Jeep: what farmers say
29 reports in FARM SHOW · 23 Best Buys6 Worst Buys
Jeep Cherokee equipped
5 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I like my Milwaukee tools, especially my M18 impact wrench, which I use when repairing pivot sprinklers.
“My 2022 Jeep Cherokee has too many computer gadgets. It makes driving feel unsafe.”
“In 1998 I bought a 1996 Jeep Cherokee used with about 10,000 miles on it. It has no rust on the body and starts every time, and the tires still wear even. It gets 19 mpg. Now this vehicle has about 286,000 miles on it and the only repair it has needed was to overhaul the transfer case. I wish everything else I owned was as reliable as this Jeep.
“My Chuck Wagon utility vehicle is my worst buy. It has no power and can barely pull itself up our driveway. I’ve had to replace the throttle cable twice, and it’ll probably go out again soon. I thought I would use this machine to haul firewood, but that’s out. Now it’s just an expensive golf cart with a bed on back.”
Darin bought a 1989 Jeep Cherokee in 2007 with about 300,000 miles on it. “It always starts. I drive it everywhere. I also drive a 1998 Cherokee and a 1967 M715 military Jeep truck. I’ve been driving only Jeeps for years. It’s a Jeep thing - you wouldn’t understand.”
“My 1997 Jeep Cherokee has more than 240,000 miles and the engine still runs as good as the one on my newer 2004 Grand Cherokee. Both vehicles are powered by a fuel-saving 4.0-liter engine.”
“I bought a 1998 Jeep Cherokee equipped with a 4.0-liter engine for my wife, and it’s my best buy. It was my first experience with Chrysler and it turned out to be a really good one. The engine isn’t big, but it has more power than I had hoped for. This car handles and runs so well that my wife won’t drive another one.”
Jeep Grand Cherokee quadra-trac
2 Best Buys3 Worst Buys“My 1996 Jeep Grand Cherokee Quadra-Trac has more than 150,000 miles with no problems. It never gets stuck and just keeps on running. The 4.0-liter engine is virtually indestructible.”
“My worst buy was a 2007 Jeep Grand Cherokee equipped with a diesel engine. The company’s ads said I could expect to get about 430 miles per tank of fuel, but I was lucky to get 250. The transmission made a high, whiny noise in drive and the windows were always noisy from the wind. Also, the tires made a growling noise whenever I drove on gravel roads. I traded the Jeep in for a Dodge Grand Caravan.”
“It’s a joy to operate and is the handiest tractor I’ve ever operated,” says Troy about his 2007 Deere 5425 tractor. It’s equipped with an 80 hp engine, cab, shuttleshift transmission, and 542 front-end loader. “It offers all the benefits of a larger tractor, yet can lift and handle a 6-row ridge-till cultivator with all the nimble qualities of a smaller tractor. It can turn short and isn’t at all clumsy. The view from the cab is like the view from a picture window. I like this tractor better than I even thought I would.
“My 1998 4-WD Jeep Grand Cherokee is my worst buy. Although it was comfortable and handled nice, I couldn’t drive it enough miles consecutively to really enjoy it. This vehicle was truly a ‘nickel and dimer’ and was always in the shop. Finally I took it back to the guy I bought it from. I took a loss on it and gladly said good riddance.”
“My DeWalt 368 circular saw is my best buy. I bought it for my husband for Valentine’s Day. He says it’s one of the best saws he’s ever owned. It cuts smooth and clean. He uses this saw at work and at home and loves it.
“My 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee is my worst buy. At speeds under 25 mph the brakes sometimes failed. The vehicle had less than 3,000 miles on it when this problem started happening. I was told by the dealer that there was nothing wrong. After this problem happened in front of my son’s school I got rid of the vehicle. As a side note, a co-worker of mine has the same problem with their 2007 Jeep Commander.”
“My 1999 Jeep Grand Cherokee is my best buy. It has a V-8 gas engine that’s fuel efficient. I’ve got about 36,000 miles on it.
“My 1998 Chevrolet 1500 4-WD pickup is my worst buy. When it was new the front end was so far out of alignment the tires wore out at only 450 miles. The dealer said it needed more miles on it before the company would let them adjust the alignment. The front brakes had to be replaced at 4,000 miles and again at 16,000 miles so I drive it as little as possible. No more GM pickups for me.”
Jeep Cherokee Sport
1 Best Buy1 Worst BuyHe’s happy with his 2018 Chrysler Pacifica Touring Plus minivan. “The Pacifica van has many improvements over the company’s Town & Country models. It’s more fuel efficient, is quieter, and is roomier with more storage area. It also has a very comfortable ride. My wife loves it.
“My 2000 Jeep Cherokee Sport has about 230,000 miles on it but still runs great and doesn’t use any oil. I use it to plow snow and with a trailer to haul snowmobiles, and it also makes a great hunting vehicle. Too bad they quit making this model.”
“I bought my 1973 Kubota L-185 tractor used six years ago, and it’s the most reliable piece of equipment on our small farm.
“My 2001 Jeep Cherokee Sport is my worst buy. It has required more minor repairs than any other vehicle I’ve ever owned. A couple of months after I bought it I noticed large white spots under the clear coat finish. I had the vehicle repainted at Daimler/Chrysler’s expense. However, neither the company nor the dealer would pay for the car we rented while the Jeep was being repainted - a job that took an entire week.”
Jeep Patriot equipped
2 Best Buys0 Worst BuysMark’s 2008 4-WD Jeep Patriot, equipped with a 2.4-liter engine and 5-speed manual transmission, has more than 167,000 miles on it. “It still has the original battery, brakes, exhaust, etc., and I’ve only spent about $150 on repairs. It gets 28 to 30 mpg, doesn’t use any oil, and drives great on snow and ice. Also, it has a lifetime powertrain warranty.”
“Our 2008 Jeep Patriot has exceeded our expectations. The fit and finish on it are excellent. We bought this vehicle mainly for its fuel efficiency and it has performed as well as the salesman said it would.
“The only problem with the Jeep is the limb saw. “I’ve already had to replace the trim head on this machine twice.”
Jeep Wrangler
2 Best Buys0 Worst BuysRon says his best buy ever is his 1988 Deere 530 round baler that he bought new. It has made nearly 50,000 bales. “I quit keeping track at 43,000. I’ve had very limited repairs on it.” Instead of paying the original new price of $27,000, Ron bought it at the clearance price of $20,000 when Deere’s 535 model was introduced. “It’s been good. The pickup teeth on this particular model were an inch longer and it feeds hay into the baler better.”
Ron also has a maintenance trick he uses and thinks that has helped his baler rack up such a phenomenal performance record. “I put a liter and a half of gear oil into the rollers, so the oil can seep through the seals and keep the bearings greased all the time. There’s only one drawback to it. You have to park it on the level over night, otherwise the oil will seep out and run down the side of the baler. I started doing this when the baler was about 3 years old. I’ve never had to replace any of those bearings that have had oil in them so it has saved a lot of maintenance time. This has just been a tremendous machine.”
Reid Knapp, Iron River, Mich.: “One of my best buys ever is a 1997 Jeep Wrangler with a Snoway snowplow. Living in northern Michigan we have our share of cold temperatures and snow. The Jeep always starts and it’s amazing the snow it can move for its size. Another plus is that we get at least 22 mpg for our local runs in the summer.”
James Jendro, Atlanta, Texas: “My worst buy is Dura-Coat coating for shop and garage floors that’s designed to fill cracks, holes and pitted areas. It’s supposed to eliminate painting and stop rust and corrosion dead in its tracks. I used the product but it didn’t fill cracks and it got stained with tire marks that would not come off. The product was guaranteed for 2 years and they did replace it once but the replacement covering wasn’t any better than the original. When I called a second time the representative on the phone was very rude.”
“I bought my 1988 Jeep Wrangler used with 130,000 miles and now it has more than 180,000 miles. I have a towbar on it so I can tow it to other farms. It’ll go anywhere an ATV will go. It’s fuel efficient and can be driven all year long even in Minnesota’s coldest weather. I can use it to tow loads weighing up to 3-ton loads if I’m careful.”
Jeep (general)
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I call it my Ikea farm Jeep because many of the accessories are salvaged Ikea store items, including the bed frames. I have a good source for such items because I maintain local apartment buildings used by college students. When they move out, I check for anything metal that’s left behind.
“A futon bed frame rail serves as a bumper and oversized radiator guard; add-on headlights are protected by the metal armrest off a porch swing; and a pair of light chains (also off the swing) protect the windshield. On the roof, a spare tire sets on another bed frame rail and a fog light designed for offroad use mounts on a curtain rod.
“To boost the Jeep’s hauling capacity, I added oversized tires and a beefed-up suspension system that includes coil-over-shock absorbers off a junked-out Dodge Dakota pickup. They can support loads up to 1,600 lbs.
“I wanted something that I could use around my farm like a utility vehicle, without spending the money for one. My grandfather taught me that if you aren’t rich enough to buy it, then learn how to make it. I already had the Jeep, which I bought used about 4 years ago. I paid $1,200 for it and spent about another $500 on the lights, tires and suspension system.”
Jeep Cherokee 4-WD wagon equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA 1997 Jeep Cherokee 4-WD wagon equipped with an in-line 4.0-liter, 6-cyl. engine and automatic transmission rates as David’s “best buy”. “My wife bought this vehicle new in 1998 and has had no trouble at all with it. It has more than 145,000 miles on it. I’ve replaced two sets of brakes and six sets of tires as well as a battery. Otherwise it has required only routine maintenance. My wife has talked about replacing it for two years, but she hasn’t found anything else that has caught her eye.”
Jeep Cherokees
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Farmers in our area really like New Holland model 256 Rollabar rakes. They skip less hay in low dips and in tight corners, and they turn easier in tight corners. The axle on these rakes isn’t straight but is tucked up close behind the basket. As a result, this rake works well in small, hilly, irregular-shaped fields.
“We like our two Jeep Cherokees. However, one of them recently developed a loud banging noise that was intermittent at first and then became steady and loud. Several mechanics told me I should replace the engine, but I wasn’t so sure. As it turned out, the problem was a cracked flywheel which I was able to fix for only $65.
“I really like my Kubota B2150 tractor. but I didn’t change the hydraulic oil filter for a long time. Last spring, apparently a plastic part that resembled a washer disintegrated and pieces of it got stuck in various places inside the transmission and hydraulic system. A dealer fixed it in two or three stages, trying to save me money. The problem became evident when the filter pressurized and ruptured. Now after replacing three or four filters and spending $1,300, it works fine. Even expensive filters look cheap after that experience.”
Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I couldn’t be more pleased with the 2015 Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk I bought for my wife. It has ample seating room, great cargo space, and a flawless 4-WD system. The V-6 engine has plenty of power, and the leather seating is top notch.”
Jeep Cherokeewhich
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I like my 1990 Jeep Cherokeewhich I bought used three years ago. It has 123,000 miles and still doesn’t use any oil. No major problems and it’s less expensive than a smaller 2-WD car. It has nice leather seats. I like to drive it.”
Jeep Commanche 2-WD pickup
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyKeith’s “worst buy” was his 1989 Jeep Commanche 2-WD pickup. “I should’ve known that I was in for a rough ride when the oil pan rotted out and the seals went out on the rear axle before the truck was even two years old. At about 40,000 miles the syn-chronizers started to go out in the transmission.
“Shortly after the power train warranty had expired, the valve lifters started to rattle in the engine. At about 60,000 miles I put new brakes on the truck. None of the parts were available from a jobber so I had to buy all the parts from Chrysler. The front rotors cost me $100 apiece and the total brake job cost almost $700. The real killer, though, was when the sides on the bed started to rust out. It was a nightmare trying to get Chrysler to back up its 7-year/100,000 mile rust perforation warranty.
“I drove the truck for seven years and put 84,000 miles on it before trading it in on a 1996 Ford F-150 4-WD. The Ford dealer allowed me $650 for the Jeep and I can’t blame him.”
Jeep Commander
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“We’re well pleased with our Staber top load washing machine (Staber Industries, Groveport, Ohio ph 800 848-6200; www.staber.com). It’s very efficient, using only a fraction as much water as other machines. My clothes are always clean and there’s no agitator to cause wear and tear on them. I use only one ounce of detergent per load. The extra cost of this machine has paid off in savings to our pocket book and to the environment. Best of all, it’s made in the U.S.
“My 2006 Jeep Commander is my worst buy. At first we were mostly pleased with it, except the V-6 engine wasn’t as fuel efficient as we had expected. Then we had problems with the electronics and there were noises, fluid leaks, and safety control issues. All this with well under 36,000 miles.”
Jeep Liberty
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Woods BW 180 rotary mower and Jeep Liberty are best buys. Also, I like Deere equipment built before 1990.”
Jeep Liberty CRD
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2005 Jeep Liberty CRD has great fuel economy, is nimble, turns short, and has 4-WD.
“After running BF Goodrich all-terrain tires for years, the last two sets I bought only got about 30,000 miles wear. I used to get 60,000 to 70,000 miles out of a set. The guy at the tire store said others are complaining about the poor wear also. I used to buy nothing but BF Goodrich tires - not anymore.”
Jeep Liberty Sport 4-WD model equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s the best compact sports utility vehicle we’ve ever owned,” reports Gary about his 2003 Jeep Liberty Sport 4-WD model equipped with a 3.7-liter V-6 engine, 5-speed transmission and 3-in. suspension lift. “It’s easy on fuel and can handle any kind of terrain or snow.
“I’m disappointed with my 1998 Dodge Dakota extended cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a 318 cu. in. V-8 engine. I’ve replaced everything on the front end and gone through wheel bearings, two oxygen sensors, a water pump and head gaskets. This vehicle has a terrible heater for a fully loaded, mid-sized truck. It only has about 97,000 miles on it.”
Jeep Renegade
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“We don’t have a lot of miles on our 2015 Jeep Renegade, but we love it. It gets 32 mpg and is nimble and easy to park. It only has a small 4-cyl. engine, but it’s very snappy.”
Jeep Wagoneer
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I like my 1998 Dodge Ram 2500 pickup equipped with a V-10 engine. It’s still like new with no rust. It’s a beautiful pickup. No problems.
“I like my 1992 Jeep Wagoneer, which I bought used. I repaired the clutch and radiator, and now it runs perfect. It’s fuel efficient.”
Jeep sales people
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I go everywhere with my 2006 Kubota 900 4-WD utility vehicle. It consumes about a half gallon of fuel per hour. The most difficult task was obtaining a Washington state license plate due to the vehicle’s off-road design.
“I’ve been badgering the Jeep sales people for several years now to put their diesel engine in the Wrangler series. So far they haven’t done that which I think is missing the mark. The Jeep Liberty and top end Jeep Cherokee have this engine. Volkswagen will be restarting production of their Jetta line with diesel engines this August. Hopefully, Jeep will see the light before then. If not I’ll be buying a Volkswagen. The Jetta gets an estimated 60 mpg.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.