Subaru: what farmers say
26 reports in FARM SHOW · 24 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Subaru Forester sports utility vehicle
5 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My best purchase in the last two years is my 2024 Subaru Forester. I commute to work during the weekdays, covering 20 miles of gravel roads, 60 miles of two-lane roads, and 120 miles of interstate each day. In two years of owning this vehicle, we’ve put 88,000 miles on it in every weather condition North Dakota has to offer. In that time, two sets of tires and oil changes have been the only maintenance required.”
“My 2016 Subaru Forester I bought in 2017 is a great car with no problems at all. Those guys in Japan could teach our automotive manufacturers a few things.”
“This car has been 100 percent trouble-free,” says James about his 2007 Subaru Forester. “It’s an all-wheel-drive vehicle so I don’t have to shift in and out of 4-WD. It has a lot of traction, and one time I used it to pull a Jeep Wrangler out of soft sand.
“I’ve had a lot of electrical problems with my 2005 Dodge Caravan. It seems like there’s always something going wrong with it including problems with the electric door locks, the blower speed control, and the headlights and interior lights. I’ve also had to replace two alternators. However, this van does have a comfortable ride.”
“A friend asked me to service his 2002 Subaru Forester. I was amazed how easy it is to service this vehicle and how well it’s made. It even has a spin-on oil filter for the automatic transmission and a drain plug on the transmission. Also, one large plug at the bottom of the motor drains the whole cooling system. And at 27 mpg it’s fuel efficient, too.”
“Our 1998 Subaru Forester sports utility vehicle fits well in our farm operation. It can take a fair amount of rough and tumble going to the back forty. It rides like a car and is just as quiet. I pull a small trailer behind it whenever I need to haul large parts, etc. No problems.”
On the negative side, “Our 1997 Case-IH Maxxum MX100 front wheel assist tractor performs well but had a number of breakdowns during the first months we used it. Both rims on the front wheels had to be replaced and we had to make a major repair to the front axle driveline. We also had to make adjustments on the shifting mechanism and repairs and adjustments on the hydraulic controls. It took a long time to get parts.”
Subaru Outback sports utility vehicle
4 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I’m absolutely thrilled with my 2021 Subaru Outback. With X-Mode driving and over 8-in. of clearance, it’s been amazing in the woods, traversing steep slopes and crawling over sizeable rocks. I’ve hauled several hundred pounds of firewood, concrete blocks, rocks, etc., in the cargo area. It gets great gas mileage, decent acceleration, and is an overall nice ride.”
Steven isn’t impressed with his DeWalt cordless drill. “With little use, the chuck malfunctioned after about a year. Very poor value for the price. No more DeWalt products for me.”
“We bought our 2018 Subaru Outback in 2019 with 7,000 miles. We take it back to Subaru for regular service and never had to spend money on anything other than regular maintenance. It has around 60,000 miles.
“I purchased a Woodland Mills sawmill in October and love it. It’s well-built and high in quality – a very nice saw.”
Garry’s happy with his 2012 Subaru Outback sports utility vehicle. “It has about 85,000 trouble-free miles on it but has only been back to the dealer once, for a wheel alignment. I do my own service work including oil changes and tire rotations.
“I used my Black & Decker 4-in. power grinder once to remove some paint. It wasn’t under any kind of load, but in less than 5 min. the drive gears on it failed. The grinder was new, but the company said it was a discontinued model and that parts to fix it were no longer available.”
“My 1999 Subaru Outback wagon is a wonderful best buy. It has 225,000 miles and has performed flawlessly, requiring only scheduled maintenance and tires.
“Secondly, my Kubota AWD L5030 tractor has been great. With 50 hp, it can really get a lot of work done and it starts and runs smoothly on even the coldest Wisconsin mornings. There’s a good reason why Kubota owners are so loyal to the brand.
“Finally, my Troy-Bilt 8 hp tiller has really earned its keep, tilling our large garden for 12 years. It’s well worth the money.”
Michael’s disappointed with his 2001 Subaru Outback. “Two months after I bought this vehicle it started leaking dust into the interior. Everything’s covered with dust and it’s in the air. I’ve taken the vehicle to two different dealers and a body shop. The dealers said they knew I had a problem but couldn’t do anything about it. I’m very disgusted with the vehicle and also with the lack of help I’ve received from the company.”
Subaru Crosstrek compact
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My 2019 Subaru Crosstrek compact SUV equipped with a manual transmission is quiet, has a lot of power, and is a pleasure to drive. The only problem is the window/mirror control knob is too small for my big hands.”
“My best buys are 2 value-priced loaner vehicles that I bought from a dealer - a 2017 Dodge Ram 1500 Express quad cab, 4-WD pickup equipped with a 5.7-liter gas engine and 8-speed automatic transmission; and a 2019 Subaru Crosstrek equipped with a 2.0-liter engine and CVT transmission. Both vehicles ride and handle nice and are a pleasure to drive. Neither one has many bells and whistles, which suits me just fine.”
Subaru Forrester equipped
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I like my Kubota 3240 and 327 tractors, Honda CRF 230 and Husky 310 TXC motorcycles, 2010 Ford Escape, 1999 Subaru Forrester, and Stihl chainsaws. All of them run well, work hard, and are dependable.
“The second week after I bought my Deere LA 175 garden tractor, a tie rod arm broke. The dealer said I caused it, but you could see half the break had rust on it so the part was defective. We’ve had lots of other problems with this tractor.”
A 2001 Subaru Forrester equipped with a manual transmission rates as Wilbur’s “best buy”. “We had a lot of snow last winter, but this vehicle never let us down.”
Subaru 4-WD mini truck
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1994 Subaru 4-WD mini truck that I use like an ATV is both my best buy and my worst buy. This truck is very versatile with a short turning radius, the ability to haul heavy loads, and a good heater. I installed bigger wheels and tires on it to soften the ride. The downside is that the importer gave me an air filter that didn’t properly fit, and as a result the engine got ruined with only 3,000 miles on the vehicle. In less than one year, the importer’s used engines went up in price from $550 for a transaxle/engine assembly to $800 for just the engine. A local dealer of this importer said that ‘no American-made air filters fit these trucks’, contary to what the importer said, and that he had heard of several incidences just like mine.
“I hope someone will start a class action lawsuit so that we can get reimbursed. So far, I’ve been able to locate used engines but no rebuilt engines or rebuild kits. Otherwise, I think this mini truck works great.”
Subaru 4-WD Outback SUV
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“In 2017 I bought a used 2006 Subaru 4-WD Outback SUV with about 70,000 miles. I use it as a farm ‘runabout’ but also to go on long trips. With 4-WD it goes right through mud. I love it.”
Subaru Baja pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I’ve put up many cords of firewood with my 2002 Husqvarna 372 XP chainsaw. No problems.
“I own a pair of old Ford trucks equipped with 300 cu. in., 6-cyl. engines and Holley 4160 4-barrel carburetors, so I invested in intake upgrades from Jack Clifford Performance Products and am glad I did. It has made a big difference in power and reduced fuel usage (www.cliffordperformance.net; ph 951 471-1161).
“In 2013 I bought a used 2005 Subaru Baja pickup with about 50,000 miles on it. Unfortunately, it cost more to own than any vehicle I’ve ever bought. The radiator cracked at 65,000 miles, 2 turbines failed, and a driveby wire failed at a $900 repair cost. I could have used the money I spent on repairs on a full-sized Ford F-150. Now it needs a new timing belt, water pump, and valve cover gaskets.”
Subaru Brat ranks
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA 1985 Subaru Brat ranks as Thelma’s “best buy”. “When I was an Army recruiter in West Memphis, Arkansas, I called a Subaru dealer in Memphis and the salesman described the ‘Brat’ over the phone and I bought it sight unseen. Now 25 years later it has more than 350,000 miles on it yet still runs like new, although it does need a new paint job. My husband, who I ‘found’ 10 years ago, is a Subaru technician, which helps!
The Briggs & Stratton 18 ½ hp engine on my 2007 riding mower is my worst buy. With less than 100 hours it threw a rod through the engine case. And at 25 hours the Sears mechanic had to service the valves.”
Subaru Bulldog BD300 4
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I use my 2013 Subaru Bulldog BD300 4 by 2 utility vehicle every day. I love it. It’s easy to get into, always starts, and runs beautifully. I use it to do yard work and, in winter, I fill the box with firewood and unload it by backing it right up to the door of my house. I’m 81 years old and this machine is my legs. The only problem is that the cable on the shift lever sometimes sticks.”
Subaru Forester PZEV
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Our 2016 Subaru Forester PZEV has been an excellent used vehicle purchase for us. The all-wheel drive takes us wherever we want to go. It gets wonderful gas mileage (40+ mpg) and has many safety features.
“We’ve been frustrated with our experience trying to purchase a holster from Rocky Top Holsters. The product was ordered through one company and Rocky Top Holsters ended up getting the money according to the credit card records. Multiple attempts to contact the company via email and phone delivered zero replies. Long story short, they got the money, and we didn’t get a product.”
Subaru Legacy wagon
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My son and I each bought a Subaru Legacy wagon in 1995. Neither has been back to the dealer. We just put in gas and change oil. The all-wheel drive is great on snow and on gravel roads.
“My worst buy is a 1996 Ford F-250 4-WD. It gets only 10 mpg and has no power with a load on. It won’t even go the speed limit on the interstate and it has a vibration at 30 to 45 mph that two visits to the dealer hasn’t solved. At less than 5,000 hrs., they now plan to replace both drive shafts. One other annoyance: the spare tire didn’t match the other four tires.”
Subaru Legacy GT 4-WD station wagon
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysBruce is impressed with his 2000 Subaru Legacy GT 4-WD station wagon. “Last January we had a lot of ice and snow with icy roads, but this car handled so well on them that we hardly even noticed that they were slippery. The ABS brake system is a big help in being able to stop securely. It’s a fun car to drive and I like the styling.
“My worst buys are Harbor Freight Tools. I bought an item that I was dissatisfied with and called the company’s toll-free phone number, then was told to call a different customer service number. I tried to call that number seven different times but always got a busy signal. I sent three faxes to voice my complaint but got no response. I’ll never do business with this company again.”
Richard G. McDanolds, North
“My 1973 Ford 5000 tractor has more than 25,000 hours on it but the engine has never been overhauled.
“My 1964 Patz gutter cleaner still has its original motor and drive unit. I’ve replaced the chains and drive sprockets twice. I still use this old reliable manure cleaner every day.
“My 1968 Homelite C72 chainsaw has gone through four bars and more than 25 chains and sprockets but is still going strong. It’s been very dependable and is a best buy.”
Subaru Legacy Outback 4-WD sport utility wagon
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1996 Subaru Legacy Outback 4-WD sport utility wagon is my best buy. The 2.5-liter engine is responsive, easy on fuel, and quiet. I like having 4-WD when driving on snow-packed or wet or icy roads. It has excellent ground clearance and handles like a passenger car. We’re well pleased with it and would recommend it to anyone who wants comfort, safety, and a vehicle for all road conditions.”
Subaru Outbacks
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“We’ve been pleased with our Subaru Outbacks. We’ve always had them serviced at the dealership and never had any mechanical issues. We bought a 2014 with 5,000 miles and traded it at around 95,000 miles for a 2018 with 7,000 miles. It now has around 71,000 miles. They’re outstanding cars.”
Subaru Robin engines
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Subaru Robin engines are the easiest starting, quietiest running, and most fuel efficient gas engines I’ve ever seen (Subaru Robin, Wood Dale, Ill. ph 800 277 6246 or 630 350-8200; www.robinamerica.com). However, the engines come with a cheap spark plug so if you buy them new be sure to also buy a good spark plug. If you do, these engines will run and run and run.
“My Husqvarna 395 chain saw works great.”
Subaru Sambar mini truck
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA used 1993 Subaru Sambar mini truck that he bought a year ago rates as Harry’s “best buy”. “This mini truck has performed flawlessly. It’s equipped with a 5-speed transmission and push button 4-WD with an extra ‘double low’ 4-WD gear. It has an AM radio, air conditioner, and a good heater. It had about 75,000 miles on it when I bought it.
“It’s the handiest machine on my farm. I can’t understand why someone would pay $8,000 or more for a 4-WD Gator or a Kawasaki Mule and freeze during the winter, when they can get a Subaru Sambar with more carrying capacity and for less than half as much money. One additional benefit is that in my state I can get a license tag for it and drive it on the road at 40 to 50 mpg. It works great for running errands.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.