Ford-New Holland: what farmers say
33 reports in FARM SHOW · 26 Best Buys7 Worst Buys
Ford New Holland 9030 bi-directional tractor
3 Best Buys0 Worst BuysEarl recently contacted FARM SHOW regarding fires he’s had in a 1992 Ford New Holland 9030 bi-directional tractor. Here’s what he told us:
“We bought the tractor new in the fall of 1992. In the fall of 1994, while still under warranty, we had a fire which apparently started in the brakes. My son and I were able to put it out by getting quickly to a plowed field and throwing loose dirt on it. New Holland fixed it under warranty.
“On July 5, 1997, we’d made just one round swathing hay with the tractor when we noticed smoke coming out from under the brake area again. We packed green hay into the tractor to slow the blaze down. But by the time we got help from the fire department, $15,000 to $20,000 in damage had been done. It’s now being fixed at Great Falls, Tractor Inc., where we purchased it.
“We feel this is a company problem that should be taken care of by Ford New Holland. Here’s why:
• “If my son and I hadn’t been lucky on the first fire, the whole thing would have burned to the ground and the company would have had to replace the whole tractor.
• “When you have the same problem twice with the same tractor, you have a factory flaw which makes it the company’s problem.
• “We were lucky that the ether bottle on the tractor didn’t blow up and blind someone since the fire was all around it.
• “We not only lost our swather tractor but had to rent a 2550 Ford New Holland swather, which took seven days to locate and deliver.”
A 1992 Ford-New Holland 9030 bi-directional tractor owned by the Department of Transportation burned up in June while it was being used to mow a freeway median near Sandstone, Minn. “Luckily, an alert motorist noticed the fire and called the local fire department on his cell phone. The fire was out in less than 25 minutes. In that short time, however, the cab was completely gutted, all inside duals were destroyed, as was all the wiring, batteries and hydraulic lines. It was a total loss,” Swanson says. “The state fire marshall says it was a battery cable, just as I suspected. It’s the second DOT tractor to catch fire. The first was a 1992 276 that burned up in the fall of 1993 (see Vol. 17, No. 6). The company was good about the first tractor fire, round bottom gravity wagon is a best buy (David Salzsieder, N735 Schultz Road, Denmark, Wis. 54208 ph 414 776-1446). I had the company build it for me after reading about it in FARM SHOW (Vol. 18, No. 3). It consists of a semi-circular shaped steel box that slopes down to one side. It’s built strong and always empties out clean, even in wet corn.”
“My best buy over the past few years is my 1986 Massey-Ferguson 3545 tractor. After over 4,000 hours of use we’ve spent only about $4 on parts for a set of alternator brushes. The tractor is well balanced and handles all loads easily and economically. “OurFord New Holland 9030 bi-directional tractor equipped with a loader is a best buy as is our New Holland 116 haybine. Both do a good job with minimal maintenance.” On the negative side, he’s had problems with his Tonutti10-wheel 3-pt. V-rake. “It just won’t turn over a 16-ft. windrow without bunching and lumping. After just a few hours of use there’s so much play in the adjustment locks that it’s virtually unusable.”
Ford New Holland tractors
3 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“About 4 years ago we bought 3 used Ford New Holland tractors at an auction - a 3930 and a pair of turbocharged 4630’s. All 3 have 3-cyl. diesel engines. We use them to do haying work. They’re super fuel efficient and will run all day on 5 gal. of fuel. They do a great job handling our 7-ft. disc mower, V-rake and small square baler.”
“My 1998 Dodge quad cab shortbed pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine is my best buy.
“My 1998 Dodge pickup has a lot of power and is fuel efficient. It also rides nice.
“My Deere 1750 Max-Emerge Plus conservation planter does a nice job of planting and is easy to maintain. No problems.
“My Ford New Holland bi-directional tractor is a pleasure to drive. I use it to oper-says Jack, pleased with his Deere STX 38 riding mower.
“My Deere TRS 21 snowblower has better balance and snow throwing power, in both light and wet snow, than a Toro 2000 snow-blower.”
“We like our three Ford New Holland tractors – a 1991 7710, 1995 6640, and 1999 TS 110. They get a lot of use and never let me down.”
Ford New Holland 1720 tractor equipped
2 Best Buys0 Worst BuysVic’s happy with his Ford New Holland 1720 tractor equipped with a diesel engine. “This is the first new tractor on our farm. I think diesel fuel is the way to go because it’s so economical. No problems. I use the tractor every day to do mowing work and to grow produce for our local farmer’s market.
“My Black & Decker Versapack 7.2-volt cordless saw is my worst buy. It’s equipped with a 3 3/8-in. blade. This tool barely has enough power to cut through thin wood and often quits working due to lack of power. It looks like new, but it just doesn’t work well.”
“I’m 54 years old and this is the first tractor I ever bought new. It’s great,” says Paul about his 1995 Ford-New Holland 1720 tractor. “It starts, runs and shifts fine. The four-wheel drive works great in mud and snow and it’s easy on fuel and easy to service.”
On the other hand, he’s unhappy about one aspect of the tractor and the Ford 7108 loader be bought to use with it. “The tractor’s hydraulic system has no power. The dealer says that’s just the way OSHA wants it. Also, all the welds on the loader frame broke during light snow removal, and the tractor had less than 200 hours on it.”
Ford New Holland 8670 front wheel assist
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“We’ve used this tractor for five years with no problems,” says Jimmy, pleased with his Ford New Holland 8670 front wheel assist tractor. “It has the best transmission of any tractor on the market and is user friendly.
“Our 1997 Chevrolet 1500 4-WD pickup is equipped with a 350 cu. in. engine. It has a lot of power and is very fuel efficient.”
“I like my 1994 Ford New Holland 8670 front wheel assist tractor. The powershift transmission really works well with a front-end loader. The tractor handles well in soft ground and starts right up in cold weather. The cab is tight so it stays warm in winter and cool in summer.”
Ford New Holland 8770 Genesis tractor
1 Best Buy1 Worst BuyHe likes his 1998 New Holland 644 round baler. “It’s very reliable and does an excellent job making tight, well-formed bales. We’ve used it to make 2,500 bales of hay, straw, hemp, bean straw, and corn stalks with no problems. We wish we had bought it years ago.”
On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Ford New Holland 8770 Genesis tractor. “We bought it less than four years ago to replace an older White 155 tractor and expected it to run reliably for many years. But right from the start it was plagued with breakdowns, most of them minor. Then the fuel pump began malfunctioning. It took several trips to the local dealer to get it repaired. The initial repairs were covered by the 3-year warranty. We could have extended the warranty but we didn’t because the tractor had only 1,750 hours on it and we thought all the bugs had been worked out. Unfortunately, they hadn’t. Six months later the engine blew a piston even though we had always serviced it regularly. The company wouldn’t stand behind its product and pay for an obviously defective engine. We paid a lot of money for a tractor that should have lasted many more years before needing any repairs of this sort. We’re very disappointed with this tractor and with the company for not backing up its product. We’ll never buy another New Holland tractor again.”
Initially, Dewey had problems with the cooling system in the 1995 Ford-New Holland 8770 Genesis tractor he purchased used. But it eventually became a “best buy”. “My local dealer and the manufacturer repaired the tractor far beyond my expectations. After several attempts to solve the problem, a new engine was installed. I received exemplary dealer and manufacturer service and support.”
Ford New Holland 1520
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Ford New Holland 1520 is a great tractor.”
Ford New Holland 1715 tractor required
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1996 Ford New Holland 1715 tractor required the installation of an electric fuel pump, because the tractor’s original fuel pump was gravity-fed through a very small filter. If I was low on fuel and came to a hill, we’d have to back up because the fuel wouldn’t feed. The tractor also has to be clutched two or three times to get it into any gear at a stop.”
Ford New Holland 254 rake-tedder
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 1986 Deutz Allis 4-WD tractor is my best buy. It’s highly maneuverable and easy to start and also easy on fuel. It has about 7,800 hours on it with only routine maintenance. The tie rod ends and hinges had no grease fittings and were expensive to replace. However, overall this is a good machine.
“My 1993 Ford New Holland 254 rake-tedder is my worst buy. The tires that came with it caused the machine to wrap up in hay and had to be replaced with ones that had a different tread. Another problem is this machine can only be set to do a clean raking job on one side. The roll pins wear and have a short life and the retaining rings on the tine bars don’t stay in place, which allows the nylon rollers to come out of the cam guide. As a result the rollers have a short life. The nylon bushings on the tine bars get dirt in them and have to be cleaned out in order to
Ford New Holland 3930
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2003 Deere 5220 4-WD tractor handles great. I’m impressed with the power and how it handles on hills.
“No problems with my Ford New Holland 3930 and 4630 4-WD tractors. The 4630 handles better, but the 3930 uses less fuel.”
Ford New Holland 3930 4-WD tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysJoe nominates his 1999 Ford New Holland 3930 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader as his “best buy”. “This tractor is cheap to operate and all the controls are user friendly. It has a heated cab which is a big plus.”
Ford New Holland 43 hp 4-wd
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysCharles is the owner of a 2001 Ford New Holland 43 hp., 4-WD diesel tractor. “This tractor is a dandy. It’s powerful, dependable, and starts in the coldest weather. I can bushhog all day with it and still have plenty of fuel left in the tank when I’m done. An excellent tractor.”
Ford New Holland 4630 orchard tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I love my 1987 Ford New Holland 4630 orchard tractor but have one complaint. The dealer used a kit to convert the upright exhaust system -which was equipped with a turbocharger - to a side-mounted exhaust. However, that left a 3 1/2-in. dia. hole in the hood that I have to look at every day. He said the company didn’t make a cap big enough to cover the hole. So I spent $26,000 on a new tractor that now has a hole in the hood.”
Ford New Holland 4835 tractor
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyRod’s had problems with his 1997 Ford New Holland 4835 tractor and says it’s his “worst buy”. “This tractor has about 1,300 hours on it. It has been in the shop three times for hydraulic leaks in the valve area. It also has an oil leak in the rear end housing. The problem is that there’s no gasket seal.”
Ford New Holland 4-WD 1720 tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“In 1995 I bought a new Ford New Holland 4-WD 1720 tractor equipped with a Woods 165 front-end loader with quick-tach brackets. I use this tractor to mow my yard, fluff and rake hay, and clean manure out of chicken houses and barns. I also use it to move logs, pull trailers, stack round bales, and many other chores. No problems with either the tractor or the loader.
“In 1967 my dad bought a Stihl S-10 chainsaw which I still use. It always starts on the fourth pull just like it did when it was new.”
Ford New Holland 5030 front wheel assist
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyWilliam nominates his 1996 Ford New Holland 5030 front wheel assist tractor as his “worst buy”. “It has only about 400 hours on it, but already I’ve had to make a lot of repairs. I’ve replaced seals in the power steering piston twice; and twice I’ve had to replace the rubber seals around the brake shafts in the rear axle. I also had to replace the alternator and battery, and a radiator hose blew after the first 20 hours of use.
“By the time the tractor had 350 hours, the main wiring harness for all the cab controls had worn through. Apparently the wiring harness was installed wrong and was rubbing on the tractor frame under the floor mat. The wires began to short out and smoke started filling the cab. At this point, the wires began to burn and the tractor almost caught on fire. The company wouldn’t fix it so I had to repair it at my own cost. This involved a 10-hour process of removing the cab floor and the rubber floor mat around the steering console. It was a difficult job because the rubber floor mats are thick and get very stiff in cold weather. In some places the material had to be cut just so that I could get it around the clutch pedal. Nineteen wires under the floor had to be spliced, soldered, and shrink-wrapped back together.
“The 1-ft. length of burned harness was cut out and sent to the company to warn them about the fire. The dealer was helpful, but I’d think twice before I bought another Ford New Holland product.”
Ford-New Holland 650 round baler equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysLeo likes his 1992 Ford-New Holland 650 round baler equipped with a wide pickup and fast net wrapping system and computer controls. “The customer service and free update system has been great. The baler’s trouble-free and consistently makes an even diameter bale of 1,000 to 1,100 lbs.” On the “worst buy” side, “I bought a T83698 short block engine assembly for my Deere 2510 tractor. When I opened the shipping crate all I found was the first page of the installation instructions and six fax sheets about the contents. When I asked for the complete assembly instructions I was refused. I was refused again even after I offered to pay for them. The engine didn’t run right and a $400 tune-up didn’t help. The dealer refused to give me the Deere address. I’ve used Deere tractors ever since 1947 but I guess it’s time to change paint.”
Ford New Holland 6640 tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 1994 Ford New Holland 6640 tractor equipped with a cab is a pleasure to operate in our hay fields. It rides good, has a lot of power, and steers great. It’s a good piece of machinery. “Besides being a farmer I’m also a service manager for an electrical power generating contractor that has been renting three 1995 Ford New Holland 4630 tractors. There’s not a straight piece of sheet metal on them but they’ve had no mechanical problems whatsoever.”
Ford New Holland 7740 tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I really like my 1991 Ford New Holland 7740 tractor. I use it to grind feed, plant corn, cultivate, spray crops, haul bales, etc. It’s the handiest and most reliable tractor I’ve ever owned. It has 2,500 hours with no problems.” On the negative side, “The minimum till fertilizer openers on my 1994 White 6600 planter don’t work well in corn residue. They constantly plug up with pieces of stalks and cobs. They’re absolutely junk. The company should refund my money. Otherwise the planter works great and I’ve had great dealer support on the fertilizer opener problems.”
Ford-New Holland 8240 Power Star tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Ford-New Holland 8240 Power Star tractor starts easy in cold weather, shifts smooth, and has great hydraulics. In cold weather the engine warms up quickly to heat the cab. I liked this tractor so much that I bought the company’s new Gemini 8360 model. This tractor should easily match the competition, feature for feature.
“My Demco field sprayer equipped with hydraulic fold booms is my worst buy. The booms aren’t built heavy enough and had to be reinforced. Also, the booms have to be pinned in order to transfer spray so you still have to climb out of the cab. This takes away the advantage of having hydraulic fold booms.”
Ford New Holland 8340 front wheel assist
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysJohn’s the satisfied owner of a 1995 Ford New Holland 8340 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a 456 cu. in. turbocharged diesel engine and SLE cab. “We traded in two tractors for it, hoping that it would do the work of both, and it met all our expectations. The 115 hp turbocharged diesel engine has a lot of power and can handle our 6-bottom moldboard plow and 24-ft. ‘S’-tine field cultivator with ease. Even with front wheel assist the tractor can turn short. When we’re spraying or planting we operate the engine at about 1,600 rpm’s and use just under two gallons of diesel per hour. The cab is quiet and comfortable and has good lighting for spraying at night. We had a few minor problems with the tractor which the dealer took care of under warranty. I priced Deere 7400 and Case-IH 5250 tractors before I bought it and found that the New Holland model cost considerably less money.”
Ford New Holland 8670 Genesis
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDoug nominates his 1994 Ford New Holland 8670 Genesis series tractor as his “best buy”. “It’s the most user friendly tractor I’ve ever owned. It’s equipped with a SuperSteer front wheel drive axle that lets me make tight turns without having to use the brakes. The 2-door cab is large and comfortable, and the 3-pt. hitch on back is the best in its class. This is a fuel efficient and dependable tractor.”
Ford New Holland TC25D loader tractor
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I started having problems with my 1999 Ford New Holland TC25D loader tractor just a few hours after I bought it. A switch under the seat malfunctioned. Pallet forks are difficult to put on using the loader’s hookup levers. The tractor had starting problems and required other major repairs that cost about $1,300. Now the tilt steering wheel adjustment mechanism is jammed, and I may have to take it apart. I’m using bungie cords to hold it in place for now.”
Ford New Holland TL-100 front wheel assist
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“This tractor is absolutely a joy to drive and operate,” says William, pleased with his 2004 Ford New Holland TL-100 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a 52L quick-tach front-end loader. “It’s amazing what this tractor can pull. Also, it’s really fuel efficient.”
He’s unhappy with DeWalt cordless tools. “The rechargeable batteries don’t stand up to normal use, and it seems like they’re always out of warranty when something goes wrong.”
Ford-New Holland TL90A
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I own a 1990 Ford 5900 tractor and have had it since it was new. It was built when Ford tractors were Ford-built, not Ford-New Holland-Fiat. I’ve used this tractor for the last 32 years in the field doing hay (shredding, raking, and cutting). It’s served me well as it’s a well-built machine.”
Darrell hasn’t had such a positive experience with his Ford-New Holland TL90A that he bought new in 2008. “The A/C and power steering quit on Day 1. The alternator failed in the first year. The onboard computer shut the tractor down, saying there was no oil in the 4-WD gearbox, but the tractor was 2-WD, not 4-WD. This machine has been a disappointment.”
Ford New Holland TS 110 4-WD tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Ford New Holland TS 110 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader works well. It’ll go almost anywhere with all four wheels pulling. In the past, we usually had to mount chains on our tractor tires in the winter just to get anywhere. It rides easy and the hydraulic brakes and clutch work great.”
Ford New Holland bi-directional
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Since your report in the last issue of FARM SHOW about the problems I’ve had with my 2002 Ford New Holland bi-directional TV140 tractor (purchased in November, 2003 and already more than 35 on-farm service calls), I finally had to threaten my dealer with a lawsuit. They came out the next day and finally found problems with the fuel pump, the timing, and the fuel injectors. When they first tested the tractor, the dyno was at 60 hp. But after the repairs it was like a new tractor, with the full 105 hp. When we got it home, it was like driving a new tractor. After a year and a half of hassle, it looks like we finally have the tractor we thought we bought originally.
“But here’s the bad news. The bill for the work was $2,525. The dealer said the New Holland block man was going to pay half, ‘even though he didn’t have to’ since the tractor is now out of warranty. I had to pay my half to get the tractor back, even though I have been calling and working with them on this – and many other problems totalling thousands of dollars – ever since I bought the tractor. The only reason it’s out of warranty now is because they dithered around for so long. If they don’t have any liability, why are they paying half? I think it’s because they know they can get away
with not covering the entire amount.
“My recommendation to anyone doing business with Ford New Holland is to pay $150 to have a lawyer look over any warranty contract you sign with the company. And if you end up with a tractor or other machine with problems, don’t waste time. Get a lawyer, go down to the dealer, and get a written contract from them that the problems will be resolved. If they won’t give you that, file a lawsuit sooner rather than later.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.