust in our barn. I was well pleased with it the first year, but the next year I was able to run it less than a half hour before it quit working. I took it back to the dealer who said it would probably cost more to fix it than to buy a new one, even though he never even looked at the machine. It wasn’t quite a year old and it was supposed to have a two-year warranty. I wrote to the company but they never replied.

“One of my best buys is my Case-IH 8520 in-line baler. I can’t say enough good things about it. I had a New Holland 311 model that worked fine except that it wouldn’t make two bales alike. The Case-IH model makes every bale the same regardless of field conditions.

“One of my worst buys of all time was a Generac generator. I got less than one hour of use from it even though it was in the shop for repairs three different times. I got so sick of it that I traded it for a Winco, which I like. I paid $2,300 for the Generac and got only a $900 allowance toward the Winco.

“I’m unhappy with Goodyear tires. I have a 72 hp front wheel assist tractor equipped with Goodyear tires and although we haven’t used the front wheel assist at all, the front tires have worn down to a tread thickness of only 1/4 to 1/2 inch in only 200 hours. I have another tractor equipped with Goodyear tires, but that won’t happen again.

“My Claas rotary hay rake and my Miller Pro rotary hay rake both do excellent work. However, the Miller Pro model is built much heavier. It cost a little more than the Claas, and time will tell if it lasts longer. I think hay cures faster with rotary rakes than it does with conventional wheel rakes.”

Best Buy
Forest Kline, Barry, Ill. · Vol. 24, No. 1 (2000), p. 16

Forest likes his 1998 Ford F-150 4-WD pickup with Goodyear tires. “I do a lot of driving and already have 60,000 miles on the pickup. I’m impressed with the Goodyear tires – they’re still holding up well. My other three pickups had General tires which generally weren’t good for more than about 12,000 miles.

“My 1966 Deere 4020 tractor equipped with a diesel engine is a best buy. It has a whopping 23,000 hours on it. I overhauled the engine at 7,000 hours and again at 16,000 hours. Two years ago I bought a 20-ft. Bush Hog mower to use with it. I’m well pleased with both the mower and the tractor. Even though the tractor is 34 years old, it pulls the mower very well. I mow 800 to 1,000 acres every year.”

Worst Buy
Lee Hostetler, Cottage Grove, Tenn. · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 14

“We bought our 1996 Ford F-350 pickup last spring. It already has more than 65,000 trouble-free miles on it. I’m still driving a Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a 390 cu. in. engine that I bought 23 years ago. It still runs great and isn’t all rusted out like Chevy and GM models would be by now. “My worst buys are Goodyear tractor tires. They crack and fall apart before the tread is even worn down. Maybe they hold up better in other areas that have different soil types than ours.”

Goodyear Wrangler tires

2 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Arnold Weber, Stacyville, Iowa · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 14

“I’m disappointed with the Goodyear Wrangler tires on my new Ford F-150 pickup. I was able to put only about 13,000 miles on the pickup before all the tires had to be replaced.”

Best Buy
Mike Hoy, Hedrick, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 12

Mike likes his 2004 Cub Cadet RZT 50 riding mower equipped with a 50-in. deck. “It’s a great mower and has reduced my mowing time almost by half. It always starts right up and runs great. It has a lot of power, and the deck washing system keeps grass from building up and sticking to the deck. It makes mowing a fun job.”

On the minus side, “I put a set of Goodyear Wrangler RT/S tires on my 1996 Chevy S-10 pickup. Right away, I noticed a lot of vibration at highway speeds. A mechanic tried to rebalance the tires but with no luck. I took the pickup to a different Goodyear dealer and they replaced two of the tires because they couldn’t be balanced. The mechanic said the tires were so out of balance that I was ‘driving on eggs’. I’m done with Goodyear.”

Worst Buy
Greg Dennis, Ranburne, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 4 (2004), p. 14

“My 2002 Echo line trimmer is my best buy. I’m well into my third growing season of using and abusing this jewel of a trimmer. I use it to trim grass around our house, cut weeds around our chicken houses, and for cutting weeds and light brush along fence lines and road frontages. I haven’t spent a dime on it other than routine maintenance.

“Goodyear Wrangler radial tires are my worst buys. I bought these tires for my GM pickup and had nothing but problems with them from the start, including tread separations, sidewall failure, and punctures by objects that couldn’t be found in the tire. I went through nine different tires on the pickup over a 20,000-mile period. Finally I decided to replace them with another brand.”

Worst Buy
Neal Niebruegge, Nebraska City, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 16

“My 1998 Kent Discovator does a good job of leveling the soil, has a lot of trash clearance, and is easy to adjust.

On the “worst buy” side, he lists the Goodyear Wrangler tires on his pickup. “All four tires separated down the center. Friends of mine had these tires on their trucks and work vans and had the same problem. The company didn’t provide much help.

“I purchased retread tires from High-Tec Retreading in Edgemont, S. Dak They’ve held up well and, at $49.99 per tire, are a real value.”

Best Buy
Brian Molnar, Kennedy, Sask. · Vol. 22, No. 6 (1998), p. 15

“It’s a beautiful-looking, eye-catching truck and I haven’t lost a drag race with it yet,” says Brian, proud owner of a 1998 Dodge 1500 SLT 4-WD pickup equipped with 5.9-liter engine, extended cab and short box. “It has lots of power, comfortable seats and lots of room in the cab. It gives reasonable gas mileage. I’ve put more than 3,000 miles on it, no problems.”

However, Brian’s less than satisfied with the Goodyear Wrangler AT/S 265-75/16 tires on his pickup. “They’re an all-around good tire but are terrible in water. They have a tendency to hydroplane and I’ve almost hit the ditch twice while hitting a puddle on pavement. I’m going to switch to the Aqua version of these tires.”

Best Buy
Richard MacDonald, North Manches-ter, Ind. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 15

Richard installed a 4-step SureGrip non-slip step made by K&M Mfg. on his International 1486 tractor. “Along with the hand rail they’re adjustable for your step height. Makes it much easier and safer to get in and out of the cab. I also installed a new Case-IH air ride seat, which is very comfortable and adjustable and makes the tractor ride much smoother. I fitted it with Goodyear DynaTorque radial tires. They’re excellent.”

Worst Buy
Thor Jordan, Burwell, Neb. · Vol. 21, No. 5 (1997), p. 17

Thor’s “worst buys” are the Goodyear Dyna Torque radial rear tires on his tractor. “The problem is that there are rubber ridges inside the tire which tend to chew holes in the radial inner tubes. I had four tires go flat in less than 1,500 hours. I suggest using Firestone tires because they don’t have these ridges.”

Goodyear 24-volt cordless impact wrenches

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Steve Nichols, Galesburg, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My most useful tools are my Hitachi 12-volt and Goodyear 24-volt cordless impact wrenches. They work great for removing lawn mower blades and reinstalling them after sharpening. Many tire dealers use them to buzz lug nuts off and on. It makes changing a tire or rotating tires an easy job. I use them for countless other jobs. I don’t think I’ll ever be without a cordless drill again.”

Goodyear Conquest TSI

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Lawrence Bannerman, Holly, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

Lawrence is disappointed with his 2008 Hesston 1120 haybine. “When the haybine was delivered it wasn’t completely put together and the dealer wouldn’t do anything about it. I used the machine to cut about five acres of hay and it shook so bad the knife broke. The dealer took it back and said he fixed it, but the next year it didn’t work any better. I took the haybine back to the dealer for repair and when I went to pick it up the dealer said the warranty had expired and I had to pay $500 to get the machine back. Since then I’ve cut only about 50 acres with it and have spent $1,000 on repairs.

“My 1979 New Holland 489 haybine was able to cut about 5,000 acres of hay before it broke down and I had to spend $900 on a new gearbox. But since I bought the Hesston model I’ve cut 600 acres of hay with the old New Holland model and only about 50 acres with the Hesston.” Goodyear Conquest TSI series tires on it. After only about 29,000 miles we’ve already had to replace three of the tires. The tires start separating in the center of the tread, and then the steel belting starts to protrude. We’ve gone to two local Goodyear dealers with no satisfaction. No more Goodyear products for us.”

Goodyear Dynatorque II tires

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Douglas McLennan, Maxville, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 16

“My 1994 Deere 920 mower conditioner is well built. I’m impressed with the impeller conditioning system. I use a Deere 2350 50 hp tractor to pull it.

“I also like my Deere GT42 garden tractor. The 14 hp engine handles a 48-in. mower with ease.”

“I find Goodyear Dynatorque II tires to be very rough riding on the road at certain speeds. I replaced them with Armstrong tires which I like much better.”

Goodyear Tiger Paw Uniroyal tires

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Greg Butler, Croton, Ontario · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 14

“It’s equipped with a Vortec 305 cu. in. engine that has a lot of power and is easy on fuel,” says Greg about his 1997 GM extended cab 1/2-ton 2-WD pickup. “It has needed only regular maintenance. The cab is nicely laid out. The back seat can be a little tight for bigger people but is still handy. If this pickup keeps on performing like it has, my next pickup will definitely be another GM.”

On the negative side, “The pickup came factory-equipped with Goodyear Tiger Paw Uniroyal tires which were awful. I hated them from the start and replaced them at 20,000 miles. They had no ‘bite’ at all and would squeal whenever I turned, even if I turned slowly.”

Goodyear implement

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Howard Braun, Saline, Mich. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 15

Howard owns a 1997 New Holland TR 87 combine. “I had some problems with it the first year while harvesting wheat. The dealer changed the concaves, which solved the problem. Now it works fine.

“We’ve had problems with Goodyear implement and front tractor tires. When the tires are about half worn they open up where they’ve been spliced together.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW