McCulloch: what farmers say
13 reports in FARM SHOW · 7 Best Buys6 Worst Buys
McCulloch saw
1 Best Buy2 Worst Buys“My Stihl 361 chainsaw is my worst buy. It has no power and it vibrates. It had two right side cutters together that made it cut crooked. I wanted to get credit for this saw and upgrade to the next model. However, the dealer said he couldn’t because too much time had passed. I have a McCulloch saw that’s more than 30 years old, and it cuts better than this saw.”
John’s most recent “best buy” is a 1997 Cub Cadet 2284 lawn tractor equipped with a 60-in. belly mower. “The 24 hp Kohler V-twin engine is powerful and snappy. The 60-in. mower is super rugged with grease zerks for the wheels and spindles so maintenance is easy. It’s user-friendly and has nice colors and style.”
One of John’s “worst buys” is a 1994 McCulloch 16-in. chain saw. “It’s a nightmare to work on because it assembles and disassembles like a Chinese puzzle. And there are a lot of plastic parts to break.”
“My 1994 Wood-Mizer portable band mill is my best buy ever. It’s extremely accurate and simple to use, and it does everything the company said it would and more. I’d recommend it to anyone. “MyMcCulloch chain saw is my worst buy. Bar oil got in the motor which caused the saw to smoke so bad that I could hardly see. My dealer gave me a new McCulloch and it’s the best saw I’ve ever owned.”
McCulloch chainsaw
0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys“About 25 years ago we acquired an Oliver Super 88 tractor from an elderly neighbor. I let my son buy it at the age of 10 with money he had saved from raising tobacco. Once in a while he would even sneak the tractor out of the shed and drive it to school.
“My son is the second owner of this tractor and, other than replacing the plug and points, it has been maintenance-free. It has done a lot of hard work in its lifetime, but now with field equipment getting bigger we just use it to rake hay and haul loads.”
On the negative side, “When I was lucky enough to get my 2011 McCulloch chainsaw started, I was only able to cut wood for a half hour or so. I finally got so disgusted that I smashed the saw with a hammer and threw it away. I owned an Echo chainsaw for 30 years and it worked great, but after I moved I couldn’t find an Echo dealer. We use firewood to heat our 6-bedroom home and a shop, so my son and I do a lot of sawing.”
“All I’ve put into it are new tires and fuel,” says Oliver about a 1968 Ford 5000 utility tractor he bought used. “It’s my only tractor and it gets used hard every year for field work, haying and all my other chores. It’s easy on fuel and it always starts.”
On the negative side, he’s had bad luck with his 1997 McCulloch chainsaw. “The whole starting mechanism fell off after the first hour of use. After it was repaired, it never started right again without priming it. I gave it away for use as an exercise machine, because you could sure build up your arm muscles pulling on the rope trying to start it.”
McCulloch (general)
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Honda water pump is my best buy. I bought it in case we ever have a fire on our farm. Thankfully, I haven’t had to use it yet. But it starts quick and produces a lot of pressure. We tested it during several fire drills. “My Husqvarna brush cutter and Husqvarna chain saw are both best buys. I’ve always found the Husky line of equipment to be powerful and dependable and easy to repair. Repairs are seldom necessary, though.” On the “worst buy” side, he’s unhappy with his Stihl 009 chain saw. “I used it last year to make firewood. We go through about 10 cords per year. The saw works okay but the air filtering system is terrible. It sucks in every piece of sawdust for miles around and packs it firmly around the carburetor. We have to use an air compressor to blow away the dust about every two hours. I wore out two Homelite XL chain saws and a McCulloch and never had this problem.”
McCulloch 1 500 psi
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA German-built International Harvester 624 50 hp diesel tractor equipped with a frontend loader rates as Alvin’s “best buy”. “We bought it new in 1970 for $4,500. At the time it was the only tractor I could afford to buy new. We attached a loader and have used it year around ever since then. We’ve overhauled it once.
“We bought a 2006 McCulloch 1,500 psi high pressure washer at Wal-Mart, and it’s our worst buy. We were able to use it only five times before the nylon relief valve split. We called the toll-free number and left messages, but never got a reply. We also have a McCulloch chainsaw that needs a drive sprocket, and we can’t find parts for it. Now the warranty on it has expired and we’re stuck with more useless junk.”
McCulloch 2014 Eager Beaver chainsaw
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The McCulloch 2014 Eager Beaver chainsaw I bought in 1964 is my best buy of all time. It’s equipped with a 14-in. blade. For years it was the only chainsaw I owned. It always starts on the first or second pull, even in cold weather. I bought an 18-in. chainsaw of another brand four years ago, but I still grab the McCulloch unless I’m cutting extra big or very hard wood.”
McCulloch 610 chainsaw
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“More than 32 years ago I bought a used McCulloch 610 chainsaw for $100 and have used it on our farm ever since then. During a severe ice storm in 1994, I and others ran the saw day and night removing trees.
“I accidentally drove my tractor over this saw twice and had to make new housing parts with J.B. Weld. I’ve also replaced the spark plug, air filter, chain and bar several times. The muffler is burned out and I couldn’t find another, so now it’s very noisy.
“This machine has never failed to start and never requires more than five pulls. If I haven’t used it for some time I pour the old fuel out and replace it with a fresh gas/oil mixture. A local fire department has an abrasive saw, used to cut car bodies open, with the same McCulloch engine on it that has served them well for more than 25 years. Neither saw has ever been in a repair shop.”
McCulloch 700 chainsaws
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I purchased two McCulloch 700 chainsaws in 1977 - one with a bar and the other with a bow. I used both saws to cut firewood and sold a lot of cords. Both saws are still in working condition today, but now I’m too old to operate them. The key to a long life for a chainsaw is using the right fuel-to-oil mixture and performing regular maintenance. I know this for a fact because in my spare time I work on chainsaws, weed eaters, and lawn mowers.”
McCulloch EZ Pull weedeater
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA 2004 Sears Craftsman 26 hp riding mower rates as Hal’s “best buy”. “We have a hilly yard but this unit has power to spare and has required only routine maintenance. It cuts even and doesn’t miss any grass between the blades.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2005 McCulloch EZ Pull weedeater. “We used it only twice and then it wouldn’t start. The company gave us another one which worked better, but at times it doesn’t want to run, either. Most of the problem seems to be in the carburetor and the choke system. However, when this weedeater is running it does do a good job of cutting.”
McCulloch F1000 high pressure washer
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The McCulloch F1000 high pressure washer I bought 1 1/2 years ago is my best buy. It’s easy to set up and has enough pressure to clean almost anything. The spray nozzle has four settings - one for applying soap, wax, or chemicals; a 1,000 psi vertical fan spray; a 1,000 psi jet spray (this setting will even remove paint); and a 1,000 psi jet horizontal fan spray.”
McCulloch MAC 3200 chainsaw
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I’ve used my McCulloch MAC 3200 chainsaw for almost 15 years with no problems. It has only a 14-in. bar so I thought it would balk at larger trees, but I’ve been able to take down some pretty big trees with it. I replaced the chain after repeated sharpening had left the original chain fairly dull. The saw is equipped with a primer bulb for easy starting, and even on freezing cold mornings it’ll usually get going with five or six pulls. I highly recommend this saw for light to medium-sized trees.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.