Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Oliver

Oliver: what farmers say

53 reports in FARM SHOW · 49 Best Buys4 Worst Buys

Oliver (general)

17 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
William Strum, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 19, No. 1 (1995), p. 16

William Strum, Kalona, Iowa: “My 1993 Deere 6.100 2-WD tractor equipped with cab is my best buy. The cab is very comfortable, quiet, and visibility is great. A, B, C, and D ranges shift real well onthe-go, just like a truck. I like the power quad transmission better than the power shift on my 4450, The cab is so quiet 1 can’t hear the engine run, I have to keep my eye on the tach. “My worst buy was the new short block engine I ordered from Ageo for my 1955 Oliver-White tractor. When I unpacked it, it had been shipped in an open plastic bag and was covered with dust and dirt, I complained, but Agco refused to replace it or take it apart and clean it. Instead, they wanted to blow the dirt out with compressed air. Chancing destruction from dust contamination was unacceptable to me. So now I have a tractor with no engine and I can't find a used or rebuilt engine for it.”

Best Buy
Jacques R. Tetreault, Tilbury, Ontario · Vol. 18, No. 6 (1994), p. 15

Jacques R. Tetreault, Tilbury, Ontario: “I nominate FARM SHOW as my best buy, L also like Makita power shop tools and our 1967 Oliver Super 66 tractor. It still runs like a top.”

Best Buy
Gabe Loeffelholz, Platteville, Wis. · Vol. 18, No. 6 (1994), p. 16

Gabe Loeffelholz, Platteville, Wis.: “My 1986 Honda Big Red 3-wheeler is always reliable, winter and summer, It's been almost trouble-free over many hours of work and play.” Oliver Grandalen, Portland, N. Dak.: “My best buy after 42 years of farming is my 1972 Deere 4020 tractor. We resleeved it and put in new pistons two years ago with 8,000 hours on the tractor. It wasn’t using any oil, but we thought the engine had to have some wear.”

Best Buy
Oliver Oswald, Eureka, S.Dak. · Vol. 12, No. 5 (1988), p. 12

Oliver Oswald, Eureka, S.Dak.: “It’s the best swather I've ever used,” says Oliver, happy with his new 6000 Case-IH 21ft. grain swather equipped with a double swath mechanism. “We’ ve puton 300 hours with few problems. However, the swath shifting mechanism should shift faster. A bigger hydraulic cylinder would alleviate the problem.” He also likes his Vermeer 605J Auto Weave baler. “If we had to replace it, we’d buy the same model again. It’s a well built machine, as is our Case-IH 1460 combine which has needed little maintenance.”

Best Buy
Oliver Larsen, Weyauwega, Wis. · Vol. 12, No. 2 (1988), p. 12

Oliver Larsen, Weyauwega, Wis.: “One of our best buys ever is our 1987 Aqua-Therm outside wood-burning furnace (Aqua-Therm, Box 281, Brooten, Minn. 56316). It’s everything I'd hoped for in a wood-burning hot water boiler and more. It’s easy to fire up and does everything the company said it would do.”

Best Buy
Ronald Bradt, Aylmer, Ont. · Vol. 11, No. 4 (1987), p. 12

Ronald Bradt, Aylmer, Ont.: He'sunhappy with Farmer's Surplus of Minot, N. Dak. "I needed a heavy-duty over/ under Hydraul Shift 3-speed transmission as used in White/Oliver tractors of 180-hp and greater, and more recently on some of lesser horsepower. Having determined by several phone calls that the required unit was available at a reasonable price from Farmer's Surplus, I mail-ordered the item with emphatic expression that a heavyduty unit was required. The requested money order was enclosed, along with a detailed explanation of the obvious method by which a heavy-duty unit can be identified. After nearly a month, | was notified that the shipment had arrived at customs. Shipping charges that Farmer’s Surplus said they would ‘take care of were due to the tune of over $175, I cleared customs, and prior to payment of the shipping charges, requested to sce the goods. The unit supplied was not the heavy-duty transmission requested. I’m now out the price of.the unit, which is the wrong one and won't do the job, plus the price of shipping.”

Best Buy
George Boudreau, Martinton, IIL. · Vol. 11, No. 4 (1987), p. 12

N. Dak. "I needed a heavy-duty over/ under Hydraul Shift 3-speed transmission as used in White/Oliver tractors of 180-hp and greater, and more recently on some of lesser horsepower. Having determined by several phone calls that the required unit was available at a reasonable price from Farmer's Surplus, I mail-ordered the item with emphatic expression that a heavyduty unit was required. The requested money order was enclosed, along with a detailed explanation of the obvious method by which a heavy-duty unit can be identified. After nearly a month, was notified that the shipment had arrived at customs. Shipping charges that Farmer’s Surplus said they would ‘take care of were due to the tune of over $175, I cleared customs, and prior to payment of the shipping charges, requested to sce the goods. The unit supplied was not the heavy-duty transmission requested. I’m now out the price of.the unit, which is the wrong one and won't do the job, plus the price of shipping.” Arnold D. Ross, Webber, Kan.: “Fuel economy is outstanding on my 1983 6080 tal nl 1inate suys Allis Chalmers tractorand loader bought in January, 1986, Has plenty of power to do the job. I've put 800 hrs. on itin the past 16 months with no let-down at all.”

Best Buy
Norbert Hogbin, Joice, lowa · Vol. 10, No. 2 (1986), p. 14

Norbert Hogbin, Joice, Iowa: ‘I call my 2-85 White tractor the ‘gutless wonder’. Has less power and uses more fuel than the 1750 Oliver I 140 FARM sHow |() orst Buys traded in. The first year | owned it the clutch pressure plate flew apart, throwing pieces of metal into the starter. It caused $250 damage to the starter and required nearly a $1,000 clutch overhaul. In cold weather, I always know I'll have to use a heater on it for at least half an hour to get it started.”

Best Buy
Ron Heberling, Overbrook, Kan. · Vol. 9, No. 3 (1985), p. 13

Ron Heberling, Overbrook, Kan.: "Worst product we ever owned, We had it less than two years and had over $3,000 in repairs. Injector pump, injectors, over/under drive unit, water pump and alternator are just a "Worst product we ever owned." few things that went wrong," reports Ron, unhappy with his 2255 Oliver. However his "best buy" ever is his 720 Oliver. 'We use it everyday for chores, cultivating, planting and hay- ing. It's never had the head or pan off, and we've replaced only one clutch. Just needs regular maintenance."

Best Buy
Gerald Casler, Ft. Plain, N.Y. · Vol. 8, No. 5 (1984), p. 14

Gerald Casler, Ft. Plain, N.Y.: He likes his New Holland hay equipment. “We've got a 320 baler, a 358 rake, a 495 Haybine and all are best buys. We also have four Gehl forage harvestors and several Gehl blowers that have given good service. “I bought a new Case tractor too. It has a nice cab and was a good buy because of rebates and a good trade-in allowance. I don't like it as well as some of my old Oliver tractors, however.”

Best Buy
Steve Thompson, Trenton, Tex. · Vol. 7, No. 3 (1983), p. 12

Steve Thompson, Trenton, Tex.: “In 1972 I bought a 720 Oliver wire baler and it was, and still is, the amazement of everyone that knows about it,”” says Steve, who's used all kind of balers in his custom operation, baling well over 100,000 bales annually. “I baled over 600,000 bales with the Oliver, replacing ten bottoms in the bale chamber, The sides of the bale chamber even had holes in them. I have never seen another baler that has been used so much the sides wore through. I sold the baler in 1979 to another custom baler fora standby. He liked it so well he put it on full time and baled over 100,000 bales with it. I understand White has sold the patent for this Oliver baler to Hesston.”

Best Buy
K. Joe Kinnie, Julesburg, Colo · Vol. 6, No. 3 (1982), p. 11

K. Joe Kinnie, Julesburg, Colo: ‘I have never used a product that cost me so much,” says Joe, upset with Dual herbicide by Ciba-Geigy. ‘‘We were having trouble with foxtail on a couple hundred acres of corn ground. After considering many herbicides, we chose Dual for several reasons. 1. Ciba-Geigy claimed Dual will work by itself without another mixed-in herbicide. 2. Dual was said to work exceptionally well on foxtail. 3. We were told Dual would stay in the soil longer than competitive herbicides and thus would be there to take care of weeds that came on later in the season. “Unfortunately, we had foxtail emerge six weeks after planting. Choosing Dual cost us approximately $40,000 or, on the average, 70 to 80 bushels per acre. A Ciba-Geigy representative came out but gave us no satisfaction whatsoever. The fact remains that Dual did not perform. We applied the maximum rate and used the same sprayer as with our other herbicides. Comparing the Dual acres with Lasso and Atrazine acres, it looked as though we hadn't used any herbicide at all.” Oliver Noel, St, Lina, Alberta: ‘No more dependable than a Christmas toy from Asia,” says Oliver, disappointed with his Rockwell 10-in, band saw. “In thicknesses over one inch, the blade cannot be controlled at all. The blades break frequently and alignment cannot be kept permanent. Compared to other saws, it’s junk.” He's pleased, though, with his Makita 2030 12-in. planer/jointer. “We've used it for the past year to finish and shape rough lumber for shop use. It keeps its thickness setting perfect and the motor has been 100% trouble-free.” Oliver runs a new and used tractor parts shop and says he can pick the most popular older tractors by monitoring calls for parts, ‘‘Parts calls indicate to what extent these tractors are still being used. The three most popular at this time are: 1. Case 930. 2. International Harvester 706 and 806. 3. John Deere 4020.”

