Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › John Deere › Gator

John Deere Gator every day

What FARM SHOW readers say · 24 Best Buys3 Worst Buys · ATVs & UTVs

John Deere Gator every day

24 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bill Weber, West Seneca, N.Y. · Vol. 47, No. 4 (2023), p. 14

“My Deere Gator was expensive, but it’s very dependable. I just do oil changes and regular, limited maintenance. They’re quality machines.

“My 2022 Poulan chainsaw is the same size as my old one but has limited power. It had to be tweaked to get it running right.”

Best Buy
John J. Patterson, East Peoria, Ill. · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 13

“It’s one of the best pickups I’ve ever owned,” says John about his 2006 Ford F-350 Super Duty model.

“My 2004 Deere Gator just keeps on going with no problems.

“My 2000 Husqvarna weed trimmer is still going strong.”

Best Buy
Robert Fine, Excelsior Springs, Mo. · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 13

“I use my Deere Gator every day and believe that every old man like me should have one. I use it to pick up the mail, to gather sticks, and to haul chainsaws, weed trimmers, and fencing items. It has almost 1,000 hrs. on it. I can’t keep my grandson off it, and I wish I could buy one for my wife, too. I do think the company could lower the price.”

Worst Buy
John E. Mills, Howell, Mich. · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 13

John’s satisfied with his 2016 Polaris Ranger 4-WD utility vehicle equipped with a 900 cc engine. “It has excellent power, a smooth ride, and starts good in hot or cold weather. We use it every day on our farm. The only problem is that it shifts really hard into reverse the first time we use it every day. With 4-WD and a locking differential, this machine will go just about anywhere.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2014 Deere Gator equipped with a Briggs & Stratton engine. “The engine developed a head gasket problem soon after the warranty expired, and the dealer wouldn’t cover the $1,200 repair bill. He offered to take the machine on a trade-in but I declined. Instead I brought it home, waxed it up, and sold it. Then I bought the Polaris, which is a superior product in every way.”

Best Buy
Helen Barton, Wyoming, Ill. · Vol. 41, No. 3 (2017), p. 15

“I bought my 2012 Deere Gator because I needed a utility vehicle with power steering, but that was the first thing to go wrong with it. Then other problems developed. The battery went dead all the time because it was wired wrong. Reverse gear wouldn’t work so they put in a new transmission, fortunately before the warranty expired. However, after the warranty expired it started having problems again. This time they worked on it and I ended up paying $186. Now it’s back in the shop again.

“We’ve always owned Deere equipment but have never had trouble like this. I used my previous Gator for 8 years and it never had any problems.”

Best Buy
Don Wilson, Hunter, Okla. · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 15

“I’m disappointed in our 2010 Kawasaki Mule utility vehicle. About two months after we bought it the engine started to have problems. It would die and then after 5 min. the engine would start and run a while, but then the same problem would happen again. We took the machine to the dealer, who installed a bunch of new parts and kept it for a month. When we got the rig back, it still had the same problem. We got a big repair bill that should have been covered under the warranty. We plan to get rid of this machine and buy a Deere Gator.”

Best Buy
Steve Wilkinson, Ponce De Leon, Fla. · Vol. 37, No. 1 (2013), p. 15

“We bought a used Deere Gator to replace a golf cart, and it works so well we wish we had bought it a long time ago. It hauls up to 1,500 lbs. and has a dump box. Gets great gas mileage and always starts. I could have paid for the Gator with the money I spent on batteries over the years for the golf cart.”

Best Buy
Mike Erie, Fort Scott, Kansas · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 12

“My 2006 Deere Gator is trouble-free and does everything I ask it to. It rides on no-flat tires which I really like.”

Best Buy
Bob Fine, Excelsior Springs, Mo. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 13

Bob’s the satisfied owner of a 2005 Deere Gator. “I think every farm needs at least one or two of these machines. I have one, my wife has one, and my grandkids one. I paid about $6,700 for it. I probably use it on average 12 times a day, for everything from getting the mail to hauling chainsaws, wood, apples, and fencing items, and transporting deer hunters.

“I’ve had problems with my 2008 Cub Cadet zero turn riding mower equipped with a 52-in. deck. The B & S engine has problems and the mower pulls sideways. Also, it won’t pull itself up a 25-degree hill. However, the mower does a great job around small trees and I like the leaf vacuum attachment.”

Best Buy
Shannon Rupnow, Reeseville, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 2 (2011), p. 13

“I like shopping at Tractor Supply Company. It’s a small store so I can get in and out quickly. They sell good stuff at a good price and provide excellent customer service.

“My Deere Gator is a best buy. I have no idea how I ever got by without it.

“My 2002 Ford F-150 4-WD pickup works great. It’s equipped with a V-6 engine and a 5-speed manual transmission. The seal on the slave cylinder went out. It would have been an expensive 10-hr. repair at the dealership. Instead, I pulled the engine out and did the work myself in only 5 hrs.”

Best Buy
Gary Scheetz, Parkston, S. Dak. · Vol. 34, No. 4 (2010), p. 15

“A couple years ago I traded my 4 by 2 Deere Gator, equipped with a single cylinder air-cooled engine, for a new Gator HPX 4-WD model equipped with a 2-cyl. water-cooled engine. When the weather gets cold, say under 20 degrees or so, the HPX pumps raw gas into the crankcase until the engine stops.

“I use my Gator for a lot of short trips around the farm all year long and when the weather is nice, there’s no problem. Other Gator owners of the HPX and XUV I’ve spoken with have had the same problem. The dealer said ‘they all do that’ and that you have to warm them up and burn it out of the crankcase.

“But that doesn’t work. Even if you let the machine run with the engine warmed up, if it’s cold out it still pumps raw fuel into the crankcase. I tried running a flexible hose from the air cleaner inlet to take heat off the muffler. That seems to help, but it doesn’t solve the problem. Has anyone out there found a cure? My HPX has a Kawasaki engine and a carburetor.”

Best Buy
Edsel Clayton, Diggs, Va. · Vol. 33, No. 6 (2009), p. 14

“It starts right up in any weather and, with 4-WD, it can go anywhere,” says Edsel, pleased with his 2009 Deere Gator utility vehicle equipped with a diesel engine. “It has comfortable seats. No problems.

“My 2007 Stihl chainsaw is difficult to start and is my worst buy. I’m 71 years old and have to get my young neighbor to start this saw for me.”

Best Buy
Howard Birr, Albany, Minn. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“Our 2007 Deere Gator is a reliable and versatile machine. We’ve put more than 350 hours on it with no problems, except for the fuel gauge which stopped working after the warranty had expired.”

Best Buy
Charles N. Wells, Sturgis, Ky. · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 13

“We like our 2008 Deere Gator. It’s equipped with an optional adjustable seat which comes in handy for my shorter wife, and an electric dump bed. This utility vehicle does exactly what it’s supposed to do. We use it all over our farm and yard, even though it was originally purchased by my wife for ‘house keeping’ duties. It has a low bed height which makes loading stuff easy and also provides stability on hilly terrain. The differential lock provides just enough extra traction to get through muddy places.

“This vehicle is easy to service at home and is comfortable to get in and out of for us ‘boomers’. It replaced my wife’s 1985 Honda 250 Big Red. The Honda was also a best buy.

“We’ve also used the Gator to spray fence rows instead of a 4-wheeler. It’s much easier on the spray hand. If we need to get into tight places we still have a 4-wheeler and the Honda for that, but 99 percent of the time it’s the Gator that does the work on our farm.”

Worst Buy
Steven M. Liss, M.D., Harrison, Idaho · Vol. 32, No. 5 (2008), p. 15

Steven’s unhappy with his 2004 Deere Gator. “I’m a Deere enthusiast - everything I own is green and yellow, and over the years I’ve restored fourteen different 2-cyl. tractors. However, my Gator has been a total disappointment. It’s hard to start and keep running, and when the belt gets wet it won’t go. Also, this vehicle won’t hold back going downhill and the power tilt bed was very weak. None of these problems could be fixed.

“Finally I traded it in for a 2005 Kubota RTV 900, which is my best buy. It always starts, even in sub-zero cold. I really like the hydrostatic transmission because it holds back even with heavy loads while going downhill. The cloth cab heater works great, and the dump bed tilts even when it’s overloaded. It’ll pull trailers and logs well over its rated capacity. It’s fuel efficient, too. I can drive it for several weeks on one tank of fuel.”

Worst Buy
Harold Hamilton, Eagleville, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 12

“In reference to Gary Alford’s statements in a recent issue about poor starting problems with his 2005 HPX 4-WD Deere Gator, I can say I had the same disturbing problem with my 05 HPX Gator. When I would shut it off for 15 minutes on a 90 degree day, I’d have to choke it to death to restart it.

“After two visits to the dealer with this problem, we finally found a solution. We traded it in for a diesel Gator which we are more than pleased with. It starts great and uses only half as much fuel as the gas model.

“One problem: It should have power steering because it steers hard. I have a Deere diesel lawn tractor with power steering so if they can put a unit on there, they should be able to add it to the Gator.”

Best Buy
Stephen Beck, Earlimart, Calif. · Vol. 31, No. 5 (2007), p. 14

Stephen’s the satisfied owner of a 2006 Deere Gator. “It has more than paid for itself with the savings in gas compared to doing chores in a full-size pickup. As a bonus, it’s fun to drive.”

Best Buy
Phillip Page, Fredericktown, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 14

Phillip nominates his 2005 Deere Gator as his “best buy”. “My wife was the one who expressed an interest in buying this utility vehicle. We use it almost every day. It has enough power to pull our boat dock up a steep incline and will run forever on a tank of gas. The electric dump bed is worth the extra money.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1999 Long Farmtrac 60 tractor. “This was the first new tractor I ever bought. The tractor was advertised to be ‘just like a Ford New Holland’ and the specs on it were almost the same. However, I was able to put a total of only 120 hours on this tractor because I had so much trouble with it. The brakes were bad, the hydraulic system leaked, and the fuel gauge was faulty. I did learn how to bleed a diesel fuel system. After one year I traded this tractor in for a Deere 5210, and I’m well pleased with it.”

Best Buy
Marion E. Carter, Frenchburg, Ky. · Vol. 30, No. 2 (2006), p. 15

“My Deere Gator is by far the handiest vehicle I’ve ever owned. I can’t see how anyone could set up housekeeping without this machine. It serves as a small pickup and as a general, all-around utility vehicle. It starts right up and will run forever on a tank of gas. It’ll go about anywhere on our farm. My son bought it for me and I’m just as pleased as a young mother. We can even ride it to church on Sunday.”

Best Buy
Marion E. Carter, Frenchburg, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 15

“My Deere Gator is by far the handiest machine I’ve ever owned. I can’t see how anyone could get along without it. It serves as both a small pickup and also as a general all-around utility vehicle. It always starts right up and seems to run forever on a tank of gas. It’ll go about anywhere on our farm. If I want I can even ride it to church on Sunday.”

Best Buy
Chris Schaefer, Flemington, N.J. · Vol. 26, No. 2 (2002), p. 15

Chris likes his 1999 Deere Gator. “It’s our fourth Gator so we obviously like them. We also bought a mini one for our 4-year-old. It runs quiet, looks good, and doesn’t go too fast so it’s safe for him.”

Best Buy
R.L. Dodd, Cashion, Okla. · Vol. 26, No. 1 (2002), p. 15

“In FARM SHOW’s Vol. 24, No. 4 issue, Daniel Stokes of Omro, Wis., reported that his 1999 Deere Gator was leaking gas into the oil. I’m having the same problem with my 2000 6 by 4 Gator. The spark plugs foul out and the engine backfires. The Deere dealer has worked on it several times without success so I bought a new carburetor. That didn’t solve the problem and gas is still leaking into the oil. Does anyone have an answer for this problem?

“In FARM SHOW’s Vol. 25, No. 6 issue, Larry Blockard of Hartman, Ark., said he was having trouble with fuel leaking from the fuel cap on his 1999 Deere 5410 tractor. My 2000 Deere 5310 tractor also leaks fuel out around the fuel cap. I discovered that the cap couldn’t be screwed down far enough on the tank’s plastic neck because the threads on it were faulty. I installed a new tank which solved the problem.”

Best Buy
Daniel Stokes, Omro, Wis. · Vol. 24, No. 4 (2000), p. 15

“I’m well pleased with my 1999 Deere Gator, except that the engine has a tendency to leak gas into the oil in cold weather. The company installed a different jet in the carburetor and changed the spark plugs, but I don’t think they’ve solved the problem. Does anyone else have this problem? I think it’s going to be a short-lived engine. It has only 80 hours on it now.”

Best Buy
Claude W. Winters, Eglon, W. Va. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 15

“Our 1997 Chevrolet Cheyenne 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a Vortex V-8 engine has been a dream. No problems after 3,700 miles. It can easily pull a low boy trailer loaded with equipment.

‘My 1992 Deere Gator is one of the greatest labor savers on the farm. I use it for checking, mending, and building fence, taking tools to the field for repairs, and just for getting around our West Virginia hills. It’s also a wonderful toy for our grand kids.”

Best Buy
Ralph and Lois Cole, Storm Lake, Iowa · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 15

They like their 4 by 2 Deere Gator. “When we bought it our first reaction was, ‘Why didn’t we get one sooner?’,” says Lois. “Health problems made this purchase imperative for Ralph. We use it all the time and will probably have it until our ride in a hearse. This fall wil be Ralph’s 58th year to combine grain.”

Best Buy
Martin Greenleaf, Kirkwood, Penn. · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 17

“My 1990 Case-IH 1640 combine was simple to maintain and had only one minor breakdown in six years . I liked it so much I traded it for a Case-IH 2144 combine. “My 1993 Deere Gator works great. I put more hours on it every year than I do on my tractor or combine. No problems.”

Best Buy
Will Hathaway, Turin, Iowa · Vol. 20, No. 4 (1996), p. 16

Will’s impressed with his 1996 4 by 2 Deere Gator. “The 3 by 4-ft. box is handy and dumps out. We’ve had it rounded up full of dirt. It has only a small 10 hp engine but it seems to have plenty of power and is easy on fuel. We use it every day.”

Own a John Deere? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.

Your report could appear in a future issue.

Send your Best or Worst Buy

More John Deere products

John Deere 1780 split-row 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 4240 tractor 14 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 720 diesel 3 best · 0 worstJohn Deere M tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere L110 lawn tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 3025E tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 3020 diesel 16 best · 0 worstJohn Deere gas tractor 46 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 4020 diesel 62 best · 3 worstJohn Deere 1023E tractor with backhoe 1 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 2025R tractor 4 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 9300 tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 110 garden tractor 11 best · 2 worstJohn Deere Gator 6x4 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 6400 tractor 15 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 4320 compact tractor 6 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 8120 tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 425 garden tractor 16 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 955 tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere lawn mower 12 best · 2 worst

See all John Deere reports →