Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Simplicity

Simplicity: what farmers say

24 reports in FARM SHOW · 17 Best Buys7 Worst Buys

Simplicity zero-turn riding mower

2 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Lawrence A. Newcomb, LaCrescent, Minn. · Vol. 40, No. 6 (2016), p. 13

A 2016 Simplicity zero-turn riding mower equipped with a 25 hp. engine and 48-in. deck rates as Lawrence’s “best buy”. “We’ve owned two other Simplicity mowers in the past, a 1967 model and a 1992 model. All three mowers have been excellent machines.”

Worst Buy
John & Dave Hebert, Owaneco, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 14

After feeding cattle on an open concrete slab for several years, John & Dave decided to make the jump to a Winkler hoop building that gives them optimum feeding and environmental conditions and would allow for a deep-bedded manure buildup. The building is 42 by 182 ft. long and houses 80 head at one end. The Heberts are able to let manure build up for about 6 months, using cornstalk bedding. One thing the men say they really like about the building is that it’s about 15 degrees cooler in summer and 15 degrees warmer in winter, even with the open ends. There’s also a ridge vent for summer ventilation. At the center of the building they set up a work and storage area. Simplicity riding mower. “Two days after the warranty expired the brake rod broke. The company paid for the part, but I had to pay for labor and for a new choke cable that the ‘authorized’ dealer broke. Now this mower is sitting out in my barn with a blown as advertised. Because of the heavy use that I give this rig I have to resharpen the blades regularly. However, to do that the blades have to be unscrewed from the flywheel using tools that I made myself. It’s a 2-hour job from start to finish.”

Best Buy
Earl A. Juelfs, Fults, Ill. · Vol. 20, No. 5 (1996), p. 15

“My worst buy is a 1989 White riding mower equipped with a 12 1/2 hp engine. Every time I tried to use it something broke or else it wouldn’t start. I finally traded it in for a Simplicity mower and like it a lot. I’d recommend it to anyone.” On the positive side, “Two years ago I bought a 1992 Dodge Dakota 8-cyl. longbed pickup and it’s a best buy. It has 30,000 miles with no problems. It has a lot of power and can easily pull my livestock trailer or my 18-ft. flatbed trailer. It rides like a car and has plenty of room inside and outside.”

Best Buy
Mike Shy, New Carlisle, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 12

Mike likes his Simplicity Legacy riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck. “This is our second Simplicity mower. We bought our first one in 1990 and had very few problems with it on our five acres. We just used it until it wore out. These mowers are easy to work on and seem to last forever.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2005 Sears Craftsman riding mower. “The company offered a ‘no interest for six months’ financing deal so I took the bait. What they didn’t tell me was how bad their mowers are. It doesn’t cut level and stalls easily, and it’s hard to work on. Finally I just gave it away and bought another Simplicity.”

Best Buy
Avgary G. Kehias, Pana, Ill. · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 16

“My best buy is my 1998 Simplicity Legacy riding mower equipped with a 25 hp gas engine and a 60-in. deck. I had been using a riding mower equipped with an 18 hp engine and 48-in. deck, but this one does the job a lot faster and has cut my mowing time in half. I really like how it maneuvers around all the trees in our yard. Dealer support has been outstanding. We had some problems with the engine at first so the dealer gave us a new mower to use while ours was being repaired. After it was returned, he checked back with us to be sure that we were satisfied.”

Best Buy
Braun Farms, Saline, Mich. · Vol. 44, No. 5 (2020), p. 15

“We own a 2008 Simplicity riding mower equipped with a 20 hp. engine and 50-in. mower deck, and until recently it worked fine. However, now the transmission has a hole in it and oil is leaking out. Unfortunately, the company no longer sells replacement parts for the transmission. We’ve learned that other people with these mowers have the same problem.”

Worst Buy
Richard Harris, Hillsboro, Tenn. · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 15

“My best buy is my 1997 International Cub Cadet 2140 riding mower equipped with a grass bagger. “It does a first class job of mowing our 2-acre yard, even in tall, damp grass. If I ever need another mower I’ll buy a Cub Cadet again. “My worst buy is my 1997 Simplicity riding mower equipped with a 14 hp Briggs & Stratton gas engine. It’s built too light and

Simplicity tractor

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Fred Bolton, Willow, Alaska · Vol. 40, No. 2 (2016), p. 12

“My father bought my Simplicity tractor new in 1966. It has been used a lot over the years but has always been reliable. I grew up with this tractor on the farm and have now inherited it. I use it extensively on our 37-acre homestead with the implements shown in the photo. We used the tractor to rototill about 3 acres last year alone. It has been quite a valued product over its life.”

Best Buy
Charlie Breiding, Mogadore, Ohio · Vol. 33, No. 5 (2009), p. 13

“I like my 1991 and 2000 Simplicity lawn tractors. Both have been very dependable.

“The lawn vacuum system I bought from is a best buy (www.tractorsupply.com). I use it for both grass and leaves and it has a lot of capacity. I’d recommend it to anyone.

“My Grizzly 12-volt 3/8-in. drill and 4 ½-in. saw are both worst buys. The drill lacked power and the battery went dead very quickly. Same with the saw. I accidentally dropped the drill from my work bench and the case flew apart. These tools are junk.”

Simplicity 1823 riding mower

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
James L. Oetker, Cumming, Iowa · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 14

“My 2005 Simplicity 1823 riding mower is my worst buy. The problem is the power steering has a quarter turn of play. I took the mower back to the dealer and he called the factory rep, who told them that eight out of nine power steering units do the same thing.

“Another problem is that every time I get into heavy grass the mower’s drive belt slips, unless I put belt dressing on it. I don’t think the springs on the tightener are built heavy enough. This mower should have been recalled. I use it to mow our local cemetery, but it’s an embarrassment because I can’t drive in a straight line due to the play in the power steering.”

Simplicity 4040 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Rupert Matthews, Blacksburg, Va. · Vol. 34, No. 4 (2010), p. 15

Rupert’s “all-time best buy” is his 1973 Simplicity 4040 tractor equipped with a 60-in. mower deck, 3-pt. hitch and 2,000 rpm pto. “I bought this tractor used in 1976 and it still has the original engine and rear tires. The hour meter quit working at about 1,700 hours back in the 1990’s. I’d buy a new model if they made one.”

Simplicity 7018 garden tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Lawrence Schaub, Belle Fourche, S. Dak. · Vol. 38, No. 6 (2014), p. 15

A 1979 Simplicity 7018 garden tractor equipped with an 18 hp Kohler engine rates as Lawrence’s “best buy”. I used this tractor with a 42-in. deck for many years to cut grass, until last year when I bought a new riding mower. However, I still use it with a 36-in. rototiller to till our large 50 by 100-ft. garden.”

Simplicity 7114 garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Billy Stanton, Montpelier, Ind. · Vol. 36, No. 6 (2012), p. 15

Billy’s impressed with his 1980 Simplicity 7114 garden tractor. “I use this tractor every year to mow 2 1/2 acres, and it still works good.

“I recently bought a BV100 water distiller from American Water Distillers. I was only able to make 4 1/2 gal. of water before it quit working. The distiller was guaranteed for one year. I called the company and got a recorded message saying they would call back within 24 hours. I called 8 different times but no one returned my calls. I also tried talking to a salesman twice but he hung up on me both times. That was $599 down the drain.”

Simplicity Broadmoor riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Klaas Rinsma, Quinte West, Ontario · Vol. 40, No. 2 (2016), p. 15

“I operate a grass cutting business and have used my Simplicity Broadmoor riding mower to cut lawns for 12 customers, as well as my own, for many years with no problems.”

Simplicity Broadmoor 1600 riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Willard Jungbluth, Dodgeville, Wis. · Vol. 31, No. 6 (2007), p. 13

“My 2007 Simplicity Broadmoor 1600 riding mower is my best buy. I bought it to replace a Simplicity Broadmoor 12 1/2 hp model, which was purchased in 1992 and used exclusively to mow two large lawns. My only cost on that machine was for regular maintenance and new blades. It still had the original belts on it when I traded for the new model. I love the way the new one handles. It does a neat job of mowing and is easy for me to operate at my 86 years of age. If this model lasts as long as its predecessor, as I’m sure it will, it’ll be a real best buy.”

Simplicity Champion 20 hp zero turn

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Roger Parks, Moweaqua, Ill. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 13

“My 2007 Simplicity Champion 20 hp zero turn riding mower is comfortably maneuverable and also does an excellent job mowing. It’s equipped with a 50-in. deck and independent suspension and has cut my mowing time in half. No problems.

“My 1993 GM 1500 pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter, V-6 engine and automatic transmission is a best buy. Now it has more than 180,000 miles on it with no major problems.”

Simplicity D17 garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
David S. Freiberg, Woodville, Wis. · Vol. 40, No. 6 (2016), p. 14

David likes his Simplicity D17 garden tractor. “I’ve used Simplicity garden tractors for more than 25 years and they’ve all been excellent machines. The most trouble I’ve had with this one was a worn out belt and blades.

“My Deere 2510 was a bad tractor. Anything that could go wrong with it, did.”

Simplicity Landlord garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Duane E. Ingram, Lincoln, Ill. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 14

“I use a 48-in. snowblower on my 2002 Simplicity Landlord garden tractor. The snowblower can easily clear 8-in. deep snow from my driveway in no time. I also use the snowblower to clear my neighbor’s driveway and to clear snow around buildings.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2009 Shindaiwa “long shaft” weed eater. “I don’t like the counterclockwise rotation of the string, and using this ‘long shaft’ weed eater gives me a sore back. I wish I still had my Echo 1100 series curved shaft model. That was a good machine.”

Simplicity Legacy 20 hp garden tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Michael A. Zacherl, Tionesta, Pa. · Vol. 24, No. 4 (2000), p. 15

A 1999Ford F-150 extended cab 4-WD pickup rates as Michael’s “best buy”. “I really like the 4-door cab. It has good seats and offers the driver a good view. I also like the 4-WD electronic control. It sure beats the old lockout hubs.

“I have mixed feelings about my 1999 Simplicity Legacy 20 hp garden tractor. It works great for mowing or blowing snow. However, the hydraulic system works too slow and brackets on the rocker shaft keep working loose from the frame. The tractor’s foot-controlled hydraulics are a joke when used with the mower. Also, you can’t use the differential lock and activate the hydraulics at the same time. I installed a hand-controlled lever to operate the hydraulics, which helps a lot.”

Simplicity Prestige riding mower equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gary Grimm, Young America, Minn. · Vol. 44, No. 6 (2020), p. 14

Gary’s the satisfied owner of a 2013 Simplicity Prestige riding mower equipped with a 52-in. mower deck. “Since we started using this machine our 2-acre lawn has never looked better. It cuts evenly without leaving any bunches. It has power steering and a good suspension system that results in a nice ride and ease of operation. I use a Simplicity snowblower attachment with it that also works great. I used to buy John Deere mowers, but no more.”

Simplicity Regent riding mower

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Bill Van De Bruinhorst, Clinton, Ontario · Vol. 43, No. 2 (2019), p. 15

“FARM SHOW is truly my best buy. Once I get my hands on it, I can’t let go until I’ve read every page. It brings joy to my house and workplace. Even my employees will stop working just to get their hands on the magazine. Thank you for publishing such a wonderful paper.

“My 2016 Simplicity Regent riding mower was a nightmare from day one. Anything you can imagine went wrong with it. The grill fell off and I accidentally drove over it, causing the light bulbs to shatter on our lawn. The hood fell off, and because the sheet metal is thin I couldn’t weld it. The hood ended up in my scrap pile. The mower deck fell off twice, and the left side of the front axle also broke off the frame twice. One of the tires developed a slow leak so I often had to put air in it, and a mower guard got torn off. The mower’s Briggs & Stratton engine works well, but everything around it seems to fall off. The dealer did nothing to help.”

Simplicity ZT-16 ZTR riding mower

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
John Vincent, Albany, Ind. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 14

“My best buy Deere 770 utility tractor has more than 1,000 hours of trouble-free service. I use it for pushing snow and also to pull a 5-ft. Bush Hog mower, which it handles with ease. It uses about one gallon of fuel per hour at full throttle.

“My Simplicity ZT-16 ZTR riding mower is my worst buy. It has an excellent Kohler engine but is hard on drive belts, going through up to six belts in a single season. And, it takes me up to two hours to replace a belt. The dealer can’t seem to solve the problem so this mower spends a great deal of time either in my barn or at the dealers.”

Simplicity bandsaw mill

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Randal Hatcher, Spanishburg, W. Va. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

A 1990 Yanmar 2220D 4-WD compact diesel tractor rates as Randal’s “best buy.” “The diesel engine has a lot of power and is economical to operate. It starts as easy as a gas engine, even in winter. This tractor has been trouble-free and is a good machine.

“My 2002 MTD Yard Machine lawn tractor equipped with an 18 1/2 hp engine is my worst buy. Five minutes after I first tried to use it, it started falling apart. The variable-drive unit has fallen off three times, the pulleys on the deck have fallen off twice, the differential came loose, the front axle wore out, and the cowl broke after it worked loose. This machine is described as a garden tractor, but in my opinion it doesn’t even qualify as a lawn mower.

“My Simplicity bandsaw mill is a worst buy. It’s designed better than a Woodmizer and has a solid frame, but the construction work on it is terrible. It’s badly welded and the blade guides don’t work. To fix the problem, the guide mounts will have to be cut off and new ones fabricated. Also the drive belt rubs the exhaust on the engine, causing premature wear. In my opinion, you’d be much better off building your own sawmill, or paying the extra money for a Woodmizer or Norwood model.”

Simplicity zero turn riding

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Darrin Ehret, Deep River, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 12

Darrin likes his 2005 Bobcat B300D tractor loader and backhoe. “This is the first backhoe I’ve purchased personally, although I’ve operated many others. It has smooth hydraulics, a heated cab, a lot of power for its size, good lifting power, and a comfortable cab and controls. I only wish this machine had a curved boom and faster ground speed.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2005 Simplicity 2050 zero turn riding mower equipped with a 20 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and a 50-in. deck. “It has spent more time in the shop for repairs to hydraulic pump leaks than it has spent mowing. I paid $4,600 for it and have less than 25 hours on it.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW