Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › New Idea › 5209

New Idea 5209 disc mower

What FARM SHOW readers say · 5 Best Buys1 Worst Buy · Mowers, Lawn & Snow

New Idea 5209 disc mower

5 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Walter Pinkowski, Jr., Argyle, N.Y. · Vol. 43, No. 6 (2019), p. 14

“Our Massey Ferguson 283 tractor equipped with a Massey Ferguson A10 loader is easy to service. We use this little ‘bulldozer’ to push and pack silage in our trench silos.

“I bought a used 2004 Dodge 3/4-ton diesel pickup with about 185,000 miles and it hasn’t had any problems.

“I use my 1988 New Idea 5209 disc mower to cut about 250 acres of hay per year. The hitch on this mower isn’t pretty, but the mower cuts great.”

Best Buy
Walter Pinkowski, Jr., Argyle, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My New Idea 5209 disc mower is my best buy. The machine I have was the company’s first prototype and was used for demonstrations. I use it to cut about 450 acres of hay every year. I replaced a long shaft that drives the discs, and I replaced the turtles and shields once. My only complaint is that the hitch should be built heavier.

“Our 1998 Massey Ferguson 283 tractor equipped with an Alo front-end loader is a best buy.”

Best Buy
Donald A. Schremp, Ste. Genevieve, Mo. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 15

“My 1991 New Idea 5209 discbine has been trouble-free and is my best buy. I’ve used it to cut 3,000 to 4,000 acres of hay in hilly ground with some rocks in the fields. The only reason I would get rid of it would be to buy a new one just like it.

“The windshield wipers on my 1995 Chevrolet 1500 pickup don’t work and the and the dealer can’t seem to fix them.

“One of my worst buys is a 1981 International Harvester 986 tractor which has only about 3,200 hours on it. I’ve had problems with the cab mounts, transmission, clutch, two hydraulic pumps, injection pump, pto shaft, air conditioner, and front wheel spindle.”

Worst Buy
Victor Miller, Halfway, Mo. · Vol. 23, No. 5 (1999), p. 15

Victor’s impressed with his 1998 Deere round baler. “It’s an outstanding baler that needs very little maintenance. I used it to make more than 4,000 bales the first year, including 1,000 silage bales. I never had a problem with it plugging up or with starting a bale, whether I was making wet or dry bales.

“My worst buy is my New Idea 5209 disc mower-conditioner. It’s a high maintenance mower that isn’t designed for custom haying. The pods on it have to be greased about every two weeks. Another problem is that it rides on little shoes that don’t last even a year. It should have adjustable skids.”

Best Buy
Dick Gardner, Roscommon, Mich. · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 16

Dick’s impressed with his 1994 New Idea 5209 disc mower. “The thicker the hay the better it seems to cut. It does a great job on down and tangled hay and has never plugged up. I can mow with it as fast as I can stay in the tractor seat. The cut hay dries faster than it does with a sickle mower. It takes only three minutes to change a broken knife.”

Best Buy
Dick Gardner, Roscommon, Mich. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 12

Dick’s impressed with his 1994 New Idea 5209 disc mower. “The thicker the hay the better it seems to cut. It does a great job on down and tangled hay and has never plugged up. I can mow with it as fast as I can stay in the tractor seat. The cut hay dries considerably faster than it does with a sickle mower. It takes only three minutes to change a broken knife.”

Own a New Idea? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.

Your report could appear in a future issue.

Send your Best or Worst Buy

More New Idea products

New Idea disc mower 1 best · 1 worstNew Idea 4844 round baler 2 best · 0 worst

See all New Idea reports →