Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Maytag

Maytag: what farmers say

27 reports in FARM SHOW · 11 Best Buys16 Worst Buys

Best Buy
Richard N. Burgett, Milton, Fla. · Vol. 46, No. 3 (2022), p. 13

“My 2022 Maytag commercial-grade washing machine handles big loads of laundry very well and has a 10-year extended warranty.”

Richard hasn’t been as pleased with other washing machines. “About three years ago I purchased a Samsung washer that had a 3-year warranty and that’s how long it lasted. Before that, I bought a Whirlpool washer and it lasted about five years until the warranty ran out. It suddenly flooded my house. When I took it apart to troubleshoot it, I found the outer tub had a hole in it. The drive coupler on the inner tub had deteriorated to pieces and had knocked a hole in the outer tub. Both components were unavailable, but they still made the machine. Go figure.”

Worst Buy
Joan Wilson, W. Va. · Vol. 45, No. 2 (2021), p. 15

“My 2011 Poulan 18-in. chainsaw has seen moderate to heavy use but is still going strong.

“Far and away my worst buy is my Maytag washing machine. It broke down after just two years of moderate use by our 2-person family.”

Best Buy
Jerry Couet, Dayton, Minn. · Vol. 45, No. 1 (2021), p. 15

Jerry likes his Kubota B3200 32 hp. diesel loader tractor. “It always starts right up, is fuel efficient, runs quiet, and has a 3-speed differential. However, my brother-in-laws say it’s the wrong color.

“My Maytag clothes washing machine doesn’t get my clothes clean. They don’t even get wet.”

Best Buy
Bob Hornbrook, Evansville, Ind. · Vol. 44, No. 4 (2020), p. 15

“I bought a Maytag washing machine in 1979 for $399 and still use it to wash my dirty yard clothes. I’ve had to replace only the mixing valve and timer.”

Best Buy
Daniel Bjorkman, Pembine, Wis. · Vol. 43, No. 6 (2019), p. 15

“I like my Timberline chainsaw chain sharpener (www.timberlinesharpener.com; 208 405-2020). It mounts right on the bar so I don’t even have to remove the chain. It cuts every tooth the same and does a really nice job.”

He has a problem with the 2017 Maytag washing machine he bought at Home Depot. “During the spin cycle the clothes get twisted up so you can’t get the moisture out.”

Worst Buy
UnaRose Davison, Auburn, Neb. · Vol. 40, No. 1 (2016), p. 15

“My worst buy is my Maytag washing machine, which has no center dasher. It twists and wads clothes up so that the water can’t do a good job of cleaning. My husband’s jeans are still dirty when I take them out, and once they even had mud left around the cuff even after I had used the heavy duty power wash settings. Also, I don’t like the ‘HE’ detergent we’re supposed to use with this washer.”

Best Buy
Tracy Kell, Paulina, La. · Vol. 39, No. 6 (2015), p. 14

“My Maytag washing machine was less than a year old when the timer on it went bad and had to be replaced. I don’t like the machine’s automatic water fill feature, because if you need to add a piece of clothing the machine automatically adds more water.”

Worst Buy
Robert Zurfluh, Monticello, Wis. · Vol. 39, No. 3 (2015), p. 13

“More than 20 years ago my dad bought a small Makita angle grinder, and we still use it regularly.

“I like my Schnee’s winter pack boots (www.schnees.com; ph 800 922-1562). I have one pair that’s more than 10 years old. I wear another pair from November through March for working with cattle, logging, hunting and snowmobiling. These boots are warm, dry and long lasting.

“Our 2000 Honda Rancher 350 2-WD 4-wheeler is on its third set of tires. I abuse the heck out of this machine but it keeps right on going. No problems.

“My wife loves her 2011 Speed Queen washing machine (www.speedqueen.com). It has all metal parts and gears instead of the plastic parts found on many other brands, and it’s comparably priced and has a better warranty. Our farm clothes are very hard on washing machines, but we’re happy with this one.

“In 1996 we bought our first new Maytag washing machine. The main bearings on it failed about the same day the warranty expired. A technician fixed the machine, but it broke down again within a year.”

“At one time my uncle used his 1962 Deere 4010 tractor to do all the work on his farm, doing big jobs such as plowing and harvesting. We bought the tractor used from him in 1997 and use it every day on our farm to do smaller jobs such as disking, planting, mulching, raking hay, pulling hay and silage wagons, and operating a round bale processor. The engine was overhauled long ago and the tractor now has about 16,000 hrs. on it. I’ve made a few minor repairs on it and painted it in 2012.”

Worst Buy
Doug McAlexander, Cedar Grove, Tenn. · Vol. 29, No. 3 (2005), p. 14

Doug nominates his 1993 Mack CH 613 tri-axle dump truck as his “best buy.” “I bought this truck used in 1996 with about 300,000 miles on it. Now it has about 750,000 miles. I use it to haul GVW loads weighing up to 74,000 lbs. It’s powered by an E7 300 hp Mack engine, which is the most dependable engine I’ve ever owned. The engine valve cover has never been off. I removed the oil pan at about 700,000 miles and also replaced the crankshaft bearings for preventative maintenance.

“I’m not happy with my 2003 Maytag washing machine, which is a quiet series, heavy-duty model. Whenever this washer goes into the spin cycle it’s almost impossible to keep it balanced, so I have to stay right with it. When it gets out of balance, it makes loud metal-to-metal banging sounds and also slides around on the floor. I can move the clothes around, but it doesn’t take long before it gets out of balance again. I bought it at Lowes, and they said I should contact Maytag. But all Maytag wants to do is sell me an extended warranty. I was happier with the old Maytag that this one replaced.

“About two years ago I ordered a tire bead breaker from Northern Tool and Equip-ment Co. and it’s a worst buy. I’ve never been able to break a bead down with it. The tool simply slides off the rim instead of pushing the bead down. It was built in China and is made of steel that’s too soft. It cost $19.99, but it’s not worth anything to me.”

Maytag washer

2 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Steven Stodden, Marcus, Iowa · Vol. 50, No. 2 (2026), p. 13

“I have several Milwaukee battery-powered tools, including a drill, an impact driver, a trimmer and a chainsaw. They’ve all worked well, though I’ve had a couple of batteries go bad.”

Steven’s worst buys are a Maytag washer and dryer purchased at Lowe’s. “They both failed within a year. Within a month, the washer broke. I had it repaired three times in the first year. The next time it failed, along with the dryer, was after the warranty had expired. They both ended up in the iron pile. I’ll never buy anything that says ‘Maytag’ again.”

Best Buy
Buddy Klumpp, Ponca City, Okla. · Vol. 47, No. 2 (2023), p. 14

“I bought a Maytag washer and dryer set 2 years ago. They worked great for 2 years but now they won’t start half the time. I know other people that have them and they work great. I guess I got a lemon.”

Best Buy
Charles Diller, Dillsburg, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 4 (2010), p. 14

“My Stihl MS192 chainsaw is lightweight, which makes it great for cutting small diameter wood. It starts right up every time with very little effort.

“My Maytag clothes washer is a top load model with agitating gears made of plastic. It had to be serviced within 2 years of purchase and now it needs service again. The last 2 washers we had before this one each lasted 20 years. The company won’t help pay for repairs.”

Worst Buy
Charles Diller, Dillsburg, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 2 (2010), p. 14

Charles likes his Stihl MS 192 chainsaw equipped with a 14-in. bar. “This saw cuts great and starts easy, and it weighs only 8 lbs. so it doesn’t tire me out. I use it only to cut small diameter wood.

“My Maytag top load washer is my worst buy. I used it less than two years before I had to have a service man replace the plastic agitator gear. Now 8 months later the agitator gear is going out again. The problem is poor engineering.”

Maytag Neptune washer

1 Best Buy2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Norm Zimmerman, Goodville, Penn. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 12

“We bought our 1998 Chevrolet 2500 pickup with about 129,000 miles on it and did a lot of heavy towing with it. At about 190,000 miles the transmission was rebuilt. The pickup has about 210,000 miles on it now, but the body still doesn’t show any rust. We have three Chevy pickups and like all of them.

“Our 2006 Maytag Neptune washer is our worst buy. We bought it new thinking it was a top-of-the-line washer. However, after just four years the main drum bearings were shot and the dealer told us it would cost $600 to repair. Instead, we contacted the company and bought a drum for $250 and installed it ourselves.”

Worst Buy
Robert Szabo, Westland, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 13

“I bought my Toro 20-in. Snow Master snow-blower 10 years ago for $20 from a lady who was moving to Florida, and it has been trouble-free and has saved my back and heart.

“I like my Toro 21-in., 3-blade mower. The grass catcher is easy to take off and empty, and I can fill the crankcase with Slick 50 oil straight from the bottle. I use this mower every spring, summer and fall. It doesn’t burn any oil and always starts on the second pull. It still has the original spark plug.”

On the negative side, “We bought a Maytag Neptune automatic front load washing machine in 1999 for $1,096. It’s a complete piece of junk. The control boards shorted out, and the tub bearing burned out after six years so I’m scrapping it. It does have a good motor and good control boards. I’m willing to sell parts from it.”

Best Buy
Salon Sheldon, Blissfield, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 15

“Our Maytag Neptune front load washer is easy on clothes and uses only about half as much water as a top load Maytag washer. But we’ve spent more on repairs and parts than for any other washer we’ve owned. We paid $1,100 for the washer and have spent another $127.95 for labor and $202.48 for parts.”

Maytag dishwasher

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Catherine Dibenedetto, Oscar, La. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“Our 2004 Maytag dishwasher is our worst buy. The water failed to drain out of it and then leaked out and ruined our pine floors. The company replaced the pump but then the hose broke. They replaced the hose, but now the door won’t close properly.”

Worst Buy
M.L. Lindsay, West Monroe, La. · Vol. 27, No. 5 (2003), p. 12

“My new Maytag dishwasher is my worst buy. It doesn’t do a good job cleaning dishes and doesn’t heat the water or sanitize as claimed, and any debris that happens to be left on the dishes is distributed throughout the dishwasher and ends up glued to the dishes. If you don’t load the bottom shelf before the middle shelf, the middle shelf will sag down into the bottom shelf and as a result you can’t pull it out. Another problem is that the dishes come out wet. If a few granules of detergent fall outside the cup and onto the door latch, the latch won’t fasten. The granules have to be brushed away in order for the latch to work.”

Maytag stove

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
K. Harold Martin, McCook, Neb. · Vol. 32, No. 4 (2008), p. 14

“I’m impressed with my 1998 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and 5-speed transmission. It gets more than 30 mpg on the highway and about 27 mpg with general driving. This pickup has more than 148,000 miles on it but still runs great and has been trouble-free. It has plenty of power and is a far better pickup than the Ford Rangers I’ve owned in the past. Also, it has a comfortable seat.”

On the minus side, he lists his Maytag stove and refrigerator. “This company used to be known for its high quality products, but in my opinion that quality isn’t there any more. The refrigerator freezes our produce, yet where I keep milk on the top shelf it’s 40 degrees. I have to turn up the freezer thermostat all the way in order to keep ice cream hard. The refrigerator has required many service calls.”

Worst Buy
Bob Andrews, Haines, Alaska · Vol. 28, No. 1 (2004), p. 15

A 2001 Kubota 2710 tractor equipped with a frontend loader rates as Bob’s “best buy”. “It’s a high quality, well designed tractor. I use it with a mower, bucket, and snowblower. I haven’t had the slightest hint of a problem with it. It’s easy to use and comfortable to drive, and has amazing power for its size.

“My Maytag kitchen stove is my worst buy. It’s a top-of-the-line model that cost more than $1,000. Right from the start, problems developed with the computer controls, and the door fell off several times due to a poor hinge design. All the computer controls depend on the door working, and it didn’t work. I couldn’t get any repairs made under warranty since I live out in the country. It’s a real piece of junk.”

Maytag Centennial washing machine put

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Georgeann Engle, Columbus, N.J. · Vol. 42, No. 3 (2018), p. 14

“I like my Speed Queen commercial top load washing machine. It fills quickly, does a good job of cleaning clothes, and finishes the cycle quickly.

“My Maytag Centennial washing machine put dirt right back on the clothes and took a long time to fill and finish the cycle. Also, once the machine was going we couldn’t refill it.”

Maytag MTW 5600 TQ washing machine

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Curt McGhee, Mt. Olive, Ill. · Vol. 31, No. 5 (2007), p. 14

“Our Maytag MTW 5600 TQ washing machine is so loud that I can’t even hear the TV when it’s on. The machine always makes clunking and thudding noises, but the dealer says they all do that. The company refuses to help. This will be my last Maytag product.”

Maytag MVW6200KW2 top-loading washing machine

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Steve Pottorff, Fancy Gap, Va. · Vol. 50, No. 4 (2026), p. 14

“The worst product purchase I’ve made in the past several years was a Maytag top-loading washing machine (model MVW6200KW2). I bought it at the local Lowe’s.

“My parents bought their first Maytag in 1968. It lasted a very long time. I decided Maytag was the best brand and bought Maytag machines as well. My first washer lasted 24 years, and the second 16 years. I figured Maytags were built to last, so I bought a third washer.

“Boy, was I wrong. The third one was very cheaply made and lasted only 2 years before it failed. My wife and I are the only ones in the household. Even after spending several hundred dollars to repair the machine, it still didn’t work correctly or reliably.

“I finally scrapped the Maytag and bought a Speed Queen washer. It works flawlessly. When it came time for a new dryer, we purchased a Speed Queen.

“I contacted both Lowe’s and Whirlpool Corporation (the parent company of Maytag) about the issues with the machine. Neither company was helpful or sympathetic. I don’t plan to buy any more Maytag or Whirlpool appliances.”

Maytag MVW7232HW washer and dryer

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Tom Borer, Clearwater, Neb. · Vol. 50, No. 1 (2026), p. 14

“I’m glad I bought an adapter that lets a Milwaukee battery power a Peg Perego ride-on tractor. It cost about $10 on Amazon. Just slide in an M18 battery, and away they go. The grandkids can ride their toy tractor longer, and it performs better.

“We bought a Maytag washer (MVW7232HW) and dryer (MED7230HW) in May 2021. We’ve had nothing but problems since the warranty expired. After less than four years, I threw both into the iron pile. There’s just the two of us, so they got very little use.”

Maytag Performa automatic dishwasher

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Mike Appec, Pipestone, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 3 (2005), p. 13

“ O u r Maytag Performa automatic dishwasher is our worst buy. The main pump water seal has been replaced twice, and the door seal started leaking right after we bought it. This machine seems to make more noise as it gets older. Also, we have to pre-rinse our plates and pans so it will clean them.”

Maytag refrigerator equipped

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Allen Condon, Chesapeake, Va. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 12

“It has more than 247,000 miles on it but is still going strong,” reports Allen about his 1994 Dodge 2500 diesel pickup. “The transmission was overhauled at about 150,000 miles. I use it to haul my antique tractors to shows.

“My Maytag refrigerator equipped with a bottom freezer is my worst buy. I bought it at Lowes. The first unit lasted only three days and was replaced. The second unit had forklift marks on top from the factory and lasted only 13 months. The company sent us a new compressor, but we had to pay for the $150 labor charge to install it.”

Maytag washing machine stopped

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Joan Wilson, Buffalo, N.Y. · Vol. 46, No. 3 (2022), p. 14

“Two years ago I bought a 2013 used Dodge Grand Caravan with 100,000 miles on it. Today it has 200,000 miles on it with only oil changes made every 3,000 miles. Best van I ever owned. This is probably why Dodge stopped producing them - they last too long.

“My Maytag washing machine stopped working after two years. The manufacturer says the warranty has expired and I should call a Maytag repairman. The repairman charges more to come out to my place and repair it than a new washing machine costs. I will never buy another Maytag product again.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW