Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › MacDon

MacDon: what farmers say

14 reports in FARM SHOW · 12 Best Buys2 Worst Buys

MacDon 7000 swather

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Heide, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 23, No. 3 (1999), p. 16

“After 19 years, our Morton buildings still look like new. Also, our 1991 MacDon 7000 swather cuts and works well in our tough Montana wild hay, but the paint and decals are in terrible shape. Our Deere 468 baler is an excellent baler that makes good bales and never misses tying.”

On the other hand, he doesn’t like his Sears Craftsman power washer. “If we’d known there is no way to drain it, we wouldn’t have bought it. They say you have to store it in a warm place to prevent damage form freezing.”

Best Buy
Walter Schweitzer, Ledger, Mont. · Vol. 20, No. 4 (1996), p. 16

Walter’s impressed with his 1993 MacDon 7000 swather. “The company was eager to introduce it to our area so they offered us a good price. We’ve used it every year to cut 2,000 acres of heavy, irrigated hay without any problems besides normal wear and tear. It conditions hay quicker than other swathers that we’ve seen. “My 1990 Ford F-150 XLT Lariat pickup is my worst buy. The clutch slave cylinder wore out and unfortunately it wasn’t covered by the warranty. The rear anti-lock brakes were constantly in for repairs, and the alternator failed and cost $700 to replace. All of these problems happened within the first 30,000 miles. We were happy when our hired man totaled this lemon out so that we could buy a Chevrolet.”

MacDon 9300 swather

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Tommy Carey, Boulder, Mont. · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 14

“My 1997 MacDon 9300 swather has plenty of power. I like the big tires front and back which allows it to ride smooth even over center pivot irrigation tracks. It has a comfortable air ride seat and a quiet cab.

“My Water Ace submersible water pump is my worst buy. I used it in a sump for pumping livestock water. One day the pump burned out. The dealer gave me another pump but it failed, too. Each time all the oil in the pump leaked out which made a big mess in the water. I switched back to a better known brand and haven’t had any more problems.”

Worst Buy
Stefan Bjornson, Riverton, Manitoba · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 14

“Last fall I purchased a MacDon 9300 swather equipped with a model 972 25-ft. header. It’s my worst buy. After only four hours it already had four broken guards and six broken sickle sections. At 10 hours I noticed that the drive belt on the wobble box was severely cracked. I complained to the dealer and he said the cracks didn’t matter. Wrong. I had to pay for a new belt. At 11 hours the pickup reel fell apart. I called the dealer and asked him to send someone out to fix it, but I ended up having to fix it myself. At 25 hours I noticed there were holes in the canvasses caused by small stones that were getting inside it. At 49 hours the fuel cap broke and fell off, and part of it went into the tank. After I had broken 16 guards and countless sickle sections, the company finally did replace the knife, but none of the guards. By the time the swather had 150 hours on it I had gone through 43 guards and 75 sickle sections. At 300 hours I had gone through 75 guards and 125 sections. At 300 hours the muffler came loose and was repaired, but I had to pay for the parts and am still waiting for a muffler clamp. Also at 300 hours the reel drive motor broke off and nothing has been done about that yet.

“The header float system is totally hopeless. The company says you should adjust the suspension to a 40-lb. lift on the side, but it takes more than 500 lbs. to lift it 1 in. in the middle. The canvas speed and the reel can’t be adjusted on-the-go, and the low oil pressure light comes on whenever I lift the reel or header.

“I sometimes work all day with the air conditioner on. When you shut it off and turn on the heat all the windows fog up so bad that you can’t see out of them, which is a severe problem when you’re on a busy road. The company’s cure was to turn on the heat before you shut off the air conditioner, which does not work. The air cleaner on the engine has to be cleaned every day because the intake pipe is too low.”

MacDon 972 head

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Harlan Haisley, Fairmount, Ind. · Vol. 30, No. 2 (2006), p. 14

Harlan likes the MacDon 972 36-ft. head he uses on his International 2388 combine. “This header feeds so evenly that I can drive one or two miles per hour faster than I could with my old 30-ft. head.”

Best Buy
Anthony Thilmony, Valley City, N. Dak. · Vol. 26, No. 1 (2002), p. 16

Anthony nominates his MacDon 972 header as his “best buy”. “I use it to harvest small grains and soybeans and it has performed beyond my expectations. It makes harvesting crops an enjoyable experience. The only problem I had was with the float optimizer or header height control. I contacted the company and they sent three people down from Winnipeg. They spent an entire morning working on the problem until they got it fixed. I wish all equipment companies would stand behind their equipment like this one does.”

MacDon 9200 swather

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Judd Rodman, Paonia, Colo. · Vol. 31, No. 1 (2007), p. 14

Judd nominates his 2000 MacDon 9200 swather as his “best buy”. “This machine has cut about 3,000 acres of hay per year without any major problems.

“My Deere 4430 tractor is my worst buy. The engine blew up, the transmission has gone out three times, and the hydraulics don’t work right. Also, it uses four times more fuel than my International Harvester tractors do.”

MacDon 9250 swathers

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Dean L. Freeborn, Rickreall, Oregon · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

Dean’s impressed with his 2006 and 2007 MacDon 9250 swathers. “We’ve operated MacDon swathers for several years, and these 9250 models are really good machines. We’ve used them to cut several different kinds of grass seed and hay. As long as you keep the sicklebar sharp they’ll cut through the crop.

“The 2004 Case IH MXM 155 tractor I bought last year is my worst buy. It has had numerous problems with the electrical system, hydraulics, leaks, fuel pump, etc. We bought this tractor to keep from putting so many hours on our older Magnums, but unfortunately we still had to use them because the MXM 155 is down all the time.

“My Case IH 7220 and 8030 tractors work great. Too bad the company doesn’t build these models any more.”

MacDon 9350 swather heads

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bill Clark, Miniota, Manitoba · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

A 2002 MacDon 9350 swather heads his “best buy” list. “I use it with a 972 25-ft. header and a 922 16-ft. hay header. This machine is a pleasure to operate and requires little maintenance.

“I’m disappointed, however, with the 2002 30-ft. MacDon 960 draper header we mounted on our Deere 9600 combine. The problem is that in certain wheat crops it wants to backfeed under the canvas, causing damage to the canvas. We’ve tried speeding up the header and adjusting the adapters closer to the feeder, but it hasn’t helped. Next time I think I’ll try using a Deere draper header.”

MacDon 960 draper header

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bill Clark, Miniota, Manitoba · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

A 2002 MacDon 9350 swather heads his “best buy” list. “I use it with a 972 25-ft. header and a 922 16-ft. hay header. This machine is a pleasure to operate and requires little maintenance.

“I’m disappointed, however, with the 2002 30-ft. MacDon 960 draper header we mounted on our Deere 9600 combine. The problem is that in certain wheat crops it wants to backfeed under the canvas, causing damage to the canvas. We’ve tried speeding up the header and adjusting the adapters closer to the feeder, but it hasn’t helped. Next time I think I’ll try using a Deere draper header.”

MacDon R80 discbine

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Robert Schindler, Colfax, Wis. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 13

A MacDon R80 16-ft. discbine rates as Robert’s “worst buy”. “Before I bought this discbine I told the company sales rep that I farm hilly ground, and he assured me that this new machine would work on my hills just fine. Well, it doesn’t. The hydraulic drive system cavitates going up hill and as a result the machine won’t cut hay. The dealer has been out many times, along with other company reps. They’ve tried many things to solve the problem in the last 4 years, but nothing has helped. I use a 220 hp tractor to pull the machine, but even it sometimes doesn’t have enough power.

“The company has offered to buy it back at a fraction of what it’s worth. Looks like I’m going to take a big loss.”

MacDon haybine

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Doug Smitham, Victoria Harbour, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 2 (1997), p. 15

Doug’s “best buy ever” is his 1975 Case David Brown 885 tractor. “It still works well with plenty of power and a lot of traction. “My 1995 MacDon 9-ft. haybine is an excellent machine. It works as well or even better than the company advertises.”

MacDon draper head

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Delbert Bauersachs, Pinckneyville, Ill. · Vol. 40, No. 4 (2016), p. 12

“In 2012 I bought a new New Holland 35-ft. auger head for my New Holland CR7090 combine, but the new head wouldn’t float like my old head did. The dealer worked on it for two years but could never get it to work right. I called the company but got no help. I finally solved the problem by trading this auger head in for a new MacDon draper head. Now my New Holland combine will out cut any green or red machine. Our family has three New Holland combines, all equipped with MacDon heads.”

MacDon header

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Delbert Bauersachs, Pinckneyville, Ill. · Vol. 44, No. 1 (2020), p. 13

“My Case IH Magnum tractor handles so easily and has lots of power. Great tractor.

“We can cut 125 to 140 acres a day with a 35-ft. MacDon header on our New Holland CR7090 combine with virtually no grain loss out the back. A MacDon header feeds so evenly that you can do more work than you could with a 45-ft. head from another brand. And this NH combine does a beautiful job processing the crop material.

“I also have a Kuhn SL118 manure spreader that spreads manure instead of just unloading it, like many other spreaders. It tears manure into small pieces and throws it 75 to 80 ft. Very well-built.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW