Chevrolet 2500 pickup
What FARM SHOW readers say · 25 Best Buys4 Worst Buys · Trucks & Cars
Chevrolet 2500 pickup
25 Best Buys4 Worst Buys“I have several items I could nominate as best buys. These are the standouts: Echo chainsaws, weed eater, blower and pole saw; Ridgid drill and driver (both came with a lifetime warranty); Kubota L3010 tractor with loader and RTV400 ATV; and my 2004 Chevy 2500 pickup.
“My worst buy list starts with a Westinghouse 2000 inverter generator that leaked more oil than all my past vehicles combined.”
“I had a Troy-Bilt 4-cycle mini cultivator that never ran for more than 15 min. The recoil starter engaged only when it wanted to.
“Finally, I was disappointed with DeWalt 3-speed drills and their batteries, which don’t last.”
He likes his 1991 Chevrolet 2500 pickup. “Our dad bought this great pickup used in 2000. No major problems, and the manual transmission makes it a lot of fun to drive.
“We enjoy using our DeWalt and Milwaukee tools. Our Milwaukee M18 impact wrench and M12 hammer drill are best buys.”
“My 1998 Chevy 2500 diesel 4-WD pickup is my best buy. It gets 16 to 17 mpg. Is low maintenance and has few problems. I would buy it again.
On the negative side, “My worst buy is my 2011 GMC Terrain with a 2.4l engine that went bad at 80,000 miles. No help from GM.”
Kevin’s the satisfied owner of a 2015 Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison transmission. “It had only one minor problem when the DEF tank heater quit working, but the dealer promptly repaired it under warranty. This pickup consistently got more than 20 mpg and pulled heavy loads with ease. At about 143,000 miles I traded it for a 2018 model just like it.
“My 2005 Kubota 3830 4-WD tractor equipped with a Bush Hog front-end loader has been almost trouble-free. It has a lot of power and the loader works well. The battery lasted until 2018. I’ve never had a battery last that long in any other equipment.
“I like my 2006 Exmark Lazer Z 60-in. zero-turn riding mower equipped with a Kohler engine. Over the years I’ve owned 5 other zero-turn mower brands - Bush Hog, Grasshopper, Bad Boy, Hustler, and Woods - but this one outperforms all of them.
“My dad bought his 1997 GM Z71 pickup in the fall of 1996, and I got it from him the fall of 1997 when he traded for a new model. I’ve put more than 200,000 miles on this pickup, but the engine still doesn’t use any oil and the transmission has never been touched. It has gone through several electric fuel pumps and numerous sets of brakes and rotors. I’ve used it to pull very heavy loads, some more than 10,000 lbs., with no problems. I wish I could buy a new pickup just like this one.”
He’s had problems with his 2015 Retrax retractable pickup bed cover. “Gallons of water leaked into the bed. One time my portable toolbox slid forward while I was braking, and it dented the tray that the bed cover rolls up into. That made it difficult to open and close. That tray should be out of the way of shifting cargo.”
“The 2003 Chevrolet 2500 extended cab pickup I bought used several years ago has about 176,000 miles on it, but the 6-liter gas engine still doesn’t use any oil. This pickup will pull most any load we hook up behind it.”
“I bought my 2011 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup used with about 18,000 miles on it. It’s equipped with a 6.6-liter diesel engine and an Allison 6-speed automatic transmission. I use this pickup to pull a 12,000-lb. Ditch Witch trencher and to haul other heavy loads, and for lots of other jobs including snow removal. It works great and gets a respectable 16 to 18 mpg.”
“I like my 2002 Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped with a diesel engine and Allison transmission. I use it to pull my gooseneck trailer loaded with a Deere backhoe, and also to haul my Deere tractor and 8-ft. mower. This pickup gets 14 to 16 mpg around town and 20 to 21 mpg empty on the freeway. It has more than 171,000 miles on it with no big problems.
“I also like my 2007 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup equipped with a diesel engine and Allison transmission. It pulls another gooseneck trailer loaded with my Deere compact track loader. No problems.”
Dave’s the owner of a 2002 Chevrolet 2500 heavy-duty 4-WD, extended cab longbed pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter engine and automatic transmission. “This pickup has been trouble-free and gets 17 mpg pulling a load.
“We bought several cases of TKO cleaner, but it didn’t work at all like the salesman’s demonstrations. The company didn’t return our phone calls.”
“My 2008 Chevrolet 2500 pickup is my worst buy. It had to be jump-started 10 times and the battery was replaced twice. Then the company decided to install a dual battery system at no charge. Hopefully this will make the vehicle work as well as my 2001 Chevy.”
“We bought our 1998 Chevrolet 2500 pickup with about 129,000 miles on it and did a lot of heavy towing with it. At about 190,000 miles the transmission was rebuilt. The pickup has about 210,000 miles on it now, but the body still doesn’t show any rust. We have three Chevy pickups and like all of them.
“Our 2006 Maytag Neptune washer is our worst buy. We bought it new thinking it was a top-of-the-line washer. However, after just four years the main drum bearings were shot and the dealer told us it would cost $600 to repair. Instead, we contacted the company and bought a drum for $250 and installed it ourselves.”
“I like my 2003 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty Duramax diesel pickup equipped with a 5-speed Allison transmission. I bought it used from someone who had bought it to pull a 28-ft. fifth wheel livestock trailer. He had all the minor repairs and maintenance done at a local dealer and had taken good care of the vehicle. I’ve put about 25,000 miles on it with no problems. It starts without having to be plugged in at temperatures down to 13 below zero, and it pulls a heavy load.
“My DeWalt 18-volt cordless drill is my worst buy. The drill itself works okay but I don’t like the keyless chuck. One week after I bought the drill the chuck stripped, making it almost impossible to tighten or remove any bits. The company said it was my fault for over-tightening the chuck and wouldn’t stand behind the product. I think this drill should have more steel parts and fewer plastic parts.”
Myron nominates his 2003 Chevrolet 2500 series pickup equipped with a Duramax engine as his “best buy”. “This trouble-free truck rides and drives like a Cadillac. I’m well pleased with it.”
Gary nominates his 2005 Dodge 3500 diesel pickup as his “best buy”. “It has great power and is reasonably fuel efficient. No problems.
“My 2002 Chevrolet 2500 pickup is my worst buy. I was always a Chevrolet fan until the purchase of this piston-slapping, rusting-rotor pickup. The company’s customer service and the Better Business Bureau were equally disappointing.”
Len likes his Canon mp830 printer/fax but says there’s one problem. “The machine works great and is easy to use, but the high cost of replacement ink will keep you broke.”
He says his 2001 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty pickup is “the worst lemon imaginable. It had a lot of things go wrong that were turned in under warranty, but GM just ignored them until the mileage exceeded the warranty limit, then claimed the pickup was out of warranty. I finally got a company rep to admit the rings were bad from the factory, which is why it burns a quart of oil every 500 miles. I brought it in at 8,000 miles for this problem.
“Another problem is the front axle won’t hold oil. It leaks out of a seam. The factory’s solution was to smear some silicone sealer on the bottom outside of the gearcase. The heater core must be leaking, since it smells like anti-freeze in the cab and I’ve spent hundreds of dollars on the air conditioner. The pickup sometimes quits when I’m just driving slowly and then I can’t get it started again. The fuel gauge works only intermittently.
“I’ve babied this pickup ever since it was new, but it’s just a total lemon. I’ve been a lifelong GM fan, but not any more. From now on it’s Japanese only for me, as soon as Toyota makes a 9500 GVW truck.”
“It has awesome power and will outpull any truck I’ve ever owned,” says Brian, pleased with his 2004 Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped with a Duramax engine and Allison transmission. “No problems at all.”
“My 2004 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison transmission is my best buy. It’s fuel efficient, has a great ride with all the creature comforts, and has plenty of power.”
“It’s the nicest pickup I’ve ever owned,” says Scott about his 2004 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty crew cab 4-WD equipped with a Duramax diesel engine. “It has plenty of room for my wife and two small children with car seats. The engine runs quiet and the Allison transmission is ultra smooth. It gets 15 to 16 mpg in the city. I haven’t had an opportunity to drive it on the road yet, but I’m looking forward to it.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2002 Dodge Ram 1500 crew cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5.9-liter, V-8 engine. “Three weeks after I bought it, the top radiator hose began to leak. I also had to have the sliding rear window replaced twice within the first year because it leaked, and the rear carpet had to be replaced as well. The transmission oil cooler began to leak and had to be replaced. The air conditioning went out twice, and the second time the compressor had to be replaced. Then, just before I traded the pickup in for my new Chevy, the blower motor began to make a grinding noise. The fuel economy around town was a horrible 9 to 10 mpg, and sometimes even worse. I kept the pickup for two years and put only about 25,000 miles on it. This pickup was never mistreated. I wish it could say the same about me.”
Carlton says his 2001 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty pickup equipped with an 8100 engine and a 5-speed Allison automatic transmission works great and is his “best buy”. “The engine-transmission combination on this pickup is the best I’ve ever seen. I use the pickup to haul my 21-ft. gooseneck trailer loaded with two tractors, and it has power to spare.
“My Ford F-150 pickup was one of my worst buys ever . When I left the dealer’s lot, I only got one mile down the road before the service light came on. Later, rain water poured in on the passenger side of the floor. The first winter the pickup wouldn’t start at temperatures of 20 to 25 degrees above zero. The dealer checked it out but couldn’t find any problems. When the pickup had 40,000 miles on it I traded it in for a Chevrolet with 98,000 miles, paying $500 to boot. It was the best move I ever made.”
“It starts and runs well, is easy to service, and has a comfortable ride,” reports Donald, pleased with his 2002 Chevrolet 2500 pickup. “I had a 1989 model that I sold before purchasing this one. It had more than 200,000 miles on it. I used nothing but ethanol in it. I also use nothing but ethanol in my 2002 model. It gets about 17 mpg and has had no problems. I like the location of the instruments.”
“I like my 2000 Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped with a 300 hp engine. I use it to pull a 24-ft. livestock trailer, which it handles very well. This pickup has a lot of power and is reasonably fuel efficient.”
“I purchased a 1995 Case 580 Super L backhoe with an extend-a-hoe. It has a 30-gal. tank which barely keeps me going for eight hours. My trade-in was a 580 K Case with only an 18-gal. tank, and I could run it hard for more than 10 hours. They told me the poor fuel efficiency was just the nature of the beast because the engine has a turbocharger and 15 more horsepower than the 580 K model. A Case engine is good for only about 3,500 hours, if you can even get that many hours on it. The booms are made out of ductal steel which isn’t even as good as cast iron. I’ve worn out the engines in both machines. I also broke the boom on both of them.
“I have a 1993 Chevrolet 2500 with windshield wiper problems. My son has a 1994 1500 model which was had a factory recall. However, mine wasn’t recalled apparently because there weren’t enough complaints. I was told that I’d have to pay to fix the wiper problems. I’d like to know if I’m the only one with this problem.
”I’ve tried to wear out my Deutz 6250 50 hp tractor but I don’t think I can. It’s my best buy. It doesn’t use a lot of fuel. It keeps on going and going, just like the Energizer bunny. The problem is that they quit selling this tractor in the U.S. Parts are still available, but not the tractors.”
Justin’s well satisfied with his 1998 Chevy 2500 pickup equipped with 5.7 liter engine.
“It looks good, has plenty of power, a comfortable cab, and lots of accessories. The 3.78:1 gear ratio is too low, requiring higher engine rpm’s which results in poor gas mileage - 10 to 12 1/2 mpg. Otherwise, I’m quite pleased.”
Scott Jay Claussen, Denison, Lowa: “My 1992 Vermeer R-23 twin hay rake is a real time saver and handles hay gently. In thick hay it makes baling almost too easy because I can make windrows that cover the width of the baler. There's no need to weave back and forth with the baler. I can roll two 14-ft. windrows together and save a lot of driving time with the baler. “My 1991 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup is my worst buy. I’ve had to replace the rear end, transmission, starter, and alternator. There also were electrical problems. The warranty took care of the rear end, transmission, and electrical problems. Also, it isn’t very fuel efficient. It gets only 8 to
George Janecek, Washington, Iowa: “My best buy is a 1993 Chevrolet 2500 4WD extended cab pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter turbocharged diesel engine. It has 24,000 miles with no problems. I’ve never driven a pickup with so much power and fuel economy. I get 11 to 12 mpg pulling a trailer, 15 to 16 mpg on short trips, and 20 or more mpg on the highway. I love it. I previously had a 1991 Ford pickup equipped with a 351 cu. in, engine. The engine was the only thing that was problem-free. It had no power and I was lucky to get pasta filling station without having to refuel.”
James F. Dougherty, Lake City, Iowa: “My 1992 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty 4WD pickup rides and handles like a car. No problems. It’s a pleasure to drive.”
David Hemingway, Ellendale, Minn.: David nominates his Case-IH 1480 and 1680 combines as “best buys”. “They're both easy to maintain. The 1480 has 4,000 hours on it with very few problems. They’re good machines.” On the minus side, “My Case-IH 5400 minimum till drill is a worst buy. Wet soil sticks to the inside of the disc openers and causes them to plug up. “The heater and air conditioning controls on my Case-ITH 9100 tractor are inadequate. I either cook or freeze. “My 1989 Chevrolet 2500 pickup has had constant problems with the brakes, engine, and transmission. Ithas 45,000 miles and it seems like I'm always fixing it. It’s not tough enough.”
David F. Lapp, Myerstown, Penn.: David's impressed with his Honda GX110 3 1/2 hp gas engine as well as his GX140 5 hp gas engine. “Both engines start easy, are fuel efficient, and have high torque at low speeds. They don't use much oil and are equipped with ‘oil alert’. They’ ve outlasted and outperformed the 5 and 8 hp Briggs & Stratton engines I had been using.” On the negative side, “My Hardi RY 15 back-pack sprayer equipped with a pistontype hand pump is a worst buy, It almost always leaks out the top if it’s more than half full. The pump gave out after I used ita few times, The dealer replaced some parts at no cost, but they weren't enough to overcome the poor design.” John D, Freeman, Castalia, N.C.: “It has plenty of power for pulling trailers and is built to handle big loads with ease, yet it still rides as smooth as a car. It’s a joy to own,” reports John, owner of a 1991 Chevrolet 2500 heavy duty 4-WD pickup that's equipped with a454 cu. in. engine and automatic transmission. “It gets about 10 mpg.”
Gale Carpenter, Union City, Mich.: “Tt ran like a scalded dog before I traded it,” says Gale, unhappy owner of a 1988 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD pickup. “At times the 3speed overdrive transmission slam-shifted from forwerd to reverse, while at other times, carrying the same load, it would go right into overdrive at 50 mph. The rear differential had to be overhauled three times by 8,000 miles. The right front tire wore bare on the outside but had all its tread left on the inside, and the brakes were shot at 23,000 miles. The dealership did nothing to correct these problems, so I took GM into arbitration, I drove 65 miles to Grand Rapids to have aGM representative tell me ‘We don’t builda truck to be driven off-road.’ He added that the truck wasn’t designed to pull a gooseneck trailer, as it changed the geometry of the suspension. I traded fora 1989 Ford F-2504-WD pickup (8,600 Ibs. gross vehicle weight) with 4:10 gears, 351 cu. in. engine and automatic transmission. It’s built like a Caterpillar D-8 and rides nice. But it gets only 6 mpg without carrying a load and only 3 mpg carrying a load. It doesn’t have enough power to adequately pull a tri-axle trailer loaded with a tractor. If I'm driving dowhhill or on a long stretch of level road, the pickup sometimes shifts into overdrive. In this day of college-educated engineers, you'd think a 351 engine that developed 300 hp and got 15 mpg back in the 1960's and 1970’s would certainly do better than 200 hp and 6 mpg in the 1980’s, Can anyone explain why we have to shell out $18,500 for a truck that’s not worth $9,000 and go through all these problems? And the company says, ‘Oh well, things happen. Sorry about that.’”
Leslie Johnson, Shell Rock, Iowa: “My best buy 1988 Chevrolet 2500 4-WD rides and handles beautifully. It gets good gas mileage and the 4-wheel shift works like a dream.”
Own a Chevrolet? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.
Your report could appear in a future issue.