Best Buy
Joseph Lee Winslow, Belvidere, S.C · Vol. 5, No. 6 (1981), p. 12

Joseph Lee Winslow, Belvidere, S.C: ‘I've had two sets of B.F. Goodrich tires on my tractor and have had trouble with both sets,’’ reports Joseph. The sidewalls on the first set broke after two years. The dealer paid half price on another set. After four years, am experiencing the same trouble with the sidewalls breaking. This time the dealer won't do anything about them. Both sets still had about % worth of tread left on them. “I'd have to nominate my 1755 Oliver tractor and my 1580 Lilliston peanut picker as ‘best buys’,” Joseph continues, ‘‘The 1755 is a good working tractor for the 86 horsepower range and, coupled with the 1580 peanut picker, does an excellent job picking peanuts. The over and under hydraulic shift works great to give a good range of speeds for varying conditions."

Best Buy
Edward M. Wegner, Watertown, Wis · Vol. 4, No. 6 (1980), p. 11

Edward M. Wegner, Watertown, Wis: “We have two Oliver 1365 diesel tractors, bought in 1976 on our 360-acre dairy farm. They're easy to handle and relaxing to drive. We work them hard with no breakdowns and few repairs. Very economical to operate.”

Best Buy
Joe Doyle, Holton, Kan · Vol. 4, No. 6 (1980), p. 13

Joe Doyle, Holton, Kan: “I would list the chemicals Sencor and Lorox as the poorest chemicals we ever used,” says Joe. "My biggest complaint, though, is the lack of ‘preparation service’ on new equipment by the dealer before it is delivered. Our John Deere dealer, however, is excellent on preparation. “On the best buy side, our Oliver 265 plow disk has been a good, tough tool for us, It’s our best buy.”

Best Buy
Oliver Hagg, Salina, Kan · Vol. 4, No. 4 (1980), p. 11

Oliver Hagg, Salina, Kan: ‘'I like my new 1980 Citation, a two-door with a 4-cyl. engine. The front wheel drive is good in mud and to get out of old ruts, and pulls you around corners on short turns,” says Oliver. “It has a 3-speed transmission, air conditioning, and cruise control. get 23 to 25 mpg. with farm and city driving. It has plenty room for 5 people and as large a trunk as the Nova traded in for it. With our 55 mph speed limit, the cruise control is almost a highway must,"”

Worst Buy
LeRoy Mayfield, Bovina, Tex. · Vol. 3, No. 6 (1979), p. 8

LeRoy Mayfield, Bovina, Tex.: “This tractor has been in the shop almost constantly,”’ says LeRoy about his 1977 IH 1086 tractor. “It’s a sorry tractor from front to rear. Front end wheels are weak, gears lock, it's hard to shift, clutch is hard to press and won't stop without grinding gears, hydraulic and power lift cause trouble, cab doors are weak, and the air conditioning fans are poor. “The tractor has not been abused in any way," he points out. “I have a 1973 Deere that’s been in the shop only once and a 1975 Deere that's been in only twice, and they've been driven and maintained by the same operators. Our 1975 1566 IH has been about the same as the 1086 for trouble. There won't be any more IH tractors on my farms." On the positive side, LeRoy says his John Deere 7100 Max-Emerge planter “is the best planter made. Linate plant corn, soybeans, cotton and milo and am pleased with this planter on all my crops, Especially like the seed depth adjustment, the speed of changing seed drop, and the way it handles herbicides." SAGES BIRR SE» SSweeem Vv Stes SeeYy Ve ssepevev drive train, has never been repaired. “My worst buy ever was a used 1600 Oliver tractor bought in 1968 with less than 500 hours on it,’’ reports LeRoy. ‘The tractor now has about 3500 hours on it and there’s not a single component that hasn't been replaced or repaired, including the engine, two clutches, both transmissions, hydraulic system and final drive.”

Worst Buy
Leroy Schulte, Mascoutah, Il · Vol. 3, No. 6 (1979), p. 8

Leroy Schulte, Mascoutah, Il: His “best buy" is his 1978 White 1-85 tractor. “The only trouble I’ve had was with the air conditioner, but good service from both the dealer and company got it repaired under warranty. “One of the all-time best buys ever made was a new GMC 2500 series pickup. Bought it new in 1972 and it now has 90,000 miles on it with little or no trouble, and has the original starter, fuel pump, alternator and water pump. Gets 16 mpg and uses no oil. The 350 engine with two barrel SAGES BIRR SE» SSweeem Vv Stes SeeYy Ve ssepevev drive train, has never been repaired. “My worst buy ever was a used 1600 Oliver tractor bought in 1968 with less than 500 hours on it,’’ reports LeRoy. ‘The tractor now has about 3500 hours on it and there’s not a single component that hasn't been replaced or repaired, including the engine, two clutches, both transmissions, hydraulic system and final drive.”

Best Buy
Lee R. Miller, Winthrop, Iowa · Vol. 3, No. 2 (1979), p. 9

Lee R. Miller, Winthrop, Iowa: He's pleased with his Shivvers Circu-lator and Dri-Flo System. “It's fast, accurate and saves time, labor and fuel expense, I have to credit our dealer and local construction companies for good service.” Lee adds that “my 1755 Oliver tractor has been a lemon from the start. We've had it in the shop for five engine oil seals, two clutches, brakes and a broken axle within 1600 hours. The only good thing was the service from our dealer.”

Best Buy
Merle Hatzinger, Fall River, Wis · Vol. 1, No. 3 (1977), p. 27

Merle Hatzinger, Fall River, Wis: Merle Hatzinger, Fall River, Wis., of his new International 1566. ‘‘No problems as of yet. Lots of power. Fuel use isn’t too high and maintenance is easy. Cab is a little noisy.” An lowa farmer is well pleased with his Massey Ferguson 1155 tractor equipped with an add-on M and W turbo charger: “It handles very good, the controls are handy, and it uses less fuel than the one we traded in. The cab isn't as quiet as I was expecting it to be, and it has a poor seat. think MF should replace the springs with hydraulic or air ride.” An Indiana farmer says his “best buy” is a White 2-150 tractor: ‘We like the extra power it has to pull six 18 in, plows. We especially like the quiet cab with radio and air conditioning. Handles nice too.” This same farmer wishes the frame on his model 1510 Oliver front end loader had been “beefed up” more “to stand the pressure on it from the hydraulic lift. It gets sprung out of shape.” New Holland's new TR 70 twinrotor combine has been a big hit with

Oliver tractor

4 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Walter Buck, Ringgold, Ga. · Vol. 42, No. 5 (2018), p. 13

“I repowered my 1950 Oliver tractor with a Cummins diesel engine that delivers smooth, clean power.”

Best Buy
Eric Wallis, Rudyard, Mich. · Vol. 26, No. 6 (2002), p. 15

Eric’s happy with his three Oliver tractors - a 1959 880 model, 1964 550 model, and 1974 1755 model. “The 880 has more than 8,000 hours on it, the 550 more than 6,000 hours, and the 1755 almost 5,000 hours. They’ve all been dependable tractors and have required very few repairs - just routine maintenance. It’s tough to justify a new $60,000 tractor when I already have three dependable tractors in which I have a total investment of less than $18,000, including repairs.”

Best Buy
Allan Foster, Mountain Grove, Mo. · Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999), p. 15

“One of my best buys is a 1650 Oliver tractor I purchased from Barr B Tractor in Cabool, Mo., ten years ago. This old tractor has been trouble-free and is sill going strong. It still uses no oil.”

Best Buy
Ted Sookaci, Fombell, Pa. · Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999), p. 16

Ted’s impressed with his 1985 White 2-85 tractor. “It has 3,100 hours on it but still works great. My only expenses have been for filters, tires, and a radiator repair. I use it to do all the major work on my 200-acre farm.

“I use my 1976 Gehl 95 grinder-mixer every week. Over the years I’ve replaced three bearings and a main belt. No other problems.”

On the minus side, he lists his 1980 White 2-70 tractor. “I bought it used with only 675 hours on it and thought that I was buying a quality product that would provide years of service. However, after two broken crank-shafts, a failed water pump, and hydraulic and transmission problems, I finally gave up and sold the tractor to a dealer. It had only 1,510 hours when it left the farm.

“I own several Oliver tractors - an 88 diesel, 77 diesel, 880G, 550G, and 1550G, along with the White 2-85, and have had good luck with all of them. Some of the older models have more than 8,000 hours on them with no repairs other than engine overhauls. Some of my neighbors have 1655 models with high hours and they haven’t experienced anything like the problems I’ve had with my 2-70. When I bought the 2-70 I thought that it was identical to the 1655. Since then I’ve noticed that 2-70’s are the most available used White tractor, and now I know why.”

Oliver 1550 gas engine tractor

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mitch Fenske, Mindoro, Wis. · Vol. 47, No. 5 (2023), p. 14

Mitch likes his Oliver 1550 gas engine tractor with a swept back front end. “They were built from 1965-1969. It consistently starts well and runs excellently. I don’t have to choke it, even in the winter. It runs smoothly and has plenty of hydraulic power to lift 2,500 lbs. motors to do engine swaps in other tractors.”

Best Buy
James Benshoff, Summerhill, Penn. · Vol. 15, No. 4 (1991), p. 13

James Benshoff, Summerhill, Penn.: James's “worst buy” is his 1985 GMC 4WD 1/2-ton pickup equipped with a 305 cu. in, V-8 engine and automatic transmission, “It ran great until the fall of 1989 when it started to lose power and fuel economy. We took it to a large GM dealership and left it there for three days. They rebuilt the carburetor and replaced several pollution devices for about $400, It seemed to run better for a while, but in less than two weeks it started losing power again. I called the dealer and was told to bring it back for another look. They were going to bill me for looking at it again. I said no thanks. put up with the power loss and poor fuel economy until that fall when I made an appointment with the dealer who had sold me the pickup. told him what had happened before. He kept the pickup for two days. This time the bill was about $250. When I got the pickup back it seemed to run better, but after about two weeks it lost power again, I went back to the dealer and was finally told by the shop foreman that when this engine gets 45,000 to 50,000 miles itruns this way and can’t be fixed. They said there was nothing they could do for me. You can bet this is the last GM tuck or car I'll ever buy.” James says his 1990 White American 80 4-WD tractor is a “best buy”. “We were finishing potato harvesting when the clutch went out of our Oliver 1550 tractor. Our dealer immediately picked up the 1550 for repairs and dropped off the new White tractor. We hada record amount of rain in 1990. Never having used a 4-WD tractor before could hardly believe what we were able to go through. If not for this tractor we'd have lost part of our cabbage crop.”

Oliver 1600 tractor equipped

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
James Valiquette, Escanaba, Mich. · Vol. 31, No. 4 (2007), p. 13

“My 1960’s Oliver 1600 tractor equipped with a 6-cyl. gas engine, which I bought used, is my best buy. This tractor was a one-owner model and I bought it for only $4,000. I use it on my small 80-acre farm. It starts on the first couple of turns no matter what the weather conditions. I use it with my 8-ft. snowblower and to go out in the woods to cut firewood. It’s a great tractor.”

Best Buy
Kevin Petersen, Belgrade, Minn. · Vol. 25, No. 1 (2001), p. 15

“Our best buy of all time is our 1962 Oliver 1600 diesel tractor. We bought it used about five years ago. When we bought it the tachometer didn’t work but had a reading of 7,500 hours. I think the tractor has about 10,000 to 15,000 hours on it now. It has never been in the shop since we’ve had it. It doesn’t use any oil and it runs great. It’s equipped with a KMW front-end loader which we bought five years ago. The loader has also worked great and hasn’t broken down once.”

On the negative side, he lists his Gehl 2500 skid steer loader. “We’ve never been able to use it for more than 10 minutes without it breaking down. I wouldn’t recommend this machine to anyone.”

Oliver 1650 diesel tractors

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Chuck Thomas, Liberty, Neb. · Vol. 39, No. 6 (2015), p. 14

“I own three 1968 to 1970 Oliver 1650 diesel tractors, and the engine blew on every one. I can’t find any replacements for them so now all these tractors just sit. They look great, but we can’t use them.”

Best Buy
Clair Moore, Dolliver, lowa · Vol. 19, No. 6 (1995), p. 16

Clair Moore, Dolliver, lowa: “My best buy of all time is my 1965 Oliver 1650 diesel tractor. I've never had the oil pan off because I don’t change oil on this tractor. It has a 3-roll toilet paper filter that change : Act = orst Buys OUS page) every 75 hours, [thas about 5,300 hours on it.”

Oliver 1850 diesel tractor

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Larry Simcik, Big Sandy, Texas · Vol. 41, No. 1 (2017), p. 12

“It’s the best $2,500 I ever spent,” says Larry about the 1965 Oliver 1850 diesel tractor he bought used. “I spotted this tractor sitting in a pasture off a main highway and stopped to look at it. Both rear tires were ragged. I talked to the owner, and we came to an agreeable price on the condition I could get the tractor to start. It belonged to a nice lady who had lost her husband, but it had been idle for several years.

“After I rebuilt the injector pump and replaced the battery, it started right up. After replacing the rear tires with a set of good used ones and changing the oil, we put the tractor to work and we’re still using it. It runs great, pulls hard, and sounds good. I’m proud of this tractor - it’s a highly valued addition to our farm.”

Best Buy
Hugh C. Vermilya, Dover, Minn. · Vol. 9, No. 6 (1985), p. 14

Hugh C. Vermilya, Dover, Minn.: “T traded in an Oliver 1850 tractor and paid $15,400 to boot but this 1980 Deere 2940 tractor, which had 800 hrs. on it when I bought it last year, was worth it. It has front-wheel assist and has enough power to easily pull 5 18-in. plow bottoms through sod with no problem, although the dealer cautioned against using that big a plow.” . Stephen Smith, Canton, Okla.: “My 1984 Hesston 1380 DT tractor is the most fuel efficient tractor I have ever operated without being short of power. It has 123 hp. and pulls a 6 by 18 bottom plow through heavy ground. It also has the best lighting system I have ever seen, and the best price, too.” On the minus side, Stephen's disappointed with his 1985 GMC 1“This truck gets the worst mileage I’ve ever experienced.” ton with a 454 cu. in. engine and automatic transmission. “This truck gets the worst mileage have ever experienced. I knew it would be bad but I didn’t think it would be so terribly low. Also, you can’t run the air conditioner without over-heating the engine.”

Oliver 1855 tractor

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Reginald E. Wilson, North Gower, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 1 (1997), p. 15

“I sold my Case-IH 7110 4-WD tractor to get rid of the payments and then I fixed up my Oliver 1855 tractor with a new engine, radial tires, and lights. I also mounted a White 105 cab on it. I’m very happy with it. It’s doing the same work we did with the 7110. “My 1984 Deere 6620 combine is my worst buy. Last year the rubber drain line at the bottom of the oil filter blew out, causing the engine to lose oil. We had to make repairs, including installation of a new crankshaft. The company should have used steel-braided line instead of rubber.”

Best Buy
Alvin R. Starcher, Crocker, Mo. · Vol. 16, No. 1 (1992), p. 13

Alvin R. Starcher, Crocker, Mo.: Alvin's disappointed with his Hesston 5510 round baler. “The company representative won't return phone messages and ignores “This baler needs several improvements which I'd be happy to point out if the company representative would just come to my farm.” my request for assistance. This baler needs several improvements which I'd be happy to point out if he would just come to my diesel engine which we installed in our Oliver 1855 tractor while overhauling it for the second time. The new engine has more torque, smokes less, and is clearly a superior design. It also runs cooler.”

Oliver 77 tractor equipped

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Kyle Dobias, Verdigre, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 6 (2001), p. 17

“I like my brother’s 1957 Oliver 77 tractor equipped with a diesel engine. It runs strong and works great for mowing. My dad bought it from a friend for $360.

“I rented a 1987 Case-IH 2394 tractor and I always had to use a battery charger to start it. The tractor had an electronic clutch that was operated by a fuse, which kept shorting out.”

Best Buy
Kyle Dobias, Verdigre, Neb. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 14

“I like my brother’s 1957 Oliver 77 tractor equipped with a diesel engine. It’s a strong running tractor and works great for mowing. My dad bought it from a friend for $360. It had a crack in the side of the engine.

“I rented a 1987 Case-IH 2394 and it always needed to have a battery charger to start. It had an electronic clutch that was run by a fuse that kept shorting out.”

Oliver 1250 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Rembert Cragg, Alto, Ga. · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 13

“The 1993 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a diesel engine that I bought used was the most trouble-free vehicle I’ve ever owned. It consistently averaged 22 mpg.

“My 1972 Oliver 1250 tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine has required only routine maintenance and will operate for 8 hrs. on just 3 gal. of fuel.”

Oliver 1365 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mark Miller, Belvidere, Tenn. · Vol. 27, No. 3 (2003), p. 13

“My dad has a 1972 Oliver 1365 tractor equipped with a 4-cylinder diesel engine. Over the years all we’ve had to replace was a clutch. The tractor has less than 5,000 hours on it.”

Oliver 1610 front-end loader

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Bruce Dodds, Green, Kan. · Vol. 20, No. 6 (1996), p. 14

Bruce nominates his 1983 Deere 4250 tractor as his “best buy”. “The Sound-Gard cab is quiet and comfortable and the engine runs good. It has 4,900 hours on it. I plan to have it overhauled at 5,000 hours. Some teeth have broken on the ring and pinion gear which could be due to operator error although I wonder if anyone else has had this problem. The tractor handles nice but uses more fuel than the Case 1070 that I owned previously. “I modified an Oliver 1610 front-end loader so I could mount it on my Deere 2940 tractor. It’s a light-duty loader so numerous cracks have developed in the frame and loader arms. It has a narrow bucket but that’s not much of a problem because I use a bale fork on it most of the time. It’ll get me by until I can afford a better loader.”

Oliver 1655

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Hett, Palmer, Alaska · Vol. 23, No. 4 (1999), p. 17

John likes his 1975 Oliver 1655 and 1650 tractors. “The 1655 starts easy, handles comfortably, and requires minimal maintenance. The 1650 isn’t as comfortable and I’ve had more problems with it.

“My 1975 Minneapolis Moline 955 required two costly overhauls due to a cracked oil filter can. The filter still pulls out lots of black soot.”

Oliver 1750 diesel

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Ted Sockaci, Fombell, Pa. · Vol. 50, No. 5 (2026), p. 14

“The best implement I’ve recently purchased is a Great Plains 1206NT drill. It does a great…”

This listing is from the current issue of FARM SHOW. Subscribe to read it all or get a free issue.

Oliver 1800 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mark Heesch, Rosemount, Minn. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 16

Mark’s the owner of a 1962 Oliver 1800 tractor equipped with a diesel engine and 3-pt. hitch. He says it’s his “best buy”. The entire tractor has been rebuilt and restored from the ground up. My total investment was only about $7,000. No matter what task I use this tractor for, it exceeds my expectations. It’s equipped with fluid-filled tires and fender-mounted fuel tanks. Once the fuel tanks are topped off, this tractor has unlimited traction, which is handy when pulling my home-built 10 ft. box scraper.

“My 1987 Snapper riding mower with a 42-in. deck and rear-mount engine is my worst buy. I use it on our 2-acre lawn. Every other time I use it something seems to go wrong. I’ve had problems with the fuel line plugging up, the belt jumping off a pulley, a blade disengaging, and one time a tire came completely off the wheel rim. It has also had electrical problems.”

Oliver 2255

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jim Zinne, Ryegate, Mont · Vol. 19, No. 3 (1995), p. 16

Jim Zinne, Ryegate, Mont.: “We bought a new Oliver 2255 tractor in 1974 and it gave us trouble every day of the nine years we owned it. have a list of 30 service calls and endless things I fixed on it. My dealer was helpful, but the tractor should have been replaced. I’ve talked to other owners who had similar stories. “My best buy is my 1993 Ford 250 diesel pickup equipped with a 4:10 rear axle and S-speed transmission. It's given me 38.000 miles of trouble-free service. Our 1989 Case-IH 7140 tractor is also a best buy.”

Oliver 4-WD

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jerome Welters, Sarcoxie, Mo. · Vol. 10, No. 3 (1986), p. 12

Jerome Welters, Sarcoxie, Mo.: “My Miller model 12 front end loader is a best buy. This quick-tach loader holds up well under all the strain and pressure that my 1850 Oliver 4-WD can produce, It’s heavy built and you can take it off and on in less than 5 minutes. Mounts to the tractor in 3 locations, yet has only one disconnect point.”

Oliver 500D

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Cooke, Monroe, Conn. · Vol. 22, No. 4 (1998), p. 17

“My best buy is a 1960’s Oliver 500D I bought for $2,000 12 years ago to clear eight acres of second growth maple trees with a Bush Hog. Actually, the tractor is a British-built David Brown imported by Oliver and renamed the 500D. Mine’s one of only four known of in Connecticut.

“In the 12 years I’ve owned it I haven’t had to fix a thing on the tractor, except to replace one of the bolts on the drawbar. My only complaint is that one of the two fuel filters takes up to three weeks to get because it has to be special ordered from our local auto parts store.

“Otherwise, I can’t believe how dependable the tractor is for mowing, digging post holes, plowing snow, etc.”

Oliver 55 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
George Hanzlik, Petersburg, Va. · Vol. 15, No. 1 (1991), p. 13

George Hanzlik, Petersburg, Va.: Faced with the chore of cutting more than an acre of lawn, George purchased a 1990 72-in, 3blade “Turf Hog” lawn mower built by Bush Hog, “I pull it behind an Oliver 55 tractor equipped with an independent pto and it leaves the lawn looking like it was cut by a hand push mower. I can maneuver it anywhere which reduces time spent trimming shrubbery.” Frank O’ Toole, Loysville, Penn.: Frank is impressed with his 1989 Myers 518 forage wagon. “The top beater turns backward to keep silage from being thrown too far forward when the wagon is being unloaded out the front, I bought my first one in 1988. Liked it so much I bought this one.”

Oliver 550 tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jim Burch, Brush Prairie, Washington · Vol. 38, No. 5 (2014), p. 14

“My best buy of all time is my 1959 Oliver 550 tractor. This tractor was well ahead of its time and performs as well as today’s newer models, but without all the electronics.”

Oliver 770 gas tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Russell Sprang, Kenton, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 1 (2001), p. 15

A 1980 Ford 445 backhoe powered by a diesel engine rates as Russell’s “best buy”. “This is my second Ford backhoe. I previously had a 1968 4400 model equipped with a gas engine. It performed well so when I had an opportunity to upgrade I bought this model. It’s built heavier than the first one and does a great job.

“My 1960 Oliver 770 gas tractor is a best buy. I bought it used in 1972 and had the valves ground once.

“My Ford LGT 14D lawn tractor powered by a 14 hp diesel engine is cheap to operate. The only problem I had was when the seal on the mower deck gearbox went out and ruined the bearings.”

Oliver 77RC tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Ronny Davis, Minden, La. · Vol. 39, No. 6 (2015), p. 15

A 1950 Oliver 77RC tractor rates as Ronny’s all-time “best buy”. “I joined a local antique tractor club and have been competing in vintage tractor pulls. It’s a strong pulling tractor. I pull in the 4,500-lb. stock class, as well as in 4,500 and 5,000-lb. competitive classes, and this tractor is almost always a trophy winner.”

Oliver 88

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Francis Simmers, Jamestown, N. Dak. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 17

“I’m 80 years old and have been retired for 17 years, so I haven’t bought any major equipment lately. However, we still live on the farm and have saved several items from the good old days. All of these machines continue to serve us well, and in addition they keep a lot of good memories alive. Once upon a time, they were all best buys.

“The machines include a Grasshopper mower with an 18 hp Briggs & Stratton gas engine; an Allis Chalmers 720 yard tractor with a 20 hp Onan engine; a Miller portable welder; and a series of Bobcat skid steer loaders, each one better than its predecessor. The newestone is a 742 model. We’ve also saved several tractors - a 1958 Case 900 B, a 1949 unstyled AR Deere, a 1946 Farmall H, and my favorite, a 1949 Oliver 88. It was ahead of its time and was equipped with live hydraulics, pto, and a smooth 6-cylinder engine. I added a homemade 3-pt. hitch to make it even more useful.”

Oliver HG68

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Harvey A. Campbell, York, Penn. · Vol. 18, No. 1 (1994), p. 14

Harvey A. Campbell, York, Penn.: Harvey's 1948 Farmall Super A tractor heads his all-time “best buy” list. “Performs as well today as it did when it was new. “My two brothers and I bought a 1947 Oliver HG68 tractor in 1979. It’s a good tractor. We use it to pull trees out of the woods to split for firewood. We use it al most every weekend in winter. In summer we pull a rotary mower behind it. I can’t believe how much traction this little tractor has.”

Oliver Model 35 combine

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
James A. Benshoff, Summerhill, Pa. · Vol. 49, No. 5 (2025), p. 13

“My best buy is our family’s Oliver Model 35 combine with a 10 ft. cut, which was purchased new in 1955. Everything that moved had a grease fitting.

“My father did custom cutting to help pay for the combine. We never replaced a bearing in this combine. It took two men or one man and a boy (me) about an hour to grease the machine. It never went to work until it was serviced. I don’t know how many acres of oats and wheat it cut over its lifespan. I took over the farm in 1970 and ran the combine until the 1989 season was over.

“I replaced the Oliver with a Deere 3300 with a 10 ft. cut purchased from an estate sale with 1,987 hrs. on the clock. This is the worst-engineered piece of equipment I’ve ever owned. Who puts the exhaust pipe 2 in. from the top radiator hose? No wonder it gets soft and fails. Or, why put the air intake right above and behind the header, where it can suck up all the chaff and clog? Also, the machine has very few grease fittings. Most of the non-greaseable bearings have failed and been replaced.”

Oliver Super 88 tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Ronald Hubred, Unity, Wis. · Vol. 39, No. 1 (2015), p. 14

“About 25 years ago we acquired an Oliver Super 88 tractor from an elderly neighbor. I let my son buy it at the age of 10 with money he had saved from raising tobacco. Once in a while he would even sneak the tractor out of the shed and drive it to school.

“My son is the second owner of this tractor and, other than replacing the plug and points, it has been maintenance-free. It has done a lot of hard work in its lifetime, but now with field equipment getting bigger we just use it to rake hay and haul loads.”

On the negative side, “When I was lucky enough to get my 2011 McCulloch chainsaw started, I was only able to cut wood for a half hour or so. I finally got so disgusted that I smashed the saw with a hammer and threw it away. I owned an Echo chainsaw for 30 years and it worked great, but after I moved I couldn’t find an Echo dealer. We use firewood to heat our 6-bedroom home and a shop, so my son and I do a lot of sawing.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW