Cummins: what farmers say
9 reports in FARM SHOW · 5 Best Buys4 Worst Buys
Cummins diesel engines
4 Best Buys2 Worst Buys“I’ve used Schaeffer’s Moly Bond X200 15W-40 engine oil since 1987 in all my diesel pickups (www.schaefferoil.com; ph 800 325-9962). This premium quality, multi-grade, heavy-duty engine oil is specially formulated to extend engine life. I own five different 1995-1996 Dodge 1-ton diesel pickups and I change the oil on all of them only about every 10,000 miles. The pickups have from 100,000 to 350,000 miles on them, but I’ve never had to drop an oil pan or pull a fuel injection pump. Moly Bond oil and the 12-valve Cummins diesel engines that power these pickups are both best buys.”
“Over the years I’ve owned several Cummins diesel engines including two 5.9L’s, a 6.7L, an 88 NT, and an 8.3L. These engines are dependable, start in cold weather, and have plenty of power and torque. I have them in my Dodge 2500 pickups, a Ford 9000 tandem axle flatbed truck, and Kenworth 300 tandem axle trucks. The engines’ inline design makes them easy to service, and they’re reasonably fuel efficient. The 88NT and 8.3L have almost 1 million miles on them but are still going strong.
“I use my 2013 Branson 3720 forklift in our apple orchards. This forklift offers a low cost alternative to rough terrain forklifts that sell for $60,000 to $70,000, but its design and engineering leave a lot to be desired. The 3-speed transmission doesn’t have enough gears and should be upgraded to a 4-speed. The forklift had some hydraulic leaks that I finally solved. Shortly after I got it, a steering arm casting broke and the steering arm had to be replaced. Another problem is the transmission creeps unless I use the brakes or tap the shuttle, which is a safety hazard.
“On the plus side, the forklift’s diesel engine runs good and starts easy in cold weather. The machine has a short turning radius, and its 2,500-lb. mast can handle a tank of cherries or 2 bins of apples with no problems. However, dealers don’t seem to stock a lot of parts and as a result I’ve had to wait several days for parts.”
“My best buy ever was my 1981 Bobcat skid steer loader. I used it to load silage every day of the year and also to load all the manure from our farm. In 1998 I traded it in for a new Bobcat 773. No problems with either machine.
“The Cummins irrigation engine that I bought new in 2000 is my worst buy. It was hard to start, due to a bad starter. Then the push button starter switch kept falling off due to vibration. The exhaust pipe also vibrated off.”
“We installed a 5.9-liter Cummins diesel engine in our 1992 Ford F-250 4-WD Supercab pickup and it really worked out great. This repower job was such a success that we put the same engine in a 1988 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup. Both vehicles have performed great since the conversions, both in fuel economy and power.”
“My worst buy is the 1997 Cummins diesel engine in our Gleaner R52 combine. It has 180 hours on it. The problem is that it leaks oil -I scooped several shovels full of greasy dirt out of the engine compartment. The dirt even gets into the combine’s cleaning shoe. There’s a puddle of oil at the blowby pipe, too. I don’t know how this problem will be resolved. It’s still under warranty.”
“It’s the best pickup I’ve ever owned,” says Ronald about his 1989 Dodge 250 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and 5-speed manual transmission. “I put 20,000 to 25,000 miles on it every year, but it still has the same power and fuel economy that it had when it was new and doesn’t use even a quart of oil between changes. I usually change oil every 4,000 to 5,000 miles. I use it to haul livestock, hay, equipment, etc. It rides a little rough but I expected that with a heavy duty pickup. I do wish that it had an extended cab. When I decide to trade it in I’ll probably buy another Dodge.”
Cummins 5.9-liter turbocharged diesel engine
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I installed a Cummins 5.9-liter turbocharged diesel engine in my Oliver 1755 tractor after the original engine blew up. It starts easy in cold weather and has lugging power that a lot of diesel engines don’t have. I’m well pleased with the performance of both the tractor and the engine.”
Cummins 6827 electric impact wrench
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I bought a 1993 Chevrolet S-10 Blazer 2 years ago with about 105,000 miles on it. I’ve since put on another 60,000 miles with only routine maintenance. I’ve replaced the batteries and unplugged the EGR valve a couple of times. It has a 2-battery system with an inverter.
“My Cummins 6827 electric impact wrench is my worst buy. I tried using it to remove a harmonic balancer bolt on a Toyota, but the bolt wouldn’t budge. I had to remove it by hand with a 1/2-in. breaker bar. Then I tried using it to change a tire on a Deere tractor, but it wouldn’t work on that either. It’s supposed to have 240 ft. lbs. of torque, but it’s not even close to that.”
Cummins 855 315 hp
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“We’ve owned about 25 different Massey Ferguson tractors over the past 35 years and all of them have been best buys. Perkins diesel engines have great lugging ability, start well in cold weather, and are easy on fuel. The transmissions have generally performed well. Best of all, Massey tractors cost 10 to 40 percent less than comparable size Deere or Case-IH models and are every bit as good or better.
“My newest model is a 6180 which is equipped with a creeper gear transmission and front 3-pt. hitch and pto. I bought it to operate my pto-driven Meri Crusher which I use to clear land and grind up tree stumps and brush. I was told that using the Meri Crusher would be a challenge for my tractor’s pto driveline. Apparently a lot of tractors can’t handle the Meri Crusher but after running the crusher for more than 100 hours with my 6180, I’ve had no problems. The tractor is a pleasure to drive and the Dynashift transmission is fantastic. Best of all, this tractor costs about $25,000 less than a comparable Deere without the factory-mounted front 3-pt. hitch.”
On the “worst buy” side, Chris lists the Cummins 855, 315 hp, 6-cyl. diesel engine that powers his 1989 Ford tandem axle feed truck. “At about 60,000 miles the piston head came off the number 5 cylinder and completely ruined the engine. The 3-year warranty had expired but the dealer told us that Cummins would ‘treat us right’. However, the company paid for only about $1,500 of parts and we had to pay the balance - more than $9,000 (Canadian). Other truck fleet owners we talked to said we should complain. We finally talked to the top representative of Cummins in Canada but he didn’t want to hear about it. We own 20 different diesel-powered machines and have never had an engine failure like this, but then we had never owned a Cummins diesel before either.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.