Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › MTD

MTD: what farmers say

31 reports in FARM SHOW · 24 Best Buys7 Worst Buys

MTD riding mower equipped

6 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
W. Pat McGrath, Oxford, Miss. · Vol. 44, No. 5 (2020), p. 14

He’s satisfied with his 1992 MTD riding mower equipped with an 18 hp. engine and 46-in. deck. “After all these years this mower is still going strong. I use it to mow a 1-acre lot and have replaced just 4 belts and 4 sets of blades, as well as 2 choke cables.”

Worst Buy
Gary F. Thomsen, Arion, Iowa · Vol. 42, No. 5 (2018), p. 13

“It’s an awesome tool,” says Gary about his 2017 OEMTOOLS 1/2-in. heavy-duty cordless impact wrench (sold on Amazon). “I was a little skeptical when I bought it because it only cost about $80, and I’ve had bad experiences with other ‘off brands’ in the past. But I was impressed the first time I used it. I put a socket on the wrench and put it on a lug nut, then touched the trigger, and the next thing I knew I was watching the lug nut go bouncing across the floor. I have a bad back, so I really appreciate not having to fight with a lug wrench.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2016 MTD 20-in. push mower equipped with a 300 series Briggs & Stratton engine. “It’s always a guessing game whether this mower will start or not. Last spring the starter rope on it broke on the first pull. That’s when I realized the mower’s starting mechanism is pop riveted to the engine housing. After drilling out the rivets I discovered the assembly isn’t repairable, so there’s no way to install a new rope. Luckily there was still enough rope left to attach the handle and start the engine, but now every time I try to start the mower I have to use a clamp to hold down the safety bar. I’ve inspected this mower closely but nowhere on it does it say ‘Made in China’.”

Best Buy
James McGowan, Russell Springs, Ky. · Vol. 29, No. 1 (2005), p. 13

An MTD riding mower equipped with an 18 1/2 hp engine and 46-in. deck rates as James’s “best buy.” “I traded for it two years ago and have used it since then to mow roadside lawns. It has a deep deck so it does a good job of discharging grass. It can cut anything I can drive on. The only repair it needed was to the deck wheels, and they had good reason to break off because I drove over a lot of rough ground.

“Mad Dog drill bits are my worst buy. I had to return them to the company twice. They sent more bits but they all had the same problem. My wife bought a set of drill bits for $20 from another company that work better than this set, which cost me $80.”

Best Buy
Don Clements, Wilmer, Ala. · Vol. 28, No. 1 (2004), p. 14

“My MTD 46-in. riding mower equipped with an 18 1/2 hp Briggs & Stratton engine is my best buy. I use it to cut our five acres of grass. All I’ve spent on it is fuel and time.

“My Mantis rototiller is my worst buy. It just isn’t the machine it’s advertised to be. I plan to return it to the manufacturer.”

Best Buy
Alex H. Allan, Riviere Qui Barre, Alberta · Vol. 27, No. 1 (2003), p. 14

A 1996 MTD 42-in. riding mower equipped with a 42-in. deck and 2-cyl. engine rates as Alex’s “best buy”. “It has performed well and has gone through only one set of blades and two belts, even though we’ve used it on rough land with novice operators.

“My Homelite string trimmer and 14-in. chain saw are both best buys. They’re both user friendly and have provided trouble-free service over many years. Also, they’re reasonably priced.”

Best Buy
David C. Prause, China Spring, Texas · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 15

“My 1997 MTD 46-in. riding mower equipped with an 8 1/2 hp Briggs & Stratton gas engine and automatic transmission is my best buy. It came with a 2-year warranty. It’s a good mower and moves along at a good clip. I had a Cub Cadet that cost three times as much and was a piece of junk.”

Best Buy
Ralph Odden, Frontenac, Minn. · Vol. 20, No. 3 (1996), p. 14

“It’s dependable and does a great job. No problems,” says Ralph about his 1994 MTD riding mower equipped with an optional bagger.

MTD push-type lawn mower

3 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Fred Diedrich, Pepin, Wis. · Vol. 37, No. 5 (2013), p. 14

“My 2010 MTD 21-in. push-type lawn mower runs great. However, the tenth time I tried to start it the recoil broke. It wasn’t covered by the warranty and I was charged $95 for a new recoil, which was plenty high since I paid just $170 for the mower.”

Worst Buy
Arthur Freymiller, Fennimore, Wis. · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 13

“My 2000 Husqvarna 372 XP chainsaw equipped with a 24-in. blade has plenty of power for its size, starts easy, and handles well. It has never been in the shop. The only repair was to an anti-vibration spring, and I also had to buy a new air filter.

“After I used my MTD riding mower a few times it wouldn’t start. The dealer found a valve retainer had broken. The engine was built in China and no parts were available. Neither the company nor WalMart would help.”

Best Buy
William R. Townsen, Camden, Tenn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 1989 Ford 1520 tractor equipped with a 3-cyl. diesel engine does a good job of handling my 5-ft. Bush Hog finishing mower. I use it to pick up and carry our 1991 Troy-Bilt Tomahawk chipper-shredder equipped with an 8 hp Briggs & Stratton engine. It’s a best buy, too.

“I use my 1997 MTD riding mower to pick up and grind leaves for compost. The material is blown into a home-built box that I mounted on a garden trailer. The box is open on front and has screen sides and a back door along with a tin roof.

“My 1991 Woodchuck wood stove works great (Meyer Mfg., Dorchester, Wis.).

“I haven’t had good luck with Poulan chainsaws, either electric or gas-powered.”

Best Buy
James C. Sponsler, Princeville, Ill. · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 17

“My 1992 Chevrolet C2500 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 6.5-liter turbocharged diesel engine has been virtually trouble-free and is a best buy. I have more than 90,000 miles on it. It has great pulling power for my goose-neck trailers and is much more fuel efficient than any of my previous gas engine-powered pickups. It’s by far the best all-around pickup I’ve ever owned.

“My 1997 MTD 21-in. push mower, equipped with a Briggs & Stratton 3 3/4 hp engine, is my worst buy. I’ve been generally well satisfied with the mower but have had a lot of problems with the starter recoil spring assembly. The clutch hub was made of plastic and wore out, which kept the rope from retracting. We finally replaced the plastic part with a new one made of metal, which seems to have solved the problem.”

MTD (general)

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Feature storyWorst Buy
Mike Evans, Vanderbilt, Texas · Vol. 27, No. 1 (2003), p. 15 · Full story at FARM SHOW →

A socket and wrench set made by Metrinch America (Box 945, El Segundo, Calif. 90245 ph 310 414-3200) rates as Mike’s “best buy”.

Read the whole story →
Worst Buy
Troy Plocinski, Williamsport, Penn. · Vol. 25, No. 3 (2001), p. 15

A Clarke 150 Turbo Mig welder rates as Troy’s “best buy”. “I bought it for about $100 less than a 100-amp Lincoln Mig welder I was also looking at, and it also has 150 more amps. It’s built better than many other mig welders. I give the company an A+ for this machine.

“MTD products are my worst buys. I’ve repaired a few MTD lawn and garden tractors over the years and have always found them to be cheaply constructed in every way. They have an undersized transmission, Rube Goldberg-type attachment mountings, and tinny frames. I don’t think I’d take a new one if you gave it to me.”

MTD 5 hp rototiller

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Darroll Kramer, Pine Island, Minn. · Vol. 24, No. 5 (2000), p. 14

Darroll’s impressed with his 1996 MTD 5 hp rototiller. “It starts well, runs quiet, and does a good job of mixing the soil without ridging.

“I like my 1997 Campbell-Hausfeldcoil-type roofing nailer. I do roofing as a sideline and this nailer works perfect. I’ve done a lot of shingling since I bought it but it hasn’t required any repairs at all.

“My Troy Bilt 5 hp rototiller is my worst buy. It piled the dirt too high and left a lot of ridges and hollows. I took it back to the dealer and tried a wider, 8 hp model. However, it didn’t work any better so I took it back, too. I got all my money back except for $50.”

Worst Buy
Donald G. Husek, Ritzville, Wash. · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 17

Donald’s impressed with the service provided after he had problems with his MTD 5 hp chipper/shredder. “Some welds cracked on the bottom side of the chute that’s used to feed branches in. I wrote a letter to the company. They didn’t write back back but instead sent me a new chute at no cost.”

Worst Buy
Randal Hatcher, Spanishburg, W. Va. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

A 1990 Yanmar 2220D 4-WD compact diesel tractor rates as Randal’s “best buy.” “The diesel engine has a lot of power and is economical to operate. It starts as easy as a gas engine, even in winter. This tractor has been trouble-free and is a good machine.

“My 2002 MTD Yard Machine lawn tractor equipped with an 18 1/2 hp engine is my worst buy. Five minutes after I first tried to use it, it started falling apart. The variable-drive unit has fallen off three times, the pulleys on the deck have fallen off twice, the differential came loose, the front axle wore out, and the cowl broke after it worked loose. This machine is described as a garden tractor, but in my opinion it doesn’t even qualify as a lawn mower.

“My Simplicity bandsaw mill is a worst buy. It’s designed better than a Woodmizer and has a solid frame, but the construction work on it is terrible. It’s badly welded and the blade guides don’t work. To fix the problem, the guide mounts will have to be cut off and new ones fabricated. Also the drive belt rubs the exhaust on the engine, causing premature wear. In my opinion, you’d be much better off building your own sawmill, or paying the extra money for a Woodmizer or Norwood model.”

Best Buy
T.E. Salsman, Richmond, Ky. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 12

“My MTD Yard Machine wheeled string trimmer, equipped with a 3 1/2 hp Tecumseh engine and an 18-in. cut, is my best buy. The offset cutterhead works perfect for trimming under my 800-ft. long board fence. This trimmer also has adequate power for 90 percent of my other cutting chores, such as along pond banks.”

MTD gas-powered snowblower

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Harold Emly, Sidney, Montana · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 13

“My Dixon ZTR429 zero turn riding mower has a lot of power.

“The problem with my MTD gas-powered snowblower is that I can’t get the electric start to work.”

Best Buy
Emil Kudrna, Ivanhoe, Minn. · Vol. 20, No. 4 (1996), p. 14

“My 1994MTD snowblower does a good job. It blows snow a long way and is easy to handle.”

MTD 10 hp chipper-shredder

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Rusty Jamison, Leavenworth, Kansas · Vol. 25, No. 4 (2001), p. 17

“I like my 3/8-in., 14.4-volt Chicago Elec-tric cordless drill. I bought it for $39.99, which I think was a good price.

“My MTD 10 hp chipper-shredder is my worst buy. Before I bought it I called the company to make sure the machine would handle black walnuts. They said it would so I bought it. However, I’ve found it blows the walnuts right through the side of the plastic hopper.”

MTD 18 1/2 hp riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jim Franklin, Jonesville, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 12

“My best buy is my 1987 MTD 18 1/2 hp riding mower equipped with a 46-in. deck. Over the years it has needed only new belts and blades, a couple of new batteries, and a new deck shaft. This mower is still in great working condition. We use it to cut two to three acres a week.

“My 1994 Ford 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 300 cu. in., in-line 6-cylinder engine and a 5-speed manual transmission is a best buy. It has about 140,000 trouble-free miles on it. It’s a great pickup.”

MTD 20 hp riding

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Arthur Peabody, Upton, Wyo. · Vol. 39, No. 5 (2015), p. 13

Arthur’s had a problem with his MTD 20 hp, 42-in. riding mower. “The 2-cyl. Tecumseh engine only fires on the left cylinder. I’ve taken the engine apart many times trying to fix it, but with no luck. The engine has been running on only one cylinder for a full year now.”

MTD 2185 riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
W.A. Dostal, Ossian, Iowa · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 16

“My 1997 MTD 2185 riding mower is neither a best nor worst buy. It’s equipped with a foot-operated hydrostatic shifting system which my wife can operate without having to use her left foot/knee. She has a man-made knee which isn’t as flexible as the original. One problem with this mower is that it’s almost impossible to open the oil drain plug due to its position on the engine case. The plug is located just above the engine frame mount and is too close to the frame for me to install a drain hose on it. As a result, oil drains all over the engine frame, steering linkage, and onto the floor where it makes a big mess. It’s impossible to catch the oil because it follows the steering linkage.

“The company says the oil should be sucked out through the dipstick tube, but that would leave a lot of used oil in the crankcase. Another problem is that it’s almost impossible to grease two zerks at the bottom of the steering column. The zerk’s position makes it almost impossible to fit the grease gun onto the zerk and make it hold.”

MTD 4-cycle rototiller

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
D.L. Mertell, Independence, Mo. · Vol. 37, No. 6 (2013), p. 13

He likes his 2013 MTD 4-cycle rototiller. “I had been using a Mantis model, but it was hard to start and wanted to jump out of my hands whenever it hit hard ground. My MTD is easy to start and doesn’t try to get away from me.”

MTD 8 hp snowblower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Marvin Kroontje, Magnolia, Minn. · Vol. 29, No. 3 (2005), p. 15

“My 2002 MTD 8 hp, 26-in. snowblower keeps going in snow as deep as the top of the but I need more experience with this system before I can be sure.

“Before I bought this drill, I spent about two hours between fields on the road. I had to unhook the three drills, fold the hitch wings, and hook the drills together for transport. Once I got to the field, I had to hook the drills back up again. Now, moving is easy because all the lifting and folding is done hydraulically. I just get out of the tractor and flip four small levers in order to lock the drill into road transport position. I can be ready to move in less than five minutes.

“On the downside, by purchasing this drill I went from a 36-ft. seeding width to a 30-ft. width. The company only offers this type of drill in 30 and 40-ft. widths, and the wider drill would be too much for my tractor to pull.”

MTD Ranch King riding mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Lewis Childress, Lowell, Ind. · Vol. 25, No. 3 (2001), p. 15

“My MTD Ranch King riding mower is my best buy. I like the gear pattern and the ease of varying the rig’s forward speed. However, I do have one complaint. If I try to mow the grass less than 3 1/2 in. high, the mower leaves the clippings in windrows. As a result, I have to set all our mowers to cut the grass about 4 in. high.”

MTD Ranch King 12 hp riding

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Kenneth Stull, Ethel, Mo. · Vol. 21, No. 1 (1997), p. 16

A 1995 MTD Ranch King 12 hp, 38-in. riding mower rates as Kenneth’s “best buy”. “I hope that it’ll last as long as the 1971 AMF model that I had before. No problems so far.”

MTD Yardmaster 20-ton log splitter

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Garry Chazuka, Tyler, Texas · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 15

“My 2006 MTD Yardmaster 20-ton log splitter has performed flawlessly, splitting through some massive blocks of wood up to 46 in. in diameter. A good machine.”

MTD lawn tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Merrill Smith, Deer Park, Wash. · Vol. 45, No. 1 (2021), p. 13

“My 1991 MTD lawn tractor still runs flawlessly. Mows great, always starts, and runs all day on a tank of gas.”

MTD weed trimmer

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jim Horn, Thor, Iowa · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 13

Jim likes his 2016 MTD weed trimmer. “It always starts right up, and it has a 4-cycle engine so I don’t have to mix gas and oil.”

MTD riding mowers work

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Ronald Shook, Spencerville, Ohio · Vol. 39, No. 2 (2015), p. 13

“Our 2 MTD riding mowers work great, but a rear tire on one of them kept going flat. I was going to have a tube put in it, but getting the wheel off was a real bear. I had to use a gear puller and heat the wheel hub red hot 4 or 5 times just to get it off. Apparently this company hasn’t heard of never-seize compound.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW